PL-ISSN0015-5497(print),ISSN1734-9168(online) FoliaBiologica(Kraków),vol.62(2014),No4 Ó InstituteofSystematicsandEvolutionofAnimals,PAS,Kraków, 2014 doi:10.3409/fb62_4.321
Variation in Sperm Formation Patterns in Jumping Plant-Lice (Hemiptera: Psylloidea): a Light Microscopic Study
Eugenia S. LABINA, Anna MARYAÑSKA-NADACHOWSKA, Daniel BURCKHARDT, and Valentina G. KUZNETSOVA
Accepted October 02, 2014
LABINA E.S.,MARYAÑSKA-NADACHOWSKA A.,BURCKHARDT D.,KUZNETSOVA V.G. 2014. Variation in sperm formation patterns in jumping plant-lice (Hemiptera: Psylloidea): a light microscopic study. Folia Biologica (Kraków) 62: 321-333.
The patterns of sperm formation in sternorrhynchous jumping plant-lice are reviewed. To date information is available for 143 species belonging to 54 genera, 17 subfamilies and seven of the eight psylloid families (only Phacopteronidae is not represented). For the majority of the taxa (116 species, 39 genera, 10 subfamilies and the families Calophyidae, Carsidaridae and Liviidae) the data presented here is new and is based exclusively on studies using light microscopy. Five distinct patterns of chromatin reorganisation during metamorphosis of spermatids into spermatozoa are recognised, described and named here typesI-V.TypesIandIIIwerepreviouslyknown,typesII,IV andVaredescribedhereforthe firsttimeforjumpingplant-lice.ThemostwidespreadistypeIwhichisfoundineveryfamily representing the plesiomorphic condition of spermiogenesis in Psylloidea. Types III and V are autapomorphic for the Aphalarinae and Spondyliaspidinae, respectively. Type IV was found only in two genera of Euphyllurinae and may represent a synapomorphy. Type II occurs in several unrelated subfamilies and is interpreted as a homoplasy. The patterns of sperm formation are stable within most of the examined subfamilies and can be used, to a certain extent, to elucidate phylogenetic relationships within Psylloidea.
Key words: Psyllids, Sternorrhyncha, spermiogenesis, evolution, systematics.
Eugenia S. LABINA,ValentinaG.KUZNETSOVA, Department of Karyosystematics, Zoological Institute, Russian Academy of Sciences, Universitetskaya nab. 1, 199034 Saint Petersburg, Russia. E-mails: [email protected], [email protected] Anna MARYAÑSKA-NADACHOWSKA, Institute of Systematics and Evolution of Animals, Polish Academy of Sciences, S³awkowska 17, 31-016 Kraków, Poland. E-mail: [email protected] DanielBURCKHARDT, Naturhistorisches Museum, Augustinergasse 2, CH4001 Basel, Switzerland. E-mail: [email protected]
Psyllids or jumping plant-lice (Sternorrhyncha: supported with the exception of their Aphalaridae, Psylloidea) are a relatively small group of hemip- Psyllidae, and Spondyliaspididae which were teraninsectswithabout3800describedandatleast shown to be polyphyletic (BURCKHARDT 1987a, b, as many undescribed species worldwide (BURCK- 1991,2005).BasedontheseresultsBURCKHARDT HARDT et al. 2014; D. BURCKHARDT, unpublished and OUVRARD (2012) published a revised classifi- data). WHITE and HODKINSON (1985), in their cation also comprising eight families of which five seminal paper on the systematics of psyllids based aresimilartothoseofWhiteandHodkinson(Calo- mostly on morphological characters of immatures, phyidae, Carsidaridae, Homotomidae, Phacop- introduced a classification with eight families teronidae, and Triozidae) but three are completely (Aphalaridae, Calophyidae, Carsidaridae, Homo- redefined (Aphalaridae, Liviidae, and Psyllidae). tomidae, Phacopteronidae, Psyllidae, Spondylias- Several attempts have been undertaken to study pididae and Triozidae). This classification was the systematics of Psylloidea using new characters, tested in the last three decades by several authors such as the number of seminal follicles (e.g. KLI- who investigated many taxa using morphological MASZEWSKI 1972; KLIMASZEWSKI et al. 1974; adult and immature as well as molecular characters. G£OWACKA et al. 1995; MARYAÑSKA-NADA- White and Hodkinson’s families were generally CHOWSKA et al. 2001a, b, c; KUZNETSOVA et al. 322 E.S. LABINA et al.
