Pressure-Temperature Paths from Garnet-Zoning: Evidence for Multiple Episodes of Thrust Burial in the Hinterland of the Sevier Orogenic Belt
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
American Mineralogist, Volume 87, pages 115–131, 2002 Pressure-temperature paths from garnet-zoning: Evidence for multiple episodes of thrust burial in the hinterland of the Sevier orogenic belt THOMAS D. HOISCH,1,* MICHAEL L. WELLS,2 AND LORI M. HANSON1,† 1Department of Geology, Northern Arizona University, Flagstaff, Arizona 86011, U.S.A. 2Department of Geosciences, University of Nevada, Las Vegas, Nevada 89154, U.S.A. ABSTRACT Garnets are present in two horizons of the schist of Stevens Spring from the Basin Creek area of the Grouse Creek Mountains in northwest Utah. The two horizons possess different bulk composi- tions, which resulted in garnet growth by different reactions along the same pressure-temperature (P-T) path. Garnet in the upper horizon grew from the breakdown of chlorite at upper greenschist- facies conditions and garnet in the lower horizon grew from the breakdown of staurolite at upper amphibolite-facies conditions. From the upper horizon, five garnets from three samples were ana- lyzed. All display growth zoning, ragged morphologies associated with secondary rim consumption, and yield garnet-biotite geothermometry temperatures of ~460–490 °C. From the lower horizon, one garnet from each of two samples was analyzed. These also display growth zoning, but differ from garnet in the upper horizon in that they are dominantly idioblastic and yield garnet-biotite geothermometry temperatures of ~635 °C. Garnet-biotite geothermometry calculated for every point along detailed compositional traverses across the garnets revealed localized reequilibration along rims, cracks and inclusions in both generations of garnet. Garnets from the upper horizon display prograde reequilibration and the garnets from the lower horizon display retrograde reequilibration. Numerical simulations of garnet growth using the Gibbs method with Duhem’s theorem were car- ried out to determine P-T paths. The P-T path defined by the modeling of five garnets from the upper horizon is an isothermal pressure increase of ~1.7 kbar. The P-T path defined by the modeling of two garnets from the lower horizon has a steep P-T trajectory (dP/dT = 32 bars/°C) and a total pressure change of ~0.9 kbar. Both paths are indicative of thrust burial; however, the two paths cannot be reconciled as products of a single thrust episode. These data are interpreted to indicate two different episodes of thrust burial during the Sevier Orogeny, separated by ~150 °C of heating and partial exhumation. INTRODUCTION 1983; Selverstone and Spear, 1985; Spear et al. 1990). Addi- Since the early efforts in thermal modeling of tectonic pro- tionally, arrays of P-T determinations have been interpreted as cesses (e.g., Oxburgh and Turcotte 1974; England and Thomp- recording P-T paths (e.g., Hodges and Royden 1984; McGrew son 1984), construction of pressure-temperature (P-T) paths et al. 2000). from metamorphic rocks has proven to be a powerful tool in The samples analyzed in this study are schist of Stevens studies of ancient orogenic belts. Events including thrust burial, Spring from the Basin Creek area in the northern Grouse Creek intrusive heating, and extensional exhumation have now been Mountains, Utah (Figs. 1 and 2). Garnet growth was simulated widely interpreted from the study of P-T paths (e.g., Florence using the Gibbs method with Duhem’s theorem (Spear 1989, and Spear 1993; Lang 1996; Selverstone and Spear 1985; Spear 1993) to determine P-T paths. Garnets grew in two horizons of et al. 1990; Whitney et al. 1999). differing bulk composition; each records growth at different The general approaches used in the construction of P-T paths temperatures and along different segments of the P-T path, are varied and include geothermobarometry of mineral inclu- making it possible to determine the P-T path more completely sion suites in porphyroblasts that may record progressive equi- than would have been possible with either one alone. Garnet in librium conditions during porphyroblast growth (St-Onge the upper horizon grew during upper greenschist-facies meta- 1987), inferences made from reaction textures that show the morphism along the prograde path, and garnet in the lower direction of reactions in P-T space (e.g., Thost et al. 1991), and horizon grew later during upper amphibolite-facies metamor- studies of chemical zoning in minerals, specifically garnet (e.g., phism (discussed in detail below). Florence and Spear, 1993; Lang 1996; Spear and Selverstone The two sampled horizons of the schist of Stevens Spring are the uppermost and lowermost horizons, each about 5–10 meters thick. The distance orthogonal to foliation separating * E-mail: [email protected] the two sampled