Lok Sabha Debates

F«rifc M m, V«t D t-N fc t 1 MMNBJyilaoJM ROIMBII 19| 19V/ *T5ffiTBnensa5r

LOK SABHA DEBATES

(TUN flMrtoa)

(Vol IX contains Nos 1 to io>)

LOK SABHA SKBSTABUT NEW DKUB ' M e t: Re. 1.00 CONTENTS

(Fourth Series, Vol. IX—3 r d Session , 1967]

No. 1—Monday, November 13, 19611 Kart Ika 22,1889 (Saka)

C o l u m n s Alphabetical list of Members .. (i)—(nil) Officers of the Lok Sabha (ix) Government of^India—Ministers, Ministers of State, ctc. <*)— (xi) Member Sworn ...... 1 Obituary References .... 1—30 Shrimati Indira Gandhi . . 3— 5 Shri Ranga ...... S—7 Shri Atal Bihan Vajpayee 7—9 Shri Manoharan 9— 10 Shn Yogendra Sharma 10—13 Shri Madhu Limayc 13—19 Shn A. K. Gopalan 19—20 Shri Surendranath Dwivedy ...... 20—22 Shri Frank Anthony .... 22—23 Shri N. C. Chatterjce 23—24 Shri Prakash Vir Shastri 24— 27 Shn Ram Sewak Yadav . . . . 27—30 ALPHABETICAL LIST OF MEMBERS

FOURTH LOK SABHA

‘A’ Bannerji, Shn S. M. (Kanpur). Bansh Narain Singh, Shri (Mirzapur). Abraham. Shri K. M. (Kottayam). Barrow, Shri A. E T. (Nominated— Achal Singh, Seth (Agra). Anglo-Indian). Adichan. Shri P. C. (Adoor). Barua, Shri Bedabrata (Kaliabor). Aga. Sycd Ahmad (Baramulla). Barua, Shn Hem (Mangaldai). Agadi, Shr, S. A (Koppal). Barua. Shri Rajendranath (Jorhat). Ahirwar, Shri Nathu Ram ("rikam- Barupal. Shri P. L. (Ganganagar). parh) Basi, Shri Sohan Singh (Ferozepur). Ahmad. Shri Alhaj J. (tiindih). Basu, Shri Jyotirmoy (Diamond Ahmed, Shn F. A (Barpcta). Harbour). Ahmed. Shri Jahan Uddin (Dhuhri). Ba-u, Dr. Maiireyee (Darjeeling). Aim:. Shn Debananda (Sundargarh) Basuant, Shri Sonbubhau (Bhiwandi). Amcrscy, Shri Manubhai (Banas- Behera, Shn Baidhar (Jaipur). Kantha) Berwa. Shri Onkar Lai (Kota). Amin Prof. R. k. (Dhandhuka). Bewa. Shrt Sa'ya Charan (Dumka). Amin Shn Rjmchandra (Mehsana). Bhadona, Shn Arjun Singh (Etawah) Anb.i/hagan, Shri K.. (Tinichcngode) Bhagaban Das, Shri (Ausgram). Anbuchezhian, Shn N (Dindigul) Bhagat, Shn Bali Ram (Shahabad) An:nidhan, Shri K (Chirayinkil). Bhdgavali, Shri B. (Tezpur). Anjanappa. Shri B (Ncllore) Bhakt Darshan, Shn (Garhwal). Ankmeedu. Shn Mangati (Gudivada) Bhandare. Prof R D (Bombay Cen Anthony. Shri Frank (Nominated— tral). Anglo-Indians). Bhanu Prakash Singh. Shn (Sidhi). Arumugam. Shri R. S (Tcnkav). Bhargas.i. Shri Bashweshuar Nath Asghar Husain, Shn K. M. (Akol.i) (Ajmer) Atamda*, Shri (Morcna). Bharati, Shn M.tharaj Singh (Meerut). \uadcsh Chandra Singh. Shn fF.irru- Bhattacharyva. Shn Chapalatanta khabad) (R.upanj) Ayarwal. Shn Ram Singh (bagar). Bhol.i Nath Master. Shri (Alwar). A?ad. .Shri Bhagwai Jha (Bhagalpur). Bhonsalc. Maharam Vijayamala Raja ram C'hhatrapati (Ha'kanangale). Bula. Shri R.tdha Knshan (Jhun- ‘B’ jhunu). Bahu Nath Singh. Shri (Surguja). Birua. Shn Kolat (Singhbum). Badrudduja, Sycd (Murshnlabad). Bist. Shri Jang Bahadur Singh Bajaj. Shn Kamalnayan Jamnnlal (Almora). (Wardha). Bis*as, Shn Jitendra Mohan (Ban- Bajpai, Shn Shashibhushan (Khargonc). kura). Bajpai, Shn Vidya Dhar (Amethi). Bohra, Shn Onkarlal (Chittorgarh). Bakshi Ghulam Mohammad, Shn Bose, Shn Araiya Nath (Arambagh). (Srinagar). Brahm Perkash, Shri (Outer Delhi). Balarama Raju, Shn Datla (Naraspur). Brahma, Shri Rupnath (Koknjhar). («)

