DOCSLIB.ORG

II. PALAMAS on BEING II.1. Being, Essence and Energies

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
II. PALAMAS on BEING II.1. Being, Essence and Energies Durham E-Theses THE CONCEPT OF `BEING' IN AQUINAS AND PALAMAS UNTEA, CRISTIAN How to cite: UNTEA, CRISTIAN (2010) THE CONCEPT OF `BEING' IN AQUINAS AND PALAMAS, Durham theses, Durham University. Available at Durham E-Theses Online: http://etheses.dur.ac.uk/848/ Use policy The full-text may be used and/or reproduced, and given to third parties in any format or medium, without prior permission or charge, for personal research or study, educational, or not-for-prot purposes provided that: • a full bibliographic reference is made to the original source • a link is made to the metadata record in Durham E-Theses • the full-text is not changed in any way The full-text must not be sold in any format or medium without the formal permission of the copyright holders. Please consult the full Durham E-Theses policy for further details. Academic Support Oce, Durham University, University Oce, Old Elvet, Durham DH1 3HP e-mail: [email protected] Tel: +44 0191 334 6107 http://etheses.dur.ac.uk THE CONCEPT OF ‘BEING’ IN AQUINAS AND PALAMAS CRISTIAN COSTIN UNTEA MA by Research Durham University Department of Theology and Religion 2010 CRISTIAN COSTIN UNTEA THE CONCEPT OF ‘BEING’ IN AQUINAS AND PALAMAS Abstract The aim of the present dissertation is a comparative analysis of the issue of being as found in the writings of St. Gregory Palamas and St. Thomas Aquinas. Primarily, I set two main focuses for my research: firstly, an overview of the life and work of the great Byzantine theologian and, secondly, a comparative analysis with St. Thomas Aquinas on the issue of being. Although the present dissertation deals with both theological and philosophical issues, my research remains mainly a theological one. I am not interested in a merely theoretical evaluation of the history of being, but rather in how this notion is applied in the dynamics of the relation between God and man. I structured my thesis around the evaluation of the concept of being in its applicability on God, on man, and on the way in which the two are linked. Therefore, I developed my analysis on each of the two authors, discussing in separate sections on: the divine being, the created being, the issue of grace and the views on deification. Before commencing the examination of the proposed issue, I found relevant to include an introduction dealing with the historical matters concerning each of the two theologians and their ‘dialogue’ within Eastern and Western theological framework. A final section concluded this study tracing the reception of their thought within the twentieth century Theology. This dissertation is the product of my own work, and the work of others has been properly acknowledged throughout. The copyright of this thesis rests with the author. No quotation from it should be published without the prior written consent and information derived from it should be acknowledged. CONTENTS INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................3 1. Gregory Palamas and his Writings............................................................................5 2. Thomas Aquinas and his Writings ..........................................................................10 3. Gregory Palamas – from East to West ....................................................................14 4. Thomas Aquinas – From West to East....................................................................18 I. AQUINAS ON BEING ...............................................................................................24 I.1. Being, Essence and Existence...............................................................................24 I.2. The Divine Being..................................................................................................30 I.2.1. The Simplicity of God ...................................................................................30 I.2.2. Essence and Persons ......................................................................................34 I.2.2.1. Relation and Opposition.............................................................................36 I.2.2.2. What is a Person.........................................................................................38 I.2.2.3. Persons and Relations ................................................................................41 I.3. The Created Being ................................................................................................45 I.3.1. The Essential Structure of the Created ..........................................................45 I.3.1.1. The Trinitarian Model of Creation.............................................................48 I.3.1.2. Essence in Composite Substances...............................................................49 I.3.1.3. Essence in Non-Composite Substances ......................................................51 I.3.2. Deiformity and Deformity .............................................................................53 I.3.2.1. The Likeness of Creation............................................................................54 I.3.2.2. The Likeness of Man...................................................................................56 I.3.2.3. Image, Likeness, and the Fall.....................................................................59 1 I.4. The Meaning of Divine Grace ..............................................................................61 I.5. The Limits of Knowledge and Participation.........................................................66 I.5.1. Negative Theology and the Vision of