Happy Chanukah! Ppha Achay Ch Ap Kanu H H Nuka !H
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
November 30-December 6, 2018 Published by the Jewish Federation of Greater Binghamton Volume XLVII, Number 48 BINGHAMTON, NEW YORK HappyHaHapppppyCy ChanukahCChhanuknukakah!h! Page 2 - The Reporter November 30-December 6, 2018 Opinion Point/counterpoint Why liberal Jewish women are Women’s March is the wrong demanding more from Women’s target in the fight against March antisemitism By Guila Franklin Siegel of the sinister, untrustworthy, greedy, re- By Daniel Sieradski of conscience purport to care about. (JTA) – On the heels of actress and ac- pulsive Jew. Peddlers of this evil all need (JTA) – The same Jewish liberals who So when, inspired by a president who tivist Alyssa Milano’s remarkable statement to be fought with the same conviction and gave in to efforts by the Jewish right to openly blames prominent liberal Jews for indicating that she plans to boycott the vigor, regardless of where they are on the divide the black and Jewish communities that which white nationalists refer to as upcoming 2019 Women’s March because of political spectrum and how their messages in the ‘70s are back again to divide Jews “white genocide,” a neo-Nazi walks into its leaders’ persistent antisemitic behavior, are packaged. from their would-be allies, and this time a shul and kills a bunch of liberal Jews, there has been a backlash in our own Jewish For decades, and for very ethical, laud- they’re dead set on being the breach in the you’d think that our energy would stay fo- feminist ranks. Jewish women are being able reasons, many Jewish activists have dam that lets the Nazis through. cused on the existential threat in the White urged not to abandon the national Women’s condemned Farrakhan while taking care Not three weeks after the worst massacre House – something actually leading to Jews March, lest we empower white suprema- to keep the lines of dialogue and commu- of Jews by a white supremacist in American being killed. cists, who are more dangerous to Jews and nication open with his supporters. Efforts history, Jewish liberals and conservatives Instead, the dishonorable Minister Louis to women, and are only too delighted to sow to share mutual narratives, collaborate on alike have found a target for their wrath, and Farrakhan says something abhorrent, and divisiveness among social justice activists. a huge range of public policy initiatives it’s none other than Palestinian-American suddenly all of the energy and anger after In effect, the argument goes, to raise a fuss and nurture deep interfaith bonds have all activist Linda Sarsour. Pittsburgh has been shifted away from the about antisemitism among Women’s March strengthened connections between Jews Here’s why I’m fuming: Any day now president and onto Farrakhan and the left leaders or other progressive activists is to and other minority groups in our local the president of the United States can sign that supposedly embraces him. be a tool of the far right. communities, and benefitted society as an executive order, as he has threatened to Farrakhan, as is well known, is not a It is condescending to presume that a whole. do, that will strip citizenship from those leftist, but a right-wing conservative reli- Jews who call out people like Linda Yet, despite all of these noble efforts, a who were born in America to parents that gious fundamentalist who once said, “I like Sarsour and Tamika Mallory are be- gulf remains. Farrakhan and his loopy yet were here illegally. Forgive me if I take this what I see” in Donald Trump after Trump ing manipulated and duped. We know heinous conspiracy theories are becoming personally, as the son of a septuagenarian told the Republican Jewish Coalition that antisemitism when we see it. In fact, more normalized within some minority mother who was born to two Holocaust they won’t support him because they “can’t Sarsour recently hit a new low by in- communities, and many progressive Jews survivors who sneaked into the country by buy” him. (As is usually the case, Trump voking on Twitter the pernicious “dual have begun to feel unwelcome in the very overstaying their tourist visas. was wrong on both counts.) loyalty” canard that has been the basis movements that their forebears helped to While this possibility simmers in the Farrakhan is also a virtual nobody with of persecution of Jews for centuries by create and grow. background, undocumented and document- virtually no power in the broader American accusing progressive Jews of caring more With a nearly 60 percent increase in ed immigrants are being rounded up, thrown context, who has no hope of ever being in about Israel than they