DOCSLIB.ORG

A Theory of Rhetorical Humor in American Political Discourse

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
A Theory of Rhetorical Humor in American Political Discourse ABSTRACT Title of Document: A THEORY OF RHETORICAL HUMOR IN AMERICAN POLITICAL DISCOURSE Michael Andrew Phillips-Anderson, Ph.D., 2007 Directed By: Professor Robert N. Gaines, Department of Communication This dissertation offers a theory of the strategic use of rhetorical humor in political discourse. This theory accounts for the differences between intentional and unintentional humor while creating a structure for the identification of humorous utterances. The largest gap in the current state of knowledge concerning rhetorical humor is a lack of understanding regarding the connection between humorous attempts and persuasive situations. This area of concern is answered with a classification of the rhetorical strategies of humor. I propose three nested categories for the identification of actions that have amusement or laughter as an expected response. These three categories in order of increasing exclusivity are the risible, humor, and rhetorical humor. The risible includes all stimuli that create amusement, regardless of intention. The risible is not limited to, but includes, those situations in which the speaker did not attempt to use humor but the audience was amused. Humor is a linguistic act on the part of a speaker that carries with it the intended effect of producing a state of amusement or mirth in the audience. Rhetorical humor is a linguistic act on the part of a speaker that carries with it the intended effect of producing a state of amusement or mirth in the auditor for the purpose of bringing about a change in attitude or belief. The theory presented here contends that rhetorical humor can be used to achieve nine strategic objectives for the speaker. The employment of these strategies is demonstrated through an examination of significant speeches by President Bill Clinton, Governor Ann Richards, and rights activist Sojourner Truth. With the development of a theory of rhetorical humor in political discourse and its application as a critical heuristic this project contributes to our understanding of rhetoric, political discourse, and that most human of experiences, humor. A THEORY OF RHETORICAL HUMOR IN AMERICAN POLITICAL DISCOURSE By Michael Andrew Phillips-Anderson Dissertation submitted to the Faculty of the Graduate School of the University of Maryland, College Park, in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy 2007 Advisory Committee: Professor Robert N. Gaines, Chair Professor Jeanne Fahnestock Professor Edward L. Fink Professor James F. Klumpp Professor Mari Boor Tonn © Copyright by Michael Andrew Phillips-Anderson 2007 Dedication For my parents, Paula and Bill Phillips, without whose emotional, financial, and culinary support, this dissertation would not have been completed. ii Acknowledgements My advisor, Robert Gaines, is to be commended for his wisdom and patience. He did not laugh when I told him on my first day in grad school that I wanted to write a dissertation about humor. Gaines possess a powerful intellect that made this dissertation much better than it would have been with any other advisor. He was a great source of help ab ovo usque ad mala. Ed Fink was always ready with jokes, trivia, and questions that stopped me in my tracks. I thank James Klumpp for our conversations about rhetoric, contemporary philosophy, and the Washington Capitals. Mari Boor Tonn, helped me to find wonderful sources of rhetorical humor and her suggestion to look at the discourse of Sojourner Truth was invaluable. Jeanne Fahnestock’s example of scholarship and collegiality is one I shall try to follow in my academic career. The members of my committee read my work carefully and thoughtfully. I hope that their suggestions are reflected in this final version. My parents have been great supporters of my academic career, especially when that career involved significant underemployment. My father even read a draft of the dissertation on an airplane to Australia. I made 179 of his 184 suggested revisions. I have been very fortunate to be close to many family members whose support helped be complete this project. Of special note are my grandparents, Bill and Ruth Phillips and Sol and Bettie Bogen, who likely did not think I would be in school this long. My pseudo- aunt Sue Farkas, also read part of the dissertation and always made sure I had many books from a young age. My in-laws, Carolyn Winter and Roger Bybee also read parts of the dissertation and made helpful suggestions. iii There are many people to thank in the Department of Communication at the University of Maryland. Mary Bell is to be thanked for her unqualified encouragement and Leah Waks for discussions about hockey (and academic advice). The cohort of graduate students at Maryland who were finishing as I arrived, Diane Blair, Nacho Cordova, Leslie Dinauer Lisa Gring-Pemble, and Noemi Marin, were unparalleled in their intellectual curiosity and capacity for fun. Without my cohort, I do not see how I would have finished this project. Diane Hemmings demonstrated that I was not the snarkiest person in the room. My fellow Hassle House denizen, Ric Winston, and I shared many diversions along with research and teaching ideas. Michael Philipp, also of Hassle House, was responsible for at least one year of lost productivity, several instances of anthroponomastic confusion, and many years of friendship. Bjørn and Belinda Stillion-Southard are to be commended for arriving at Maryland just in time to be the recipients of my many complaints. Of all my colleagues at Maryland, Amy Heyse, deserves special thanks. My Piceses sister and I