American Crystallographic Association ACA 2007 Transactions Symposium Diffuse Scattering
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
American Crystallographic Association Number 4 Winter 2006 ACA 2007 Transactions Symposium Diffuse Scattering APEX II ULTRA Mo Turbo X-ray Source with APEX II Detector Our highly innovative, compact Turbo X-ray Source mounts on the 3-axis goniometer in the standard, compact D8 safety enclosure to provide an ultra-bright, stable, easy-to-align X-ray beam. The Turbo X-ray Source, coupled with the HELIOS Mo optics provides up to 60 times more intense data from small crystals compared to sealed tube systems, outperforming any other Mo-system on the market. From the tiniest crystals to charge density studies, when you need performance, the APEX II ULTRA is the instrument of choice. Intensity comparison of data collected on a 0.04 x 0.04 x 0.02 mm crystal of Cimetidine BRUKER ADVANCED X-RAY SOLUTIONS North America: BRUKER AXS INC Tel. (+1) (608) 276-3000 Fax (+1) (608) 276-3006 www.bruker-axs.com [email protected] Netherlands: BRUKER AXS BV Tel. (+31) (15) 215-2400 Fax (+31) (15) 215-2500 www.bruker-axs.nl [email protected] Germany: BRUKER AXS GMBH Tel. (+49) (721) 595-2888 Fax (+49) (721) 595-4587 www.bruker-axs.de [email protected] American Crystallographic Association www.AmerCrystalAssn.org 2007 ACA Transactions Symposium on Diffuse Scattering See What's on The Cover - page 64. Table of Contents 2 President’s Column 3-4 Calls for ACA Nominations / News of Crystallographers 5 IUCr Publishing Award / Rutherford Medal 6-7 Jim Jorgensen (1948-2006) / Martha Ludwig (1931-2006) 8-10 News from Canada 10 Web-Watch Column 12 US National Committee for Crystallography 13 From the Editor's Desk / Anti-Science- Intelligent Design 14 Energy and the Environment 15 Update - Bridging the Sciences 15-16 Fair and Useful Copyright 17 Fall Meeting of the AIP Governing Board 18-20 2006 ACA Election Results 22-23 News from Latin America / Argentine Crystallographic Society Meeting 24-25 2006 ACA Small Molecule Course 25-26 2006 ACA Macrmolecular Course 28-29 64th Pittsburgh Diffraction Conference 30 Workshop on Remote Data Collection 31 Update - RCSB PDB 32-33 Contributors to ACA Award Funds 36 ACA 2006 Honolulu / Workshop on Neutron Crystallography 38-39 ACA 2006 Honolulu/ Workshop on imgCIF 40-54 ACA 2006 Honolulu / Travel Award Winners 55-58 ACA 2006 Honolulu / Corporate Members 59 Book Review - J. D. Bermal: A Life in Science and Politics 60-62 ACA 2007 Salt Lake City - Preview 63-64 Future Meetings 64 What's on the Cover Contributors to this Issue Contributions toACA RefleXions may be sent to either of the Editors: Please address matters pertaining to advertisements, membership inquiries, or use of the ACA mailing list to: Connie Chidester ...................................... Judith L. Flippen-Anderson 2115 Glenwood Dr. ............................................. 3521 Launcelot Way Marcia J. Colquhoun, Director of Administrative Services Kalamazoo, MI 49008 ...................................... Annandale, VA 22003 American Crystallographic Association c/o Hauptman-Woodward Medical Research Institute tel. 269-342-1600 ..................................................tel. 703-346-2441 700 Ellicott Street, Buffalo, NY 14203 fax 716-898-8695 ...................................................fax 716-898-8695 phone: 716-898-8690, ext. 321; fax: 716-898-8695 [email protected] ..................... [email protected] email: [email protected] Deadlines for contributions are: February 1 (Spring), May 1 (Summer), August 1 (Fall) and November 1 (Winter) ACA RefleXions (ISSN 1958-9945) Number 4, 2006. Published four times per year in the spring, summer, fall and winter for the membership of the American Crystallographic Association, P.O. Box 96, Ellicott Station, Buffalo, NY 14205-0096. Membership in the ACA includes a non-deductible charge of $1.75 from membership dues to be applied to a subscription to the ACA Newsletter. Periodicals postage paid at Buffalo, New York. POSTMASTER: Send address changes to ACA, P.O.Box 96, Ellicott Station, Buffalo, NY, 14203. President's Column Winter 2006 The Future of Education in Crystallography solving of a crystal structure without fully appreciating the For quite some time now I have scientific principles behind what one is doing. This is true in been concerned about the both small-molecule and macromolecular crystallography, and I future of university courses in suspect that it is also true for other related fields such as powder crystallography, especially from diffraction. the point of view of a “small- However, it is eduction in the fundamentals of crystallography molecule” crystallographer that I’m worried about. I’m sure that I am by no means the first (I am going to limit my to express concern about this issue; Dick Marsh and many others comments exclusively to have worried about this increasing reliance on a “black box” graduate-level education). approach to solving a structure. There is no easy solution to For the past two or three this