do about preserving antisemitic incidents nationwide over the in cages, having their kids taken from them public office let alone president of the Unit- American values and ideals. last two years even prior to the horror at and sent halfway across the country, and are ed States. He will never have the sway or Like almost every other issue these days, the Tree of Life synagogue, American Jews then deported without their children. These influence the president has to inspire acts of the fight against antisemitism is becoming no longer have the luxury of looking the kids, who when they are are lucky enough antisemitic violence. And while Farrakhan increasingly politicized, pitting right against other way or tolerating moral equivoca- to be reunited with their parents, suffer from may boast tens of thousands of supporters, left in a meaningless debate about the iden- tion. At the interfaith solidarity service for severe emotional and psychological trauma Trump has tens of millions. Unlike President tity of the worst antisemites in our midst. the greater Washington, DC, community from which they may never recover. Trump and his white supremacist base, But there is no “antisemitism Olympics,” following Pittsburgh, District of Colum- In light of this and the administration’s Farrakhan is not an existential threat to where we crown David Duke and Richard bia Mayor Muriel Bowser declared that attacks on the rights of transgender men Jewish people. Spencer’s team with the gold medal as the America had failed its Jewish population and women, women’s right to choose, Of course, Linda Sarsour has denounced far more dangerous, authentic antisemites, that awful weekend. the rights of workers to organize in their Farrakhan’s rhetoric and the Women’s while Louis Farrakhan and the Nation of “It is not the job of the Jewish commu- workplaces and the right of black people to March has repeatedly issued statements Islam come in a distant second and have nity to solve antisemitism,” she said. Nor, vote, it becomes clear that everything this saying that they find his views reprehensible to settle for the silver. All antisemitism I would add, are we obliged to passively administration stands for will result in the and incompatible with their movement. emanates from the same age-old tropes See “Liberal” on page 6 destruction of all that we as Jewish people See “Target” on page 14 In My Own Words Miscellaneous updates RABBI RACHEL ESSERMAN, EXECUTIVE EDITOR So much has been going on politically in our country come true, but, even with the little music I can hear, I find my foot starts to hurt. It’s actually kind of funny – well, that I haven’t had a chance to write about anything personal myself humming and singing like I haven’t done since my funny in a painful kind of way. I’ll be happy when every- for several weeks. Below are some thoughts that might be hearing loss almost two decades ago. Music so lifts my thing gets back to normal. Of course, at my age, normal of interest. spirits that any music at all feels like a blessing. is no longer what is was. Syracuse ear surgeon and audiologist If it’s not one thing... Biting off more than I can.... At the end of October, I had my yearly check-up for This section could have also been called “the joys of If it’s the end of November, then it’s time for me to my cochlear implant. The surgeon gave me a clean bill getting older.” Sometimes it seems like there is always a pick out the books I’ll be reading for the Temple Concord of health and the audiologist made only one very minor new problem to deal with. For example, the doctor recently Sisterhood book review. You’ll have to wait for the first change. My hearing is still not perfect. However, while I diagnosed the pain in my right foot as a bunion complicated article for the big reveal of those works. However, after do get aggravated about the things I can’t hear, I’m more by arthritis. The bunion was not a surprise: I have one on sending in the information to the Sisterhood PR person, amazed at what I can hear. Although it can be tempting to my left foot and have worn orthotics and special shoes for I’m starting to wonder if I’ve bitten off more than I can take the changes for granted, I frequently remind myself the past few years because the pain in the big toe on my chew. To give you a hint, two of the three books are literary how lucky I am to have the CI. left foot was so bad I thought I might no longer be able to novels, which are more 500 pages each. The third book is Being able to hear music is one very important way go for walks (the only exercise I can do because of a back a young adult novel, a first for the Sisterhood review; that that the CI has improved my life.