Book Arthasastra-In-A-Trascultural

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Book Arthasastra-In-A-Trascultural The ArthaàÈstra in a Transcultural Perspective Comparing Kauäilya with Sun-Zi, Nizam al-Mulk, Barani and Machiavelli The ArthaàÈstra in a Transcultural Perspective Comparing Kauäilya with Sun-Zi, Nizam al-Mulk, Barani and Machiavelli Editors Michael Liebig Saurabh Mishra INSTITUTE FOR DEFENCE STUDIES & ANALYSES NEW DELHI PENTAGONPENTAGONPENTAGON PRESSPRESSPRESS The Arthaàästra in a Transcultural Perspective Comparing Kauäilya with Sun-Zi, Nizam al-Mulk, Barani and Machiavelli Editors: Michael Liebig and Saurabh Mishra First Published in 2017 Copyright © Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses, New Delhi ISBN 978-81-8274-938-2 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without first obtaining written permission of the copyright owner. Disclaimer: The views expressed in this book are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses, or the Government of India. Published by PENTAGON PRESS 206, Peacock Lane, Shahpur Jat, New Delhi-110049 Phones: 011-64706243, 26491568 Telefax: 011-26490600 email: [email protected] website: www.pentagonpress.in In association with Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses No. 1, Development Enclave, New Delhi-110010 Phone: +91-11-26717983 Website: www.idsa.in Printed at Avantika Printers Private Limited. Contents Preface vii Contributors ix 1. Introduction 1 Michael Liebig and Saurabh Mishra 2. Kauäilya Redux? Re-use, Hybridity, Trans-cultural Flow and Resilience of the State in India 31 Subrata K. Mitra 3. Understanding Kauäilya’s ArthaàÈstra: Origination, Migration and Diffusion 68 Pradeep Kumar Gautam 4. Kauäilya and Machiavelli in a Comparative Perspective 113 Michael Liebig 5. ArthaàÈstra: Reflections on Thought and Theory 172 Medha Bisht 6. RÈjadharma, Legitimacy and Sovereignty in the ArthaàÈstra 195 Saurabh Mishra 7. Kauäilya and Sun-Zi: Comparative Philosophical Analysis 222 M.S. Prathibha vi The ArthaàÈstra in a Transcultural Perspective 8. FatÈwÈ-ye jahÈndÈri: Hybrid Political Theory in the Delhi Sultanate (Perso-Islamic and Endogenous Traditions of Statecraft in India) 241 Seyed Hossein Zarhani References 264 Index 286 Preface This edited volume continues the series of publications of the Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (IDSA) that address the pre-modern Indian political theorist Kauäilya and the relevance of his thought for contemporary strategic thinking and practice. The three conferences on Kauäilya’s ArthaàÈstra organised by IDSA since 2012 are documented in three edited volumes.* These contain analyses of the core ideas and concepts of Kauäilya’s ArthaàÈstra and investigate their relevance for India’s strategic culture. This particular volume takes us a step further by situating Kauäilyan thought in a comparative perspective. That means, first, taking a trans-temporal, mainly intra-cultural perspective on the significance of Kauäilyan thought for the evolution of India’s political institutions and practices. Here, the concepts of intra and trans-cultural hybridity, and the ‘re-use of the past’ are key. In addition, a comparative perspective involves correlating Kauäilya to pre-modern political thinkers of other civilisational spaces and historical contexts, such as Sun Tzu, Ziauddin Barani, Niccolo Machiavelli, and Nizam-ul-Mulk. The impulse for these publications came from a brainstorming in spring 2014, when a group of researchers from IDSA and the South Asia Institute (SAI), University of Heidelberg, met in New Delhi. They shared the view that the academic evaluation of the core concepts of Kauäilya’s ArthaàÈstra – and their contemporary relevance – remain inadequate, and devoid of a comparative dimension. As a result, two trilateral workshops were held: one in May 2015 at IDSA in New Delhi, and another in February 2016 at ISAS in Singapore – the latter titled ‘Evolution of the Modern State in India: Comparing Kauäilya, Machiavelli, Nizam-ul-Mulk, Barani and Sun-Tzu.’ Meanwhile, Prof. Subrata *Gautam, P.K. / Mishra, S. / Gupta, A. (Eds.) (2015, 2016a/b): Indigenous Historical Knowledge – Kautilya and his Vocabulary, vols. I, II, III. New Delhi: Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses/Pentagon Press. viii The ArthaàÈstra in a Transcultural Perspective Mitra moved from Heidelberg to the Institute of South Asia Studies (ISAS), National University of Singapore. The project has been enriched by the researchers and their research subjects drawn from different cultural and national traditions. The research results presented at the workshops are both interesting and novel – offering fresh insights into the evolution of the science of politics, statecraft, and inter-state relations. We are delighted that these research findings are being shared with a wider audience. Jayant Prasad Subrata Mitra Director General, IDSA Director ISAS, NUS Contributors Col. Pradeep Kumar Gautam (Retd.) is currently a Research Fellow in the Military Affairs Centre at the Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (IDSA), New Delhi, India. Dr. M. S. Prathibha is currently an Associate Fellow in the East Asia Centre at the Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (IDSA), New Delhi, India. Dr. Medha Bisht is an Assistant Professor in the Department of International Relations at the South Asian University, New Delhi, India. Dr. Michael Liebig is a Fellow and Lecturer at the South Asia Institute, Heidelberg University, Germany. Dr. Saurabh Mishra is a Research Assistant at the Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (IDSA), New Delhi, India. Dr. Seyed Hossein Zarhani is a Fellow and Lecturer at the South Asia Institute, Heidelberg University, Germany. Prof. Subrata K. Mitra is the Director of Institute of South Asian Studies, National University of Singapore, Singapore. 1 Introduction Michael Liebig and Saurabh Mishra In writing this introduction, we have to take a somewhat bigger sweep. This edited volume is already the fifth in a series of books published by the Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (IDSA) that are addressing Kauäilyan thought and its contemporary relevance.1 This volume, however, is the first in the series that has an international character right from the beginning – both with respect to the researchers involved and its subject area – looking at Kauäilya’s ArthaàÈstra in a comparative, transcultural perspective. Yet, it needs to be emphasised that it was a long way until the ‘comparative moment’ was reached. The contents of this edited volume are derived from two workshops on Kauäilyan thought – one in May 2015 at the IDSA in New Delhi and the other one in February 2016 at the Institute of South Asian Studies (ISAS), National University of Singapore. However, the genesis of this book goes back to 2012, when a group of Political Science researchers from India and Germany2 came to the conclusion that the idea-contents of Kauäilya’s ArthaàÈstra are far too important for Political Science – political theory, International Relations (IR) theory, Security Studies and Intelligence Studies – as to be solely left to Sanskrit philologists. Unquestionably, Indology has done most valuable scholarly work on the ArthaàÈstra – including making it accessible to the social sciences. But we thought that a fresh approach was overdue that situated Kauäilyan thought firmly in a Political Science frame. After all, the ArthaàÈstra deals with political theory and theorised statecraft and Kauäilya himself calls it a work of ‘Political