Academy Schools and Their Introduction to English Education

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Academy Schools and Their Introduction to English Education Comments Welcome The Effects of Moving to More Autonomous School Structures: Academy Schools and Their Introduction to English Education Stephen Machin* and James Vernoit** October 2010 * Department of Economics, University College London and Centre for Economic Performance, London School of Economics ** Centre for Economic Performance, London School of Economics Abstract In this paper, we study a high profile case of where changing school structures resulted in schools having more autonomy and flexible governance, namely the introduction of academy schools to the English secondary school sector. We consider the impact of academy status on pupil intake, pupil performance and on pupil performance in neighbouring schools using a difference-in-difference approach comparing how these outcomes altered in academy schools compared to their (non-academy) predecessor school relative to changes in a set of matched comparison schools. Our results suggest that moving to the more autonomous academy school structure may well have yielded performance improvements, that the quality of intake went up and there is some limited evidence of positive spillovers to neighbouring schools. It seems that becoming an academy takes a while to yield such benefits. Meanwhile, in the controversial policy discussion about academies, our results (at least so far) do seem to place a relatively positive slant on the programme introduced by the Labour government of 1997-2010. JEL Keywords: Academies; Pupil Intake; Pupil Performance. JEL Classifications: I20; I21; I28. 0 1. Introduction Around the world, there is serious interest in what types of educational institutions deliver better outcomes to pupils. Nowhere is the debate more vociferous than for the case of schools. Policy focus in many countries has been placed on whether innovative schooling strategies can offset the problems that have been connected to low student achievement in state/public schools. Examples include learning lessons from the private sector (see Chakrabarti and Peterson, 2008), giving more autonomy to schools (Clark, 2009), different forms of school accountability (Hanushek and Raymond, 2004) and more flexible (and extended) teaching times and curriculum innovation (e.g. Abdulkadiroglu et al, 2009). A growing economics of education literature has presented empirical estimates of the impact of school type on pupil achievement. A quite sizable recent body of US work on charter schools (publically funded schools that have autonomy levels more like private schools) does find some evidence of achievement gains.1 In England, different school types seem important in enabling choice and competition to raise pupil performance.2 Almost everywhere in the developed world, increased parental demand for school choice and the high housing valuations induced by what parents view as better schools for their children (Black and Machin, 2010) all point to a heightened focus on what kind of schools deliver better outcomes to children. Some nations have been more innovative than others in their departure from the orthodox model of the local or community school. The charter school movement in the US has 1 This literature is not without controversy. Recent, typically small scale, quasi-experimental evaluations of charters in particular US cities (Boston and New York) does report positive impacts on educational achievement (see Abdulkadiroglu et al, 2009, Dobbie and Fryer, 2009, and Hoxby and Murarka, 2009). Wider coverage non-experimental evaluations produce more mixed results (CREDO, 2009). 2 See, for example, Gibbons, Machin and Silva (2008) find that in English community schools there is little scope for choice/competition to enhance performance, whilst such a possibility exists in faith schools where more autonomy in decision making is present. 1 spread across many states. In Sweden, a new type of private school has started operating in most of the country (self-titled ‘free schools’) that compete for students with public schools on an equal financial basis. These free-schools are privately managed, but receive full public funding which is calculated on the basis of the number of students that they enrol who live in their local area. In England, various different types of school have enjoyed popularity, but none more so than the case of academy schools that we study in this paper. Academy schools, and their gradual introduction into the English Educational system, have generated a controversial area of schools policy ever since the first clutch of academies opened in September 2002. Academies are independent, non-selective, state- funded schools that fall outside the control of local authorities, managed by a private team of independent co-sponsors. The sponsors then delegate the management of the school to a largely self-appointed board of governors.3 Each governing body of the academy has the responsibility to employ all academy staff, agree levels of pay, agree on conditions of service with its employees, and decide on the policies for staffing structure, career development, discipline, and performance management. It is hypothesised that the combination of independence to pursue innovative school policies and curricula, with the experience of the sponsor, will enable the Academy to drive up the educational attainment of their pupils throughout the school. The aim of this paper is to carefully appraise this hypothesis. It is important to find out whether or not the increased autonomy of academies does, in fact, result in superior academic performance for children who attend them. This matters both from an economic perspective which argues that more autonomy and flexible governance sharpens economic incentives, and from a public policy standpoint. On either side of the latter debate on 3 An academy usually has around thirteen governors, with seven typically appointed by the sponsor. 