Quick viewing(Text Mode)

Marine Animals I

Marine Animals I

Marine I. The

OCN 201 Biology Lecture 6

Illustration :

Arthropods Segmented The

Family Tree Mollusks

Echinoderms Round Worms

Cnidarians

Bilateria

Ctenophores

PlacozoaNo Ancestral

)]

that

that

27

” ”

RESEARCH ARTICLE ArthropodsM. leidyi EST Set RESEARCH ARTICLE “ Segmented

SUMMARY Set

“ Worms

Vertebrates SpizellomycesM. leidyi punctatus Batrachochytrium dendrobatidis Cryptococcus neoformans READ THE FULL ARTICLE ONLINE Saccharomyces cerevisiae Phycomyces blakesleeanus The Genome of the Ctenophore http://dx.doi.org/10.1126/science.1242592 )] methods. To understand the Rhizopus orizae Outgroup Amoebidiumet parasiticum al 28 Citeramoredetaileddescriptionofthe this article as J. F. Ryan ., Science 342, 1242592 (2013).Sphaeroforma arctica leidyi and Its Implications Capsaspora_owczarzaki DOI: 10.1126/science.1242592 Monosiga ovata Salpingoeca rosettamodel as implemented in RAxML ( for Cell Type 72 Monosiga brevicollisG Pleurobrachia pileus Mnemiopsis leidyi We found no support in any of these analyses

shown oral side down. are about

ment of Ctenophora as to all other

Maximum-likelihood analyses support the place-

of , , and (Tr,Cn,Bi).

Cnidaria and Bilateria (Cn,Bi) and for a

broad support for a sister relationship between

animals (Tr,) (Table 1 and fig. S1). We recovered

Mertensiid sp Placozoa being the sister lineage to the rest of

for (Cn,Ct), Diploblastica (Bi,), or

Joseph F. Ryan, Kevin Pang, Christine E. Schnitzler, Anh-Dao Nguyen, R. Travis Moreland, atotalof16analyses(Table1).

od and matrix. This multifactorial strategy yielded

outgroups (table S11) in each combination of meth-

ogy, we included four different sets of nonmetazoan

effect of outgroup selection on our ingroup topol-

in PhyloBayes (

and Bayesian [with the CAT model as implemented

GTR+

matrices by using maximum-likelihood [with the

animals, 64.9% missing data). We analyzed both

nldsprilgnmcdata genomic partial includes from many taxa (58

mals, 19.6% missing data) and an

includes only data from complete (13 ani-

and fraction of missing data: a

matrices that differ in breadth of sampling

of gene sequence evolution. We assessed two data

sampling used in previous phylogenomic analyses

has allowed us to improve on the ctenophore The availability of the complete genome of Phylogenetic Position of Leucetta chagosensis David K. Simmons, Bernard J. Koch, Warren R. Francis, Paul Havlak, FIGURES IN THE FULL ARTICLE raphanus 88 NISC Comparative Sequencing Program, Stephen A. Smith, Nicholas H. Putnam, Porifera

Fig. 1.M. leidyi M. leidyi history and anatomy.

Steven H. D. Haddock, Casey W. Dunn, Tyra G. Wolfsberg, James C. Mullikin, 77 Oscarella lobularis

Tr

Po

Ct Cn Bi Oopsacas minuta Mark Q. Martindale, Andreas D. Baxevanis* Fig. 2. Previously98 proposed relationshipsCarteriospongia foliascens

97 queenslandica www.sciencemag.org of the fi ve deep of animals. Suberites domuncula 96 (Bi,) Lubomirskia baicalensis Fig. 3. Tree produced by maximum-likelihood

Ephydatia muelleri)Ctenophoraas Introduction: An understanding of ctenophore biology is critical for reconstructing events that The label at the

analysis96 of the EST set. B genome is low to m. See the supplementary materials fo adhaerens

occurred early in animal evolution. The phylogenetic relationship of ctenophores (comb jellies) to m Placozoa

Fig. 4. Tree produced by maximum-likelihoodCyanea capillata

Tr

Po

Ct Cn

other animals has been a source of long-standing debate. Until recently, it was thought that Porif- Bi Clytia hemisphaerica