Science’. We felt that we should work with respect to Kauäilya’s ArthaàÈstra 2 The ArthaàÈstra in a Transcultural Perspective in a directionality that somewhat paralleled that of Amrita and Aruna Narlikar with respect to the MahÈbhÈrata.3 We had, still somewhat vaguely, three research areas in mind: (a) Exploring the relevance of Kauäilyan ideas and concepts for the present – that is, the foreign and domestic policies of post-independence India. (b) The interpretive explication of the central ideas and concepts of Kauäilya’s ArthaàÈstra with respect to its domestic and foreign policy dimension. (c) Exploring the significance of Kauäilya for the genealogy of political thought and the evolution of Political Science and IR theory. Back in 2012/13, the focus of our research had been the relevance of Kauäilyan thought for present-day India.4 What influence, if any, does Kauäilyan thought have on post-independence India’s institutional evolution and political culture as well as on Indian strategic culture? Through expert interviews and the (content) analysis of contemporary political and strategic texts, our research finding was rather clear-cut: Yes, Kauäilyan thought-figures are a significant ideational ingredient of modern India’s politico-strategic culture. This applies to the manifest influence of Kauäilyan thought via the conscious and deliberate ‘re-use of the past’ (Mitra) in addressing contemporary challenges by politico- strategic actors – embedded in India’s paradigm of the ‘modernity of tradition’.5 Equally significant is the latent influence of Kauäilyan thought within the ‘habitus’ (Bourdieu) of political and strategic actors as well as within ‘popular politicising’.6 Subrata K. Mitra’s article in this volume provides the theoretical entrée to the question of the relevance of Kauäilyan thought for modern India’s political institutions and behaviour. However, we quickly came to a second and quite sobering finding – the
Recommended publications
  • Philologischer Kommentar Zur Kritischen Edition Des Moks.Op¯Aya
    Philologischer Kommentar zur kritischen Edition des Moks.opaya¯ iv. Sthitiprakaran. a bearbeitet von Martin Straube Stand: 23. Januar 2012 purv¯ aparavic¯ ar¯ arh¯ a¯ ´semus.¯ı kva gata¯ tava ? (iv.26.2) Vorwort Der vorliegende Kommentar ist philologischer Natur. Er soll in Form eines Stellenkom- mentars Rechenschaft geben über die Kriterien für die Entscheidungsfindung bei der Textkonstitution und diese absichern sowie Hinweise zur Syntax und Grammatik, zum Kontext, zu Parallelen innerhalb und außerhalb des Moks.opaya¯ und weiterführender Literatur in übersichtlicher Form zur Verfügung stellen. Mit dem Symbol K erfolgt ein Verweis auf einen Eintrag innerhalb des philologi- schen Kommentars. Textpassagen aus dem Moks.opaya¯ werden im Falle der Prakaran. as i–iv in der Form des edierten Textes zitiert, wobei auf die Angabe von Lesarten im allgemeinen verzichtet wird. Die bislang erst teilweise (v) bzw. noch nicht edierten (vi) Prakaran. as v und vi liegen in Abschriften einzelner Handschriften vor, die zum Teil durch Kollationen anderer Handschriften ergänzt sind. Dementsprechend handelt es sich bei Zitaten aus diesen Teilen des Moks.opaya¯ stets um vorläufig und unsicher erstellte Texte. Zitaten und Belegstellen aus dem vi. Prakaran. a wurden an Stellen, an denen dies hilfreich schien, die entsprechende Stellenangaben des Yoga- vasi¯ s.t.ha (Pan. s´¯ikar 1937) hinzugefügt; hierbei wird der „Purv¯ ardha“¯ mit vi und der „Uttarardha“¯ mit vii gezählt. Deutsche Wiedergaben bereits edierter Passagen des Moks.opaya¯ stammen zumeist aus der die kritische Edition begleitenden Übersetzung von Dr. Roland Steiner und sind in diesem Fall mit „R. S.“ bezeichnet; alle nicht gekennzeichneten Übersetzungen stammen vom Autor des vorliegenden Kommentars.