the Divine Essence ............................68 I.5.2. The Light of Glory and the Eternity of Being ...............................................71 II. PALAMAS ON BEING.............................................................................................74 II.1. Being, Essence and Energies...............................................................................74 II.2. The Divine Being ................................................................................................81 II.2.1. Essence .........................................................................................................81 II.2.2. Hypostasis ....................................................................................................86 II.3. The Created Being...............................................................................................92 II.3.1. Creation and the Image of God ....................................................................92 II.3.2. The Fall.........................................................................................................96 II.3.3. The Unity of the Human Being ....................................................................98 II.4. The Uncreated Energies ....................................................................................101 II. 5. The Vision of the Divine Light and the Union with God.................................106 CONCLUSIONS...........................................................................................................110 SELECTED BIBLIOGRAPHY....................................................................................115 2 INTRODUCTION My thesis proceeds from a primary interest on a detailed analysis of Gregory Palamas’ doctrine: its origins in previous patristic writings and its effects on the Orthodox theological tradition. There are two main points of my research: firstly, an overview of the life and work of the great Byzantine theologian and, secondly, a comparative analysis with Thomas Aquinas on the issue of being. The purpose of my research is to find divergent and convergent points in the two Christian traditions, in the way these were considered in the fourteenth century Byzantine theological scene and the circumstances in which the two theologians later became representative for East and West. History has preserved a somewhat antagonistic image of the two authors whose doctrines I am proposing to analyse in more depth. The Palamite and Thomist doctrines are considered by most modern critiques as irreconcilable in certain points. They are the expression of an extremely divergent development in the Eastern and Western Christian tradition. In the Orthodox world, the twentieth century represented a significant re-evaluation of the works and thought of Gregory Palamas (from Dumitru Stăniloae’s first translation in a modern language and monograph in the early 30’s, to Panayotis Christou’s editions in Greek and the multitude of studies published in the West). Nonetheless, a considerable part of his writings still remains un-translated into modern languages. The evaluations on this theme still allow for substantial research effort, which can be developed beyond the simple analysis of the monastic treaties and hesychast spirituality, to a deeper systematic evaluation. The problem of being can be considered a sensible interference point between church doctrine and Greek philosophy and also between Eastern and Western theological traditions. I shall be attempting to provide a detailed analysis of the theological and patristic resources on this matter, and also of its philosophical background, considering that the distinctions disputed in fourteenth century Byzantium presupposed a metaphysical and 3 linguistic background which was interpreted differently by the two traditions. From the Eastern point of view, the assimilation of Aristotle’s philosophy by Thomist theology looked
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Orthodox Church of Th E Mother of G Od
    We would like to welcome all parish visitors and invite you to join us after the Liturgy for Coffee hour. Sunday, January8, 2017 Tone 4 Gospel: Matthew 4:12-17 (Sunday after Theophany) Epistle: Ephesians 4:7-13 29th Sunday After Pentecost Afterfeast of the Theophany. Sunday after Theophany. Ven. George the Chozebite, Abbot (6th c.). Ven. Domnica of Constantinople (474). St. Emilian the Confessor, Bishop of Cyzicus (9th c.). Ven. Gregory, Wonderworker of the Kiev Caves (Near Caves—1093). Ven. Gregory the Recluse, of the Kiev Caves (Far Caves—13th-14th c.). Hieromartyr Isidore and 72 others at Yuriev (Estonia—1472). St. Paisius of Uglich (1504). Hieromartyr Carterius of Cæsarea in Cappadocia (304). Martyrs Theophilus the Deacon, and Helladius, in Libya (4th c.). Martyrs Julian and his wife, Basilissa, and with them Marcionilla, her son Celsus, Anthony, Anastasius, 7 children and 20 soldiers, at Antinoë in Egypt (313). Ven. Elias the Hermit, of Egypt (4th c.). Martyr Abo the Perfumer, of Tiflis (Georgia—790). i Troparion – Tone 4 Of old, the river Jordan / turned back before Elisha’s Vlash mantle at Elijah’s ascension. / The waters were parted in two / and the waterway became a dry path. / This is truly a symbol of baptism / by which we pass New Jersey through this mortal life. / Christ has appeared in the Deacon - - Jordan to sanctify the waters! Sub Kontakion – Tone 4 Parish CouncilParish Vice President: Holly Dawson Today the Lord enters the Jordan and cries out to John: / “Do not be afraid to baptize me. / For I have come to save Adam, the first-formed man.” Afterfeast of the Theophany of our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ Diocese of New York Andrew Romanofsky V.
