DOCSLIB.ORG

Rationales for Giving: Touching the Emotional Bases

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Rationales for Giving: Touching the Emotional Bases Rationales for Giving: Touching the Emotional Bases Noam Zion Hartman Institute, Jerusalem Excerpted from: Jewish Giving in Comparative Perspectives: History and Story, Law and Theology, Anthropology and Psychology Book Three: For the Love of God: Comparative Religious Motivations for Giving Christian Charity, Maimonidean Tzedakah and Lovingkindness (Hesed) Previous Books: A DIFFERENT NIGHT: The Family Participation Haggadah By Noam Zion and David Dishon LEADER'S GUIDE to "A DIFFERENT NIGHT" By Noam Zion and David Dishon A DIFFERENT LIGHT: Hanukkah Seder and Anthology including Profiles in Contemporary Jewish Courage By Noam Zion A Day Apart: Shabbat at Home By Noam Zion and Shawn Fields- Meyer A Night to Remember: Haggadah of Contemporary Voices Mishael and Noam Zion [email protected] www.haggadahsrus.com 1 A. Empathy, Righteous Indignation and the Exodus B. Self-Perfecting Therapeutic Giving versus World-Perfecting Tikkun Olam C. Philanthropic Civic Pride D. Respect for Human Dignity E. Gratitude, An Opportunity to Give Back and the Faithfulness of a Steward F. Mercy, Rahmanut, Compassion G. Brotherhood, Solidarity, Reciprocity and Mutual Responsibility H. Redemption: Empowering Tzedakah and Enabling Love I. Prudent Giving: Investing in One’s Future J. David Hartman: Mature Love with Respect for Frailty and Acceptance of Interdependence K. Edgar Kahn’s Time Bank: A This-Worldly Bank for Depositing the Gifts of Rich and Poor Alike Appendix: A Universal Labor Exchange of Volunteers, “Rich” and “Poor,” in Mutual Service 2 The philosopher of ethics, Martha Nussbaum, poses an essential question for our study of the ethics, religion and the personal motivations of givers: what is the role of emotions in moral deliberation?i She acknowledges that Stoics and Kantian rationalists wish to remove emotions from all moral discussions, because they think all emotions, including love and mercy, prejudice rational thinking and objective justice, which ought to constitute the sole bases for morality. Nussbaum, however, sides with Aristotle and Maimonides, who hold that emotions must be cultivated positively if individuals and societies are to educate to moral action. “E- motions” are motive forces that help to transform values into specific behavior. More importantly, she argues, moral emotions, such as compassion, courage and righteous indignation, help us to discern the moral topography of a situation as well as to determine how to respond and thus, how to be “responsible.” Let review basic concepts in Jewish, Greek and Christian narratives of giving in terms of the emotional mindset and judgments that are nurtured by their ways of seeing the drama of life and the value of generosity. A. Empathy, Righteous Indignation and the Exodus In a particular situation a decision about giving is preceded by an interpretation of that moment in terms of a narrative pattern of meaning. In each case the giver sees not just static facts, but a situation that triggers a self-understanding of how the giver stands in relationship to the recipient within a narrative trajectory. One reads the situation in terms of a dynamic impulse toward action that will bring closure to the story. For example, my father, Rabbi Moses Sachs, while watching television in 1963, saw the German shepherd dogs let loose on black demonstrators protesting Jim Crow in Birmingham, Alabama. He witnessed police beating with clubs these still-oppressed children of former slaves.. He listened to these long- suffering people, now standing up to demand their freedom, and he heard Martin Luther King, Jr. offer a narrative paradigm – the Biblical Moses’ “Let My People Go” – to make sense of the struggle morally. My father recalled his own name and identified with his Biblical namesake, Moshe, who, when seeing an Egyptian beating a Jew, his brother, decided to intervene after seeing that there was no one else to act. My father also understood from his yearly role in leading the Seder on Passover that “each one is obligated to see oneself as if s/he went out of Egypt.” So he felt impelled morally and narratively to be true to his past and his calling and to go to Birmingham in order to contribute his voice and his bodily solidarity to a people, like his, who were struggling for freedom. One of the rabbis with my father, Rabbi Richard Rubenstein, interpreted the meaning of that solidarity between Jew and Black based on