DOCSLIB.ORG

UC San Diego UC San Diego Electronic Theses and Dissertations

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
UC San Diego UC San Diego Electronic Theses and Dissertations UC San Diego UC San Diego Electronic Theses and Dissertations Title Frontiers and borders : sources of transcendent credibility and the boundaries between political units Permalink https://escholarship.org/uc/item/84b1t6kz Author Williamson, Rosco Publication Date 2007 Peer reviewed|Thesis/dissertation eScholarship.org Powered by the California Digital Library University of California i UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, SAN DIEGO Frontiers and Borders: Sources of Transcendent Credibility and the Boundaries between Political Units A Dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree Doctor of Philosophy in Political Science by Rosco Williamson Committee in charge: Professor David Mares, Chair Professor Alan Houston Professor Richard Madsen Professor Victor Magagna Professor Michael Monteon 2007 ii Copyright Rosco Williamson, 2007 All rights reserved iii The dissertation of Rosco Williamson is approved, and it is acceptable in quality and form for publication on microfilm: _____________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________ Chair University of California, San Diego 2007 iii iv TABLE OF CONTENTS Signature Page...............................................................................................................iii Table of Contents..........................................................................................................iv List of Tables.................................................................................................................vi Vita. ..............................................................................................................................vii Abstract........................................................................................................................viii Chapter 1: Theory..........................................................................................................1 Why Is This Question Worth Asking?................................................................3 Dependent Variable: Boundary Distinctiveness..............................................14 Proposed Explanation.......................................................................................18 Changes in the Number of Sources of Transcendent Credibility.....................27 Chapter 2: Methodology..............................................................................................51 Operationalization.............................................................................................52 Methodology.....................................................................................................64 Implications of the Hypothesis.........................................................................67 Plan of the Dissertation.....................................................................................69 Chapter 3: China: The Sui and T’ang Dynasties.........................................................73 Unification of China under the Sui and T’ang Dynasties (589-700)................75 China and Tibet (620-800)................................................................................99 Chapter 4: Fifteenth and Sixteenth Century Central Asian Islamic Empires.............122 Fifteenth Century Central Asia.......................................................................124 Sixteenth Century Central Asia.......................................................................142 Chapter 5: Medieval Europe, 400-1000.....................................................................167 iv v Christendom....................................................................................................170 The Carolingian Empire and the Saxons.........................................................182 The Vikings.....................................................................................................203 Chapter 6: The Protestant Reformation, 1517-1565..................................................223 Ideology: A Priesthood of All Believers........................................................224 The Establishment of Lutheranism.................................................................238 The Establishment of Calvinism.....................................................................254 The Catholic Reaction.....................................................................................264 Changing Distinctiveness of Boundaries........................................................269 Chapter 7: The Thirty Years’ War: From God to Proto-Nationalism.......................279 The Significance of the Addition of the Nation..............................................281 The Ideological Development of the Change..................................................302 Richelieu as Innovator of Proto-Nationalism..................................................311 Distinctive Boundaries: The Peace of Westphalia 1648................................323 Chapter 8: The “Westphalian” States System............................................................331 Ideological Foundations of Nationalism.........................................................334 Impact on the Political Boundaries of Europe................................................374 Chapter 9: Implications..............................................................................................384 