2 academies you will find, on one side, fierce supporters who passionately believe that academies will drive up educational performance, and on the other side, you will find fierce critics of Academy schools who claim the Academies do not work, and that they are just a way of (implicitly) privatising the state-education system in England. The rest of the paper is devoted to this task. In the next section of the paper, we discuss the nature of secondary schooling in England, and document the rise of academies. Section 3 describes the data and modelling strategy we adopt, and uses this discussion to formulate key hypotheses to be tested in the empirical work. Section 4 presents the results, whilst Section 5 concludes. 2. The Introduction of Academy Schools to English Education Academies are a new type of secondary school, first introduced into the English education system in the early 2000s. In this section, we consider this introduction, discussing how it relates to the different school types in the English secondary school system and documenting the scale of the rise of academy schools. School Types in England The English education system has always been characterised by a strong voluntary movement which has actively been involved in the delivery of education. These voluntary organisations are typically religious, and prior to the 19th century, were the sole providers in the delivery of education in England. Since this time, the state sector has gradually taken up a more active involvement in providing the resources to the education system by first helping to fund these early schools, and then actively creating new schools that have no affiliation with the voluntary sector (now called community schools). However, the 3 commitment of the voluntary movement to education has never waned, and even today, a significant percentage of the schools in the English education system are provided on the basis of a partnership between the voluntary sector and the state sector. Today, these schools are named either as a voluntary aided school, voluntary controlled school or a foundation school. In addition to the voluntary sector, there is also private sector involvement in England’s education system. However, this has typically taken the form of private funded independent schools which run alongside state funded schools. During much of this time, there was little private sector involvement in the state funded schools (Machin and Wilson, 2008). However, since the 1988 Education Act, the UK government has actively encouraged schools, which are public-private ventures as a medium for delivering education (for more details, see Machin and Wilson, 2008). The passing of this act led to the creation of a new type of school, which enabled the private sector to work in partnership with the state sector within the same school. These new types of school were called city technology colleges (CTC). In more recent years, the academy school programme has been introduced and, in some important dimensions, can be thought of as a continuation of the CTC scheme. Together, these different school types make up the English secondary education system. Table 1 shows a typology of English secondary schools, listing the different type of school available in the sector and the key features in terms of school autonomy and governance. The Table orders the school types by the amount of autonomy that their governing body/management body has in making schooling decisions, and how dependent they are on the state sector. At the top of the list are registered independent schools which 4 are able to charge fees. They also have a management body which determines the staffing
Recommended publications
  • School Prospectus
    ST JUDE’S CATHOLIC PRIMARY SCHOOL We live, love and learn together joyfully, in Jesus' name. SCHOOL PROSPECTUS Headteacher: Malcolm Tipping BA (QTS) Hons. ST JUDE’S CLOSE MAYPOLE BIRMINGHAM B14 5PD TEL: 0121 464 5069 WEBSITE: www.stjuderc.bham.sch.uk WELCOME On behalf of the staff, governors and children of St Jude's Catholic Primary School I welcome you to St Jude’s. I am immensely proud to have been appointed as the new Headteacher of St Jude's. The staff, children, governors and parents have been very welcoming and have shown what a wonderful community our school is rooted in. I strongly believe in the partnership between home, school and parish and that, together, we can work successfully for the ongoing development of your child. Our School Mission is centred in our Catholic foundation, which can be seen in every aspect of the life of our school, relationships within it, and the curriculum it provides. We warmly welcome children of other faiths and believe that we can learn a great deal from each other about justice, tolerance and respect. Our RE Inspection Report (September 2011) states that, “The catholic life of St Jude’s is outstanding. Provision for the spiritual and moral development of the children and the extent to which the curriculum for RE meets the children’s needs are excellent.” and, “Teaching is highly effective in enthusing pupils and ensuring they make the best possible progress.” As a school, we want to do the very best that we can for your child, academically, spiritually and socially, and therefore ask you to support us in our work and the decisions we make for the benefit of our school community.