their shared narrative of the Egypt: “The Negro community saw the rabbis in a way in which they had seldom seen Jews. By our very presence we were handing down a kind of ‘apostolic’ succession to them. We were saying that the flesh and blood children of Israel were behind them in their struggle, that we had gone from slavery to freedom, and we knew they would. The convention behind the 3 symbolism of solidarity was heightened by our willingness to incur risks of physical harm to bear witness to our convictions."1 However, the identification of Jew and Negro was by no means unidirectional. Just as the African-American took heart from the Jews,2 so too were the rabbis inspired by the marchers. My father recalled vividly the powerful sermon about Moses at the burning bush that he heard in a Birmingham church. Another colleague recalled: “Reverend Ralph Abernathy at a rally held in a church.... told how Moses avoided looking at the [burning] bush. God finally forced Moses to look at the bush, and Moses looked at it until the fire of that bush burned within him. With that fire within, Moses took the first steps towards redeeming his people. I think that many of us felt that way about our ‘Birmingham’ experience. Something about those days transformed our brothers' burning desire for freedom and equality into a flame burning within us."ii When he returned home, he delivered a sermon comparing each stage of the African-American liberation movement to the Zionist liberation movement in its response to anti-Semitism and the Nazi denial of civil rights. Here, a narrative 1 “As early as 1948, James Baldwin had written in an essay entitled ‘The Harlem Ghetto,’ which appeared in Commentary published by the American Jewish Committee: “The Negro identifies himself almost wholly with the Jew. The more devout Negro considers that he is a Jew, in bondage to a hard taskmaster and waiting for a Moses to lead him out of Egypt. The hymns, the texts, and the most favored legends of the devout Negro are all Old Testament and therefore Jewish in origin: the flight from Egypt, the Hebrew children in the fiery furnace, the terrible jubilee songs of deliverance.... The covenant God made in the beginning with Abraham and which was to extend to his children and to his children's children forever is a covenant made with these latter-day exiles also: as Israel was chosen, so are they.” (Marc Schneier, Shared Dreams: MLK and the Jews, 151-156) 2 Esther and the Jewish Beanies: The Voter Registration Marches in Selma, Alabama, 1965 “Upon returning to Selma, M. L. King learned that Sheriff Clark and his henchmen had used cattle prods on a group of marching students. As King's voter registration campaign branched out into neigh- boring counties, the state troopers were quick to put marchers to flight, shooting one, Jimmy Lee Jackson. While in his hospital bed, Jackson was charged with assaulting a police officer. On February 26, Jackson died. James Bevel delivered a sermon that night at Selma's Brown Chapel, expounding ‘on Esther 4:8, in which Mordecai warned Esther of an order to destroy the Jews, and charged her to go to the king and `make request before him for her people.' [‘I shall go to the king in spite of the law; and if I perish, I perish’ (Esther 4:17).] He preached that the king now was Governor Wallace, who ran the state troopers and kept Negroes from voting. ‘I must go see the king!' [Esther 4:16] he cried, and soon brought the whole church to its feet vowing to go on foot.... ‘Be prepared to walk to Montgomery!’ shouted Bevel.” On March 3, King approved Bevel's call for a fifty-mile march from Selma to Montgomery, the capital in Montgomery, the homeland of the Confederacy, to petition Governor Wallace to end ‘police brutality and grant Alabama Negroes the elective franchise.’ At the press conference, Bevel wore a yarmulke, something he'd been doing since his Freedom Riding days. He sometimes explained this affectation as an outgrowth of ‘his affection for the Hebrew prophets and other times as a protec- tive device to keep himself out of jail, saying Mississippi sheriffs were so mystified by the sight of a Negro preacher in a `Jewish beanie' they preferred to let him alone.’ As the march progressed, skullcaps became a symbol of the movement. James Bevel, as mentioned before, had worn one for several years, but now the marchers called for ‘freedom caps’ of their own. The demand for yarmulkes was so great that an order was wired for delivery of a thousand caps when the marchers would arrive in Montgomery and demonstrate at the state capitol. When the group finally reached Montgomery days later, having surged to some twenty-five thousand people, the event was heralded as the greatest day ever for the civil rights.” (Marc Schneier, Shared Dreams, 151-156) 4 pattern, an emotional empathy and an interpretation of the past in its relationship to the present impelled his action. In the light of this Biblical narrative my father felt impelled to join these demonstrators, not only to show his empathy, not only to do the right things according to his conscience, but to advance this story toward its just and happy ending, as promised by the God of the Exodus.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Hesed, the Emotional Component of Tzedakah: Consolation, Joy and Empowerment in Maimonides and Erich Fromm
    Hesed, The Emotional Component of Tzedakah: Consolation, Joy and Empowerment in Maimonides and Erich Fromm A. Biblical and Rabbinic Hesed B. Verbal Consolation: Responding to the Alienation and Pain of the Poor C. The Maimonidean Joy of Giving: Imitatio Dei and Reviving the Dead D. HaRakhaman, Giving as Empowerment for the Beloved: Erich Fromm’s The Art of Loving (1956) and Maternal Love Excerpted from: Jewish Giving in Comparative Perspectives: History and Story, Law and Theology, Anthropology and Psychology Book Three: For the Love of God: Comparative Religious Motivations for Giving Christian Charity, Maimonidean Tzedakah and Lovingkindness (Hesed) Previous Books: A DIFFERENT NIGHT: The Family Participation Haggadah By Noam Zion and David Dishon LEADER'S GUIDE to "A DIFFERENT NIGHT" By Noam Zion and David Dishon A DIFFERENT LIGHT: Hanukkah Seder and Anthology including Profiles in Contemporary Jewish Courage By Noam Zion A Day Apart: Shabbat at Home By Noam Zion and Shawn Fields-Meyer A Night to Remember: Haggadah of Contemporary Voices Mishael and Noam Zion [email protected] www.haggadahsrus.com 1 A. Biblical and Rabbinic Hesed ג ד "The Rabbis said to Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi: Today little school children came to the Beit Midrash (the study hall) and spoke of things the like of which were not even said in the days of Joshua, son of Nun [the student of Moshe]. [These pupils recited the alphabet and thereby strung together letters into sentences that teach moral wisdom as exemplified in the following:] Aleph Bet means: "Study (Aleph –ulpan in Aramaic) wisdom (Binah)! Gimel Dalet means: Grant lovingkindness (Gemol Gemilut hasadim) to the poor (Dal)! What is the significance of the shape of the letter Gimel that extends its ‘leg’ [as if running]? It teaches that the way of giving lovingkindness (Gemilut hasadim) is to run after the poor (Dal of Dalet) [to provide their needs].
    [Show full text]
  • The Material Culture of Love and Loss in Eighteenth-Century England Jennifer A
    ‘I mourn for them I loved’: The Material Culture of Love and Loss in Eighteenth-Century England Jennifer A. Jorm Bachelor of Arts (History) Honours Class 1 A thesis submitted for the degree of Master of Philosophy at The University of Queensland in 2015 School of Historical and Philosophical Inquiry i Abstract This thesis analyses the material culture of love and loss in eighteenth-century England through the lens of emotions. My study builds on scholarly works on material culture, emotions, death, love, and loss. It examines objects used to declare love, to express grief, and to say farewell. Chapter One introduces the historiography of this topic, outlines the methodology used, and problematises the issues and questions surrounding the relationship between individuals and objects during this period, such as the eighteenth century “consumer revolution,” and the rise of sentimentalism. This chapter also introduces what I term the “emotional economy,” or the value placed on an object based on emotional signficance regardless of its intrinsic value. Chapter Two explores love tokens and the role they played in not only the expression of romantic love, but the making and breaking of courtships and marriages. This chapter concludes that the exchange of tokens was vital to the expression of love, and was an expected emotional behaviour to progress a courtship into a marriage. Chapter Three explores the material culture of death, focusing on tokens created and distributed for the comforting of mourners, and the commemoration of the dead. It’s findings confirmed that mourners valued tokens and jewellery, particularly those made with hair belonging to the deceased in order to maintain a physical connection to their loved ones after their passing.