    [Show full text]
  • Orthodox Teachers and Saints of the 18Th and 19Th Centuries
    UNIT 2C TRADITION 59: ORTHODOX TEACHERS AND SAINTS OF THE 18TH AND 19TH CENTURIES Introduction – Breaking the Bonds After the failure of the Council of Florence and the fall of Constantinople to the Turks in 1453 the Christian east began to slide into a period of prolonged decline. Bemused by the Reformation which had racked the West yet lacking the theological and spiritual vigour which might have insulated the Church from corrosive Western influences, Orthodoxy began to imitate western manners and culture. Most notoriously, the Ecumenical Patriarch, Cyril Lukaris, (1572-1638), in his struggle against the growing dominance of Rome, resorted to Protestant Calvinism and his teaching was condemned by no less than six local councils between 1638 and 1691. In an attempt to fight fire with fire and as a direct response to the career of Lukaris, two Confessions of Orthodox faith were issued by Peter Mogila, Metropolitan of Kiev (1633-1647) and Dositheus, Patriarch of Jerusalem (1669-1707), both Confessions being consciously adapted from Roman Catholic sources and both works being part of a wider disastrous program of westernisation. The 18th century, therefore, saw Orthodoxy in the East increasingly incarcerated within a western mindset which debilitated its spiritual life. The hierarchy in Russia not only looked to Rome as the model for efficient church administration, (urged on by Peter Mogila), but in the person of Patriarch Nikhon (1605-1681) it looked also to contentious models for liturgical reform. In 1652 to 1653 this policy triggered in Russia a tragic split between those who would not submit to the new ritual, the so- called Old Believers, and the reformers, a schism which has not been properly healed to this day.
    [Show full text]
  • Canon Law of Eastern Churches
    KB- KBZ Religious Legal Systems KBR-KBX Law of Christian Denominations KBR History of Canon Law KBS Canon Law of Eastern Churches Class here works on Eastern canon law in general, and further, on the law governing the Orthodox Eastern Church, the East Syrian Churches, and the pre- Chalcedonean Churches For canon law of Eastern Rite Churches in Communion with the Holy See of Rome, see KBT Bibliography Including international and national bibliography 3 General bibliography 7 Personal bibliography. Writers on canon law. Canonists (Collective or individual) Periodicals, see KB46-67 (Christian legal periodicals) For periodicals (Collective and general), see BX100 For periodicals of a particular church, see that church in BX, e.g. BX120, Armenian Church For periodicals of the local government of a church, see that church in KBS Annuals. Yearbooks, see BX100 Official gazettes, see the particular church in KBS Official acts. Documents For acts and documents of a particular church, see that church in KBS, e.g. KBS465, Russian Orthodox Church Collections. Compilations. Selections For sources before 1054 (Great Schism), see KBR195+ For sources from ca.1054 on, see KBS270-300 For canonical collections of early councils and synods, both ecumenical/general and provincial, see KBR205+ For document collections of episcopal councils/synods and diocesan councils and synods (Collected and individual), see the church in KBS 30.5 Indexes. Registers. Digests 31 General and comprehensive) Including councils and synods 42 Decisions of ecclesiastical tribunals and courts (Collective) Including related materials For decisions of ecclesiastical tribunals and courts of a particular church, see that church in KBS Encyclopedias.