Brahmanand. Swami (Hamirpur). Deo. Shri K. P. Singh (Dhenkanal). Brij Bhushan Lai. Shri (Bareilly). Deo, Shri Pratap Keshari (Kala- Brijendra Singh. H.H. Maharaja handi). (Bharatpur). Deo, Shri Raj Raj Singh (Bolangir). Brijraj Singh—Kotah. Shri (Jhala- Deoghare, Shri Narendra Ramchandra- war). ji (Nagpur). Buta Singh. Shn (Rupar). Dcsai, Shri C. C. (Sabarkantha). Desai. Shn Dinkar (Kanara). •C’ Dcsai. Shri Morarji (Surat). Dcshmukh. Shri B. D. (Aurangabad). Chakrapam. Shri C' K. (Ponnani). Dcshmukh, Shri K. G. (Amravati). Chanda. Shri Anil Kumar (Bholpur). Deshmukh, Shri Shivajirao Shankar- Chanda. Shrimati Jyotsna (Cachar) rao (Parbhani). Chandra Sckhar Singh. Shri (Jehana- Dcvendra Vijay Singh. Shn (Satna). bad). Dcvgun, Shri Hardayal (East Delhi). C'handrika Prasad, Shn (Ballia) Dcvmder Singh. Shri (Ludhiana). Chatterjee, Shn N C (Burdwan) Dhandapani. Shn C. T (Dhara- Chatterji. Shri Krishna Kumar puram). (Howrah) Dhillon. Shri Gurdial Singh (Taran- C'hatur\cdi. Shn Rohan Lai (Etah). taran). Chnudhun. Shri Tridib Kumar Dhrangjdhra. Shri Sriraj Mcghrajji (Bcrhamporc) (Surcndranagar). Chaudhun. Shn Nmraj Singh (Hoshan- Dhulcshu<«r Mecna, Shri (Udaipur) gabad). Digvijai Nath. Mahant (Gorakhpur). Chauhan. Shri Bharat Singh (Dhar) Digsijava Narain Singh. Shri C'havan, Shri D R (Karad). (Muzaffurpur) Chavan. Shri Yeshwantrao Bala*an(- Dinesh Singh. Shri (Pratapgarh). rao CSatara). Dip.i. Shri Anirudha (Phulbani) Chittybabu. Shri C. (Chingleput). Dixit. Shn Gangacharan (Khandwa) Choudhary. Shri Valmiki (Hajipur). Durairasu. Shri A. (Pcrambalur). Choudhury Shri J K (Tripura West). Dwivedi. Shri Nagcshwar (Machhli- shahr). Dwivcdy. Shn Surendranalh (Kcn- D’ drapara) Dalbir Singh Shri (Sirsa). Damam, Shri S R (Sholapur). ‘E» Dandeker, Shn Narayan (Jamnagar). Bring. Shn D. (North East Frontier Dange, Shri Shnpad Amrit (Bombay Tract). Central South) F.sthosc. Shri P P (Muvattupuzha). Dar, Shri Abdul Gham (Gurgaon). Das, Shri Nayan Tara (Jamui). Dasappa. Shn Tulsidav H. (Mysore). ‘F* Daschovtdhury. Shri Bcnoy Krishna Fernandes Shn George (Bombay (Cooch Bchar) South). Dass Shri C (Tirupalhi). Deb. Shn D N. (Angul). KT Deiveekan. Shn M (Kallakuriehi). Delkar, Shri Sanjibhai Rupjibhai Gajruj Singh Kao, Shri (Mahendra- (Dadra and Nagar Ha veil). garh). («/)

