DOCSLIB.ORG

Galileo Was Wrong the Church Was Right

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text

Load more

Galileo Was Wrong The Church Was Right The Evidence from Church History Volume III Chapters 14 - 17 Seventh Edition Robert A. Sungenis, Ph.D. Published by Catholic Apologetics International Publishing, Inc., 2013 Mailing address: P. O. Box 278 State Line, Pennsylvania, 17263 1-800-531-6393 Copyright © 2013 by Robert A. Sungenis, Sr. and assigns All rights reserved. No part of the contents of this book Galileo Was Wrong: The Church Was Right: The Evidence from Church History, Volume III is permitted to be reproduced or copied by any means whatsoever without written consent from the copyright holder, except for short quotations to be used in various print or electronic mediums. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Sungenis, Robert, A, Sr. Galileo Was Wrong: The Church Was Right by Robert A. Sungenis Bibliographical reference 1. Geocentrism. 2. Cosmology 3. Church History. 4. Galileo 5. St. Robert Bellermine Cover design by Robert Sungenis Seventh edition Previous five editions, in two volumes, were titled Galileo Was Wrong: The Church Was Right, published between 2005 and 2010. Sixth edition, in three volumes, was published in January 2013. ISBN-10: 1939856035 ISBN-13: 978-1-939856-03-6 Printed in the United States of America 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 ii Unless otherwise noted, all Scripture passages are taken from either the Revised Standard Version or the Douay-Rheims Bible. Some passages have been translated by Robert Sungenis directly from the Hebrew or Greek. A CDROM is included with this book so that the reader can view the electronic animations and graphics. In the text of the book, notice is given that there is a corresponding animation, picture, photo, graph or chart in the CDROM. Cover Design and Production: Robert Sungenis Animations for CDROM: Douglas Rudd Photographs and Illustrations: Mark Wyatt Licenses and permissions for pictures and graphics are listed at the end of the Bibliography section iii Special Appreciation Our thanks to the following individuals and institutions for helping in the content and publishing of this book: A special thanks to Mark Wyatt for his insight and advice during the entire course of this project, and for the production of the photographs and charts. A special thanks for his research on Newton’s Principia Mathematica. A special thanks to Gerald Margand, Paul Melka, Dean Davis, Kari Oppliger, and Thomas Canfield for their proof reading of this book. A special thanks to Mario Derksen for his translation of the German texts; Fr. Brian Harrison and Ryan Thomas for their translation of the Italian texts; and Hildegard Pohl for her translation of the French texts. The Hebrew, Greek and Latin texts were translated by Robert Sungenis, except for Fr. Harrison’s translation of selected portions of Alexander VII’s Speculatores Domus Israel. A special thanks to Douglas Rudd for his production of the CDrom. A special thanks to the Britons Catholic Library, Catholic University of America, Georgetown University, George Washington University, and the Washington Theological Union. iv This book is dedicated to: St. Robert Cardinal Bellarmine and Father Filippo Anfossi, Master of the Sacred Palace For their courage and foresight in standing up to the unproven theories of Galileo Galilei v Table of Contents About the Author ix Scripture Abbreviations x Introduction 1 Chapter 14 Scripture Passages Teaching Geocentrism 17 How Much Authority Does Scripture Possess in Science? 17 Language of Fact versus Language of Appearance 24 Official Statements of the Catholic Magisterium 27 Scriptural Passages Teaching a Stationary Earth 30 Joshua 10:10-14 30 Exegetical Details 35 Galileo’s Interpretation of Joshua 10 39 Ecclesiasticus (Sirach) 46:3-5 47 Habakkuk 3:11 48 2Kings 20:9-12 49 2Chronicles 32:31 49 Isaiah 38:7-8 50 Psalm 8:3-6 50 Psalm 19:1-6 51 Galileo’s Interpretation of Psalm 19 44 1Chronicles 16:30 57 Psalm 93:1-2 57 Psalm 96:9-11 59 Psalm 75:2-4 62 Psalm 104:5, 19 62 Psalm 119:89-91 63 Ecclesiastes 1:4-7 64 Ecclesiasticus (Sirach) 43:1-10 66 Job 9:6-10 67 Job 22:13-14 68 Job 26:7-9 68 Job 26:10-11 70 Proverbs 8:27-30 70 Wisdom 7:15-22 71 1Esdras 4:34 72 Job 38:12-14 72 Psalm 82:5 73 Psalm 99:1 73 vi Isaiah 13:13 73 Isaiah 24:19-23 74 Job 38:18: Constitution of the Firmament 74 Chapter 15 The Consensus of Church Fathers 79 Geocentrism 84 The Length of the Genesis Day 105 The Firmament 128 The Spherical Earth 138 Chapter 16 The Catholic Church’s Teaching on Geocentrism 147 1979: John Paul II Reexamines Galileo Case 147 1992: An Analysis of John Paul II’s Speech on Galileo 153 A Logical and Inevitable Warning to the Church 156 How Then Should the Church Proceed? 