    [Show full text]
  • New Europe College Black Sea Link Program Yearbook 2014-2015 Program Yearbook 2014-2015 Black Sea Link
    New Europe College Black Sea Link Program Yearbook 2014-2015 Program Yearbook 2014-2015 Black Sea Link ANNA ADASHINSKAYA ASIYA BULATOVA NEW EUROPE COLLEGE DIVNA MANOLOVA OCTAVIAN RUSU LUSINE SARGSYAN ANTON SHEKHOVTSOV NELLI SMBATYAN VITALIE SPRÎNCEANĂ ISSN 1584-0298 ANASTASIIA ZHERDIEVA CRIS Editor: Irina Vainovski-Mihai Copyright – New Europe College ISSN 1584-0298 New Europe College Str. Plantelor 21 023971 Bucharest Romania www.nec.ro; e-mail: [email protected] Tel. (+4) 021.307.99.10, Fax (+4) 021. 327.07.74 DIVNA MANOLOVA Born in 1984, in Bulgaria Ph.D. in Medieval Studies and in History, Central European University, 2014 Dissertation: Discourses of Science and Philosophy in the Letters of Nikephoros Gregoras Fellowships and grants: Visiting Research Fellow, Brown University, Department of Classics (2013) Doctoral Research Support Grant, Central European University (2013) Medieval Academy of America Etienne Gilson Dissertation Grant (2012) Junior Fellow, Research Center for Anatolian Civilizations, Koç University (2012–2013) Junior Fellow in Byzantine Studies, Dumbarton Oaks Research Library and Collection (2011–2012) Participation in international conferences in Austria, Bulgaria, France, Hungary, Italy, Spain, Switzerland, Turkey, United Kingdom, and United States of America. Publications and translations in the fields of Byzantine Studies, History of Medieval Philosophy, and History of Medieval Science. WHO WRITES THE HISTORY OF THE ROMANS? AGENCY AND CAUSALITY IN NIKEPHOROS GREGORAS’ HISTORIA RHŌMAÏKĒ Abstract The present article inquires
    [Show full text]
  • The-Lords-Prayer-English.Pdf
    οtI) ~ ΩΞ I:LI 8 ~ ~ ο t:) ~ ~ t:) ~8- ρ-ι tl)M ~ I1.ιtl) CI) .X..~. 00 ΩΞ '" c"- ><iS ~ ~< ~ ga -.% ~. 2§ tl)f-< ::Σ: ο <::ε ..J Ζ ~ ο < I:LI ::ε >< Ε-4=Σ= ...:Ι Ο:Ι: ΤΗΕ LORD'S PRA YER 1st EDmONS 1991 2nd EDmON 1997 3rd EDmON 2001 © 2001 HOLΥ MONASTERY OF ST. GREGORIOS 63087 - ΜΤ. ΑTHOS - GREECE ISBN 960-7553-09-8 PREFACE Meanings ίπ Gospel discourse are formulated ίπ the Holy Spirit and therefore with enduring vαlue αnd α view to eternity. Every' teαching, pαrable, story and description, αs well αs every phrase, every word and ever)' "detαil" contαined ίπ the Gospel ο! Christ is ο! greαtest depth αnd significαnce. These αre not exhαusted by α mere superficiαl interpretαtion, the most our own poor spiritual measure can conceive. This is αlso true ο! the God-given prα)'er knorvn to us . αs ''Our Father", which the Lord Himself gαve to His Church as απ exαmple ο! prαyer for αΙΙ of us. Our Holy Fαthers lived the Gospel ofChrist. They kept His holy commαndments. Their life, their discourse became extensions of the Gospel, αnd their experience ίπ the Spirit ο! God enriches the holy Tradition ο! the Church. They reveαl the great depth ofthe sαving words ο! the Lord Christ αnd prove thαt His commandments "are not heavy", but cαn be αpplied by Christiαns ίπ αΠΥ αge, αnd thus they keep control over our lαck ο! faith, neglect αnd sloth. With our old and modern Holy Fαthers αs interpreters ofthe Lord's Prαyer, we investigate αnd touch its depths, directing it to the Lord.