shared many classes and papers and phone calls and revisions. We may have taken some different approaches in our programs, but I’m so glad we got to walk together at the end. Long time friends, Min and Matt McKnight, Kara Reinsel, Emily Rems, James Calder, Leigh Bailey, and Kimberley Raue were always ready to help, particularly if it involved dinner. Lydia Hu was of great help in locating articles about the speeches of the Silly Season. The librarians and staff at the Museum of Television and Radio in New York and Kristin Carey and Comedy Central found video archives which were of great value. iv Finally, I owe so much to my wife and partner, Rachel Phillips-Anderson. When I began this project I had no idea that I would have a wife and a new name before graduation. I think it is no coincidence that that I really started writing after we met. I thank you for your great understanding of late nights and weekends of furious work, your excellent bibliographic skills, and for making this process a much more fun experience than so many others seem to find it. You may not have married a doctor, but at least you’re married to one now. v ridiculum acri fortius et melius magnas plerumque secat res. For ridicule often decides matters of importance more effectually and in a better manner, than severity. Horace Sermones (1.10.14-15, c. 35 BCE) vi Table of Contents Dedication ........................................................................................................................... ii Acknowledgements ............................................................................................................ iii Table of Contents .............................................................................................................. vii List of Tables .......................................................................................................................x List of Figures ......................................................................................................................x Chapter One: Introduction to the Problem and the Theoretical Background of Humor in Rhetoric ...........................................................................................................1 Statement of the Problem .................................................................................................... 2 Research into Humor .......................................................................................................... 3 Theories of Humor in Philosophy ............................................................................... 3 Theories of Humor in Psychology ............................................................................ 15 Theories of Humor in Communication ..................................................................... 17 Critical Studies with Theoretical Implications ......................................................... 34 Questions still to answer ................................................................................................... 44 Ontology of humor and the classification of humorous occurrences ....................... 45 The strategic uses of humor ...................................................................................... 45 Chapter Two: A New Theory of Rhetorical Humor in Political Discourse, Illustrated by Examples of American Political Rhetoric ...................................................49 An Ontology of Rhetorical Humor ................................................................................... 50 Humor is a Speaker-Centered Practice ..................................................................... 51 Identification of Humorous Attempts ............................................................................... 54 A Pragmatic Approach to Humor ..................................................................................... 56 Classification of Rhetorical Humor .................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Tony Abbott's 'Private Dinner' with Barack Obama Actually a Lunch Attended by Dozens February 1, 2016
    Tony Abbott's 'private dinner' with Barack Obama actually a lunch attended by dozens February 1, 2016 David Wroe National security correspondent Former prime minister Tony Abbott crossed paths with US President Barack Obama at an event attended by dozens of other people rather than having a "private dinner" as reported. Mr Abbott, who has been in the US for several days, met Mr Obama at a lunch of the Alfalfa Club, an informal gathering of high-powered businesspeople and politicians, according to multiple sources. The impromptu meeting was reported in News Corp papers as the pair having "met privately", suggesting Mr Abbott was still being actively courted and received by the Obama administration in what would be a source of frustration for his successor Malcolm Turnbull. Instead the meeting took place at a larger gathering believed to have been attended by about 50 Washington powerbrokers. Mr Abbott's high-profile engagements in the US in the past week as well as those of former defence minister Kevin Andrews have underscored how the former prime minister and his supporters are determined to project influence as the spear- carriers of the Liberal Party's right wing. The Alfalfa Club, which has existed for more than a century, has about 200 members. Mr Abbott and Mr Obama are understood to have met at a club lunch on Saturday held at the mansion of the revered civil rights leader, lawyer and business executive Vernon Jordan. Mr Abbott is understood to have also attended the club's main social event of the year, a dinner held on Saturday night at Washington's Capital Hilton hotel, though Mr Obama did not attend the dinner.
