14176 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS May 17, 1976 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS
A MISSION DISASTROUS are words as foreign to them as Swahlll 1s to essential to free governmen~. Its legal pro Floridians. tection will be hollow, as Alexander Ha.mll Secretary Kissinger set off his African ex ton predicted, and its freedom will become pedition with the professed alms of helping a sham. HON. HARRY F. BYRD, JR. achieve a peaceful transition to majority rule The press has gradually learned that It has OJ' VIRGINIA In Rhodesia and weakening Soviet infiuence the inescapable obligation to Ulumlnate the IN THE SENATE OF THE UNITED STATES in Africa. reality behind the appearance. If following The effect of his trlp 1s most likely to be an that course tends to place the press in an Mondav, Mav 17, 1976 escalation of violence, since the extremists adversary position vis-a-vis not only gov now have the lmplled backing of the United ernment but any and all other institutions, Mr. HARRY F. BYRD, JR. Mr. Presi States for an all-out campaign against dent, the ably edited Tampa, Fla., Trib so much the better for us and for them, and Rhodesia--a country in which blacks have most of all for the public. The adversary une published an excellent editorial on more freedom and a higher standard of living position is Indeed the natural position for a Secretary Kissinger's African trip--and than 1n most of the black-ruled countries. press that takes seriously its responslb111ty to promises. I ask unanimous consent that When Kissinger began hls trip, we said it uncover what is wrong or corrupt in public this editorial, captioned "A Mission was a Mission Impossible. We would now call llfe, or with private Institutions or individu Disastrous," be printed in the RECORD. it a Mission Disastrous. als whose activities affect the public inter There being no objection, the article est. was ordered to be printed in the RECORD, But a much more ditncult problem is the as follows: obverse of this one. Does the press not also [From the Tampa Tribune] CONFIDENCE IN THE PRESS have the responsib1llty of making the judg ment not to publish, the responsibUity of A MissiON DISASTROUS self-restraint, of withholding a potentially secretary of State Henry Kissinger, report dangerous secret, or refusing to publish de ing to the Senate Foreign Relations Com HON. ELIZABETH HOLTZMAN tails that could damage the nation's security mittee ... on his trip to black Africa: OF NEW YORK or an individual's reputation? "We made, I believe, an immense and IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES The dilemma is a terribly real one. No welcome impact in Africa on those ... who newspaperman wants to damage the national truly care for peace, independence and jus Monday, May 17, 1976 security; and yet no newspaperxnan any long tice." er places full faith and credit 1n the phrase Mr. Kissinger 1n this statement exceeds Ms. HOLTZMAN. Mr. Speaker, in a "national security" which has so often been ~ven the diplomatic license for hypocrisy. democratic society, the perpetual tug of used as a wrapper to clothe error, venality, Who are those who "truly care for peace, war between liberty and order frequently corruption or even a drift toward authoritar independence and justice"? is waged over the limits on freedom of is.nism and personal rule. Idi Amln, the dictator of Uganda, aptly de scribed by former United Nations Ambas the press. John Oakes, an editor of the However each time that Information al sador Pat Moynihan as "a racist murderer"? New York Times, recently made an im legedly Involving national security Is pub Samora Machel, leader of the Communist portant contribution to this debate in an lished In the American press, the ~uestlon is band which has made a pollee state of article that appeared on the Op Ed page unavoidable: Are we taking undue advan Mozambique? of that paper. I commend his article to tage of our First Amendment privilege to the President Kenneth Kaunda of Zambia, who my colleague's attention. detriment of the nation, or are we acting in deals with polltlcal opponents by throwing the publ1c Interest? Each case must be de them in jall? The text follows: cided on its merits, but each case legitimately The Marxist dictator of Tanzania, Julius CONFIDENCE IN THE PRESS raises the question anew. K. Nyerere, who aids the training of ter (By John B. Oakes) Freedom of the press in the United States rorlsts to operate against Rhodesia? (What 1s the Uberty of the press? ... Its today Is under more serious attack than at secretary Kissinger knows that 15 of the security, whatever fine declaration may be any time since the Sedition Act nearly two 49 countries 1n Africa are under direct mili inserted in any constitution respecting it, centuries ago. As the press has assumed the tary rule and 29 have one-party governments must altogether depend on public opinion, responsib111ty in recent years of inquiring which brook no opposition. Of the only five and on the general spirit of the people and Into the hidden recesses of government- which permit more than one political party of the government.-AZexander Hamilton) executive, legislative and judicial-the reac to offer candidates, one 1s the country which The experience of Watergate is the most tion on the part of governing authority has was the principal target of the Kissinger ex recent demonstration that a free press is es been to attempt to place new and unaccus pedition: Rhodesia. sential to a free democracy. Yet, ironically, tomed restrictions on it. In his effort to gain favor with the black just as government because of its size and The attacks take various forms. One used ruled governments, Mr. Kissinger promised complexity has distanced itself from the in with growing frequency, Is the "gag order," a "unrelenting opposition" to white control in dividual citizen, the press has been dis kind of prior censorship forbidding the press Rhodesia and South Africa. tancing ltseU from the individual reader at to publish certain material on the ground He also promised to tighten the economic the very moment when democracy needs lt that to do so would endanger the defendant's squeeze on Rhodesia by funnellng American most. strictions upon It. aid to its hostile neighbors (notably Mozam The intimate, almost personal, relation The First Amendment's guarantees and the bique) and trying again to persuade Congress ship between newspaper and reader of an Sixth Amendment's guarantee of trial by to cut off U.S. imports of Rhodesian chrome. earlier day has declined; and the consequent an impartial jury may often on occasion The secretary represented these policies as growing alienation of public from press conflict; the question is a real one and is necessary to deter further Soviet-Cuban in threatens even greater danger to press free under constant scrutiny and discussion by tervention of the kind which won Angola and dom than specific legislative or judicial re both press and courts. But lt would surely be to assure favorable treatment of American straints about which we are so rightly con better to impose sanctions on otncers of the interests in Africa. cerned. court to forestall leaks, and use other devices "Our chrome imports would be greatly en As the confidence of Americans in all our such as sequestration of juries and changes dangered," he told the Senators, 1! the black institutions has been weakened, as our so of venue than to Introduce censorship nationalists take over Rhodesia without ciety has at the same time become more through loose employment of the gag order, American support. complex, more broadly sophisticated and less as is done so often at present. Surely, Mr. Kissinger doesn't delude him trustful, and as newspaper management has Slmilarly, the repeated use of the sub self that his efforts to appease the African tended to move steadily away from the per poena power in recent years to force news radicals wlll either block Soviet imperialism sonally directed journalism of an Individual papermen to testify before a grand jury or or assure a permanent supply of Rhodesian editor toward the impersonality of a corpo to reveal their sources in criminal cases rep chrome for our strategic industries. rate structure, the newspaper's direct rela resents another potentially crippling attack If the black nationalists overthrow the tionship to the public has become more on press and publlc freedom, for the very present Rhodesian government, they will feel strained; and public understanding of the basic reason that confidentlali ty of sources free to shut off chrome supplles or quadruple inextricable connection between press liberty fs at the heart of the newspaper's ability to the price to the u.s. as suits their purposes. and publlc Uberty has been correspondingly function. They can be expected to act in concert with blurred. But the press does not help its case by Russia, the other principal source of supply. But once the publlc becomes convinced insisting on an absolutist position, on re As for good wlll? In the African dictator however wrongly-that the press does not garding the First Amendment as automati ships, to borrow a phrase from Mao, it grows deserve that First Amendment guarantee, cally overriding every other provision of the out of the barrel of a gun. "Peace and justice" which was written into the Constitution as Constitution, not to mention common sense. May 17, 1976 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 14177
The press Is not going to retain-or regain mittee only as a last resort. It was our belief moved the restrictions and reverter clause public confidence 1! it is perceived to be that the serious public charges raised during from all the property originally transferred constantly arrogant, unwilling to recognize the past year about the activities of Rep by the 1948 Act including the Holiday Isle confiicting rights, or not too concerned about resentative Robert Sikes presented precisely property. maintaining the most rigid standards to pro the kind of matter that the House Ethics The removal of these restrictions was of tect and preserve its own integrity. Committee was establlshed to investigate and substantial benefit to the value of an the Newspapermen have a special obUgation rule upon. In past years investigations have la.nd transferred by the 1948 Act, including to retain public confidence through conscious been undertaken by Congress on its own the Holiday Isle property. Prior to the re and deliberate effort to open ourselves to initiative regarding the conduct Qf members moval of the restrictions, CBS Development the publlc, to pay particular attention to based on serious public charges. One such had paid no gross receipts taxes to its land complaints of unfairness, inaccuracy, bias, investigation, that of Representative Adam lord, the Okaloosa. Island Authority. In the vindictiveness-that is, to make ourselves Clayton Powell, helped lead to the 1968 de ten year period following the removal of voluntarily accountable. Some newspapers cision to create this committee. No member the restrictions in the deed transferring have already gone a considerable distance tn of Congress, however, was prepared to take the Holiday Isle, CBS Corp. paid the Island doing just this-but not many and certainly the steps necessary to assure that the issues Authority approximately $19,173 in taxes. not enough. raised about Representatives Sikes would be Since this fee represented one percent of If there comes to be a widespread publlc reviewed by Congress. gross receipts, according to the CBS arrange conviction that the press is a closed institu we have therefore prepared and trans ment with the Okaloosa Island Authority, tion and therefore not to be trusted, or that mitted a complaint to the Committee. We the gross receipts to CBS for the ten-year the press is Willing to defy the national in· consider the issues involved in this case of period following removal of the reverter terest or trample on individual rights merely such a nature as to represent a fundamen clauses were in excess of $1.9 million. to sell papers, the First Amendment protec tal test of whether members of Congress and According to Representative Sikes, Holiday tions may indeed crumble before the com this Committee are willing to take seriously Isle leases were disposed of in mid-1972 for bined assault of legislatures and courts. The their ethical obligations as elected public $600,000. While CBS Development Corp. was result, as President David Truman of Mount officials. dissolved in 1973, according to Representa Holyoke College recently said, wm be ..far The case set forth in our complaint, we tive Sikes, he still continued as of May 30, more damaging to the national interest than believe, creates an obligation on the Com 1975, to receive some income from Holiday any [restrictions] resulting from a responsi mittee to conduct an investigation. The in Isle leases. ble self-restraint by the press." vestigation should review the facts we have The final picture here is clear. Representa The legal right inherent 1n the F1rst brought to the Committee's attention and tive Sikes has sponsored and shepherded Amendment carries with it a moral obliga any other relevant facts, and should consider through Congress legislation designed to tion. a kind of moral compact between press the appllcation of the various rules we have increase the value of a relatively small piece and people. This is not something that can referred to plus any other relevant rules, of property, a slgniftcant piece of which was be enforced; but it is something that the regulations or standards of conduct. The full leased by a corporation in which he was a press Will ignore at its own and the coun House of Representatives, of course, has the principal shareholder. His actions, without try's peril. ultimate responsib111ty to decide these mat disclosure to the Congress of his personal ters. financial interest, constitute a clear cut con filet of interest. Representative Sikes• only The complaint is based on information that defense is that it came as a complete sur STATEMENT OF MR. FRED WER has been gathered from public documents, prise to him that Holiday Isle was bene and statements by Representative Sikes, by fiting from his efforts. He is thus relying THEIM:ER OF COMMON CAUSE Common Cause staff members operating un SUBMITI'ED TO THE HOUSE COM on a highly unusual claim, that he did not der my supervision. As a private organiza k.now that he was dealing with his own MITTEE ON STANDARDS OF OF tion. without subpoena power, we have gath property. Certainly, in the words of the FICIAL CONDUCT ered as much information as we could under Code of Ethics, Representative Sikes sought these limitations. There are numerous ques and accepted "benefits under circumstances tions to be pursued which can now only be which might be construed by reasonable HON. DONALD M. FRASER resolved in the course of an investigation by persons as infiuencing the performance of this Committee. his governmental duties." OF MINNESOTA We have brought before this Committee in FIRST NAVY BANK IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES our complaint allegations that deal with Representative Robert Sikes' personal finan During the periods 1965-1966, and 1972, Monday, May 17, 1976 cial holdings in three areas: the CBS Devel Representative Sikes provided assistance to persons seeking to organize the First Navy Mr. FRASER. Mr. Speaker, on May 6 opment Corp, the First Navy Bank, and Fair child Industries. Bank, in their efforts to replace the Florida and 7, 1976, the gentleman from First National Bs.nk at the Pensacola Naval Florida socialism" for his country. ognizing our concerns that States be treated We have charged this confiict under the as equal partners in the determinations basic only ru1e we found at all concrete on the He soon learned a lesson that changed the course of his life: The noble slogans of "so to planning and development of resources subject-a rule that goes to the weakest form within a State, particularly when develop of influence Sikes could have exercised with cialism" and "brotherhood" and "people's democracy" were a mask for sheer totalitar ment 1s contemplated on federally-owned respect to Fairchild, his vote on the floor in land. August 1974 for passage of the Defense Ap ian power, trampling all real freedom under propriations Bill. foot. Sixty-seven percent of Utah's land is But that is a far weaker ca.se than cou1d Pachman's new book, "Checkmate in federally owned and much of it is inter be made. If the Committee believes the po Prague," subtitled, "The Memoirs of a Grand spersed with both private and State master," has really nothing to do with chess tential conse~uences of applying our con owned property. A large portion of the tention are too far-reaching, we would urge as such, except in showing that the totali the Committee to investigate and evaluate tarian juggernaut is truly total in its domi State's energy resources are contained on the member's conduct in the far more serious nance over the life of the people, not only this Federal property and the only way to context that is involved: a ranking mem in politics and economics, but even in such avoid chaos and conflict in the develop ber of an appropriation subcommittee who margin.al activities as sports and games. ment of these resources is ·to provide a has held stock that could rise or fall de What is tragic about the book is that the logical process for State input in the total pending on the subcommittee's actions and, Russian "liberators" were greeted so enthu planning and decisionmaking phases of perhaps, on the Defense Department's de siastically after the German defeat, by naive every demonstration project using these sire to please powerful subcom.m.ittee mem and hopeful populaces who actually believed bers who are also shareholders. A failure to that Soviet hegemony wou1d bring them into resources. disclose in this setting Is an unusually seri the camp of "international solidarity" of the Utah is particularly interested in the ous matter. working classes. development of synthetic fuel from oil CONCLUSION Any honest historian of the 20th century shale. Governor Rampton states that he In summary, we believe that we have pre could have told them otherwise. Just as supports the recovery of synthetic fuels sented this Committee with sufficient in Hitler used the deceptive rubrics of "Na from coal, oil shale and other resources, formation to carry out its responsibilities to tional Socialism" and "labor" in the name of both renewable and nonrenewable, but conduct an investigation of Representative his Nazi Party to conceal its basic despotism, would like to see the ·committee rescind Sikes' activities. We believe that this is pre so the Soviets constantly promulgate the its limitation on the size of oil shale de same fictions to mask their ruthless be cisely the kind of case which the House velopments detailed in the legislation. Ethics Committee was created to deal with. trayal of the workers' hopes for equality, In the March, 1968 Report o! the Commit democracy and a humane socialism "that In addition, he considers it desirable, tee on Standards o! Offi.cial Conduct, the fol wears a human face." whenever possible, to use the resources lowing statement was made: The word "communism" has been used as and personnel of the State and region "A mere statement o! guidelines serves a bogeym.an in the West, manipulated by where a facility is located to provide the neither as a deterrent to improper conduct the cunning to frighten the credulous; but socio-economic, environmental and tech- nor as a yardstick !or punitive action, in the it is not communism per se that poses a nical research needed by the Federal absence of means that demand respect for threat to freedom: The early Christians, it Government. the guidelines. Enforcement is the substance seems probable, practiced a primitive form that makes standards meaningful. It would of communism, based on genuine sharing There is strong agreement with and arm the House with the weapon needed to out of love and brotherhood. praise for the principle of providing defend itself, and, in truth, make it the judge It is, rather, the totalitarian monster mas funds for impacted communities. Gover of its own membership." querading as the liberator of mankind that nor Rampton considers it particularly At stake here 1s whether this Committee deludes and then destroys the hopes of the important that State and local govern- May 17, 1976 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 14179 ments have input in deciding who shall Africans who, in their new independence, and even labor leaders, traditionally allled pay the socio-economic impact costs. are deservingly proud. And it is unfair to the ruling party. The devaluation of the In peso is being discussed openly, although Pres assessing the energy needs of the to us and especially when we realize that ident Echeverria, not very well known as an Nation, the Governor emphasizes that Dr. Kissinger, in order to carry out his economist, is proudly saying: "The dollar synthetic fuel must be developed and Santa Claus act, first must get the sup may be devalued, but the peso wlll not." produced to augment our diminishing oU port of Congress which could take a dim In the last thirty months, inflation has and natural gas supplies if we hope to view of more aid appropriations and of risen more than 50 percent. Trying to please maintain the strength of our economy the American public which shows every the powerful CTM, the government has and the Nation's security. indication of being fed up with give agreed to two blanket wage increases total aways. His path through Africa could be ling 42 percent. During the first four months According to Governor Rampton: of 1975, while President Echeverria was pre In this regard we gratefully acknowledge come one strewn with broken promises paring the most recent of his expensive trips the leadership of the House Committee on that could create tensions, rather than abroad, the trade deficit reached 48.7 per Science and Technology . . . in the develop cement relations. cent and even the earnings from the tourist ment of the concepts embodied in H.R. 12112. trade fell by 10.3 percent compared to last This bill is a model of Federal-State-local year. cooperation in the solution of a problem with The Mexican foreign debt in 1970, when overriding national consequences with sig OTHER VOICES ON MEXICO Echeverria took office was $3.2 billion, but n11lcant State and local impact. he and his cronies have managed things in such a way that it has grown to $8 billion HON. LARRY McDONALD in 1974. These dismaying figures have been OF GEORGIA piled up in spite of the recent oil findings THE NEW KISSINGER PROMISES in Mexico, bringing several hundred roll IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES lion dollars in oil exports. Monday, May 17, 1976 The rumblings of unrest and discontent HON. JOSEPH M. GAYDOS are everywhere, but President Echeverria an OF PENNSYLVANIA Mr. McDONALD of Georgia.. Mr. swers with more inflationary measures and Speaker, my recent comments on events crushing all opposition to his leftist policies. IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES in Mexico has created quite a stir. How Monday, May 17, 1976 ever, that is not because the situation is NoT ALL Is DEMAGOGUERY Mr. GAYDOS. Mr. Speaker, news re particularly new, but because those who Listening to the thunderous radical out ports on Secretary of State Henry Kis have been concerned about it have not bursts by President Luis Echeverria-Alvarez, been able to reach large numbers of peo his sure successor, Jose Lopez-Portlllo, and singer's journey through Africa told of their leftist courtiers, it is possible to think promises of U.S. dollar giveaways at ple, due to the "liberal" form of media that Mexico is going the way of Communist most every stop. censorship we must endure. Cuba. One totaled $200 million as a "contri It pleases me to call attention to a But the fact is that the Mexican dema bution" to a development fund. Another project of the American Security Coun gogues have not yet had their day. was a $75 million "gift." The topper was cil called Radio Free Americas which Just last month there was a bitter clash an offer to join in a $7.5 billion project to has been providing details of the attempt between President Echeverria-Alvarez and "roll back the desert," no less. Perhaps to steer Mexico into the Castroite camp, the Mexican Association of Private Enter we shall learn of others later. without the consent of the Mexican peo prise, based in the northern part of the coun ple. Two examples of these brief broad try, where large steel, manufacturing, min These new proffered generosities, it ing and agricultural enterprises are centered. should be unnecessary to add, comes casts dealing with Mexico will show the These conservative Mexican elements, wor while our Federal budget continues dan nature of this project. ried about the prevaillng leftist polltical gerously out of balance and when count The article follows: trends, had issued a statement defending less American communities are in severe REPORT ON MEXICO their rights under the Constitution and de financial trouble. President Luis Echeverria-Alvarez, of Mex nouncing the activities of radical politicians For one example in thousands, my ico, is already back in his country, after ren and labor leaders. The Communists immedi home country in Pennsylvania is with dering homage to dictator Castro, in person, ately countered with the accusation that and insulting the national feelings of the rightist elements were preparing a revolu out funds to repair its many deteriorated Cuban people. Up to now, barring what his tion, while President Echeverria-Alvarez bridges and so far has received little sycophants wlll decide to the contrary, he himself accused the businessmen in North hope from Washington. And yet Dr. Kis has completed a series of expensive trips ern Mexico as being reactionary and pro singer would have our scarce tax dollars abroad connected with his search for votes fascists. undertake a desert rollback half the as Secretary General of the United Nations. But the defenders of free enterprise were world away. There has been some important dissent as not shouted down by the demagogues. They I have an abiding sympathy for im to the advantages for Mexico in so many reasserted their views and pointed out that poverished people in Africa and else costly polltical tours. One dissenter came the leftists were responsible for the critical out into the open because a radio network economic situation of Mexico and were flirt where and find myself conditioned to disapproved of the exaggerated praise by one ing with Marxist-Leninist tendencies. back any reasonable program by which of its commentators, who was fired in spite An even more encouraging sign comes from they may be helped. But I would like, of his protests. the very respected Mexican Institute for nevertheless, to see others in the so Mr. Echeverria reached home in his role Social and Economic Research, for twenty called Western World, many of them fi as a world statesman to find that the "13·th one years fighting for responsible and demo nancially better off than we, take a lead of September" Communist guerrillas had cratic reforms in Mexico. Its "Sheet for Eco in this. We are doing, and have done, been kUling policemen during his absence at nomic Information", issued March 15, is a in the rate of more than one a day. Altogether, courageous defense of Mexican democratic more the giveaway field than any seventy-two policemen, plus several soldiers ln.stitutions. other nation and thus it is disturbing to and marines, have been murdered in a few "We are losing our freedom. Things go bad me to read of Dr. Kissinger's new com weeks, while President Echeverria, his rela here . . . The citizen has a right to rule mitments which threaten another spill tives and his friends, were enjoying them Mexico, but he has forgotten it ... It 1s ing of hard-earned dollars as gifts in selves abroad. in our hands to change things going bad ... still another area. In a few more days, the ruling bosses of When the State is being subverted by the The Secretary has done this country the official Institutional Revolutionary Party Socialists, it no long fulfills its mission and wlll let it be known who will be the next it is not granted the monopoly for vio no favor in basing our offers of friend president of Mexico, to replace Echeverria, lence ... The people do not then ha.ve any ship in Africa on grants and gifts. In if the country does not go through a politi other right against the abuses but theJr effect, this is seeking to buy good rela cal crisis similar to the ones in Chile, Peru own violence ... There is no other alterna tions with the peoples there rather than and Ecuador, or the ones expected in Argen tive ..." achieving them through a mutual under tina, Colombia, and Venezuela. It may hap This strong statement against the creep standing and respect. It is the old for pen that the Mexican Armed Forces wlll get ing leftist tendencies of the people ruling eign aid theory of a free-handed Uncle tired of the corruption, the inefficiency and Mexico is very important, especially a few Sam revived and I fear that it will not the whims of the pollticians in power. months before a presidential election 1n work any better for us in Africa than it But the most serious aspect of the Eche which the one-party system will try to oust verria adm1nistrat1on now coming to an end, demagogue Echeverria with Lopez-Portmo as did in Southeast Asia, or India, or in the is that it has brought about the worst eco his sure successor. The Mexican Agrarian other regions in which we have poured nomic crisis in the recent history of the Revolution has made many more leftist mil b1llions. country. The deterioration in the balance of lionaires 1n Mexico than the so-called In my mind, it is demeaning to the payments 1s alarming economists, politicians "cient11lcos" or scientists who surrounded 14180 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS May 17, 1976 dictator Porfirio Diaz and who did not dare formerly Colombian interest in the Panama ate agrees to a new treaty and we lose the to invent the permanent rule o! the Institu Railroad. Ms. Berger completely !ails to men sovereign rights that are now legally ours. tional Revolutionary Party, although they tion that our rights in the Zone were in !act were swept away by violence and had kept secured by a payment o! $10,000,000. This themselves in power by violence. may seem peanuts in comparison with what we are proposing, !or example, to pay Greece A DIALOG ON HOW GOVERNMENT and Turkey 73 years later !or bases to !acll1- HURTS ITSELF tate our protecting them !rom their Commu MISLEADING CANAL DEBATE nist neighbors, but it is not so trifling in comparison with the $7,000,000 we had paid HON. JACK F. KEMP to acquire Alaska--with an area approxi HON. DEL CLAWSON mately a thousand times greater than the OF NEW YORK IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES OF CALIFORNIA Zone-only 36 years before. Ms. Berger notes that "An American can Monday, May 17, 1976 IN THE HOUSE OP REPRESENTATIVES remain in the Canal Zone only as long as Monday, May 17, 1976 he or she is employed there" but she taUs Mr.~· Mr. Speaker, earlier today to note that the same is true of Panama I read mto the REcORD an informative Mr. DEL CLAWSON. Mr. Speaker, the nians. There is no oppressed indigenous pop article on government competition with Washington Post of Saturday, May 15, ulation in the Zone and substantially all the private sector, an article appearing in contains a column by Mr. John M. Cabot property in it belongs to the U.S. govern the May issue of the magazine, Govern which examines the major premises on ment. There are several other statements in ment Executive. both sides of the debate over U.S. policy Ms. Berger's article that seem to me argu able. A second article also appears in that concerning the Panama Canal. I com issue, entitled "A Dialog on How Gov mend the column to the attention of my I have not seen Gov. Reagan quoted as pointing out that the u.s. government un ernment Hurts Itself," authored by C. colleagues, particularly for the realistic doubtedly connived at the Panamanian coup W. Borklund, its publisher. view of international relations. that brought independence (despite Secre I commend this second article to the The column follows: tary Hay's denials); or that we assured the attention of my colleagues: success of the coup by an interpretation o! MisLEADING CANAL DEBATE A DIALOG oN How GoVERNMENT (By John M. Cabot) the 1846 treaty that even the Soviets might HURTS ITSELF blush with shame to defend; or that our In the past weeks I have noted various treaty With Panama was hastily signed, with (By C. W. Borklund) commentaries as well as several news stories a man who had a blatant conflict o! interest· Last May at the Spring meeting of CBEMA in The Post with regard to the Panama Canal or that it has been the arrogance of Amer: (Computer and Business Equipment Manu controversy. I certainly agree with The Post leans to the Panamanians in the Zone over facturers Association) member-company top that Gov. Reagan's reported statements are the years that has contributed importantly management, then-Administrator of the GSA misleading and unfortunate, though per to the present situation. I have not heard (General Services Administration) Art haps not "demagogic" by presidential cam much from the pro-new-treaty advocates Sampson proposed "an annual procurement paign standards. But I am bothered by the about the many concessions the Panama management review" between CBEMA and equally misleading statements made by The nians have won from us by throwing tan GSA. Post's columnists. trums, or how, when we sought the imple The conference he had in mtnd. "would One can perhaps dismiss Nicholas von mentation of the barely ratifled 1936 treaty focus on procurement techniques we use Hoffman's recent column as self-evidently provisions to secure sites outside the Zone and specific lessons learned in the preced tendentious (he, for example, mentions our !or its defense, they blackmailed us before ing year. It would be a conference researched many interventions in Panama before 1903 granting them; or how, after the war, they in advance and structured to provide GSA, without mentioning that under Article 35 of simply rejected a new treaty granting us their other users of your products in the Federal our treaty o! 1846 with New Granada (Col continued use despite the 1936 treaty; or Government and members of the industry, ombia) we had not only the right but also how every concession on our part only led to itselt, with direction for the year to come." the obligation to maintain freedom o! transit accelerating demands on theirs. One more specific he wanted to see: "Pro on the isthmus of Panama; that several of In this connection, although I agree with posals for new buying techniques. We can these interventions were at the specific re then examine those ideas to see if they make quest of the Colombian government, which most of The Post's editorial of May 5, it seems to me open to question in some of its sense for both industry and Government." could not itselt maintain freedom of transit, The first such conference was a one-day, and that others were understaken to tore points. It is certainly a legitimate question whether we want the canal closed and "frank talk" session held last October-hal! stall European intervention). But I am more the GSA/CBEMA teams concentrating on perturbed at Marllyn Berger's column on fought over if we reject a new treaty. But is it not a legitimate question what happens business equipment and otll.ce machines, the May 3 which, coming from a lady who you other hal! on computers, peripherals and say "was a diplomatic reporter for The Post, to "assuring continued free American transit through the canal" after the maximum related hardware/software systems. 1s NBC correspondent !or national affairs," WAKE UPS should be enlightening but is actually about treaty duration of 50 years? Previous hlstory as misleading as anything I have noted Gov. does not reassure me. And what has become Since this dialogue is designed for the long Reagan as saying. of the proposed sea level canal, which was haul, says CBEMA President Pete McCloskey to be built at vast expense to the United "We can bite off chewable parts of the totai Ms. Berger is right in arguing that we do States, presumably to be turned over to Pan problems." That alone tends to make the ar not have titular sovereignty to the Canal ama at the expiration of a new treaty? rangement unique among government-indus Zone. Then-Secretary of War Taft and In short, I think that the American peo try seminars which, says one observer of such many other responsible American otll.cials things, "usually consist o! a lot o! people have made the same point over the years. ple should be more fully and accurately in formed about this "vital and legitimate in spending one day a year making grand pro But I would like her to explain how she rec nouncements about •needs' and the rest ot onciles her statement that we do not "exercise terest." President Ford and Gov. Reagan and, with apologies, the American press the year doing 'business as stupidly usual.' .. sovereignty" in the Zone with Article m "We're not looking for any instant magic," of the treaty o! 1903, which says we have including The Post, have not given the American people a full and balanced picture sums up McCloskey. But for all the low-key "all the rights, powers and authority which approach, targets laid on last October the United States would possess and exercise of this most important and complicated question. I feel it is the press' duty to do so. amount to major goals to measure progress 1f it were the sovereign ... to the exclusion against this coming Fall. In the computer of the exercise by the Republic of Panama o! Perhaps this is the moment in history to give up the canal-and possibly it is not. arena alone, Government heard some eye any such sovereign rights, powers and au openers. Probably the strongest one: thority." TWenty-three years ago, when I was chief U.S. negotiator of what became the treaty "Because of Federal procurement and con That article has not been amended by of 1955, the question of giving up the canal tracting practices, the Federal inventory of either of the subsequent treaties of 1936 or was not even raised. Who knows what fur general purpose computers is some 70% ob 1955. The question before the American peo- ther demands will be made on us 23 years solescent compared to only 30% in private ple today is whether the old treaties, which hence? Nobody from the Third World seems industry." The reasons are several. Among give us sovereign rights to the Zone in per to be ra.ising questions about the vast terri them: petuity, shall be superseded by a new treaty tories the Soviets have seized and hold by Long procurement times--''Government gradually d1minish1ng those rights untU they force, because they know Communists don't can't even handle the purchase, not count are totally relinquished (as I understand tt) cede territory, and fear them. I agree with ing justtftcation-to-buy and system-need 1n a maximum o! 50 years. The Post that Gov. Reagan's jingoism is not analysis, in lese than two years normally." Nor does the $250,000 annual payment (in promoting a satisfactory settlement of this The sharpest contrast to this is among firms creased to 460,000 bolivares in 1986 not problem. I dread to think of what wm im in private industry who provide computer $500,000 as Ms. Berger incorrectly states) mediately follow 1t the Senate votes down a time-sharing services. provided by the 1908 treaty enter into the new treaty, but I must say I dread equally There, under competitive pressure, the equation. Historieally these payments were to think of the probable consequences, in latest state-of-the-art hardware and soft to be made in return !or our taking over the the light ot the historical record, 1t the Sen- ware is "bOUght. In addition, sensitivity to May 17, 1976 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 14181 customer demand is so strong that "If I Closkey, "why government needs so much since is not all that simple. There is, for need," some firms say, "I can add three main more protection than a commercial enterprise instance, "The Benchmark problem." In sim frame computers to my complex in a month." to perform in many cases the same or a sim plest terms, it amounts to the procuring Acquisition cost vs. end-user need-Fed Uar function." oftlce picking the best discount-off-list-price eral computer-system buyers have concen One-sidedness in commitments, agam plus offered from among qualified bidders; tell trated too greatly on cost avoidance, i.e. ini the long-lead times of system procurement, ing all other qualified firms "meet or beat tial purchase price plus attendant pressures has another onerous effect. Companies tend that and we'll consider your bid." for greater and greater company price dis to bid their "safest" systems, i.e. ones on That happens not just over discounts but counts and related auctioneering practices. which R&D is already written ofl. the equip on all other services one or the other bidder Far too little attention, says CBEMA, is ment is fully proven, and thUF the risk is may offer. This ..auction," like that in com g1 ven to the end user's real needs. In simpler the lowest. That not only means the Gov puters," carried on long enough wm destroy terms, they say in effect, there are many times ernment tends to be offered wha.t is already competition. when a Cadillac is better than a Chevrolet in outdated; but also it causes another abra In a related way, CBEMA has been push relation to an agency's overall mission perfor sion-in effect Government demanding the ing the message that GSA should recognize mance. But that, says the industry, is a poor latest state-of-the-art (again, because they in their procurements that some companies analogy. know it won't be "on-line" for st:veral years) do their own marketing and equipment sup and not getting it. port among customers; other firms use deal A better one is "start small and let the sys ers. "Do you recognize that the dealer pro tem grow," again with the agency computer Those are only highlights from among the user having "the whip hand" in the evolu 16 major procurement subjects first out vides a service which you expect the manu lined-on both the computer and business facturer to provide if you buy direct?" tion-just as he has in most private in And related to that in turn are some other dustry cases. (McCloskey even has suggested equipment sides--at last Fall's meeting and that GSA hold periodic meetings with in the subject of continuing GSA/CBEMA staff facts of the market which should dictate a dustry computer-users so Government could discussions since. Some of the others: fiexibUity in procurement practice and an learn that first-hand rather than just take A conviction in both CBEMA and GSA awareness in GSA of what the marketplace CBEMA's word for it.) that present GSA policy does not adequately supplier arrangements are. Examples, raised cover (nor consider it effectively in new bid more as questions at the moment: In short, final accounting for an agency's 1-Does the "guy who quotes F.O.B. des productivity rests with the head of the proposals) the many problems, including cost, that surface in conversion from one tination (which Government prefers) get agency. Yet, in ADP (automatic data pro credit in his bid price against the guy who cessing ) procurements, says CBEMA, "he gets ADP system to another; A need for guide lines to allow upgrading with minimum pro quotes F.O.B. factory?" jerked around by the ADP types" who empha 2-0n price reduction and price escalation size purchase "cost" rather than system "ef curement restrictions from a present to a. proposed ADP