Oandhi, Shrimati Indira (Rae Bareli). T -Ganesb, Shri K. R. (Andaman and Nicobar Islands)- Iqbal Singh, Shri (Fazilka). Ganga Devi, Shrimati (Mohanlal- g«ni). T Gan pal Sahai, Shri (Sultanpur). Jadhav. Shn Tulshidas (Baramati). Gautam, Shri C. D. (Balaghat). Jadhav. Shri V. N. (Jalna). Gavit. Shri Tukaram Hurji (Nandur- bar). Jaggaiah. Shn (Ongolej. Gayatri Devi, Shrimati (Jaipur). Jagjiwan Ram, Shri (Sa»aram). Ghosh, Shri Bimalkanti (Scrampore). Jaipal Singh, Shri (Khunti). Ghosh. Shri Ganesh (Calcutta South) Jamir, Shri S. C. (Nagaland). Ghosh, Shri P. K. (Ranchi). Jamna Lai, Shri (Tonk) Ghosh, Shri Parimal (Ghatal), Janardhanan, Shri C. (Trichur). Ciirja Kumari, Shrimati (Shahdol) Jena Shn Dhami Dhar (Bhadrak). Oirraj Saran Singh, Shri (Mathura). Jha Shri Bhogcndra (Jamagar). God, Shn Shri Chand (Chandigarh). Jha, Shri Shiva Chandra (Madhubani). Gopalan. Shri A. K. (Kasargod). Jitendra Bahadur Singh, Shn (Shah- had) Gopalan. Shri Pattiam (Tcllichcrry). Joshi, Shri Jagannath Rao (Bhopal). Gopalan, Shrimati Susccla (Ambala- puzha) Joshi, Shn S. M. (Poona) Goundcr. Shn R. Muthu (Tiruppat- tur) ‘IC Govind Das. Dr. (Jabalpur). Gowd, Shri Y. Gadilmgana (Kumool). Kabir. Shri Humayun (Basirhat). Gowda, Shri M. Huche (Chikmaga- Kachwai. Shn Hukam Chand (Ujjain) lur). Kahandolc. Shri Z. M. (Malcgaon) Gowdcr, Shn M K Nanja (Nil- Kalita, Shn Dhircshwar (Gauhati). giri»J. Kamalanathan, Shri M. (Krishnagiri). Guha, Prof. Samar (Contai). Kamblc. Shri Tukiram Dasrath Gupta, Shri Indrajit (Alipore). (Latur). Gupta. Shri Kanwar I-al (Delhi kameshwar Singh Shn (Khagar.a). Sadar). Kamla Kumari. Kumari (Palamau). Gupta, Shn Lakhan I al (Raipur). Kandappan. Shn S (Mcltur). Gupta. Shri Ram Kishan (Hissar). Kapoor. Shri Lakhan Lai (Kiihan- ganj). Karan Singh. Dr. (Udhampur). ‘IP Kami Singh. Dr. (Bikaner). Kavturc, Shri Arjun Shripat (Kham- Hajarnawis. Shri R M (Chimur). gaon). Haider, Shri Kansari (Mathurapur) Katham, Shn Binendra Nath (Jalpai- Hanumanthaiya. Shri K. (Bangalore). guri). Hari Krishna, Shri (Allahabad). Kavade. Shri Bhanudas Ramchandra Huzarika, Shri Joginder Nath (Dibru- (N ask). garh). Kcdaria. Shri C. M. (Mandvi). Heerjibhai, Shri (Banswara). Kesri, Shri Silaram (Katihar). Hem Raj, Shri (Kangra). Khadilkar. Shn R. K (Khed). Himatsingka, Shri Prabhu Dayal Khan. Shn Ghayoor All (Kairana). (Godda). Khan, Shri H. Ajmal (Periakulam). ( / v )