    [Show full text]
  • Secondary Education in Wirral 2016-2017 Information for Parents
    Useful websites and phone numbers ACE (Advisory Centre for Education) Phone: 0808 800 5793 www.ace-ed.org.uk Ofsted www.ofsted.gov.uk Wirral SEND Partnership www.wired.me.uk Wirral Website www.wirral.gov.uk Admissions Portal www.wirral.gov.uk/schooladmissions Secondary Education in Wirral 2016-2017 Information for parents Children and Young People’s Department Hamilton Building, Conway Street, Birkenhead, Wirral, Merseyside CH41 4FD s n Phone: 0151 606 2020 Fax: 0151 666 4207 Email: [email protected] w o si o is n m e d la n o i o Wirral Council’s Children and Young People’s Department can not be held responsible for misleading, out of date or incorrect information held on cached l h pages accessed through or maintained by individual search engines, online forums or internet third party sites. n sc o k/ u The information in this booklet relates to the school year 2015 to 2016. However, there may be changes before the beginning of that year or during that year. ly v. go p l. p ra A ir w 365Jun14SK . w w w Contents September 2015 Dear Parent I hope that you will find this booklet helpful. It provides information about secondary education in Wirral and in particular about the arrangements for transferring to secondary school. It is available to all parents whose children are in their last year of Types of school 4 Transport policy 10 primary education and to all parents who tell us that they are moving into the borough with children of secondary school age.
    [Show full text]
  • Section 52 Outturn Statement 2010
    Department for Education DATA COLLECTION (OUTTURN) LA Name Wiltshire LA No. 865 Year 2010-11 Contact Helen Miles Email [email protected] TABLE B Tel No. 01225 713677 School Opening Income Opening Pupil Expenditure School Name Community Delegated SEN Funding generated by Community Focussed Community Community (does not include Community Focussed Funds (Including (including some Standards Fund schools Pupil focussed Total resources focussed school Capital Sorting Revenue Other focussed focussed community Committed Uncommitted Focussed DfE Reference Extended Planned Budget pupil focussed Standards residue (not (excluding extended school available to expenditure Expenditure from column for Balance [OB01] Government extended school extended school focussed Revenue Revenue Extended School Number School Revenue Share SSG and LSC Fund) [I03] and included in (7)) community funding and/or school (sum of (does not include Revenue - LAs own (2009-10 B01 & Grants [I06] funding and/or facilities income expenditure, Balance [B01] Balance [B02] Revenue Balance [OB02] funding) [I01, Minority Ethnic [I05] focussed grants [I15] 3 + 4 + (6 to 13)) income) [E31 & CERA [E30] use B02 carried grants [I16] [I17] CERA or Balance [B06] (2009-10 B06 I02 & I14] Pupils [I04] income) [I07 to E32] forward) income) [E01 to carried forward) I13] E29] NNNN £ £ £ £ £ £ £ £ £ £ £ £ £ £ £ £ £ £ (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14) (15) (16) (17) (18) (19) (20) NURSERY SCHOOLS 0 Total Nursery Schools (21) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
    [Show full text]
  • Primary School (Key Stage 2)
    Primary school (key stage 2) Performance tables 2015 Cornwall 908 Introduction The performance tables give information on the achievements of pupils in local primary schools, and how they compare with other schools in the local authority (LA) area and in England as a whole. This booklet presents a selection of key performance measures, but a wider range of information is available at www.education.gov.uk/schools/performance 1 About the tables in this booklet General You should also look at more than one ■ and below the average percentage of pupils The national curriculum key stage 2 test results for performance measure to get an idea of how at the end of KS2 made expected progress in state funded schools in England are provided in latest results for diferent schools compare. For reading (2015 national median=94%) these tables along with teacher assessment data. example, while igures for the percentage of ■ and below the average percentage of pupils For each LA, schools are listed alphabetically, with pupils achieving level 4+ in reading, writing and at the end of KS2 made expected progress in special schools shown in a separate section at the maths gives an indication of pupils’ achievements writing (2015 national median =97%) end of each list. Schools that do not take pupils at the end of KS2, it doesn’t tell you how far they ■ and below the average percentage of pupils up to the age of 11 (e.g. infant schools) are not have progressed from their starting point. at the end of KS2 made expected progress in included.