    [Show full text]
  • Virtual Convenings 2020
    VIRTUAL CONVENINGS 2020 Since March 2020, in response to the COVID-19 global crisis, Meridian has harnessed the tools of digital connectivity and doubled down on our convening power to host more than 100 virtual programs with leaders in business, diplo- macy and governments around the world to discuss issues of heightened global importance amid this pandemic and the impacts on the future of international engagement, cooperation and collaboration. Pandemic Preparedness and Response: Global Perspectives on COVID-19 March 25 A discussion on the global response to the COVID-19 pandemic, with special remarks from Ambassador John E. Lange, Senior Fellow for Global Health Diplomacy at the United Nations Foundation and often re- ferred to as the “United States Avian Influenza and Pandemic Ambassador.” SPEAKERS: Ambassador John E. Lange, Senior Fellow for Global Health Diplomacy, United Nations Foundation Brittany Masalosalo, Head of International Affairs and Public Policy at 3M His Excellency Ashok Mirpuri, Ambassador of the Republic of Singapore Ambassador Nestor Forster, Chargé d’Affaires at the Embassy of Brazil AUDIENCE: 95 members of the foreign diplomatic corps and private sector, 394 total views MEDIA: YouTube Livestream Insights@Meridian with Acting Secretary of DHS Chad Wolf April 1 An off-the-record briefing from a key member of the White House Coronavirus Task Force, Acting Secretary of the Department of Homeland Security Chad Wolf, who discussed the steps that his Department is taking to mitigate the spread of the virus, as well as ongoing international and cross-sectoral cooperation and coordination efforts taking place around the world. SPEAKERS: Acting Secretary of the Department of Homeland Security Chad Wolf Oscar Munoz, CEO and President of United Airlines Moderated by Ambassador Stuart Holliday, President and CEO of Meridian AUDIENCE: 73 members of the foreign diplomatic corps and private sector Global Business Briefing with the Ambassadors of Italy and Spain to the U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Ccwnews 2004 Acornell Club of Washington Publication
    CORNELL CLUB May CCWNEWS 2004 ACORNELL CLUB OF WASHINGTON PUBLICATION http://ccw.alumni.cornell.edu OF WASHINGTON Mark Katz ‘86, Speaker at Annual Dinner: “Politics is Easy-Comedy is Hard” May Tuesday, May 18, 6:00 p.m. 2004 The Madison Hotel 1177 15th St, NW Is it legal to have fun at an Annual Meeting? You bet! Come hear Mark In this CCWNews Katz ‘86, a trained and licensed humorist who, under the banner of his Sound Bite Institute, generates hum for himself and his clients, a hodge- Coming Events . p. 2 podge of world leaders, corporate cheeses, and various VPs. Mark was the kid who cracked jokes from the back row of your seventh grade Clinton at Cornell . p. 2 English class, but he grew up to write humor speeches for the president Club Announcements. p. 3 of the United States. Qatar Dinner . p. 3 50+Singles. p. 4 Our guest speaker can trace his career from the principal’s office to the Young Alumni Happy Hr. p. 4 Oval Office--with a four-year stop in Ithaca along the way. Mark is the author of the critically-acclaimed Clinton & Me, an account of his two- ISSC . p. 4 term tenure as the in-house humorist of the Clinton White House, where Softball. p. 5 he helped the president prepare for his annual funny speeches to the Washington press corps, Dragons. .p. 5 including the celebrated Clinton video shown at the White House Correspondents’ Dinner in April MDDG. p. 5 of 2000. Annual Dinner . .pp.6-7 Copies of Clinton & Me will be available for Mark to sign, and a portion of the book sales will Father’s Day Picnic .