    [Show full text]
  • Mah Tir, Mah Bahman & Asfandarmad 1 Mah Asfandarmad 1369
    Mah Tir, Mah Bahman & Asfandarmad 1 Mah Asfandarmad 1369, Fravardin & l FEZAN A IN S I D E T HJ S I S S U E Federation of Zoroastrian • Summer 2000, Tabestal1 1369 YZ • Associations of North America http://www.fezana.org PRESIDENT: Framroze K. Patel 3 Editorial - Pallan R. Ichaporia 9 South Circle, Woodbridge, NJ 07095 (732) 634-8585, (732) 636-5957 (F) 4 From the President - Framroze K. Patel president@ fezana. org 5 FEZANA Update 6 On the North American Scene FEZ ANA 10 Coming Events (World Congress 2000) Jr ([]) UJIR<J~ AIL '14 Interfaith PUBLICATION OF THE FEDERATION OF ZOROASTRIAN ASSOCIATIONS OF '15 Around the World NORTH AMERICA 20 A Millennium Gift - Four New Agiaries in Mumbai CHAIRPERSON: Khorshed Jungalwala Rohinton M. Rivetna 53 Firecut Lane, Sudbury, MA 01776 Cover Story: (978) 443-6858, (978) 440-8370 (F) 22 kayj@ ziplink.net Honoring our Past: History of Iran, from Legendary Times EDITOR-IN-CHIEF: Roshan Rivetna 5750 S. Jackson St. Hinsdale, IL 60521 through the Sasanian Empire (630) 325-5383, (630) 734-1579 (F) Guest Editor Pallan R. Ichaporia ri vetna@ lucent. com 23 A Place in World History MILESTONES/ ANNOUNCEMENTS Roshan Rivetna with Pallan R. Ichaporia Mahrukh Motafram 33 Legendary History of the Peshdadians - Pallan R. Ichaporia 2390 Chanticleer, Brookfield, WI 53045 (414) 821-5296, [email protected] 35 Jamshid, History or Myth? - Pen1in J. Mist1y EDITORS 37 The Kayanian Dynasty - Pallan R. Ichaporia Adel Engineer, Dolly Malva, Jamshed Udvadia 40 The Persian Empire of the Achaemenians Pallan R. Ichaporia YOUTHFULLY SPEAKING: Nenshad Bardoliwalla 47 The Parthian Empire - Rashna P.
    [Show full text]
  • INDIAN FICTION – Classical Period Stuart Blackburn, Ph.D
    INDIAN FICTION – Classical Period Stuart Blackburn, Ph.D. Overview ‘Moral story’ Short didactic tales known as nithi katha (‘moral story’) are generally in prose, although sometimes the ‘lesson’ itself is in verse. Nearly all these numerous stories began as oral tales before being collected and written down in manuscripts by scribes and scholars. The collections often use what is called a ‘frame-story’ to give a narrative coherence to the otherwise disparate tales. These originally oral tales were collected and redacted in manuscript form sometime in the early centuries of the Common Era. Some were composed in Pali, but most were in Sanskrit, although all were eventually written down in every Indian language. Oral tales Nearly every genre of ancient and classical Indian literature, from the Vedic hymns to the great epics, is founded on oral tradition and then mediated, and usually altered, through scribes and manuscripts. In the case of the collections of classical fiction, however, we see a more transparent process in which oral tradition was more completely replicated in written manuscripts. We cannot overstate the popularity and longevity of oral storytelling in India, nor can we put a date on it. We can only assume that the oral stories found in these classical story collections draw upon tales that, even by the time they were committed to writing in the 6th c. CE, were already hundreds of years old. Pancatantra Contents The Pancatantra (‘Five-Books’) is a collection of nearly 100 animal fables. The frame-story is that a pundit instructs three ignorant princes in the art of statecraft, using these moral stories as lessons.