    [Show full text]
  • History of Women Reel Listing
    History of Women Reel Listing Abailard, Pierre, 1079-1142. Agrippa, von Nettesheim, Heinrich Cornelius, Letters of Abelard and Heloise. 1486?-1535. London, Printed for J. Watts. 1743 The glory of women; or, A treatise declaring the Item identification number 1; To which is prefix'd a excellency and preheminence of women above men, particular account of their lives, amours, and which is proved both by scripture, law, reason, and misfortunes: extracted chiefly from Monsieur Bayle. authority, divine and humane. Translated from the French by the late John Hughes, London, Printed for Robert Ibbitson. 1652 esq. 7th ed. Item identification number 7; Written first in Latine Reel: 1 by Henricus Cornelius Agrippa ... and now translated into English for the vertuous and beautifull female Adams, Hannah, 1755-1832. sex of the commonwealth of England. by Edvv. An alphabetical compendium of the various sects Fleetvvood, gent. which have appeared in the world from the beginning Reel: 1 of the Christian æ ra to the present day. Boston, Printed by B. Edes & sons. 1784 Alberti, Marcello, b. 1714. Item identification number 3; with an appendix, Istoria della donne scientiate del dotore Marcello containing a brief account of the different schemes of Alberti. religion now embraced among mankind. The whole In Napoli, Per Felice Mosca. 1740 collected from the best authors, ancient and modern. Item identification number 8. Reel: 1 Reel: 1 Adams, Hannah, 1755-1832. Albertus Magnus, Saint, bp. of Ratisbon, 1193?- A summary history of New-England, from the 1280. first settlement at Plymouth, to the acceptance of the Albertus Magnus, de secretis mulierum.
    [Show full text]
  • Sex, Spirits, and Sensibility: Human Generation in British Medicine, Anatomy, and Literature, 1660-1780
    Sex, Spirits, and Sensibility: Human Generation in British Medicine, Anatomy, and Literature, 1660-1780 Darren Neil Wagner PhD The University of York Department of History September 2013 Abstract This thesis explores the physiological idea of animal spirits in relation to nerves, sex, and reproduction in the culture of sensibility. That physiology held the sex organs of both females and males to be exceptionally sensitive parts of the body that profoundly affected individuals’ constitutions and minds. Sexual sensations, desires, volition, and behaviour depended upon animal spirits and nerves. A central concern in this perception of the body and mind was the conflict between rationality from the intellectual will and sexual feelings from the genitalia. The idea that the body and mind interacted through animal spirits became influential in Georgian culture through anatomical and medical writings, teachings, and visual displays, but also through its resonance in literature about sensibility. This research predominantly draws upon material and print cultures of medicine, anatomy, and literature from 1660-1780. The analysis highlights the roles of gender, markets, literary modes, scientific practices, visual demonstrations, medical vocations, and broader social and political discourses in conceptions of the body and mind in relation to sex and reproduction. Ultimately, this study fleshes out the sensible and sexual body, which cultural and literary historians have frequently referred to, and emphasizes how the organs of generation commanded
    [Show full text]
  • DANSON Erotica Collection at TRINITY COLLEGE , OXFORD Catalogued by Alison Felstead
    The DANSON Erotica Collection at TRINITY COLLEGE , OXFORD Catalogued by Alison Felstead Transcribed by Patrick J. Kearney Scissors & Paste Bibliographies Santa Rosa, California, and Trinity College, Oxford, 2019 © 2019 The President and Fellows of Trinity College, Oxford. The Danson Collection he Danson erotica collection of approximately 450 items forms part of the much larger Danson Tcollection, which came to Trinity College in 1976. It was the bequest of Lieutenant-Colonel John Raymond Danson (1898-1976), an old member of the College, who matriculated in 1912, reading Law. He served as captain in the Cheshire Regiment in the First World War, and was awarded the Military Cross. He entered the family firm of average adjusters after the War, and was made a partner in 1921. He maintained his ties with the military, serving in the Territorial Army between the wars. In 1940 he went to France with the British Expeditionary Force, where he commanded the 4 th Battalion Cheshire Regiment and rose to the rank of Lieutenant-Colonel. He retired from the army after the evacuation from Dunkirk in 1940, and returned to the family firm, where he remained until his retirement in 1953. He was made an Honorary Fellow of Trinity in 1969. Danson had decided to leave his books to Trinity after discussing this with the College President, Herbert Blakiston (President 1907-38), in the early 1930s, and spent the next forty years building a collection with the College in mind. In a letter to J R H Weaver (President 3 1938-54) dated 27 June 1949 Danson outlined the history and the contents of his library: “It was started by my grandfather [John Towne Danson] who died in 1897 [i.e.