horizons is about 300 m (Fig. 2). Between the † Present address: Department of Natural Resources/Air Qual- two horizons is a package of interlayered amphibolite, quartz- ity Bureau, 7900 Hickman Road, Suite 1, Urbandale, IA 50322. biotite gneiss, and garnet-free pelitic schist. There are no high- 0003-004X/02/0001–115$05.00 115 116 HOISCH ET AL.: P-T PATHS FROM GARNETS, SEVIER OROGENIC BELT FIGURE 1. Simplified geologic and location map for parts of the Raft River, Grouse Creek, and Albion Mountains. Abbreviations are as follows: MM, Middle Mountain; CR, City of Rocks; VM, Vipont Mountain. Modified from Armstrong (unpublished mapping), Compton (1972, 1975), Miller (1980), Todd (1980), Wells (1996), and new mapping by M.L. Wells (this study). Top inset, tectonic map of the western U.S., shows location of metamorphic core complexes (black fill), leading edge of the Sevier fold and thrust belt (thick line with sawteeth), and outline of the Cenozoic Basin and Range Province. Bottom inset is a generalized map illustrating location of northern Great Basin metamorphic core complexes (diagonal wavy pattern) and study area in the hinterland of the Sevier orogenic belt. Thrusts of the foreland fold and thrust belt are shown by barbed lines; hatchured lines are major normal faults of the Wasatch fault system. angle faults between the sample sites, and there is no evidence (Holdaway 2000). Pressure constraints were obtained in rocks for foliation-parallel faulting within the schist of Stevens Spring, from the upper horizon using MBPG (muscovite-biotite-pla- and thus the two sampled horizons are considered to have un- gioclase-garnet) geobarometry. Although rocks from the lower dergone the same P-T history. Sample stations UH1 and UH2 horizon possess a mineral assemblage appropriate for the ap- are from the upper horizon on the south side of Basin Creek, plication of MBPG geobarometry and geobarometry based on and LH1 is from the lower horizon on the north side of Basin the anorthite breakdown reaction (GASP geobarometry), they Creek (Fig. 2). were not used because the low grossular content of the garnets Throughout the schist of Stevens Spring, a schistosity con- and the low anorthite content of the plagioclases create prob- sisting of granoblastic quartz and feldspar and planar aligned lems with the propagation of uncertainties (Todd 1998). Crude micas is overprinted by a greenschist-facies ductile fabric that pressure constraints for rocks in the lower horizon were ob- is expressed as shear bands, strain shadows around tained through considerations of staurolite and sillimanite sta- porphyroblasts, and dynamically recrystallized quartz. Samples bilities. were examined petrographically to determine which were best suited for detailed microprobe analysis. Samples showing the GEOLOGIC SETTING least visible alteration, the least overprint of the younger fab- The metamorphic rocks studied in the Grouse Creek Moun- ric, and a mineral assemblage appropriate for thermobarometry tains are part of a discontinuous belt of isolated occurrences of and for determining P-T paths based on garnet growth zoning amphibolite-facies Barrovian metamorphic rocks in the meta- (at least quartz + muscovite + biotite + plagioclase + garnet) morphic core complexes of the western Cordillera (Fig. 1). The were judged to be suitable. The temperatures of garnet growth regional metamorphism resulted from crustal thickening within were determined using garnet-biotite geothermometry the hinterland of the Sevier orogenic belt, mostly in Cretaceous HOISCH ET AL.: P-T PATHS FROM GARNETS, SEVIER OROGENIC BELT 117 FIGURE 2. Geologic map (a), geologic cross section (b), and tectonostratigraphic column (c) of the Basin Creek area, northern Grouse Creek Mountains. Sample localities for studied pelitic schist are shown with labeled circles. Locations of kyanite- bearing metamorphic rocks are indicated with triangles on a, in close proximity to studied samples. All map units are keyed to the tectonostratigraphic column c, with the exception of Oligocene granite (black fill). time, with local enhancement of deformation fabrics and con- graphically elevated hinterland crust experienced gravitation- tact-regional metamorphic effects around Cretaceous plutons ally driven horizontal extension synchronous with protracted (e.g., Snake Range, Miller and Gans 1989). The principal ar- shortening within the foreland fold and thrust belt. guments for the thrust-burial genesis for the metamorphism Throughout the Raft River, Grouse Creek, and Albion Moun- are metamorphic pressures locally recording burial of two to tains, a remarkably consistent yet greatly attenuated sequence three times that of stratigraphic burial (e.g., Hodges et al. 1992) of Proterozoic to Permian greenschist- to amphibolite-facies and systematic lateral metamorphic pressure gradients within metasedimentary