    [Show full text]
  • The Revival of Political Hesychasm in Greek Orthodox Thought: a Study of the Hesychast Basis of the Thought of John S
    ABSTRACT The Revival of Political Hesychasm in Greek Orthodox Thought: A Study of the Hesychast Basis of the Thought of John S. Romanides and Christos Yannaras Daniel Paul Payne, B.A., M.Div. Mentor: Derek H. Davis, Ph.D. In the 1940s Russian émigré theologians rediscovered the ascetic-theology of St. Gregory Palamas. Palamas’s theology became the basis for an articulation of an Orthodox theological identity apart from Roman Catholic and Protestant influences. In particular the “Neo-Patristic Synthesis” of Fr. Georges Florovsky and the appropriation of Palamas’s theology by Vladimir Lossky set the course for future Orthodox theology in the twentieth century. Their thought had a direct influence upon the thought of Greek theologians John S. Romanides and Christos Yannaras in the late twentieth century. Each of these theologians formulated a political theology using the ascetic-theology of Palamas combined with the Roman identity of the Greek Orthodox people. Both of these thinkers called for a return to the ecclesial-communal life of the late Byzantine period as an alternative to the secular vision of the modern West. The resulting paradigm developed by their thought has led to the formation of what has been called the “Neo- Orthodox Movement.” Essentially, what the intellectual and populist thinkers of the movement have expressed in their writings is “political hesychasm.” Romanides and Yannaras desire to establish an Orthodox identity that separates the Roman aspect from the Hellenic element of Greek identity. The Roman identity of the Greek people is the Orthodox Christian element removed from the pagan Hellenism, which, as they argue, the Western powers imposed on the Greek people in the establishment of the modern nation-state of Greece in 1821.
    [Show full text]
  • J a N U a R Y Sunday Before Theophany of Our Lord
    2 0 1 7 J A N U A R Y Sunday before Theophany of Our Lord. Epis. Colossians 2:8-12; Hebrews 13:17-21; 2 Timothy 4:5-8. Gos. Luke 2:20-21, 40-52; Mark 1:1-8. Tone 3. Mat. Gos. 6. 1 S (+) Circumcision of Our Lord; +) St. Basil the Great and his mother, St. Emilia (New Year. Thanksgiving Service) 2 M Holy Hierarch Sylvester, bishop of Rome; Ven. Seraphim of Sarov (Forefeast of Theophany) 3 T Holy Prophet Malachi; Martyr Gordius 4 W Synaxis of the Seventy Apostles; Ven. Teoctist; Ven. Apolinaria (Fast free) 5 T Holy Martyrs Theopemptus, Theonas; Ven. Syncletica (Eve of Theophany) (Strict Fast) 6 F (+) Holy Theophany of Our Lord Jesus Christ (Fast free) 7 S + Synaxis of the Holy Prophet, Forerunner and Baptizer John (Saturday after Theophany) Sunday after Theophany. Epis. Ephesians 4:7-13. Gos. Matthew 4:12-17 (Beginning of the Lord’s ministry). Tone 4. Mat. Gos. 7. 8 S Ven. George the Chozebite and Domnica 9 M Martyr Polyeuctus; Ven. Eustratius; Holy Hierarch Peter, bishop of Sebastea 10 T St. Gregory of Nyssa; + Ven. Antypas of Calapodest; Holy Hierarch Dometian, bishop of Melitene 11 W + Ven. Theodosius, founder of cenobite life in Palestine; Ven. Vitaly 12 T Martyr Tatiana the deaconess and Eustasia 13 F + Martyrs Hermylus and Stratonicus; Holy Hierarch James (Jacob), bishop of Nisibis 14 S Ven. Martyrs slain at Sinai and Raithu; St. Sava of Serbia; St. Nina (Leave-taking of Theophany) 29th Sunday after Pentecost. Epis. (of the 28th Sunday): Colossians 1:12-18.