160 A Detailed Analysis of John Paul II’s 1992 Speech 166 Canon Giuseppe Settele’s Imprimatur 187 The 1835 Index of Gregory XVI 195 A Closer Look at the “Error of the Theologians” 206 Cardinal Ratzinger: “The Crisis of Faith in Science” 217 1500-1600: The Church Confronts Copernican Cosmology 222 1566: Pius V and the Catechism of the Council of Trent 226 Official Sanctions against Copernicanism 236 1615: The Church Confronts Fr. Paolo Antonio Foscarini 239 1616: The Church Confronts Galileo Galilei 253 Excursus on Giordano Bruno 257 Galileo’s Letter to Benedetto Castelli 263 The Investigation of Galileo Continues 284 1633: The Sentence and Punishment of Galileo 304 1641: Galileo Converts to Geocentrism 322 1639: Galileo’s Conversion to the True Catholic Faith 336 1664: Alexander VII and the Index of Forbidden Books 341 Alexander VII’s Bull: Speculatores Domus Israel 342 1741: The First Index of Benedict XIV 352 1758: The Second Index of Benedict XIV 358 The Efforts of Pietro Lazzari for Galileo 361 The Rebuff to Astronomer Joseph Lalande 370 1742-1833: The Disclaimer on Newton’s Principia 370 1822: Pius VII and Canon Settele’s Imprimatur 379 vii 1822: The Battle between Anfossi and Olivieri 382 1820-1822: More Detail on the Settele Decisions 435 1835: Gregory XVI’s Index of Forbidden Books 441 1850: The Vatican Supports the 1633 Condemnations 453 1893: Leo XIII’s Encyclical Providentissimus Deus 453 1921: Benedict XV’s Encyclical In Praeclara Summorum 460 1941: The Book of Pio Paschini on Galileo 465 1616-1664: Are the Papal Decrees Infallible? 466 1870: Vatican Council I, Magisterium & Modern Science 480 1965: Vatican Council II’s Gaudium et Spes 484 2003: Catholic Apologetics and Geocentrism 487 St Pius X Society, Jason Winshel 487 2010: Catholic Culture, Dr. Jeffrey Mirus 496 2001: Fr. George Murphy, Ph.D. Physics 505 “The Church Does not Teach Geocentrism Today” 509 “The Church Fathers Did Not Debate Geocentrism” 515 1965: Lumen Gentium 12: “The Whole Body…Cannot Err” 520 The Signs of Apostasy 522 Chapter 17 Interpreting Genesis 1 529 Its Geocentric Implications 529 Protestant Interpretations of Genesis: Hugh Ross 534 Higher Criticism: Raymond Brown, Stanley Jaki 548 Genesis 1 Day/Night Sequence Revisited 560 The Stars and the Speed of Light in Genesis 1 566 Using the Redshift Formula for a Small Universe 582 Critique of Ferdinand Crombette 583 Bibliography 589 Webliography 685 Licenses and Permissions 703 viii About the Author Robert A. Sungenis, Ph.D., is the founder of Catholic Apologetics International Publishing, Inc., a non-profit corporation. He holds advanced degrees in Theology and Religious Studies and was a physics major in college. His 700-page doctoral dissertation defended geocentric cosmology from scientific, theological and historical perspectives. He is the author of over twenty books on religion, politics, science and culture. He is also the managing partner of Stellar Motion Pictures, LLC in Los Angeles, which specializes in producing movies on science and religion. He is the executive producer of the recently released movie, The Principle. He has appeared on radio and television, including programs on CNN, the BBC and EWTN. Some of Robert’s publications include the following: The Catholic Apologetics Study Bible, Vol. 6, The Gospel According to St. John (CAI Publishing, Inc., 2010); The Catholic Apologetics Study Bible, Vol. 5, The First Epistle to the Corinthians (CAI Publishing, Inc., 2008); The Catholic Apologetics Study Bible, Vol. 4, The Book of Genesis, Chapters 1-11 (CAI Publishing, Inc., 2008); The Catholic Apologetics Study Bible, Vol. 3, The Epistles of Romans and James (CAI Publishing, Inc., 2008); The Catholic Apologetics Study Bible, Vol. 2, The Apocalypse of St. John (Queenship Publishing, 2007); The Catholic Apologetics Study Bible, Vol. 1, The Gospel According to St. Matthew (Queenship Publishing, 2003); Not By Bread Alone: The Biblical and Historical Evidence for the Eucharistic Sacrifice (Queenship Publishing, 2000); How Can I Get to Heaven: The Bible’s Teaching on Salvation Made Easy to Understand (Queenship Publishing, 1998); Not By Faith Alone: The Biblical Evidence for the Catholic Doctrine of Justification (Queenship Publishing, 1997); Not By Scripture Alone: A Catholic Critique of the Protestant Doctrine of Sola Scriptura (Queenship Publishing, 1997); Shockwave 2000 (New Leaf Press, 1994). ix Scripture Abbreviations Jg Judges New Testament Rt Ruth 1Sm 1 Samuel Mt Matthew 2Sm 2 Samuel Mk Mark 1Kg 1 Kings Lk Luke 2Kg 2 Kings Jn John 1Ch 1 Chronicles Ac Acts 2Ch 2 Chronicles Rm Romans Er Ezra 1Co 1 Corinthians Nh Nehemiah 2Co 2 Corinthians Tb Tobit Gl Galatians Jt Judith Ep Ephesians Et Esther Ph Philippians 1Mc 1 Maccabees Cl Colossians 2Mc 2 Maccabees 1Th 1 Thessalonians Jb Job 2Th 2 Thessalonians Ps Psalms 1Tm 1 Timothy Pr Proverbs 2Tm 2 Timothy Ec Ecclesiastes Ti Titus Sg Song of Solomon Pm Philemon Ws Wisdom Hb Hebrews Es Ecclesiasticus (Sirach) Jm James Is Isaiah 1Pt 1 Peter Jr Jeremiah 2Pt 2 Peter Lm Lamentations 1Jn 1 John Br Baruch 2Jn 2 John Ez Ezekiel 3Jn 3 John Dn Daniel Jd Jude Hs Hosea Ap Apocalypse (Revelation) Jl Joel Am Amos Old Testament Ob Obadiah Jh Jonah Gn Genesis Mc Micah Ex Exodus Na Nahum Lv Leviticus Hk Habakkuk Nm Numbers Zp Zephaniah Dt Deuteronomy Hg Haggai Js Joshua Zc Zechariah Ml Malachi x For the wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and wickedness of men who by their wickedness suppress the truth.
Recommended publications
  • The Spectrumspectrum the Calendar 2 Membership Corner 3 the Newsletter for the Buffalo Astronomical a Letter from Mike 4