system; clauses, CBEMA says, in a word, "they're un fectiveness' in the agency when evaluating realistic." With the former, GSA requires proposals. The "inequlty"-philosophically another part of the "contract equal risk" problem they get the same price reduction granted Total new systems vs. augmentation-Bet "any customer" commercially by a manufac ter for the end-users, says industry, would be of Government refusing to make payments on leased equipment and software, and turer or dealer. Fact is, there can be one again, if Federal procurements were made on time, sound business reasons for a commer the basis of an initial buy with a plan for maintenance services, on Government owned equipment in the interim between when one cial price reduction, e.g. distressed line, in· system augmentation. What usually happens, ventory clearance, mistaken bUling, that a instead, is a constant reiteration of the re fiscal year's contract runs out and the con clusion of negotiation on the next year's; firm shouldn't be forced to live within on quirement with all the attendant delays in going contracts. re-competing a contract. A simplified solicitation document for In price escalation, GSA says, if an investi Ten years ago, when Government had 2400 maintenance of Government-owned ADP gation proves the contractor justified, GSA general purpose computers an4 40% of them equipment; Recommendations on use of will grant the increase. CBEMA doesn't want were owned by IBM, that push to generate remote terminal emulation in ADP procure that in the contract and besides that, thinks competition may have been justified, says one ment; the "inequitable and unsatisfactory" GSA should look at a possible increase when mM executive. But today, when no one man ways GSA uses mandatory requirements it is at about the 8% level (even if they ufacturer has more than "20% of the pie and contracts for ADP high technology/quantity don't grant it) rather than waiting untU the Government has some 8,000 computers," buying; they're in a "double-digit crisis." that acquisition exercise is no longer justi A CBEMA contention, re. Circular A-76 And for all these, and other government fied. which calls as a policy for Government re industry problems, "We're not saying the sys liance on private industry for goods and Government, in sum, faces a much more tem is all bad," says Henriquez; "Just that pressing problem. Every agency, Federal, services, that current implementing instruc it needs improving." And the main reason tions are too limiting. CBEMA, in short sup State and local Is short of funds to finance for that, in turn, says McCloskey, is that for programs. They have, points out McCloskey, ports "the present rationale of GSA F~deral Management Circular (FMC) 75 5 which all the problems, much 1s very good to indus one of three choices: "either cut programs, "euphasizes private vs. public (in-house) try about Government procurement in the increase taxes (both hard to do, especially in cost comparisons on the full range of alter CBEMA field. an election year), or increase agency pro natives offered by the private sector." ductivity." (Traditionally, Government does rely on How GOVERNMENT EXPORT POLICY PENALIZES High Cost to Bid-Besides driving down the the private sector for ADP equipment and INDUSTRY ••• AND GIVES No REWARDS IN sales price with "discount" demands, GSA associated maintenance but does not nor RETURN rules shoved into the bidding exercise have mally use industry for programming and U.S. Government policy and practices disoouraged competition. "Not only the "hard operation of the equipment. What is being which, in effect, prevent or at least delay dollar' elements such as system design, pro pushed is, basically, more reliance on indus export sales-often for six months to a year posal preparation, benchmarking (demon try for systems design, programming, data. are stimulating foreign buyers, especially in strating the system will do what the mission entry, training and operation.) Russia and the East European bloc, to create statement says is required) and acceptance their own technological and manufacturing test costs have gone up significantly," says INTO THE OFFICE capab111ty. McCloskey, "but also the time and effort to Over on the business equipment side, the This is evident in a host of areas-semi understand the procurement process and all chief benefit of last Fall's conference and the conductors, numerically (that is, computer) of its ramifications has become a very costly resultant dialogues is, in simplest terms, controlled machine tools, aerospace equip proposition." Government and the industry getting to ment of all kinds including commercial Result: a "considerable danger" that only know each other better. With both Sampson transports, computers and oftlce equipment. companies with large resources will be able and then-Federal Supply Service director In short, says CBEMA's Pete McCloskey, "We to compete. Related to that are terms and Mike Timbers leaving shortly after the first (the United States) create our own competi conditions that find their way into GSA ADP interchange took place, there was some spec tion." equipment-purchase contracts, including de ulation the whole communication-of-prob lems idea. might die right there. The most frustrating part of all this, to mands for multiple (as much as 5-7 years) the critics, is that the U.S. gains no meas commitments from industry to fulfill a con It has, says CBEMA's Vico Henriquez, been ureable benefit from this shortsightedness. tract if Government orders and re-orders. just the opposite. "The career staff people In fact, say the industrial representatives out Government, the other hand, insists on are 100% for it (these meetings and the in the world-market trenches, the very mo the right to cancel a competitively awarded dialogue. The change in leadership has made tives for stringent limits on export of high contract on 30 days written notice "and for no difference at the working level." technology products (national security, "the any reason;" plus multiple-year renewal op Moreover, "they're very competent people. national interest," et al) are harmed not tions on fixed price contracts at its choice. We haven't had a meeting yet where they helped, by this kind of economic "fortress CBEMA thinks a fairer "contract mutuality'' haven't really done their homework." In America." would be 1! contracts could be cancelled only itially, the GSA/FSS and CBEMA "shirt • Chief among the culprits, they say, 1s a tor lack of t'unds or because a requ1reznent sleeves" debaters 1denttfled "a lot of cripple- 'lack of clear statutory guidance and a re was no longer needed. crappie headaches." sultant dispersion of authority and differing .. I find it hard to understa.nd," says Me- But much of what they've gotten into departmental positions toward East-West 14182 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS May 17, 1976 trade." Moreover, in the complex inter-agency payments, in political and economic ties. for energy has greatly accentuated the bureaucracy which rules on, for instance, Moreover, by forcing potential customers to South's long-standing climatic advantage, export Itcense requests, there's a general lack build their own technology base, the U.S. does which permits lower plant construction and of both technical expertise and personnel not foreclose but actually encourages operating costs. continuity. The result is a review-and-ap strengthened military capability among po THE SEEDS OF HOSTILITY proval process which is not only financially tential adversaries-to the enent the two These economic factors, of course, are not punitive to the exporter but which actually are related at all. the whole story. However the underlying mo runs counter to the claimed Congressional But one of the largest threats the industry tivations are viewed, relatively generous intent of encouraging exports, at least as sees is that Government policy and practice, Northern assistance for the poor, public spelled out in the Export Administration Act in effect, threatens to take away U.S. world education, and job opportunities for blacks of 1969. leadership in fields it once pioneered. have combined powerfully with increased em Restricting exports which would make "a ployment opportunities for managers and significant contribution to the military po professionals in the South to produce an in tential of other nations" is not, they say, THE SECOND WAR BETWEEN THE terregional exchange of human capital that "difficult to understand." What is, they com STATES-PART II amounts to a multibillion-dollar Point Four plain, ts the abiUty granted the bureaucracy program of technical assistance. Although it to make export turn-down decisions based appears that there has been a marked de on an all-embracing rationale called the "na crease in the black outfiow to the North since tional interest"-which they point out, can HON. MICHAEL HARRINGTON OF MASSACHUSETTS 1970, this informal program continues in a cover not only national security but also the major sense: Those who migrate southward domestic and world economic situation, poli IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES tend to be above average in income and edu tics, the status of domestic employment/un Monday, May 17, 1976 cational level, while the thousands who con employment and even "unspecified sociolog tinue to fiow to the older industrial cities of ical and psychological factors." Mr. HARRINGTON. Mr. Speaker, to the Northeast and Midwest are below aver That phrase, "national interest," they day I am inserting the second of an eight age in these respects. This has placed an awe charge is in increasing use as the reason for part series concerning regional economic some burden on the already eroding tax base speciftc export license denials. Worse, say the development which appeared in the May of the North. critics, such "capricious and arbitrary deci Moreover, national economic recovery may sions" are, in effect forcing what would have 17, 1976 edition of Business Week. This particular segment deals with the reasons lead disadvantaged Southern blacks ancl been overseas customers to, instead, create whites to migrate as heavily as before. "As their own design and manufacturing capa behind the tremendous shift in U.S. pop the economy improves," says Harvard Univer b111ty and become competitors. ulation to the South in recent years and sity's John F. Kain, an economist and profes This is a special worry to CBEl\~-member also discusses the current Federal prac sor of city and regional planning, "the net companies. Last year, $13.8 billion of their tice of spending more in the faster-grow migration of blacks could shift back to the $32.7 billion in sales came from overseas; ing, fiscally potent sunbelt region than North. The slowdown in the last five years, from 30 to 50% of the members' total 621,000 say, is occurring because of the particularly payroll are employed because of exports. In in the stagnating industrialized North. The text of the second installment high unemployment in older industrial cities, the main, they want not only to maintain such as Cleveland. This is relatively tempo their share of foreign markets vis-a-vis for follows: rary." eign competitors "but also to gain a foothold WHY MIGRATION BECAME A FLOOD TmE Other experts maintain that the South's in new markets early in their development." There is always something mysterious economic advantages mean it will continue That also implies, of course, a multina about mass m igrations. Some causes of the to be the region of opportunity for bla.cka tional character for many CBEMA-member movement to the South and Southwest are as well as whites. NASPA's Campbell says: companies. Overseas affiliates, licensees and familiar: good climate, cheap land and labor, "When recovery intensifies, you'll get a fur even wholly owned subsidiaries, they long ago and the sheer availability of materials and ther pick-up in the South and Southwest. learned like virtually every other multi-na space. The exodus of Southern blacks appears to be tional, are the best-if not frequently the But what is mysterious is the sudden accel over for the foreseeable future. With regard only-way to capture foreign buyers. eration. Perhaps the most important factor to Puerto Ricans, however, the problems are Government insensitivity to the politico that seems to have been overlooked is that similar, and their infiow may resume once economics of the matter is not the industry's at some point around the late 1960s, South the Northeast shows signs of life." Thus the only complaint. Government naivete about ern growth achieved a critical mass, turning pressures on Northern cities will continue. U.S. technological superiority--or rather they orderly migration into a fiood tide. But this impact of the vast migration is say in fact the lack of it-is just as upset Growth became self-sustaining as the not the only aspect of public policy that ting. South's industrial base broadened and deep contains the seeds of interregional host1Uty. As the Russians have already demonstrated ened. This process, which amounts to "im An even more striking element, which is cer repeatedly, they and increasing numbers port substitution," will continue, and it is tain to lie at the center of the coming war of other nations on both sides of the Iron now clear that Northern leaders who mini between the states, is that the largest net Curtain have the technological capab111ty to mize manufacturing losses by promising eco :flows of federal spending continue to go to do anything they feel they must do, includ nomic vitality based on exportable business those regions that are growing the fastest ing and especially in the military field. services are whistling "Dixie." (chart, page 94). As Roy Bahl puts tt, "The On at least two counts, the industry faults The emergence of a large population of Northeast is not getting federal assistance, the Pentagon as one of the main obstacles financially independent retirees and profes and in the Southeast and Southwest, where to speedy granting of export licenses: sional people was also an important stimulus. they have no fiscal problems at all, it's fiow U.S. mllltary top management "would The maturing of both federal and private ing right tn." never buy its computer needs from a poten pension plans is perhaps the major factor This pattern was readily justified when the tial enemy," they say, "because that would underlying this groups migration toward South stlll lagged behind other regions. Fur make the U.S. dependent on them for spare warmer climates and the countryside. thermore, there is an underlying logic that parts, servicing, etc. Why can't they give the The Impact of good agricultural conditions draws major federal projects toward useless Russians credit for feeling the same way?" combined with the end of the draft to give land. Huge irrigation projects and dams, They see a marked inconsistency "in deny the South an extra push relative to the North. highway systems, navigable rivers ancl ing moderately advanced computers to the People stay on the farm when agricultural canals-projects that defy the profit calculus USSR, Eastern Europe and the People's Re prices are favorable. The rise of farm prices of the private sector-have always lured fed publlc of China and at the same time (the in the early 1970s thus cut sharply into a eral bureaucrats and engineers to backwater Pentagon, itself) actively exporting weapons traditional Northeastern source of inmigra bayous and vast open places. But the con systems containing highly sophisticated com tion. Furthermore, the end of the mllltary sequences of this tradition have drawn the puters to nations whose long-term allegiance draft reduced the tendency of farm youths to ire of the Joint Economic Committee. In its to the U.S. is questionable; and where such return to cities visited while in uniform. 1976 report, the committee notes: "In recent technology is highly susceptible to uncon The energy crunch also had a major im years the largest increases in direct federal trolled leakage." pact on business relocation. In the late 1960s, employment have occurred in precisely those Moreover, they add, the U.S. would have to supplies of natural gas for interstate ship regions that are experiencing the greatest increase immensely its export of general pur ment were sharply reduced because of the private sector growth. Federal nonmilitary pose computers (which are also available unrealistically low prices set by the Federal payrolls as a percentage of nonfarm income from several other developed nations) and Power Commission. To obtain adequate sup are often three to four times higher in grow "they would have to be of the very latest plies, many companies found it necessary to ing states than in stable or declining states. state-of-the-art" before they would make a locate in energy-rich areas and buy unregu Many of these expenditures could be shifted significant contribution of any kind "to a lated intrastate gas. Although pressures are to high unemployment areas." peaceful potential enemy." mounting for deregulation, the availability Moreover, these projects no longer require Thus, by denying or delaying (to the point of gas continues to provide Louisiana, Ala large inputs from Northern industry. "Years of the company losing the overseas sale) in bama, and many other Southern states with ago," Bahl says, "when the federal govern dustry export license requests, the U.S. Gov a strong locational advantage. In addition, ment made disbursements for big projects, ernment costs the U.S. in jobs, in balance-of- the explosive rise in the over-all price level there were major leakages-TVA, for in· May 17, 1976 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 14183 stance, generated a considerable volume of Strong agricultural earnings of such States energy prices have generated enormous wind contracts for the Middle Atlantic states. Now as Wisconsin have provided an offset, but the falls for coal and oil producers and the that the South is relatively self-sufficient, empty factories and fiscal hardships of such governments that tax them. According to a those leakages no longer occur." Further dis cities as Cleveland and South Bend bear wit staff report of the JEC, 80% of the tax in tortions of federal effort arise from regional ness to the uneven grace of federal activism creases posted by energy states in 1975 were differences in the cost of living. "The cate (page 97). based on higher coal and oil levies, and the gorical grants tend to be directed toward Northwest-Central (Plains plus 13 energy-rich states account for more than lower-income states," Bahl adds. "Now if you Rocky Mountain) 70% of the combined surpluses of all 50 don't correct for differences in living costs, state governments. it looks as though the Southern regions are Right now, forecasting the future growth trends of this area is something like track Federal defense outlays have also worked still the lower, so they continue to get most powerfully to offset the region's homegrown of the money." ing one of Colorado's bighorns up the side of a glacier on a snowy night. The eight Rocky educational shortcomings. "The acquisition THE WINNERS AND THE LOSERS Mountain states stand out both for their of knowhow, both from the standpoint of Although data on the regional distribution No.1 position in terms of net federal outlays mobility of Northern management and labor of the total federal impact (chart, page 94) and for breakneck rates of growth from a and improvement occurring within the South are of recent vintage, the sense that there 1s very shall base. On the other hand, despite itself, is a key factor," says economist Elsie a chronic imbalance has been growing for this growth, the region has fewer than 300,- Watters of the Tax Foundation. "And this 1s some time. Aside from the highly visible 000 factory hands. The BEA's Bretzfeider the kind of advantage that can snowball." incidence of federal employees--more than identifies energy projects and associated con The South is on its way to virtual self-suffi half of them civilian and of such projects struction as the major nonfederal source of ciency in education, as well as business out as the Tennessee Va.lley Authority, the Ar growth, and many of the region's residents put. kansas River project, Cape Canaveral in show no interest in matching the South's Florida, the Redstone Arsenal in Huntsvllle, open-door industrial policy. NASPA Presi Ala., and the Lyndon B. Johnson Space Cen dent Campbell recalls a recent speaking en RESOLUTION TO APPROPRIATE $25 ter in Houston, there is the evidence of the gagement in Denver wistfully. "There were a MILLION FOR HUMANITARIAN AS regional economic growth differentials them lot of complaints about growth," he says. selves. Looking at growth in these regions, SISTANCE TO THE VICTIMS OF "I said, if you don't like growth, you should THE EARTHQUAKE-RAVAGED NA the high degree of association between net come back East and try decline for a while." federal benefit and faster growth becomes Plains population has grown at only about TION OF ITALY manifest: half the national rate since 1950 but the The Northeast region has staked out a solid inducement HON. EDWARD I. KOCH for manufacturers. Says economist Clyde To some extent the victim of its earlier OF NEW YORK prosperity, this area (New England and Mid Hartz, of Schlage Lock Co.: "The Bible Belt east) is singled out by experts as the most of the Plains states is the place of be if you IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES severely affected by the South's steamroller want very productive labor, conservatism, Monday, May 17, 1976 drive toward self-sufficiency. Says Bahl: "The and a good place to raise your family." Northeast is overdeveloped relative to its Spending has also benefited enormously Mr. KOCH. Mr. Speaker, Senator John future role. The reason they had the central from the virtual doubling in farm income Marchi of Staten Island, who is a dis office, for instance, was agglomeration, the levels that began in 1972. On the other hand, tinguished member of the New York need to be near other businesses. But that only Missouri has a population density equal State Legislature and chairman of it.s is disappearing in two ways-firms can de to the national average, so local markets are Senate Finance Committee, has accept centralize to other regions, or they can move stlll small. ed the cochairmanship of the Italian Re to the suburbs. Transportation and com The Far West munications changes have played an impor lief Committee of Famee Furlane of This region is decelerating, and its per North America, Inc., which is an organi tant role. New York is stlll a fine deepwater capita income is Virtually the same as the port, for instance, but that's no longer so Northeast's. Nonetheless, the consequence zation of American citizens having close important. This part of the situation is going will not be so visible, for this area never ties to Italy. The Senator introduced on to continue." developed greatly as a service center for May 10, 1976, a resolution which cites In short, changes that new highways, air other regions. Climatic advantages and a the high death toll, the high number of ports, pipelines, canals and communications heavy infusion of federal funds provide it injured, and the extraordinary destruc have wrought in the calculus of locational with a growth cushion not enjoyed by the tion and damage inflicted on homes and strategy mean that it wlll gradually be Northeast or the Great Lakes area. Further stripped of many of the "export" functions property as a result of the recent earth more, most of its cities have been shaped quake in Italy. Those who would like to it once sold to other regions, including both largely by the single-family construction, manufactured goods and business services. highways, and private automotive transpor assist in aiding the Italian quake victims At this point the region's most conspicuous tation that have predominated in the newer should be in touch with the Italian Re harbinger is perhaps the incredible magni growth regions. lief Committee of Fam.ee Furlane of tude of the negatives. As Alvin L. Erlich, North America, Inc., at 7316 Roosevelt president of the Ward-Johnston subsidiary Already, however, many parts of this region have equaled or exceeded Northeastern cost Avenue, Jackson Heights, Queens, N.Y. of Chicago's Ward Foods, sees it: "I don't 11372. The telephone number of that think people are going to uproot in those levels for both labor and land, environmental kinds of dimensions. What do you do? Dupli constraints are critical, and some firms are organization is (212) 651-2431. cate the whole city of New York? Somewhere beginning to move out. Bethlehem Steel The resolution, which I endorse whole along the way the economics are going to Corp. is selling an 800,000 sq.-ft. fac111ty in heartedly and urge upon the Congress. be such that you do not move." Richmond, Calif., and other companies, such follows: as Hewlett-Packard, National Semiconductor, The view that so populous a region cannot RESOLUTION INTRODUCED IN THE NEW YORK slide forever is also advanced by BEA econ and Schlage Lock, have tilted expansion STATE SENATE programs toward the Plains, Rocky, and omist Robert Bretzfelder. "It's dtmcult to Whereas, the United States of America ha& picture the economy getting anywhere near Southern regions. But agriculture-food pro cessing, still California's largest sector, is never hesitated to lend help to the people full employment,'' he says, "without New of nations hit by natural disaster, such as York and the other industrial states growing strong, electronics has spurted because of new consumer and industrial applications, Yugoslavia and Guatemala; and, more than they did during 1969-73, even Whereas, the United States is specially before the recession hit them." and California is slated for the prime con tract on the B-1 bomber. bound by historic, cultural and family ties The Great Lakes to Italy; and The South In this region, which shows the highest Whereas, at a time when Italy 1s under Both regions (Southeast plus Southwest) severe economic and social pressures, it 1s per capita rate of net outpayments to the are richly endowed with land, minerals, federal government (chart, page 94), manu important that the United States do what facturing is stlll the king, queen, and court energy, and net federal outlays. Vincent ever it properly can do to help shore up of the economy, accounting for nearly 50% Barabba, director of the U.S. Census Bureau, democratic institutions there; and of all private wage and salary payments. But emphasizes changes in transportation. "One Whereas, the U.S. Agency for Interna employment in this vital "export" sector of the major reasons !or the shift to net tional Development has already made $353,- slipped by 8% from 1970 to 1975, and popula lmmigratlon 1n the South and net outmtgra. 000 avaUable for the Ita.lla.n victims; and tion, which rose at the national rate during tion in the Northeast has been the nation's Whereas, the U.S. made $25 million avaU the 1950s, has plummeted to 89% of the rellance on truck transportation," he says. able for rellef in the Guatemalan earth national average since 1970. Like the North "Massive highway construction in the 19505 quake, east, this region is lagging behind the BEA's and 1960s opened up many parts of the South Now, therefore, be it est1m.ates as lts "overdeveloped" heavy manu to manufacturing plants." Resolved, That the Legislature of the facturing sector continues a m.igratlon In sharp contrast to the rest of the nation, State of New York memorialize the Congress toward southern markets and raw ma.terlaJS. state cotiers are overtlowtng here, since of the United States to appropriate $25 mil- 14184 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS May 17, 1976 Uon !or humanitarian assistance to the vic Congress for leaking classltied Information, prerogatives of a supposedly coequal branch tims of the earthquake ravaged nation of we may never know the facts. In any case, of government. It is appall1ng that Congress Italy and to approve all other measures as the admlnlstration's political purpose was would accept the proposition that it had to may be appropriate to assist the Italian peo served. prove itself worthy before It could receive ple in their time of ordeal. It is my view that in all probabllity there and use on an equal basis information classi was no conspiracy to discredit and thwart fied by the executive branch. And yet a. few Congress, and that the failure of Congress in days after being named chairman of the this instance reflects a deeper and more Senate committee, Senator Church an CONGRESSMAN MICHAEL HARRING troubling institutional failure. It would be nounced that any member of the staff who more comforting to assume a conspiracy or leaked would be fired; the CIA was permitted TON COMMENTS ON THE CON covert action by the executive, because the to come to the Senate to approve the security GRESSIONAL INVESTIGATIONS OF culprits might then be discovered and pun mechanisms and "debug" the premises; and THE INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY ished, and our faith in institutions would the CIA stlll refused to allow much of the remain intact. It is a time-honored credo of most sensitive material to be physically the American political tradition that fatiure transmitted to the Congress, after requiring HON. BELLA S. ABZUG and adversity are the result of corruption the investigative staff to work a.t the agency. OF NEW YORK and malfeasance on the part of individuals Perhaps the most damaging institutional IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES or small groups. Thus the Nye investigation feature of the investigations was the estab into the causes of World War I pointed to lishment of deadlines for their completion. Monday, May 17, 1976 the venality of the munitions makers, and Even though the cutoff dates, especially in thus McCarthy sought the causes of the cold Ms. MICHAEL the Senate, were extended, the message was ABZUG. Mr. Speaker, war in the disloyalty and weaknesses of State HARRINGTON, our able and articulate col conveyed at the outset that there was a dead Department and armed services personnel. line. In such a. situation even the most league from Massachusetts, has published It would, however, be a dreadful error to simple-minded adversary would adopt a in-the current issue of the Nation an arti explain the failures of the Congressional in strategy of delay, and that Is precisely what cle on the congressional investigations of telligence investigations--or indeed the mis the administration did to great effect. Instead the U.S. intelligence community. The deeds of the intelllgence agencies-by con of putting the executive on notice that the piece is well worth reading, and I include spiracy theories or individual acts of irre investigations would be concluded when Con sponsibll1ty. The problems are institutional, gress was satisfied with the results, the com its text in the RECORD: fundamental to the functioning of the fed [From the Nation, May 22, 1976] mittees were in the position of having to ex eral government. The CIA is the limiting plain to their parent bodies why they had CONGRESS BOOTS THE CIA PROBES case-the most extreme instance-in which not met the original deadlines and to re (By Representative MicHAEL J. HARRINGTON) exposure would discredit not individuals but quest new ones. WABHINGTON.-The extraordinary failure of an institutional process, undermining confi dence in the agencies and the assumptions A third institutional dlfiiculty was com the Congressional investigations of the Intel mittee staffs. In the House the staff was too ligence agencies to produce reform--or even of the entire national security establishment. Thus, at least in the administration's view, small for the task: thirty-three In all. The an enhanced public awareness of the prob Senate committee had the opposite problem: lems-is a striking political victory for the the disclosure of abuses would not reassure the people about the ability of the system to a. staff of 133 persons who, according to press national security establishment and its a.llies. reports, did not always pull in the same di The victory Is the more striking because the cleanse itself. Instead of reaffirming the le gitimacy of the government's authority, it rection. The result, on the Senate side, is that political professionals on the Hlll were out large quantities of staff reports remain classi smarted, outpollticked, and finally routed by might seriously undermine it. Regrettably, this point of view was also ac fied and unabsorbed by the political process. the technocrats and bureaucrats at the other cepted in grea. t measure by the Congressional The House staff has become the object of a.n end of Pennsylvania Avenue. committees running the investigations. From internal House Investigation to determine The rout comes on the heels of a year's the outset great pa.lns were taken to dem who leaked the final report to Daniel Schorr, celebration of the resurgence of Congres onstrate that Congress was "responsible," a clear warning to those in the future who sional power and authority, following the war that House and senate were worthy of being may feel that disclosure serves a public pur In Vietnam, Watergate and impeachment. admitted into the secret chambers of the pose. Our resurgence in the area of foreign affairs executive branch. As a. result, the Congres The political consequences of the con was especially well advertised and supposedly sional investigations were on the defensive straints placed on the investigations have embodied In such statutes as the War Pow from the beginning and never seized the of been simply disastrous. The most costly re ers Act, the Commitments Resolution and fensive. When the Senate Select Committee sult was the failure of either committee to the prohibitions on use of force in Southeast on Intelligence began its investigation of hold coherent and sustained public hearings. Asia. CIA assassination plots, it decided to pro That public education is a major function of Four and a half months after the resigna ceed exclusively in secret, thereby abdicating Congress was demonstrated beyond any doubt tion of President Nixon, the Congress voted. its responsibll1ty to show the American pub by the Senate Watergate hearings in the to Investigate the inner sanctum of the na lic that an agency responsible for misdeeds summer of 1973. While the CIA Investigations tional security establishment, the intel of that magnitude could be called to public were not entirely analogous to the Watergate ligence agencies, and thus ra.lsed hopes for account. Senator Church argued that he did affair, the need for public education was in the urgently needed restructuring of the not want to "hold up this sordid story before some ways even more pressing. The war in cold-war apparatus and its surrounding the world." Then, after the senate commit Vietnam had provided conclusive evidence mythology. Now, fifteen months later, we tee had spent five months investigating as that the judgment of the executive branch have, If anything, turned the clock back. sassinations behind closed doors, the Presi about threats to national security was ca The House Intelligence Committee disbanded dent made a. predictable appeal to suppress lamitously :flawed. In the wake of that ex 1n disarray after Its final report was pub the committee's written report on the sub perience, Watergate gave proof that a. Presi lished In The Vlllage Voice, and no new ject, and Church complained that "conceal dent could exploit the national security my~ oversight or reform legislation has even ment is the order of the day." Fortunately, thology for explicitly partisan political pur been contemplated in the House. The trau the senate did vote to release the report, but poses. We now know that the misuse of the matic effects of the Voice leak and the the precedent had been established that the FBI for political purposes started with kUling of Athens CIA Statton Chief Richard imperatives of secrecy in the interest of na Franklin Roosevelt, and that paranoia about Welch have taken their toll also In the tional security could determine the mode of opposition to the war in Vietnam drew the Senate, where at this writing there seems Congressional procedure. At least that, it was CIA into domestic polltices. The need In 1975 little or no chance to establish a meaningful clear, would not be changed. was to define the proper and constitutional oversight committee--something that a year Publication of the assassination report limits of what could be done in the name of ago was regarded as the bare m1n1mum of re alone should have been convincing evidence national security, beginning 1n the obvious form to be expected from the investigations. that our institutions had badly malfunc place: the 1ntell1gence agencies. It is tempting to conclude that Congress tioned. Instead of driving home that point, The House Intelllgence Committee gets has been subverted by the same forces that the opposite Impression was conveyed, even better marks on this score than does the subverted Salvador Allende and Martin by such respected liberals as Senator Mon Senate, although the House committee failed Luther King-that in effect the intelllgence da.le, who concluded: "We're not any good a.t to sustain a thorough examination of the agencies mounted a covert action against the assassinations, and thank God!" In other basic issues. The Senate committee did not Congress to discredit its public lma.ge, m.a.ln words, although we cannot drag our spies out commence its hearings untll September, when ly by leaking ln!ormation to the press and into public view to account for their mis the issue's momentum ha.d considera-bly di then blaming it on the Congressional investi deeds, we can be reassured that they are good minished. And then, inexpllcably, the Senate gators. Naturally there were leaks, and al old incompetent American spies who are bad chose to begin with lengthy hearings on the though their source has not been established, at what they do because they are Americans, CIA's retention of shellfish toxin against the the a.dminlstra.tion has created the strong and are therefore harmless. wishes of the President. The boredom of these impression that they came from Congress. The acceptance by Congress of the execu hearings caused the networks, and even pub Whtie a case ca.n be made that the adminis tive's ground rules for secrecy and security lic TV, to take the Church committee off the tration ha.d a stronger motivation than did was a.n early and ominous concession of the a.lr. Thus, when a. few hours of hea.rtngs were May 17, 1976 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 14185 finally held in November on covert action excesses. My point is that Congress must CHESS AS THE ELECTRIC UTILITY and CIA meddling in Chile, they went un share a large part of the blame for the fall INDUSTRY'S PAWN broadcast and largely ignored. ure to reform the intelllgence agencies. To We are now paying the price for the failure say that we were tricked by the clever pro to hold informative hearings, because the fessionals of the CIA, who cannot shoot field of battle for access to the public mind straight in Havana, but can run circles HON. HENRY A. WAXMAN was left to the administration. Now that the around two Congressional committees, is to OF CALIFORNIA sole legislative product of the investigations, miss that point. In the face of the admin a bill to set up an intelligence oversight com istration's pro-secrecy onslaught, the Con IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES mittee in the Senate, is in deep trouble, gress could have defended itself only by mak Monday, May 17, 1976 there is no informed public, no constituency, ing a specific and compelling case for the from which to draw support for even modest misdeeds of the intell1gence agencies. In Mr. WAXMAN. Mr. Speaker, On reforms of the status quo. other words, maximum possible disclosure is April9, the Commerce SUbcommittee on While the Congress was defensively trying the only antidote to the complaints about Health and Environment and the Science to prove to the executive branch that it was leaks. Disclosure would show the public that Subcommittee on Environment and the a trustworthy and reliable partner in n& much of what is classified is either trivial or Atmosphere held a day-long joint hear tional security and tntelllgence policy, the a concealment of inefficiency and ineffective ing on the controversy which has flared administration had no intention of being ness; whereas the misdeeds were real, in some converted. Instead it sk.lllfully exploited Con cases crtm1nal, and in many cases violations over the validity of EPA's CHESS studies. gress' defensive position. The theme of the of our most fundamental political beliefs. The CHESS program is a series of studies administration's strategy was that the execu As it is, no individuals who may have com designed to measure and evaluate the tive branch should regulate itself and the mitted criminal acts in the name of national impact of air pollution on human health. most effective way to make a persuasive security have been indicted by the Justice These studies have been an invaluable public case for self-regulation was to repre Department, although no one disputes that source of information on the relationship sent Congress as inherently irresponsible, crtmlnal acts were committed. The apparent between sulfur orides and their deriva particularly in safeguarding classified in perjury of admlnlstra.tion officials before tive, sulfates, and the aggravation of in formation. The first move seems to have been Congressional committees is not being pur to avert a Congressional investigation alto sued by the Justice Department or the Con cidences of heart and lung diseases a,nd gether by creating the impression of execu gress. And the body politic is still disturbed other impairments of our physiological tive self-regulation. Thus President Ford by some of the questions left unanswered by functions. responded to the sensational disclosures of the investigations, not the least of which is On February 29, the Los Angeles Times CIA domestic spying by appointing the the apparent CIA cover-up of anti-Castro published a lengthy article which alleged Rockefeller Commission to investigate. Di assassination plots at the time of the Warren that Dr. John F. Finklea, who directed rector Colby acknowledged to the Senate Commission's deliberations. the CHESS program in 1972, deliberately Armed Services Committee that the CIA was In all likelihood it w1ll be another genera indeed gull ty of wrongdoing in this area.. tion before an opportunity recurs to address distorted scientific data in order to estab When word of the CIA assassination plots the important issues of intelligence and lish a stronger link between low levels of reached the press, that subject was added to national security. Only by a truly objective pollution and adverse health effects than the mandate of the Rockefeller Commission. understanding of what took place this past might be justified by the evidence. Even The climax of the self-regulation strategy year will we be in a position to take advan though EPA did not rely on the CHESS was the President's Executive Order of tage of whatever opportunities are afforded studies in formulating its pollution con February 18, 1976, purporting to carry out an in the future. And that objectivity w1ll be trol strategies, the electric utility in adequate internal reform of the intelligence hard to achieve if the blanket of secrecy and agencies, and thus relieving Congress of concealment is allowed to suffocate the dem dustry seized on these charges in an at the task. No committee of Congress even ocratic processes of a free people. tempt to discredit congressional and held hearings on the Executtve Order. regulatory efforts to require continuous The crucial event in the administration's reduction of sulfur emissions. campaign was the handling of the k1lling of As the Clean Air Act will be debated in Athens CIA Station Chief Welch in December WE ALL HAVE STORIES TO TELL the House within the next several weeks, 1975. David Phillips, founder of the Associa it is of crucial importance to resolve this tion of Retired Intelligence omcers, attacked controversy to the greatest extent pos those who were "unnecessa.rily exposing in HON. CHARLES E. GRASSLEY telligence operators," and Welch was burled sible. At stake is not only the reputation as a national hero after the plane bearing OF IOWA of Dr. Finklea but, by inference, the his body was kept in a holding pattern over IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES credibility of EPA's research program. Andrews Air Force Base so that its arrival Monday, May 17, 1976 At our April 9 hearings, witness after could be covered Uve on morning network witness refuted the allegations contained news programs. In short, the a.dmlnistration Mr. GRASSLEY. Mr. Speaker, it is my in the Los Angeles Times article. Not one seized on this tragic event to launch a publtc pleasure today to mention the recent scientist who was directly connected relations blitz against all disclosure of in publication of an unusual and charming with the CHESS study could contradict formation about intelUgence activities. Mem boOk, "We All Have Stories To Tell." It bers of Congress, at home for the Christmas the study's conclusions or document the recess, quickly got the word from their has come to my attention because the charges which have been leveled against constituents; no more exposure of CIA editor was formerly a constituent of the Dr. Finklea. Except for the presentation activities. Third District of Iowa, now residing in by the electric utility industry, no one Self-regulation by the executive depends the congressional district of our col testified that the current sulfur dioxide on nonregulation by a complacent Congress. league RoBERT GIAIMO, of Connecticut. air quality standards are not justified by It is precisely the discredited mechanisms of This is an unusual book because the the vast amounts of scientific and health past oversight that are now being preserved 15 authors are a group of senior citizens, for the next generation. The quality of the data available. Indeed, some voiced con traditional pattern of oversight was revealed none of whom had written in any formal cern that the standards may not be 1n a CIA memorandum of February 1978, sense before. They came together for a stringent enough-that there may not dealing with the CIA's strategy to cope with course in writing offered by the Creative exist threshold levels below which no the Senate investigation of the ITT-ciA Arts Workshop in New Haven, Conn., and adverse health etiects occur. Chile affair. The memo, as stated in the financed by a grant from the Connecticut Although the hearing uncovered a House committee report, suggested that Sen. Commission on the Arts. This course was broad consensus on the validity of the Henry Jackson, long a member of the Senate anything but busy work. It was a serious CHESS study's conclusions and the Armed Services CIA Oversight Subcommittee, workshop taught by a gifted teacher and propriety of Dr. Finklea's conduct, help take the rrr investigation away from Senator Church's Multinational Corporations professional writer. The result is a book clearly more research on the effects of Subcommittee: "Senator Jackson repeatedly of short pieces, largely reminiscence, that air pollution on health needs to be un made the comment that ln his view the CIA brings to life a whole new source of de dertaken. An understanding of the proc Oversight Subcommittee had the responsi light and interest for us all. I want to ess by which sulfur oxides are trans bility of protecting the agency in the type congratulate the New Haven group for formed into highly toxic sulfates re of situation that was inherent in the Church an innovative and worthwhile program mains elusive, and needs to be more subcommittee. As a result of this conviction, and to recommend it to you all and fully explored. I believe we should also Senator Jackson would work with the agency to see that we got this protection." especially my colleagues on the Commit carefully evaluate whether EPA's re It is not m.y view that tlhe purpose of Con tee on Aging as an important cultural search and regulatory functions should gressional oversight is to protect any federal contribution that could be made by senior be more clearly separated, so that the agency from the exposure of its abuses and citizens in all parts of our country. integrity of the factfinding and decision- 14186 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS May 17, 1976 making processes can be better pro Almost immediately the article became a Research Institute, an arm of the electric tected. political factor. Representatives of the coal utillty industry, handled the issue with kid An excellent summary of the contro industry, the electric ut111ties, and other pur gloves. Greenfield said he had "a professional versy to date was published in the April veyors of sulfur pollutants began clamoring or technical disagreement" with the CHESS for a moratorium on new clean air legislation monograph, but no reason to believe that 23 issue of Science. I urge all my col until the charges could be examined. Faced Finklea had distorted the data or analyses leagues who have been concerned over with moun tlng pressure on the eve of con (though he acknowledged that he didn't this issue to review the attached article: gressional consideration of amendments to really know for certain). Greenfield was SULFUR PoLLUTION: CHARGES THAT EPA the Clean Air Act, two House committees forced to explain to skeptical congressmen DISTORTED THE DATA ARE ExAMINED the subcommittee on environment and how it was that, when he wore his EPA hat, (By Philip M. Boffey) health, chaired by Representative Paul G. he endorsed the CHESS report and praised The charges were very serious-they im Rogers (D-Fla.), and the subcommittee on it lavishly, yet now that he's carrying the pugned the professional integrity of a fast the environment and the atmosphere, spear for the utillties, he's finding fault with rising government health official and the chaired by Representative George E. Brown, CHESS. Part of his answer was that he has validity of a government antipollution pro Jr. (D-Calif.)