Khan. Shri Latafal All (Muzaffar- Mahadeva Prasad, Dr. (Maharajganj). nagar). Mahadevappa Yashvantappa, Shri Ram- Khan. Shri Mushir Ahamad (Kas- pur (Gulbarga). ganj). Mahajan, Shri Vikram Chand. Khan. Nawabzad.i Zulfiquar Alt (Chatnha). (Rampur). Maharaj Singh, Shri (Mainpuri). Khanna. Shri Prem Kishan Shah- Mahato, Shn Bhajahari (Purulia). jahanpur). Mabida. Shn Narendrasingh (Anand) Kikar Singh. Shn (Bhatinda) Mahishi. Dr. Sarojini (Dharwar North) Kinder Lall. Shri (Hardoi). Maiti, Shri Sachindra Nath (Midna- Kirutnnan. Shn Thanda\ar (Sivaganja). porc) Kisku Shn Amiyj Kumar (Jhargram). Majhi, Shri Mahcndra (Mayuibhanj) kothari. Shri S. S. (Mandsaurj. Malhotra. Shri Inder J (Jammu). lvotoki. Shn I.iladhar (Nowgong). Malimanyappa, Shri (Madhugin). Koushik. Shn K M iChanda). Mandal, Shri Bindhcshwan Prasad Knpalam Shn J. B (Guna). (Madhipura). knpalam Shnmati Sucheta (Gonda). Mandal, Dr. Pashupah (Vishnupur). Krishna. Shri M. R (Pcddapalli). Mandal, Shri Yamuna Prasad Krishnamoorthi. Shri V (C'uddalorc). (Samastipur). Krishnan. Shn G Y (Kolar) Mane, Shri Shankarrao Dattaraya (kolhapur). Krichnappa Shn M V (Hoskote) Mangalathumadam, Shn G. P (Mave- kuchclir Shri G (Vellore). likar.i/ Kundu Shn Samarcndra (Balasorc). Mamkya Bahadur of Tripura, H. H. Kuntc, Shn Dattatrava Kashinath Maharaja (Tripura East). (Kolaba) Manoharan, Shri K. (Madras North). Kurccl. Shri Baijnath (Ramsanchi- Maran. Shn Murasoli (Madras South). ghat) Marandi, Shn lshwar (Rajmahal). kushok Bakula (Ladakh) Masani. Shri M. R. (Rajkot). Kushwah. Shri Yashwant Singh (Bhind). M a tuna Din, Shn (Chail). Mayavan, Shri V. (Chidambaram). Mccna. Shri Meetha Lai (Sawai ■L’ Madhopur) Mcghachandra. Shri M. (Inner Mani Lakkappa. Shri K (Tumgur). pur). Lakshmikanthamma. Shnmati T Mehta. Shn Asoka (Bhandara) (Khammam). Mehta. Shri Prasannhhai (Bhavnagur). Lain Sen, Shn (Mandi). Mclkotc. Dr G S (Hyderabad). Laskar. Shn Nihar Ranjan (Karim- ganj) Mcnon. Shn P Govinda (Mukuuda- puram) Laxtni Bai. Shnmati Sangam (Medak) Menon. Shn V Viswanatha (Erba- Limaye, Shn Madhu (Monghvr) kulam) Loho Prabhu. Shri J. M (Udipi) Minimata Agam Das& Guru, Shnmatb Lutfal Haque. Haji (Jangipur) (Janjgir) Mirza, Shri Bakar Alt (Secunderabad )>■ ‘M* Mishra, Shn Bibhuti (Motihari). Mishra. Shri G S (Chhindwara). Madbok, Shri Bal Raj (South Delhi). Madhukar, Shri Kamla Misra Misra, Shri Snnibas (Cuttack). (Kesaria). Modak, Shri Bijoy (Hoogly) (»)

Mody, Shri Piloo (Godhra), *0 * Mohamed Imam, Shn I. (Q m ^ y ) Mohammad Ismail, Shri (Barrack- Onkar Singh, Shri (Budaun). pore). Oraon, Shri Kartik (Lohardaga). Moban Swarup, Shn (Pilibhit),