SCIENCE

ctenophore . [Photo credit for (A): courtesy of Bruno Vellutini] 200

(Science, Dec 2013) Later development of magnipapillata analysis of gene content. transcript is 5.8 kb. Eight

era (sponges) was the earliest diverging animal lineage, but recent reports have instead suggested 96 Podocoryna carnea Cnidaria M. leidyi Ctenophora as the earliest diverging animal lineage. Because ctenophores share some of the same Fig. 5. The origin) of postsynaptic genes.Hydractinia echinata

Nematostella(Tr,) vectensis M complex cell types with bilaterians (such as neural and mesodermal cells), the phylogenetic position 82 Anemonia viridis Fig. 6. Inventoryto of myogenic components

)One- Aiptasia pallida J M. leidyi

of ctenophores affects how we think about the early evolution of these cell types. )Ctenophoraassistergrouptothe

D Metridium senile D

in M. leidyi. )Diploblasticahypothesis.Weseeno

Methods: We have sequenced, annotated, and analyzed the 150-megabase genome of the cteno- Acropora palmata F

Ct

Po

Tr Cn Bi Acropora millepora phore Mnemiopsis leidyi. We have performed detailed phylogenetic analyses on these new data SUPPLEMENTARY(about 10 cm MATERIALS Montastraea faveolata

using both sequence matrices and information on gene content. We conducted extensive genomic )Coelenteratahypothesis.( bocki Materials and Methods A inventories on signaling pathway components and genes known to be critical to neural and meso- 45 Nemertoderma westbladi Meara stichopi

Figs. S1M. leidyi to S10

tables S5 to S10.

characteristics of this genome are presented in

end and mate-pair sequencing alone. Additional

high-quality genome assembly based on paired-

S3 and S4); this has made it possible to produce a

moderate, as compared to other metazoans (tables

tive sequence in the

alternatively expressed exons. The level of repeti- A), (E), and (F) and very little support for (B) (see

may be inflated owing to a subset of these being

is high compared to other genomes (table S2), but

other genes. This number of nested intronic genes

percent of predicted genes are embedded within of an unspliced dermal cell types, among others. 98 groups with non-ctenophores. The average length

)Gastrulastage.( Isodiametra pulchra Tables S1 to S31I Symsagittifera roscoffensis

Results: Our phylogenetic analyses suggest that ctenophores are the sister group to the rest of the References Convolutriloba longifissura

)Adult

Po

Ct

Tr Cn extant animals. We fi nd that the sets of neural components present in the genomes of Mnemiopsis Bi Saccoglossus kowalevskii

A Ptychodera flava ( and the Amphimedon queenslandica are quite similar, suggesting that sponges have the Strongylocentrotus purpuratus

necessary genetic machinery for a functioning but may have lost these cell types. 44 Asterina pectinifera )andis

Branchiostoma floridae 26 13 DECEMBER 2013 VOL 342 We also fi nd that, although Mnemiopsis has most of the genes coding for structural components of )Aboralviewofcydippidstage.( 83 Petromyzon marinus C Gallus gallus

mesodermal cells, they lack many of the genes involved in bilaterian mesodermal specifi cation and, BilateriaGenome = 100 bootstrap intestinalis therefore, may have independently evolved these cell types. support Halocynthia roretzi

43 ), was 98.2%. In

Po

Tr

Cn Ct The phylogenetic positionBi of the ctenophoreEchinoderes horni )Earlycleavagestages.( 88 Xiphinema index

Discussion: These results present a newly supported view of early animal evolution that accounts Mnemiopsis leidyiH 94and its implications regarding

Euperipatoides kanangrensis to

for major losses and/or gains of sophisticated cell types, including nerve and muscle cells. This0.2 the origin of mesodermal99 cell types. (AAnoplodactylus) Adult eroticus M. leidyi E 99 evolutionary framework, along with the comprehensive genomic resources made available through M. leidyi. (B) Summary of the relationships of the fiBoophilus ve microplus Daphnia pulex

main branches of animals and the outgroup Choano- )PoriferaassistergrouptotherestofMetazoa.(

this study, will yield myriad discoveries about our most distant animal relatives, many of which will 93 Drosophila melanogaster

C

)PlacozoaassistergrouptotherestofMetazoa.( fl a g e l l a tlifea history and . anatomy. ( C) Inventory of myogenic specifi cation shed light not only on the biology of these extant organisms but also on the evolutionary history of E Schmidtea mediterranea

genes in Mnemiopsis. Components present in the Paraplanocera oligoglena genome is among the smallest 7%