-held a joint hearing on 9 been examining the raw data from subse gram. April to receive testimony on the charges and quent years of CHESS and believes it contra On 29 February the Los Angeles Times their implications. It was a marathon session dicts some of the initial findings. When published a story asserting that a former re involving more than 20 witnesses, including pressed, he said he has seen nothing in the search adm1n1strator at the Environmental some who were expected to be friendly to data that would undercut the current federal Protection Agency (EPA) deliberately dis Finklea and some who were deemed hostile. standard for sulfur dioxide, but he expressed torted research reports "in an effort to prove But by the end of the day, Finklea, a hard doubts that sulfates are as hazardous as the that pollution from sulfur-bearing fuels had driving type who seems to have made a few CHESS monograph indicated. (The federal an adverse effect on human health." enemies on his way up the executive ladder, government has not yet promulgated a sul The investigative article, written by re had been showered with flattering testi fate standard but several states have.) For porter W. B. Rood, pointed the finger at John monials to his integrity and competence the most part, Greenfield was unwtlllng to F. Finklea, currently director of the National while several witnesses threw darts at the get very specific about his differences with Institute for Occupational Safety and Health L.A. Times. CHESS pending completion of an analysts but previously the head of EPA's Human Congressional staffers say they had some by his new firm of the raw data from several Studies Laboratory in North Carolina. In his difficulty finding witnesses to criticize Fink years of CHESS. That, he explained, might former capacity Finklea was a key figure lea's handling of CHESS, since few critics take a year or two. in managing the EPA program known as have surfaced publicly. The scientist who While the attack on Finklea largely failed CHESS (Community Health and Environ seemed most critical in quotes attributed by to materialize, a battalion of witnesses from mental Surveillance System), a series of the L.A. Times-Harv·ard's George B. Hut EPA-ranging from agency director Russell epidemiological studies in communities chinson--declined to appear, according to Train down to the foot soldiers who had around the country aimed at determining staffers. worked on the CHESS report--marched into the health effects of exposure to relatively Among those who did appear, the most the fray to defend both Finklea and the pro low levels of pollutants. The program was critical by far was Robert W. Buechley, an gram against what one called "publlc char designed to evaluate whether existing air epidemiologist at the University of New Mex acter assassination" in a "sensational arti quality standards are adequate, to obtain ico's Cancer Rooearch and Treatment Cen cle." The thrust of their combined testi data for new standards that might be needed, ter who served at EPA during the time the mony was that: and to document any health benefits that CHESS monograph was prepared. Buechley, Finklea did indeed revise, or require the might result from controlling air pollution. who was not Interviewed for the L.A. Times original authors to revise, some of the papers In the spring and summer of 1972, Finklea article, nevertheless echoed its charges. He that went into the monograph. This was was in charge of preparing the early drafts claimed that "promises were made" by partly to establish uniformity in data pres of a monograph analyzing data from the first CHESS leaders "that specific scientific find entation and partly because some of the first year of the CHESS program, 1970-71. That ings would be forthcoming to incrlminate drafts contained incomplete analyses. monograph, which was eventually published those pollutants for which regulations were In the process, there were instances where in 1974, purported to find that sulfur pol being written ... ill-done studies were then Finklea left out qualifying statements, but lutants (notably sulfur dioxide and sus written up as if they did, in fact, incriminate this does not appear to have been systematic pended sulfates) were associated with a the desired pollutant." But Buechley ac and there 1s no evidence he sought to distort variety of adverse health effects, including knowledged that he did not work on CHESS the data. aggravation of asthma and heart and lung himself, he merely worked alongside the Some of the original authors were unhappy disease in the elderly. CHESS scientists and heard their gripes. at the time with Finklea's editorial changes, The L.A. Times reported tha.t "extensive When pressed, he said he could not document and their unhappiness wa:; exacerbated by interviews" with government and nongov his charges and was unwilling to be more pressure to meet short deadlines as Finklea ernment scientists and others had disclosed specific about the alleged wrongdoing. lashed his troops to complete the project. that, 1n preparing this monograph: Another witness who had seemed critical (The L.A. Times described "lasting scars" on "Dr. John F. Finklea rewrote the work of scientists whose marriages were broken, agency scientists, often deleting what the when quoted in the L.A. Times-Ian P. T. Higgins, professor of epidemiology at the whose careers were threatened, or who be· researchers felt were important qualifiers on came "psychotic" under the pressure.) experimental results; University of Michigan-took a more equiv "Ftnklea deleted material from the reports ocal position in testimony. On the one hand, The complaints of the original authors, that did not show a connection between sul he asserted again that CHESS data "have and much of the criticism by other scientists fur pollution and adverse health effects; sometimes been overinterpreted" in the sense cited in the L. A. Times article as well, were that "insu11lcient weight has been given to directed at a draft of the monograph pre "Finklea screened statistical analyses to inconsistencies in the findings." This poses pared by Finklea. Subsequently Finklea was downplay evidence tending to weaken or con the danger, he said, "that conclusions might promoted to another post in EPA, the draft tradict the case against pollution; and be drawn that significant effects on health are was widely circulated for review and criti "Finklea overrode agency scientists' objec produced by lower levels of pollution than cism, and it was revised by Finklea's succes tions to publishing estimates of the health are justlfied by the evidence"; thus "unneces sors before final publication. The reviewers' impact of pollution which were either statis sary, costly attempts at further reduction in comments were no more critical than 1s nor tically dubious or unsupportable." pollution might be instituted." That seemed mal for such an exercise, which is meant The article viewed the consequences as to support the paper's allegations. But Hig to elicit criticism. Most participants believe serious. "Relying heavlly on the disputed gins also praised the CHESS program, said he the final document is a valuable piece of work CHESS studies," it said, "EPA has called for had never intended to impugn Finklea, and whose overall merit far outweighs any dis controls on sulfur pollution that would cost claimed the L.A. Times "distorted" his posi agreement they may have over specific details power companies and ultimately American tion. of interpretation. consumers billions of dollars." The evidence to support these charges con Another seeming critic in the L.A. Times The document does not slant its inter sisted largely of quotes from individuals- article, Benjamin G. Ferris, Jr., of Harvard's pretations by using only "worst case" or some named, some not--who were critical of School of Public Health, who had coauthored "least case" analyses; rather, it employs a "best judgment" approach. Although the CHESS findings, Winklea, or both. Most of (With Higgins) a 1973 paper critical of a. draft some the critics who were identified by name aimed of the CHESS monograph, resolutely empha reviewers complained that the draft empha their barbs at the CHESS monograph. Only sized the valuable aspects of the CHESS pro sized results indicating an adverse health one of them impllcated Ftnklea, and he did gram in his testimony. effect, other participants believe there are so by saying that he had heard others blame GREENFIELD SWITCHES SIDES factors in the CHESS approach which could Flnklea. The remaining attacks on Finklea Slm11arly, Stanley M. Greenfield, former cause underestimation of health effects. came from anonymous sources. The article assistant administrator for research and de Even lf one assumes the worst about cited not a single specific example of material velopment at EPA, who now heads a con CHESS, that does not call into question that Finklea had supposedly distorted or sulting fl.rm that 1s analyzing the sulfur is EPA's regulatory program for sulfur oxides, deleted. sue under contract with the Electric Power which ls based on a broad array of studies
. . May 17, 1976 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 14187 and analyses. The national ambient air qual Assisting in the entrenchment of tempo lie relations functions would be eliminated ity standards for sulfur dioxide were set rary agencies is, however, not among entirely. before the CHESS studies even began, and the them. This tradition has, over the years, You really wouldn't know that the FEA emission standards for power plants are based led to an enormous growth in the Fed could revert if you listened to the Adminis on the ambient standards, not on CHESS. erai bureaucracy and corresponding in tration and the FEA. Faced with a June 30 CHESS has indeed been cited to support expiration date and mandatory language in EPA's case for controls on power plants con crease in the Federal budget. the FEA act stating that he must submit a verting from oil or gas to coal, and to but The more difficult yet more responsi report to Congress on whether or not he tress EPA's opposition to the use of disper ble course of action would be to reconcile wants FEA renewed, as well as what he plans sion techniques to control pollution-but the necessary functions of the FEA to to do if it isn't renewed, the President sent It is only one among many supporting permanently constituted agencies of to Congress on February 16, 1976, a. month studies. Government already possessing the nec and a half late, a brief one page letter saying CHESS is only one. In some cases, CHESS essary administrative personnel and ex it seemed to him it should be renewed. This was not even a factor in establishing federal pertise, rather than permanently is a far cry from what the law requests. I standards. have written to the President regarding this authorizing yet another layer of action and would like my correspondence in By the end of the long day, Finklea had to emerged With his reputation largely restored. bureaucracy. The savings taxpayers cluded at the end of my statement. Even those congressmen who asked the most would be substantial. Faced with a June 30 cut-off of his job, hostile questions stressed that they were not Representative PATRICIA SCHROEDER, in FEA Administrator Frank G. Zarb talks in questioning his integrity. But the avalanche testimony before the Senate Appropria his budget submission to your subcommittee of support for Finklea proved disquieting to tions Committee on April 8, 1976, pre of "the next decade" at the FEA, and that some. Witness Buechley claimed that some sented an admirable overview of the ''FEA's fundamental mission now and in the EPA scientists who had been critical of case against extending the FEA and future wlll be to formulate energy policies CHESS in conversations With him [and pre offered responsible alternatives to FEA that wlll most effectively solve . . . " the sumably with journalist Rood as well] sang problems of America's energy shortage. This a different tune when called upon to testify. extension. For the benefits of those who is a far cry from the short term intention of Rood, who attended the hearing, declined to did not have the opportunity to review Congress. in comment afterward but gave no indication the testimony, I insert it the RECORD. The FEA began in 1974 as a group of em he does not stand behind his original piece. STATEMENT OF CONGRESSWOMAN PATRICIA ployees transferred from other agencies. Sec Some congressmen said that, in exonerat SCHROEDER BEFORE THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON tion 6 of Public Law 93-275 made the pri ing Finklea, they did not intend to endorse THE DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR AND mary transfers: from the Department of the EPA's sulfur oxides program. They noted that RELATED AGENCIES OF THE SENATE COMMIT Interior, the Office of Petroleum Allocation, the CHESS monograph had been prepared in TEE ON APPROPRIATION the Office of Energy Conservation, the Office a great rush while the agency was facing a I am pleased to be here to offer my state of Energy Data and Analysis, and the Office legal challenge to one of its sulfur dioxide ment to the subcommittee. My comments of on and Gas. The Energy Division was standards--not necessarlly the best environ are directed at the Federal Energy Adminis transferred over from the Cost of Living ment for objective analysis. Moreover, the al tration. I urge your subcommittee to con Council-an agency I need remind no one, legations of distortion had been largely in sider an alternative to the FEA budget which has already vanished from the scene. vestigated by the agency itself. Representa request. Assuming the Federal Energy Ad Let me list the current set-up at FEA: tive Barry M. Goldwater, Jr. (R-Calif.) has ministration Act of 1974, which expires 1. Executive direction and administration. requested additional investigations, and he June 30, 1976, is not renewed by either the 2. Energy policy and analysis. said at the hearing that Congress should ex House or t h e Senate, Sections 9 and 10 of the 3. Regulatory programs. amine whether EPA's research function Act permit a reversion of FEA functions 4. Energy conservation and environment. should examine whether EPA's research func back to the executive departments and 5. Energy resource development. tion should be separated from the regula agencies from whence they came. 6. International energy affairs. tory process. But chairman Rogers, probably Since t h ere is a good possibility that the 7. Strategic planning and storage. the most influential House member in air FEA law will not be renewed-an effort to Mr. Chairman, the President and the FEA pollution matters, indicated that such fur that end is already underway in the House themselves apparently have not faced the ther scrutiny will not necessarily weaken the l think the subcommittee should seriously question of where these various operations antipollution fight . In a day that was largely consider funding only those FEA !unctions would go. But I have: the following proposal devoted to examining charges that sulfur that were detailed over from other depart would do the trick. oxides regulations have been made too ments and agencies back in 1974 and which stringent, Rogers managed to extract some First, the Department of the Interior can will revert back should the FEA expire on take back the functions it previously held testimony which indicated to him, at least, June 30. that the standards may not be strict enough. these would be energy resource development And even these functions should be and energy policy and analysis. As Interior scrutinized. Some perhaps can be eliminated already has its Bureau of Mines and its USGS altogether. Others, while still needed, may energy data gathering functions, (and does a be oversta.Eed and overbudgeted by FEA, and better job at them than the FEA can do, should be trimmed. The FEA is not known FEA MUST BE ABOLISHED-CON even though FEA's data is often borrowed for its conservation of tax dollars. from them) , I think Interior can continue GRESSWOMAN PATRICIA SCHROE Only the House Subcommittee on Energy these functions with ease. DER and Power of the House Interstate and For eign Commerce Committee has held hear Second, the Department of the Interior ings on the FEA renewal. These hearings should have the new strategic reserve office, have not been completed-with the dead as they have long administered public lands HON. FLOYD J. FITHIAN line for reporting the authorization bill un and reserves. OF INDIANA der the Budget Act so close at h and, the Now we are left with the FEA's interna IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES expiration of the FEA is a real possibility. tional office. The FEA act mandates interna I also believe it is the only possibility which tional participation. If there is any reason Monday, May 17, 1976 deserves serious consideration. it needs to be continued, I believe that this Mr. FITHIAN. Mr. Speaker, the House I am of the opinion that the FEA should small office would also work quite well in go when the present law runs out this June. the Department of Interior, as its primary will soon have the opportunity to deter I am doing all I can to that end, including mine the future of the Federal Energy making my views known to this subcommit function is to offer counsel so that the State Administration, one of the fastest grow tee and oth ers in the House and Senate wh o Department follows the right course in inter ing bureaucracies in Washington. have to deal with the FEA. national affairs affecting energy. The easiest course of action regarding I think that ending the FEA will make a Third, I believe that the Energy Research the FEA would be to simply extend the great bicentennial gift to the taxpayers of and Development Administration (ERDA) this nation. wm, in the long run, be the best location Agency's temporary mandate as the There is a great fear that some terrible for the FEA's energy conservation and en administration and the House Com disaster will befall the nation without the vironmental functions. ERDA's technical and merce Committee have suggested. In FEA-th at our energy policy will fall apart. scient ific stance could easily be broadened to deed, rubber stamping the proposal to But such is not the case. include readily available conservation continue the FEA would be something Congress in its wisdom placed reverter clauses in the original FEA authorizing methods, and the agency is already man of a traditional response to a bureauc dated to perform environmental studies. to legislation and in all subsequent FEA legis racy's desire perpetuate itself. lation which would redelegate FEA duties Right now, FEA's dual mandate-increasing The House of Representatives has and functions back to the departments and both energy production and energy conserva many fine traditions, traditions which agencies from whence they came. The FEA's tion-is contradictory. FEA is working at should be cherished and perpetuated. top-heavy, bloated administrative and pub- odds with itself. 14188 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS May 17, 1976 Fourth, Regulatory programs 1n the FEA spiration to her children, and a good wife previous environmental reviews have are orphans. The Cost of Living Council Is to her husband. already essentially resolved rel8ited dead. But the Department of the Treasury OUr Mother of the Year has lived in issues. fs experienced 1n regulation. In fact, the FEA's regulatory functions were set up by Hawthorne for 25 years, and every one Alternatives to this route being con Treasury personnel transferred 1n for that of her 12 children were born here. Every sidered by the FPC include a pipeline purpose. There is no reason why regulatory one has attended St. Joseph's School, through the Arctic National Wildlife programs cannot be sent over to Treasury. and the older ones are either attending Preserve in northern Alaska and then Fifth, The so-called Executive Direction or have graduated from Leuzlnger High through Canada which is strongly op and Adm1n1strative functions, some $31 mn School. posed by environmental groups, and a Uon and 1000 employees, should disappear. Of the four who have graduated, the trans-Alaska pipeline to a southern Too much time, money, and personnel at three girls are working locally and the Alaska port for gas liquefaction and FEA are invested 1n self-promotion. I recognize that the departments and other, a boy, is in the Army. And this shipment by boat to west coast States. agencies to which I suggest transfer of FEA's Mother of the Year is also a grand Judging from the surplus of oil now be function have not been known as the most mother. ing anticipated on the west coast when consumer-oriented. The Department of the Let me read you some excerpts from the Alaskan oil pipeline is in operation, Interior is often accused of being 1n bed with the letter which won for her the 1976 it makes little sense to talk about even the major on companies. The Department of Mother of the Year award. It was writ more fossil fuel ending up in that area the Treasury 1s well known for its kowtowing ten by her oldest daughter, Margie, who in the form of Alaskan naturai gas. to the major on companies on the foreign tax is 21: Several companies have filed with the credit agreement. The ERDA is thought to be too nuclear-oriented. In behalf of eleven brothers and sisters and FPC for construction of Alaskan natural But, for whatever draw-backs my proposal myself, I am submitting this account of the gas transportation facilities. An FPC de might have, I firmly beUeve it will, 1n the love and regard we have for our mother. An cision combining parts of several of the long run, prove far more effective than the ordinary day for Mom begins at about 5 A.M. proposals would coincide with my legis FEA. It's not often that the American Pe and ends around 1 A.M. Preparing Dad's lation and be best for Michigan. Con troleum Institute, the Ralph Nader groups, breakfast and lunch is first on her list of struction of the pipeline would take and the enVironmentalists all gang up on duties to be performed, followed by rousing sleepy young-uns either for school or work. about 5 years and cost roughly $6 bllllon. one agency. But indeed, the FEA has been Senate and House Committees are subjected to such criticism. Given more life, By the time they all show up shiny bright, lunches and books are ready for distribution. holding hearings now or will begin con the FEA would become the worst ogre we Mom's day has only begun. sideration short1y on this issue. I am have ever created. Everything perta.ining to our home must Even if the subcommittee does not agree confident that careful consideration will be 1n order before outside activities can be result in both the most economical and on the need to abolish the FEA, lt ought to considered. We, ourselves can imagine what seriously scrutintze the FEA's budget re it would be like to face twelve loads of the most environmentally sound route quests by function so that we w1l1 have better laundry, sewing, patching, and mountains of for a pipeline to the Midwest where the data for our debate on the agency's future. ironing. Would you believe Mom's favorite gas is needed for homes and industry. hobby is the yard work? Did my brothers ever luck out! ... We are very certain that Mom has a real love for children. She has changed 48,384 MRS. DARLENE KORAN, HAW diapers and this does not include the care NEW BISHOP NAMED TO HEAD LONG THORNE, CALIF., CHAMBER OF she has given her grandchildren. ISLAND DIOCESE COMMERCE'S "MOTHER OF THE YEAR" Let me close by saying that I am ex tremely proud to have Mrs. Koran as one of my constituents in the 31st Con HON. JEROME A. AMBRO HON. CHARLES H. WILSON gressional District and I would like it to OF NEW YORK be recorded that the debate of this Con IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES OF CALIFORNIA gress was briefly suspended so that we Monday, May 17, 1976 IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES could pay tribute to her, Hawthorne's Monday, May 17, 1976 Mother of the Year. Mr. AMBRO. Mr. Speaker, I would like to bring to the attention of my colleagues Mr. CHARLES H. WU..SON of cai1- the elevation of Bishop John McGann to fornla. Mr. Speaker, it is my great pleas Bishop of the Roman Catholic Diocese ure today to pay tribute to Mrs. Darlene of Rockville Centre on Long Island. Koran, known to her friends as Dottie, NEW APPROACH Bishop McGann has earned a reputa who is the Hawthorne Chamber of Com tion for involvement and participation merce's Mother of the Year. with Diocesan priests, nuns, and brothers Let me say at the outset, that in order HON. GUY VANDER JAGT in the decisionmaking process during his to win the accolade of "Mother of the OF MICHIGAN 5 years as Auxiliary Bishop of the sprawl Year," a woman must be more than a IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ing Rockville Centre Diocese, which in mother; she must also be a woman who cludes Nassau and Suffolk Counties. has contributed in various ways to the Monday, May 17, 1976 No stranger to the Diocesan adminis quality of life of her community; and a Mr. VANDER JAGT. Mr. Speaker, I tration, Bishop McGann has worked in woman who has served her friends and have recently introduced new legiSla the Chancery Office since 1969. Shortly neighbors with untiring devotion. tion, H.R. 13678, which I am convinced after being named Auxiliary Bishop, In short, she must be one of those rare, will help to speed up the delivery of Bishop McGann was named Episcopal and, if I may say so, noble individuals, Alaskan natural gas to Midwestern Vicar for Suffolk County and moved to of whom any town or nation can be States, including Michigan. Brentwood. During that time, he visited proud. Such a woman is Mrs. Koran. Let The legislation instructs the Federal every parish and church institution in me give you a brief synopsis of her ac Power Commission to approve the con the county, talking and consulting with complishments: struction of a pipeline from the North clergymen and parishioners. She has worked countless hours in Slope of Alaska, via the present oil pipe Bishop McGann was born in Brooklyn snack stands at Little League baseball line corridor, to Fairbanks and then fol and studied for the priesthood on Long games and Pop Warner football games; lowing the Maska-Canada highway Island before being ordained in 1950. A chau1fered boys to ball games, sold ad through eastern Alaska and southeast man of great personal charm and vertising in programs, helped with through Canada to the U.S. border. warmth, Bishop McGann is expected to church bazaars, fashion shows, book This route would be the least expen stress consultation and "co-responsibil fairs, and bake sales. She has gone to sive according to the Department of the ity" with parishioners in church a:fiairs. campouts with her Girl Scout daughters, Interior and Federal Power Commission Our new Diocesan leader is a talented, kept everybody accounted for on vaca preliminary studies. It would stand the highly motivated clergyman and emi tions in the mountains, and been an in- best chance of early completion because nently qualified for the august position May 17, 1976 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 14189 to which he has been called. I am looking State and Federal governmental agen that could lose its most precious free forward to working with him on both the cies. doms by default." local and national levels. During the month of May I hope that The answer to our educational prob I would like this Chamber to join me full recognition will be given to the im lems is not more Federal aid, not higher in extending to Bishop McGann our con portant work being done by those in this teacher salaries, not more extravagant gratulations on his new position and most field and to the need for our full support buildings and facilities. We have had all sincere best wishes for unparalleled of their activities. of these things in recent years and they success. have gone hand in hand with our declin ing standards. What we need, instead, is a return to basics and a return to stand ards. "BETTER HEARING AND SPEECH" THE NEED TO GO BACK TO THE I wish to share with my colleagues the BASICS IN EDUCATION editorial, "The Basics," as it appeared in the Richmond Times Dispatch of April HON. DANTE B. FASCELL 5, 1976, and insert it into the RECORD at OF FLORIDA HON. PHILIP M. CRANE this time: IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES OF ILLINOIS THE BASICS ••• Monday, May 17, 1976 IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES The title ot the study is "Achievement Test Score Decline: Do We Need to Worry?" and Mr. FASCELL. Mr. Speaker, May is Monday, May 17, 1976 the answer is yes, we do. "Better Hearing and Speech Month" and Mr. CRANE. Mr. Speaker, although Sponsored by CEMREL, Inc., a national it is appropriate that we recognize this we are spending more money on higher educational laboratory in Chicago, the 160- subject's importance to millions of Amer pa.ge study determined that the decline in education today than ever before the student knowledge and academic skUls, as icans. unfortunate fact is that standards in tracked by a variety of standardized tests, 18 The ability to communicate is our most our high schools, colleges, and universi real. It is not the result of quirks in the tests, human characteristic. When a person ties are rapidly declining. Federal aid or intrinsic flaws in the testing process. Those cannot communicate, isolation from and assistance to education has been who insist, comfortingly, that no one should friends, family, and society often occurs. high in cost, but low in results. The only worry, "the kids are smarter than ever," are Yet nearly 10 million Americans, or discernible results show a trend in the wrong. We ought to be concerned, we ought 1 out of every 20 persons, sutfers from direction of lower rather than higher to be alarmed, about the sag in skUls that are essential to civUized society. some type of speech or language dis quality. Through the 1940s, the 1950s, and up to order. Some 14 million Americans have a Previously, a high school diploma the mid-1960s, achievement test scores stead hearing impairment. meant that students could read at the ily increased, noted the report's authors. Individuals with such problems may appropriate 12th grade level. This is not after analyzing data from nine major tests, encounter isolation in vocational, social, true today. For the class of 1976, only including the Scholastic Aptitude Test, Amer emotional, and educational areas. For one State--Arizona-will have any ican College Testing Program, and the Iowa example, adults with speech and lan statewide competency requirement for a Tests of Educational Development. But since guage disorders may find it diffi.cult to about 1965, scores in many subject areas- high school diploma. That requirement English, writing, literature, vocabulary, read gain employment or may be forced into will be the ability to read at a ninth ing, social studies. mathematics, and natural less satisfying jobs, because of their in grade level. In the other 49 States, the sciences--have beea dropping. The declines ability to communicate effectively. School only State requirements for high school are "more dramatic in recent vears and most children may experience difficulties in graduation will be years of schooling. evident for higher grades. They are especially learning because of such a problem. The A recently published study entitled pronounced in verbal tests, but hold for onset of a hearing impairment at birth "Achievement Test Score Decline: Do nearly all tested areas." or during infancy may result in severe We Need To Worry?" concludes with an The big question is "Why?" Authors Anne gret Harnischfeger and David E. Wiley say delays in the development of speech and emphatic, "Yes." there's no sole cause, but they do pinpoint language. Sponsored by Cemrel, Inc., a na one major factor: changes in the school cur According to the American Speech and tional educational laboratory in Chicago riculum. Hearing Association, the answers to the the 160-page study determined that the Declines in achievement scores, they found, following questions will indicate signs of decline in knowledge and academic skills paralleled closely declines in enrollment for disordered communications: on the part of American students is real. basic academic subjects. Enrollment in regu First. Is the individual's speech and/ Through the 1940's, the 1950's, and up lar high school English courses has declined or language so different from others of the mid-1960's, test scores steadily in more than that of any other subject (11 per cent in one two-year period), and English the same age, sex, or ethnic group that creased. Since about 1965, scores have test scores have correspondingly taken the it attracts unfavorable attention? been dropping. greatest plunge. Mathematics is next in de Second. Is the individual's speech and/ One of the reasons for this decline, cline of both enrollment and achievement. or language difficult to understand? state authors Annegret Harnischfeger followed by the natural sciences. Third. Does the individual appear to and David E. Wiley, is the change in cur Not only are secondary students taking have diffi.culty hearing or understanding riculum. Enrollment in basic high school fewer courses in general English and math. speech? English courses has declined more than but they are signing up for typical college that of any other subject and English preparatory courses such as algebra, foreign Fourth. Does the individual avoid languages and physics in decreasing numbers. communicating with others because he is test scores have correspondingly gone Also, fewer are taking courses in United self -conscious about his speech, hearing, down most dramatically. States and state history, although world his and/or language ability? Discussing this unfortunate state of tory's popularity hasn't diminished. affairs, the Richmond Times Dispatch The logical conclusion is that students are If the answer is "yes" to any of these noted that, "the logical conclusion is that not going to learn basic academic skills 1f questions, a thorough evaluation by a students are not going to learn basic they are permitted to duck the tough, de speech pathologist or audiologist is need academic skills if they are permitted to manding courses in which such skiDs are ed to determine the individual's com duck the tough, demanding courses in taught. One particularly arresting statistic: munications strengths and weaknesses. which such skills are taught. One partic From 1970 to 1973, students taking remedial After a complete evaluation is obtained, math increased by more than 80 per cent, ularly startling statistic: From 1970 to while students taking general math decreased the speech pathologist or audiologist will 1973, students taking remedial math in be able to provide or recommend a pro 15 per cent. creased by mor~ than 80 percent, while The academic nose-dive dates to the mtd- gram-if required-to meet the specific students taking general math decreased 1960s; not coincidentally, those were the communication needs of the individual. 15 percent." giddy days when schools around the nation Speech and language pathology and The kind of "freedom" for students were capitulating to juvenUe demands for audiology services are provided in many student "freedom." That kind of freedom, it public and private schools, community which has been brought about in recent appears, could result in a nation populated clinics, hospitals, rehabilitation centers, years, the Times Dispatch points out, by illiterates and ignoramuses, a nation that private practices, health departments, "could result in a nation populated by could lose its most precious freedoms by de colleges and universities, industries, and illiterates and ignoramuses, a nation fault. Schools and colleges ought not hesitate 14190 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS May 17, 1976 1n requiring students to take such essentials duced, I have observed with great inter MoRGAN. Without their leadership and as English, math, history, foreign language est the lack of enthusiasm on the part of and science and in allowing selection of "elec concern, and that of ranking members, tives" only after foundation requirements Soviet and Eastern European officials in Representative BROOMFIELD and Repre have been satisfied. implementation of the third basket of the sentative WINN, and the help of the com The report cited in this editorial would Accord. mittee members, this legislation might make good background for groups Interested Just last week, for example, nine Soviet never have seen the light of day. 1n restoring high standards to public educa dissidents announced formation of a The articles follow: tion. It is available free from CEMREL, 875 group to monitor human rights viola [From New York Times, May 16, 1976] N. Michigan Ave., Chicago, Dl., 60611. tions in the Soviet Union. This public SOVIET DISSIDENT WARNED ON RIGHTS UNIT group to assist the fulfillment of the Moscow, May 15.