    [Show full text]
  • Alfalfa Club Annual Dinner, Statler-Hilton Hotel, Washington, D.C., January 25, 1975
    REMARKS BY SENATOR HUBERT H. HUMPHREY ALFALFA CLUB ANNUAL DINNER Statler-Hilton Hotel Washington, D.C. January 25, 1975 President Ford, former President Borman, honored guests, gentlemen of Alfalfa .•. I hope you will not consider it immodest if I say this night is long overdue • • • . • • President Humphrey .•• You've gotta believe, Frank, you've gotta believe. I had no doubts about the outcome of this election until George McGovern told me he was 1000% behind me. And Ed Muskie suggested I give my acceptance speech on a flat bed truck outside of the Washington ~· And Mayor Daley suggested that we move this convention to Chicago. And someone ••• I don't know who ••• hired Victor Lasky to write a book about me. With all that advice and help, I knew I needed support, so I organized a Chairmen for Humphrey Committee. I sought the most powerful men I could find Hebert (A-bear), Poage, Patman, and Alexander Butterfield. If I were going to crash, Mr. President, I would want the FAA in on it. Now, you have heard President Borman disclose one of my secrets. Yes, it is true that I streaked through the streets of Minneapolis in the interest of full disclosure. (Shake head in disbelief.) But nobody looked. Well, that's not quite true. One person did , and I heard him say, "There's old Hubert with his tongue flapping again. " President Borman, you will have a chance to hear my entire speech. I don't intend to give a long one, but if I do, don't worry about that 7 a.m.
    [Show full text]
  • Bill Clinton Bibliography - 2002 Thru 2020*
    Bill Clinton Bibliography - 2002 thru 2020* Books African American Journalists Rugged Waters: Black Journalists Swim the Mainstream by Wayne Dawkins PN4882.5 .D38 2003 African American Women Cotton Field of Dreams: A Memoir by Janis Kearney F415.3.K43 K43 2004 For Colored Girls Who Have Considered Politics by Donna Brazile E185.96 .B829 2018 African Americans--Biography Step by Step: A Memoir of Hope, Friendship, Perseverance, and Living the American Dream by Bertie Bowman E185.97 .B78 A3 2008 African Americans--Civil Rights Brown Versus Board of Education: Caste, Culture, and the Constitution KF4155 .B758 2003 A Matter of Justice: Eisenhower and the Beginning of the Civil Rights Revolution by David Nichols E836 .N53 2007 Winning While Losing: Civil Rights, the Conservative Movement, and the Presidency From Nixon to Obama edited by Kenneth Osgood and Derrick White E185.615 .W547 2013 African Americans--Politics and Government Bill Clinton and Black America by DeWayne Wickham E886.2 .W53 2002 Conversations: William Jefferson Clinton from Hope to Harlem by Janis Kearney E886.2 .K43 2006 African Americans--Social Conditions The Mark of Criminality: Rhetoric, Race, and Gangsta Rap in the War-on-crime Era * This is a non-annotated continuation of Allan Metz’s, Bill Clinton: A Bibliography. 1 by Bryan McCann ML3531 .M3 2019 Air Force One (Presidential Aircraft) Air Force One: The Aircraft that Shaped the Modern Presidency by Von Hardesty TL723 .H37 2003 Air Force One: A History of the Presidents and Their Planes by Kenneth Walsh TL723 .W35
    [Show full text]
  • Administration of Barack H. Obama, 2009 Digest of Other White House Announcements December 31, 2009 January 20 January 21 Januar