    The Spectrumspectrum the Calendar 2 Membership Corner 3 the Newsletter for the Buffalo Astronomical a Letter from Mike 4

    Inside this issue: TheThe SpectrumSpectrum The Calendar 2 Membership Corner 3 The Newsletter for the Buffalo Astronomical A Letter from Mike 4 Obs Report 5 The Banquet 6 Stay Warm and 9 Cozy Astro Day Poster 11 March/April The Galileo Affair 12 Volume 17, Issue 2 Gallery 18 May Star Chart 19 March Star Chart 19 April Star Chart 20 Our Newly Redesigned Website is Live! If you haven’t checked out BuffaloAstronomy.com recently, it’s time for a visit. Our new site, designed by webmaster and club member Gene Timothy is up and running. The interface is clean and organized and much easier to update with club news and astronomy content. You can now register for the April Banquet, join the club and pay dues using a PayPal account or a major credit card. Coming soon is a new log-in area which will allow members to communicate with each other, share a profile and access special features, including BAA historical information and an archive of Spectrum issues dating back many decades. Come visit and share your comments, thoughts and ideas on how we can make the site better and more useful to the club. A BIG thank you to Gene and the BAA Board for their hard work and creativity! 1 BAA Schedule of Astronomy Fun for 2015 BAA Schedule of Astronomy Fun for 2015 Mar 13: BAA Meeting at 7:30pm at Buffalo State College Mar 20: New Moon Mar 20: Total Solar Eclipse (Arctic) Mar 21-22: Maple Syrup Festival at BMO 9am-3pm Need help for Solar viewing Mar 21: Messier Marathon Dusk till Dawn at Beaver Meadow Observatory Apr 4: First Public Night at Beaver Meadow Observatory April 4: Total Lunar Eclipse Apr 11: BAA Annual Dinner Meeting at Risottos April 18; New Moon Apr 18/19: NEAF who wants to car pool?? April 21-22: Lyrids Meteor Shower Apr 25: Astronomy Day at Buffalo Museum of Science details TBA May 2: Public Night BMO May 8: BAA Meeting at 7:30pm at Buffalo State College May 18: New Moon Jun 6: Public Night BMO Jun 12: BAA Meeting/Elections at 7:30pm at Buffalo State College Jun 17 New Moon July 4: Public Night BMO – I will need help as I have family obligations that day.
  • Galileo in Rome Galileo in Rome