    [Show full text]
  • Holy Scripture in the Orthodox Church "The Bible" Compiled by Father Demetrios Serfes Boise, Idaho, USA August 20 2000
    Holy Scripture In The Orthodox Church "The Bible" Compiled by Father Demetrios Serfes Boise, Idaho, USA August 20 2000 Introduction by Father Demetrios Serfes : Priest: Wisdom! Let Us Attend! Let Us Hear The Holy Gospel! Peace Be Unto All! Choir: And To Thy Spirit! The Bible is the book of the Church. We therefore read Holy Scripture, not as isolated individuals, but as members of the Church. In order to keep Holy Scripture in the mind of the Church, we observe how Scripture is used in worship, and how it is interpreted by the Holy Fathers. Our approach then to the Bible is both Liturgical and Patristic. The Eastern Orthodox Church belief about Holy Scripture that is the Bible of the Old Testament and the New Testament we must be fully aware from within Holy Tradition. Tradition, is a life, a personal encounter with Christ our Lord in the Holy Spirit. Tradition then not only is kept by the Church - it lives in the Church, it is the life of the Holy Spirit in the Church. The Bible is then the supreme expression of God's revelation to man. "The standard of the Let me humbly now give you a clearer understanding of Holy Tradition in the Eastern Holy Spirit as the Orthodox Church: sole Inspirer and Interpreter of the The meaning of Tradition in the early Christian Fathers refers to the Revelation made Holy Scriptures, and as the Unifier, in a by God and delivered to His faithful people through the mouths of His prophets and spirit of freedom, of apostles.
    [Show full text]
  • Whose Tradition?: Adapting Orthodox Christianity in North America By
    Whose Tradition?: Adapting Orthodox Christianity in North America by © Lydia Bringerud A thesis submitted to the School of Graduate Studies In partial fulfillment of the Requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. Department of Folklore Memorial University of Newfoundland May 2019 St. John’s Newfoundland For my Naşa Karin-Irina Doehl, proud feminist and Orthodox Christian, to whom I owe so much. May her memory be eternal. ii Abstract Focusing on three Orthodox Christian communities – St. Paraskeva and St. Luke in Midwestern US, and St. Nicolas in Atlantic Canada – this thesis examines the complex cultural dynamics surrounding Orthodox Christianity in North America. I explore the ways believers, both the Orthodox-born and new converts, negotiate with an ancient faith in a contemporary society where this faith may appear counter-cultural. Building on Leonard Primiano’s (1995) theory of vernacular religion, I propose the concept of vernacular theology to shed light on these processes. Despite the illusion of theology as the exclusive purview of clergy, laypeople exercise interpretive agency to creatively adapt doctrine to their individual life circumstances. Considering the significant role of Church history in the religious choices and experiences of my consultants, I begin with a historical overview of Orthodox Christianity, from its origins in the Roman Empire to the present day, including its path to North America. The themes of empire, romantic nationalism, anti-Westernism, and Communism that have historically shaped this faith are explored specifically in Romania, Russia, Serbia, and Ukraine, the home countries of my Orthodox-born participants. I analyze the Orthodox Church’s response to globalization and how this may affect the future of the Church in North America.
    [Show full text]
  • Eastern Orthodox Prayers Eastern Orthodox Prayers
    Eastern Orthodox prayers Eastern Orthodox prayers PDF generated using the open source mwlib toolkit. See http://code.pediapress.com/ for more information. PDF generated at: Fri, 11 Jun 2010 15:50:50 UTC Contents Articles Eastern Orthodox prayers 1 Jesus Prayer 1 Akathist 13 Axion Estin 17 Theotokion 20 Ektenia 21 References Article Sources and Contributors 23 Image Sources, Licenses and Contributors 24 Article Licenses License 25 1 Eastern Orthodox prayers Jesus Prayer The Jesus Prayer (Η Προσευχή του Ιησού) or "The Prayer" (Evkhee, Greek: Η Ευχή - the Wish), also called the Prayer of the Heart[1] (Καρδιακή Προσευχή) and "Prayer of the Mind (Nous)" (Νοερά Προσευχή), is a short, formulaic prayer often uttered repeatedly. It has been widely used, taught and discussed throughout the history of the Eastern Churches. The exact words of the prayer have varied from the simplest possible involving Jesus' name to the more common extended form: Christogram with Jesus Prayer in Romanian: Doamne Iisuse Hristoase, Fiul lui Dumnezeu, miluieşte-mă pe mine păcătosul ("Lord Jesus Christ, Son of God, have mercy on me, the sinner"). “Κύριε Ιησού Χριστέ, Υιέ του Θεού, ελέησόν με τον αμαρτωλόν.” “Lord Jesus Christ, Son of God, have mercy on me, the sinner.” [2] The Jesus Prayer is for the Eastern Orthodox one of the most profound and mystical prayers and it is often repeated continually as a part of personal ascetic practice. Its practice is an integral part of the eremitic tradition of prayer known as Hesychasm (Greek: ἡσυχάζω, hesychazo, "to keep stillness"), the subject of the Philokalia (Greek: φιλοκαλείν, "love of beauty"), a collection of fourth to fifteenth century texts on prayer, compiled in the late eighteenth century by St.