    Administration of Barack H. Obama, 2009 Digest of Other White House Announcements December 31, 2009 The following list includes the President's public schedule and other items of general interest announced by the Office of the Press Secretary and not included elsewhere in this Compilation. January 20 In the afternoon, in Statuary Hall at the U.S. Capitol, the President and Mrs. Obama participated in the Inaugural luncheon. Later, they attended the Inaugural parade. In the evening, at the Washington Convention Center, the President and Mrs. Obama attended and made remarks at the Neighborhood Ball. During the ball, he participated in an interview with Robin Roberts of ABC News. They then attended and made remarks at the Obama Home State Ball. Later in the evening, at the National Building Museum, the President and Mrs. Obama attended and made remarks at the Commander-in-Chief Ball. Then, at the Hilton Washington Hotel Center, they attended and made remarks at the Youth Ball. Later, at the Washington Convention Center, they attended and made remarks at the Biden Home State Ball followed by the Mid Atlantic Region Ball. January 21 In the morning, at the Washington Convention Center, the President and Mrs. Obama attended and made remarks at the West/Southwestern Regional Ball followed by the Midwestern Regional Ball. Later, at the DC Armory, they attended and made remarks at the Southern Regional Ball. Then, at Union Station, they attended and made remarks at the Eastern Regional Ball. Later in the morning, the President met with White House Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel.
    [Show full text]
  • Written Testimony of Michael J. Gerhardt, Burton Craige Distinguished Professor of Jurisprudence, University of North Carolina A
    Written Testimony of Michael J. Gerhardt, Burton Craige Distinguished Professor of Jurisprudence, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill Submitted to Presidential Commission on the United States Supreme Court, August 9, 2021 1 Introduction and Overview My name is Michael Gerhardt. I am currently Burton Craige Distinguished Professor of Jurisprudence at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Scholar in Residence at the National Constitution Center, and the inaugural Richard Beeman Visiting Scholar and Senior Lecturer at the University of Pennsylvania Law School.1 I appreciate the invitation to submit written testimony to the Presidential Commission on the Supreme Court of the United States (hereafter “the Commission”). As directed, my written testimony will focus on the major subject matters that the Commission has been established to address in Executive Order 14023 (April 9, 2021). While I only speak for myself and in my individual capacity in this testimony, the views and recommendations expressed herein are informed by my experiences within the Supreme Court selection process and by my research and scholarship, including the book The Federal Appointments Process (Duke University Press, revised edition 2000). From 2009 to 2021, I have had the honor and privilege of serving as Special Counsel to the Democratic members of the Senate Judiciary Committee for the Supreme Court nominations of Sonia Sotomayor (2009), Elena Kagan (2010), Neil Gorsuch (2016), Brett Kavanaugh (2018), and Amy Coney Barrett (2020). In addition, I testified as an expert witness during the confirmation proceedings for Justice Samuel Alito (2006), was Special Counsel to the Ranking Member on the nomination of John Roberts as Chief Justice of the United States (2005), served as Special Counsel to the Clinton White House for the nomination of Stephen Breyer to the Supreme Court (1994), and was one of the eight members of the Clinton-Gore Justice Department 1 I am grateful to Albert F.