    Galileo in Rome Galileo in Rome

    Galileo in Rome Galileo in Rome The Rise and Fall of a Troublesome Genius William R. Shea and Mariano Artigas Oxford New York Auckland Bangkok Buenos Aires Cape Town Chennai Dar es Salaam Delhi Hong Kong Istanbul Karachi Kolkata Kuala Lumpur Madrid Melbourne Mexico City Mumbai Nairobi São Paulo Shanghai Taipei Tokyo Toronto Copyright © 2003 by Oxford University Press, Inc. First published by Oxford University Press, Inc., 2003 198 Madison Avenue, New York, New York 10016 www.oup.com Issued as an Oxford University Press paperback, 2004 ISBN 0-19-517758-4 (pbk) Oxford is a registered trademark of Oxford University Press All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior permission of Oxford University Press. The Library of Congress has catalogued the cloth edition as follows: Artigas, Mariano. Galileo in Rome : the rise and fall of a troublesome genius / Mariano Artigas and William R. Shea. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-19-516598-5 1. Galilei, Galileo, 1564-1642—Journeys—Italy—Rome. 2. Religion and science—History—16th century. 3. Astronomers—Italy—Biography. I. Shea, William R. II. Title. QB36.G2 A69 2003 520'.92—dc21 2003004247 Book design by planettheo.com 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 Printed in the United States of America on acid-free paper CONTENTS ACKNO W L E D G E M E N T S vii I N TRO D U C TIO N ix CHA P TER O N E Job Hunting and the Path
  • The Jesuits and the Galileo Affair Author(S): Nicholas Overgaard Source: Prandium - the Journal of Historical Studies, Vol

    The Jesuits and the Galileo Affair Author(S): Nicholas Overgaard Source: Prandium - the Journal of Historical Studies, Vol

    Early Modern Catholic Defense of Copernicanism: The Jesuits and the Galileo Affair Author(s): Nicholas Overgaard Source: Prandium - The Journal of Historical Studies, Vol. 2, No. 1 (Spring, 2013), pp. 29-36 Published by: The Department of Historical Studies, University of Toronto Mississauga Stable URL: http://jps.library.utoronto.ca/index.php/prandium/article/view/19654 Prandium: The Journal of Historical Studies Vol. 2, No. 1, (2013) Early Modern Catholic Defense of Copernicanism: The Jesuits and the Galileo Affair Nicholas Overgaard “Obedience should be blind and prompt,” Ignatius of Loyola reminded his Jesuit brothers a decade after their founding in 1540.1 By the turn of the seventeenth century, the incumbent Superior General Claudio Aquaviva had reiterated Loyola’s expectation of “blind obedience,” with specific regard to Jesuit support for the Catholic Church during the Galileo Affair.2 Interpreting the relationship between the Jesuits and Copernicans like Galileo Galilei through the frame of “blind obedience” reaffirms the conservative image of the Catholic Church – to which the Jesuits owed such obedience – as committed to its medieval traditions. In opposition to this perspective, I will argue that the Jesuits involved in the Galileo Affair3 represent the progressive ideas of the Church in the early seventeenth century. To prove this, I will argue that although the Jesuits rejected the epistemological claims of Copernicanism, they found it beneficial in its practical applications. The desire to solidify their status as the intellectual elites of the Church caused the Jesuits to reject Copernicanism in public. However, they promoted an intellectual environment in which Copernican studies – particularly those of Galileo – could develop with minimal opposition, theological or otherwise.
  • Debate Over Justification by Faith: Evangelicals and Catholics