2012) and karyotypes (e.g. MARYAÑSKA-NADA- Material and Methods CHOWSKA 2002; LABINA et al. 2007). These char- acters were shown to be of some use in solving For nearly three decades, we have prepared hun- taxonomic problems at the suprageneric level. dreds of cytological preparations to study karyo- types and male meiosis of psyllids represented by Variation in sperm formation patterns within a wide taxonomic range (e.g. MARYAÑSKA-NADA- Psylloidea was investigated in a number of publi- CHOWSKA 2002; LABINA et al. 2007; KUZNETSOVA et al. 2012; NOKKALA et al. 2013). For this purpose, cations (LE MENN 1966a, b; KUZNETSOVA et al. adult males were fixed in Carnoy fixative (96% 1997; TIAN et al. 2007). LE MENN (1966a, b) was ethanol and glacial acetic acid, 3:1) and refriger- the first to observe the remarkable, so-called o ated at 5 C in the laboratory until slides were made. “binuclear” male germ cells by electron micros- Seminal follicles were extracted from adult speci- copyineightspeciesofHomotomidae(Homotoma mens and squashed on the slide. The preparations ficus), Psyllidae (Arytaina genistae, Cacopsylla were frozen using dry ice, the coverslips were re- visci, Chamaepsylla hartigii, Psylla alni, P. buxi) moved with a razor blade, and the preparations and Triozidae (Bactericera femoralis, Trioza urticae) were dehydrated in fresh Carnoy fixative for 20 min corresponding to “Type I” as defined below. and air dried. Then they were subjected either to Later, KUZNETSOVA et al. (1997) discovered by Schiff-Giemsa staining (GROZEVA &NOKKALA 1996) light microscopy a different, also unusual type of or to silver staining (HOWELL &BLACK 1980) or sperm formation in ten species of the genera to C-banding (SUMNER 1972), as the case required. Aphalara, Craspedolepta and Crastina (Aphalari- In our present study, the same cytological prepa- dae, Aphalarinae) corresponding to “Type III” as rations were used to study a post-meiotic phase of defined below. More recently, binuclear sperms spermatogenesis, i.e. spermiogenesis. By light mi- were reported for Acizzia jamatonica (Psyllidae) croscopy, we followed the progressive differentia- and Bharatiana septentrionalis (Calophyidae) tion of the spermatid components and changes in (TIAN et al. 2007) but the attribution to a particular chromatin organization during metamorphosis of sperm formation type is problematic. spermatids into spermatozoa in males of 125 spe- cies belonging to 51 genera and 16 subfamilies of In this paper we confirm the presence of the two the families Aphalaridae, Calophyidae, Carsidari- previously described types of sperm formation and dae, Homotomidae, Liviidae, Psyllidae, and add another three discovered by light microscopy Triozidae. Observation and literature data are in a wide taxonomical range of Psylloidea. Fur- summarised in Table 1. We follow the classifica- thermore, we plot the known types of sperm for- tion by BURCKHARDT and OUVRARD (2012). mationpatternsonacladogramreflectingthelatest Voucher preparations are deposited at the Depart- classification of Psylloidea by BURCKHARDT and ment of Experimental Zoology, Institute of Syste- OUVRARD (2012) and discuss the phylogenetic matics and Evolution of Animals PAS in Kraków, implications. Poland.