    [Show full text]
  • Academies, Autonomy, Equality and Democratic Accountability: Reforming the Fragmented Publicly Funded School System in England’
    West, A. and Wolfe, D. (2019) ‘Academies, autonomy, equality and democratic accountability: Reforming the fragmented publicly funded school system in England’. London Review of Education, 17 (1): 70–86. DOI https://doi.org/10.18546/LRE.17.1.06 Academies, autonomy, equality and democratic accountability: Reforming the fragmented publicly funded school system in England Anne West* − London School of Economics and Political Science, UK David Wolfe − Matrix Chambers, UK Abstract This article focuses on the transformative academies policy in England. Based on an analysis of documentary evidence, we argue that the policy has resulted in the fragmentation of the state-funded school system and stark variation between academies, with those within multi-academy trusts (MATs) having no legal identity. We examine the variation between funding agreements, the control by central government, the role of MATs and the governance of academies. We propose policy options to improve the current incoherent and fragmented set of provisions, including restoring the legal identity of schools in MATs and allowing academies if they so wish, to convert to maintained schools. Keywords: academies; multi-academy trusts (MATs); funding agreements; law; governance; finance Introduction Since 2000 there has been a rapid and radical transformation of publicly funded school- based education in England: over a third of schools – and nearly three-quarters of secondary schools – are now ‘academies’ rather than ‘maintained’ by local authorities. Academies are owned and run by not-for-profit private trusts (exempt charities) that register as companies with Companies House and are subject to company law. They are controlled and funded directly by central government by means of a contract – a funding agreement – between a trust (that is, a legal entity) and the Secretary of State for Education (DfE, 2018a), rather than being run by a governing body in accordance with statutory education law, as is essentially the case for maintained schools.
    [Show full text]
  • The Composite Prospectus for Parents and Carers 2019 to 2020
    The composite prospectus for parents and carers 2019 to 2020 Checklist 6 Allerton Bywater Primary School 26 Carlton Primary School 40 Admissions policies 7 Allerton Church of England Primary Carr Manor Community School 41 School 26 Choosing a school for up in Leeds. Across all of our knowledgeable and informed The Admissions policy for Leeds Carr Manor Primary School 41 Community and Voluntary Alwoodley Primary School 27 your child is a really schools and services we have about the process. Controlled schools for entry in Castleton Primary School 42 important decision. a shared ambition – to be the September 2017 8-13 Armley Primary School 27 Chapel Allerton Primary School 42 We understand this and in best city to grow up in: a child Leeds is a diverse, dynamic How to apply for a Reception place for Ashfield Primary School 28 Leeds we are committed to friendly city. This means working and incredible place to learn. September 2017 14 Christ Church Upper Armley Church of Asquith Primary School 28 working with parents and carers in partnership with you to Every day thousands of children Important dates 14 England Primary School 43 to help and support you. This understand and meet the unique and young people are inspired Austhorpe Primary School 29 How do I apply for a place? 15 Christ the King Catholic Primary School booklet has been designed to needs of your child and realise to be their best and shape our Bankside Primary School 29 A Voluntary Academy 43 do that. It provides information their personal potential. city’s future.
    [Show full text]
  • Secondary Education Admissions 2021/2022 (PDF)
    Knowsley Secondary Education Admissions 2021–2022 Apply online www.knowsley.gov.uk THE INFORMATION CONTAINED IN THIS BOOKLET IS IMPORTANT IF YOU NEED ANY FURTHER INFORMATION ABOUT THE ADMISSIONS PROCESS AND HOW TO APPLY FOR A SECONDARY SCHOOL PLACE PLEASE CONTACT: Knowsley School Admissions Education Improvement Team, Knowsley Council, PO Box 21, Municipal Buildings, Archway Road, Huyton, Knowsley, L36 9YU Telephone: (0151) 443 5142/3372 Email: [email protected] Each secondary school can provide you with more information about their school if you have further questions. Contact details for Knowsley Secondary Schools can be found in this booklet along with details open days/ evenings when you can visit the schools you are interested in and are encouraged to attend. Please note: Where the term ‘schools’ has been used in this booklet, this also applies to Academies. Privacy Notice Knowsley Council will use the information provided on your school admission application and any other supporting information you provide will be used for the following purposes. • To ensure the effcient co-ordination and fair allocation of school places. • To ensure your child has access to school associated entitlements • To ensure information is accurate. • To prevent or detect crime. • To protect public funds. • To meet our key aims and legal duties. We use the information to complete our duties under the Department for Education’s ‘School Admissions Code’ (2014) and ‘School Admissions Appeal Code’ (2012). There may be a requirement to share information with schools, other council service areas, local health trusts, other local authorities and central government. This will only be when necessary and where the law allows it to support the applications process.