Po

Tr

Ct Cn Capitella telata all animal , including our own. Mnemiopsis genome95 are inBi blue, and names are Helobdella robusta underlined. Absent components84 are in red. CerebratulusThe lack of lacteus

85 M. leidyi many of these)Close-upviewofcombrows.( factors in Mnemiopsis indicatesTerebratalia that transversa

B 44 Euprymna scolopes ctenophore mesodermal cell types are specifi ed differ- M. leidyi Lottia(Cn,Ct) gigantea (Ct,Bi) (Po,) (Ct,)

ently than in bilaterians, suggesting that they perhapsCrassostrea virginica

sign 44% of these gene predictions into

up 58% of the genome, and we conservatively as-

16,548 predicted protein-coding loci, which make

densely packed with gene sequences. It encodes AB C D E F

in the Animal Genome Size Database (

of genomes when compared with those cataloged

The

Characteristics of the

assembled.

the assembly is both complete and accurately

to a single scaffold. These numbers suggest that

94.8% of cases, a single EST mapped completely

as determined by baa.pl25 (

Table 1). Ct, Ctenophora; Po, Porifera; Tr, Placozoa; Cn, Cnidaria; Bi, Bilateria.

support in any of our analyses for the hypotheses in (

rest of Metazoa. (

sister to Bilateria. (

evolved independently in these two lineages. bottom of each pane corresponds to the header of Table 1. (

Fig. 2. Previously proposed of relationships the five deep clades of animals.

celled fertilized embryo. (

long). (

Fig. 1. 1242592-2 Fig. 3. Tree produced by maximum-likelihood analysis of the EST Set. The tree was produced from a matrix consisting of 242 genes and 104,840 amino A B acidCnidaria characters. Circles on nodesC indicate 100% bootstrap support. Support placing ctenophores as sister to the rest of Metazoa is 96% of 100 bootstrap

RESEARCH ARTICLE FGF replicates. BMPs/dpp Shh/hh Bilateria 1242592-4 13 DECEMBER 2013 VOLNK2 342 SCIENCE www.sciencemag.org Wnt/Wg Noggin s Placozoa u GATA le c Twist u Eomes n Lbx Porifera MyoG Mef2 Slp NK3 Snail Mrf4 Ctenophora Eya Six1/4 Myf5 MyoD Choanoflagellata Gli NK4

The list of author affi liations is available in the full article online. *Corresponding author. E-mail: [email protected] 1336 13 DECEMBER 2013 VOL 342 SCIENCE www.sciencemag.org Segmented Published by AAAS Worms The Animal Vertebrates

Family Tree Mollusks

Echinoderms Round Worms

Cnidarians Text

Bilateria

)]

that

that

27

M. leidyi

EST Set

Genome Set

M. leidyi

)] methods. To understand the

28

ramoredetaileddescriptionofthe

model as implemented in RAxML (

G

We found no support in any of these analyses

embryo shown oral side down. Embryos are about

ment of Ctenophora as sister group to all other

Maximum-likelihood analyses support the place-

of Placozoa, Cnidaria, and Bilateria (Tr,Cn,Bi).

Cnidaria and Bilateria (Cn,Bi) and for a clade

broad support for a sister relationship between

animals (Tr,) (Table 1 and fig. S1). We recovered

Placozoa being the sister lineage to the rest of

for Coelenterata (Cn,Ct), Diploblastica (Bi,), or

atotalof16analyses(Table1).

od and matrix. This multifactorial strategy yielded

outgroups (table S11) in each combination of meth-

ogy, we included four different sets of nonmetazoan

effect of outgroup selection on our ingroup topol-

in PhyloBayes (

and Bayesian [with the CAT model as implemented

GTR+

matrices by using maximum-likelihood [with the

animals, 64.9% missing data). We analyzed both

nldsprilgnmcdata genomic partial includes from many taxa (58

mals, 19.6% missing data) and an

includes only data from complete genomes (13 ani-

and fraction of missing data: a

matrices that differ in breadth of taxon sampling

of gene sequence evolution. We assessed two data

sampling used in previous phylogenomic analyses

has allowed us to improve on the ctenophore

The availability of the complete genome of Phylogenetic Position of

M. leidyi Radiata

Tr

Po

Ct Cn

Ctenophores Bi www.sciencemag.org

(Bi,) Flatworms

)Ctenophoraas

The label at the

B

genome is low to

m. See the supplementary materials fo

m

Tr

Po

Ct

Cn

Bi

SCIENCE

ctenophore body plan. [Photo credit for (A): courtesy of Bruno Vellutini]