Table 1 Species studied and types of spermiogenesis Type of Taxon spermio- Collecting data Indentification Reference genesis by Aphalaridae Aphalarinae binuclear ? ? LE MENN 1966a,b sperm Aphalara calthae (Linnaeus, 1761) III Finland: near Turku – Caltha S. Nokkala KUZNETSOVA et al. palustre 1997 KUZNETSOVA et al. Aphalara exilis (Weber et Mohr, 1804) III Poland: Gorce Mts – Rumex sp. E. G³owacka 1997 Poland: west Beskidy Mts – Aphalara maculipennis Löw, 1886 III Polygonum sp. E. G³owacka present paper 1 Georgia: Kolkhida, Paliastomi KUZNETSOVA et al. Aphalara polygoni Foerster, 1848 III Lake – Polygonum sp. A. Gegechkori 1997 Craspedolepta bulgarica Klimaszewski, Georgia: David Garedzhi – KUZNETSOVA et al. 1961 III Achillea sp. A. Gegechkori 1997 Types of Spermiogenesis in Psylloidea 323
Table 1 cont. Russia: Primorsky Krai, Khasan- Craspedolepta flava (Kuwayama, 1908) III sky District, near Kedrovaya Pad’ E. Labina present paper Reserve – Artemisia spp. Poland: Kazimierz Dolny – Craspedolepta flavipennis (Foerster, 1848) III Chrysanthemum sp. E. G³owacka present paper Russia: Primorsky Krai, Khasan- Craspedolepta kerzhneri Loginova, III sky District, near Kedrovaya E. Labina present paper 1963 Pad’ Reserve – Artemisia spp. Russia: Primorsky Krai, Khasan- Craspedolepta latior Wagner, 1944 III sky District, near Kedrovaya E. Labina present paper Pad’ Reserve – Artemisia spp. Russia: Primorsky Krai, Craspedolepta lineolata Loginova, 1962 III Vladivostok – Artemisia sp. E. Labina present paper Craspedolepta malachitica (Dahlbom, Poland: Mielnik – Artemisia KUZNETSOVA et al. 1851) III absinthium E. G³owacka 1997 Craspedolepta nebulosa (Zetterstedt, Poland: Gorce Mts – Chamerion KUZNETSOVA et al. 1828) III angustifolium E. G³owacka 1997 KUZNETSOVA et al. Craspedolepta nervosa (Foerster, 1848) III Poland: Gorce Mts – Achillea sp. E. G³owacka 1997 KUZNETSOVA et al. Craspedolepta omissa Wagner, 1944 III Poland: Gorce Mts – Artemisia sp. E. G³owacka 1997 MARYAÑSKA-NA Craspedolepta sonchi (Foerster, 1848) III Finland – Leontodon autumnalis S. Nokkala DACHOWSKA et al. 2001c Craspedolepta subpunctata (Foerster, Poland: Gorce Mts – Chamerion KUZNETSOVA et al. 1848) III angustifolium E. G³owacka 1997 Russia: Primorsky Krai, Khasan- Craspedolepta terminata Loginova, sky District, near Kedrovaya 1962 III Pad’ Reserve; Khasansky District, E. Labina present paper Krabovy Peninsula – Artemisia spp. Russia: Primorsky Krai, Khasan- sky District, near Kedrovaya Craspedolepta topicalis Loginova, 1962 III Pad’ Reserve; Ussuriysky District, E. Labina present paper Kraunovka – Artemisia spp. Russia: Altai Republic, Craspedolepta villosa Loginova, 1962 III Chemalsky District, Edigan E. Labina present paper Village – Artemisia sp. Georgia: Caucasus Mts, III Hersureti, – Myricaria bracteata A. Gegechkori KUZNETSOVA et Crastina myricariae Loginova, 1964 Russia: Altai Republic, al. 1997 III Chemalsky District, Edigan E. Labina present paper Village – Tamarix sp. Pachypsyllinae USA: Maryland, Beltsville – Pachypsylla sp. I Celtis tenuifolia M.