    [Show full text]
  • The Critical and Artistic Reception of Beethoven's
    THE CRITICAL AND ARTISTIC RECEPTION OF BEETHOVEN’S STRING QUARTET IN C♯ MINOR, OP. 131 Megan Ross A dissertation submitted to the faculty at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Department of Music in the College of Arts and Sciences. Chapel Hill 2019 Approved by: Mark Evan Bonds Tim Carter Annegret Fauser Aaron Harcus Mark Katz ©2019 Megan Ross ALL RIGHTS RESERVED ii ABSTRACT Megan Ross: The Critical and Artistic Reception of Beethoven’s String Quartet in C♯-Minor, Op. 131 (Under the direction of Mark Evan Bonds) Long viewed as the unfortunate products of a deaf composer, Ludwig van Beethoven’s “late” works are now widely regarded as the pinnacle of his oeuvre. While the reception of this music is often studied from the perspective of multiple works, my dissertation offers a different perspective by examining in detail the critical and artistic reception of a single late work, the String Quartet in C♯ minor, Op. 131. Critics have generally agreed that the string quartets best exemplify the composer’s late style, and that of these, Op. 131 stands out as the paradigmatic late quartet. I argue that this is because Op. 131 exhibits the greatest concentration of features typically associated with the late style. It is formally unconventional, with seven movements of grotesquely different proportions, to be played continuously, without a pause, as if to insist on the unity of the whole. It conspicuously avoids a sonata-form movement until its finale, opening instead with an extended fugue; the sonata-form finale, in turn, quotes from the fugue, again reinforcing the notion of formal wholeness.
    [Show full text]
  • Myth, History, and Liminality in Harlem and the Bronx
    1 Mapping Memory: Myth, History, and Liminality in Harlem and the Bronx David Andrew Laidler Wellington, New Zealand A Thesis submitted to Victoria University of Wellington in Candidacy for the Degree of Master of Music Te Kōkī New Zealand School of Music March 2016 2 Abstract Mapping Memory: Myth, History, and Liminality in Harlem and the Bronx David Andrew Laidler (Under the supervision of David Cosper and Kimberly Cannady) The relationship between notions of ‘history’ and ‘myth’ is a familiar dilemma within the field of historiography. As this thesis will seek to demonstrate, myth – defined here as evaluative representations of the past to suit demands of the present – is virtually indistinguishable from history, insofar as both are constructed from the same raw materials: subjective remembrances. Through an examination of mythical representations of physical places, this thesis will present a model to explain how myth is constructed, thereby emphasising the intimate and problematic relationship between the aforementioned categories. In short, myth making occurs when memories travel through liminal space from one individual to the next, with said liminal points allowing for degradation and transmutation. The further along one is in the chain, the more one is dependent on myth. Through electing to focus on two such locales that have been of particular interest to me – Harlem during the jazz age and The Bronx during the origins of hip hop – I was able to adopt an auto-ethnographic perspective, gaining insight into the extent to which my understanding was dependent on a series of compounding representations. Further, these areas also draw attention to how such representation can broaden or localise, depending on the myth and the purpose of its invocation.
    [Show full text]
  • Final Thesis
    YALE UNIVERSITY New Haven, CT IT’S NO JOKE: The Use of Humor by Presidential Candidates from Kennedy to Trump and the Path to Power Through One-Liners, Talk Shows, and Tweets A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of the Bachelor of Arts in Political Science By Abigail Bessler Advised by Professor Walter Shapiro April 2017 Table of Contents INTRODUCTION...................................................................................................................Page 3 THEORIES OF LAUGHTER.................................................................................................Page 7 “What is its nature?”...................................................................................................Page 7 “What is its source?”...................................................................................................Page 8 “Should an orator want to stir up laughter?”.............................................................Page 10 “To what extent?”.....................................................................................................Page 13 “Into what categories can the humorous be divided?”..............................................Page 13 A (BRIEF) HISTORY OF PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION HUMOR...................................Page 14 John F. Kennedy and the Politics of Personality......................................................Page 15 Richard “Sock It to Me?” Nixon...............................................................................Page 18 Ronald
    [Show full text]
  • Administration of Barack Obama, 2015 Digest of Other White House
    Administration of Barack Obama, 2015 Digest of Other White House Announcements December 31, 2015 The following list includes the President's public schedule and other items of general interest announced by the Office of the Press Secretary and not included elsewhere in this Compilation. January 1 In the morning, the President, Mrs. Obama, and their daughters Sasha and Malia traveled to Hanauma Bay, HI. In the afternoon, the President, Mrs. Obama, and their daughters Sasha and Malia traveled to Kailua, HI, where at Island Snow, they purchased shave ice and greeted customers and staff. Later, they returned to their vacation residence. In the evening, the President and Mrs. Obama traveled to Honolulu, HI. Later, they returned to their vacation residence in Kailua. Also in the evening, the President had a telephone conversation with Governor Andrew M. Cuomo to extend his and the First Lady's condolences on the passing of the Governor's father, former Governor Mario M. Cuomo of New York. January 2 In the morning, the President traveled Marine Corps Base Hawaii in Kaneohe Bay, HI. Then, he returned to his vacation residence in Kailua, HI. Later, he traveled to Marine Corps Base Hawaii in Kaneohe Bay. Also in the morning, the President had a telephone conversation with Senate Majority Leader Harry M. Reid to wish him a full and speedy recovery from injuries sustained while exercising. In the afternoon, the President returned to his vacation residence in Kailua. In the evening, the President, Mrs. Obama, and their daughters Sasha and Malia traveled to Honolulu, HI. Later, they returned to their vacation residence in Kailua.