References...................................................................................................................417 v vi LIST OF TABLES Table 1...........................................................................................................................46 vi vii VITA 1992 Bachelor of Arts, Northwest Nazarene College (Chemistry, History) 1998 Master of Arts, San Diego State University (History) 2000-2003 Teaching Assistant, Department of Political Science University of California, San Diego 2002 Master of Arts, University of California, San Diego (Political Science) 2003-2006 Adjunct Professor of History and Political Science Point Loma Nazarene University 2006-present Assistant Professor of Political Science Point Loma Nazarene University 2007 Doctor of Philosophy, University of California, San Diego (Political Science) FIELDS OF STUDY Major Field: Political Science (International Relations and Political Theory) vii viii ABSTRACT OF THE DISSERTATION Frontiers and Borders: Sources of Transcendent Credibility and the Boundaries between Political Units by Rosco Williamson Doctor of Philosophy in Political Science University of California, San Diego, 2007 Professor David Mares, Chair Rather than starting with physical form as “state”-centered theories do, a more useful theoretical model should begin with the content of political units. Specifically, this model should examine a crucial element of the content of a political unit, the “source of transcendent credibility,” and analyze the effects this has on the physical form of political units in a given system. Hence, this dissertation hypothesizes that the boundaries between political units in a given system will be relatively more distinctive as the number of sources of viii ix transcendent credibility within that system increases. A source of transcendent credibility is an unseen (transcendent) force that a critical mass of the population in a territory believes to be acting on behalf of and in favor of the “faithful.” To more efficiently and effectively generate compliance from the people, a ruler will link his own credibility to this inherently credible source. Competing sources of transcendent credibility within a system increase the perceived threat to the ruler’s source of efficient compliance generation. The cost-effectiveness of this means of generating compliance creates large incentives for the investment of resources to protect the source’s efficacy. One potential threat arises from the fact that an international rival can improve its’ bargaining power vis-à-vis a ruler by undermining the ruler’s source of transcendent credibility, provided the two rivals rely on different sources of transcendent credibility. Second-tier variables, geopolitics and military capabilities, can exacerbate the perceived threat from an international rival that depends on a different source of transcendent credibility. The dissertation tests this hypothesis using case studies that vary in both time and space: the unification of northern and southern China under the Sui and T’ang, the eighth century rivalry between China and Tibet, the rise of the Shiite Safavid Empire alongside the Sunni Ottoman Empire in the sixteenth century, and the European continent from the medieval period to the present. The extended European case examines the dynamic of changing numbers of sources of transcendent credibility in a system and responses to these changes. The conclusion discusses the implications for the future global system and the discipline of Political Science. ix 1 CHAPTER 1: THEORY: THE NUMBER OF SOURCES OF TRANSCENDENT CREDIBILITY AND THE DISTINCTIVENESS OF BOUNDARIES A. Introduction B. Why Is This Question Worth Asking? 1. The International Question 2. The Political Unit Formation Question C. Dependent Variable: Boundary Distinctiveness D. Proposed Explanation 1. Explanatory
Load more

Recommended publications
  • LECTURE 5 the Origins of Feudalism
    OUTLINE — LECTURE 5 The Origins of Feudalism A Brief Sketch of Political History from Clovis (d. 511) to Henry IV (d. 1106) 632 death of Mohammed The map above shows to the growth of the califate to roughly 750. The map above shows Europe and the East Roman Empire from 533 to roughly 600. – 2 – The map above shows the growth of Frankish power from 481 to 814. 486 – 511 Clovis, son of Merovich, king of the Franks 629 – 639 Dagobert, last effective Merovingian king of the Franks 680 – 714 Pepin of Heristal, mayor of the palace 714 – 741 Charles Martel, mayor (732(3), battle of Tours/Poitiers) 714 – 751 - 768 Pepin the Short, mayor then king 768 – 814 Charlemagne, king (emperor, 800 – 814) 814 – 840 Louis the Pious (emperor) – 3 – The map shows the Carolingian empire, the Byzantine empire, and the Califate in 814. – 4 – The map shows the breakup of the Carolingian empire from 843–888. West Middle East 840–77 Charles the Bald 840–55 Lothair, emp. 840–76 Louis the German 855–69 Lothair II – 5 – The map shows the routes of various Germanic invaders from 150 to 1066. Our focus here is on those in dark orange, whom Shepherd calls ‘Northmen: Danes and Normans’, popularly ‘Vikings’. – 6 – The map shows Europe and the Byzantine empire about the year 1000. France Germany 898–922 Charles the Simple 919–36 Henry the Fowler 936–62–73 Otto the Great, kg. emp. 973–83 Otto II 987–96 Hugh Capet 983–1002 Otto III 1002–1024 Henry II 996–1031 Robert II the Pious 1024–39 Conrad II 1031–1060 Henry I 1039–56 Henry III 1060–1108 Philip I 1056–1106 Henry IV – 7 – The map shows Europe and the Mediterranean lands in roughly the year 1097.