    [Show full text]
  • Ethnography and Queer Translation 72 EVREN SAVCI
    Queering Translation, Translating the Queer This groundbreaking work is one of the first book-length publications to critically engage in the emerging field of research on the queer aspects of translation and interpreting studies. The volume presents a variety of theo- retical and disciplinary perspectives through fourteen contributions from both established and up-and-coming scholars in the field to demonstrate the interconnectedness between translation and queer aspects of sex, gender, and identity. The book begins with the editors’ introduction on the state of the field, providing an overview of both current and developing lines of research, and builds on this foundation to look at this research more closely, grouped around three different sections: Queer Theorizing of Translation, Case Studies of Queer Translations and Translators, and Queer Activism and Translation. This interdisciplinary approach seeks not only to shed light on this promising field of research but also to promote cross-fertilization between these disciplines toward further exploring the intersections between queer studies and translation studies, making this volume key reading for students and scholars interested in translation studies, queer studies, poli- tics, activism, and gender and sexuality studies. Brian James Baer is Professor of Russian Translation in the Department of Modern and Classical Language Studies at Kent State University. Klaus Kaindl is Associate Professor at the Centre for Translation Studies at the University of Vienna. Routledge Advances in
    [Show full text]
  • Elizabeth of the Trinity
    ELIZABETH OF THE TRINITY The Charism of her Prayer JEAN LAFRANCE adapted from the French by a nun of the Carmel du Pater Noster, Jerusalem with an Introduction by Archbishop Joseph Tawil Printed at Darlington Carmel Imprimatur: Nihil Obstat: James Joseph Beltritti Very Reverend Father Tadgh Tierney, OCD Latin Patriarch of Jerusalem Provincial Councillor 27 December 1983 CONTENTS Acknowledgment (i) Introduction (ii) Preface ‘Love draws its object’ Life and Prayer 1 Chapter 1 ‘A Praise of Glory is a soul that dwells in God’ The Spirituality of Elizabeth of the Trinity 11 Trinitarian Vocation 15 Theological Life 21 Chapter 2 ‘A Praise of Glory is a silent soul’ Movement of Elizabeth’s Recollection 29 Chapter 3 ‘A Praise of Glory is a soul ever gazing upon God’ Crystal of Love 44 Faith and Simplicity 47 A Soul’s Night 54 A Fathomless Abyss 62 Chapter 4 ‘A Praise of Glory is a being ever in thanksgiving’ Elizabeth’s Prayer 68 Pray Continually 70 Elizabeth and Contemplative Prayer 73 Praying Contemplatively on the Holy Scriptures 80 Praying in the Present 85 The Prayer of the Church: Carmel’s Mission 91 ‘Janua Caeli’, Mary the Mother of God 100 Epilogue ‘In the Heaven of our Soul’ 105 Prayer to the Holy Trinity 109 ACKNOWLEDGMENT We are grateful to His Beatitude, Msgr James Joseph Beltritti, Latin Patriarch of Jerusalem and Superior of the Carmel du Pater Noster, for his encouragement of this adaptation of Jean Lafrance’s book on Blessed Elizabeth of the Trinity. A special thanks also to all those who assisted with their generous support and prayers.