--soviet authorities today Helsinki Accord in the U.S.S.R. is led by began cracking down on a dissident watch MONITORING THE HELSINKI the renowned scientist Yuri Orlov and dog group formed three days ago to monitor ACCORD the distinguished sinologist Dr. Vitaly the Soviet Union's compliance with the hu Rubin. It intends to monitor violations to man rights provisions of the Helsinki dec Helsinki Accord signatory countries. laration. HON. MILLICENT FENWICK As is so often the case, this attempt to Yurl Orlov, the leader of the group, was picked up by three plainclothesmen and OF NEW JERSEY hold the U.S.S.R. to its international driven off for questioning as he walked along IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES commitments has been attacked by a street in southwest Moscow with another articles in the Soviet newspapers. Yes Monday, May 17, 1976 group member, Mikhail Bernshtam. Mr. Orlov, terday's New York Times reported from a physicist unemployed because of his dis Mrs. FENWICK. Mr Speaker, it was 9 Moscow that Soviet authorities have al sident activities, was released after an hour months ago that a delegation of House ready moved against this group. Yuri of interrogation. Members visited the Soviet Union and Orlov, for example, was picked up on WARNINGS ARE EXPLAINED Romania. You led that delegation and Saturday and interrogated for an hour. Within a few hours, the official press agency I am sure you know what it meant to all The harassment was further intensified Tass took the unusual step of confirming of us to work under your leadership and when Tass news agency noted, in an that Mr. Orlov had been picked up by the to have you as our spokesman. unusual step, that Mr. Orlov has been pollee and had been "officially warned of The trip made a lasting impression on "officially warned of the inadmissability the inadmissibil1ty of his antilaw actions" of his antilaw actions." in connection with the new group. most of us who realized, after talking for Tass, which rarely acknowledges dis many hours with dissidents and Soviet Mr. Speaker, I have received evidence sident activities, said the warnings were citizens wanting to emigrate, that the from many individuals in the past 8 intended "to cut short Orlov's provocative hopes of these people had been pinned months that this type of harassment is activity as well as to prevent the perpetra to the implementation of the Helsinki far from unusual. I have dozens of tion by Orlov and persons connected with Accord which had been signed just before cases which are clear violations of the him of actions punishable by law." our arrival. Helsinki Accord. The speed of the reaction by the au Congressman YATES and I cochaired an The Commission will help the State thorities underscores the Soviet Union's con tinuing sensitivity on the human rights ad hoc committee which met with dis Department to speak forcefully for these issue, particularly following criticism in the sidents and refuseniks and with Jews, people in an the countries which are West that it has not lived up the minimum Christians and agnostics. Through all of parties to the accord. It will also standards set on humanitarian issues by the our conversations, the one consistent strengthen European efforts at monitor 25-state European Security Conference, thread was that the West must not forget ing compliance. There are many non which wound up last summer at Helsinki. the third "basket" of Helsinki Accord, governmental groups which are already The Kremlin has denounced Western ef which addresses itself to human rights. active in Europe. I would like to mention forts to monitor Soviet compliance as inter ference in Soviet internal affairs. It has also We also pursued this theme with Soviet a few of them because it is this concerted responded by accusing the West in turn of officials, including Secret3,ry Brezhnev, mobilization of world opinion that is violating the human rights of its citizens. whom we met at Yalta on August 14. our best hope for realizing the promises However, the prospect of having Soviet When Congress reconvened in Sep made at Helsinki. Some of the European citizens, even dissidents, watching its actions tember, I introduced H.R. 9466, which groups concerned with compliance are: in a formal manner poses a. more awkward was later introduced in the Senate as S. 1. The East-West Institute, Van Stolkweg problem for Moscow. Today's incident sug 2679, believing that it was essential to 10, The Hague, Netherlands. gested that the authorities planned to head involve Congress in the monitoring of 2. Association Europeene Pour Une Vraie off such a threat by treating it purely as the Accord. There will be no other such Detente, 19 Rue Monsieur 75007 Paris, anti-Soviet activity, which is a criminal of France. fense under Soviet law. mechanism until the autumn of 1977, 3. North Atlantic Assembly, 3 Place Petit Mr. Orlov told reporters after his release when an international committee meets Samlom, Brussels 1000, Belgium. that the security officers had called the new to establish a form for such monitoring. 4. World Council of Churches, 120 Route group 1llegal and warned that legal action We must follow through on the agree de Fernay, Geneva, Switzerland. would be bought if its activities continued. ments we have signed. As President Ford 5. Committee on the Helsinki Agreement, DISCRETING MOVE SEEN said in Helsinki, history will judge the Council of Europe, Strasbourg, France. Tass asserted that "it is difilcult to qualify effectiveness of the conference "not by 6. Institute of Jewish Affairs, London, Orlov's actions in any other way than an the promises we make, but the promises England. attempt to question in the eyes of the in we keep." 7. European Cooperation Research Group, ternational public the sincerity of the Soviet 35 Bow Street, London WC2R 7AU. U.K. The monitoring commission would Union's efforts to undeviatingly implement embody those principles which, above all Mr. Speaker, in conclusion, I would the international obligations it assumed.'' others, have distinguished this Nation: like to urge my colleagues to support this It added that the group's formation could also be "another provocation" to undermine our respect for human dignity and for measure which has been supported by detente. the right of dissent; the importance of such diverse groups as the National There are nine founding members of the the individual; and the freedom to pur Conference on Soviet Jewry, the Feder new dissident committee, which calls itself sue one's own beliefs. I feel strongly that ation of American Scientists, the Na the "Public Group To Promote the Fulfill we should emphasize these values in our tional Confederation of American Ethnic ment of the Helsinki Accords in the USSR." international relations, Mr. Speaker. Groups, the Episcopal Diocese of Wash The other members are Aleksandr Gins· '.rhis is what America does best: recog ington, the Association of American berg, a friend of the writer Aleksandr Solz nizing that we are one human family, Publishers and the Veterans of Foreign henitsyn; Aleksandr Korchak, Vitaly Rubin across any barriers of distance or dis Wars. The bill has also received wide and Lyudmila Alekseyeva. sent. support in the House, where it now has Mr. Sakharov himself has not joined but The establishment of this commission 96 cosponsors of both political parties is believed to be a supporter of the group. by the Congress would be a step in that and from all regions of the country. It was he who informed Western reporters after Mr. Orlov was picked up today. direction and would indicate to the world In closing, I would like to pay tribute that the United States will continue its to the chairman of the subcommittee, In its statement several days ago, the new dedication to human rights. group said it would compile instances of Representative DANTE FASCELL, and the human rights violations and pass them on Mr. Speaker, in the 8 months since the chairman of the International Relations to the governments and citizens of other first Helsinki Commission bill was intro- Committee, Representative THoMAS countries. May 17, 1976 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 14191 [From the New York Times, May 14, 1976] yourselves. I urge you all to press actively ADMINISTRATION PROPOSAL ON NINE RUSSIAN DISSIDENTS UNITE TO MONlTOJt on whatever levels are available to you for ADDmONAL URANIUM ENRICH RIGHTS a wider recognition of our obligation to pro MENT FACILITIES ALLOWS EX· Moscow, May 13.-Nine Soviet dissidents test violations of human rights wherever they occur. More important, the protests CESS COSTS AND RISKS TO GOV today announced formation of a group to ERNMENT-AND RICH REWARDS monitor Soviet compliance with the Hel must have more teeth than the expressions sinki declaration signed last year and to re of "official dismay" which presently consti TO PRIVATE UTILITIES port human rights violations to other coun tute the lion's share of U.S. human rights tries that signed that document. policy. The influence of our government 1s The organization, named the Public Group much more far-reaching than such feeble HON. JOE L. EVINS to Assist the Fulfillment of the Helsinki Ac indications of concern, and should be OF TENNESSEE cords in the U.S.S.R., said in a statement brought to bear when possible. IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES it was concerned with sections laying down In Iran the situation is particularly grim. basic freedoms of conscience, religion and Between forty and one hundred thousand Monday, May 17, 1976 bellef and those providing for greater human people languish in jail for political of fenses, hundreds and perhaps thousands Mr. EVINS of Tennessee. Mr. Speaker, contacts and-exchanges of information and an editorial published recently in the culture. have died from torture and execution, and The group is led by Yurt Orlov a scientist, the arbitrary and typically ruthless power Nashville Tennessean is critical of a pro and includes Yelena Sakharov, the wife of of the Shah continues to be employed with posal by the administration to allow Andrei D. Sakharov, the Nobel Peace Prize out restraint. No government resorting to private ownership of uranium enrich winner, Aleksandr Ginzburg, Anatoly Mar such extremes has a claim on our respect. ment plants as unwise and ill-advised in chenko and Pyortr Grigorenko. I extend my full support to this assembly that it will result in higher electric power Dr. Sakharov is not a member of the group, of the Joint Session of American Commu nities to Support Political Prisoners in Iran. prices for the American consumer and but he told Western correspondents that he further concentrate the Nation's energy supported its planned activities. I hope this can be one of many steps to The Helsinki declaration was signed last ward a heightened awareness of the grue resources in the hands of a few large August by the Soviet Union and 32 other some human rights situation 1n Iran and companies. European states, along with the United States around the world. The editorial points out that the ad and Canada. ministration's proposal provides for a The statement by the dissident group said Federal guarantee of $8 billion to offset it would accept written complaints by So any private losses. viet citizens about violation of the accords UNEMPLOYMENT IN CONSTRUCTION affecting them personally, and would pass INDUSTRY "What is being proposed," according on the complaints in summarized form to to a scientist quoted in the editorial, "is heads of governments and the public of other a rather lopsided partnership between countries that signed the Helsinki declara HON. WILLIAM LEHMAN the public and private sectors, in which tion. OF FLORIDA the risks are public and the rewards are It will also try to collect information and private." 1n "special cases of inhumanity" will appeal IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES Further, the editorial quotes a report to foreign governments to form international Monday, May 17, 1976 committees to try to verify information. by the General Accounting Office as de Mr. LEHMAN. Mr. Speaker, as the Na scribing the administration's proposal tion recovers from the recent recession, as "excessively generous." it is easy to lose sight of certain sectors Because of the interest of my col REPRESSION IN IRAN of the economy where unemployment is leagues and the American people in this still a major problem. The construction vital and important matter, I place a industry in south Florida is just one ex copy of the editorial in the RECORD, here HON. MICHAEL HARRINGTON ample. with. OF ~ASSACEnJSETTS From the standpoint of the unem The editorial follows: IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ployed, there is still a depression. One NUCLEAR FuEL PROPOSAL GIVES AWAY Monday, May 17. 1976 person who is still feeling the effects of Too MucH the depressed state of the construction The Ford administration's proposal to let Mr. HARRINGTON. Mr. Speaker, I industry is Mr. Pat Byrd of Opa Locka, private industry in on the government's recently sent a statement of support to Fla. Besides being unemployed, Mr. Byrd uranium enrichment monopoly is coming a coalition of student and citizen groups finds himself faced with the prospect of under increasing scrutiny and with good rea in Baltimore who are attempting to raise losing his home because he is no longer son. public awareness and concern over the able to make the mortgage payments on Last summer the administration made its great number of political prisoners m time. The following is a letter Mr. Byrd proposal in the form of the Nuclear Fuel As Iran. I am inserting that statement in surance Act after it was determined that the recently sent to Secretary Carla Hills. It government's three enrichment plants would the RECORD at this point for the atten is a simple but eloquent plea for help. I be unable to meet the growing demand for tion of my colleagues. It is regrettable am sure he is not alone in his predica nuclear plant fuel. indeed that so little international atten ment, and I urge HUD to use the power According to a government study, there is tion has been focused on this situation it has to provide emergency relief to those the possibility of a shortage of nuclear fuel in comparison with the cases of, say, for whom the recession is still a reality. by the mid-1980s unless steps are taken to Chile and Brazil, where human rights The letter follows: increase production capacity in the near violations are certainly serious but prob APRIL 22, 1976. future. To meet such a shortage, two alter ably not as widespread as those under Ms. CARLA HILLS, natives were put forth: Have the govern the Shah. Secretary, HUD, HUD Building, 451 7th Street ment expand one of its three existing en S.W., Washington, D.C. richment plants or allow private industry to The statement follows: DEAR Ms. HILLS: My name is Patrick Byrd, build a new one. STATE~ENT BY CONGRESSMAN MICHAEL HAR I reside at 351 Bahman Avenue, Opa Locka, At present, private companies operate the RINGTON FOR THE JOINT SESSION OF AMERI Florida. I am a Carpenter who has been un government's plants under contract, and CAN COMMUNITIES TO SUPPORT POLITICAL employed for the last fourteen (14) months. it was widely expect ed that 1f private in PRISONERS IN IRAN It is my understanding that Congress dustry were allowed to own and operate en I am sorry that I am unable to deliver this passed an Act that would assist me, and richment plants, some of these contracted message of support in person, because I be others in the event of Mortgage foreclosure companies would be among the first to enter lieve the advancement of human rights is a on my home. the field. crucial issue facing the world today. Accounts The Mortgage Company is now in the proc Indeed, one of the partners, Goodyear Tire of torture and brutality by agents of auto ess of foreclosing. and Rubber Co., in Uranium Enrichment cratic governments may seem far away to I request your assistance in the implement Associates, operates the government's enrich those of us in the United States, but the hor Ing of this Congressional Act. Your coopera ment plant at Portsmouth, Ohio. UEA, whose ror of the situation is all too real for those tion is solicited and wlll be appreciated. Your other partners are the Bechtel Corp. and the involved. Our detachment from the situation response is vital to my family and myself. I Williams Companies has prcposed building and the lack of immediate material involve look forward to it. a $3.5 billion enrichment plant at Dothan, ment make this an Issue of conscience, one Sincerely, Ala.., if the a.dmlnlstra.tlon's bill passes Con which will only come to prominence through PATRICK BYRD, gress. the efforts and dedication of people like Opa Locka, Fla. Among the key provisions of the Nuclear 14192 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS May 17, 1976 Fuel Assurance Act are: a. federal guaran raise nuclear fuel costs some $700 million tor Schweiker, it 1s not a new one, and it 1s tee of $8 billion to cover private industry a. year-and the consumers would end up dlmcult to believe that st111 another omcial losses if they occur and '8.l'e beyond industry's paying it. report would dispel it. control; a presidential pledge that fuel orders That $700 million figure might even be In fact, you can make a. good case that the placed with the private producers by either conservative. Mr. Komes told the congress more the assassination 1s investigated, the domestic or foreign consumers will be hon men, "We are going to have dlmculty ... more entrenched public skepticism becomes. ored--even if the government must provide with our investors . . . in keeping as low as The two senators are going to write a report it out of federal stockpiles; and permission that 15%" rate of return. which the full Church Committee will then for foreign interests to invest in the private Congress can resolve that dlmculty very either suppress or make public. If released, ventures provided 55% voting ownership easily-by rejecting the Ford administration as it should be, that report may reveal how remains in U.s. hands. proposal and mainta.lnlng the government's two senators can start from the same infor Until the administration wrote a. bill with monopoly on enrichment of uranium. mation and reach entirely different orders such favorable terms for prtvate industry, of doubt. But we suspect that the net effect companies such as UEA were playing it coy. of the exercise will be to emphasize, again, Afterwards, their reluctance vanished-and that with a limited body of fact different in with good reason. The administration's bill PERSPECTTVE ON ~y vestigators will draw different inferences 18 adequately described by Dr. Barry Com from it. That has been the heart of the mys moner, a scientist who opposes nuclear ASSASSINATION tery all along. power in general: "What is being proposed Some of us, that is, want to believe the is a rather lopsided partnership between the HON. DEL CLAWSON simplest conclusion consistent with the given public and private sectors, in which the risks evidence, while some of us want to believe are public and the rewards private." OF CALIFORNIA the most complex conclusion not inconsis A Bechtel spokesman admitted that the IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES tent with it. Given that basic difference in UEA consortium would probably gross $300 Monday, May 17, 1976 human temperaments, we'd wager that there million annually when its plant went into will always be a mystery in the Kennedy operation. Federal omcials estimate that by Mr. DEL CLAWSON. Mr. Speaker, per assassination for those who want to find it the end of the century the enrichment of spective, both historical and logical, is there, regardless of the depth and frequency uranium for use in nuclear power plants an element which appears to be needed o! the investigations. But that is not to say would be a $9 billion a. year business. in much of the current controversy over that the mystery exists independently of the The spokesman tried to compare the gov will to believe in it. ernment's largesse to the Federal Deposit the Warren Commission report on the Insurance Corp. '"l'he consortium is buying assassination of President Kennedy. An technology and service from the government, editorial in the Washington Star for we are simply asking that the government Sunday, May 16, I believe supplies some PROJECT ON EQUAL EDUCATION guarantees that it works," the Bechtel omcial of that necessary element. At this point RIGHTS SURVEY !!laid. in the CONGRESSIONAL RECORD, therefore, However, the General Accounting omce, I commend the editorial to the attention which studied the proposal for Congress last HON. AUGUSTUS F. HAWKINS fall, characterized the Ford bill as "exces of my colleagues: sively generous." The report concluded: "Its THE WILL To DoUBT OF CALIFORNIA (the administration proposal) fundamental The first serious look at the shortcomings IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES l!lhortcoming is that it shifts most of the of the Warren Commission report on Presi Monday, May 17, 1976 risks during construction ... to the govern dent Kennedy's assassination came in Ed ment." According to the GAO, it would be ward J. Epstein's interesting book Inquest, Mr. HAWKINS. Mr. Speaker, the more in the public interest for the govern which began as a master's thesis at Harvard; Project on Equal Education Rights ment to continue its dominant role by set and the poking and prodding by various PEE~! the National Organization for ting up a corporation that could borrow pub hands--from television networks to law pro Women Legal Defense and Education lic funds to construct new enrichment plants. fessors skilled in the rules of evidence Fund recently published the results of a During congressional hearings on the Nu has gone on ever since. clear Fuel Assurance Act, administration of To what effect? In our view, none of these survey it conducted of State depart ficials have argued that if the government studies has shaken, and several tend to con ments of education. The results show continues its monopoly, it wm cost the tax firm, the original conclusion of the Warren that only nine State education depart payers some $2.8 billlon. Mr. Jerome Kames, panel that Lee H. Oswald, acting alone, shot ments are in complete compliance with board chairman of UEA, told the congress the President from the Dallas textbook de Federal regulations for ending sex bias men that the Dothan plant would not cost pository. Often assailed, by cranks and con in education. The regulations were is the taxpayers a cent--if it succeeded. spiracy theorists as well as by the ingenuity sued last June by the Department of And, of course, the bill admittedly wlll of scholars, that theory has stood. Health, Education, and Welfare to en cost the taxpayers a very pretty penny if it Now we have a suggestion from a. sub doesn't succeed. committee of the Senate Select Committee able affected agencies to comply with Moreover, an investigation by the Associ on IntelUgence--Sens. Gary Hart and Rich title IX of the Education Amendments ated Press indicates that even a successful ard Schweiker-that yet another omcial in of 1972. UEA venture will cost the American taxpay vestigation, this time by the Senate, be Public attention has focused chiefly on ers, directly and indirectly. Jarvis L. Schwen undertaken. the impact of title IX on schools and col nesen, head of a government task force re The two senators base their recommenda leges. However, the law also covers State viewing the UEA proposal, told AP that the tion, reportedly, on new information made education departments which have a administration's claim of a $2.8 billion saVing available to the Church Committee (though powerful influence on public education it!! exaggerated. not to the Warren Commission) about plots in this country as they are responsible Mr. Schwennesen said that, according to on the life of Fidel Castro. the UEA proposal, the government would But the two senators do not agree what for overseeing public education in each have to buy $1 billion worth of enriched questions remain open. Senator Hart harbors State. uranium from UEA and stockpile it to help "lingering doubts"-not that oswald was PEER's survey was designed to deter get the private plant started. In other words, actually the trigger man at Dallas but about mine the extent to which these State the government will not spend $2.8 billion to "the question, which the Warren Commis agencies carried out the five basic steps increase its capacity and to provide relatively sion did not answer, 'Why?'" Senator for eliminating sex discrimination as low-cost uranium to nuclear power plants, Schweiker, for his part, has more substantive mandated by title IX. State education but it may be forced to lay out $1 billion doubts about the Warren Commission's basic departments are required to first, offi to subsidize UEA's profits. conclusions and says that "six months on this subcommittee reinforce and strengthen cially designate a coordinator to see that Moreover, the nuclear fuel produced by those doubts." the activities of each department com private industry would be more costly than This senatorial disparity can only be ex ply with title IX, including the investi that now provided by the government. To plained, we suppose, in one of two ways: collect its overhead and make its proposed gation of sex discrimination complaints; Either the two senators interpret the same second, notify all employees, students, profit margin of 15%, UEA estimates that new body of information differently, or Sena it would Eell enriched uranium at $85 per tor Schwelker has seen evidence that Sena and any other affected groups of the unit, compared to the government's present tor Hart hasn't seen. The latter supposition name, address, and telephone number average price of $54 per unit. seems improbable, so that we are really back of the coordinator; third, notify all em As Mr. Schwennesen explained it to AP, to a familiar problem that has dogged the ployees and students under its jurisdic the government would, most likely, then be Warren Commission report all along. As the tion that the department does not dis forced to raise its price so that customers Commission initially said, you can't prove criminate on the basis of sex, and inform would buy from UEA. All of this financial a negative to a certainty. them of their rights under title IX. Ini juggling, according to AP calculations, would If this is the problem that bothers Sena- tial notices were to have been published May 17, 1976 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 14193 by October 1976; fourth, conduct a thor (PEER) of the National Organization for quirements "sound like techn1ca11t1es." But, ough review-self-evaluation--of its own Women Legal Defense and Education Fund she added, "when state omcia.ls break the policies and practices to determine if said the agencies had falled to take steps law ... it affects students and teachers 1n such policies comply with title IX; fifth, mandate under Title IX of a 1972 educa every school district in the state." tion law. When state agencies fall to set an ex establish and publish grievance proce PEER called on the Health, Education, and ample by getting their own houses 1n order, dures for resolving sex discrimination Welfare Department which issued Title IX Knox said, it undercuts their efforts to help complaints. rules last June, to Investigate its charges local school systems comply with Title IX The PEER survey of 51 State depart and press the agencies to comply. requirements. ments of education-including the Dis Among violators PEER said it found 1n a PEER said its survey showed that Georgia, trict of Columbia--revealed that 80 per survey this spring were the Maryland and Indiana, South Dakota, and vermont had cent of the State departments of educa Virginia departments of education and the fa.Ued to take any of the required first steps. tion are in violation of .at least one of the District of Columbia school system. Locally, it found that V1rg1n1a. had faUed title IX regulations. I am inserting in HEW's Title IX rules bar sex discrimlna to pick a. staff compliance coordinator and the RECORD, for the information of my tton 1n a wide range of school, college and that Maryland and the D.C. school system other education activities from student fi had falled to publicize properly their colleagues, the results of that survey and identity or how they could be contacted. a copy of a Washington Post article on nancial aid and faculty hiring to athletics. PEER said the state agencies were re PEER said none of the three had ade the PEER survey: quired to take some tnitial steps of their quately publicized their non-d1scr1mination PROBE BY HEW AsKED 41 STATE AGENCIES own: picking staff members to coordinate policies by informing every employee 1n ACCUSED 011' SEX BIAS compliance activities, reviewing depart writing, but observed that many agencies (By Eric Wentworth) mental policies and procedures and remedy appeared confused over what kind of notice Fourty-c:>ne state education agencies are ing any problems, proclaimlng nondlscrtm was required. violating one or more federal requirements tnation policies and notifying employees of It said its survey also disclosed that for ending sex bias, a. women's rights group their rights, and establishing grievance pro neither the D.C. schools nor V1rg1n1a had charged yesterday. cedures to handle any complaints. reviewed their own pollcles. Maryland had The Project on Equal Education Rights Holly Knox, PEER director, said the re- fafied to establish grievance procedures.
STATES VIOLATING CERTAIN TITLE IX REQUIREMENTS,t MAY 6, 1976 (Key: An X indicates a violation; an (•) indicates information not available)
Federal Federal Title IX Notice of Grievance fund Title IX Notice of Grievance funds coordi designa Notice of Self· proce- (thou coordi designa Notice of Self- proce- (thou State nator tion policy evaluation dure sands)' State nator tion policy evaluation dure sands) 2
Alabama______X X X ------$84,167 New Jersey______X X X ------$105,764 Alaska______X X X ------44,498 New Mexico...... X X (•) (•) ______40,541 Arkansas______X X ------49,219 New York.------X X ------322,898 California______X X ------373,996 North Carolina...... X X X ------114,813 Colorado______X X X ------50,362 Ohio______X X ------136,460 ConnecticuL______X X X X 41,486 Oklahoma______X X X ------54,075 District of Columbia.------X X X ------24,828 Oregon______X X X ------35,685 Rorida •.• ------______------X ------123,950 Pennsylvania...... X X X ------X 174,181 Geor~a______X X X X X 101,959 South Carolina______X X X ------67,708 Illinois .. ______------X ------177,768 South Dakota...... X X X X X 19,613 Indiana______X X X X X 65,918 Tennessee______X X X ------79,898 Iowa______X X X X 38,716 Texas ••.. ------X ------______---- 229,811 Kansas ______------X ------40,003 Utah ______------X ------25,602 Kentucky------__ ------X ------71,499 Vermont______X X X X X 8, 879 Louisiana __ ------X X ------86,297 Virginia.------X X X X ------113,725 Maryland______X X ------X 79,145 62,531 Massachusetts______X X X ------86,142 33, 162 142,627 64,858 =~~~i::o~a:::::::::::·-----··x· ~ :::::::::::·-----··x·::::::::::: 60,678 ~:s~c~~!~~~~~:======Wyoming______X B X ------~------~-======X X ------10,101 Missouri ______------X X 73,444 Montana______X X ------19,781 TotaL ••.•...• 18 35 30 21 9 3, 448,867 Nevada______X X X X ------11,523
t See the regulation implementing title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 (45 CFR, pt. 86). ~ordinator. ~oti~e.of Policy: State .did not notify affecte~ groups that, as required by ti.tle IX 1 Funds allocated by formula to States by the U.S. Office of Education, fiscal year 1976. 1t does not d1scnmmate on the basrs of sex. Self-evaluation: State has not begun to revrew its Note: Title IX Coordinator: State did not designate an employee to coordinate its own efforts policies and practices for title IX violations. Grievance procedure: State has no trtle IX complaint to comply with title IX. Notice of Designation: State did not inform affected groups how to contact procedure . ..•. MISS KAREN mENE TRIPP RE training program offered by the Red WOMAN VIP'S EXPRESS COMl\UT CEIVES RED CROSS CERTIFICATE Cross in first aid, small craft or water MENTS OF MERIT safety. I salute Miss Tripp for fast action, and would like to bring the details of this rescue to the attention of my col HON. CLAIR W. BURGENER HON. PHILIP E. RUPPE leagues by quoting from the Red Cross OF MICHIGAN letter which was sent to me: OF CALIFORNIA IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES On July 19, 1975, Miss Tripp, trained in IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES Monday, May 17, 1976 Red Cross lifesaving, heard her mother say Monday, May 17, 1976 that a swimmer 1n Tawas Bay was calling for Mr. RUPPE. Mr. Speaker, the Amer help from about 500 feet off shore. Taking a Mr. BURGENER. Mr. Speaker, the ican National Red Cross has recently ring buoy handed to her by her mother, Women Volunteers in Politics-VIP's brought to my attention a heartening Miss Tripp swam to the troubled swimmer, in San Diego County, Calif., have written example of courageous action by a young shouting encouragement and instructions to American. Miss Karen Irene Tripp, of tread water. After reaching the swimmer, expressing their commitment to the Dec Tawas City, Mich., has been named to she towed him Into shore with the ring buoy, laration of Independence, the Constitu receive the Red Cross Certificate of continuing to reassure him. She then assist tion of the United States, and the Bill of Merit and accompanying pin, for her ed others in treating the victim for shock by Rights. They have -asked thrut- I - insert quick work in saving a drowning swim wrapping towels around his body. Within an this letter in the RECORD. mer. This is the highest award given by hour the victim seemed completely recovered I and left the scene. Without doubt, the hope that my colleagues will find the American Red Cross to a person who their expression of commitment to the saves or sustains a Ufe by using skills prompt, unhesitating action of Miss Tripp and knowledge learned in a volunteer saved the victim from drowning. basic documents of our freedoms of in- 14194 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS May 17, 1976 terest and include the letter to be re stitute and the Boston Wool Trade As company would have to engage in a lot of printed at this point in the RECORD: sociation. costly transactions that are simply not necessary." WoMEN V.I.P.'s, But Exxon seemed to tell a. different story La Mesa, Calif.• May 14, 1976. to state tax authorities. Congressman CLAIR BURGENER, In the Wisconsin tax case, Mr. Thomas G. House Office Building, OIL COMPANIES SUPPORT Ragatz, counsel for Exxon, said: Our evi Washington, D.O. DIVESTITURE dence will show th.ait none of (Exxon's) DEAR CONGRESSMAN BURGENER: In tlus Bi· functional departments are integral parties centennial year the Women V .I.P.'s (Volun of a unitary business composed of all func teers in Polltlcs) wtsh to shout :from the tions combined; rather 1lt will show that each rooftops and publicly acclaim our love for HON·. ABNER J. MIKVA function is independerut and not unitary to, and our dedication to those three great docu OF ILLINOIS or an integral part of, any other function. ments, the Declaration of Independence, IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES Repeatedly, the company made the argu the Constitution and the BUl of Rights. ment that each functional division--explo No other Natlon in the world has the Free Monday, May 17, 1976 ration, transportation, refining and market dom and individual Liberty for its people Mr. MIKVA. Mr. Speaker, I would ing stood on its own feet. Each, it was that these documents give to us. Because, as claimed, was "operated as separate businesses in our Pledge of Allegiance, we are One Na like to bring to the attention of my in competition with other oil companies hav tion Under God. colleagues an article by the Honorable ing similar functions." So let those small groups of troublemak PHILIP A. HART, senior Senator from Thereby, it seems to me, was laid to rest ers who wish to change these documents the State of Michigan, on clivestiture of the most reasonable argument the industry etiher by force or smooth-sounding words, the major oil companies. Throughout his has made against vertical divestiture: That be hereby warned that the Women V.I.P.'s distinguished career of public service, somehow we would mess up the emciencies stand ready to protect, uphold and fight for that come from vertical integration. our Declaration of Independence, BUl of Senator HART has been one of the Na tion's most thoughtful analysts of the If-with the profit motive as their incen Rights and the Constitution. tive--the companies already have organized To this end we pledge our fortunes our impact of monopolistic business practices into functional units, we can assume this 1s lives and our sacred honor. upon the American economy d.nd the the most emclent arrangement. Approved unanimously at our May 13th American consumer. In the following And, it becomes clear that we will not do 1976 Meeting. article, which appeared in the April1976 great harm to the industry by moving these DoROTHEA K. BENNER, edition of the Consumer Federation of separate functional units out from under National Legislation Chairman. America News, Senator HART shows the the corporate umbrella and into the competi inconsistencies inherent in the argu tive world. What the Wisconsin Exxon testimony has ments of the large oil companies against done for us Is to give evidence that the real BilL TO REMOVE TARIFF ON WOOLS clivestiture, and further shows how those world recognizes what the theoretical world OF 46's GRADES AND COARSER same oil company arguments have been preaches--that competition, within a com contradicted in statements made in open pany or outside it, 1s the best road for all. court by Exxon Oil Co.'s own attorney. It seems a small step to move those .. mini HON. ALBERT H. QUIE The article follows: competitive" segments into a world o! "maxi OF MINNESOTA [From the consumer Federation of America competition". News, April 1976] But, I believe, it 1s a step that will help IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES Is BREAKING UP HARD TO Do? energy consumers---and all consumers- Monday, May 17, 1976 (By Senator Philip A. Hart) everywhere. Mr. QUIE. Mr. Speaker, I am today in The ad on the television was picture clear: THE DIVESTIT'ORE PROCESS troducing for myself and Congressman There was the jigsaw puzzle. And the message Inevitably the question arises as to how KARTH was that each piece of the on industry Inter divestiture can be accomplished. How do you legislation to remove the tariff on go breaking up an Exxon, a Shell, a Phillips? wools of 46's grades and coarser. These locked-just llke the jigsaw puzzle. Clearly we were being subtly told that lf, heaven The industry has informed us that it is just wools, which are produced only in mini forbid, the government should step in and about impossible. The faot is, of course, that mal quantities, if at all, in the United pry the pieces separate from each other, our financiers, our accountants, our cor States, have for many years been free of the whole system bullt up over the years porate lawyers, and our courts have had dec duty if used in the manufacture of car would collapse. ades of experience in handling all of the pets, papermakers' felts, lumbermen's It was an entertalnlng ad-and to many problems which would arise. Because they socks and some other products. quite persuasive. Then, one day, Senate do arise almost every day of the week in any This bill would simply extend this Antitrust and Monopoly Subcommittee staff kind of corporate reorganization, regardless ers made a trip to Wisconsin and picked up of whether it comes from court-ordered di same treatment to all other products in the transcript of a case In the Tax Appeals vestitures (ranging !rom the 1911 Standard which these coarser wools can be used. Commission-Exxon Corporation vs. Wis Oil case to the pending divestiture by Kenne It is my belief that this legislation will consin Department of Revenue. cott of Peabody Coal), bankruptcy proceed increase the use of the finer wools which At issue was whether the state could &~pply ings, voluntary divestitures, and even merg are produced in great quantity in this a formula for taXing the entire operation of ers. The problem in all of them is to do the country, by stimulating the manufacture Exxon or must tax only the marketing busi best possible job of protecting the equities of products in which the finer domestic ness carried on in the state boundaries. of all parties. The key question was: Is Exxon a com Mergers are not usually thought of in this and coarser foreign wools can be blended. pany so integrated-so commingled-so de connection, yet they raise just as many prob Blankets are an example. pendent, one diVision on the other-that lems of equity as divestitures. The off-again Mr. Speaker, the decline in the use of it would be called "unitary"? on-again attempt of Mobil Oil to merge its wool in this country in recent years is a If it were decreed "unitary", it would have affiliate, Marcor, is a case in point. Will an cause of great concern and I am delighted to pay higher taxes in Wisconsin-and a outright merger fairly treat those Marcor to have the opportunity to make what I number of other states. stockholders with roughly $600 million am certain will be a contribution to stim For those o! us who think that this in equity in Marcor who have evidently chosen ulating usage of this fiber. dustry can manage quite wf'll if broken up not to sell out to Mobil over the past couple into separate divisions, by function, the o! years? wm the issue of Mobil stock in I want to make it clear that this legis company's response was instructive. connection with the merger dilute the equity lation is not intended to establish a prec Exxon-and all the other major oil com of existing Mobil stockholders? And how edent for removal of the tariff on wools panies---had lectured the Antitrust Subcom about the del:Yt? Wlll those investors who finer than 46's, the so-called apparel mittee for years as to the essential value hold three quarters of a blllion dollars in type wools. The domestic wool produc vertical integration gives to the company. Ma.rcor debt have more or less security in a Mr. Frank Ikard, president of the American merger with Mobil, which has $1 billlon of ing industry needs that protection pro Petroleum Institute, told the subcom.mlttee its own long-term debt? Evidently the direc vided by this tariff. It is with this under that if divestiture legislation were to separate tors of both Mobil and Marcor are fully standing that my bill has the endorse the !unctions o! the major companies, confident that these questions can be worked ment of the National Wool Growers As it: " ... Would inevitably cause every com out satisfactorily to most of the investors in sociation. It is also supported by the pany, regardless of its degree of integration, volved, because they know that the expertise American Textile Manufacturers In- to become less emcient than it is now. Each needed to do the job exists. May 17, 1976 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 14195 What are the mechanics o! divestiture? departments in such companies are generally w1ll be maintained between Cairo and Mos The simplest approach is to have the exist treated as independent businesses." cow. Both sides have too much at stake to ing integrated companies establish separate The point of this is clear. There are already accept a complete split. subsidiaries in the functions to be divested in place the accounting and financial data production, pipelines, refining, and market necessary to perinit the rapid development It is becoming increasingly apparent ing. The subsidiaries could be sold or spun and implementation of any divestiture plan from recent press reports that both the off. Given the magnitudes involved, the spin which should be required by Congress. Egyptians and the Soviets are going out off is the most likely solution, with stock of their way to avoid a "complete split." holders in the original company receiving, To many observers, the Moscow-Cairo pro