Universita' Degli Studi Di Torino
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
UNIVERSITA' DEGLI STUDI DI TORINO School of Management and Economics Master’s Degree in International Accounting Dissertation on: Participation Banking in Turkey: Comparative Analysis, Z/Yen reference & perspectives Relator: Professor Paolo Pietro Biancone Corelator: Professor Giuseppina Lucia Maria Candidate: Hajar Boulam Academic Year 2014/2015 Abstract. Islamic banking system developed significantly especially in the phase of last financial crisis. Its working principles are believed to be more stable and fair, for these exact reasons many conventional banks are turning up part their assets into shariah compliant assets, either by setting up Islamic windows or establishing subsidiaries. In addition, new Interestfree Banks were set up, both in Eastern and Western countries. This paper work will focus on the Islamic Banking in Turkey. The choice of Turkey was made for several reasons. Firstly, is a country that gathers East and West, therefore, it could be seen as a close example to the Mediterranean countries. Secondly, is a secular country, characterized by Dual Banking system, formed by conventional and islamic banks, private and state owned. Thirdly, it belongs to the QISMUT countries that are driving Global Islamic Finance Growth, consequently Turkey could be a potential global financial Hub. 1 To my parents, To my 3 countries "seeking knowledge is like swimming in a deep Atlantic Ocean with high waves, through storms, thirst, hunger and loneliness, but once you have reached the seashore you will realize that you have obtained priceless treasures" Hajar Boulam 2 Acknowledgments: I owe this work to many people who helped me in my research process. First and foremost, I want to thank my reader, Professor Paolo Biancone , who provided me with invaluable feedback and big help. I am also thankful to Professor Maria Lucia Giuseppina for the guidance and supervision. Similarly, Dr. Nihat Gümüş’s editing and structured research was infinitely interesting and helpful. I am incredibly grateful to Şevket Can Tülümen for his enormous help, time and continuous support during my journey and the MÜSİAD Association for funding my research in Istanbul. I am also very grateful to the guidance of many Professors that dedicated me their time and help: Prof. Dr. H. Saduman Okumus, Vice Rector at Istanbul Ticaret Universitesi. Special Thanks to Dr. Prof Ahmet Faruk Aysan, Member of the Board & Member of the Monetary Policy Committee at Central Bank of the Republic of Turkey, for his precious explanation and help. Special thanks to Dr. Mehmet Saraç, Professor of Islamic economics and Finance at Sakarya and Istanbul Universitesi. I am so thankful to the experts of 5 Participation Banks (Bank Asya, Albaraka Bank, Turkiye Finans, Kuveyt Turk Bank, Ziraat Katilim Bank) and TKBB members in Turkey who let me interview them and gave me leads to sources. 3 Furthermore, I have to thank all professionals for their precious help and priceless contribution: Mr. Ramazan Aksu, Mr. Melikşah Utku, Mr. Paul Wouter, Mr. Osman Nihat Yilmaz, Mr. Aydin Yabanli, Mr. Ahmet Albayrak, Mr. Muhammad Alauddin, Mr. Raci Kaya, Mr. Ahmet Deryol, Mr. Sherif Ayoub, Mr. Hamizi Hamzah, Ms. Nuran Pakdemirli, Mr. Shehada Mouzahem, Mr. Abdulbari Mashal, Mr. Mohammad Alsenan, Mr. Mesut Polat, Ms. Esra Yalcin, Ms. Zeynep Güran, Mr. Recep Tekçam, Ms. Tuğba Yildirim, Ms. Gokcen Dogan, Ms. Vildan Velieva, Mr. Harun Yasakçi, Mr. Omer Lutfi Tama, Mr. Metin Turkay, Ms. Neşe Pektaş Zurnacı, Ms. Kübra Gökçen Doğan, Mr. Cen Öztürk and others. Special Thanks to Tulumen family; my classmates Cristiana, Giulia, Emanuela, Bianca, Can, Abee, Elena, Alessandro, Simone, my friends Maria, Francesca, Francesca C. and Alessandra, my schoolmates of bachelor degree courses, and all the international friends of the italian and turkish dormitory and Edisu Team. 4 1. GENERAL LANDSCAPE 1.1. Introduction………………………………………………………….......... 8 1.2. Purpose……………………………………………………………………. 9 1.3. Methodology……………………………………………………………… 9 1.4. Structure………...…………………………………………………………. 9 2. ANALYSIS OF Z/YEN INDEX DIMENSION TO DETERMINE THE QUALIFICATION OF FINANCIAL CENTER ………………………….... 11 2.1. The evaluation of global financial hub……………………………………. 11 2.2. Methodology…………………………………………………………….... 11 2.3. Competitiveness Factors and their relative importance…………………… 12 2.4. Z/yen index, Turkish case ………………………………………………… 13 2.4.1. Business environmental sector …………………………………………. 13 2.4.2. Financial sector development……………………………………………. 15 2.4.3. Infrastructure…………………………………………………………….. .19 2.4.4. Human capital…………………………………………………………….. 22 2.4.5. Reputational and general factors ………………………………………….25 3. DESCRIPTION OF ISLAMIC FINANCE………………………………. ..27 3.1. Definition of Islam and Islamic Finance 3.1.1. The meaning of Islam and Pillars …………………………………….... 