    [Show full text]
  • Separate Rooms, 1989) Is a Novel Written by Pier Vittorio Tondelli, an Italian Writer Active in Bologna During the 1980S
    Tondelli’s Camere separate Through Roland Barthes’ Lexicon Laura Gagliardi Camere separate (Separate Rooms, 1989) is a novel written by Pier Vittorio Tondelli, an Italian writer active in Bologna during the 1980s. In order to understand the thematic complexity of this book, I shall use the theoretical lexicon elaborated by the French theorist, Roland Barthes, in his A Lover’s Discourse: Fragments (1977). Barthes’ writing becomes an essential tool to explore the subtleties of romantic novels, which can be read more deeply and more clearly when analyzed through the definitions of typical lovers’ images which are defined and exemplified in Barthes’ love vocabulary.1 The Italian critic Eugenio Bolongaro, in his essay “A Scandalous Intimacy,” remembers that “Pier Vittorio Tondelli's Camere separate is such a novel, a work that challenges the method as well as the hedonism of the Barthesian model,” a work seen “as the site for an endlessly renewed encounter between living beings in and through language” (816). Therefore, to survive the challenge, and go beyond the understanding of Tondelli’s novel, I shall follow a process of analysis going deep into the lexicon provided by Barthes, applying it to different moments in Tondelli’s work. Tondelli was born in 1955 in Correggio, a small town in Emilia Romagna, and began his career at twenty-five with the novel Altri libertini (1980), a literary phenomenon that upset the intellectual scene of the time2. Introducing themes that were considered outrageous and foul, such as homosexuality and sexually transmitted diseases— Camere separate is the first novel to ever depict the AIDS epidemic in Italy.
    [Show full text]
  • A Dictionary of Dictionaries
    137846 Dictionary of Dictionaries 417p Douglas Quirk, O.A.* Acknowledgements This Dictionary of Dictionaries was not prepared for, nor does it represent the views of any known organization, institution or special interest group. All who have been approached to sponsor this material have vehemently opposed its creation or publication. These included my tailor (who insists on sewing into my suits a GFR label: 'Guaranteed Factory Reject'?), my soap-maker (who just went broke), my maiden aunt (who died just before I was born), my local psychological association (which declined to comment or be named) and the kid who today kicked a hole in the rust that is my car (who used some invective when I offered him part ownership in this my other possession). Perhaps you think I ought to thank all these for whatever kind thoughts they might have intended. Like all dictionaries, this one steals other people's words and ideas. Many of the definitions offered here are plagiarized from Ambrose Bierce's Devil's Dictionary. It was impossible to obtain his permission to reproduce his definitions. You see, around the middle of the last century, when he was in his 80s, I bore the pain of assassinating him, out of sheer envy of his vitriolic tongue. May his remains rest in pieces, wherever they are. INTRODUCTION People know how to be people. They just don't know how to talk to themselves or others about being people. Because we don't know how to talk about being people, we often mislead ourselves and others by using the wrong words and ideas.
    [Show full text]
  • Phd Thesis BHARTI PARMAR
    A Grammar of Sentiment Bharti Parmar A GRAMMAR OF SENTIMENT thinking about sentimental jewellery towards making new art about love and loss Bharti Parmar BA (Hons), MA (RCA), SEDA (University of Plymouth) October 2008 Submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements of the University of Wolverhampton for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy This work or any part thereof has not previously been presented in any form to the University or to any other body whether for the purposes of assessment, publication or for any other purpose (unless otherwise indicated). Save for any express acknowledgments, references and/or bibliographies cited in the work, I confirm that the intellectual content of the work is the result of my own efforts and of no other person. The right of Bharti Parmar to be identified as author of this work is asserted in accordance with ss.77 and 78 of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. At this date copyright is owned by the author. Signature............................................. Date..................................................... 1 A Grammar of Sentiment Bharti Parmar 2 A Grammar of Sentiment Bharti Parmar This written thesis is accompanied by four artworks. These artworks comprise half of this PhD submission. The author wishes to discuss these artworks with the examiners during the viva in the form of a presentation. The artworks are illustrated and discussed throughout the written thesis. 3 A Grammar of Sentiment Bharti Parmar Contents Illustrations of artworks (Gems, Hairworking, Emblems, Words) 6-10 Abstract 11 1. Chapter one: Introduction 1.1. The research, its aims, objectives and outcomes 13 1.2. Analytical and intellectual frameworks 31 1.3.