    Debate Over Justification by Faith: Evangelicals and Catholics

    Journal of the Adventist Theological Society, 20:1-2 (2009):112-146. Article copyright © 2009 by Norman R. Gulley. Debate Over Justification by Faith: Evangelicals and Catholics Norman R. Gulley Southern Adventist University 1. Biblical Understanding of Justification by Faith Paul says “they are justified by his grace as a gift, through the redemption which is in Christ Jesus” (Rom 3:24, RSV), for “a man is justified by faith apart from works of the law” (Rom 3:28 RSV), with even faith a gift (Rom 10:17). Humans are “justified by his blood” (Rom 5:9, ESV). Calvary was the “one act of righteousness” which “leads to justification and life for all men” (Rom 5:18b, ESV). “God made him [Christ] who had no sin to be sin for us, so that in him we might become the righteousness of God” (2 Cor 5:21). Justification is found in Christ, and is received by faith. This has nothing to do with Christ’s faithfulness in the covenant which continues human membership in the covenant, as proposed by “New Perspectives on Paul” scholarship. Justification explains how one gets in (not how one stays in) the covenant. Justification is an entry level reality, having to do with how one is saved. The word justify in Hebrew (hitsdiq) and Greek (dikaioun) “never refer to the infusion of righteousness, that is the transformation of someone from being ungodly to being virtuous.” Justification is the same throughout humans’ history, in old and new covenant periods, because it is about the one eternal gospel (Rev 14:6).
  • Gallieo and the Catholic Church

    Gallieo and the Catholic Church

    Galileo and the Catholic Church PROF BOB DAVIS, DEPT OF RELIGIOUS EDUCATION Galileo and the Catholic Church • Narrating the Galileo Affair • Understanding the nature of the conflict between Galileo and the Church authorities • Understanding its sequel and its legacy for the interaction of science and religion • Beyond simple dichotomies and stereotypes GALILEO: A Life in Context • 1564-92: Early years • 1616: Condemnation in Padua & Florence of Copernicanism (law of pendulum & • 1616-23: Controversy falling bodies) with Grassi • 1592-1610: Padua/ • 1623-32: Wrote Venice years (a Dialogue Copernican by 1597); • 1633: 2nd Trial use of telescope 1609 • 1633-42: Last years • 1616: 1st Trial under house arrest 3 The Church and Heliocentrism: Pope Paul V and the condemnation of 1616 • initial ecclesiastical sponsorship of Copernicus and the New Science––tacit approval through the reigns of nine popes • Heliocentrism first denounced by Protestant reformers Luther and Melanchton on biblical grounds: the attack on Kepler • Galileo in Rome (1611)––the ‘ridicule of the mathematicians’ v ‘the curiosity of the teachers’ (Clavius) • After receiving counsel from several theologians on the orthodoxy of heliocentrism, the Congregation of the Index officially condemned Copernicanism in 1616 as “false and as completely contradictory to Divine Scriptures.” Endorsed by Paul V, but only ‘for the prevention of the circulation of writings’ and refusing to term it ‘heresy’. • Donec corrigatur––permission for those ‘learned and skilful in the science’ to go on
  • The Galileo Affair in Context: an Investigation of Influences on the Church During Galileo’S 1633 Trial

    The Galileo Affair in Context: an Investigation of Influences on the Church During Galileo’S 1633 Trial