    [Show full text]
  • And Justice for All: an Alternative Decision to Williams V. Nassau County Medical Center to Ameliorate the Harsh Impact of New Y
    Minnesota Journal of Law, Science & Technology Volume 12 Issue 1 Article 4 2011 And Justice for All: An Alternative Decision to Williams v. Nassau County Medical Center to Ameliorate the Harsh Impact of New York's Late Notice of Claim Statute on Infant Medical Malpractice Plaintiffs David A. Mayer Christopher McGrath Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarship.law.umn.edu/mjlst Recommended Citation David A. Mayer & Christopher McGrath, And Justice for All: An Alternative Decision to Williams v. Nassau County Medical Center to Ameliorate the Harsh Impact of New York's Late Notice of Claim Statute on Infant Medical Malpractice Plaintiffs, 12 MINN. J.L. SCI. & TECH. 23 (2011). Available at: https://scholarship.law.umn.edu/mjlst/vol12/iss1/4 The Minnesota Journal of Law, Science & Technology is published by the University of Minnesota Libraries Publishing. 121_MayerMAYER DA,.DOCX McGrath (DO NOT D C.ELETE And) Justice for All: An Alternative Decision4/4/2011 to 8:07 AM Williams v. Nassau County Medical Center to Ameliorate the Harsh Impact of New York’s Late Notice of Claim Statute on Infant Medical Malpractice Plaintiffs. Minnesota Journal of Law, Science & Technology. 2011;12(1):23-60. And Justice for All: An Alternative Decision to Williams v. Nassau County Medical Center to Ameliorate the Harsh Impact of New York’s Late Notice of Claim Statute on Infant Medical Malpractice Plaintiffs David A. Mayer* & Christopher McGrath** Strict construction of New York State’s late notice of claim statute1 has unintentionally thwarted the lofty goals of equal access to justice and equal protection under the law through de facto economic segregation of infant medical malpractice plain- tiffs.
    [Show full text]
  • Rapport Annuel D'activité
    rapport annueL d’activité ÉTABLISSEMENT PUBLIC DU CHÂTEAU, DU MUSÉE ET DU DOMAINE NATIONAL DE VERSAILLES rapport annueL d’activité ÉTABLISSEMENT PUBLIC DU CHÂTEAU, DU MUSÉE ET DU DOMAINE NATIONAL DE VERSAILLES 2019 Préface Comment pourrions-nous nous conten- des « Arbres admirables » dessiné grâce au mécénat ter de regarder en arrière et nous remé- de Rémy Martin illustre symboliquement l’impor- morer l’année 2019 quand nous savons tance pour le château de Versailles de son patri- tout de l’année 2020, dominée par la moine végétal. La création d’une ferme de perma- COVID-19 qui, pendant de longues culture à l’emplacement des étangs Gobert, avec le semaines, a changé notre vie à tous ? La soutien de la Fondation Nature et Découvertes, rédaction du rapport d’activité est, témoigne de la volonté de l’Établissement public de pour les équipes de l’Établissement développer un écosystème durable. L’intérêt gran- public, un exercice fastidieux, exigeant, dissant qu’il suscite auprès des visiteurs – et des qui donne la fierté du devoir accompli, mécènes – témoigne de la pertinence de ce choix, qui pousse à parfaire les projets imparfaits ou ina- pour le château de Versailles, inscrit dans la moder- chevés, qui galvanise l’énergie pour « faire mieux » nité à toutes les étapes de son histoire. Comme pour l’année suivante. Ce devait être en 2020. être fidèle aux préceptes de Louis XIV, le rapport Et puis le dimanche 15 mars au soir, les grilles du entre les « dedans » et les « dehors » s’équilibre de château de Versailles se sont refermées pour une plus en plus pour le public, faisant de cet ensemble durée inconnue.
    [Show full text]
  • WBHR 2015 2.Pdf
    i i i i Department of Historical Sciences Department of History Faculty of Philosophy and Arts Faculty of Humanities University of West Bohemia in Pilsen University of Hamburg Tylova 18 Von-Melle-Park 6 301 25 Pilsen D-20146 Hamburg Czech Republic Federal Republic of Germany i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i West Bohemian Historical Review V j 2015 j 2 Department of Historical Sciences Department of History Faculty of Philosophy and Arts Faculty of Humanities University of West Bohemia in Pilsen University of Hamburg Tylova 18 Von-Melle-Park 6 301 25 Pilsen D-20146 Hamburg Czech Republic Federal Republic of Germany i i i i i i i i Editors-in-Chief: Lukáš NOVOTNÝ / Plzeˇn/ Pilsen Gabriele CLEMENS / Hamburg Redaction: Roman KODET The journal is abstracted in The Central European Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities (CEJSH). Since October 2015 the journal has been included in the prestigious European database of scientific jour- nals ERIH PLUS (European Reference Index for the Humanities and the Social Sciences). Journal’s title abbreviation: WBHR Online at http://www.ff.zcu.cz/khv/en/about/research/vbhr.html ISSN 1804-5480 MK CREˇ 19550 i i i i i i i i Editorial board Stanislav Balík / Faculty of Law, University of West Bohemia, Pilsen, Czech Republic Gabriele Clemens / Faculty of Social Sciences, University Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany Anselm Doering-Manteuffel / Faculty of Humanities, University of Tübingen, Tübingen, Germany Ewald Frie / Faculty of Humanities, University of Tübingen, Tübin- gen, Germany Radek Fukala / Faculty of Philosophy, J.