200

Later development of

transcript is 5.8 kb. Eight

M. leidyi

)

(Tr,)

M

to

)One-

J

M. leidyi

)Ctenophoraassistergrouptothe

D

D

)Diploblasticahypothesis.Weseeno

F

Ct

Po

Tr

Cn

Bi

(about 10 cm )Coelenteratahypothesis.(

A No symmetry

M. leidyi

tables S5 to S10.

characteristics of this genome are presented in

end and mate-pair sequencing alone. Additional

high-quality genome assembly based on paired-

S3 and S4); this has made it possible to produce a

moderate, as compared to other metazoans (tables

tive sequence in the

alternatively expressed exons. The level of repeti- A), (E), and (F) and very little support for (B) (see

may be inflated owing to a subset of these being

is high compared to other genomes (table S2), but

other genes. This number of nested intronic genes

percent of predicted genes are embedded within

of an unspliced

groups with non-ctenophores. The average length )Gastrulastage.(

I Placozoa

)Adult

Po

Ct

Tr

Cn

Bi A

Sponges(

)andis 26

13 DECEMBER 2013 VOL 342

)Aboralviewofcydippidstage.(

C

Genome

), was 98.2%. In

Po

Tr

Cn Ct

Bi Ancestral

)Earlycleavagestages.(

H

to M. leidyi

ctenophores E

)PoriferaassistergrouptotherestofMetazoa.(

C

)PlacozoaassistergrouptotherestofMetazoa.(

life history and anatomy.

E

genome is among the smallest 7%

Po

Tr

Ct Cn

Bi Protist

M. leidyi

)Close-upviewofcombrows.(

B

M. leidyi

(Cn,Ct) (Ct,Bi) (Po,) (Ct,)

sign 44% of these gene predictions into homology

up 58% of the genome, and we conservatively as-

16,548 predicted protein-coding loci, which make

densely packed with gene sequences. It encodes AB C D E F

in the Animal Genome Size Database (

of genomes when compared with those cataloged

The

Characteristics of the

assembled.

the assembly is both complete and accurately

to a single scaffold. These numbers suggest that

94.8% of cases, a single EST mapped completely

as determined by baa.pl25 (

Table 1). Ct, Ctenophora; Po, Porifera; Tr, Placozoa; Cn, Cnidaria; Bi, Bilateria.

support in any of our analyses for the hypotheses in (

rest of Metazoa. (

sister to Bilateria. (

bottom of each pane corresponds to the header of Table 1. (

Fig. 2. Previously proposed of relationships the five deep clades of animals.

celled fertilized embryo. (

long). (

Fig. 1.

1242592-2 RESEARCH ARTICLE Phyla • Placozoa • Porifera (sponges) • Cnidarians (jellyfish, , hydroids) • Ctenophores (comb jellies) • Flat Worms • Round Worms • Molluscs (clams, snails, , octopi) • Segmented Worms • Arthropods (, crabs, shrimp) • Echinoderms (sea stars, brittle stars)

Placozoa

• Simplest animal? • Lacks symmetry • Only four cell types • No tissues or organs • Found on surfaces • Probably feeds on surface and • Can fold itself to create a digestive pocket Porifera (sponges)

• “Skeleton” may be or silica spicules, or entirely of the protein collagen • Benthic -- intertidal to abyssal, all latitudes • Suspension Feeders (strain , bacteria. A few exceptions) • Large range of cell types, lack of tissue types • Source of many bioactive compounds

Diversity in size & shape, Many growth forms

MBARI Sponge Skeletons Glass sponge ( Venus’ Flower Basket) Natural Sponge

collagen

Sponge Anatomy

choanocyte Arthropods Segmented Worms The Animal Vertebrates

Family Tree Mollusks

Echinoderms Round Worms

Cnidarians

Bilateria

Ctenophores Radiata Flatworms

Placozoa Sponges Ancestral Protist

Ctenophores (comb jellies) Ctenophores (comb jellies)