    Xavier University Exhibit Honors Bachelor of Arts Undergraduate 2020-5 The Galileo Affair In Context: An Investigation of Influences on The Church During Galileo’s 1633 Trial Evan W. Lamping Xavier University, Cincinnati, OH Follow this and additional works at: https://www.exhibit.xavier.edu/hab Part of the Ancient History, Greek and Roman through Late Antiquity Commons, Ancient Philosophy Commons, Classical Archaeology and Art History Commons, Classical Literature and Philology Commons, and the Other Classics Commons Recommended Citation Lamping, Evan W., "The Galileo Affair In Context: An Investigation of Influences on The Church During Galileo’s 1633 Trial" (2020). Honors Bachelor of Arts. 45. https://www.exhibit.xavier.edu/hab/45 This Capstone/Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Undergraduate at Exhibit. It has been accepted for inclusion in Honors Bachelor of Arts by an authorized administrator of Exhibit. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Evan Lamping Dr. Byrne CPHAB Thesis The Galileo Affair In Context: An Investigation of Influences on The Church During Galileo’s 1633 Trial 1 I. Introduction When most people learn about the Galileo controversy of 1633, their knowledge of the affair is most commonly comprised of the facts of his condemnation on counts of heresy and possibly some other details about how and why his inquisition was conducted. These details are often simply concerned with the Church’s indefensible view of the earth as the center of the universe, combined with some scripture passages describing the sun as standing still or the earth being fixed in place and unmovable.
  • Maurice Finocchiaro Discusses the Lessons and the Cultural Repercussions of Galileo’S Telescopic Discoveries.” Physics World, Vol

    Maurice Finocchiaro Discusses the Lessons and the Cultural Repercussions of Galileo’S Telescopic Discoveries.” Physics World, Vol

    MAURICE A. FINOCCHIARO: CURRICULUM VITAE CONTENTS: §0. Summary and Highlights; §1. Miscellaneous Details; §2. Teaching Experience; §3. Major Awards and Honors; §4. Publications: Books; §5. Publications: Articles, Chapters, and Discussions; §6. Publications: Book Reviews; §7. Publications: Proceedings, Abstracts, Translations, Reprints, Popular Media, etc.; §8. Major Lectures at Scholarly Meetings: Keynote, Invited, Funded, Honorarium, etc.; §9. Other Lectures at Scholarly Meetings; §10. Public Lectures; §11. Research Activities: Out-of-Town Libraries, Archives, and Universities; §12. Professional Service: Journal Editorial Boards; §13. Professional Service: Refereeing; §14. Professional Service: Miscellaneous; §15. Community Service §0. SUMMARY AND HIGHLIGHTS Address: Department of Philosophy; University of Nevada, Las Vegas; Box 455028; Las Vegas, NV 89154-5028. Education: B.S., 1964, Massachusetts Institute of Technology; Ph.D., 1969, University of California, Berkeley. Position: Distinguished Professor of Philosophy, Emeritus; University of Nevada, Las Vegas. Previous Positions: UNLV: Assistant Professor, 1970-74; Associate Professor, 1974-77; Full Professor, 1977-91; Distinguished Professor, 1991-2003; Department Chair, 1989-2000. Major Awards and Honors: 1976-77 National Science Foundation; one-year grant; project “Galileo and the Art of Reasoning.” 1983-84 National Endowment for the Humanities, one-year Fellowship for College Teachers; project “Gramsci and the History of Dialectical Thought.” 1987 Delivered the Fourth Evert Willem Beth Lecture, sponsored by the Evert Willem Beth Foundation, a committee of the Royal Netherlands Academy of Sciences, at the Universities of Amsterdam and of Groningen. 1991-92 American Council of Learned Societies; one-year fellowship; project “Democratic Elitism in Mosca and Gramsci.” 1992-95 NEH; 3-year grant; project “Galileo on the World Systems.” 1993 State of Nevada, Board of Regents’ Researcher Award.
  • Francis De Sales, the Galileo Affair and Autonomy of Modern Science by Alexander T

    Francis De Sales, the Galileo Affair and Autonomy of Modern Science by Alexander T

    1 Francis de Sales, the Galileo Affair and Autonomy of Modern Science by Alexander T. Pocetto, OSFS (Paper Presented at the International Patristics, Medieval and Renaissance Conference, Villanova University, 1999) The perennial debate between science and religion appears to be heating up again, especially in the area of evolution where the conflict between the two has been the most pronounced and protracted. Richard Dawkins takes the position that science does not need religion or God to understand the origin and evolution of the universe, while Michael Behe sees the importance of an 'Intelligent Designer' as necessary for filling in a big gap in Darwinism.1 In a recent attempted rapprochement in this area, Pope John Paul II stated that he sees no inherent contradiction between the theory of evolution and Catholic teaching.2 It is not the intent of this study to argue for the complete autonomy of science in the sense of being totally unrelated to religion but rather to appreciate that they both can and should live in harmony. Religion, as one author has clearly, concisely, and persuasively demonstrated, can and should play a confirming role in its relationship to science.3 It is this confirming aspect of religion that will be emphasized. As an outstanding Christian humanist, Francis de Sales steeped himself in the knowledge of Sacred Scripture, the Fathers of the Church and the writers of classical antiquity and exhibited an openness to all genuine human values and achievements.4 The further one delves into the works of this saint, the more one becomes convinced, as Karl Rahner says, that "Christianity is the most radical anthropology."5 For de Sales, the Incarnation is absolutely indispensable to the meaning and understanding of human nature and its relation to the whole of creation since he views the universe as "a book which contains the word of God, but a language which each person does not understand."6 The more we grasp the implications of the Incarnation, the deeper will be our understanding of humanity, our world and the role of the physical sciences.
  • Volume 28, Number 2 Fall 2017