    [Show full text]
  • A Comparative Analysis of Educational Teaching in Shahnameh and Iliad Elhamshahverdi and Dr.Masoodsepahvandi Abstract
    Date:12/1/18 A Comparative Analysis of Educational Teaching in Shahnameh and Iliad Elhamshahverdi and dr.Masoodsepahvandi Abstract Ferdowsi's Shahnameh and Homer's Iliad are among the first literary masterpieces of Iran and Greece. These teachings include the educational teachings of Zal and Roudabeh, and Paris and Helen. This paper presents a comparative look at the immortal effect of this Iranian poet with Homer's poem-- the Greek blind poet. In this comparison, using a content analysis method, the effects of the educational teachings of these two stories are extracted and expressed, The results of this study show that the human and universal educational teachings of Shahnameh are far more than that of Homer's Iliad. Keywords: teachings, education,analysis,Shahname,Iliad. Introduction The literature of every nation is a mirror of the entirety of thought, culture and customs of that nation, which can be expressed in elegance and artistic delicacy in many different ways. Shahnameh and Iliad both represent the literature of the two peoples of Iran and Greece, which contain moral values for the happiness of the individual and society. "The most obvious points of Shahnameh are its advice and many examples and moral commands. To do this, Ferdowsi has taken every opportunity and has made every event an excuse. Even kings and warriors are used for this purpose. "Comparative literature is also an important foundation for the exodus of indigenous literature from isolation, and it will be a part of the entire literary heritage of the world, exposed to thoughts and ideas, and is also capable of helping to identify contemplation legacies in the understanding and friendship of the various nations."(Ghanimi, 44: 1994) Epic literature includes poems that have a spiritual aspect, not an individual one.
    [Show full text]
  • YB DEC 06.Pmd
    YUVA BHARATI DECEMBER 2006 YUVA BHARATI Vol. 34 No.5 A Vivekananda Kendra Publication VOICE OF YOUTH 02 Prarthana Founder Editor P.Parameswaran MANANEEYA EKNATHJI RANADE 09 This years Kendra Samachar Editor:SHRI P. PARAMESWARAN 11 The Special events of the year Editorial Office: 5, Singarachari Street 12 Vivekananda Kendra Institute of Culture Triplicane, Chennai - 600 005 Ph:(044) 28440042 16 Vivekananda Kendra Natural Resources Email:[email protected] 17 Rural Development Programmes in T.N Web: www.vkendra.org 18 Vivekananda Kendra Vidyalayas SingleCopy Rs. 7/- Annual Rs. 75/- 24 Other events of the Vidyalayas For 3 yrs: Rs. 200/- Life(20Yrs) Rs. 800/- 28 V.K. Rural Welfare Project, Khatkati (Plus Rs. 30/- for outstation 39 An Appeal Cheques) They alone live who live for others, the rest are more dead than alive. -- Swami Vivekananda This Yuva Bharati is being sent to all Patrons of Vivekananda Kendra as Vivekananda Kendra Samachar titled as PRARTHANA. All Patrons are requested to enroll themselves as Subscribers of Yuva Bharati and other magazines of the Kendra. YUVA BHARATI DECEMBER 2006 PRARTHANA (Thoughts on Prayer) he Kendra Prayer is the soul force behind every Kendra worker. It is chanted every day as a part of Sadhana with total surrender and Tdedication. The Divine inspiration and the spiritual energy that emanates from the prayer enable and equip the worker to carry on the allotted work all through his life without the least expectation of any reward in any form whatsoever. It is this cumulative strength of collective prayer that sustains the purity, ability and strength of the organisation.
    [Show full text]
  • New Arrival in Academy Library
    New Arrival in Academy Library SL Name of Books Authors Name 1 The Book of Five Rings Miyamoto Musashi 2 The Creator's Code Amy Wilkinson 3 Kanthapura Raja Rao 4 Gods, Kings and Slaves R. Venketesh 5 Untouchable Mulk Raj Anand 6 Heart of Darkness Joseph Conrad 7 Make Your Bed William H. Mcraven 8 Give and Take Adam Grant 9 The Guns of August Barbara Tuchman 10 The Craft of Intelligence Allen W. Dulles 11 Parties and Electoral Politics In Northeast India V. Bijukumar 12 The ISI of Pakistan : Faith, Unity, Discipline Hein G. Kiessling 13 China's India War Bertil Lintner 14 The China Pakistan Axis Andrew Small The Hard Thing About Hard Things : Builing A Business When There Are No 15 Easy Answers Ben Horowitz 16 Great Game East Bertil Lintner 17 Ashtanga Yoga John Scott 18 1962 : The war that wasn't Shiv Kunal Verma 19 Sins of Gods : Warriors of Dharma Dr. Chandraanshu 20 Legal And Professional Writing And Drafting In Plain Language Dr. K. R. Chandratre 21 Line on Fire Happymon Jacob 22 Mocktails : Recipe Book Vivian Miller 23 An End To Suffering: The Buddha In The World Pankaj Mishra 24 The Seventy Great Mysteries of The Ancient World Brian M. Fagan 25 Dragon on Our Doorstep Pravin Sawhney ,Ghazala 26 A Handful of Sesame Shrinivas Vaidya , MKarnoor 27 The Biology of Belief Bruce H. Lipton 28 Hkkjr % usg: ds ckn jkepUnz xqgk 29 Indian Polity : For Civil Services Examinations M Laxmikanth 30 India Super Goods : Change The Way You Eat Rujuta Diwekar 31 A Book For Government Officials To Master: Noting And Drafting M.K.