    [Show full text]
  • Rolling Service Door Systems
    ROLLING SERVICE DOOR SYSTEMS NON-INSULATED DOORS 600/610/620 PRODUCT LINE INSULATED DOORS MODELS 625/627 INDUSTRY LEADING COMMERCIAL & INDUSTRIAL SOLUTIONS ROLLING SERVICE DOOR SYSTEMS STEEL & ALUMINUM DOORS General features and benefits A comprehensive line of Rolling Service Doors • Face-of-wall mounting is standard with between- • Galvanized steel, stainless steel and aluminum jambs mounting available on most models doors in a variety of gauges, slat profiles, finishes • Push-up, chain-hoist, crank or motor operation available and options • Electric motor option with an array of remote • Standard door widths up to 30'4" (9246 mm) and controls, as well as other accessories, simplifies door 28'4" (8636 mm) in height, and custom door sizes operation up to 1500 sq. ft. (139,355 sq.mm)∆ • Ventilated slats with perforations or fenestrations Solid, reliable construction for the long term extend applications to open-air environments • Guide designed to ensure smooth curtain operation (Model 610 only) • Steel brackets provide additional strength • High-usage package, sloped bottom bars and • Helical torsion springs designed for 20,000 cycles, pedestrian pass doors with high usage up to 100,000 cycles • Insulated slats (Models 625 and 627) and perimeter • Wind load options to meet specifications seal protection options (weather baffle, lintel seal, A host of standard features and available options guide weather seals, bottom astragal) offer additional protection against air infiltration • Curved or flat slats in a range of sizes and profiles,
    [Show full text]
  • Introduction
    Introduction The Other Voice [Monsieur de Voysenon] told [the soldiers] that in the past he had known me to be a good Catholic, but that he could not say whether or not I had remained that way. At that mo- ment arrived an honorable woman who asked them what they wanted to do with me; they told her, “By God, she is a Huguenot who ought to be drowned.” Charlotte Arbaleste Duplessis-Mornay, Memoirs The judge was talking about the people who had been ar- rested and the sorts of disguises they had used. All of this terrified me. But my fear was far greater when both the priest and the judge turned to me and said, “Here is a little rascal who could easily be a Huguenot.” I was very upset to see myself addressed that way. However, I responded with as much firmness as I could, “I can assure you, sir, that I am as much a Catholic as I am a boy.” Anne Marguerite Petit Du Noyer, Memoirs The cover of this book depicting Protestantism as a woman attacked on all sides reproduces the engraving that appears on the frontispiece of the first volume of Élie Benoist’s History of the Edict of Nantes.1 This illustration serves well Benoist’s purpose in writing his massive work, which was to protest both the injustice of revoking an “irrevocable” edict and the oppressive measures accompanying it. It also says much about the Huguenot experience in general, and the experience of Huguenot women in particular. When Benoist undertook the writing of his work, the association between Protestantism and women was not new.
    [Show full text]
  • Head-Of-State and Foreign Official Immunity in the United States After Samantar: a Suggested Approach
    Fordham International Law Journal Volume 34, Issue 2 2011 Article 6 Head-of-State and Foreign Official Immunity in the United States After Samantar: A Suggested Approach Christopher D. Totten∗ ∗ Copyright c 2011 by the authors. Fordham International Law Journal is produced by The Berke- ley Electronic Press (bepress). http://ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/ilj Head-of-State and Foreign Official Immunity in the United States After Samantar: A Suggested Approach Christopher D. Totten Abstract A concept of immunity for foreign heads of state has existed since ancient times. Such immu- nity constitutes customary international law (“CIL”) and, when applicable, frees such individuals from the criminal jurisdiction of foreign nations while carrying out their duties. In the United States, executive branch guidance is considered determinative on the issue of foreign head-of-state immunity; however, the executive branch does not always provide suggestions of immunity, or it may provide suggestions that violate CIL. Drawing upon both US and against foreign sitting and former heads of state and government officials increasingly are becoming more established and ma provide additional guidance in the absence of, or as a supplement to, US executive branch guidance. For example, while relevant international immunity law norms generally prohibit crim- inal prosecutions by domestic jurisdictions against foreign sitting heads of state and other senior governmental officials, they allow such suits against former leaders and officials in certain circum- stances. Moreover, these same norms permit prosecutions against both sitting and former heads of state and officials if these prosecutions are commenced by international criminal tribunals (e.g., the ongoing International Criminal Court proceeding against President Omar Al-Bashir of Sudan).