Mohinder Kaur, Shrimati (l>,t;.i«) V Mohsin, Shn Fakniddin Huseinsab (Dharwar South). Padmavati Devi, Shrimati (Rajnand- Molahu Prasad, Shn (Bansg^Q,,) gaon) Mondal, Shri lugol Kishorc (Uhibcria). Pa/ia (H iadutaf. Mntyunjay Prasad, Shn (Maharaj- Pan dry, Shri Kashi Nath (Padrauna). ganj). Pandey. Shn Sarjoo (Ghazipur). Muhammad Ismail, Shri M. (Maiqen). Pandey, Shri Vishwa Nath (Salempur). Muhammed Sheriff, Shri (b g" „ na.h,.. Pandit, Shrimati Vijaya 1 akriimi puram). (Phulpur). Mukerjec. Shn H. N. (Calc^t, North Panigrahi. Shn Chintamani (Bhub* East). ncswar). Mukerjee, Shrimati Sharda (Ratnagiri). Pant, Shri Krishna Chandra (Naraital). Mukne, Shri Yeshwanlrao Martandtao Paokai Haokjp. Shri (Outer Manipur). (Dahanu). Parmar, Shri Bhaljibhai Ravjibhai Mulla, Shri Anand Narain (Lucknow) (Dohad). Murthy, Shri B. S. (Amalafeunm), Parmar, Shn Dahyabhai (Patan) Murti, Shri M. S. (Anakap,^-) Paitap Singh, Shri (Simla). Muthusami, Shn C. (Karur) Parthasarthy, Shri P C. (Rajampet). Paswan, Shri Kedar (Roscra). W Patel, Shn Baburao (Shajapur). Naghnoor Mugutsab N a b ,^ shn Patel, Shn J. H. (Shimoga). (Belgaum). Patel, Shn Manibhai Jhavcrbhai Nahata, Shri Amrit (Barmer), (Damoh). Naidu, Shri N. P. Qhenealraya Patel, Shri Nanubfaai N (Buliar). (Chittoor). Patel. Shri Pashabhai Chhotabhai Naik, Shri Gum Charan (keonjhar). (Baroda) Naik, Shn Raja Venkatapa (Raichur). Patil, Shri Anantrao (Ahmednagar). Nair, Shri N Sreekantan (^uiion). Patil, Shn Chudaman Ananda (Dhulia). •Nan -ShT> .® X. /&xr- made). Patfl, Shn Deorao Sbeoram (Yeotmal). Nambiar, Shn K. Ananda (Tiruchira- Patil, Shri Nana Ramchandra (Bhir) ppolli). Patil, Shri S. B. (Bagalkot) Nanda, Shri Gulzan La) Patil, Shrj Sadashiv Daft (Sangli). Narayanan, Shri (Pollachi). Patil, Shri Tulsiram Abaji (Osraana- Nath Pai, Shri (Rajapur). bad). Nayanar. Shri E. K. (Palghat). Patodia, Shn Deoki Nandan (ialore) Nayar, Shri K. K. (BahraicJ,) Poonacha, Shn C. M. (Mangalore). Nayar, Shrimati Shakuniala (Kaisar Pradhani. Shri Khagapathi (Nowrang- pur). Nayar, Dr. Sushila (Jhanai), Pramanik, Shn Jatindra Nath (Balur- Nesamony, Shri A. (N a g e re ^ ghM). Prasad, Shri Y. Ankineedu (Machili- Nihal Singh, Shri (Chandauli) patnam). Nirlep Kaur, Sirdarni (S an g ^ ). Puri, Dr. Surya Prakaih (Nawada). <*)