Ctenophores (comb jellies) • Earliest branching metazoan ? • All are marine • Pelagic from 0 to >3000 m (few benthic creepers) • Have eight rows of cilia (comb rows) • Carnivorous • Use tentacles with sticky colloblasts • Some directly ingest prey (Beroe)

)]

that

that

27

M. leidyi

EST Set

Genome Set

M. leidyi

)] methods. To understand the

28

ramoredetaileddescriptionofthe

model as implemented in RAxML (

G

We found no support in any of these analyses

embryo shown oral side down. Embryos are about

ment of Ctenophora as sister group to all other

Maximum-likelihood analyses support the place-

of Placozoa, Cnidaria, and Bilateria (Tr,Cn,Bi).

Cnidaria and Bilateria (Cn,Bi) and for a clade

broad support for a sister relationship between

animals (Tr,) (Table 1 and fig. S1). We recovered

Placozoa being the sister lineage to the rest of

for Coelenterata (Cn,Ct), Diploblastica (Bi,), or

atotalof16analyses(Table1).

od and matrix. This multifactorial strategy yielded

outgroups (table S11) in each combination of meth-

ogy, we included four different sets of nonmetazoan

effect of outgroup selection on our ingroup topol-

in PhyloBayes (

and Bayesian [with the CAT model as implemented

GTR+

matrices by using maximum-likelihood [with the

animals, 64.9% missing data). We analyzed both

nldsprilgnmcdata genomic partial includes from many taxa (58

mals, 19.6% missing data) and an

includes only data from complete genomes (13 ani-

and fraction of missing data: a

matrices that differ in breadth of taxon sampling

of gene sequence evolution. We assessed two data

sampling used in previous phylogenomic analyses

has allowed us to improve on the ctenophore

The availability of the complete genome of

Phylogenetic Position of

M. leidyi

Tr

Po

Ct

Cn

Bi

www.sciencemag.org

(Bi,)

)Ctenophoraas

The label at the

B

genome is low to

m. See the supplementary materials fo

m

Tr

Po

Ct

Cn

Bi

SCIENCE

ctenophore body plan. [Photo credit for (A): courtesy of Bruno Vellutini]

200

Later development of

transcript is 5.8 kb. Eight

M. leidyi

)

(Tr,)

M

to

)One-

J

M. leidyi

)Ctenophoraassistergrouptothe

D

D

)Diploblasticahypothesis.Weseeno

F

Ct

Po

Tr

Cn

Bi

(about 10 cm )Coelenteratahypothesis.(

lobate A

M. leidyi

tables S5 to S10.

characteristics of this genome are presented in

end and mate-pair sequencing alone. Additional

high-quality genome assembly based on paired-

S3 and S4); this has made it possible to produce a

moderate, as compared to other metazoans (tables

tive sequence in the

alternatively expressed exons. The level of repeti- A), (E), and (F) and very little support for (B) (see

may be inflated owing to a subset of these being

is high compared to other genomes (table S2), but

other genes. This number of nested intronic genes

percent of predicted genes are embedded within

of an unspliced

groups with non-ctenophores. The average length

)Gastrulastage.(

I

)Adult

Po

Ct

Tr

Cn

Bi

A

(

)andis 26

13 DECEMBER 2013 VOL 342

)Aboralviewofcydippidstage.(

C

Genome

), was 98.2%. In

Po

Tr

Cn

Ct

Bi

)Earlycleavagestages.(

H

to

M. leidyi

E

)PoriferaassistergrouptotherestofMetazoa.(

C

)PlacozoaassistergrouptotherestofMetazoa.(

life history and anatomy.

E

genome is among the smallest 7%

Po

Tr

Ct

Cn

Bi

M. leidyi

)Close-upviewofcombrows.(

cestid B

M. leidyi

(Cn,Ct) (Ct,Bi) (Po,) (Ct,)

sign 44% of these gene predictions into homology

up 58% of the genome, and we conservatively as-

16,548 predicted protein-coding loci, which make

densely packed with gene sequences. It encodes AB C D E F

in the Animal Genome Size Database (

of genomes when compared with those cataloged

The

Characteristics of the

assembled.

the assembly is both complete and accurately

to a single scaffold. These numbers suggest that

94.8% of cases, a single EST mapped completely

as determined by baa.pl25 (

Table 1). Ct, Ctenophora; Po, Porifera; Tr, Placozoa; Cn, Cnidaria; Bi, Bilateria.