    Volume 28, Number 2 Fall 2017

    Volume 28, Number 2 Fall 2017 Homosexuality—An Abomination or Purely Irrelevant?: Evaluating LGBT Claims in Light of the Old Testament (Gen. 18–19; Lev. 18:22; 20:13) MICHAEL A. GRISANTI Is Same-Sex Marriage a Sin? BRYAN MURPHY The Pauline Response to Today’s Sexual and Gender Confusion BRAD KLASSEN WWJD about LGBT?: Evaluating LGBT Claims in Light of Christ’s Teaching MICHAEL RICCARDI Solus Christus and the Protestant Reformation of Europe JONATHAN MOORHEAD TMS.edu Volume 28 Fall 2017 Number 2 The Master’s Seminary Journal CONTENTS Guest Editorial ..................................................................................................... 111-13 F. David Farnell Homosexuality—An Abomination or Purely Irrelevant?: Evaluating LGBT Claims in Light of the Old Testament (Gen. 18–19; Lev. 18:22; 20:13) .......................................................................... 115-33 Michael A. Grisanti Is Same-Sex Marriage a Sin? .............................................................................. 135-44 Bryan Murphy The Pauline Response to Today’s Sexual and Gender Confusion ..................... 145-66 Brad Klassen WWJD about LGBT?: Evaluating LGBT Claims in Light of Christ’s Teaching ................................................................................................. 167-80 Michael Riccardi Solus Christus and the Protestant Reformation of Europe ................................. 181-200 Jonathan Moorhead Reviews ...............................................................................................................
  • Behind the Scenes at Galileo's Trial

    Behind the Scenes at Galileo's Trial

    Blackwell-000.FM 7/3/06 12:24 PM Page iii BEHIND THE SCENES AT GALILEO’S TRIAL Including the First English Translation of Melchior Inchofer’s Tractatus syllepticus RICHARD J. BLACKWELL University of Notre Dame Press Notre Dame, Indiana © 2006 University of Notre Dame Press Blackwell-000.FM 7/3/06 12:24 PM Page iv Copyright © 2006 University of Notre Dame Notre Dame, Indiana 46556 All Rights Reserved www.undpress.nd.edu Manufactured in the United States of America Behind the Scenes at Galileo’s Trial was designed by Jane Oslislo; composed in 10/13.3 Fairfield Light by Four Star Books; printed on 50# Nature’s Natural (50% pcr) by Thomson-Shore, Inc. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Blackwell, Richard J., 1929– Behind the scenes at Galileo’s trial : including the first English translation of Melchior Inchofer’s Tractatus syllepticus / Richard J. Blackwell. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and indexes. isbn-13: 978-0-268-02201-3 (acid-free paper) isbn-10: 0-268-02201-1 (acid-free paper) 1. Galilei, Galileo, 1564–1642—Trials, litigation, etc. 2. Religion and science— History—17th century. 3. Inchofer, Melchior, 1585?–1648. Tractatus syllepticus. 4. Catholic Church—Doctrines—History—17th century. 5. Inquisition—Italy. I. Inchofer, Melchior, 1585?–1648. Tractatus syllepticus. English. II. Title. qb36.g2b573 2006 520.92—dc22 2006016783 ∞The paper in this book meets the guidelines for permanence and durability of the Committee on Production Guidelines for Book Longevity of the Council on Library Resources. © 2006 University of Notre Dame Press Blackwell-01 5/18/06 10:01 PM Page 1 chapter one The Legal Case at Galileo’s Trial Impasse and Perfidy galileo’s trial before the roman inquisition is one of the most frequently mentioned topics in the history of science.
  • Galilæana Viii