V Ram. Shri Bhoia (Bagaha). Qureshi, Shri Mohamad Shaffi Ray, Shri Rabi (Puri). (Ananlnag). Reddi, Shri G. S. (Miryalgoda). i Reddy. Shri M. N. (Nizamabad). *R’ Reddy, Shri Neelam Sanjiva (Hind* pur). Radhabai. Shrimati B. (Bhadrachalam). Reddy, Shri P. Antony (Anantapur). Raghu Ramaiah, Shri Kotha (Guntur 1. Reddy, Shri P. Ganga (Adilabad). Rai, Shri Charanjil (Dausa). Reddy. Shri R. Surendar (Warangal). Raj Deo Singh, Shri (Jaunpur). Reddy, Shri R. Dasaratha Rama Rajani Gandha, Kumari (Raigarh) (Kavali). Rajaram, Shri K. (Salem). Reddy, Shri Y. Eswara (Cuddapah). Rajawkharan, Shn M. V. (Kanakii- Rohatgi, Shrimati Sushila (Bilbaur). pur). Roy. Shn Bishwanath (Deoria). Raju, Dr. D. S. (Rajahmundry) Roy. Shri Chittaranjnn (Joynagar). Rajya Lakshmi. Shrimati Lalita Roy, Shrimati Uma (Malda). (Dhanbad) Ram Charan. Shri (Khurja) ■S’ Ram Dhan, Shn (Lalganj). Ram Kishan, Shn (Hoshiarpur) Saboo, Shri S G (Sikur). Ram Sewak. Choudhr( (lalaun). Sadhu Ram. Shri (PhiUaur). Ram Shekhar Prasad Singh. Shri Saha. Dr. Sisir Kumar (Birbhum). (Chapra) Saigat. Shr, A S. (Bilaspur). Ram Subhag Singh. Dr (Buxar) Sail. Shn Ebrahim Suluiman (Kozhi Ram Swarup, Shri (Robertsganj) kode) Ram, Shri Tulamohan (Arana) Salccm Shri Mohammad Yunus (Nal- gonda) Ramabadran. Shri T D (Tmdivanam) Salve. Shn Narendra Kumar P. Ramamoorthy. Shri S. P (Sivakasi) (Bctul) Ramamurti, Shri P (Madurai). Samanla Shn Satis Chandra (Tamluk) Ramani. Shn K (Coimbatore) Samhandhan. Shri S K (Tirultani). Ramdhani Das, Shn (Gaya). Sumbasivam. Shn V. (Nagapattinam) Ramji Ram. Shn (Akbarpur) Sambhali. Maulana Ishaq (Amroha). Rana, Shri M B (Broach). Sammathan, Shn P A (Gobichetti- Randhtr Singh. Ch (Rohtak) palyam) Rane, Shn S R (Buldana). Sanghi. Shri N. K (Jodhpur). Ranga. Shri N G (Srikakulara) Sankata Prasad, Dr. (Misrikh). Ranjeet Singh, Major (Khalilabad). Sam Bux Singh, Shri (Falehpur) Rao, Shn J. B. Muthyal (Nagarkur- Santoiham. Dr M. (Tiruchendur) nool). Sapre, Shrimati Tara (Bombay North Rao, Shri i Ramapathi (Karimiugar). Eatl). Rao, Shn i. Rameshwar (Mahbub- Sarnia. Shri Ananta Tripathi (Bhanj- nagar). nagar). Rao. Shri Jaganath (Chatrapur) Satya Naram Singh. Shn (Varanari). Rao, Dr. K L. (Vijayawada). Savitn Shyam, Shnmati (Aoala). Rao, Shn Karri Narayana (Bobbili). Sayeed. Shri P M. (Laccadive. Mhiieoy Rao, Shn Thirumala (Kokinada). and Amindivi ltlandi). Rao. Praf V. K. R. V. (BrtUry). Sayyadali Samadali, Shri (Jatpon). Rao. Shn Vitwaarai Nanumiha Sen. Shri A«hok» Kumar (Calcutta (Parvadupuram). North Wctf). (Wi)