    [Show full text]
  • An Analysis of the Vānarinda Jātaka
    THE PROMISE OF INTERPRETATION: AN ANALYSIS OF THE VĀNARINDA JĀTAKA by VISHMA KUNU (Under the Direction of Glenn Wallis) ABSTRACT My contention is that the Vānarinda Jātaka (VJ) is a specifically Buddhist narrative, being a strategic reworking of situations and characters common to Indian oral tradition. By way of a fluid, triple-layered construct that is experimental in nature, I support this claim by exploring the interpretive possibilities of the text. Chapter one functions as a philological groundwork, and is a translation of the Pāli text that highlights terminology with distinctive resonances in the Buddhist tradition. The second chapter reveals the ways in which the VJ is marked by generality, drawing out pan-Indian elements through an examination against excerpts from the Pañcatantra, considered nīti literature, and the Sundarakāa in Vālmīki’s Rāmāyaa, a Hindu work, all having pre-literate roots. In the third chapter, I offer a creative explication of the VJ, bringing to light the abundance of Buddhist allusions, and doctrinal references embedded within the narrative. INDEX WORDS: Jātaka, Pāli canon, Gāthā, Buddhist narratives, Indian oral tradition, Hanumān, Pañcatantra THE PROMISE OF INTERPRETATION: AN ANALYSIS OF THE VĀNARINDA JĀTAKA by VISHMA KUNU B.A., University at Albany, State University of New York, 2000 A Thesis Submitted to the Graduate Faculty of The University of Georgia in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree MASTER OF ARTS ATHENS, GEORGIA 2004 © 2004 Vishma Kunu All Rights Reserved THE PROMISE OF INTERPRETATION: AN ANALYSIS OF THE VĀNARINDA JĀTAKA by VISHMA KUNU Major Professor: Glenn Wallis Committee: Dorothy Figueira Carolyn Medine Electronic Version Approved: Maureen Grasso Dean of the Graduate School The University of Georgia May 2004 DEDICATION For my grandmother, Jessodra Tiwary, who never read a single word with her eyes.
    [Show full text]
  • Organizing, Staffing, Leading, Controlling and Motivation
    Organization & Management Organization and Management follows the Market Analysis. This section should include: your company's organizational structure, details about the ownership of your company, profiles of your management team, and the qualifications of your board of directors. Who does what in your business? What is their background and why are you bringing them into the business as board members or employees? What are they responsible for? These may seem like unnecessary questions to answer in a one- or two-person organization, but the people reading your business plan want to know who's in charge, so tell them. Give a detailed description of each division or department and its function. This section should include who's on the board (if you have an advisory board) and how you intend to keep them there. What kind of salary and benefits package do you have for your people? What incentives are you offering? How about promotions? Reassure your reader that the people you have on staff are more than just names on a letterhead. Organizational Structure A simple but effective way to lay out the structure of your company is to create an organizational chart with a narrative description. This will prove that you're leaving nothing to chance, you've thought out exactly who is doing what, and there is someone in charge of every function of your company. Nothing will fall through the cracks, and nothing will be done three or four times over. To a potential investor or employee, that is very important. Ownership Information This section should also include the legal structure of your business along with the subsequent ownership information it relates to.