    [Show full text]
  • Monastic Discourse on the Ottoman Threat in 14Th- and 15Th-Century Serbian Territories
    Bojana Vasiljević “FEAR OF THE TURKS”: MONASTIC DISCOURSE ON THE OTTOMAN THREAT IN 14TH- AND 15TH-CENTURY SERBIAN TERRITORIES MA Thesis in Comparative History, with a specialization in Interdisciplinary Medieval Studies. Central European University Budapest CEU eTD Collection December 2017 “FEAR OF THE TURKS”: MONASTIC DISCOURSE ON THE OTTOMAN THREAT IN 14TH- AND 15TH-CENTURY SERBIAN TERRITORIES by Bojana Vasiljević (Serbia) Thesis submitted to the Department of Medieval Studies, Central European University, Budapest, in partial fulfillment of the requirements of the Master of Arts degree in Comparative History, with a specialization in Interdisciplinary Medieval Studies. Accepted in conformance with the standards of the CEU. ____________________________________________ Chair, Examination Committee ____________________________________________ Thesis Supervisor ____________________________________________ Examiner ____________________________________________ Examiner CEU eTD Collection Budapest November 2017 “FEAR OF THE TURKS”: MONASTIC DISCOURSE ON THE OTTOMAN THREAT IN 14TH- AND 15TH-CENTURY SERBIAN TERRITORIES by Bojana Vasiljević (Serbia) Thesis submitted to the Department of Medieval Studies, Central European University, Budapest, in partial fulfillment of the requirements of the Master of Arts degree in Comparative History, with a specialization in Interdisciplinary Medieval Studies. Accepted in conformance with the standards of the CEU. ____________________________________________ External Reader CEU eTD Collection Budapest November
    [Show full text]
  • His Life and Importance Part II Thessaloniki
    Gregory Palamas His life and Importance Part II Thessaloniki 1338 and Gregory is in Thessaloniki & Barlaam is in Constantinople cozying up to the Patriarch Gregory continues his writing and focuses on the interpretation of ascetic ideas and truths writing about the relation of body and soul and holy illumination and perfection. Writes first three sections of his famous work The Triads. Triads He wrote, “Our heart [center of soul] is the place of the rational faculty, the first rational organ of the body.” Must keep watch over and correct our reason by a rigorous discipline by gathering our mind, which has been distracted by the senses, and lead it back into the interior, to the selfsame heart which is the seat of our thoughts. Psycho-physical methods of holding the mind in the body is not a mechanical way of obtaining grace. It is a way for beginners to practica$y avoid distraction and wandering of the mind. Triads “Contemplation...is a union and a divinization which occurs mystica$y and ine%ably by the grace of God, a&er stripping away of everything here below which imprints itself on the mind, or rather afer the cessation of al intelectual activity.... We intend to show...that though they (the monastics) have indeed seen (the light), yet their organ of vision was, properly speaking, neither the senses nor the intelect.” Triads “Beyond prayer, there is the inefable vision, ecstasy in union, and the hidden mysteries,...where there is an unknowing which is beyond knowledge; though indeed a darkness, it is yet beyond radiance.
    [Show full text]