27 5 3.1.2. Islamic finance…………………………………………………………... 30 3.1.3. Meaning of Shariah & Sources ………………………………………..... 31 3.2. Sharia Compliant Financial Instruments ………………………………….. 42 3.3. Islamic Capital Market ……………………………………………………..56 3.3.1. Islamic Capital Market Instruments …………………………………….. 56 3.3.2 Definition of Sukuk ……………………………………………………….57 3.3.3. Tradable Islamic financial assets………………………………………….58 3.3.4. Classification of sukuk …………………………………………………...59 4. THE OUTLOOK OF ISLAMIC FINANCE IN TURKEY ……………....63 4.1 Background: History of Banks in Turkey……………………………………63 4.2 Statutory Progress in Islamic Banks: Banking Law reforms ………………..64 4.2.1. Ist Decree: Special Finance Houses……………………………………..64 4.2.2 II Law: Islamic Deposit Insurance Scheme …………………………… 66 4.2.3. III Law: SFH switched to Participation Banks ………………………..67 4.3. General Outlook about Banking Sector in Turkey………………………….68 4.4 Comparative ratios of Dual Banking system ………………………………..71 4.4.1 Research Method and Data ………………………………………………71 4.4.2 Results of The Analysis…………………………………………………..72 4.5. Practical visits & Interview with Participation Banks……………………... 76 4.5.1. Albaraka Participation Bank …………………………………………… 76 4.5.2 Bank Asya………………………………………………………………...82 6 4.5.3 Kuveyt Bank …………………………………………………………….. 91 4.5.4 Turkiye Finans …………………………………………………………....97 4.5.5 .Ziraat Katilim Bankasi …………………………………………………..97 4.5.6 TKBB Association………………………………………………………...98 5. HOW ISLAMIC BANKING TOOLS CAN CONTRIBUTE TO THE ISTANBUL INTERNATIONAL FINANCE CENTER PROJECT 5.1. Istanbul International Finance Center Project …………………………....100 6. IMPACT OF EMIGRANTS ON EUROPEAN ECONOMY AND OPENING OF ISLAMIC BANKS 6.1 History and origins of the word “Market”.....................................................107 and the oldest Arabic market 6.2 The oldest Arabic Market : Okhath………………………………………....107 6.3 Excursus of Arabic Emigrations…………………………………………....108 6.4. The effect of emigration on Consumption…………………………………111 6.5. The effect of religious restrictions on Consumption……………………….113 6.6. Islamic Finance in Europe ………………………………………………... 115 6.6.1.Islamic Finance in France …………………………………………...…. 115 6.6.2. Islamic Finance in United Kingdom…………………………………….117 6.6.3. Islamic Finance in Luxembourg………………………………………..118 6.6.4. Islamic Finance in Germany……………………………………………119 7. CONCLUSIONS…………………………………………………………….121 BIBLIOGRAPHY……………………..……………………………………... 123 7 1. GENERAL LANDSCAPE 1.1. Introduction Turkey’s first regulation for Islamic Finance was realized in the 1980s, during a period of liberalization as part of a plan to attract foreign direct investments. Interest free banking was introduced with the legalization of “special finance houses” which did not possess bank status and therefore did not benefit from banks’ privileges. The Islamic Finance sector kept evolving steadily in the 1980s and 1990s with Arab Gulf investors setting up finance houses and commencing lending activities, accommodating mainly specific religious clients. The leap for interest free banking came after the 2001 economic crisis. Banking finance legislation went through a major overhaul after the crisis. A union was formed to provide a certain level of state control and support for special finance houses. 2006 saw the introduction of Banking Law No. 5411, which legitimized participation banking and provided insurance through the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund for participation deposits. Along with these changes, the special finance houses union became the Participation Banks Association of Turkey (“TKBB”), which sets forth the ethical, professional principles for participation banks. All participation banks had to be a member of TKBB. The following years saw a rapid increase in participation banking and the 2008 global crisis highlighted the need for more stable financing. In line with the government’s support of Islamic Finance and interest free finance instruments, the World Bank Global Islamic Finance Development Center was launched on the premises of the Istanbul Stock Exchange in late 2013. 8 Turkey had various previous experiences with interest free financing in the form of profitloss sharing certificates and real estate certificates mainly used for the financing of large infrastructure and construction projects. The issuance of sukuk was initially regulated with the Capital Markets’ Board (“CMB”), the first sovereign sukuk issuance was realized in August 2013 with significant oversubscription closing at USD 8 billion which shows huge demand for sukuk. 1.2. Purpose The objective of this paper is an attempt to elaborate Islamic Banking in Turkey, to examine whether Turkey can become an International Financial Hub by