    [Show full text]
  • John Cleland's the Dictionary of Love: an XML Edition
    John Cleland's The Dictionary of Love: An XML Edition Emily K. Davis Thesis submitted to the Faculty of the Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in English David Radcliffe, Chair Daniel Mosser Carlos Evia April 27, 2007 Blacksburg, Virginia Keywords: Dictionary, Love, Cleland, XML, Digital Humanities, Sociolinguistics Copyright 2007, Emily K. Davis John Cleland's The Dictionary of Love: An XML Edition Emily K. Davis (ABSTRACT) Conducting and disseminating humanities research is fast becoming a highly technological endeavor. The variety of multimedia options for presenting information changes the questions we ask and the answers we find as well as the problems we encounter and the solutions we devise. The following essays provide an account of creating a digital edition of John Cleland's The Dictionary of Love using XML. The project utilizes traditional literary research methods while working toward an untraditional digital final product, a characteristic that highlights the feedback loop between form and function. Thus, the purpose of this project is twofold: to provide students and scholars information and analysis on The Dictionary of Love and, in the process, to examine and discuss the challenges, drawbacks and benefits of producing the content as a web-compatible resource. Table of Contents Author's Acknowledgments v Forward vi Chapter 1: About the Project The 'Why?' and 'How?' of Constructing a Digital Resource 1-8 Questions and Challenges 9-14 Chapter 2: Publication History of The Dictionary of Love 15-19 Chapter 3: Analysis The Dictionary of Love and Language in Richardson's Pamela 20-23 Literary Examples 24-30 Appendix A: Biography of John Cleland 31-33 Appendix B: Biography of Ralph Griffiths 34-36 Appendix C: Biography of J.
    [Show full text]
  • Notes and References
    Notes and References 1 Blake Studies: A Critiul Survey 1. Bakhtin, Toward a Methodology for the Human Sciences', in Speech Gellres lind Otller Late Essays, ed. by Caryl Emerson and Michael Holquist (Austin, Texas: University of Texas Press, 1986), p. 170. 2. 'Blake' (1920), rep. in T.S. Eliot: Selected Prose, ed. by John Haywood (Harmondsworth: Penguin, 1965), pp. 159--62 (p. 162). For a rather different treatment of this issue see Nelson Hilton, 'Blake and the Apocalypse of the Canon', Modern LAnguage Studies, 16, 1 (Winter 1988),134-49. 3. Some of these deficiencies are being remedied by writers whose work I shall discuss laler, the following are especiall y valuable: Jon Mee, Dangerolls Enthusiasm: William Blakt~ and the Cull un! of Radi­ calism in the 1790s (Ox ford : Clarendon Press, 1992); David Worrall, Radical Culture; Discourse, Resistance and Surveillance, 1790-1820 (Hemel Hempstead: Harvester Wheatsheaf, 1992) and E.P. Thompson, Witness Against the Beast: William Blake and the Moral LIIW (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1993). 4. 'Toward a Methodology', p. 170. 5. A good sense of the scope of this debate can be found in the 44 works (89 vols) reprinted in the series, 'The Feminist Controversy in England, 1788-1810', ed. by Gina Luria (New York and lon­ don: Garland Publishing Inc, 1974). See too, Women, the Fllmily lind Freedom: The: Debate in Documents, Vol. I 1750-1880, ed. by Susan Groag Bell and Karen M. Offen (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1983). 6. Valentin Nikolayevich Volo~inov, Marxism olld the Philosophy of LoII­ gZloge (Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press, 1986), p.
    [Show full text]