rata, shares in each o! the subsidiaries. rift is more analogous to a lovers' spat In other words, each stockholder would have or even a trial separation than to a di the same residual claim to assets after di U.S.S.R. AND EGYPT vestiture as he had before. In order to pre vorce, as the administration would have vent continuation of common control, of us believe. Recent actions by both sides course, large stockholders would be allowed clearly indicate that a mood of reconcili a period of time in which to decide which HON. BENJAMiN S. ROSENTHAL ation surrounds present Soviet and Egyp function they chose to retain and to dispose OF NEW YORK tian attitudes. of their stockholdings in the other functions. Sadat's May Day 1976 speech in Suez General corporate debt can be allocated IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES spoke of the Russians in a conciliatory among the new functional companies on Monday, May 17, 1976 tone, saying: some reasonable basis, such as the corpora tion's investment in the different functions. Mr. ROSENTHAL. Mr. Speaker, on We do not wish to enter a battle or escalate Another merger example is useful here. March 14 Egyptian President Sadat a battle with the Soviet Union. United Gas had 11 separate debenture issues called for the abrogation of Egypt's Furthermore, his decision to back away at the time it was acquired by Pennzoil in treaty of friendship and cooperation with from a threalt to publish a list of griev 1968. These were replaced by comparable the Soviet Union. This action, regarded ances against the Russians also comes Pennzoil issues, with a modest cash reserve by many observers as a climax to the established to redeem debentures of in out of an apparent desire to play down vestors who preferred not to exchange their rapidly deteriorating relationship be Egypt's differences with Moscow. Other old securities for Pennzoil. Incidentally, the tween the two countries, seemed to some recent developments include: whole process was reversed a few years later to signal Sadat's desire to adopt a for The signing of a new trade agreement when Pennzoil was required by the FPC to eign policy decidedly more pro-Western after several months of delay, divest United Gas Pipeline Co. and pro-American. A Soviet delegation expected in June PENSION RIGHTS PROTECTED Fresh on the heels of Sadat's an to discuss a long-term commercial ac Witnesses in Subcommittee hearings also nouncement, the Ford administration in cord, raised a question about the effect of divesti formed Congress of its decision to sell Instructions to the Egyptian press to ture on pension rights. Again, this is a prob six C-130 combat transport planes to modify the anti-Soviet tone of its recent lem which arises frequently and is solved Egypt and to provide training for Egyp articles, and on the basis of existing law. Thus, Scovill tian personnel in U.S. military schools. Manufacturing Co. sold its last metals divi Continued Soviet use of naval mainte This decision, the administration nance and supply facilities at the port of sion for $40 Inillion a couple of weeks ago. claimed, was based largely on Egypt's The purchase price included $22 Inillion in Alexandria. cash; the balance represented mostly the desire to work more closely with the Likewise, the Soviets appear to be try assumption by the buyer of the unfunded United States, and its decision to repudi ing to "minimize the damage" of their portion of pension obligations for Scovill em ate previous policies of close cooperation break with Mr. Sadat. Common diplo ployees who were transferred to the new em with the U.S.S.R. in the political, eco matic ground was reached when the So ployer. There was no problem, in other nomic and military fields. viets called for a resumption of the Ge words, with the pension rights of employees Despite efforts in Congress to stop the neva Peace Conference, and Egyptian under the divestiture action. will be The crunch question, of course, is: Can the arms sale, the transaction car Foreign Minister Fahmy met recently affected companies make reasonable and ried out amidst administration assur with the Soviet Ambassador to Cairo, equitable allocations of assets, liabilities and ances that there will be no further arms their first meeting since the friendship net worth necessary to accomplish divesti sales to Egypt this year and this deal treaty was abrogated. ture? The answer has to be yes. constitutes no precedent. If the present pattern of reconcilia Three majors-Gulf, Sun, and Continen As I already indicated, the administra tion in Soviet-Egyptian relations is not tal-have already done so internally. They tion's justification for the arms sale was the beginning or a continuation of an have reorganized their corporate structures based largely on Egypt's decision to turn arms supply relationship, it has certainly to provide separate functional subsidiaries, away from Moscow and pursue friendlier placed their relationship on firmer including production, refining, marketing, relations with the United States. and transportation. These are separately-in ground. corporated subsidiaries, each with its own in At the time, I expressed skepticism Very careful attention should be given come statement and balance sheet, in which over what seemed to be an exaggeration to the future shape of Soviet-Egyptian the sole stockholder is the parent. Divesti of the extent of the Soviet-Egyptian fall relations and the manner in which they ture by these companies simply requires that out. Despite official claims to the con could and should affect American-Egyp the parent dispose of its stock in the sub trary, intelligence reports show Soviet tian relations, the balance of power in the sidiaries affected by the legislation. arms shipments to Egypt did not halt Middle East and the achievement of an The same thing can be said generally for after the Yom Kippur War. Moreover, overall peace settlement. pipeline divestiture. Nearly all pipelines are nearly all of Egypt's losses in the 1973 separately-incorporated entitles with their war were replaced by the Soviets, and it own company owners as shareholders. is widely believed that Egypt is contin But how about the production, refining uing to receive additional Soviet weap and marketing operations of other majors? SORRY CHARLIE! Here we may rely on the testimony of Ex ons, directly or through Eastern Euro xon's witnesses in its case against the Wis pean countries. consin Department of Revenue, as men In an earlier statement in which I HON. HELENS. MEYNER tioned earlier. spoke out against arms sales to Egypt, I OF NEW JERSEY One of Exxon's expert witnesses was t_he quoted from a monograph entitled "So managing director of Arthur Andersen's viet Arms Aid in the Middle East," pub IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES Houston qffice, which audits the books of a lished by Georgetown University Center Monday, May 17, 1976 number of integrated companies other than for Strategic and International Studies. Exxon. On the basis of 28 years' experience, An important and even prophetic section Mrs. MEYNER. Mr. Speaker, the purse the witness testified that "all [integrated] seine method for tuna fishing, which companies use the functional profitab111ty in the article states: kills hundreds of thousands of porpoises independence for measuring the perform Despite the recent vicissitudes 1n Soviet Egyptian relations and Cairo's probing for each year, has been ordered halted with- ance of their various operations." He in 2 weeks by a May 12 District responded affirmatively to a question by Ex U.S. and Western European arms, it stm ap u.s. xon's counsel as to "whether these functional pears that some type of working arrangement Court order. I applaud the wisdom of the 14196 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS May 17, 1976 court in ruling that the interests of the man of the social science division during tions. In my opinion, the elimination of tuna industry, important as they are, the vital developmental years of UNLV. price controls and tripling the price of must be served only after protection of In the late 1950's and the 1960's, Dr. natural gas will not significantly increase the animals is assured. Wright served on most of the key com gas supplies even in the short run. Although the purse seine method was mittees which worked out the plans and This approach is unfair to the consumer an eminently successful response by our the policies which eventually led to the and it will not resolve our gas supply tuna companies to the Japanese chal emergence of UNLV as an increasingly problems. lenge of the 1950's, it was disastrous for autonomous institution within the Uni Further, high-priced natural gas is porpoises. This is well known. I am sure versity of Nevada system. His patient going to fuel inflation-not provide en that many of us have received stacks of and skilled negotiations often served to ergy for the American people. mail from children as well as adults lessen the tensions between the grow voicing deep concern about the rapidly ing southern institution and its allied dwindling numbers of this friendly, in university in Reno. In addition, Dr. telligent mammal. Young people of all Wright remained active as a research THE NEWS MEDIA AND THE CIA ages who loved Flipper and who flocked scholar, and the University of Nevada to see the ''Day of the Dolphin" could Press in 1970 published his monograph not bear to think of these creatures "Lincoln and the Politics of Slavery." HON. ROBERT W. KASTENMEIER trapped in nets, drowned by the hun As one of his colleagues has remarked, OF WISCONSIN dreds of thousands, wasted. A can of In describing John Wright, the great prob IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES tuna hardly seemed worth that price. lem Is that it is difilcult to avoid sounding Monday, May 17, 1976 One seventh-grade correspondent of like an insincere panegyrist when one is mine said: merely noting a few of his more obvious Mr. KASTENMEIER. Mr. Speaker, Instead of writing me back, talk to some qualities. Charles Seib is not only one of America's invaluable columnists; he also serves as body, have a meeting with somebody. If you As a teacher, he has been noted for don't do something about it, I will try to. an ombudsman, watchdog, and in-house his thorough preparation and deep critic of the press which makes him a I urge the House of Representatives to knowledge of American History, for his unique and much-needed individual. pass legislation in support of the District patience and fairness, and for his firm In his May 14, 1976, article in the Court decision. I hope to be able to belief that students should not be Washington Post, Charles Seib discusses reassure the children, especially, that treated as numbers, but rather as indi the matter of CIA in:filtration into Amer Congress has "had a meeting" about the viduals. Dr. Wright's administrative ap ican journalism and the foreign media. porpoises. proach is widely-even fondly-remem bered, for he pursued his tasks with a As chairman of the House Judiciary Sub sense of humanity and not with a pro committee on Courts, Civil Liberties, and AN OUTSTANDING EDUCATOR DE clivity for bureaucratic manipulation the Administration of Justice, I am nat SERVES RECOGNITION and insensitivity. A quiet and self-ef urally interested in and have dealt with facing man, he provided leadership and legislative and constitutional questions inspiration for his colleagues purely by involving the press. Thus, I am particu HON. JIM SANTINI the moral force of his example as a larly sensitive to the issue raised by OF NEVADA Christian gentleman. Charles Seib. IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES One cannot easily summarize the char There has been a relative lack of in vestigative zeal on the part of the press Monday, May 17, 1976 acter or the influence of John Wright. Those who have known him and who in making revelations about the CIA use Mr. SANTINI. Mr. Speaker, I am have been privileged to ha.ve been his of the press. One can only draw the con pleased to join with other proud Ne colleagues will agree that there is an in clusion that the American press cannot vadans in honoring Dr. JohnS. Wright tangible, ineffable quality to the man always be relied upon, particularly when upon the occasion of his retirement from a compound of gentleness, tolerance, pa it cannot do the right thing respecting the Department of History of the Uni tience, and good will. The final tribute, itself. The press, in this instance, has un versity of Nevada, Las Vegas, on May 15, then, must be to John Wright the man fortunately subordinated the public's 1976. Through his 20 years of distin a fine teacher, a devoted scholar, and a right-to-know to its own self-interests. guished service, Dr. Wright has made gentleman of dignity and great worth. The Seib article correctly states the in numerous contributions to the field of herent problem in this situation-one education and our understanding of cannot be part of the national security American history. police state apparatus and still claim to To convey to you the importance of THE NATURAL GAS BILL serve the free press. the accomplishments Dr. Wright has COMPROMISE lf its his hensive set of anti··infiation poUcies to Con happens to Muhammad. We all gonna come torical rate. As a result, the nation lost some gress every year. This program must include and go, Jesus, Moses, Zacharius, Jacob, An $500 billion in production of goods and serv an inflation information system to alert the drew, Bartholomew, John, Paul, Isaac, Isaiah, ices in the last five years alone. And we can President and Congress to emerging inflation you know, all come and go . . . I can't be expect to lose another $600 to $900 billion problems, a program to expand the supply of fired, you can't fire talent." by 1980. goods, services, labor and capital in tight Is he "clean" now? That astounding waste lies at the center of markets, and recommendations to strengthen "Straight as an arrow,'' he responds. our economic problems. And coming to grips antitrust enforcement and to increase com He says he still has "a contribution," to with it requires fundamental reform of the petition. Furthermore. the President is re make, "far beyond what people are lookin' way in which we manage our economy. It re quired to recommend any actmtnistrativll or at, they're lookin' at all this flare and this quires that this nation answer the basic legislative actions he feels are necessary to sizzle." What he wants to be, he says, is question of whether or not it is an important promote reasonable price stablity. "a liaison" between oil-rich countries and function of government to assure that all I disagree with those who claim that low impoverished ones. He says he's negotiating citizens willing and able to work are given un.employment means high inflation. In the with Kuwait, and wants to arrange loans for an opportunity to do so. 1960s inflation averaged only 2.3 per cent other countries. "You see, I'm a student of The Full Employment and Balanced and the unemployment rate averaged 4.8 per economics. I'm a businessman." He also ad Growth Act of 1976, authored by Rep. Augus cent. In the last few years we have seen mits he hasn't made his first deal yet--but, tus Hawkins and me, is one proposed answer that as unemployment came down from the then, even Ali told him he was "crazy" when to that question. This measure, co-sponsored 9 per cent level, inflation was cut in half he said he could raise $10 million for a fight by many other members of both houses of from about 12 per cent to 6 per cent. to Zaire. Congress, proposes a general economic policy This bill is not intended to provide all of "Every little promotion I do is a big pro framework and a package of programs that the answers to every eoonoinic situation that motion," he says. "Get ready for one of the vary from year to year depending on eco Inight develop. But it does face up to the cru biggest in the world, it has nothin' to do noinic conditions and decisions by Congress cial need to streamline government and with prize fighting, and it's gonna blow the and the President. This flexibility is a major make it more efficient and responsive. mind of everybody. strength of the bill. It requires the Congress and the Pres "So, I'll be around." The Act is based on two simple, yet pro ident to undertake a complete review of all Trust him. found, premises: First, that work and pro existing government rules and regulations to ductivity are better than welfare and waste; determine which still serve the public in and, second, that the full use of our human terest and which should be ellminated. And and capital resources is in the best interest it further requires them to carry out each of all the American people. year an In-depth evaluation and review of 20 PUTTING AMERICA BACK TO WORK The principal thrust of the Act is to en per cent of the dollar volume of existing courage the creation of job opportunities in federal programs. Thus, all government pro private enterprise through tax credit and grams would receive a special intensive eval HON. DOMINICK V. DANIELS budget policies that will stimulate the uation at least once every five years, thereby giving Congress and the executive branch OF NEW JERSEY private sector in a balanced and sustainable way. the information necessary to atnend, extend IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES Many of the auxiliary programs, such as or eliininate programs. Monday, May 17, 1976 the incentive program to revitalize de As a result, the bill does what many peo pressed areas, the skills-training and job ple only talk about. That is, it faces up to the Mr. DOMINICK V. DANIELS. Mr. placement grant.s and loans from the problems of overregulation, excessive bu Speaker, I am inserting into the RECORD development financing institutions, are reaucracy and programs that don't work or today an editorial which appeared in specifically designed to create jobs in private cost too much. the Washington Post on Friday, May 14, industry. Moreover, the programs for The Act also calls for more systematic and 1976, written by the distinguished Sen emergency public works and community de structured long-range planning. It became velopment would provide jobs in private obvious with the energy crisis and food price ator from Minnesota, HuBERT H. HUM explosion of the Inid-1970s that we must do PHREY. business by channeling funds to private contractors. Additional activities under the a much better job of anticipating future Senator HUMPHREY, who along with my bill will supplement and not supplant the problems, their econoinic impact and what friend and colleague, Representative private sector. It is not a public service to do about them. The bill allows us to look AUGUSTUS F. HAWKINS, authored H.R. 50, jobs proposal. ahead. the Full Employment and Balanced Beyond these measures. I am convinced The Act sets an initial objective of reduc that econoinic policy must be broadened to Growth Act of 1976, wrote this editorial ing unemployment among adults to not more as a response to editorials which ap treat systematically structural problems that than three per cent within four years. This is impede growth, employment and price sta peared in the Washington Post on March an ambitious goal, but it can be done. The bility. The bill reflects this conviction and 30 and May 8 dealing with jobs legis President is required to inform Congress would require a range of supplemental poli lation. of his views on this goal and to recommend cies: As chairman of the Manpower, Com any changes he believes are needed. A comprehensive youth employment pro pensation, and Health and Safety Sub The Act also provides for a new coopera gram to provide jobs, training and employ committee, which held 6 days of hear tive relationship whereby the President and ment services to young people who are un the Congress, working with the Federal able to find work without assistance; ings on H.R. 50, I am most concerned Reserve Board, would establish explicit, about the continuing unemployment A financial institution responsible for en numerical goals each year for employment, couraging private and public investment in problem which our Nation faces and the production and purchasing power. That is economically depressed regions, econoinic lack of initiative the present administra the most crucial reform in the legislation. sectors and inner cities; and tion is showing in dealing with this situ Last year, by contrast, instead of setting A program designed to correct federal tax, ation. My colleague Mr. HAWKINS has de positive goals that would challenge economic spending and employment policies that have voted long hours of hard work and in policy, the debate degenerated into nothing undermined the economic strength of certain in more than a superficial discussion of the regions and areas of the country. vestigation to the concepts envisioned size of the federal deficit and the rate of H.R. 50 and the formation of a flexible The Act recognizes that public policy has increase in the money supply. No progress responded much too slowly during periods of general economic policy framework. was made and policy suffered. economic instability and seeks to eliminate The report for H.R. 50 was filed by In addition, the bill places new require this problem with a comprehensive counter the Education and Labor Committee on ments on the Federal Reserve to make its cyclical manpower program, including such May 14. I strongly urge my colleagues to credit and interest rate policies respond to elements as accelerated public works, com consider this piece of legislation care these national economic poli-.::y decisions. If munity development, anti-recession support fully, and the importance of establishing they do not, the President can make recom to states and local governments, and emer a goal of full employment for our Na- mendations to the Board and Congress to gency public service jobs. These programs CXXII--896---Part 12 14200 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS May 17, 1976 are designed to begin and end. automatically in a day-care center: Child Garden Montes That was the aim of the vetoed b111. It de as economic conditions warrant. sori. layed the standards a bit longer and provided Finally, the Act creates a new Full Employ One of the kids 1s 3%-year-old Laura an extra $125 mill1on to help the states meet ment omce 1n the Department of Labor. It Lacey. She is well-dressed, bright, articulate, them. President Ford, 1n vetoing it, said 1s required to assist all those able and. will happy, active: the model of what we have nothing about the earlier agreement, worked ing to work to find decent jobs. A reservoir come to think of as the middle-class chtld. out so carefully by his own people and Con of useful publicly financed jobs will be But in fact the Federal Government pays her gress. He objected to the whole idea of Fed available for those who have no other em fee at the center, $130 a month. eral standards and introduced the new de ployment opportunities, up to the llm1ts of Laura Lacey is the reality at the heart of mand that day-care money be included in the annual numerical employmelllt ~oal set an abstract political debate. President Ford Federal block grants for community services. by Congress. recently vetoed a bill providing added fund Unless Congress acts on new legislation, Fed The direct cost of author1z1ng the Act 1s ing for day care, saying that it violated his eral standards will now take effect without less than $50 million to establish the general principles for Federal aid, and the Senate money to meet them. policy framework for full employment. The fatled to override the veto. Unless Congress The real reawn for the veto was evidently indirect costs-tha.t is, those determined by finds a way around the President's objec the specter of Ronald Reagan. The President subsequent legislation to fulfill the mandate tions. Laura Lacey w111 have to leave the wanted to look tough, and what could be of the Act-will be arrived at each year with Child Garden day-care center. tougher than to drive children out of day in the goal-setting process. Laura's mother, Geraldine Lacey, a slim care centers. Gerald Ford should have to ex Assuming a normal economic recovery, I attractive woman of 34, is separated from her plain to Laura and Geraldine Lacey. see no reason to expect 1nd1reot budget costs husband. She worked as a secretary but to exceed $8 to $12 billion, after taking into found, she said, that she did not make account the drastically decreased costs of enough to support herself and the chtld. So welfare and the increased revenues from she went back to school, to the University uf I. F. STONE ON "THE THREAT TO taxes. In contrast, under present policies, Minnesota, where she hopes to become a excessive unemployment in 1976 alone wtll nurse. While there she is on welfare--a fact THE REPUBLIC" cost the U.S. Treasury more than $50 btllion that troubles her. 1n lost tax revenues and increased costs for "People think of welfare as a leech on unemployment compensation, food stamps society," Mrs. Lacey said, "and I feel that HON. BELLA S. ABZUG and welfare. way, too. My ego is bruised. I want to study OF NEW YORK The full Employment and Balanced Growth to get off welfare." IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES Mrs. Lacey had Laura in a private home Act embodies the best in current thinking Monday, May 17, 1976 about how to ensure full production in our first-a woman minding half a dozen chil economy and modern, coordina.ted policy dren-but that turned out to be a depressing Ms. ABZUG. Mr. Speaker, the current making in our government. Undoubtedly, it place. Then she looked at many day-care cen issue of the New York Review of Books will be refined and improved during debate, ters before choosing Child Garden. includes a thoughtful article by I. F. discussion and committee hearings. But the "The kids looked so nice here," she said, strategy set forth in the Act provides our "and they were interested in Laura when she Stone on the congressional investiga best chance for sustaining a healthy economy cam~idn't resent a new child, as I'd seen tions of the intelligence community by while providing the greatest opportunities for in other places. I was so happy to see that. the House and Senate select committees. product! ve and constructive work to all And I though it mattered that there was a In addition to detailing the gross Americans. man teaching here. a:buses of the intelligence agencies and "I hope I don't have to move Laura their refusal to cooperate with the in now-1 don't think it's healthy to keep changing. I'm just depressed ..." vestigating committees, Mr. Stone goes The situation of Geraldine and Laura on to observe that they are not even very CHILDREN AND POLITICS Lacey 1s not unusual in the United States good at doing what they are supposed to now. There are 2.8 million American children be doing: between 2% and 6 who Uve with their mother The secret agencies fall in the task of HON. SHIRLEY CHISHOLM alone. And altogether, 6.5 mill1on of that age really intelligent assessment of human aspi OF NEW YORK have working mothers. ration and social forces for several reasons. The trend toward working mothers and One 1s that they attract a large proportion of IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES single-parent families has made day care screwballs, crackpots, paranoids. A second 1s Monday, May 17, 1976 an essential factor in many lives. It enables that the nature of the profession makes many women to work instead of going on paranoia its occupational disease. The third Mrs. CIDSHOLM. Mr. Speaker, in this welfare--and thereby to save public funds. is that ruling classes and bureaucracies gen morning's New York Times, an article Welfare costs the Government about three erally prefer the paranoid explanation. If by Anthony Lewis summarized the cur times as much as day care. trouble, if protest against the Vietnam war, rent national situation with respect to The Federal Government now provides if radical agitation for social justice, if day care. Despite the overwhelming sup $600 million a year for care of children in racial rising against discrimination are just poorer famtlies, matched by $200 mill1on the product of Satanic "subversives" plotting port on the part of this House, the failure from the states. The question inevitably de last week in the Senate to override Mr. unrest, then there 1s no need to amend poli bated is to what extent Federal standards for cies, to give up ruling class privileges. All Ford's unwise and unsound veto will day care should go along with Federal money. one need do is purge and imprison the "con have dire consequences for all child care Congressional supporters of day care funds, spirators." The spies blind their masters facilities in which children from pov such as Senator Walter Mondale of Minne comfortably to realities. It wasn'·t for lack of erty-level homes are enrolled. sota, have not wanted to set up a tight net spies that the Czars fell. The argument proffered by the ad work of Federal rules. They agree that regu ministration in Mr. Ford's veto message lation should be left largely to state and The Stone piece is eminently worth did nothing to answer to the real prob localities. reading, and I include its full text in the On the other hand, studies have shown RECORD at this point: lems which have resulted from a lack of widespread and gruesome examples of bad Federal moneys for title XX centers. day care, unsafe buildings, children ignored THE THREAT TO THE REPUBLIC The problem is one of the inability to because of inadequate staff, and so on. Sen {I. F. Stone) meet health and safety codes---not just ator Mondale and others in Congress have It can be said-but it would be unwise Federal staff requirements--and, be felt that Federal money should not be used to dwell on it-that the Church and Pike cause of this veto, many day care cen to send children to such places-that it committee reports represent the first time should be used, gradually, to assure a decent in history any country's legislature has ever ters throughout the country are facing environment in places where children will investigated, exposed, and shamed its 1ntell1- shutdowns. spend as much as eight hours a day. gence agencies and their "dirty tricks." Long I would like to insert into the RECORD In 1974, after long negotiations, the Ford before electronics, as far back as the Rome Mr. Lewis' eloquent discussion of "Chil Administration and Congress agreed on mod of the Caesars, a spy-haunted society feared, dren and Politics," for the consideration est Federal standards. A new law required as Tacitus tells us, that somehow walls day care centers, first, to meet state and local might have ears.1 But a degenerate Senate, of all my colleagues in the House: rules on fire, safety and health. And it estab ClllLDREN AND POLITl:CS lished stamng standards, for example one (By Anthony Lewis) adult teacher or volunteer to about six chil 1 "Never was Rome more distracted and MlNNEAPOLIS.-Nestled against a Wall of dren between 2% and 6. terror-stricken. Meetings, conversations, the St. Mary's Basilica, a hulking old church near When the time approached to apply those ear of friend and stranger were alike downtown M1nneapolis, 1s a small play standards, it turned out that many centers shunned; even things mute and lifeless, the ground. Ten children, 2% to 6 years old, use could not meet them. Conditions were worse very roofs and walls, were eyed With sus the swings and slide and run over to talk than had been realized. The states asked for picion" (The Annals of Tacitus, 4.69, Mod With their teacher, Michael Young. They are more time and more Federal help. ern Library edition). May 17, 1976 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 14201 though constitutionally and nomlnally still kind, and indeed all "do-gooders," a favorite denoted by "Italics" and a footnote explain all-powerful, lacked the will to do anything term of contempt with J. Edgar Hoover. The ing them. about it. bomb squads, Red squads, anarchist squads An example Is Chapter X on CIA influence Unfortunately there is little prospect that appeared in many cities during the ninteenth in academic Institutions, the media, andre our Senate, and our Congress, will behave century were the FBI's progenitors, as they ligious organizations. There are several any better. Between the time this is being rema.in its collaborators. American history italicized references to "university officials written and the time it will be read, the can be read as a continuous struggle between and professors" who "provide leads and make Senate is expected to vote on a first timid democracy and property, and in that per introductions for intelligence purposes." One effort at reform, an intelligence oversight spective there is no doubt where the secret suspects that originally the phrasing plainly committee. But its prospects are dim, and police stand. said they helped the CIA recruit on cam some of its provisions dubious. Their true role as the janissaries of prop pus. The report as published did not specu The Republican White House and the erty is only implicit, of course, in these late on the fact that the relation between Democratic Old Guard in the Senate are in carefully manicured Church reports. Nor do university officials and professors on the one a bipartisan alliance against any real re the reports make more than a partial breach hand and students on the other Is hardly form. A similar coalition in the House-led in the secrecy which shrouds the agencies. one of equallty, and the door ls thus opened by the Republican McClory of illinois and We must assume, after all we have learned, to favoritism or discrimination, depending the Democrat Stratton of New York-is that the committee staff itself was penetrat on the student's reaction to the indecent blocking bills to revive and clear the way ed by the agencies. The reports themselves proposal. for publication of the suppressed Pike re as internal evidence will reveal to a careful The most dramatic evidence of last-min port. The secret agencies are smugly confi reading-were the product of a continuous ute struggle is the blank white and the no dent that they have not only weathered the wrangle among the staff, the committee, and tation "[deleted]" which cover all but a few storm but entrenched themselves. the agencies. The agencies controlled what lines on page 332 of Book 1. This was the Their strength has deep roots. The great went out of their files and what went into concluding portion of that section on the masters of property in our society are un the reports. The effort to censor as much as total size of the aggregate intelligence budg willing to give up "dirty tricks" in defense possible and the effort to tell as much as et for fiscal year 1976, which begins at page of their investments and privileges at home possible have left their marks. The final 330 with the sentence, "The Committee's and abroad. For them, the end justifies the product must be read with extreme care. analysis indicated that [deleted] blllion con means, just as surely as for their adversaries Every formulation, almost every word, must stituted the direct costs to the United States in Moscow and Peking. Radicals, opponents be evaluated not only for what it does say for its national intelligence program for FY of the existing order, critics who go too far, but for what it does not say. The latter is 1976." A footnote said it was "deleted pend are fair game, outside the law, on both sides. sometimes the more revealing. Ing further Committee consideration," and It is not an accident that--as the Church The committee had power to subpoena, on the very morning the report was given to the committee found-the FBI has twice as paper, but there are indications throughout press the committee voted to let the full Sen many informers in radical or liberal organi the report that the agencies withheld much ate decide on whether to disclose the full zations as in organized crime. in many areas which the committee wanted figure. The main job of a political secret police to explore. "The Central Intell1gence Agen The nonsense that publication of that fig in any society is to keep in power those who cy," the committee says in the introduction ure would somehow reveal secrets to the have it. When the Roman Senate, after one to Volume 1 (p. 7), "and other agencies of enemy prevailed in committee and wm prob particularly terrible scandal, tried to put the executive branch have limited the Com ably prevail on the Senate floor, although some limit on informers, the Emperor mittee's access to the full record.... In former CIA director James Schlesinger testi Tiberlus interposed his veto, saying, "Bet some highly important areas . . . the Com fied (p. 377) "that our enemies already know ter to subvert the constitution than to re mittee has been refused access to files or doc in the first place and it's broadly published." move its guardians." 2 Though no one today uments." Elsewhere (p. 470) the report says that di speaks so frankly, that is still the answer In assessing the feasib111ty of congressional rect and indirect inte111gence costs are of those who cannot bring themselves al oversight, one must not forget this initial roughly 3 percent of the total budget. The together to prohibit "dirty tricks." and successful defiance of the power given total Is now over $400 b1llion. That would To understand the Intelligence miasma, Congress by the Constitution to oversee and bring the total costs, direct and indirect, one must look at the family tree of the CIA. control every department of government. secret and budgeted, of all inte111gence to The CIA is only the Institutionalization, This muted note indicates that the Church about twelve b1llion dollars. But committee though on a vast and unprecedented scale, committee knuckled under. The precedent sources, in this deplorable and labyrinthine of what we have done for more than a bodes 111 for congressional oversight. If this comedy, say that this figure is too high and century and a half in Latin America and was the best the Church committee could that their own way of reporting was mislead an earller China under the rubric of defend do, after the multitudinous revelations of ing. So now we must wait for the promised Ing "American lives and property." Watergate, what can one expect of a per Senate vote on whether to disclose the real Then we used State Department agents manent committee when press and public figure or leave it hidden. That vote will be and the US Marines. The Marines were bill opinion are once again somnolent? a neuralgic point in American constitutional collectors for National City Bank and en This withholding of whatever the agen history. forcers for the banana, oil, and sugar com cies did not wish to disclose was only the The battle over the figure still to be fought panies. What the CIA has done in Indo beginning of the struggle. At the outset of Its on the Senate floor Involves the most funda china, Iran, and Chile Is no diiferent in kind inquiry the committee put Its neck into a mental constitutional considerations. Con from the crass way Marines turned patriots noose by agreeing "in a meeting with Presi gress has two weapons in dealing with the into bandits and puppets into presidents in dent Ford" that It would not ~close any inte111gence agencies. One Is the power of Central America and the caribbean. It is classified information given it without con disclosure. The other Is the power of the only the means that have grown to keep sulting the agencies and "carefully consld purse. A vote to blank out the total w111 be a pace with the expansion of the American er[lng) the Executive's reasons for maintain vote to surrender both powers to the agen empire and new forms of exploitation like ing secrecy." The committee says that it re cies. The fight against absolutism, the fight the multinationals.s tained final decision. But It was inhibited for parliamentary supremacy, began with You cannot run an empire without secrecy. because attempts to go against agency wishes the power of the purse. In the eyes of the And you have to be ready to deal with tur would risk a White House blast and a refusal Framers nothing was more important in the bulent natives abroad and dissenting citizens of cooperation. So "virtually all difficulties Constitution than Article I, Section 9, at home. The FBI is well equipped to aid were resolved" and "the only significant ex Clause 7, which embodies that power. It says the CIA in that task. Its family tree, its ception" was the release of the Assassination "no Money shall be drawn from the Treas dominant prejudice against liberals and the Report last November even though the execu ury" except In pursuance of appropriations left, its coziness with the right, go back to tive branch thought this "would harm na made by law and that "a regular Statement the instinctive host111ty of propertied inter tional security." Since, even Ford had to go and Account of the Receipts and Expendi ests to whatever elements in our society on record against assassination, at least of tures of all public Money shall be published seemed to threaten property. This is how other nations' leaders and at least in peace from time to time." The CIA, unlike the they saw abolitionists, trade union orga time, the White House and the agencies had FBI, has from its beginning completely nizers, socialists, anarchists, radicals of any to swallow defeat on that one. evaded that clause. W111 the Senate take the But down to and well past the original final step In constitutional emasculation by 2 Tacitus, Annals 4.30. deadline for the report, it Is clear that the voting to keep secret even the aggregate to 3 General Smedley Butler, one of the best committee had to suffer constant revision tal of the cost of alllntelllgence agencies? and bravest men the Marine Corps ever pro and censorship. The committee notes that The baneful influence does not end with duced, got into trouble for tell1ng the truth three chapters, on "Cover," "Espionage," and the suppression of facts and figures. The re about the imperialist purposes he had "Budgetary Oversight," were omitted alto ports read as If written not only with the served from Cuba to the Philippines. See gether on the insistence of the agencies, agencies peering over the shoulders of the Lowell Thomas's biography of him, Old Gim along With two sections of the chapter on writers but actually participating in the let Eye ( 1933) and Butler's recently repub "Covert Action of the CIA" and one section phrasing. There are some passages which lished War Is a Racket (1935) tn Three Gen o~ the chapter "Department o~ State." Else sound as 1f they were written or rewritten at erals on War, Garland Publishing, New York where "particular passages" rewritten on the Langley or ln the FBI headquarters. There ia and London. insistence of the intelligence agencies were throughout a tendency to opaque, sotto voce, 14202 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS May 17, 1976 bureaucratic phraseology of a kind at which rest, then there is no need to amend policies, fevt of us fully realized until the Church the White House and the State Department to give up ruling class privileges. All one report on the FBI the extent to which J. have always been adept. The prose style-to need do is purge and imprison the "conspira Edgar Hoover had been practicing "dirty single out one of the recent masters in this tors." The spies blind their masters com tricks" at home. The most shameful, of genre-is sometimes downright Nixonian. fortably to realities. It wasn't for lack of course, was the long harassment of Martin There are many instances of what could legit spies that the Czars fell. Luther King and the civil rights movement. imately be called brain-washing-the bland, The CIA could foment the mob that killed It is depressing that despite all we now know almost subliminal assertion as eternal veri Mossadeq in Iran. It