    [Show full text]
  • Roman Tymoshevskyi the Discourse of Kingship in John Gower's And
    Roman Tymoshevskyi The Discourse of Kingship in John Gower’s and Thomas Hoccleve’s Mirrors of Princes MA Thesis in Comparative History, with a specialization in Late Antique, Medieval, and Renaissance Studies. Central European University Budapest May 2019 CEU eTD Collection The Discourse of Kingship in John Gower’s and Thomas Hoccleve’s Mirrors of Princes by Roman Tymoshevskyi (Ukraine) Thesis submitted to the Department of Medieval Studies, Central European University, Budapest, in partial fulfillment of the requirements of the Master of Arts degree in Comparative History, with a specialization in Late Antique, Medieval, and Renaissance Studies. Accepted in conformance with the standards of the CEU. ____________________________________________ Chair, Examination Committee ____________________________________________ Thesis Supervisor ____________________________________________ Examiner ____________________________________________ CEU eTD Collection Examiner Budapest Month YYYY The Discourse of Kingship in John Gower’s and Thomas Hoccleve’s Mirrors of Princes by Roman Tymoshevskyi (Ukraine) Thesis submitted to the Department of Medieval Studies, Central European University, Budapest, in partial fulfillment of the requirements of the Master of Arts degree in Comparative History, with a specialization in Late Antique, Medieval, and Renaissance Studies. Accepted in conformance with the standards of the CEU. ____________________________________________ External Reader Budapest CEU eTD Collection May 2019 The Discourse of Kingship in John Gower’s and Thomas Hoccleve’s Mirrors of Princes by Roman Tymoshevskyi (Ukraine) Thesis submitted to the Department of Medieval Studies, Central European University, Budapest, in partial fulfillment of the requirements of the Master of Arts degree in Comparative History, with a specialization in Late Antique, Medieval, and Renaissance Studies. Accepted in conformance with the standards of the CEU.
    [Show full text]
  • View Our Extensive Collection, and Allow Us to Assist You in Building Your Own Private Collection of Fine and Rare Books
    We invite you to visit us at our new location in Palm Beach, Florida, view our extensive collection, and allow us to assist you in building your own private collection of fine and rare books. OUR GUARANTEE All items are fully guaranteed and can be returned within ten days. We accept all major credit cards and offer free domestic shipping and free worldwide shipping on orders over $500 for single item orders. A wide range of rushed shipping options are also available at cost. Each purchase is expertly packaged to ensure safe arrival and free gift wrapping services are available upon request. FOR THE COLLECTION OF A LIFETIME The process of creating one’s personal library is the pursuit of a lifetime. It requires special thought and consideration. Each book represents a piece of history, and it is a remarkable task to assemble these individual items into a collection. Our aim at Raptis Rare Books is to render tailored, individualized service to help you achieve your goals. We specialize in working with private collectors with a specific wish list, helping individuals find the ideal gift for special occasions, and partnering with representatives of institutions. We are here to assist you in your pursuit. Thank you for letting us be your guide in bringing the library of your imagination to reality. 561-508-3479 | 1-800-rare-book (1-800-727-3266) | [email protected] www.RaptisRareBooks.com 2 Contents Featured Antiquarian Books..................................................................4 Literature.............................................................................................12