-M. Yang present paper Rhinocolinae present paper II Spain: Mallorca, Boquet Valley – Pistacia lentiscus I.D. Hodkinson Agonoscena cisti (Puton, 1882) Spain: Cádiz prov., Sierra E. Labina present paper II Blanquilla – under olive trees Spain: Mallorca, Boquet Valley – present paper Pistacia lentiscus I.D. Hodkinson Agonoscena targionii (Lichtenstein, II 1874) Spain: Cádiz prov., Sierra E. Labina present paper Blanquilla – under olive trees Listronia varicicosta (Hodkinson et Hollis, Spain: Mallorca, Formentor – 1981) II Cistus albidus I.D. Hodkinson present paper II Poland: Kraków – Acer E. G³owacka present paper platanoides Rhinocola aceris (Linnaeus, 1758) II Georgia: near Tbilisi – A. A. Gegechkori present paper platanoides II Finland: Turku – A. platanoides S. Nokkala present paper Spondyliaspidinae Australia: Adelaide, Urrbrae, Anoeconeossa sp. (communis group) V Wait Campus – Eucalyptus G.S. Taylor present paper leucoxylon Australia: Adelaide, Urrbrae, Anoeconeossa sp. (fuscipennis group) V Wait Campus – Eucalyptus G.S. Taylor present paper leucoxylon Australia: Adelaide, Urrbrae, Anoeconeossa unicornuta Taylor, 1987 V Wait Campus – Eucalyptus G.S. Taylor present paper leucoxylon 324 E.S. LABINA et al.
Table 1 cont. Australia: Strathalbyn-Goolwa – Australopsylla sp. V Eucalyptus sp. G.S. Taylor present paper Australia: Adelaide, Urrbrae, Blastopsylla adnatariae Taylor, 1985 V Wait Campus – Eucalyptus G.S. Taylor present paper lehmannii Australia: Goolwa – Melaleuca Blastopsylla moorei Taylor, 1985 V lanceolata G.S. Taylor present paper Australia: Queensland, Brisbane, Boreioglycaspis melaleucae Moore, V Indooroopilly, CSIRO – G.S. Taylor present paper 1964 Melaleuca quinquenervia Australia: Goolwa – Eucalytus Cardiaspina albitextura Taylor, 1962 V camaldulensis G.S. Taylor present paper Australia: Ambleside, near Hahndorf Cardiaspina retator Taylor, 1962 V – Eucalytus camaldulensis G.S. Taylor present paper Australia: Urrbrae, Wait Campus Creiis sp. V – Eucalyptus leucoxylon G.S. Taylor present paper Australia: Urrbrae, Wait Campus Cryptoneossa triangula Taylor, 1990) V – Angophora floribunda G.S. Taylor present paper E. Labina present paper V Ethiopia: Eucalyptus sp. Ctenarytaina eucalypti (Maskell, 1890) Portugal: Madeira – Eucalyptus E. Labina present paper V sp. Australia: Ambleside, near Glycaspis brimblecombei Moore, 1964 V Hahndorf –Eucalytus camaldulensis G.S. Taylor present paper Hyalinaspis sp. V Australia G.S. Taylor present paper Australia: Ambleside, near Platyobria lewisi Taylor, 1987 V Hahndorf – Eucalytus camaldulensis G.S. Taylor present paper Australia: Adelaide, Urrbrae, Spondyliaspis plicatuloides (Froggatt, V Wait Campus – Eucalyptus G.S. Taylor present paper 1900) microcarpa Calophyidae Calophyinae Calophya nigripennis Riley, 1885 I USA: Maryland M.-M. Yang present paper I USA: California, Alameda Co., P.G. da Silva as present paper Berkeley, UC Campus – Schinus C. rubra Calophya schini Tuthill, 1959 Molle I South Africa: near Cape Town E. G³owacka present paper Mastigimatinae Bharatiana septentrionalis Yang &