DESY 17-071 Exotics: Heavy Pentaquarks and Tetraquarks Ahmed Ali,1 Jens S¨orenLange,2 and Sheldon Stone3 1DESY Theory Group, Notkestrasse 85, D-22607 Hamburg, Germany 2Justus-Liebig-Universit¨atGiessen, II. Physikalisches Institut, Heinrich-Buff-Ring 16, D-35392 Giessen, Germany 3Physics Department, 201 Physics Building, Syracuse University, Syracuse, NY 13244-1130, USA July 31, 2017 Abstract For many decades after the invention of the quark model in 1964 there was no evidence that hadrons are formed from anything other than the simplest pairings of quarks and antiquarks, mesons being formed of a quark-antiquark pair and baryons from three quarks. In the last decade, however, in an explosion of data from both e+e− and hadron colliders, there are many recently observed states that do not fit into this picture. These new particles are called generically \ex- otics". They can be either mesons or baryons. Remarkably, they all decay into at least one meson formed of either a cc or bb pair. In this review, after the introduction, we explore each of these new discoveries in detail first from an experimental point of view, then subsequently give a theo- retical discussion. These exotics can be explained if the new mesons contain two-quarks and two- antiquarks (tetraquarks), while the baryons contain four-quarks plus an antiquark (pentaquarks). The theoretical explanations for these states take three divergent tracks: tightly bound objects, just as in the case of normal hadrons, but with more constituents, or loosely bound \molecules" similar to the deuteron, but formed from two mesons, or a meson or baryon, or more wistfully, they are not multiquark states but appear due to kinematic effects caused by different rescatterings of virtual particles; most of these models have all been post-dictions. Both the tightly and loosely bound models predict the masses and related quantum numbers of new, as yet undiscovered states. arXiv:1706.00610v2 [hep-ph] 27 Jul 2017 Thus, future experimental discoveries are needed along with theoretical advances to elucidate the structure of these new exotic states. Contents 1 Introduction 3 2 Theoretical techniques for quarkonia and exotic hadrons spectroscopy 6 2.1 Quarkonium potentials . .6 2.2 Lattice simulations . .7 2.3 Born-Oppenheimer tetraquarks . .9 2.4 Doubly heavy tetraquarks on the lattice . 10 1 3 Experimental evidence for pentaquarks 11 3.1 History . 11 3.2 The LHCb observation of pentaquark charmonium states . 12 0 − 3.2.1 The Λb ! J= K p decay . 12 0 ∗ 3.2.2 The Λb ! J= Λ decay amplitude . 14 0 ∗ 3.2.3 Fits of the reaction Λb ! J= Λ to the data . 16 0 + − 3.2.4 The matrix element for Λb ! J= Pc K decay . 16 0 − + 3.2.5 Amplitude fits of Λb ! J= K p allowing Pc states . 17 0 − 3.3 Consistency check using Λb ! J= pπ decays . 20 + ∗ 3.4 Independent confirmation of the Pc(4450) using a model independent Λ description 26 3.5 Impending studies using photoproduction of J= p resonances . 30 4 Experimental evidence for tetraquarks 31 4.1 The X(3872) state . 31 4.1.1 Mass of the X(3872) . 31 4.1.2 Width of the X(3872) . 32 4.1.3 Decays of the X(3872) . 33 4.1.4 Production of the X(3872) . 36 4.1.5 Interpretation of the X(3872) . 39 4.2 The X(3940) state . 42 4.3 Y states . 44 4.4 Z states of type I in the charmonium mass regime . 49 4.5 Z states of type II in the charmonium mass regime . 53 4.6 Z states in the bottomonium mass regime . 57 4.7 Another curious system: J= φ resonances . 59 5 Theoretical models for tetraquarks 65 5.1 Tetraquarks as cusps . 65 5.2 Tetraquarks as hadroquarkonia . 66 5.3 Tetraquarks as hybrids . 67 5.4 Tetraquarks as hadron molecules . 67 5.5 Tetraquarks as compact diquark-antidiquark mesons . 68 5.6 The diquark model . 69 5.7 Non-relativistic Hamiltonian for tetraquarks with hidden charm . 70 5.8 Low-lying S and P -wave tetraquark states in the cc¯ and b¯b sectors . 71 5.9 Heavy-Quark-Spin Flip in Υ(10860) ! hb(1P; 2P )ππ ................. 76 5.10 Drell-Yan mechanism for vector exotica production at the LHC and Tevatron . 79 6 Theoretical models for pentaquarks 80 6.1 Pentaquarks as rescattering-induced kinematic effects . 81 6.2 Pentaquarks as meson-baryon molecules . 82 6.3 Pentaquarks in the compact diquark models . 83 6.4 SU(3)F structure of pentaquarks . 84 6.5 An effective Hamiltonian for the hidden charm pentaquarks . 85 6.6 b-baryon decays to pentaquarks and heavy quark symmetry . 87 6.7 Weak decays with P in decuplet representation . 