    [Show full text]
  • Faith Schools in England: Faqs
    BRIEFING PAPER Number 06972, 20 December 2019 Faith Schools in England: By Robert Long and Shadi Danechi FAQs Inside: 1. Introduction: what is a faith school? 2. Frequently Asked Questions 3. Statistics www.parliament.uk/commons-library | intranet.parliament.uk/commons-library | [email protected] | @commonslibrary Number 06972, 20 December 2019 2 Contents Summary 3 1. Introduction: what is a faith school? 4 2. Frequently Asked Questions 5 2.1 Can faith schools use faith-based criteria in their admissions policies? 5 New academies and free schools: the 50% limit and abandoned proposals to repeal 6 2.2 What can faith schools teach in Religious Education? 6 Local authority maintained secondary schools 6 Academies and Free Schools 7 2.3 Can faith schools use faith as a criteria when hiring staff? 7 2.4 Do particular rules apply in the inspection of faith schools? 9 2.5 Can schools become faith schools when converting to academy status? 10 2.6 Can faith schools teach creationism? 10 2.7 Do children attending faith schools have particular rights relating to school transport? 10 2.8 How can new faith schools be opened? 13 2.9 Do faith schools have to teach Relationships and Sex Education? 14 2.10 What do faith schools have to teach about same sex marriage? 14 3. Statistics 17 3.1 Number of faith schools 17 Region and local authority 17 Pupils 18 3.2 Secondary school performance 19 Cover page image copyright: Haddington Infant School Classroom by David Gilmour. Licensed under CC BY 2.0 / image cropped.
    [Show full text]
  • School Performance in Academy Chains and Local Authorities – 2017
    This publication includes analysis of the National Pupil Database (NPD): https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/national-pupil-database The Department for Education is responsible for the collation and management of the NPD and is the Data Controller of NPD data. Any inferences or conclusions derived from the NPD in this publication are the responsibility of the Education Policy Institute and not the Department for Education. ISBN: 978-1-909274-54-9 Published June 2018 Education Policy Institute. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License. For more information, visit: creativecommons.org 2 About the author Jon Andrews is Director for School System and Performance and Deputy Head of Research at the Education Policy Institute. As well as publishing a number of reports on the expansion of the academies programme he has co-authored reports on free schools, grammar and faith schools, school funding, the disadvantage gap, and world class standards. Prior to joining EPI, Jon worked in the Department for Education from 2003 to 2016, most recently heading the Department’s Revenue Funding Analysis Unit. About the Education Policy Institute The Education Policy Institute is an independent, impartial, and evidence-based research institute that promotes high quality education outcomes, regardless of social background. We achieve this through data-led analysis, innovative research and high-profile events. Education can have a transformative effect on the life chances of young people, enabling them to fulfil their potential, have successful careers, and grasp opportunities. As well as having a positive impact on the individual, good quality education and child wellbeing also promotes economic productivity and a cohesive society.
