Political Survival and the Modern Prince
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Inside Autocracy: Political Survival and the Modern Prince The Harvard community has made this article openly available. Please share how this access benefits you. Your story matters Citation Carter, Brett Logan. 2014. Inside Autocracy: Political Survival and the Modern Prince. Doctoral dissertation, Harvard University. Citable link http://nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:13065026 Terms of Use This article was downloaded from Harvard University’s DASH repository, and is made available under the terms and conditions applicable to Other Posted Material, as set forth at http:// nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:dash.current.terms-of- use#LAA ছঝঝ -ঘঐঊগ $ঊছঝছ# ؛ i ঊকক ছঐঝজ ছজছট %JTTFSUBUJPO "EWJTPS 1SPGFTTPS 3PCFSU ) #BUFT #SFUU -PHBO $BSUFS *OTJEF "VUPDSBDZ 1PMJUJDBM 4VSWJWBM BOE UIF .PEFSO 1SJODF "ঋজঝছঊঌঝ 7JSUVBMMZ BMM "GSJDBO BVUPDSBUT OPX HPWFSO XJUI QBSMJBNFOUT BOE PSHBOJ[F SFHVMBS NVMUJQBSUZ FMFD UJPOT 5IFZ IBWF MJUUMF DIPJDF 4JODF UIF FOE PG UIF $PME 8BS 8FTUFSO HPWFSONFOUT IBWF SFRVJSFE OPNJOBMMZ EFNPDSBUJD JOTUJUVUJPOT JO FYDIBOHF GPS BJE JOWFTUNFOU BOE EFCU SFMJFG 8JUI WJPMFOU SFQSFTTJPO JNQPTTJCMF UP DPODFBM GSPN UIF JOUFSOBUJPOBM DPNNVOJUZ MJGF BT BO BVUPDSBU IBT HSPXO NPSF EJ୭୮ୢDVMU 4JODF BVUPDSBUT GPSDFE UP HPWFSO XJUI OPNJOBMMZ EFNPDSBUJD JOTUJUVUJPOT IBWF CFFO ॎ NPSF MJLFMZ UP MPTF QPXFS UIBO UIFJS DPVOUFSQBSUT #FUXFFO BOE UIF OVNCFS PG BVUPDSBDJFT JO "GSJDB GFMM GSPN UP GPS "GSJDBؠT BVUPDSBUT MFBSOFE UP TVSWJWF EFNPDSBUJD JO 5IF SBUF PG EFNPDSBUJ[BUJPO IBT TMPXFE TUJUVUJPOT 5P VOEFSTUBOE IPX UIJT EJTTFSUBUJPO GPDVTFT PO UIF 3FQVCMJD PG $POHP SVMFE CZ %FOJT 4BTTPV /HVFTTP GPS BMM CVU ୮ୢWF ZFBST TJODF 6TJOH PSJHJOBM EBUB PO UIF $POHPMFTF FMJUF UIFJS UIJT EJTTFSUBUJPO ୮ୢOET UIBU "GSJDBؠT BVUPDSBUT BOE UIF TFDVSJUZ BQQBSBUVT FMFDUJPOT QPMJUJDBM QBSUJFT DPOGSPOU DIBMMFOHFT PME BOE OFX XJUI EJ୭GFSFOU DPOTUSBJOUT "DDPSEJOHMZ UIFZ ୮ୢOE EJ୭GFSFOU TPMV UJPOT "VUPDSBUT PODF SFMJFE PO TJOHMF QBSUJFT UP QSFWFOU FMJUF DPVQT 5IFZ OPX TFDVSF DPNQMJBODF XJUI "GSJDBؠT BVUPDSBUT TPDJBM UPPMT #Z SFEF୮ୢOJOH UIF QPPM PG DBOEJEBUFT GPS UIF SFHJNFؠT DSJUJDBM QPTJUJPOT XIJDI JOEVDFT MPZBMUZ XIFO FMJUFT BSF FYDMVEFE GSPN UIF SFHJNF 5P أ QPMJUJDT