Queer Potentiality in Postwar Japan and the Post-Method American Theatre
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA SAN DIEGO UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA IRVINE Proximal and Reminiscent Nostalgias: Queer Potentiality in Postwar Japan and the Post-Method American Theatre A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Drama and Theatre by Jonathan Charles Reimer Committee in charge: University of California San Diego Professor Emily Roxworthy, Chair Professor Julie Burelle Professor Marianne McDonald Professor Daisuke Miyao University of California Irvine Professor Anthony Kubiak 2020 Copyright Jonathan Charles Reimer, 2020 All rights reserved. The Dissertation of Jonathan Charles Reimer is approved, and it is acceptable in quality and form for publication on microfilm and electronically: Chair University of California San Diego University of California Irvine 2020 iii DEDICATION This dissertation is dedicated to my grandmothers, Dorothy Reimer and Betty Creyer, both of whom crossed over into the beyond during my time in this program. You are forever loved. iv TABLE OF CONTENTS Signature Page .......................................................................................................................... iii Dedication .................................................................................................................................. iv Table of Contents ...................................................................................................................... v List of Figures ............................................................................................................................ vi Acknowledgements .................................................................................................................. vii Vita ............................................................................................................................................ x Abstract of the Dissertation ....................................................................................................... xi Introduction: Nostalgia and the Past’s Relationship to Now ...................................................... 1 Chapter 1: Performative Trauma in Postwar Japan ................................................................... 32 Chapter 2: Yukio Mishima’s Body ........................................................................................... 72 Chapter 3: Shamanic Meisner ................................................................................................... 126 Chapter 4: Queer Time-Spaces .................................................................................................. 167 Conclusion: The Dawning of the Age of Nostalgias ................................................................. 203 Works Cited ................................................................................................................................ 214 v LIST OF FIGURES Fig. 1.1. Hasegawa, Tōhaku. Shōrin-zu byōbu .......................................................................... 42 Fig. 1.2. Rolls Press. War and Conflict World War Two. pic: September 1945 ...................... 42 Fig. 1.3. Reimer, Jon. A porcelain figurine of 18th-century aristocrats ................................... 53 Fig. 1.4. Reimer, Jon. The figure’s “Made in Occupied Japan” stamp ................................... 53 Fig. 2.1. Guido Reni’s “The Martyrdom of Saint Sebastian,” circa 1616 ................................ 84 Fig. 2.2. Yukio Mishima as Saint Sebastian in photo by Kishin Shinoyama, circa 1966 ........ 84 Fig. 2.3. General Douglas MacArthur standing beside Japanese Emperor Hirohito ................. 98 vi ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS My journey to this point has been complicated, and the same can be said of my time in the doctoral program at UCSD and UCI. Through all of my teaching jobs, directing gigs, GSR assignments, and some steep learning curves, though, choosing to move to La Jolla to pursue this graduate experience continues to be one of the best decisions I have ever made. As such, there are a lot of people to thank for their love and support in helping me over the past six years. First and foremost, I would like to thank the faculty and staff of the UCSD Department of Theatre and Dance and the UCI Department of Drama. I am especially grateful to my chair, Emily Roxworthy, for her unwavering support, patience, and guidance. You continue to be a role model for my aspirations in academia as a professor, a mentor, an author, and an administrator, as well as in life as a parent, friend, and colleague. I hope to follow in your footsteps enough to make you proud someday. I am also indebted to Marianne McDonald for her dedicated mentorship since the dissertation’s inception. You are my kindred spirit, Marianne, who always understands the intricacies of my interculturalism and obsession with Mishima in ways that others rarely get or cared to. I am truly honored that mine is the final committee of your illustrious career. A special thank you to my other committee members Julie Burelle, Anthony Kubiak, and Daisuke Miyao for contributing to my growth as a scholar and being dedicated stewards towards the completion of this dissertation. You each have given me such profound inspiration and life- altering epiphanies over the years; I am honored to have had you on this journey with me. I would like to extend special thanks and sincerest gratitude to Marybeth Ward, the Graduate Coordinator of the Department of Theatre and Dance during my time at UC San Diego. vii I know I am not alone in saying that I do not think I would have made it through this doctoral program experience without her kind assistance, but it bears repeating: MamaBear, you are truly a one-of-a-kind, generous soul, and I have been so blessed to have you on my team. An entHusiastic thank you to Mark Maltby for being steadfast in his trust and respect toward me from the moment we met. We’ve gone through a lot of ups and downs in Promotions and this department, but you have always had my back. Thank you for being a great boss and an even better San Diego father figure. It cannot go unsaid how thoroughly satisfying this program has been for me, particularly with regards to the amazing tutelage from tremendous scholars and artists I have had the privilege of learning from at UC San Diego, including but not limited to Nadine George-Graves, Jim Carmody, Janet Smarr, Jade Power-Sotomayor, Gabor Tompa, Kim Rubinstein, and Jennifer Chang. Thank you all for providing me with guidance, opportunities, employment, and encouragement during my tenure here. I am better for knowing you and honored you know me. I am also grateful to my fellow PhD peers for their support, guidance, empathy, and friendship. We helped each other along the way, and your community helped me to push forward and see this through. Thank you to my PhD cohort – Tezeru Teshome, Ricardo Rocha, and Michael Dahan – who shared long car rides, long seminars, and long conversations on our journeys from Day One of this program until our one-by-one completions; I am honored to be counted among your ranks. Thank you also to the PhDs of UCSD and UCI who came before and after me, who mentored me as I navigated this process and offered encouragement, guidance, and comradery, especially Yi-Jen Yu, Maddie Williams, Heather Ramey, Matthieu Chapman, and Raimondo Genna. In particular, I must emphatically thank my writing partners and academic besties Alison Urban, Melissa Minniefee, and Kara Raphaeli, as well as Tonya Kneff-Chang of viii the University of Michigan, Jess MitcHell, Jennie Goldstone, and Bayan AbusneineH, who worked with me the most and encouraged me continuously. If it were not for your time and friendship, making it through to the end of this process would not have been nearly as pleasant, so I am forever grateful. At Muhlenberg College, there are also many people to acknowledge. I must start by thanking my mentors Beth Schachter, Jim Peck, and Charlie Richter for being the ones to first set me on this path and for continuing throughout the years to encourage and promote me along the way. Next, to my dear friends and colleagues Randall Smith, Jim VanValen, Kiyaana Cox-Jones, and Matt Moore: thank you for being my sounding boards and kindred spirits. Thanks also to Jess Bien, Curtis Dretsch, Karen Dearborn and everyone else in Theatre and Dance for your kindness, your faith in my abilities and potential, and for always cheering me on. A special life-long shoutout to my family, in particular my parents Clayton and Nancy Reimer, for always supporting me with every crazy endeavor I have chosen to pursue. Doing a PhD in Theatre is definitely one of the biggest ideas I have thrown at you, so thank you for always encouraging me to reach for my goals and live my dream. I love you. Last but not least, I must thank the wonderful Manuel Andres Perez Changanaqui, my beautiful husband. It was during my time in this program that we reconnected, began again, and eventually married. You remain my biggest cheerleader and my best friend. Thank you, Andy, for always being there for me, even when things get tough, especially now. This is for our future; the great work continues. ix VITA 2006 Bachelor of Arts, Muhlenberg College 2014-2020 Teaching Assistant, Dept. of Theatre and Dance University of California San Diego 2018-2019 Lecturer, Dept. of Theatre and Dance University of California San Diego 2018-2019 Lecturer, Dept. of Theatre and Dance Muhlenberg College 2020 Doctor of Philosophy, University of California