    Galilæana Viii

    CORE Metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk Provided by Institutional Research Information System University of Turin BIBLIOTECA DI GALILÆANA VIII COPERNICUS BANNED The Entangled Matter of the anti-Copernican Decree of 1616 edited by Natacha Fabbri and Federica Favino LEO S. OLSCHKI EDITORE MMXVIII Tutti i diritti riservati Casa Editrice Leo S. Olschki Viuzzo del Pozzetto, 8 50126 Firenze www.olschki.it ISBN 978 88 222 6584 5 CONTENTS Introduction . Pag . VII Roberto Bondì, Dangerous Ideas: Telesio, Campanella and Galileo . » 1 Natacha Fabbri, Threats to the Christian Cosmos. The Reckless As- sault on the Heavens and the Debate over Hell . » 29 Franco Motta, Nature, Faith and the Judge of Faith. Some Consid- erations on the Historical-Political Context of Copernicus’ Con- demnation . » 57 Luigi Guerrini, The Archbishop and Astronomy. Alessandro Marzi- medici and the 1604 Supernova . » 101 Federica Favino, Alchemical Implication of 1616 Affaire. On the Par- ish Priest Attavanti, the Knight Ridolfi and the Cardinal Orsini . » 127 Giovanni Pizzorusso, Francesco Ingoli: Knowledge and Curial Ser- vice in 17th-century Rome . » 157 Édouard Mehl, Kepler’s second Copernican Campaign. The Search for an Annual Stellar Parallax after the Roman Decree (1616) . » 191 Rienk Vermij, Copernicanism and the Bible in the Dutch Republic around 1616: a non-debate . » 211 Steven Vanden Broecke, An Astrologer in the World-Systems Debate. Jean-Baptiste Morin on Astrology and Copernicanism (1631-1634) . » 223 Index of Names . » 243 — V — Franco Motta NATURE, FAITH AND THE JUDGE OF FAITH Some Considerations on the Historical-Political Context of Copernicus’ Condemnation 1. The denunciation of Galileo and the first examination of Coperni- canism by the Inquisition The dossier against Galileo that reached the desk of the Prefect of the Index, Cardinal Sfondrati, in February 1615 contains several interest- ing charges.
  • THE TRIAL of GALILEO-REVISITED Dr

    THE TRIAL of GALILEO-REVISITED Dr

    THE TRIAL OF GALILEO-REVISITED Dr. George DeRise Professor Emeritus, Mathematics Thomas Nelson Community College FALL 2018 Mon 1:30 PM- 3:30 PM, 6 sessions 10/22/2018 - 12/3/2018 (Class skip date 11/19) Sadler Center, Commonwealth Auditorium Christopher Wren Association BOOKS: THE TRIAL OF GALILEO, 1612-1633: Thomas F. Mayer. (Required) THE CASE FOR GALILEO- A CLOSED QUESTION? Fantoli, Annibale. GALILEO; THE RISE AND FALL OF A TROUBLESOME GENIUS. Shea, William; Artigas, Mariano. BASIC ONLINE SOURCES: Just Google: “Galileo” and “Galileo Affair” (WIKI) “Galileo Project” and “Trial of Galileo-Famous Trials” YOUTUBE MOVIES: Just Google: “GALILEO'S BATTLE FOR THE HEAVENS – NOVA – YOUTUBE” “GREAT BOOKS, GALILEO’S DIALOGUE – YOUTUBE” HANDOUTS: GLOSSARY CAST OF CHARACTERS BLUE DOCUMENTS GALILEO GALILEI: b. 1564 in Pisa, Italy Astronomer, Physicist, Mathematician Professor of Mathematics, Universities of Pisa and Padua. In 1610 he observed the heavens with the newly invented telescope- mountains and craters of the moon, moons of Jupiter, many stars never seen before; later the phases of Venus; sunspots. These observations supported his belief that the Copernican (Heliocentric) system was correct, i.e. that the Sun was the center of the Universe; the planets including earth revolved around it. This was in direct contrast to the Ptolemaic-Aristotelian (Geocentric) System which was 1500 years old at the time. Galileo’s Copernican view was also in conflict with the Christian interpretation of Holy Scripture. Because of the Counter Reformation Catholic theologians took a literal interpretation of the Bible. Galileo was investigated by the Inquisition in 1615 and warned not to defend the Copernican view.