88 7 Summary 90 2 1 Introduction When the two B factory experiments BABAR and Belle were proposed, well over a quarter century ago, their main goal was to measure the matter-antimatter asymmetry in the B-meson sector.1 This goal they indeed accomplished very well, together with other related key measurements in flavor physics, which greatly helped in testing the charged current weak interactions in the standard model [1]. While in depth studies of hadronic structure was not on the agenda of these experiments, they also succeeded in uncovering a new facet of QCD. The discovery of the exotic hadron X(3872) in 2003 in the decays B0 ! J= π+π−K by Belle [2] came as a complete surprise.2 Confirmation soon thereafter by BABAR [3, 4], CDF II [5{7], D0 [8], and later by the LHCb [9] and CMS [10], established the X(3872) as a genuine resonance, as opposed to a threshold effect (called a \cusp"). Its discovery turned out to be the harbinger of a new direction in hadron physics. Thus, out of the debris of B-meson decays emerged a second layer of strongly interacting particles called tetraquarks (four-quark states), all containing a cc quark pair. Likewise, in the decays of the Λb-baryon, LHCb later established the existence of two + + pentaquark states Pc (4380) and Pc (4450) in the J= p decay mode [11]. As the minimum valence quark content of such a state is ccuud¯ , the newly discovered baryons have five quarks. Meanwhile, well over two dozen exotic hadrons have found entries in the Particle Data Group [12]. Tentatively called PC X, Y , Z and Pc, they have various J quantum numbers, and come both as charged and neutrals, as discussed in detail in this review and elsewhere [13{16]. At least two b¯b counterparts of the cc¯ states, + + ¯ ¯ Zb (10610) and Zb (10650), have also been reported by Belle [17]. Their valence quark content is bbud. A closely related question is whether tetraquarks and pentaquarks also come with a single charm or bottom valence quark, was reviewed recently [18]. Quarkonium physics is a well-studied system theoretically, having its roots in the non-relativistic quarkonium potential [19, 20]. Its present formulation is in the context of effective field theories based on QCD [21, 22] and lattice-QCD [23{26]. The progress in lattice-based techniques is impressive and allows us to connect the observed hadronic properties with the fundamental parameters in QCD. In particular, hadron spectra below the strong decay thresholds are calculated accurately, and extensive results for multiplets are available. However, so far there are no reliable lattice results for flavor exotic states, though possible cc¯du¯ candidates with J PC = 1+− have been searched for in the vicinity of the ¯ ∗ + DD threshold [27], where the Zc (3900) is found experimentally. No ccs¯ s¯ resonance has been found in the J= φ scattering on the lattice, though their experimental evidence has mounted, and no ccd¯u¯ bound state is found in the DD∗ scattering either [28]. We briefly review the current lattice simulations in section 2, but we shall be mostly using the available phenomenological approaches for the theoretical discussion of tetraquarks and pentaquarks in this review. For the spectra of the cc¯ and b¯b bound states below their corresponding open flavor thresholds, DD¯ and BB¯, potential models are reliable, as they successfully reproduce the observed 1S, 2S, and 1P states, in the cc¯ -, and many more higher states in the b¯b-sector. The most popular of these, the Cornell potential [19, 20], incorporates a color Coulomb term at short distances and a linear confining term at large distances, with the spin-dependent interquark interaction responsible for the splitting of the states in these multiplets governed by a one-gluon exchange Breit-Fermi Hamiltonian. The quarkonium- potential-based studies were substantially extended to cover the cc¯ and b¯b states above the open flavor thresholds (see, for example, Ref. [29]). The concordance between experiments and such theoretical estimates is remarkable in both the charm and bottom sectors, predicting correctly a large number of observed states. While empirical, these potential-model based studies provide useful benchmarks for the quarkonia states, as they provide the background upon which exotic particles are to be searched for and characterized. What are the criteria for an observed hadron to be termed as exotic? The clues to novel features 1They followed the exploratory work done by the ARGUS and CLEO experiments operating in the Υ resonance region. 2Mention of a specific decay mode implies use of the charge-conjugate mode as well. 3 in QCD may come in a number of ways which we discuss here briefly. For example, the exotic hadrons may have unconventional J PC quantum numbers, such as having J PC = 0−−; 0+−; 1+−, which are not allowed for non-relativistic qq¯ states.