    [Show full text]
  • A MUSLIM MISSIONARY in MEDIAEVAL KASHMIR a MUSLIM MISSIONARY in MEDIAEVAL KASHMIR (Being the English Translation of Tohfatuíl-Ahbab)
    A MUSLIM MISSIONARY IN MEDIAEVAL KASHMIR A MUSLIM MISSIONARY IN MEDIAEVAL KASHMIR (Being the English translation of Tohfatuíl-Ahbab) by Muhammad Ali Kashmiri English translation and annotations by KASHINATH PANDIT ASIAN-EURASIAN HUMAN RIGHTS FORUM New Delhi iv / ATRAVAILS MUSLIM MISSIONARYOF A KASHMIR IN FREEDOMMEDIAEVAL FIGHTER KASHMIR This book is the English translation of a Farsi manuscript, Tohfatuíl- Ahbab, persumably written in AD 1640. A transcript copy of the manuscript exists in the Research and Publications Department of Jammu and Kashmir State under Accession Number 551. © KASHINATH PANDIT First Published 2009 Price: Rs. 400.00 Published by Eurasian Human Rights Forum, E-241, Sarita Vihar, New Delhi ñ 110 076 (INDIA). website: www.world-citizenship.org Printed at Salasar Imaging Systems, C-7/5, Lawrence Road Indl. Area, Delhi ñ 110 035. INTRODUCTIONCONTENTS //v v For the historians writing on Mediaeval India vi / ATRAVAILS MUSLIM MISSIONARYOF A KASHMIR IN FREEDOMMEDIAEVAL FIGHTER KASHMIR INTRODUCTIONCONTENTS / vii Contents Acknowledgement ix Introduction xi-lxxx Chapter I. Araki and Nurbakhshi Preceptors 1-65 Chapter II. Arakiís first Visit to Kashmir: His Miracles, Kashmiris, and Arakiís Return 66-148 Chapter III. Arakiís Return to Iran 149-192 Part I: Acrimony of the people of Khurasan towards Shah Qasim 149-161 Part II: In service of Shah Qasim 161-178 Part III: To Kashmir 178-192 Chapter IV. Mission in Kashmir 193-278 Part I: Stewardship of Hamadaniyyeh hospice 193-209 Part II: Arakiís mission of destroying idols and temples of infidels 209-278 Chapter V. Arakiís Munificence 279-283 Index 284-291 viii / ATRAVAILS MUSLIM MISSIONARYOF A KASHMIR IN FREEDOMMEDIAEVAL FIGHTER KASHMIR INTRODUCTIONCONTENTS /ix/ ix 1 Acknowledgement I am thankful to Dr.
    [Show full text]
  • Russian Coal Mining in Svalbard
    Russian Coal Mining in Svalbard An Examination of Sovereignty and Arctic Cooperation Group 25 Narin Zimbalista, Luna Persson, Zoe Svendsen & Julie Sejr Reventlow Characters: 141595 1 1. Introduction 4 Research Question 7 Supporting Questions 7 Research Design 7 2. Background Information 8 2.1 A Brief History of Svalbard 8 2.1.1 Mining as a Settlement Builder 9 2.1.2. Russian and Norwegian interests in Svalbard 10 2.2 Geopolitical Context in the Arctic 11 2.2.1 Russian conduct in the Arctic 12 2.2.2 Barents Sea Dispute 13 3. Literature Review 15 3.1 An overview of the Arctic conflict 15 3.2 Theoretical Considerations within the literature 17 3.3 Russia in the Arctic 18 3.4 Svalbard and the Russian Presence 19 3.5 Concluding Considerations 20 4. Theoretical Framework 22 4.1 Realism 22 4.1.1 Economic Nationalism 24 4.2 Constructivism 26 4.3 Main theoretical deductions 28 5. Methodology 31 5.1 Philosophy of Science 31 5.1.1 Realism 31 5.1.2 Constructivism 33 5.2 Methods 34 5.2.1 Content analysis 34 5.2.2 Documents as data 37 5.3 Results 39 5.3.1 - Thematic Coding Results 39 5.3.2 Summarizing Qualitative Content Analysis Results 42 6. Analysis 46 6.1 How is Russia utilizing coal mining in Svalbard to project influence? 46 6.2 How has the Svalbard Treaty and the UNCLOS constructed norms and rules that have affected the contemporary jurisdiction of Svalbard? 51 2 6.3 How can Realism and Constructivism offer insight to Russian and Norwegian behaviour in Svalbard? 55 7.
    [Show full text]