support in any of our analyses for the hypotheses in (

rest of Metazoa. (

sister to Bilateria. (

bottom of each pane corresponds to the header of Table 1. (

Fig. 2. Previously proposed of relationships the five deep clades of animals.

celled fertilized embryo. (

long). (

Fig. 1. 1242592-2

beroe RESEARCH ARTICLE cydippid

Ctenophores Cnidarians (anemones, corals, jellyfish)

• Named for the stinging cells (cnidocytes) • Radial symmetry • Two forms: polyps and medusae (some have alternation of generations) • Asexual and

• Radial symmetry • Simple Digestive system (blind sac) • No circulatory, respiratory or excretory systems Polyp Medusa • carnivores/detritovores • Primitive nerve networks Cnidocytes Cnidocytes

• Prey capture • Turf wars • Defense

toxins

Class : hydroids and hydromedusae : Sea anenomes, corals, sea pens Class Cubozoa: sea wasps and box jellies Class Scyphozoa: jellyfish (big jellies) Jellyfish

Arthropods Segmented Worms The Animal Vertebrates

Family Tree Mollusks

Echinoderms Round Worms

Cnidarians

Bilateria

Ctenophores Radiata Flatworms

Placozoa Sponges Ancestral Protist Flatworms (Platyhelminthes) • Turbellarian flatworms are marine, benthic • Infauna from intertidal to deep sea • Carnivorous or herbivorous • Move by cilia or undulations • but no

Roundworms ()

• Flow-through digestive system! • Found all over (terrestrial, freshwater, marine) • VERY abundant free-living in benthic infauna • Many other types are parasitic • Many are deposit feeders, Arthropods Segmented Worms The Animal Vertebrates

Family Tree Mollusks

Echinoderms Round Worms

Cnidarians

Bilateria

Ctenophores Radiata Flatworms

Placozoa Sponges Ancestral Protist

Molluscs

MAJOR CLASSES • (Clams, oysters, mussels)

(snails, nudibranchs)

• Cephalopoda (squid, octupus, ) Bivalves Burrowing

• Many burrowing and boring boring • Others attach to rocky surfaces • Suspension feeding or selective deposit feeding

Gastropods

• Many with shells (snails, whelks, etc.) some types without shells (e.g. nudibranchs) • Some planktonic forms (e.g. pteropods) • Herbivores and carnivores, deposit and suspension feeders • Have a radula (a toothed scraper)

• Well developed and eyes • Many have ink sacs • Only one type still has external shell (Chambered nautilus) • Carnivores; Have a radula and beak for tearing food • Many can rapidly change colors (camouflage, communication)

Molluscs Arthropods Segmented Worms The Animal Vertebrates

Family Tree Mollusks

Echinoderms Round Worms

Cnidarians

Bilateria

Ctenophores Radiata Flatworms

Placozoa Sponges Ancestral Protist

Segmented Worms () • Major Class: the • Mostly benthic, a few planktonic - predatory epifauna

- tube-dwelling infauna (deposit/ suspension feeders) well developed Polychaetes

Food capture & Gas Exchange Christmas tree

tube dwelling

Arthropoda (jointed foot)

(protection, leverage) • Striated Muscle (quick, powerful) • Herbivores, carnivores, omnivores • External Skeleton requires molting Arthropoda: Crustacea

Malacostraca branchiopods

isopods copepods amphipods

mysids

decapod

Arthropoda

• Vast majority of marine arthropods are • Exceptions: marine , cheliceriformes (e.g., horseshoe crabs, pycnogonids)

horseshoe crabs

halobates Arthropods

Arthropods Segmented Worms The Animal Vertebrates Family Tree Mollusks

Echinoderms Round Worms

Cnidarians

Bilateria

Ctenophores Radiata Flatworms

Placozoa Sponges Ancestral Protist Echinoderms • Echino derm = spiny skin • Most are suspension or deposit feeders, sea stars also predatory • From intertidal to abyssal depths, nearly all are benthic • Have tube feet • Bilaterally symmetric as larvae, adults pentaradially symmetric

Echinoderms Sea Stars Sea Cucumbers

Sea Urchins Brittle Stars

Crinoids Echinoderms

Questions?