problem. The IUCr and other institutions (including many decades it has become synchrotron and neutron diffraction facilities as well as Cold increasingly evident that Spring Harbor) help out immensely by having summer schools and upon the retirement of "hands on"workshops. The ACA has been trying to address this structural chemists like issue with summer courses covering small molecules (organized myself, with research programs by Bryan Craven and Charles Lake) and macromolecules having their main thrust linked (originally organized by B. C. Wang and his group and currently to crystallographic structural being run by Andy Howard) and with workshop such as the one analysis, chemistry departments in on “Crystallographic Educational Policies for the Physical and universities across the country are not replacing those positions Life Sciences” organized by Katherine Kantardjieff and the ACA with junior tenure-track appointments in the same area. I find this Continuing Education Committee for the Orlando meeting in 2005. very ironic given that yet another Nobel Prize has been awarded At this point I am simply tossing this topic up for discussion, (Roger Kornberg, Chemistry, 2006) for which crystallographic and perhaps we could get our readers’ reaction in the form of results provided the critical underpinning to his overall research. “letters-to-the-editor” in future issues of RefleXions. One has only to look at the rapid growth in depositions to all Bob Bau the structural databases to know that this situation is not unique. Yet, we are producing new generations of scientists who rely on crystallographic equipment and techniques, but have little knowledge of the underlying theory, technology or its limitations. Who will push the state-of-the-art? Who will teach crystallography courses in the future? I used to offer a graduate-level course once every two years, but as the use of single-crystal analysis has become more widespread in the past 10 years or so, I’ve been asked to offer this course on an annual basis. However, as I said earlier, what happens when people like me retire? Many universities now offer x-ray courses taught by professional crystallography staff members, most of whom do a really fine and excellent job. This will of course significantly help “plug the gap”, but this practice is by no means universal. In the macromolecular crystallographic community, with a user base of investigators that is continuing to expand, the situation is just as mixed, ranging all the way from universities that offer crystallography courses on a regular basis, to institutions in which graduate students who use crystallography as a tool simply “pick up” a working knowledge of the technique informally from more A C A senior members of their research groups (typically postdocs), with the research director offering guidance and suggestions when difficult structures appear. In addition, many websites now offer “self-help” internet-based instructions on how to solve a protein structure. ACA Council: Rear - Louis Delbaere, N. Rao, Lee Groat, One reason for the present state of affairs, of course, is the Middle: Doug Ohlendorf, Marcia Colquhoun, Bill Duax, undeniable fact that as computers become more and more powerful, and as programs become more and more sophisticated, Front: Alan Pinkerton, Lisa Keefe, Bob Bau it is becoming easier to take a “black box” approach to the 2 Calls for Nominations / News of Crystallographers Winter 2006 2007 Art in Crystallography Prize 2007 ACA Margaret C. Etter Early Career Award to Cora Lind ACA RefleXions Editors are accepting entries to the 2007 Art in Crystallography contest in the form of images emailed to either Cora Lind (U of Toledo) received editor ([email protected] or [email protected]. her PhD in 2001 from Georgia edu). Entries should be accompanied by a paragraph explaining Tech where her thesis described the science and the method of producing the image. A photo of her synthetic studies of the artist would be appreciated but is not required. Prizes consist negative thermal expansion of a small monetary award and a banquet ticket at the annual materials using novel sol-gel meeting. Winning entries will be posted on the web and will also methods and her extensive be displayed as printed images at the ACA Meeting. (Winners characterization of the are not, however, required to attend the meeting). We will also structural behavior of these feature images in ACA RefleXions from time to time. Judging compounds vs. temperature will be by a panel appointed by the Editors; please let us know and pressure. As a post- if you are interested in being a judge. doc at Cornell her research focused on the synthesis of complex nitrides and platinum Nominations for 2008 ACA Awards complexes for use in fuel cells. She joined the U of Toledo faculty The Elizabeth A. Wood Science Writing Award, established as an assistant professor in 2003. Her in 1997, is given periodically to authors of books or articles that research program, already thriving and bring science to the attention of a general audience.