could help to bring Attorney General Levi has rejected recom ties of dubious propositions, propositions the about the killing of Lumumba in the Congo mendations from within the Justice Depart investigators were supposed to challenge and and Allende in Chile, but there is no evidence ment for an independent citizens' investiga test, not to accept without examination as that it can successfully Canute the tides tion of King's assassination and insists on major premises. A prime example is the of change in our time. Each side in the cold turning it back for another self-inquiry by statement at the very beginning of the CIA war struggle now beginning again has prof the FBI. This is the only field of law enforce report that "a national intelligence system ited by the excesses and inhumanities of the ment in which it is left to the suspect to in is a permanent and necessary part of our other. Read Sakharov's great memoranda and vestigate himself. government. The system's value to the coun ask yourself whether the stultification and And it is alarming that even the Church try has been proven." rigidiflcation that secrecy has imposed on committee recommendations would still al Humanity will never get rid of the intel Soviet science, industry, and society recom low the FBI to engage in "preventive intelli ligence miasma until that overblown non mend a similar experiment on our side. gence," the catchword which has allowed the sense is challenged. The greatest intelligence Intelligence agencies thrive by telling the worst abuses and invasions of privacy and networks of our time failed to prevent the boss he's doing fine. When reports signal the basic rights in the past. We applaud Senator most disastrous surprise attacks their regimes truth, they are more than often ignored. Philip A. Hart for pointing out in a separate suffered. Pearl Harbor, the Nazi attack on There were, we now know, intelligence re opinion appended to the Church report on the Soviet Union. the place and timing of ports which questioned the dominant delu the FBI that the recommendations in this the D-day invasion of Hitler's Fortress Eu sions about the Vietnam war, which warned respect would for the first time give "statu rope were historic disasters. The American, that the Bay of Pigs invasion would not tory authorization" for the very abuses the the Soviet, and the Nazi regimes all had in trigger a popular uprising in CUba, and which committee has exposed. telligence networks of a magnitude and advised two years before Allende's election The intell1gence agencies have become a power without precedent in all history, even that the days of our copper monopoly in cancer that threatens the Republic. The au under the Czars and the First Empire of Chile were numbered no matter who won the thor! ty of the FBI should be restricted to Napoleon. Yet they suffered unprecedented coming election. But they were ignored and crimes. Terrorism is a crime, even though loss through effective surprise in those three men who ventured such reports risked the politicially motivated, and can be handled tremendous attacks. One put the Nazi armies query, "Who let that pinko in?" like any other crime. This and all other Ictnds almost at the gates of Moscow before effec You cannot--as even such great liberal of crime would be better handled if the FBI tive defense could be organized; the second papers as The New York Times and The did not waste so substantial a portion of its crippled our naval and air forces in the Pa Washington Post in their queasy editorials resources on the whole spectrum of what cific from Hawaii to the Philippines; the on the CIA advise-square the circle. You it calls "do-gooders,'' all of them treated third was the beginning of the end for Hitler cannot make lawlessness lawful. You cannot prima facie as suspect. And it should be made ism. All three regimes had explicit and cor bring "dirty tricks" within a constitutional a statutory offense for the FBI to practice rect warnings, but in all three cases the warn system. In this bicentennial year we are for "dirty tricks," to act as an tagency for se ings were drowned in the sheer volume of in getting the basic lessons of the Revolution cretly defaming citizens it dislikes and dis flowing reports and by the failure of the and the basic advantages and virtues of an rupting their lives by just that kind of "dis center to assess all this information cor open society. It cannot be open without risk. information" in which the CIA has special rectly. "Intelligence" is not the same as but the risks of free discussion over and over ized abroad and can also resort to at home. intelligence. again have proven superior to the risks of I believe the Church CIA report does not Intelligence networks have mainly been repression. Some intelligence activity is in tell the full truth about the CIA's origins. proven effective in intimidating their own escapable for military and law enforcement "Dirty tricks" were justifiable for the OSS, peoples. But no regime has yet been saved purposes, but how much? The evidence sug its predecessor, in wartime; the CIA took over from disastrous error by "intelligence." The gests that we are drowning in intelligence, the same practices in peace. Its conditioning, American Republic got along quite well in that we need not more but less "collection," its personnel, and a substantial part of its ternally without a Federal Bureau of Inves not more spying but more analysis and activities stm link it indissolubly to "dirty tigation until 1908 and without a "dirty thought. And thought requires debate. And tricks." I believe the wise course would be to tricks" agency abroad until 1947. Since then, you cannot have debate so long as ideas outlaw "dirty tricks" and abolish the CIA as the Church report says, the U.S. "has de and expressions are watched and "collected." altogether and let its legitimate intell1gence voted enormous resources" to its intelligence There is no room in an open society for a functions be taken over by other agenciNt network. But never has the United States thought police, and that is what the FBI and Otherwise Big Brother is here to stay. been more poorly advised and suffered more tbe CIA, With occasional assists from the shameful pratfalls than in that period. The military, have become. postwar successes of Western capitalism have The picture which emerges from the been due to the vitality of enterprise, the Church reports, muted and mutilated as superior advantages of an open society, and they are, must be made explicit. The CIA has TRIBUTE TO MORRIS B. CHAIN the moral bankruptcy of the Soviet regime. become a huge conglomerate, With its secret And that last was more than anything else tentacles in almost every section of American HON. WILLIAM M. KETCHUM the product of Russia's reliance on secrecy life, prostituting the universities, books, the and the secret police. The dead-end course press, and religious institutions; it runs a OF CALIFORNIA of Stalinism is the same course on which we network of businesses at home and abroad, IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES are being impelled in the name of "national some wholly fictitious, some real enough to security." be insurance companies and aviation lines. Monday, May 17, 1976 If the U.S. is hated by the best youth in The magnitude is veiled but at one point the Mr. KETCHuM. Mr. Speaker, I am Iran, in South Korea, in Chile, in the Domin report says that these ostensibly private greatly privileged to count among my ican Republic, wherever the writ of our businesses gross $1.6 blllion a year and gen constituency a most remarkable man, secret agencies and its puppet regimes has erate profits substantial enough to replenish run, the Soviet Union is hated in Kiev, in a CIA "Contingency Fund" from which it acknowledged as one of the country's Warsaw, in Prague, and in Bucharest for the can finance secret activities wholly outside leading defense attorneys, and truly a very same reasons. The agencies on both sides the orbit of any supervision or audit, even legend to those who know him. Morris have succeeded to the extent that brutality from within the Executive. B. Chain, of Bakersfield, Calif., is not and repression can succeed, but the price will The whole Angola business was financed in only my constituent, but my personal be paid in future explosions on both sides. this way. The CIA has become a big business, friend. Therefore, it was with great The secret agencies fail in the task of a conglomerate, operating behind various pleasure that I learned of Mr. Chain's really intelligent assessment of human aspi "legitimate" fronts as a conspiracy against selection to receive the Kern County ration and social forces for several reasons. society, with its "hit men" and "enforcers" One is that they attract a large proportion on the Ma.fia model. It can provide-and has Bar Association's respected "Bench and of screwballs, crackpots, paranoids. A second provided-presidents with the means to oper Bar Award" recently. I regret that I was is that the nature of the profession makes ate outside the constitutional system, even to not able to participate in the banquet paranoia its occupational disease. The third the point of waging secret war. Here lies the paying honor to Morris Chain, and is that ruling classes and bureaucracies gen lesson of Watergate, already half forgotten. would like at this time to offer my own It has been said over and over again that erally prefer the paranoid explanation. If tribute in this House. trouble, if protest against the Vietnam war, the bribery, the corruption of elections, the if radical agitation for social justice, if racial assassinations, and the other "dirty tricks" Morris Chain has practiced law for 44 rising against discrimination are just the the CIA has been practicing abroad must in years. Throughout his career, often de product of Satanic "subversives" plotting un- evitably spread to the domestic front. But fending clients accused of the most sen- May 17, 1976 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 14203 sational of crimes, he has exemplified the should be tota.lly suppressed, and all the taining to safety and the safe operation of a basic roots of the American judicial sys powers of government exerted, under the boat on the river," he said. preservation of internal peace, Virtue, and "Barge tow operators need to know more tem. He has dedicated himself to assur good order, as well as for the defense of their about the channel. When you're carrying ing that one's right to receive proper lives, liberties, and properties, against the passengers for hire, it's a little more com defense in a fair trial was protected, and hostile invasions and cruel depredations of plicated. We're classed as a passenger-carry has perpetuated the philosophy that an their enemies. ing vessel." individual is innocent until proven Blackmore figures there are those who otherwise. Referring to the event in a letter to think operating a. ferry is easy as crossing Above and beyond his outstanding James Warren, Adams stated: the street, but he disagrees. This Day the congress has passed the most "What tricks you, gives you more prob contributions to the judicial system, important Resolution that ever was taken in lems than anything else is high winds. Some Morris Chain represents another great America. winds will change two to three times a day. American tradition: a man who reached "You must remember how to cope with the top though his own hard work, de It was obvious that the United Colonies different winds. I judge the velocity and wind termination, and continuing effort to were on the verge of declaring their in direction by looking at the water, the type excel. pendence. of wave and how large it is. While he is now the senior partner in "When the Wind velocity gets up to 40 firm miles an hour, it'll blow the top off white the of Chain, Younger, Jameson, caps. when it gets above 45 miles an hour, we Lemucchi, Busacca, and Williams, Mor FERRY TALE tie up." ris Chain had no easy road to his cur He remembers a storm in 1960--"the first rent successful position. Fresh out of time I was ever scared," he said. law school, he sought employment ask HON. WILLIAM L. HUNGATE . "We were going up river when we pulled ing only for the experience he would OF MISSOURI in and tied up. A lot of times you get severe gain, offering to work w!thout salary. IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES Winds. But the wind slacked off to about 15 miles an hour, and just about the time we For 5 years, he served as court Monday, May 17, 1976 appointed public defender, often pre got back in the channel, a Wind started blow Mr. HUNGATE. Mr. Speaker, Allen ing from the northeast 75 to 80 miles an paring his own cases without benefit of hour. assistance or investigation by others; as Blackmore, one of my constituents from "It blew water over the deck of the barge he says, he simply could not afford it. Canton, Mo., is retiring after operating eight to 10 inches deep. We blew back in a Determined to succeed, he often worked a ferry on the Mississippi River for 46 mile down the river. 18 hours per day preparing his cases. years. I believe my colleagues will be in "Rain and hall and that Wind . . . it was Morris Chain is well known for the terested in his story and I submit this terrible. We couldn't tell any direction. No last chapter of his "ferry tale": control at all. crystal ball he keeps in his office. He "I'll always remember that one. We respect uses it to demonstrate to clients the un CANTON FERRY PILOT LAUNCHES FINAL SEASON those dark and stormy clouds, I'll tell you." predictability of the law. (By Susan Denkler) Storms brewing up north also command Mr. Chain is a member of numerous When Allen Blackmore landed a ferry for some respect from Blackmore, who knows organizations, including the National the first time, he launched a career that ex excessive rainfall and snow melt combine Association of Criminal Defense Law tended 46 years and the Width of a river. for a spring flood. yers; the American Judicature Society; Now he's ready to step down. The danger for a ferry during flood times "It was a big thrill when I was able to get is minimal, but if the water rises above the State Bar of California; the Kern in that boat and land it myself," Blackmore their high water landing north of the main County Bar Association; the American said. landing, the ferry is out of commission. Trial Lawyers Association. He currently "We were living close to the ferry on a "In 1973, we lost about 30 days due to high serves as President of the Kern County farm when I started riding on the river. As water. It went over our high water landing Chapter of the California Trial Law a boy I would help With the decking chores. in 1960, '65 and '73. Every one's been a little yers Association, a position he also held Ellis Inman hired me when I was about 18 higher." years old." In 1973, the official stage in Canton was in 1964. For 10 years, Blackmore continued to work 24.49 feet. In 1953, Morris Chain received an out of Batchtown, Ill., for the West Point "We've had some high water, I'll tell you, other great--and well deserved-honor: Ferry which crossed to Winfield, Mo. but we don't look for too much this year, he was named "Man of the Year" by the June 8, 1940 marked a move to the Mis unless we get excessive rain. If you don't Jewish War Veterans. souri side of the river when Blackmore be have high water by the 15th of June, you're To Morris, his wife, Edith, and their came owner and operator of his own ferry reasonably safe." family, I say congratulations on a job located at Canton. He's been there ever since. Even With changeable Winds, storms and I "There's not many left," Blackmore said occasional high water, Blackmore professes well done. know tha:t my colleagues recently. "We're the only one between here a love for his kind of life. here in the House will be honored to join and the headwaters of Minnesota. There's "I can hardly think of anything I dislike with me in recognizing the achievements been a ferry here since 1853." about it. I've always enjoyed the work. This of this outstanding figure in the practice Blackmore said he plans to retire in De is always a little more of a challenge." of law. cember, but quickly adds, "I'm not going to Few dignitaries have taken the 10-minute quit altogether. The wife and I plan on doing ride, but Blackmore has a lot of regular some traveling, and I'll catch up on some customers, commuting to work and school, TWO HUNDRED YEARS AGO TODAY of the fishing I've mi&::ed out on all these and he's crossed tourists from every state years." in the union. He "conservatively" e~timates making 380,- "We have quite a few people who come HON. CHARLES E. WIGGINS 000 to 395,000 round trips With the ferry in down, park the car and ride across. A lot of his lifetime. people take their children or grandchildren OF CALIFORNIA "We'll make about 35 round trips in a day. for a ride on a Saturday. IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES During the busy time we'll make about 10 "They're just hard to find in this part Monday, May 17, 1976 more than that ..." of the country. People have talked bridges as The season opens around mid-March and long as I've been operating a ferry. It'll die Mr. WIGGINS. Mr. Speaker, 200 years extends through mid-December, Blackmore down, then start up again and die down ... ago, on May 15, 1776, the Continental said. The busiest period is June through De "If they did build one I imagine it would Congress approved the preamble to the cember when many tourists and a lot of be closer to Keokuk or Hannibal, and the farmers' grain is crossed. type of road would be an interstate. If the resolution urging the colonies to estab "We cross plenty of wheat in the first two bridge wasn't right close to the ferry, I don't lish governments, if they had not already weeks of July. The tourist season is generally expect it would affect us much." done so. John Adams, ·one of the fore busiest June 15 through Labor Day." His ferry holds six cars, four loaded trucks, most proponents of independence, wrote Neil Kizer, an operator, and deckhand one big semi tractor trailer or two tandems. the preamble, which read in part: Michael Hitt help out. It's the second one he's owned, bought in It appears absolutely irreconclleable to rea Blackmore said he was required to take an 1955. He paid $15,000 for the barge, $7,000 soa and good Conscience, for the people o! examination With the St. Louis Coast Guard for the launch. these colonies now to take the oaths and af before he could operate the ferry. The writ A like model today would bring closer :firmations necessary !or the support o! any ten examination consisted of about 50 ques to $40,000 for the barge, $30,000 for the government under the crown of Great Brit tions on the "rules of the road." launch, he said. ain, and it is necessary that the exercise of "You· need to know all the different laws The ferry will continue to operate. Black- every kind of authority under the said crown and rules, lights and buoys. Everything per- more's successor is John Froman, a native 14204 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS May 17, 1976 of minute Meyer, Ill., across from the Daddy's children all help out, some full-time "Always", he said, "you have to get edu landing. and others part-time. Then there are Rae's cated, you have to be thrifty, you have to Blackmore and his wife, Hazel, plan to two sons, both helping out after school. One save and a family has to work together". spend their winters in Alamo, Tex., and their of her boys goes to the Virgin Islands Col Eventually, he put all those factors to summers back in the home area. lege and tends bar at Daddy's most nights. gether so well that he owned seven acres of -..We'll · always call this home," Blackmore Also there are what you might call itinerant land, plently of room for vegetables, cows, said. relatives. goats and of course, first one house and then "All these years I've been outside on the Everybody gets along swimmingly and by others, all for the family. And the roadside river, in tbe sunshine. I couldn't stand to working very hard. They are in the kitchen, acre was the site, then as now, of "Daddy's". be cooped up. behind the bar, and out among the custom Rae inherited her father's good business "There's people that have told me, 'I ers, who are accommodated-50 maximum sense. First she learned the beauty shop busi wouldn't have that ferry 1f you'd give It to at a time-in the windowed main dining ness, and ran her own In Manhattan for me.' But I can't think of anyone I would room that looks out to the lagoon and that years while married and raising her two trade jobs with. picturesque fleet of fishing boats. boys. Now she has a beauty shop in down "It's been good to me," he said. Already Rae has expansion plans in mind, town Charlotte Amalie, as well as the res involving a cocktail lounge where there taurant. would be "some nice quiet music", as she The St. Thomas branch of Chase Man puts it, her eyes dancing in anticipation. hattan Bank thinks so well of her business abilities that It advanced the $150,000 neces A LIVING MEMORIAL TO ONE MAN'S Thus, Daddy's really is family. Cold in sary to establish the restaurant. But the GOODNESS deed is the temporary stranger who stops local bankers pretty well knew what kind of by to enjoy some of the best food in the a family Daddy had put together, helped by Caribbean, and somehow manages to leave his wife, who still survives as a quiet ma HON. RON DE LUGO without feeling he is a part of that family. triarchal presence. For in St. Thomas, char Rae hardly will permit it I OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS acter is prime collateral anytime. Locals, of course, know what to expect IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES Daddy llved long enough to see his res as they telephone in their reservations, and taurant open. He was in a wheelchair at the Monday, May 17, 1976 then stop by for first, second or even third last, aged 72, and he would roll himself to dinner sittings. But among those who have the front patio of the main house, higher Mr. DE LUGO. Mr. Speaker, in our fast come in for the first time and later walked up the hlll, to watch in serenity as the con changing world, it is nice to know that away cousins-cozy, you would have to in struction crews busied themselves on the some things stay the same. For years, clude just this first year the Prince and great new structure below. "Daddy's," a small eatery in Charlotte princess of Denmark; Miss Black America; "Daddy's" was opened in August of 1974. Amalie on St. Thomas, U.S. Virgin Is top government officials, both local and na Daddy died in October, his tasks accom tional; also wandering Haitians, honeymoon plished, Oh Lord. lands, was a haven for the bone-weary ers, island fishermen, and cruise ship visitors and hungry. Isiah Venzen, "Daddy" to away from theii- ships for a couple of hours. almost everyone, became famous for his According to Rae, who bubbles over with meals, and cherished for his friendship. cheerful gab, there never has been a short OAK PARK, ILL., NAMED "ALL His whole family, three generations order roadside stand like the one run by her worth, became involved in the restaurant beloved Daddy. AMERICA CITY" with its ambience of warmth and good First of all, nobody ever called him any cheer. In 1974 a new "Daddy's" opened, thing but "Daddy". He was a deep-chested HON. HENRY J. HYDE powerhouse of a man, with arms like baseball operated by Rae Venzen Brunn, daugh OF ILLINOIS ter of the late "Daddy" Venzen. While bats. His menu, 1f you could call it that, con IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES the building was new, the old traditions sisted of whatever Daddy chose, depending Monday, May 17, 1976 of the original "Daddy's" remain. Re on what nearby fishermen had brought in cently, the st. Thomas Daily News pub on that particular day. Mostly, requests for Mr. HYDE. Mr. Speaker, as the Con lished an article celebrating this re meals meant that Daddy would have to in gressional Representative of the 6th Dis markable man, his family, and his en terrupt his domino game, or his "medical" trict of Dlinois, it gives me great pride to terprise. It is surely a tribute to one consulting with neighbors, customers. announce that the village of Oak Park cronies, and mere passers-by. Those who man's goodness in his dealing with his has been named an "All-America City" fellow man. I recommend it to my could pay for their food did so; those who couldn't just then ate anyway, and paid by the National Municipal League. Only colleagues : later. 10 cities in the country have been selec Fifteen minutes up, down and around the The Venzens are an old St. Thomas family. ted for this honor, and I am truly not Red Hook Road from downltown Charlotte One of Rae's grandfathers, a blue-eyed surprised that Oak Park is one of them. I Amalie, near Benner's Hlll and across the Frenchman, bought one of the first parcels have long thought of Oak Park as an out road from fishing fleet dock, sits tthe world's of land on the breeze-cooled east end of the standing community-{)ne that cities and only monument with menus--$150,000 res island. And as a Virgin Islander born and taurant honoring the late Isiah "Daddy" towns throughout the Nation could study bred, Daddy, her father, had warm wisdom, with great profit. Venzen. Naturally, the restaurant is called and an apparently irresistible personality "Daddy's"-at least it seems natural to call that didn't need to be taught In the island Certainly the greatness of any com it th81t iln St. Thomas, where family ties are schools where he learned his letters. munity is nothing more than a reflection very close, it has become this year's "In" spot For example, he is remembered still for of the attitudes of its inhabitants. It is for vacationers and locals alike, who go there uncommon skills with herbal cures, particu evident that Oak Park is a community to feast on fresh local fiS'h, sizzling steaks larly by the local fishermen, who recall and chops. that :reflects the attitude of public the paralyzing hangovers and other varied spirited people with ideas, enthusiasm, It all adds up to a warm St. Thomian disorders that always vanished with h:is story, honoring a local patriarch who num dosing. zest, and energy. bered his friends in the thousands during He produced his "medicines" in 5-gallon I am sure that the people of Oak Park the three generations in which he raised a kerosene cans, boiled fiercely for hours over share a deep sense of pride and ful:ftll family of seven from the proceeds of a tiny an outdoor fire. ment in their community's latest award. roadside shack stand. One of his former "patients" ruminated As their Congressman-but more than The "new" Daddy's stands on the very on Daddy from the immense cockpit of his that, as a longtime admirer of Oak same site, only now dinnerware gleams in 65-foot charter fishing boat, moored across Park-I share in that sense of pride. the soft candlelight on tables, artwork by the road. "Daddy", he said simply, "was closer local a:rne of ALL-AMERICA; ACTION, NOT STATUS, WON ton, Sara Bode, Dawn Goshorn and Bobbie 10 communities so designated nationwide- We never had any real doubt that Qak Raymond played a major part in Oak Park's oak Park now boasts a stable, racially inte Park deserved a.n All-American City designa selection. grated population; a thriving downtown tion and a lot of other honors as well. Last But, Oak Park won because Oak Park has shopping mall; and an architectural preser week's announcement resolved at least the people who are not surprised by the work vation program that has attracted national one doubt about whether this award would that has been accomplished in the village. attention. arrive. In fact, they would only be surprised by a In the 19608, however, dire predictions were Our heartiest congratulation to the hard lack of positive action. being made for the historic suburb adjacent working committee members who put to Oak Park won because residents have to Chicago's deteriorating West Side neigh gether the presentations which won the shown they not only want a good community, borhoods. award-it could not have been won with but are willing to put in the time and effort Demographers (population experts] said it out their efforts. to effect positive change. was only a matter of time before the 4~ From what we know of the judging proc Oak Parkers have always known they have square-mile, rectangular-shaped community ess, excellent presentations alone do not a.n outstanding community. Now, the coun became a.n extension of the city's black make winners: they simply display to full try knows, too. The World remains Bullish ghetto. advantage the fundamental characteristics on Oak Park. Real estate expel'ts predicted property of a vital community. This community values in the village would plunge in the face warts and all, as they say in the movie about No DAMPENED SPmiTS AT CITY CELEBRATION of a.n influx of minority groups. us-is vital. Shoppers began abandoning the village's (By Jeanne Quinn) And there lies the difference between Dak aging business district in favor of the ultra Park and the also-ra.ns. This community, Outside, the All-America City was being modern, enclosed shopping centers that were long since built up, now aging, is dealing pummeled with a freakish combination of popping up like corn in suburban fields. with economic and social challenges in vital, snow, rain, and wind. But inside Oak Park's All signs indicated Oak Park was going energetic ways, involving plenty of problems Village Hall on Madison St., the atmosphere downhill. The former hometown of such and disputes. One of the hallmarks of the was warm and cordial. Nearly a thousand giants as architect Frank Lloyd Wright and process, one of the key judging criteria this residents had braved the unseasonable authors Ernest Hemingway and Edgar Rice year, is citizen involvement. It takes many weather-mix to witness Oak Park's celebra Burroughs was supposed to become a. slum. forms here, from a core of dedicated volun tion of Oak Park: the official naming of the But it didn't happen and the fact that it Village a.s "All-America City" in 1976. didn't is a. tribute to the tenacity and esprit teers through the on-again off-again task In this Bicentennial year, many felt it was forces to the occasional event ·of mass de corps of is residents. participation. particularly significant that Oak Park had To meet the challenge of achieving racial garnered a.n award traditionally reserved for integration in housing rather than succumb This is a community which long has had newer or more spectacular cities. Indeed, Oak ing to the "Chicago pattern" of block-by the key attributes of a highly desirable place Park was the only Illinois municipality to block resegregation, the Oak Park Housing to live--location, schools, quality housing, receive the award this year. Center was formed by 15 local residents in business services and civic institutions that Shortly after the start of the two-hour, 1971. work. Those things don't carry much weight Sunday afternoon celebration, Vlllage ofH Its two major objectives are to assure that with All-America. judging panels. cials received the "All-America City" flag blacks seeking housing in Oak Park will not They ask not "What do you have?" but from a representative of the National Mu be concentrated in one section of the village rather "What are you doing?" nicipal League. Bill Kurtis, Channel 2 news and to maintain white demand in areas that For several years, Oak Park has been do anchorman and Oak Park resident, otnciated already are integrated. ing a lot about its past, its present and its at the opening ceremonies. The results have been impressive. Integra future. Respect for the historical heritage Following the flag presentation, residents tion has been conducted in an orderly fash and its potential for the future, a hard look and officials stood elbow-to-elbow, feasting ion. Six per cent of the suburb's population at the economics of the present and their on cake and punch and listening to the con is made up of minorities. About 4 per cent is implications for the future and anticipa temporary sounds of the OPRFHS Jazz Band. black, according to village omcials. tion of the urban lifestyles of the future- Many wore lapel buttons emblazoned with White demand for homes is high, and the all of these have affected the way the com the "All-America City" logo. real estate experts' confidence in the suburbs' munity has done things for more than seven years. Later, several hundred residents watched sta.bllity is reflected in the fact that property a special slide program highlighting Oak values have increased about 16.5 per cent 1n ·The things Oak Park has been doing in re Park's major accomplishments. Opting for the last four years. cent years reached a high point in 1975, re more fanciful adventure, their chlldren raced To lure shoppers back to downtown oak sulting in the All-America City designation to the wet courtyard and released colorful Park, merchants two years ago began con for 1976. The award itself is a. landmark on balloons imprinted with Oak Park's newest struction of a. $1.5 million grassy shopping the continuing trall to more excellence and title. mall stretching from Harlem to Forest ave the distinctive symbol a banner to help in nues and from North Boulevard to Ontario spire more effort; we are delighted and Street. confident. It was a gamble that paid off. When it DAY CARE BILL: CASUALTY OF opened in November, 1974, sales in stores on OAK PARKERS WIN AWARD FOR VILLAGE PRESIDENT'S PRIMARY WOES the mall increased 10 to 14 per cent, accord Oak Park has been named one of 10 recipi ing to Qak Park Mall Commission omcials. ents for the All-American City Award by the Oak Park has always had a lot going for National Municipal League, and that is no it architecturally. Wright lived and worked in small statement. HON. CHARLES B. RANGEL the village between 1890 and 1910. seventy The league described the All-America Cities OF NEW YORK one of its 328 bUildings of "architectural as "places where citizen involvement is help IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES merit" are considered national landmarks. ing shape a desired style of life and achieve It took a group of O:ak Park residents, how improvements in community institutions." Monday, May 17, 1976 ever, to transform this obvious but dormant Of course, all communities strive for im Mr. RANGEL. Mr. Speaker, the Presi asset into a profitable tourist attraction. provement, but Oak Park actually has made They formed the Frank Lloyd Wright Home tangible progress. dent recently vetx>ed the day care bill and Studio Foundation in 1972, purchased The league also said, "The 1975-1976 which would have granted States addi Wright's home to spare it from the wrecker's stories presented by winning communities tional time to meet Federal standards for ball, and established a tour center to direct represent a casebook of citizen activism with these centers and would have provided visitors to the village's architectural attrac accomplishments including improved human the States with $125 million to assist tions. relations, construction of community facUl them in meeting these new gUidelines. Al "The amazing thing is that all these pro ties, revitalization of downtown areas, preser though we overrode the veto in the grams were started by people instead of by vation of historic sites, development of recre government," said Mrs. Edith Slayton, presi ational facilities, creation of senior citizen House, the Senate failed in its attempt. dent of the oak Park-River Forest League of programs and services, reorganization of local Clearly this veto by the President was Women Voters. government and provisions of wider housing an attempt to appease the more con- "They originated not in board rooms, but opportunity." servative elements within his party. Un- 14206 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS May 17, 1976 fortunately as the President acts more debated is to what extent Federal standards tions and open assaults of an insidious and and more like a politician, instead of an for day care should go along with Federal vindictive administration, it becomes the money. indispensable duty of these hitherto free and incumbent President acting for the good Congressional supporters of day-care funds, happy colonies, with true penitence of heart, of the entire Nation, important programs such as Senator Walter Mondale of Minne and the most reverent devotion, publickly to are sacrificed. Although a certain amount sota, have not wanted to set up a tight net acknowledge the over ruling providence of of political demagoguery is expected dur work of Federal rules. They agree that regu God; to confess and deplore our offences ing this political season, I :find it de lation should be left largely to state and against him; and to supplicate his interposi plorable that children are being penal localities. tion for averting the threatened danger, and ized because of the President's political On the other hand, studies have shown prospering our strenuous efforts in the cause misfortune. widespread and gruesome examples of bad of freedom, virtue, and posterity. day care: unsafe buildings, children ignored The Congress, therefore, considering the Anthony Lewis wrote a column for because of inadequate staff, and so on. sen warlike preparations of the British Ministry Monday's New York Times in which he ator Mondale and others in Congress have to subvert our invaluable rights and priv tells of the tragedy that will ensue if Con felt that Federal money should not be used iledges, and to reduce us by fire and sword, gress does not act to reverse this callous to send children to such places-that it by the savages of the wilderness, and our own act on the day care legislation. I call should be used, gradually, to assure a decent domestics, to the most abject and ignomini upon my colleagues to carefully review environment in places where children will ous bondage: Desirous, at the same time, to Lewis' remarks which I insert at this spend as much as eight hours a day. have people of all ranks and degrees duly In 1974, after long negotiations, the Ford impressed with a solemn sense of God's point in the RECORD: Administration and Congress agreed on superintending providence, and of their duty, CHILDREN AND POLITICS modest Federal standards. A new law re devoutly to rely, in all their lawful enter (By Anthony Lewis) quired day-care centers, first, to meet state prizes, on his aid and direction, Do earnestly MINNEAPOLIS.