    [Show full text]
  • Final Template for Catholic Schools
    PLYMOUTH CAST SCHEME OF DELEGATION Plus Guidance for Local Governing Bodies JUNE 2016 Contents: Preamble: Governance in Plymouth CAST Please read this first! Page 3 Part One: Scheme of Delegation Introduction 4 Ethos and mission 6 Directors’ powers and responsibilities 7 Constitution of the Local Governing Body 9 Members of the Local Governing Body 10 Delegated powers 16 Ethos and Values 19 Finance 20 Premises 23 Curriculum and Standards 25 Admissions and Appeals 26 Intervention and removal of delegated responsibility 28 Annual review 29 APPENDIX 1 - Functioning of the Local Governing Body 30 Chairman and Vice-Chairman of the Local Governing Body 30 Conflicts of Interest 31 The Minutes; Committees; Delegation 32 Meetings of the Local Governing Body 33 Clerk; Notices; Indemnity 36 APPENDIX 2: Protocol for intervention in vulnerable schools 39 APPENDIX 3: Academies to which the Scheme of Delegation applies 43 Part Two: Additional Guidance for Governors APPENDIX 4: School Governance Document 45 APPENDIX 5: Notes to accompany School Governance Document 46 Note 1: Categories of Governor 46 Note 2: Process for selecting Parent Governors 47 Note 3: Process for selecting Staff Governors 48 Note 4: Calculating the required numbers of governors by category 49 Note 5: Governor Record Sheet 50 APPENDIX 6: Additional Notes Note 6: Governors Code of Conduct 50 Note 7: Safeguarding checks 50 Note 8: Written declaration by Governors to Bishop and Board 51 APPENDIX 7: Local Governor ‘Written Undertaking’ 52 APPENDIX 8: Latest Government guidance on Regulated Activities 53 APPENDIX 9: Flowchart for Foundation Governor Appointments APPENDIX 10: Information for Prospective Foundation Governors APPENDIX 11: Expression of Interest Form for Foundation Governors APPENDIX 12: Foundation Governor Declaration for Bishop 2 Preamble: Governance in Plymouth CAST Important Note: Please Read This First Welcome to this guidance document for school governors.
    [Show full text]
  • Faith in the System
    Faith in the system The role of schools with a religious character in English education and society Introduction The Government and the providers of publicly funded schools with a religious character have come together to set out in this document our shared understanding of the contribution these schools (popularly known as faith schools) make to school-based education and to the wider school system and society in England1. We are taking the opportunity to highlight the very positive contribution which schools with a religious character make as valuable, engaged partners in the school system and in their local communities and beyond. At the same time, we want to dispel some of the common myths and misunderstandings around faith schools and to build a basis for greater understanding and dialogue within society. The Government and faith school providers believe that all schools – whether they have a religious character or not – play a key role in providing a safe and harmonious environment for all in our society, thereby fostering understanding, integration and cohesion. We set out here our shared commitment to this endeavour and the principles that continue to underlie our joint vision and understanding of the contribution faith communities and their schools make to educating young people in England, to nurturing young people in their faith and to promoting community cohesion. The faith school providers who sponsor schools with a religious character often also have a particular role in helping to meet the needs of those people in their faith communities who would otherwise be hard to reach, thus enabling them to integrate into society.
    [Show full text]
  • Context Data for Primary Schools in the Maldon District (Cont'd)
    APPENDIX 1 Context data for primary schools in the Maldon District (Cont’d) Number on Roll DfE* School Ward Type of School** Capacity*** (as at May Ref. 2015)**** 2030 Heybridge Primary School Heybridge East Academy Sponsor Led 367 224 2095 Southminster Church of England Primary School Southminster Academy Sponsor Led 315 188 2106 St Cedd's Church of England Primary School, Bradwell Tillingham Academy Sponsor Led 195 169 2230 Maldon Primary School Maldon East Community School 405 341 2310 Burnham-on-Crouch Primary School Burnham-on-Crouch South Community School 417 355 2590 Cold Norton Primary School Purleigh Community School 147 153 2620 Purleigh Community Primary School Purleigh Academy Converter 205 210 2630 Tollesbury School Tollesbury Community School 210 197 2649 Wentworth Primary School Maldon West Community School 420 410 2994 Maylandsea Primary School Althorne Academy Converter 315 268 All Saints Church of England (Voluntary Controlled) Primary 3201 Maldon North Voluntary Controlled School 323 317 School, Maldon Latchingdon Church of England (Voluntary Controlled) 3230 Althorne Academy Converter 175 91 Primary School St Nicholas Church of England (Voluntary Controlled) Primary 3232 Tillingham Voluntary Controlled School 133 117 School, Tillingham Woodham Walter Church of England (Voluntary Controlled) 3235 Wickham Bishops and Woodham Voluntary Controlled School 105 104 Primary School St Mary's Church of England (Voluntary Aided) Primary 3450 Burnham-on-Crouch North Voluntary Aided School 210 190 School, Burnham-on-Crouch Tolleshunt
    [Show full text]