    [Show full text]
  • Nominations to the Board of Directors of the Corporation for Public Broadcasting Hearing
    S. HRG. 110–1226 NOMINATIONS TO THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF THE CORPORATION FOR PUBLIC BROADCASTING HEARING BEFORE THE COMMITTEE ON COMMERCE, SCIENCE, AND TRANSPORTATION UNITED STATES SENATE ONE HUNDRED TENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION SEPTEMBER 17, 2008 Printed for the use of the Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation ( U.S. GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE 80–430 PDF WASHINGTON : 2013 For sale by the Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Printing Office Internet: bookstore.gpo.gov Phone: toll free (866) 512–1800; DC area (202) 512–1800 Fax: (202) 512–2104 Mail: Stop IDCC, Washington, DC 20402–0001 VerDate Nov 24 2008 12:49 Apr 23, 2013 Jkt 075679 PO 00000 Frm 00001 Fmt 5011 Sfmt 5011 S:\GPO\DOCS\80430.TXT JACKIE SENATE COMMITTEE ON COMMERCE, SCIENCE, AND TRANSPORTATION ONE HUNDRED TENTH CONGRESS SECOND SESSION DANIEL K. INOUYE, Hawaii, Chairman JOHN D. ROCKEFELLER IV, West Virginia KAY BAILEY HUTCHISON, Texas, Ranking JOHN F. KERRY, Massachusetts TED STEVENS, Alaska, Vice Chairman BYRON L. DORGAN, North Dakota JOHN MCCAIN, Arizona BARBARA BOXER, California OLYMPIA J. SNOWE, Maine BILL NELSON, Florida GORDON H. SMITH, Oregon MARIA CANTWELL, Washington JOHN ENSIGN, Nevada FRANK R. LAUTENBERG, New Jersey JOHN E. SUNUNU, New Hampshire MARK PRYOR, Arkansas JIM DEMINT, South Carolina THOMAS R. CARPER, Delaware DAVID VITTER, Louisiana CLAIRE MCCASKILL, Missouri JOHN THUNE, South Dakota AMY KLOBUCHAR, Minnesota ROGER F. WICKER, Mississippi MARGARET L. CUMMISKY, Democratic Staff Director and Chief Counsel LILA HARPER HELMS, Democratic Deputy Staff Director and Policy Director CHRISTINE D. KURTH, Republican Staff Director and General Counsel PAUL NAGLE, Republican Chief Counsel (II) VerDate Nov 24 2008 12:49 Apr 23, 2013 Jkt 075679 PO 00000 Frm 00002 Fmt 5904 Sfmt 5904 S:\GPO\DOCS\80430.TXT JACKIE C O N T E N T S Page Hearing held on September 17, 2008 ....................................................................
    [Show full text]