    [Show full text]
  • DPI 610/615 Series Druck Portable Pressure Calibrators
    GE Sensing Features Setting the Standard for Portable Pressure Calibrators • Ranges -14.7 to 10,000 psi The technically advanced Druck DPI 610 and DPI 615 • Accuracy from 0.025% full scale (FS) portable calibrators are the culmination of many years of field experience with the company’s DPI 600 series. • Integral combined pressure/vacuum pump These self-contained, battery powered packages contain a pressure generator, fine pressure control, device • Dual readout: input and output energizing (not IS version) and output measurement capabilities, as well as facilities for 4 to 20 mA loop • 4 to 20 mA loop test: auto step and ramp testing and data storage. The rugged weatherproof design is styled such that the pressure pump can be • Intrinsically safe (IS) version operated and test leads connected without compromising the visibility of the large dual parameter display. The mA step and ramp outputs and a built-in • RS232 interface and fully documenting version continuity tester extend the capabilities to include the commissioning and maintenance of control loops. • Remote pressure sensors DPI 610/615 Series Druck Portable Pressure Calibrators DPI 610/615 Series is a Druck product. Druck has joined other GE high–technology sensing businesses under a new name—GE Sensing. g GE Sensing A highly accurate and easy to use calibrator is only part reduce response times to breakdowns and emergencies of the solution for improving overall data quality and by removing the need for ’Hot Permits‘ and gas detection working efficiency. The DPI 610 and DPI 615, with data equipment. This gives peace of mind to all those storage and RS232 interface, reduce calibration times responsible for safety within hazardous areas.
    [Show full text]
  • 9780521564946 Index.Pdf
    Cambridge University Press 978-0-521-56494-6 - The Carolingian World Marios Costambeys, Matthew Innes and Simon Maclean Index More information INDEX . Aachen on conversion of Avars and Saxons, and memory of Charlemagne, 5 108 Charlemagne’s burial place, 154, 197 on force and conversion, 74 palace complex and chapel, 77, 157, on imperium, 166 168, 169, 173, 174, 175, 178, 196, 197, on pope and emperor, 138 199, 201, 205, 213, 214, 217, 218, 282, on the virtues and vices, 300 293, 295, 320, 409, 411, 420, 425 relationship to Willibrord, 106 Abbo of St-Germain-des-Pres:´ on Viking Alemannia. See also Judith, Empress; attack on Paris, 277 Charles the Fat Adalhard, Charlemagne’s cousin, 193 and Carolingian conquest, 225 and Hincmar’s De ordine palatii [On the and Charles Martel, 46 Governance of the Palace], 295 and family of Empress Judith, 206 and succession of Louis the Pious, 199 and opposition to rehabilitated in 820s, 206 Carolingians, 41, 51 afterlife: ideas of, 115 and Pippin III, 52 Agnellus of Ravenna, 59 conquest under Carloman and Pippin Agobard of Lyon III, 52 controversy with Amalarius of Metz, Merovingian conquest, 35 121 under Charlemagne, 66 criticism of Matfrid’s influence, 213 Amalarius of Metz on Jewish slave traders, 367 on Mass, 121 Aistulf, Lombard king, 58, 62 annals, 22, 23 laws on merchants, 368 and Pippin’s seizure of kingship, 32 military legislation of, 279 production of, 18, 21 Alcuin Annals of Fulda, 23, 231, 387, 396, as scholar, 143 404 as teacher, 147 Annals of Lorsch, 23, 166 asks ‘what has Ingeld to do with
    [Show full text]
  • The Authors of Articles in This Number of the Harvard Theological Review
    THE AUTHORS OF ARTICLES IN THIS NUMBER OF THE HARVARD THEOLOGICAL REVIEW GEORGE HODGES, A.M., D.D., D.C.L., LL.D., Dean of the Episcopal Theological School, Cambridge. Author: The Episcopal Church; Christianity Between Sundays; The Heresy of Cain; In this Present World; Faith and Social Service; The Battles of Peace; The Path of Life; William Perm; Fountains Abbey; The Human Nature of the Saints; When the King Came; The Cross and Passion; Three Hundred Years of the Episcopal Church in America; The Administration of an Institutional Church; The Happy Family; The^ Pursuit of Happiness; The Year of Grace; Holderness; The Apprenticeship of Washington; The Garden of Eden; The Training qf Children in Religion; A Child's Guide to the Bible; Everyman's Relig- ion; Saints and Heroes; Class Book of Old Testament History; The Early Church; Henry Codman Potter, Seventh Bishop of New York; Religion in a World of War; How to Know the Bible. EPHRAIM EMERTON, Ph.D., Winn Professor of Ecclesiastical History, Emeritus, in Harvard University. Author: Introduction to the Study of the Middle Ages; Synopsis of the History of Continental Europe; Mediaeval Europe, 814-1300; Desid- erius Erasmus; Unitarian Thought; Beginnings of Modern Europe. JAMES BISSETT PRATT, A.M.,Ph.D., Professor of Philosophy in Williams College. Author: The Psychology of Religious Belief; What is Pragmatism? India and its Faith; Democracy and Peace. WILLIAM HALLOCK JOHNSON, Ph.D., D.D., Professor of Greek and New Testament Literature in Lincoln University, Chester County, Pennsylvania. Author: The Free-will Problem in Modem Thought; The Christian Faith under Modern Searchlights.