PG IPQFآ FNQMPZ B JO XIJDI OFX SFDSVJUT "GSJDBؠT DPOUFNQPSBSZ BVUPDSBUT DSFBUF TPDJBM JOTUJUVUJPOT NPOJUPS BQQPJOUFFT JOUFSBDU XJUI USVTUFE BJEFT "VUPDSBUT TVQQMFNFOU UIFTF XJUI QBSBMMFM HPWFSONFOUT XIJDI GPSDF JJJ %JTTFSUBUJPO "EWJTPS 1SPGFTTPS 3PCFSU ) #BUFT #SFUU -PHBO $BSUFS FMJUFT TFQBSBUFE CZ DMFBWBHFT UP DPNQFUF BHBJOTU FBDI PUIFS 8IFO "GSJDBؠT BVUPDSBUT EFQMPZ UIFTF NPOJUPSJOH EFWJDFT F୭GFDUJWFMZ UIFZ GPSHP BSCJUSBSZ QVSHFT JO GBWPS PG UFOVSF QPMJDJFT UIBU SFXBSE DPNQFUFODF XIFO DJUJ[FOT أ GPDBM NPNFOUTآ 5IF JOUFSOBUJPOBM DPNNVOJUZؠT JOTJTUFODF PO FMFDUJPOT DSFBUFT TFOTF UIFJS TIBSFE EJTDPOUFOU 4JODF UIFZ CFMJFWF JOUFSOBUJPOBM BUUFOUJPO XJMM TIJFME UIFN GSPN SF QSFTTJPO PQQPTJUJPO MFBEFST NPCJMJ[F VOSFTU 5IJT JOTUJUVUJPOBM MBOETDBQF DPNQFMT BVUPDSBUT UP GBTI JPO FMFDUPSBM BMMJBODFT XJUI PQQPTJUJPO MFBEFST #Z KPJOJOH UIF SFHJNF UIFZ PODF JNQVHOFE PQQPTJ UJPO MFBEFST TBDSJ୮ୢDF QVCMJD DSFEJCJMJUZ GPS NJOJTUFSJBM QFSRVJTJUFT 1PQVMBS HPPEXJMM DPOTUJUVUFT BO BOE TP "GSJDBؠT BVUPDSBUT DPNNJTTJPO TVSSPHBUFT UP HFOFSBUF JU 8JUI SFQSFTTJPO MFTT JOTVSBODF QPMJDZ DSFEJCMF BVUPDSBUT DPOTUSVDU UIFJS TFDVSJUZ BQQBSBUVTFT UP UISFBUFO WJPMFODF XJUIPVU QSPWPLJOH JU JW $POUFOUT * 5IF .PEFSO 1SJODF "ঞঝঘঌছঊঝজ *গজঝঝঞঝঘগজ ঊগ ঝ 5ছ 8ঊট ঘএ %খঘঌছঊঌঢ 5IF "SHVNFOU 5IF 3FTFBSDI %FTJHO "QQSPBDIFT UP "VUPDSBUJD 4VSWJWBM 5IF 1MBO PG UIF %JTTFSUBUJPO 5 3জ %ঌকগ ঊগ 3জ ঘএ %গজ 4ঊজজঘঞ /ঐঞজজঘ &EVDBUJPO PG B %JDUBUPS 4BTTPV /HVFTTP * 5IF -JTTPVCB *OUFSMVEF 5IF 8BS PG +VOF ** 4PDJBM 5PPMT PG &MJUF $POUSPM 3ঌছঞঝখগঝ ঊগ ঝ 1ঘকঝঌজ ঘএ )ঘঙ 3FDPOTUSVDUJOH "VUPDSBDZ " 5IFPSZ PG 3FDSVJUNFOU *O(SPVQ 'PSNBUJPO BOE &MJUF #FIBWJPS $PODMVTJPO $ঘখঙকঊগঌ 8ঝঘঞঝ .ঘগঝঘছগঐ $POTPMJEBUJOH "VUIPSJUZ BOE &MJUF $PNQFUJUJPO " 5IFPSZ PG 1BSBMMFM (PWFSONFOUT $MFBWBHF BOE 4J[F JO UIF 1BSBMMFM (PWFSONFOU $PODMVTJPO W 5 4ঘছঌছঢ .ঊজঘগঌ -ঘঐ ঊগ 4ঘঌঊক *গজঝঝঞঝঘগজ 5IF 0SJHJOT BOE &WPMVUJPO PG UIF (SBOEF -PHF EV $POHP " 5IFPSZ PG 4PDJBM *OTUJUVUJPOT 5IF (SBOEF -PHF EV $POHP UIF 1BSBMMFM (PWFSONFOU BOE &MJUF #FIBWJPS $PODMVTJPO 5ঘ4ঞএএক ঘছ /ঘঝ ঝঘ 4ঞএএক " 5IFPSZ PG $PBMJUJPO 5FOVSF 5FOVSF 1PMJDJFT BOE &MJUF #FIBWJPS $PODMVTJPO *** 1PQVMBS 4VQQSFTTJPO 8JUIPVU 7JPMFODF &কঌঝঘছঊক "ককঊগঌজ 'ছঊঞ ঊগ 'ঘঌঊক .ঘখগঝজ "MMJBODFT 'PSHFE BOE 'PSFHPOF " 5IFPSZ PG &MFDUPSBM "MMJBODFT XJUI 0QQPTJUJPO 1BSUJFT 5IF 'BUF PG UIF 1PMJUJDBM 0QQPTJUJPO $PODMVTJPO &কঌঝঘছঊক $ঘখঙঝঝঘগ ঊগ 1ঘঙঞকঊছ .