-Nestled against a wall of St. and local rules in fire, safety and health. And recommend, that Friday, the Seventeenth day Mary's Basilica, a hulking old church near it established staffing standards, for exam of May next, be observed by the said colonies downtown Minneapolis, is a small play ple one adult teacher or volunteer to about as a day of humiliation, fasting, and prayer; ground. Ten children, 2V2 to 6 years old, use six children between 2 V2 and 6. that we may, with united hearts, confess and the swings and sllde and run over to talk When the time approached to apply those bewail our manifold sins and transgressions, with their teacher, Michael Young. They are standards, it turned out that many centers and, by a sincere repentance and amendment in a day-care center: Child Garden Mon cou1d not meet them. Conditions were worse of life, appease his righteous displeasure, and. tessori. than had been realized. The states asked through the merits and mediation of Jesus One of the kids is 3 Y2 -year-old Laura Lacey. for more time and more Federal help. Christ, obtain his pardon and forgiveness; She is well-dressed, bright, articulate, happy, That was the aim of the vetoed blll. It de humbly imploring his assistance to frustrate active: the model of what we have come to layed the standards a bit longer and pro the cruel purposes of our unnatural enemies; think of as the middle-class child. But in fact vided an extra $125 mlllion to help the states and by inclining their hearts to justice and the Federal Government pays her fee at the meet them. President Ford, in vetoing it, benevolence, prevent the further effusion of center, $130 a month. said nothing about the earlier agreement, kindred blood. But if, continuing deaf to the Laura Lacey is the reality at the heart of worked out so carefully by his own people voice of reason and humanity, and inflexibly an abstract political debate. President Ford and Congress. He objected to the whole idea bent on desolation and war, they constrain us recently vetoed a bill providing added funds of Federal standards and introduced the to repel their hostile invasions by open re for day care, saying that it violated his prin new demand that day-care money be in sistance, that it may please the Lord of ciples for Federal aid, and the Senate failed cluded in Federal block grants for commu Hosts, the God of Armies, to animate our to override the veto. Unless Congress finds a nity services. Unless Congress acts on new officers and soldiers with invincible fortitude, way around the President's objections, Laura legislation, Federal standards will now t'!l.ke to guard and protect them in the day of bat Lacey will have to leave the Child Garden effect without money to meet them. tle and to crown the continental arms, by day-care center. The real reason for the veto was evidently sea and land, with victory and success: Laura's mother, Geraldine Lacey, a slim the specter of Ronald Reagan. The President Earnestly beseeching him to bless our civil attractive woman of 34, is separated from her wanted to look tough, and what could be rulers, and the representatives of the people, husband. She worked as a secretary but tougher than to drive children out of day in their several assemblies and conventions; found, she said, that she did not make care centers. Gerald Ford should have to to preserve and strengthen their union, to enough to support herself and the child. So expl-ain to Laura and Geraldine Lacey. inspire them with an ardent, disinterested she went back to school, to the University of love of their country; to give wisdom and Minnesota, where she hopes to become a stability to their counsels; and direct them nurse. While there she is on welfare-a fact to the most efficacions measures for estab that troubles her. TWO HUNDRED YEARS AGO lishing the rights of America on the most "People think of welfare as a leech on honourable permanent basis-That he would society," Mrs. Lacey said, "and I feel that way, TODAY be graciously pleased to bless all his people too. My ego is bruised. I want to study to get in these colonies with health and plenty, off welfare." and grant that a spirit of incorruptible pa Mrs. Lacey had Laura in a private home HON. PATRICIA SCHROEDER triotism, and of pure undefiled religion, may first--a woman minding half a dozen chil OF COLORADO universally prevail; and this continent be dren-but that turned out to be a depressing IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES speedily restored to the blessings of peace and place. Then she looked at many day-care cen Monday, May 17, 1976 Uberty, and enabled to transmit them in ters before choosing Child Garden. violate to the latest posterity. And it is rec "The kids looked so nice here," she said, Mrs. SCHROEDER. Mr. Speaker, 200 ommended to Christians of all denomina "and they were interested in Laura when she years ago the Colonies were embroiled in tions, to assemble for public worship, and came-didn't resent a new child, as I'd seen abstain from servile labour on the said day. in other places. I was so happy to see that. the beginning of their struggle to obtain And I thought it mattered that there was a freedom from England-a struggle man teaching here. which was to bring hardship and suffer 'I hope I don't have to move Laura now ing to many Americans before our inde I don't think it's healthy to keep changing. pendence was won. U.S. POLICY TOWARD ISRAEL I'm just depressed . . ." Congressman CHARLES E. BENNETT has The situation of Geraldine and Laura La cey is not unusual in the United States now. brought to the attention of the Subcom HON. WILLIAM M. BRODHEAD There are 2.8 million American children be mittee on Census and Population, which OF MICHIGAN tween 2Y:z and 6 who live with their mother has jurisdiction over the Bicentennial, a IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES alone. And 'altogether, 6.5 million of that age resolution which was adopted 200 years have working mothers. ago today, calling for a day of fasting and Monday, May 17, 1976 The trend toward working mothers and prayer. I would like to share this resolu Mr. BRODHEAD. Mr. Speaker, on single-parent famllles has made day care an tion with my colleagues in the House. May 3, 1976, I was privileged to attend essential factor in many lives. It enables many women to work instead of going on I ask unanimous consent that the reso the annual dinner of the American Is welfare--and thereby to save public funds. lution be printed in the RECORD as fol rael Public Affairs Committee. At that Welfare costs the Government about three lows: dinner, an address was given by Senator times as much as day care. [From the Journals of the Continental HUBERT HUMPHREY. I think that this The Federal Government now provides Congress, March 1776] speec~ is a particularly excellent one, $600 million a year for care of children in In times of impending calamity and dis for it is a clear and logical explana poorer fam111es, matched by $200 m1llion tress; when the liberties of America are im tion of the special relationship that ex from the states. The question inevitably minently endangered by the secret machina- ists between the United States and Is- May 17, 1976 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKs· 14207 rael. The speech also contains some im our country. It is good for the basic demo proclaimed to the world that the Jewish portant comments about mistakes 1n cratic process that people who have convic people have a right to a free and indep~ndent current U.S. policy toward Israel. Be tions about what American public policy nation. This nation, a land of immigrants and cause of the importance of this subject should be take time to get their fellow Amer a land of help, helped rekindle the ancient icans and their public officials to understand Jewish prayer to be in Jerusalem agPortugal, in Japan and in the deal lat.el:v about the appropriateness of the ghetti, gefilte fish or Polish sausage. We are nations that struggle for self-government in kind of work that you're engaged ln. a nation of immigrants, even into our 20oth southern Africa. We Americans ought to Tn other words, quec;tlons have sort of year. We are concerned about the land ot support freedom-loving people, first 9.nd last been ra!Fed. Should you be here? Much of our fathers, be it Poland or Italy or Russia and all the time. the talk, frankly. aR I. Ree it, has been down or Norway or England or Ireland or Africa. My, how we go out of our way to accom right ridiculous and silly. Columnists, edito And we have evey right to urge the Congress modate ourselves to others, and any little rial writers have warned us about ethnic lob and the President to pursue policies that we deviation, by some of our friends, is subject bies. We've been hearing a lot about "ethnic" deem to be correct. we are never assured to such criticism. As Ambassador Pat Moyni lately. T.:ley've been warning us about ethnic that those policies will be followed. We may han observed so well in his all too-brief tour lobbyin15, e~oeciallv in foreign affairs. We've not win. We may not be able to gain the at the UN, there are so few real democracies heard carelec;s, and I think. wreckless things majority, but we surely have that right to in this world that we cannot be indifferent to beinP' said about the oowerful Jewish lobby, state our case. their needs and their principles. Within the the Greek lobby, the Turkish lobby, the Bal Now, I want to turn to the major topic limits of our resources then, and with our tic states lobby-you mention it, as if some before us this evening, but I thought I'd kind security objectives clearly outlined, democ how or another, it was against the law in of clean that little issue away before we got racies merit the support of America. And this country to speak up for what you be any further along because every once in a idealism still has a place in public pollcy. lieve ln. while I hear people say: "Well, the real For our democratic heritage is not one that's Now, let me just lay it on the line. What trouble is these people-the Jewish people just unique to ourselves, it is shared by a privilege it is to be both a good Jew and they're just thinking about Israel." That's Israel. Our system of liberty and equality a good American at the same time. Let no just a lot of hogwash. I want to tell you that also gives Israel its national vitality: And one contest the patriotic dedication of the the Jewish people in America, the people of America's love for freedom is the cornerstone Jewish community in the United States. of Israel's independence. From the first days of our republlc, from the Jewish faith, have been thinking about the davs George Washington needed help in the poor in this country, they've been thinking ISRAEL'S HERITAGE DEMOCRACY battle for our independence, people of Jew about the education of our people, they've These values are the heritage of a demo ish faith have been in the front lines doing been thinking about how to make our cities cratic Israel. They are the values of our their job for freedom, for justice. The whole better, they've been thinking about immi nation as well. And whether here in America theme of justice and the priceless nature of gration laws, they have been thinking about or in Israel, we must stand for their preserva the human spirit comes from Jewish philos civil rights and civil liberties and the Bill of tion and protection. We must never forget ophy and Jewish religion. I'm very proud Rights and the Constitution of the United Israel's claim to moral right based on its to be with an audience such as this, and I States. And I would think that you should strong democratic institutions. What I am trying to say here, and possibly want you to know that I approve of what be terribly proud, all of you that represent these great organizations, for what you stand inadequately, is that it is time for this coun you are doing. In fact, I not only approve of try, this America, to be clearly identified in what you are doing, you arrived just in time for. I for one, as a member of Congress, ap plaud you. I only wish to God there were the minds of mankind everywhere that we because there is work to be done in this support and put a premium upon our support city, and make no mistake about it. .thousands more like you. We need y.)u. for those who cherish democratic institu I approve not only because I happen to THE LAND AND ITS PEOPLE tions-they shall be first in line; they shall agree with the program that you're advocat Well-28 years ago, Israel's first Prime have our first guarantees; they shall have our mg, but also because I think it is good for -Minister, the beloved David Ben Gurian, first generous help; they, above all, shall C:XXII--897-Pa.rt 12 14208 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS May 17, 1976 be helped-and once that's understood, I ain. Many times Britain disappoints us and or birth. The American citizenship carries think there will be others who will treat we're very critical of her. But Britain has a with it the world over the protections of us with a great deal more respect. special place in the hearts of Americans. And this country. . . . Jews around the world Just recently cele we're not about ready, in order to make some When we start taking pride in our citizen brated Passover, the festival of thanksgiving body happy somewhere else in the world, to ship and letting people know that we take and of freedom. I think it's right that we sell out our relationship with Britain-end pride in it, we'll be respected. It's about time look ahead and ask questions. Will Israel we're not ready to do that with Israel, and that the world knew that we mean that kind be free and safe at next year's Passover? Will people need to know it. of business. Israel be free on its 50th anniversary and We must never forget that the world Finally, the President of the United States the years beyond? To all Americans who be watches intensely what our nation does and has foolishly threatened to veto a foreign lieve in freedom, cherish it and who will sac particularly what it does in the Middle East. aid appropriations bill on several grounds. r11lce to preserve it, I think the answer 1s The Soviets, the Arab nations, the non but one of the grounds is that it contains quite obvious. It 1s and it must be: Yes. aligned nations follow our every move. If we funds for Israel allocated in conformance But let us understand that preserving digress, 1f we're ambivalent, if we're doubtful, with our new budget act to cover what we Israel's freedom, as this audience knows all they sense it immediately. We must never call a three-month "transition quarter." The too well, will not be an easy task. It is a give the impression, through our acts, that simple truth is that the fiscal year of the demanding task. Today Israel celebrates its we are relegating our relationship with Israel new act starts in October. The fiscal year independence at a time of uncertainty over to a second-place status. Perceptions in the under the old act ends June 30, and there the intention of its neighbors, at a time of world of diplomacy are as important as out is a period of time from July 1 through Sep diplomatic isolation such as no country has right actions. Let me review this record which tember when there are no funds made avail had to endure for at least generations, and causes me some concern: able unless a special act of Congress pro at a time of great economic hardship. In October 1973, during a grave moment of vides those funds. Possibly, my friend Sen ator Case told you about it because he was so ISRAELIS HARD PRESSED the Yom Kippur War, the United States fi nally began resupply efforts to Israel, only instrumental, along with Senator Javits, in Its citizens are taxed at a rate of unprece after considerable pressure was exerted by seeing that these transition funds were made dented hardship and sacrifice. Its enemies members of Congress on the Administration. available. have skillfully used international bodies and I know. I was one of those. I was on that TRANSITION QUARTER AID their own great economic power to try to telephone with the Secretary of Defense, with Now let me set the record straight. We dis turn world oplnion against Israel. The mo the Secretary of State asking when do we cussed this matter in the Committee. I serve mentum of peace that was started with an start moving the supplies. Thank goodness as chairman of the Subcommittee on Foreign American initiative has been nearly halted those supplies moved, and they moved in Economic and Mllita.ry Assistance. I tele by those nations and groups who know how large quantities, to the everlasting credit of phoned the Secretary of State, Mr. Kissinger, critical peace is to Israel's ultimate security. the government of the United States and to ln my capacity as chairman of Floreign As But it seems that a new element has been the President of the United States. But I sistance Subcommittee on Jan. 29 to deter added to Israel's struggle for freedom during shall never forget those critical first days of mine the Administration's position on pro these troubled days, and I speak of it openly that war when we were not so sure whether viding Israel with $550 million in trans! tion and honestly as I see it. I'm deeply concerned the United States would provide aid quickly quarter funding. This matter was brought that a series of Administration actions and to the embattled Israelis. It's important that up by Senator Case, and we discussed it in attitudes over a brief period have given the Arab states, the Soviet Union and all know committee. impression that the United States may be that we will not dlllydally, that there is a There was doubt as to what we ought to weakening its commitment to Israel. commitment, that it will be acted upon do and the committee said to me: "Mr. Now, I refuse to believe that this Adminis promptly, that there wlll be no reassessment, Chainnan, go call the Secretary of State." We tration deliberately seeks to call into ques that the facts are stated clearly ahead of went and called the Secretary of State. The tion the basic American commitment to time. Secretary of State told me personally that Israel at the most difficult time in its history. Prior to the Secretary's Sinai peace initia he approved the transition funds, that he And I refuse to believe that our President tive, the Administration launched a reassess felt it was proper what we were doing. would knowingly abandon Israel, and I don't ment of American policy which included a He said he could not, however, speak for think he will. If this were to happen, the halt, temporarily to be sure, in the delivery the Ofllce of Management and Budget. But atated policies of five American Presidents of critical military items and needlessly and he is the President's first ofllcer. The Secre would be abruptly reversed. But through painfully increased Israel's apprehension at a tary of State is the President's first ofllcer. inattention and inadvertence, and, I regret Well, the OMB, that's the Ofllce of Manage to say it, insensitivity, this Admlnlstration moment of growing international isolation. Let me be frank about that reassessment. ment and Budget, and the White House have has taken steps which I believe have the It followed the unwarranted public scolding spoken differently. President Ford and the effect of eroding the historical bonds of trust of Israel after the breakdown of spring nego OMB have obviously overruled the Secretary and confidence between the United States tiations. I am saying nothing here that I of State. The President and some of his and Israel. haven't said privately to the Secretary of people have lobbied House members to pre The erosion has been very gradual, but it State who I like and admire. I have tried to vent Israel from receiving these funds. When has been profound. It is alarming for the be a helpful friend and will continue to be. that failed, a veto was threatened. future of Israeli-American relations. Friends, however, do not accuse one an Now what good does it do for a Secretary At this point, let me state that I have no other in such a manner even at difllcult of State to say, as he did on Apr. 4, that the disagreement with the goal of securing the times-at least not publicly. At the United United States wlll help keep Israel strong, trust and the friendship of the Arab world. Nations, all too many times, we stood idly by while the President threatens the veto of a Securing that trust and friendship and being whlle nations tried to humiliate Israel and blll containing funds vital to Israel's secu cammltted to the defense and the security impugned its motives. rity. The two are a contradiction in terms. and the freedom of Israel are not in contra To be sure, when they tried to equate I want this audience to know that we take diction. In fact, I believe that securing Arab Zionism with racism. thank God the public this matter seriously in the Congress, and trust and friendship is an imperative. But position of the United States was made we want you to take it seriously. Israel while we are pursuing this policy, we should manifestly clear, to the everlasting credit knows that you can't, on the one hand, state not forget that Israel, for the United States, of the President, the Secretary of State, and that we are going to keep Israel strong, and, cannot be regarded as just another nation our Ambassador. Those are moments that we on the other hand, have a threatened veto among many nations in the Middle East. Like can be proud of. of the blll that includes the money. The Con it or not, Israel has a special place in the Let me speak with equal candor about an gress understands this contradiction, and hearts of the American countrymen, and it other subject. For too many years, this gov we're not going to let the American people does have that special place. ernment has countenanced an unjust and be fooled. A SPECIAL RELATIONSHIP odious boycott of Israel by powerful corpora This dangerous series of events which We must declare without embarrassment tions and Arab nations. We stlll wait for an seems to weaken, or perceives, or looks as if and with no apology that Israel has earned a initiative from the Administration which it weakens, the American commitment to special relationship with America. The Arab will declare that the United States should Israel continues unabated. But let me as world must understand that if it desires bet use its powers to enact and enforce laws sure you that, in what we call politics, per ter relations with the United States, it must which impose on American corporations a ception is sometimes even more important accept our good relations with Israel. No Ad standard of conduct ln their overseas deal than the fa_s.ts. ministration should ever mislead any Arab ing fully as strict as that required at home. The Adtillnistration attempts to start a leader to believe otherwise. Whoever will be By the way, in legislation waiting for the significant military relationship with Egypt President of the United States next year must President's signature 1s the necessary legis only to be told directly by the Congress that assure all nations that we are ready to have lation that will make it manifestly clear that we will not permit this to happen. constructive and positive relations with them, we mean business. It will be only at this Let me say here and now that we must but we wlll not do so at the price of ending moment that we can say in the rest of the not, and if I have my way-and I intend to our special relationship with the State of world that we will not participate in, nor have something to say about it-we must Israel. will we acquiesce in, nor tolerate, an eco not undertake a full-fledged m111ta.ry com I sometimes feel that there is an analogy nomic boycott of Israel or discrimlnatlon mitment to Egypt, a commitment that can here. We have our problems with Great Brit- aimed at American citizens of Jewish feJth only increase the risk of war and vastly in- May 17, 1976 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 14209 crease the expend!tures of the American and It must tell the Soviet Union something policy; a people and a country, who are in people and pose a threat to peace in the as well. sisting for their right to be free and inde Middle East. I and my colleagues have no I am confident that 1f Israel is aided to pendent; a people and a country who are disagreement whatsoever in providing Egypt overcome its severe economic problems, and willing to use their resources to enrich the with the means necessary to better the lives it desperately needs help, and 1f it can re lives of their own people; a people and a of its people. We want to help President main strong, then we can call upon Israel country who are willing to play a responsible Sadat in every way we can to improve the to make the sacrifices for peace. And it wlll role in world a1Ia1rs. If every country that living standards of that poverty-stricken na make them. I believe that Israel has the we've helped would do as much, then to tion. But the best way !or Egypt to im moral courage and the fortitude to grapple night, the world would be a happier and a prove its living standards is to quit wasting with the tough issues of the West Bank, the safer place in which to live. its money on unnecessary weaponry. Palestinians and the problem of the new What a blessing it would be if there could settlements. But to ask Israel to do so in be some turning back of the flow of arms the absence of a full-fiedged effort on our Into the Middle East. Now this is the type part is an unfair and unfriendly act. TIMBER BILL WILL ASSURE CON of positive relationship which should be en A FATHER AND SON TINUITY OF TIMBER HARVEST couraged. I applaud the !act that neither It is indeed difficult to discuss these issues Israel nor this organization has ever op without recalling my last visit to Israel's cap posed economic assistance, or technical as Ital, the historic city of .Jerusalem, just a HON. JAMES WEAVER sistance, or food assistance, or humanitar short time ago. I stood on the Judean toot OF OREGON Ian assistance to any nation in the Middle hills, and I had with me my son who is a IN THE HOUSE OP REPRESENTATIVES East or elsewhere. The Administration is de state senator from Minnesota. I wanted him Monday, May 17, 1976 termined to sell vast quantities of arms to to know the experiences that his father has a great number of Israel's potential enemies had. I believe in bringing up the sons at Mr. WEAVER. Mr. Speaker, today I 1f they just put the cash on the barrelhead, least with some of the opportunity to share am introducing legislation to remove the and we are concerned about that. I don't be In the experiences of the father. I wanted lieve that our balance of trade needs to be that son of mine, who is a state senator, to threat of court action that could restrict sustained by making America the world's be another spokesman for justice and for the timber harvest in the Northwestern arms merchant. freedom and for Israel. And let me tell you, States. It is responsive to the court deci PERCEPTIONS THREATEN PEACE he got the message. When we stood there on sions already handed down which invite the Judean foothills before the panorama of action by Congress to remedy the short The Ford Administration, and I say this the City of David, I could see the Parliament, with a heavy heart, simpy does not un comings in existing law. the Knesset, the Dome of the Rock, Mount I direct attention to the features of derstand that actions which are perceived Zion, and the Old City. What a sense that to weaken the American commitment to he should know this; what a proud ritual, 1! the bill that I believe represent a solid Israel are not acts of peace, but rather w1ll you have any feeling at all. middle ground, and balance the concerns threaten the peace. They can only bring I walked through the Jaffa Gate down the expressed by the industry, by environ confusion and postponement of peace. A ancient cobblestones, and I made my way to mentalists, and others for the resources final peace is all that Israel seeks and des of the National Forest System. Industry perately needs--a peace that will end the the Wailing Wall. Standing before the holiest hatred and a peace that will provide security. shrine of the people of Israel and Jews wanted :flexibility-and the bill provides Why must Israel remain economically around the world, I was told that the people ample :flexibility to the Forest Service. viable and m1litarily strong? I think there of Israel come to the wall to lament over the Environmentalists wanted strong guide are three simple reasons. destruction of the Second Temple, to shed lines to protect watersheds, soils, streams, 1. No Arab nation has recognized Israel or spiritual tears !or those who had given their lives in defense of Israel and the Jewish and wildlife, and the bill has these. has expressed a great willingness to do so. My bill is similar to the one approved 2. No Arab nation has been willing to people. For centuries, tears, salt have marked unanimously by the Senate Committees abandon the systematic scheme of boycott on Agriculture and Interior. It does con and diplomatic pressure on Israel. Jewish existence. Jews have shed tears !or 3. No Arab leader has accepted Israel's in the ancient exile, the Czar's pogroms: they tain modifications which will strengthen vitation to come forward and negotiate di have wept for the victims of Nazi terrorism, congressional oversight over the Forest rectly. the heroes of Warsaw, and the sons and the Service, and provide balance in funding I'm not saying these things to be hostile to fathers who died in defense of a united Jeru all multiple uses. the Arab nations. On the contrary, the hap salem, and a free independent Israel in 1948, Most important, it contains the same piest day of my service in the senate For 1956, 1967, and once again in 1973. provision as the Senate bill which elimi eign Relations Committee will be when we Just think of that tattering destruction, of war, of sacrifice and of suffering. Think nates language from the 1897 law, and can know that Arab and Jew alike are work permits the Forest Service to use modern ing in concert !or the development of that literally of the rivers of tears that have beautiful part of the world which is so much come from these incredible experiences. Too forest management practices, including a part of the history of the home of western many tears have been shed throughout the harvesting. Sustained yield operation on civlltzatton. centuries; too many young men have given each national forest is required, as are A weak Israel, however, with an uncertain their lives in defense of Israel's freedom and several guidelines for all timber harvest relationship with the United States, will not the right of Jews to be free wherever they ing-that harvest levels will be set only make sacrt:tlces for peace in the !ace of the live. It is time, I say, to end the tears, to pursuant to land management plans; three factors I just mentioned. Weakness end Israel's pain, to restore her confidence harvests shall be based on availability does not bring security. Nations take risks and to help to bring her peace-the peace for for peace when they are either very secure or which she has !ought for 28 years, the peace and suitability of lands for timber pro extremely desperate. I never want to see Is her prophets spoke of and her sons and ductions, and land not suited to growing rael make sacrt:tlces and compromises for daughters have prayed for. As Israel's na timber will not be subject to timber pro what might be called peace out of despera tional anthem. Hatikvah, proclaims: "Once duction as a management goal. tion. The United States must never be a again, the land of Israel must be filled with A section-by-section description of my party to any such eventuality. hope, and with that hope, she will prosper. bill follows: NEEDED: A CLEAR MESSAGE When this comes to pass, people will rejoice. Section 1 is the bill title: National Forest Therefore, I call upon the President and For the miracle of Israel whose people wlll Management Act of 1976. the secretary of State to act positively in the make the desert bloom in security and In Section 2: Makes seven findings by Con execution of American policy towards Israel. peace." gress. A major one calls upon the Federal And I ask them to act in a timely and in a That's my testament to you tonight: Government to become a catalyst among all very precise manner so there is no ambiguity, that's the way I believe, and those are the forest land owners to encourage and assist no uncertainty, that the message is clear and thoughts that will govern my actions in the them in their long-term use and Improve undistorted. The time has come for this Congress. Those are the thoughts that will ment. Another directs the Forest Service to government to recognize the dangers which govern my votes, and will indeed inspire promote and expand the use of recycled forest lie ahead. If we continue to act with insen whatever legislation I can put my hand to. products. sitivity, and hesitancy in our relationship to And I say to you now, don't you waste a Section 3 : Requires a new chapter to be Israel, bickering over a technical matter single day or a moment whlle you are here. prepared in future Assessments made under called the transition quarter, bickering over You contact every member of Congress, and the Renewable Resources Planning Act to something that is part of the law of this tell them that all that you ask is that study the fiber potential of the National land-every other department of govern America show its dedication to democracy, Forest System, as compared to current ment, every other program has received their that we show our dedication to those who are production. transiti()(D. quarter money-bickering over w1lllng to die for freedom. Section 4: Adds a new paragraph of direc this amount that would go to Israel-yes, What I love about Israel so much is that tions on what must be included 1n the Re and to Egypt as well--only spreads uncer she reveals in her existence what I think are newable Resource Program which the Presi tainty throughout the entire Middle East, the best objectives of American foreign dent transmits to Congress. These state ad- 14210 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS May 17, 1976 dition goals for resource planning, including be included in the forest development road gation of activities involving Representa protection and improvement of soil, water, system plan, and that any other road for tive SIKES, based on a Common Cause and air resources. timber removal or other purpose shall be complaint. Section 5: This section requires the Sec temporary, and allowed to revert to vegeta I feel it would be useful to place in the retary of Agriculture to fix many new guide tion within 10 years. RECORD the Common Cause communica lines for the development of land manage Section 9: Establishes the National Forest ment plans on the National Forest System. System by statute. Most national forests were tions relating to the dispute over com They must provide for public particiaption created by executive order of the President, mittee rules. in the formulation and review of proposed and could be removed back to the public Three letters follow: plans; specify how the interdisciplinary ap domain the same way. This requires that they COMMON CAUSE, proach mandated by the existing law Will be cannot be so moved, except by act of Con Washington, D.C., May 5, 1976. implemented; identify the suitability of gress. Wn.LIAM G. GEOGHEGAN, Esq., lands for resource management; provide for Section 10: Includes past and future re Counsel to the House Committee on Stand obtaining inventory data and the various sponsibilities and authorities of the Forest ards of Official Conduct, Ring Building, resources, soil, and water, including maps, Service in the term "renewable resources" Washington, D.C. graphic material and explanatory aids; for which it must plan. DEAR Bn.L: This is to follow up on our con provide methods to identify special condi Section 11 : Limits the sale of timber from versation this morning. If there is any disa tions or situations where there is a hazard each national forest to a quantiy equal to or greement about the scope of any obligations to the resources; insure consideration of the less than a quantity which can be removed of secrecy at the inquiry stage-and I don't economic and environmental aspects of var from such forest every year on a sustained think there is-Common Cause believes that ious systems of renewable resource man yield basis. An exclusion for natural dis should be discussed in public session at the agement, including the related systems of asters is provided. outset of Thursday's hearings. There is ob silviculture and pro'OOction of forest re Section 12: Contains conforming amend viously no reason why any discussion of that sources to provide for outdoor recreation, ments to the Renewable Resources Planning issue should be kept secret. Hopefully, there's range, timber, watershed, wildlife, and fish. Act of 1974. no problem here. We simply don't want to be Guidelines must also be promulgated that Section 13: Redesignates paragraphs in the hit by surprise in executive session with ob Will provide for diversity of plant and ani 1897 Organic Act. ligations that go far beyond our understand mal communities, based on the suitab111ty Section 14: Amends the Organic Act by ing of the purposes of privacy at this stage. and capab111ty of the land area; recognize striking out the twelfth paragraph, and sub The 1968 Report of the Committee on the need for protection of soil, water, aes stituting: "For the purpose of achieving the Standards of Official Conduct indicates a thetic, and wildlife resources where condi policies set forth in the Multiple Use Sus concern that the Committee avoid being used tions are critical for tree regeneration; pre tained-Yield Act and the Forest and Range as a forum for cheap and wide-spread pub scribe appropriate systems of silviculture ac land Renewable Resources Planning Act of licity of frivolous charges. The "inquiry" r:ording to geographic area, including har 1974, the Secretary of Agriculture may sell at stage, which is intended to determine vesting, thinnings, regeneration, and other not less than appraised value, trees, portions whether the charges are substantial enough treatment methods; Insure research and con of trees, or forest products located on the to warrant an investigation, can sensibly be tinuous monitoring on the ground of the National Forest System." Additional lan shielded from too much public attention un effects of each management system in use guage limits sales contracts to 10 years, ex til the Committee is satisfied that an inves or proposed for use, and provide for its dis cept in circumstances beyond control of the tigation is appropriate. We would, therefore, continuance if it proves detrimental to the purchaser, and permits sale of trees of less accept an obligation not to report anything productivity of the land; provide that tim than $10,000 in value without competitive we hear said about Mr. Sikes at the Thursday ber harvesting shall be determined only bidding. inquiry. That fully covers the purpose of go through the preparation of the land man It also requires the Forest Service to estab ing into executive session on this occasion. agement plans; identify the relative produc lish utilization standards for removal of Just to be clear, we retain the right to say tivity of national forest land, and assure timber. publicly what we know from any other Section 15: Validates timber sales made source, as the Constitution surely requires. that timber production is not a manage pursuant to the 1897 Organic Act, and re ment goal where the cost of production ex quires re-negotiation of the 50 year timber The mere fact that we were present at the ceeds the economic return; and permit in sale contract in Alaska to conform to the inquiry doesn't affect our general freedom of creased harvesting only upon demonstra new requirements of this bill. speech about matters we didn't learn there. tion that it is justified by management prac Section 16: Provides that in the calcula We can say what we said to the committee; tices. tion of money returned to the counties from that's established even for Witnesses before Additional guidelines are to be established timber sale receipts, there shall be included a federal grand jury. And finally, there is no for all timber harvesting, and for clea.rcut all collections for reforestation under the legitimate secrecy about the procedures, rul ting in particular. They must Insure that Knutsen-Vandenberg Act, and credits allowed ings, or other actions of the Committee it timber will be cut only where there is no to timber purchasers for construction of self. The Congress obviously wants the pub irreversible damage to soil, slope, or other roads. This will yield about $60 million more lic to have confidence in the procedures its watershed conditions, there is assurance to the counties where National Forests are Committee follows in deciding whether to that the land can be restocked in 5 years, situated. investigate, as well as in the course of an in and protection is provided for streams, and Section 17: Abolishes the National Forest vestigation itself. That would be impossible other bodies of water. Clearcutting guide Reservation Commission, and directs the if complainants were ordered not to discuss lines must assure that it will be done only Secretary of Agriculture to report to Con procedures. when it is the optimum means to meet the gress annually on all land purchases and ex I don't think there is disagreement about land management goals, that the interdis changes affecting the National Forest System. this, but we don't want to face any uncer ciplinary review has assessed the impact on Section 18: Adds a new paragraph to the tainty about whether we're violating any ob other resources, the cuts are designed to Knutsen-Vandenberg Act to permit collec ligations of secrecy. If there is dispute, let's blend into the natural terrain, and maxi tions to be made from timber purchases to discuss this important issue openly at Thurs mum size limits for clearcuts are set for each work on the timber sale area to improve its day's hearing before going into executive geogrpahic area or other suitable claslfl.ca productivity in addition to reforestation. session. tion. The lat'OOr limitation does not apply Section 19: Provides a title to the 1960 Sincerely, to the harvesting of timber damaged by Multiple Use Act. PHU.IP HEYMANN, natural disaster. Section 20: Strikes out the provision in Counsel to Common Cause and A committee of scientists must be ap the 1964 National Forest System Roads and Fred Wertheimer. pointed by the Secretary of Agriculture to Trails Act which relieves timber purchasers provide technical advice and counsel on of paying for road standards that are higher COMMON CAUSE, these guidelines. than what is needed to remove the timber. Washington, D.C., May 7, 1976. WILLIAM G. GEOGHEGAN, Esq., Section 6: Puts the Forest Service pro Counsel to the House Committee on Stand grams under a fixed term authorization of ards of Official Conduct, Ring Building, five years. This will require Congress to ex COMMON CAUSE ON THE SIKES Washington, D .C. amine its five-year Program and act posi CASE DEAR Bn.L: I wanted to write you promptly tively on it before money to carry it out can to try and straighten out whatever con be appropriated. It also requires that fund fusion there may be after yesterday's hear ing of the various programs not vary more HON. DONALD M. FRASER ing before the House Committee on Stand than 10% from the levels established in the OF MINNESOTA ards of Official Conduct. As you know, our Program. position was that it would be wrong for us Section 7: Requires the Secretary of Agri IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES to reveal any testimony or evidence we heard culture to report to Congress the extent of Monday, May 17, 1976 on that occasion about Congressman Sikes. the lack of vegetative cover in the National We also thought it was fairer not to release Forest System, and the amount of money Mr. FRASER. Mr. Speaker, the Stand our opening statement to the public while needed to restock it. a-rds of Official Conduct Committee has the Committee was deciding whether to ·ini Section 8: Requires that permanent roads voted to ·go ahead with a formal ihvesti- tiate an investigation. On the other hand, we May 17, 1976 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 14211 were clear that we had a constitutional right bind witnesses, what is it that we were being legal authority for the Committee's use of to continue to discuss Representative Sikes' confronted with yesterday at the session? "executive session" to limit or eliminate our record, to reveal the substance of our posi These are I,lOt unimportant matters. What right to make public: (1) the substance of tion before the Committee at .some later is at stake is the basic structure of a free the factual allegations we were putting be date, and to talk about any unfairness or government. I believe that the Committee fore the Committee; (2) arguments (such as legal misconceptions that we saw in -the is making a far broader claim to burden the those we make here) as to what is acceptable procedures. constitutional rights to free speech and to conduct by a. Member; and (3) information The Committee was not prepared to con petition Congress than has been made be as to the conduct of Committee proceed cede any of these rights, saying that they fore. Perhaps I have overlooked some prece ings. Absent any showing by the Committee were inconsistent with the very meaning dents for all this; if so, I think you should of legal and constitutional authority to limit of "executive session." This is simply wrong let us know about them right away. I don't such important rights, we will insist on keep as a matter of law and history. Such claims think that either the Committee or Common ing them; but consistent with this, we re for executive session are, I believe, wholly Cause should be confused about what is at main willing to assist in any way the Com unprecedented and starkly unconstitutional. stake here. mittee desires. The attached memorandum is Whether inadvertently or not, the Com Sincerely, such an effort. mittee was setting forth a sweeping new PHn..IP HEYMANN, The allegations we have set forth raise construction of the rules and a novel de (By JANE TINKER) two central (and several less major) issues mand for the total future silence of anyone Counsel for Common Cause. of standards of conduct. who testifies in executive session. Let me be (1) Is it permissible for a Member who is specific. COMMON CAUSE, a substantial shareholder in a closely held I. To the best of my knowledge there is corporation to use his position, without re no precedent whatsoever for House action Washington, D.C., May 11, 1976. Hon. JOHN J. FLYNT, vealing his personal interest, to sponsor and against a witness who simply continues to guide through passage legislation, a major state publicly what he has stated to a. Com Chairman, House Committee on Standards of Official Conduct, Rayburn House Office effect of which is to grant federal property mittee in executive session. Representative interests to that corporation? If the Com Bennett attempted to make that clear yester Building, Washington, D.C. DEAR MR. CHAIRMAN: I very much hope mittee rules such conduct is not permissible, day at the hearing, but we could not obtain as we urge, then there is a central Committee assurance of even that minimal that the Members of the Ethics Committee will read the enclosed memorandum [not factual question that demands investigation: protection for First Amendment rights. whether Rep. Sikes is telling the truth to the Surely it is inconceivable that the price of reprinted) submitted on behalf of Common Cause explaining why we believe the Com Committee when he denies having known petitioning Congress can be made a legally that "this leasehold would be affected by binding obligation not to continue to make mittee is obligated to p.roceed with an in vestigation of certain activities involving the legislation". If he is not telling the truth one's complaint in public. to this Committee, the prolonged intentional II. I believe there is no precedent for Representative Sikes. It is long enough to be worth summarizing in this letter. concealment of a serious undisclosed con forbidding a witness before a. congressional flict of interest deserves severe condemna committee, whether in executive or open The Committee presently has under con sideration a. threshold question-whether to tion now, i.e. promptly after the conceal session, to make public what he said to the ment is revealed. This is not a criminal pro committee and that he said it. How could undertake an investig81tion regarding the ac tivities of Representative Sikes. We submit ceeding, it is plainly civil in nature. The law the responsiveness of Congress to citizens is clear that time delays, occasioned by con ever be evaluated if the price of appearing as that, whenever two conditions are met by factual allegations, the Committee has the cealment, are not valid grounds for dismissal a witness would be a prohibition of stating of a noncriminal charge. what