    [Show full text]
  • Harvard Theological Review the Beginnings of Modern Europe
    Harvard Theological Review http://journals.cambridge.org/HTR Additional services for Harvard Theological Review: Email alerts: Click here Subscriptions: Click here Commercial reprints: Click here Terms of use : Click here The Beginnings of Modern Europe (1250– 1458). Ephraim Emerton. Ginn & Co. 1918. Pp. xiv, 550. Maps. \$1.80. Dana C. Munro Harvard Theological Review / Volume 12 / Issue 02 / April 1919, pp 241 - 243 DOI: 10.1017/S0017816000010579, Published online: 03 November 2011 Link to this article: http://journals.cambridge.org/ abstract_S0017816000010579 How to cite this article: Dana C. Munro (1919). Review of Josiah Gilbert, and G. C. Churchill 'The Dolomite Mountains' Harvard Theological Review, 12, pp 241-243 doi:10.1017/S0017816000010579 Request Permissions : Click here Downloaded from http://journals.cambridge.org/HTR, IP address: 128.122.253.228 on 25 Apr 2015 BOOK REVIEWS 241 religious crisis as more of an intellectual than of a mystical char- acter is entirely new and wholly original, but certainly it has never been propounded in such a definite way and so well harmonized with the whole of Augustine's intellectual and spiritual career, in a vigor- ous synthesis of his life and his theology. Being a work of synthesis, there is no room for details in the book. As for the synthesis itself, like all syntheses, it has a personal element, which, however, does not at all diminish the objective value of the study. G. F. LA PIANA. HARVARD UNIVEBSITY. THE BEGINNINGS OP MODERN EUROPE (1250-1458). EPHRAIM EMERTON. Ginn & Co. 1918. Pp. xiv, 550. Maps. $1.80. The publication of this new volume by Professor Emerton is an event of great interest to a host of his students and friends.
    [Show full text]
  • Memorable Crises. Carolingian Historiography and the Making of Pippin's Reign, 750-900 F.C.W. Goosmann
    Memorable Crises. Carolingian Historiography and the Making of Pippin’s Reign, 750-900 F.C.W. Goosmann Summary This study explores the way in which Frankish history-writers retroactively dealt with the more contentious elements of the Carolingian past. Changes in the political and moral framework of Frankish society necessitated a flexible interaction with the past, lest the past would lose its function as a moral anchor to present circumstances. Historiography was the principal means with which later generations of Franks were able to reshape their perception of the past. As such, Frankish writers of annals and chronicles presented Pippin the Short (c. 714-768), the first Carolingian to become king of the Franks, not as a usurper to the Frankish throne, but as a New David and a successor to Rome’s imperial legacy. Pippin’s predecessor, the Merovingian king Childeric III (742-751), on the other hand, came to be presented as a weak king, whose poor leadership had invited the Carolingians to take over the kingdom for the general well-being of the Franks. Most of our information for the period that witnessed the decline of Merovingian power and the rise of the Carolingian dynasty derives from Carolingian historiography, for the most part composed during the reigns of Charlemagne (d. 814) and Louis the Pious (d. 840). It dominates our source base so profoundly that, to this day, historians struggle to see beyond these uncompromising Carolingian renderings of the past. In many ways, the history of the rise of the Carolingian dynasty in the eighth century can be viewed as a literary construction of ninth-century design, and the extent to which this history has been manipulated is not at all easy to discern.
    [Show full text]