ঘঋকণঊঝঘগ $PNQFUJUJPO $POUSPM BOE UIF -FHJTMBUJWF &MFDUJPOT PG " 5IFPSZ PG -PDBM &MFDUPSBM $PNQFUJUJPO #FMJFGT 3FHJPOBM )PTUJMJUZ BOE -PZBMJTU $PNQFUJUJPO $PODMVTJPO 0ছঐঊগণগঐ .ঘছগ 3ঙছজজঘগ 4VQQSFTTJPO BOE 3FQSFTFOUBUJPO " 5IFPSZ PG -PDBM 4FDVSJUZ "QQPJOUNFOUT &UIOJDJUZ BOE UIF -PDBM 4FDVSJUZ "QQBSBUVT $PODMVTJPO *7 5IF 8BZ 'PSXBSE $ঘগঌকঞজঘগ 5IF "SHVNFOU 'VUVSF 1SJPSJUJFT 3এছগঌজ WJ -JTUJOH PG ୮ୢHVSFT GSJDBؠT "VUPDSBDJFT JO" GSJDBؠT "VUPDSBDJFT JO" GSJDBؠT "VUPDSBDJFT JO" PX "GSJDBؠT "VUPDSBUT -PTF 1PXFS( 0JM 1SPEVDUJPO JO $POHP BOE UIF 01&$ $PVOUSJFT 4BTTPV /HVFTTPؠT 3FBM &TUBUF JO $FOUSBM 1BSJT /FXMZ &MFDUFE "GSJDBO 1SFTJEFOUT (MPCBM "VUPDSBDJFT JO (MPCBM "VUPDSBDJFT JO (MPCBM "VUPDSBDJFT JO MJUF 4IV୭୯୳JOH %VSJOH 4BTTPV /HVFTTPؠT 'JSTU 3FJHO& &MFDUPSBM 'SBVE JO " $POHSBUVMBUPSZ .FTTBHF UP 4BTTPV /HVFTTP 4BTTPV /HVFTTPؠT .JE BOE )JHI -FWFM "QQPJOUFFT .CPDIJMBOE %FTDSJQUJWF TUBUJTUJDT 1SFEJDUJOH 3FHJNF "QQPJOUNFOUT (FPHSBQIJD 1SPYJNJUZ BOE "QQPJOUNFOU 1SPCBCJMJUZ 5IF &୭GFDU PG 1SPYJNJUZ BOE $P&UIOJDJUZ 8JUIJO UIF *O(SPVQ 5JNJOH PG UIF 3FDSVJUNFOU (BNF 1SPQPTJUJPO 7JTVBMJ[FE 1SFEJDUJOH &MJUF #FIBWJPS 5IF &WPMVUJPO PG *O(SPVQ 4FMFDUJPO .JE -FWFM "QQPJOUNFOUT 5IF &WPMVUJPO PG *O(SPVQ 4FMFDUJPO )JHI -FWFM "QQPJOUNFOUT 5IF 4J[F BOE &WPMVUJPO PG UIF 1BSBMMFM (PWFSONFOU 5JNJOH PG UIF .POJUPSJOH (BNF 5IF 1SFWBMFODF PG $MFBWBHFT JO UIF 1BSBMMFM (PWFSONFOU 5IF &୭GFDU PG 1PSUGPMJP 4FOTJUJWJUZ PO $MFBWBHFT WJJ 5IF &୭GFDU PG 1PSUGPMJP 4FOTJUJWJUZ BOE 0JM 3FWFOVF PO 1BSBMMFM (PWFSONFOU 4J[F &WPMVUJPO PG UIF (SBOEF -PHF EV $POHP $IBSBDUFSJTUJDT PG (-$ *OJUJBUFT 1SFEJDUJOH (-$ .FNCFSTIJQ #JSUI 7JMMBHFT PG (-$ *OJUJBUFT "GSJDBO "VUPDSBUT -JOLFE UP 'SFFNBTPOSZ 4PDJBM *OTUJUVUJPO %JBHSBN 4PDJBM *OTUJUVUJPO %JBHSBN 4PDJBM *OTUJUVUJPO %JBHSBN 4PDJBM *OTUJUVUJPO %JBHSBN 5JNJOH PG UIF 4PDJBM *OTUJUVUJPO (BNF 1SPQPTJUJPO WJTVBMJ[FE 5IF (-$ BOE UIF 1BSBMMFM (PWFSONFOU 4BTTPV /HVFTTPؠT 'PSFJHO 5SBWFM "OUJ3FHJNF #FIBWJPS "NPOH *OJUJBUFT .JOJTUFSJBM 3FBQQPJOUNFOU 3BUFT 5FOVSF %FOTJUZ 5JNJOH PG UIF 4IV୭୯୳JOH (BNF 3FHJNF "QQPJOUFFT 5FOVSF %VSBUJPO BOE -PZBMUZ 5FOVSF 5FSNJOBUJPO BOE "OUJ3FHJNF "DUJWJUZ FTDSJQUJWF 4UBUJTUJDT GPS $POHPؠ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୭GFDU PG (-$ .FNCFSTIJQ PO &MJUF #FIBWJPS %FUFSNJOBOUT PG &MJUF 4IV୭୯୳JOH #BMBODF