one had asked of, and said to, a com responsibility to conduct an investigation. The two conditions are: (1) that the allega (2) Is it permissible for a Member to use mittee? Rule Xll,2,(k), is intended to apply his official position to attempt to obtain gov to Members of Congress and their staffs to tions involve significant violations of either the historic duty of a Member not to dis ernment permits and insurance for a pros prevent them from revealing what they have pect! ve bank and then accept, from the heard in executive session. The legislat ive credit the House by engaging in, or giving the appearance of engaging in, financially owner, the opportunity to buy a substantial history makes this clear. It is not designed portion of the privately held stock in that to interfere with the First Amendment rights self-serving conduct ar any more specific rules which were also applicable at the time bank? We think such conduct-which is ap of witnesses and potential witnesses to speak parently uncontested-is plainly impermis their piece. Like the law governing federal the conduct took place; and (2) that the allegations have sufficient factual support to sible because of the suspicions it suggests to grand juries, the Rule is directed not at reasonable men and thus the discredit it witnesses but at representatives of the raise reasonable suspicions of serious wrong doing and thus reqUire a factual investiga brings to the House. Here, too, further government. factual investigation of the precise nature If the matter is otherwise classified or tion. When both these conditions are met, as of the arrangement is obviously called for. protected without regard to the rules of The extent of Rep Sikes' activity is sufficient executive session, that is, of course, a dif we show in the attached memorandum tha.t they are here, the Committee has an obliga to raise reasonable suspicions of even more ferent story. Witnesses are bound by federal serious activities--at the very least, a prior law in dealing with national security matters. tion to conduct an investigation and make findings based on tha.t investigation. There expectation of participation in the bank. The See, 18 U.S.C. § 793-798. If such law applies Comm.ittee cannot avoid answering these to forbid a person discussing some matter, it can be no thought of the Committee dis missing "for want of prosecution" by a pri questions without shirking its responsibllity. applies after the witness leaves a congres The central responsibility for investiga sional hearing, just as it did before he vate complainant who has already set the allegation and factual support before the tion of these matters is, and has been. the entered the hearing. Committee's. If the Comm.ittee disagrees with ill. I believe there is no authority and no Committee in a sworn complaint. The Rules of the House make it clear that the Job of the standard we have set forth as requirin"' precedent for forbidding a witness from an investigation, it should explain what talking about the way he was treated be pursuing an investigation lies with the Com mittee, not with any complainants-whether alternative standards it believes are applica for the committee in executive session, the ble. If the Comm.ittee accepts these stand committee's procedures, and the committee's they are from within or outside the House. Of course, Common Cause is not with ards but believes that the conduct alleged rulings. One Member tried to make it clear was permissible for any Member of the House that we were in danger of violating House drawing from this matter. We continue to be willing to take part in open session, or in it should say so. If the Committee agree~ rules if we even made public the discussion such conduct is impermissible but believes about the proposed rules of secrecy. We were executive session at the inquiry stage, pro vided fair and equitable rules are estab that there is no adequate factual basis for certainly unable to get from the Committee undertaking an investigation of whether it an assurance that we could discuss these lished. We are anxious to participate in any way that does not smother the possibllity of occurred, it should say that. What Common matters (except for the last-minute de Cause seeks is a clear explanation of the re cision at the executive session to make public criticizing the Committee's proceedings or decisions if we feel that is warranted. sponsibility this Committee is prepared to the transcript of the whole session). How assume for dealing with allegations of seri could the legislative process work if witnesses The extension at the May 6 meeting of would appear at the risk of never being able the meaning of "executive session" to forbid ous wrongdoing by one of its Members. The to complain of the way the proceedings were discussion of these matters is unprece public is entitled to at least that. handled while they were there? What wit dented. It is also destructive of public trust Although we disagree profoundly with the ness would appear on these terms? in the Congress. Public evaluation of the position the Committee took, I appreciate, IV. The Library of Congress has stated Congress reqUires tha.t citizens know the Mr. Chairman, your Willingness to hear our that there is no authority or precedent for good and the bad about these matters so they arguments on secrecy procedures so fully in binding a. witness to silence in any way sim can judge how willing the House is to deal executive session last Thursday. we would ply because he appears before an executive seriously with the difiicult subject of allega appreciate the opportunity to argue the legal session of the House of Congress. They sug tions concerning one of its own Members. issues involved in this case before the Ethics gested, and we agreed, that the way to han We have already expressed at the May 6 Committee in open session. dle this is to reach a common understanding meeting our com.m.itment not to reveal pub Sincerely, on what will be said or not said. As you know, licly any testimony or evidence we might PHILIP B. HEYMANN, we tried to be entirely fair in that regard. hear from or about Rep. Sikes 1n executive By JANE TINKER, But 1! there is no legal authority at all to session at the inquiry stage. But we find no Counsel for Common Cause 14212 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS May 17, 1976 CHAIRMAN EVINS SPEAKS AT THE United States Government for a small busi It was on August 12, 1941, that the late NATIONAL BICENTENNIAL SALUTE ness loan. Wright Patman-the first Chairman of the He had about as much trouble getting a House Small Business Committee--intro TO SMALL BUSINESS direct loan then as small businessmen do duced the first Resolution in the 77th Con today. gress authorizing the establlshment of a Se Ill. BICENTENNIAL INDEPENDENCE FROl\! HIGH lect Committee on Small Business in the HON. JAMES C. CORMAN INTEREST RATES House. This first Committee was charged initially OF CALIFOILNIA In my view, one of the greatest achieve with the responsibility of investigating IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ments of this Bicentennial Year would be charges of discrimination against small busi for the small businessman to be able to de Monday, May 17, 1976 ness in the awarding of defense contracts. clare his independence from high interest Over the years, Congress has recreated and Mr. CORMAN. Mr. Speaker, as chair rates and once again receive low-interest re-established the Committee because of its direct loans from the Small Business Admin reports, its usefulness and its service to the man of the Subcommittee on Govern istration. ment Procurement and International small businessmen of the Nation. Perhaps we can appeal to the patriotism The present Congress--the 94th Con Trade of the House Small Business Com of our friends at the omce of Management gress--made the Committee a permanent mittee, I was delighted at the talk that and Budget. and standing Committee with legislative au Representative JoEL. EviNs, chairman of Over the years of my service in the Con thority. the Small Business Committee, gave at gress I have fought the battles of small busi The authority and responsibilities of our the recent presentation of awards to the ness as has our Committee in the House. Committee have thus been greatly expanded small business subcontractors of the year. As has been indicated, after 30 years, I am to meet the mounting challenges to small not seeking re-election to the Congress. business. Because of the importance of his re I am looking to my successors in the Con marks and the substantial interest in I am pleased to have had the honor of gress and others to carry on the fight to pre serving as Chairman of the Select Commit this matter by the public and the small serve, promote and perpetuate American tee for a number of years-appointed by the business community, I would like to small business and our free enterprise Speaker-and now to serve as the first Chair share Chairman EVINS' thoughts with my system. man of the new legislative Committee on colleagues. This conference is concerned with small Small Business. business procurement--getting a fair share Over the years our Committee has had The text of the speech follows: of government contracts among other cur SPEECH BY REPRESENTATIVE JoEL. EVINS many outstanding members, including rent small business problems. The Honorable Mike Mansfield, now the I. INTRODUCTORY I was pleased to note recently that Depart Majority Leader in the Senate. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, certainly I am ment of Defense subcontracts to small busi Senator Henry M. Jackson, a contender for pleased and delighted to have this oppor ness concerns in 1975 amounted to 39.3 per the Presidency and former Chairman of the tunity of appearing before this cllstingu1shed cent of all military subcontracts-although Democratic National Committee. group of small businessmen, officials of the I would hope that this total would be even The late senator Estes Kefauver of Ten Small Business Administration, and others larger. nessee. interested in the growth and progress of The 1975 percentage does reflect a slight Representative Charles Halleck, the Re small business. increase--about one percent--over the publican Minority Leader for many years. It 1s fitting and appropriate this Bicen amount of subcontracts that went to small Former Congressman Leonard Hall of New tennial Year of our Nation's founding that business subcontractors in 1974. York, later Chairman of the Republican Na small business be recognized for its tremen Our Committee over the years has devoted tional Committee. dous contributions to the founding of our much time and effort to resolving problems James Roosevelt of California, and many Nation and the establishment of our Re which subcontractors have in securing work others. public and our free enterprise system. from prime contractors at the Department Today our expanded Committee functions Small businessmen were in the vanguard of Defense, and certainly we shall continue as a service Committee--a legislative Com of the American Revolution. to do so. mittee--an oversight Committee-and an in Today as we celebrate the 200th anniver Our Committee has taken a strong posi vestigative Committee. sary of our Nation's birth, small business tion in favor of mandatory small business Our Committee serves the small business remains strong and important to this Nation. subcontracting by Federal departments and man by following up on complaints and re Congress has again recently declared that agencies, and I was pleased to note that there quests for assistance referred to us by our it shall be a policy of this Nation to aid, has recently been established a test program Colleagues in the House and by going to bat counsel, assist and promote American small for mandatory small business subcontracting. for the small businessman. I believe this new set-aside program is a business and our free enterprise system. V. RECENT CONGRESSIONAL ACTION-BILLS Today we cannot over-emphasize the im good indication that small business is con tinuing to make progress toward securing an PASSED portance of small business to our economy Wearing the mantle of legislative author and to our country. even greater share of Federal contracts for goods and services in the future and we look ity, our Committee during this session has n. THE IMPORTANCE OF S!.ULL BUSINESS forward to even greater progress. lost little time in moving forward with leg Small business is the seedbed of our free Regettably we must face the fact that islation to assist the small businessmen of enterprise system. small businessmen this year are caught up the Nation. Small business is the heart and soul of in a squeeze between- In this connection, I want to commend my our economy. Big Government. friend and Colleague Representative Neal Small business is creative and the mother Big Business. Smith of Iowa-the Chairman of the Legis of invention--of new technology. And High Interest. lative Subcommittee--and the members of Small business is responsible for hun Big Government over-regulates small busi the Small Business Committee for their out dreds--indeed thousands--of breakthroughs ness and forces small businessmen to spend standing work in expediting hearings, re in new technologies. many man-hours filling out useless forms porting and passing vital small business leg Small business wlll continue to be the and questionnaires complying with frivolous islation. source of new technologies-new tech regulations and much red tape. During the first session, the Committee niques and new productions. While Big Business and small business completed action on 28 bllls and resolu Small business is where the mind is free should be complementary in our competitive tions--and three bills passed the House by to exercise its greatest capabilities. free enterprise system, we know that Big unanimous vote. More than 95 percent of all businesses in Business often applies every conceivable Among the bills passed during the first this country are considered small business. pressure to capture an even larger segment session include: Small businesses contribute almost 50 per of the market. H.R. 5541-the Small Business Emergency cent--one-half--of our Gross National And High Interest-high interest rates- Relief Act-now Public Law 94-19~and Product. restrict the ability of a small businessman to which authorizes a Federal agency to cancel While small business is important ooday- grow and expand. or modify, under certain circumstances, a 1 should point out that small business is We are concerned with these problems fixed-price contract where the small busi confronted with many problems and is fight American small business is concerned-and nessman has encountered substantial price ing for its economic life against Giantism, I am sure that Administrator Kobellnski and increases which were not anticipated. This unfair competition and deceptive trade prac officials of SBA are also concerned with them. act also provides that 1! a contractor is un able to obtain energy, petroleum or petro tices in the marketplace. We have studied these problems-now we leum products, the delay is an excusable Our pioneer forefathers were tradesmen, need action-action by SBA and the Admin one--and he must be allowed additional time craftsmen and small businessmen. istration-and action by the Congress. to fulfill his commitments. IV. HISTORY, GROWTH AND DEVELOPMENT OF History tells us that Samuel Adams, Paul H.R. 905~this blll provides for amend Revere, Roger Sherma.n and other Revolu SMALL BUSINESS COl\!:Ml'rl'EE ments to the SBA and SBIC Acts clarifying tionary War leaders were small businessmen. The Small Business Committee in the the eligibility of agricultural oriented small Tradition tells us that Paul Revere was the House and Senate are a natural outgrowth of businesses to obtain SBA loans and estab first small businessman to apply to the a national concern for small business. lishes a new program of financing to assist May 17, 1976 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 14213 small business in meeting pollution stand Over the years our COmmittee has fought highest paid bureaucracies here in Wash ards. to maintain the independence of SBA when ington, expanding from a borrowed staif Another bill passed during the current any Administration has sought to place the session provides assistance to small busi agency in a huge bureaucracy mass where to 3,400 employees in just 2 years. Next nesses injured by the disruption of public SBA and the interests of the small business year, while the controls it administers are ut111ty service. This bill would establish a man would sutfer and be diminished. coming off, it wants 700 more. program of special assistance to small busi Our Committee continues to be concerned The FEA has repeatedly overstepped nesses injured as a result of the disruption with the growth in regulatory agencies af its statutory responsibilities, starting of services by public ut111ties. fecting small business and the public gener bureaucratic range wars with the FPC The Legislative Subcommittee, headed by ally. over natural gas policy, with the Depart Congressman Neal Smith of Iowa, has a We have seen the number of regulatory heavy schedule of pending small business agencies in the Federal Government double ment of State over international oil pol measures, including an Omnibus Small Busi from 12 to 24 in the past 10 years. icy, and with ERDA over nuclear power ness blll recently reported which raises the We have seen their budgets increase from promotion and solar energy. ceiling on authorizations of small business $860 million to 3 and one-half billion F'EA's public relations efforts have been loans, among other provisions. dollars. a gross misuse of public moneys. Its 112 Time will not permit a detailed accounting While we all recognize that we need some public relations experts have spent over of all bills pending before our Committee. regulation, we now have in too many in $3.5 million to propagandize and promote Suffice it to say that our Committee is stances over-regulation-regulatory "over the agency and to lobby Congress. keenly aware of its legislative responsibiUties klll"-too much regulation, too many rules, and expanded authority-and we are moving too much paperwork, red tape and guide F'EA's self-assumed role of major oil forward in the public interest. lines. company advocate runs at cross-purposes VI. SOME BASIC BELIEFS OF THE COMMITTEE Certainly the time has come to act against with its regulatory responsibilities, se this excessive bureaucratic imposition on verely impairing the agency's credibility This great conference will be interested in small business-to free small business. knowing some of the basic beliefs of our and effectiveness. Committee. Vill. CONCLUSION It is my hope that the introduction of Our COinmittee favors a climate and In summary, may I say that we must this bill will help focus attention on these atmosphere in this country favorable to the continue to work against excessive over serious problems with the Federal Energy growth and progress of American small busi regulation and red tape in Government- Administration before FEA extension ness. provide increased loans and asstistance to legislation comes to the fioor. It is my We favor action to end government over small business-generate a greater share of intention to present the bill as a substi regulation-regulatory "over-kill"-to end government procurement--create and main unnecessary paperwork, needless reporting tain a climate favorable to the growth and tute to H.R. 12169, the Commerce Com requirements and discriminatory taxes progress of American small business-in the mittee's bill to extend the F'EA, during which discourage capital formation and public interest. the fioor debate on the measure. harass small business. These goals must be achieved in the Americans from all walks of life and We favor doing away with red tape and months ahead. from every Statt; in the Union are ex giving small businesses the green light for Again, let me thank you for permitting pressing their concern this year over the growth and expansion. me the opportunity of sharing with you the growth and cost of the Federal Govern We favor vigorous enforcement of the observance of Small Business Week in this ment. We should respond to these con antitrust laws to break up the monopolies our Nation's Bicentennial Year. and conglomerates and to restore competition Small business began strong in this cerns, and ending the F'EA is a good place to the marketplace. country-and as I return to Tennessee at to start. We favor the elimination of unfair trade the conclusion of this session of the Con practices that drive small businesses into gress, I have faith and confidence to hope bankruptcy and that encourage and assist to believe that small business will continue LT. THOMAS BIGELOW NAMED the steady growth of monopolies, multina to grow stronger in the future. ''CITIZEN OF THE YEAR'' BY HAW tional corporations, conglomerates and Let's keep it that way. THORNE, CALIF., CHAMBER OF giantism. Thank you and good luck. COMMERCE One of the most important phases of our Committee's work this year has been the in vestigation by a Special Antitrust Ad-Hoc HON. CHARLES H. WILSON Subcommittee of reports that there is and FEA MUST BE ABOLISHED has been for some time in this country a OF CALIFORNIA move underway to repeal the Robinson-Pat HON. FLOYD J. FITHIAN IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES roan Act, the "Magna-Carta'' of small busi Monday, May 17, 1976 ness. The Robinson-Patman Act must be OF INDIANA maintained and should be vigorously en IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES Mr. CHARLES H. WILSON of califor forced. nia. Mr. Speaker, today it gives me pleas The COngress and the country are looking Monday, May 17, 1976 ure to pay tribute to a leading citizen of forward to the report and recommendations Mr. FITHIAN. Mr. Speaker, I want to Hawthorne, Calif., Lt. Thomas Bigelow, of this Subcommittee in the near future with great interest. respectfully urge my colleagues to sup who has recently been named "Citizen We favor a stronger and also an expanded port H.R. 13795, a bill to transfer the of the Year" by the Hawthorne Chamber small business assistance program to en necessary functions of the Federal En of Commerce. courage the creation of new small busi ergy Administration to other agencies Lieutenant Bigelow is a policeman and nesses and to provide jobs and employment and to allow the F'EA to expire. Repre during his 23 years with the Hawthorne for Americans through the free enterprise sentative ScHROEDER and I introduced Police Department he has taken on so system. this bill last week to provide a rational many other responsibilities and given the We favor a return to the direct small loan and responsible alternative to the pro people of Hawthorne so much of his off program for small businesses. duty time that one can truly say that We favor a greatly expanded and increased posed 3-year extension and expansion of amount of the Government procurement dol the FEA suggested by the administration he has made an outstanding contribu lar going to small business subcontractors and the House Commerce Committee. tion to the community. and small industries-and As you may know, the Federal Energy For instance, he worked in the PTA's We favor a strong and continuing overall Administration was created in 1974 to for more than 9 years in his school dis program to assist small business-the back deal with the specific problems created trict, spearheading the block parent pro bone of our country. by the Arab oil embargo. That short gram. For his outstanding work with VII. VALDEDICTORY OBSERVATIONS term crisis has passed, FEA's controls are children and youth he received an hon I truly believe that this year-1976---can being phased out. The time has now orary service award from the Centinela be a landmark year not only for small busi come to phase out the FEA. Valley Council of PTA's. ness but for America. The record of the FEA over the past This Citizen of the Year is well known We must eliminate the threats to small 2 years demonstrates conclusively that for his work with the Centinela Child business and our competitive free enterprise the agency is unfit for an expanded role Guidance Clinic, part of the Southwest system. We must strengthen SBA in the in administering national energy policy. Community Health Clinic Association. public interest. This organization is an outpatient facili The Small Business Administration is con The record suggests, in fact, that the sidered small in size compared with the vast agency is unfit to continue even as pres ty, providing counseling for families who departments of Government--Commerce, ently constituted. have problems with youngsters from Agriculture and Labor, for instance. The FEA is one of the fastest growing, 3 to 18 years of age. These cover a wide 14214 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS May 17, 1976 spectrum, such as drugs and alcohol in the Washington Star of May 14, the families pay substantially higher tax rates abuse, truancies and runaways, youths flaws of that philosophy. The column is than low-income families. with abnormal sexual behavior patterns included at this point in the CoNGREs As for the matter of tax relief, if the fed and other problems. Every year many SIONAL RECORD for the information of my eral government took $25,000 from each of those 3,000 people, that would raise a whop families and young people are saved from colleagues : ping $75 million. Is that enough to make serious consequences because of the work TEDDY'S FEEBLE DEFENSE OF FEDERAL SPENDING a. dent in the cost of a $413 billion govern done by this clinic. (By William F. Buckley.Jr.) ment? Lieutenant Bigelow has been active in Sen. Edward Kennedy, 1n obiter dicta on "The government probably misplaces $75 this clinic for several years. He has been the annual report of the Joint Economic million every minute or so," is Mr. Reynold's a working president for 2 years and has Committee of Congress, ha.s emitted a. few wry remark. just been elected to a third term. By thoughts calculated to make Americans feel Sen. Kennedy isn't particularly interested working, I mean he has done such things better about federal spending. In doing so, in taking more money from the a.filuent for he ra.n into the buzzsaw of economist Alan the sake of accumulating more money for as being responsible for painting the the government. There isn't enough around clinic, acquiring needed equipment and Reynolds. "The first and most da.ma.ging misconcep the rich to make much difference. presently, locating and remodeling new tion," Sen. Kennedy wrote, "is the myth of He wants to take their money so that they quarters. He has rustled such things as the mushrooming federal government . . . won't have the money to spend as they wish carpeting, fixtures, furnishing, and ma The only valid comparison is the ratio of to spend it, preferring that it be spent a.s terial to redecorate the building, also do (federal) spending is GNP. And that propor Sen. Kennedy wishes to spend it. It's bad ing much of the physical labor himself. tion ha.s remained almost precisely constant enough that the public is paying tax dol a.t about 20 per cent ever since the early lars for economic analysis of the quality of As a police officer for the city of Haw Sen. Kennedy's. thorne, the 1976 Citizen of the Year has 1950s." Get that a.t about. For one thing, raw federal spending is an presented special programs to many imprecise index of federal control, neglecting groups on such things as self protection off-budget a.nd regulatory agencies, a.nd the for women, antiburglary techniques, pro role of matching grants and revenue sharing MEDICAL DEVICE AMENDMENTS OF tection for senior citizens and similar in fostering the explosion of state and local 1976-CONFERENCE REPORT subjects, often on his own time. spending. It doesn't cost the taxpayers very Lieutenant Bigelow has his B.A. in much to finance the CAB, but the CAB costs police science from Cal State, is a mem taxpayers a. lot of money, a.s anyone knows HON. HENRY A. WAXMAN who ha.s commuted from San Francisco to ber of the Southern California Juvenile OF CALIFORNIA Los Angeles, which is twice the distance from Officers Association and the Los Angeles Washington to New York, and paid half the IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES County Peace Officers Association. fare-because CAB is out of the picture. Monday, May 17, 1976 He has been a member of the Wise "But a comparison of current federal burn School District Board of Trustees spending with the level of 'the early 19508' Mr. WAXMAN. Mr. Speaker, years of for 8 years, serving as president on two i.e., the Korean War,'' Mr. Reynolds points effort were completed last week with occasions. He served as vice president of out, "is just diTty pool. Defense wa.s more the House and Senate passage o! the the Hawthorne Coordinating Council, than half of the budget back then, and only conference report to the Medical Device and was in charge of case conferences a. fourth now. Still, federal spending wa.s 14 Amendments of 1976. This is a landmark per cent of GNP in 1951, 17.1 per cent in for this body. His concern for people has 1956, 19.1 per cent in 1966 and 23.6 per cent piece of legislation. benefited individual families when nor in 1976. That may sound like 'about 20 per As this House was told when it first mal channels were not available to help cent.' But federal spending in 1977 would be passed this bill on March 9, there is a with emergency food and other necessi about $265 b1llion if it were still 14 per cent compelling need for this legislation. ties. He has aided new citizen families of GNP, rather than the $413 billion figure Astonishingly, there is not now any Fed and in other instances helped save jobs Congress is now shooting for.'' eral regulation mandated by the Con for heads of households. "The second myth," writes Mr. Kennedy, gress to assure that medical devices on I am very proud to have persons such "is the so-called crushing burden of federal the market are safe and effective. The debt. In 1950, when the country emerged as Lieutenant Bigelow as part of our from World War II, the federal debt was a.n device industry is one which is indispen police department, and as a member of incredible 32 per cent of the nation's GNP. sable to the provision of quality health our community. In 1974, the level was a. modest 26 per cent." care to the American people. It is one in And I am equally proud to have him as But as Mr. Reynolds points out, savings which the public has placed a great deal one of my constituents in the 31st Con bonds are fixed in dollar terms, while GNP of its trust-in large part because of the gressional District of California. I think ha.s been wildly bloated by inflation. Bonds industry's outstanding contributions to it should be recorded that the business inevitably shrink in relation to the GNP, medical research and treatment. of this great Nation has been temporarily which means simply that the government has swindled the bondholders. Nevertheless, it has been documented suspended so that we could pay homage But even then, federal debt rose from 35 time and again that in the absence of to this citizen who, in his quiet way, has to 38.5 percent of GNP between 1974 and mandatory standards designed to protect contributed so much to the quality of life 1975. The "crushing burden" isn't the per public health, the American people have of his neighbors. centage of the GNP of the federal debt, it is from time to time been exposed to an un the taxes required merely to pay the inter reasonable risl~ due to the lack of safety est on that debt--a burden close, now, to and efficacy, or from the misuse or abuse, $50 b1llion. of some medical devices. A blue-ribbon FEDERAL SPENDING Sen. Kennedy has a solution. It is, as you commission chaired by Dr. Theodore would suspect, tax reform. He trots out the Cooper documented that, over a 10-year usual figure: "In 1973, over 3,000 people with HON. DEL CLAWSON adjusted gross incomes in excess of $50,000 period, hundreds of deaths and thou paid no Federal income tax at all. This priv sands of incidences of illness and injury OF CALIFORNIA ileged group represents the wealthiest one were caused by medical devices. The IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES half of 1 percent of all families in the United Health and Environment Subcommittee Monday, May 17, 1976 States. Yet they paid not one dime in federal received extensive testimony of numer Taxes. . . . The data. means that average ous instances of harmful effects caused Mr. DEL CLAWSON. Mr. Speaker, workingclass familles making $7,500 to by unproven or defective intrauterine judging from some of the discussion of $15,000 must pay higher taxes. devices, pacemakers, intraocular lenses, Federal spending, it would not be sur As a matter of fact, that is the least of the and other instruments which play a prising to read a headline one of these meaning of the data. All these data mean crucial and intimate role in the promo days stating "Robin Hood is alive and is that federal income taxes aren't paid on adjusted gross income (though I myself tion of human health. well and living on Capitol Hill." But we The nature of the industry itself posed might find to our dismay that it would believe they should be) but on taxable tn come-a.fter specified deductions neither a vexing problem for our subcommittee be a Robin Hood who applies his philos Sen. Kennedy nor Congress nor the average in devising an appropriate and effective ophy with a di1Ierence--taking from all working family wants to do without. regulatory mechanism. The devices in in order to bestow some highly costly The 3,000 red herrings don't constitute the dustry, which grosses over $6 billion a beneficence. Mr. William F. Buckley, Jr. wealthiest one half of 1 percent of all fami year, produces everything from tongue points out in his column which appeared lies. All studies show that high-income depressors and crutches to renal cathe- May 17, 1976 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 14215 ters and artificial heart valves. The chal heartened by the extraordinary coopera gregate personal income, production, and lenge before the subcommittee was to tion among the devices industry, public the gross national product simply do not design a regulatory scheme that was interest groups, the Food and Drug Ad grow as quickly when large percentages both tailored to such a diverse spectrum ministration, and the Health Subcom of expenditures are made by and within of health care products, and consistent mittee in writing this legislation. Well Government. This is statistically prov with our overriding concern-that those deserved congratulations are to be ex able. devices which reach the market be es tended to Chairman PAUL ROGERS, with Employment has lost. Dollars spent in tablished as safe and effective. whom it has been an honor and a priv Government do not create as many jobs. The general rule which has been ap ilege to work, to member of the Health Competition has declined. Government plied in this legislaiton is: the less and Environment Subcommittee, and its is forcing itself into obtaining more and scientific documentation available to es outstanding staff. I am very proud of the more of its goods and services without tablish safety and efficacy, the greater work we have done on this bill. the benefits of competition. This is sta the showing of these qualities that has tistically provable. to be made by the manufacturer. This, in The adequacy of investment capital my judgment, is the most prudent and has declined. The private sector has lost reasonable approach which could be GOVERNMENT SHOULD NOT BE part of the capital base it needs for fa adopted. It is structured to provide the IN COMPETITION WITH PRIVATE cility expansion and employment as a flexibility necessary to regulate such an ENTERPRISE result of the circumvention of Congress amorphous range of products but is de policy. This is statistically provable. signed, ultimately, to protect the public And America's technological lead over health. HON. JACK F. KEMP other industrialized nations is being lost. As I have mentioned earlier, much of OF NEW YORK In large measure this is because of the our attention was of necessity focused on IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES way in which increasing percentages of thos.e devices which are most dramati Monday, May 17, 1976 the innovative, creative processes asso cally involved in supporting or sustain ciated with research a.nd development ing human life and health, and particu Mr. ECEMP. Mr. Speaker, on February are being moved into the often stale en larly those which are implanted in the 19, I introduced House Joint Resolution vironments of the bureaucracies. This is body. This conference report makes clear 818, a resolution to clarify and reaffirm statistically provable too. that all these devices must secure pre Government purchasing policies. The growth of Government in general market approval before they can be This resolution is receiving growing has had much to do with this. But the come commercially available to the pub support from within Congress and from growth in Government being an increas lic, unless it can be clearly and con the private sector, and I can assure my ingly larger provider of goods and serv vincingly shown that premarket clear colleagues that strong support for its ices for itself has had a profound effect ance is not necessary to assure the de adoption has been privately expressed to on this trend. It has accelerated this vice's safety and efficacy. Moreover, any me from officials within the administra trend significantly. decision not to require premarket clear tion. Government has no business being in ance must be fully, and publicly, docu The resolution is designed to reassert business. Yet, we are at a point where mented. the principle embodied in OMB Circular Federal dollars are being used increas I believe this is a crucial first step in A-76-that it is the general policy of ingly to compete with the private sector. guaranteeing that the intrauterine de the Government to rely upon private And Government has an unfair, inequi vices available to women, the pacemakers commercial sources for the goods and table and anticompetitive advantage implanted in our elderly, and the devices services required to meet Government over the private sector, because Govern which are increasingly used to replace needs. ment also sets the rules governing the damaged or dysfunctional human or Why is this resolution and the prin competition between and with itself. In gans will be of the highest quality, and ciple reflected through it of such major simplest terms it has the double ad as safe and effective, as possible. importance to our economy? vantage of both playing the game and Second, we have provided that any in Congress has before it an opportunity setting the rules-player and umpire. formation regarding any adverse health we cannot miss. It is an opportunity to The results of this can be obvious. You effects associated with the use of a de redirect about $2 ¥2 billion in existing can see rather readily the effects on tax vice be available to the public. Federal spending into the Nation's burdens, the economy, employment, and Third, we have required under most smaller businesses each year. This would our status. You can see that Government circumstances that patients who have be a new flow of activity into the private, is moving toward becoming the first con been subjected to a health risk due to the productive sector of the economy-not a vergence of monopoly and monopsony use of a device be notified by their physi redirection of existing contract dollars a single seller and a single buyer. It is cian so that appropriate corrective treat from one type of business to another. buying more than ever and is producing ment can be undertaken. And it would be done without spending more than ever-to sell to itself. But Fourth, we have required that all who one extra dollar of taxpayers' money. other results are not as obvious. You can participate in developing performance How would this come about? By re not see as readily the effect on our way standards for medical devices disclose affirming the policy of Congress that the of thinking, of shifts in relative import any potential conflicts of interest which Government should buy its goods and ance between what Goven1ment decides would prejudice their involvement in services from the private sector in both should be done and what the people de this process. the defense and civilian fields. This is cide should be done, and of the decline in Fifth, we have require that informed already the policy of the Congress. It has the success rate in experimental tech consent be obtained by researchers who been clarified and reaffirmed by us be nology. are investigating the use of a device with fore. And it has been adopted by all ad This is why I believe we are winning human subjects. Although exactly what ministrations. the support of so many Members--Mem constitutes informed consent is outlined Yet this policy is constantly eroded at bers who are becoming cosponsors of the only in the conference report, we very the department and agency levels, pre resolution. As of today, we have there are much intend and expect that those pro sumably by those who want a larger bu 43 cosponsors of the me::t.sure in the visios will be rigorously followed by in reaucracy, one more dominant in our House and 10 cosponsors of the Senate vestigators and researchers. society. It has become a policy observed companion bill, Senate Joint Resolution As can be seen, we have conscientiously more in the breach than in compliance- 186, introduced by our former colleague tried, in a time when the consumer is a breach which has produced a number and my friend, Senator BILL BROCK ot rightfully demanding to be fully apprised of losses for the country. Tennessee. Those cosponsors are: of the choices and opportunities, and the The taxpayers have lost. A dollar spent Mr. KEMP of New York. risks and benefits available, to make cer in-house by Government simply does not Mr. ADDABBO of New York. tain that information can be secured. I buy the same level of productivity as one Mr. ARCHER of Texas. believe we have, on the whole, succeeded. spent in the private sector. That is statis Mr. AsHBROOK of Ohio. This legislation has truly been a col tically provable. Mr. BAFALIS Of Florida. laborative effort. I have been greatly The economy has lost. Real wages, ag- Mr. BROWN Of Ohio. 14216- EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS May 17, 1976 Mr. BROWN of Michigan. rely, to the maximum extent, on the private thwarted 1s the dedicated opposition of the Mr. BURGENER of California. sector. It, the Government, is not to compete federal employee labor unions-it is obvious with private enterprise. that such organizations, now more than a Mr. CEDERBERG Of Michigan. The first directive was issued in 1955 by million strong in membership, have a vested Mr. COLLINS of Texas. the then Bureau of the Budget. This origlnaJ. interest in furthering Government growth in Mr. CRANE of Illinois. directive has been revised four times since employment. It increases their membership. Mr. DERWINSKI of Illinois. then and is known as Circular A-76. Thus the Government unions have been Mr. DICKINSON Of Alabama. The 11m1ted circumstances covering Gov fighting the whole concept of service con Mr. DUNCAN of Oregon. ernment in-house work are very clear in A-76. tracting-in Congress and in the Courts. It Mr. EscH of Michigan. This policy 1s bipar:tisan and has not shifted is a logical stand since their strength as Mr. EsHLEMAN of Pennsylvania. since 1955 through several changes of Ad unions depends on their growth, for one mintstrations. thing, and for a constantly increasing pay Mr. GoLDWATER of California. An