Sea, Sbri Deven (Atansol). Shiv Chandika Prasad, Shri (Jam- Sen Shri Dwaipayan (Katwa). ahedpur). Sen, Sbri Phani Gopal (Pumea). Shiv Charan Lai, Shri (Firozabad). Sea, Dr. Raneo (Baruat). Shivappa, Shri Nuggeshally (Hassan). Sequeira, Shrj Erasmo de (Marmagoa). Shukla, Shri Shambhu Nath (Rewa). Sethi, Shri Prakash Chandra (Indore). Shukla, Shri Vidya Charan (Maha- Sethuramac, Shri N. (Pondicherry). samund). Siddiah, Shri S. M. (Chamarajanagar). Sezhiyan, Shri Era (Kumbakonam). Sidheshwar Prasad, Shri (Nalanda). Shah, Shrimali Jayaben (Amreli). Sinha, Shri Mudrika (Aurangabad). Shah, Maharaja Manabendra (Tchri Garhwal). Sinha, Shri Ram Krishna (Faizabad). Shah, Shri Shantilal (Bombay North Sinha, Shri Satya Narayan (Dar- West). bhanga). Shah, Shri Trilokshah Lai Priendra Sinha. Shrimali Tarkcshwari (Barh). (Ranker). Sivasankaran. Shri P. (Sripcrumbu- Shah, Shri Virendra Kumar J. dur). lunagadh). Sn.ii.ik. Shri Nar Deo (Hathras). Shalwale, Shri Ram Gopal (Chandni Solanki. Shri Pravinsinhji Natvar- Chowk). sinhji (Kaira). Shambhu Nath, Shri (Saidpur). Solanki. Shri Somchandbhaj Manubhai Shankaranand. Shri B. (Chikodi). (Gandhinagar). Shanda Nand, Shri (Sitapur). Somani. Shri Nand Kumar (Nagaurt Sharma, Shri Beni Shankar (Banka). Somasundaram, Shri S. D. (Thanjavur). Sharma. Shri Diwan Chand (Gurd.n- Sonar, Dr. Amril Ganpat ( Ramtek). pur). Sonavane. Shri Tuyappa Hari (Pan- Sharma. Shri M. R. (Karnal). dharpur). Sharma, Shri Narain Swaroop (Doma- Sondhi. Shri M. L. (New Delhi). riaganj). Srecdharan. Shri Arangil (Badagara). Sharma, Shri Ram Aw'ar (Gwalior). Suhrav.-Iu. Shrj K. (Mayuram). Sharma, Shri Shiv (Vidisha). Sudarsanam, Shri Nladdi (Narsarao- Sharma, Shri Yajna Datt (Amritsar). pet). Sharma, Sh:i Yogcndra (Bcgusjrai). SunJar I al. Shri Jludu (Bastar). Shashi Ranjan. Shri (Pupri). Sunder Lai. Shri (Saharanpur). Supakar. Shri Sradhakar (Sambalpur). Shastri, Shri B. N. (Lakhimpur). Suraj Rhan. Shn (Ambala). Shastri. Shri Prakash Vir (Hapur). Surcndra Pal Singh. Shn (Buland- Shastri, Shri Raghvir Singh (Baghpat). shahr). Shastri. Shri Rama Avtar (Patna). Surs ngh. Shri (Jhahua). Shastri, Shri Ramanaod (Bijnor). Sursanarayana. Shri Kommareddi (Rluru). ShaVri, Shri Sheopujan (Bikramganj). Swuran Singh. Shri (Jullundur). Shastri, Shri Shiv Kumar (Aligarh l. Swell. Shri G. G. (Autonomous Dis Sheo Narain. Shri (Ba&ti). tricts). Sher Singh, Prof. (Jhajjar). *T Sheth, Shri Tblsidas Muljibhai Tamaskar. Shn V. Y. (Durg). Kutch). Tapuriah. Shri Surendra Kumar Shinde, Shri Annasahib P. (Kopargaon). (Pali). Shinkrc, Shri laoandan Jagannath Tarodcfcar. Shri Venkatarao Babarao (Panjim). (Nanded). (vi ii)

Thakur Shri Gunanand (Sahara) Vidyarthi. Shn R S (Karol Bagb). Thakur Shri P R (Nabaduip) Vijaya Raje, Shrimati (Chatra) Ttwarv Pandrt D N (CopaIganj) Virbhadra Singh, Shn (M abuu). Ttu.m Shn Kamal Nath (Bcitiah) Vi&wamhharan, Shri P (Trivandrum). Tnpathi Shn Krishna Deo (Unnao) Viwanatham. Shn Tenneti (Vuakha- Tula Ram Shri (Ghatampuri patnam) Tyagi Shri ()m Prakasb (Morad.ihad) \ i%Manatban, Shn G (Wandiwaih) \\ js Shn Ramesh Chandra (Bhilwara) o r ‘X’ Uikc\ Shri M C» (M andhl Ulaka Shri Ramai-handra (koraput) Xavier Shn S (Tirunelvcli) Lman.ith Shn R (Pudukkoti.ul ‘V •V Yadab Shn Nagcndra Prasad (Sita- Vajpa>cc Shri Ual Hihan I Halram- marhO pur) \adav Shn Chindrairet (Azamgarh) Vccrtppi Shr Kimchindri (Ridar) Yadas Shri lageshwar (Banda) Vcnkatasubbmh Shri P (Nandval) Yad.n Shri Ram Sewak (Barabanki) Venkatswamv Shn G (Siddipcl) Yajnik Shn Indulal (Ahmedabad) Verma Shn Balgo\md (Khen) YiOipil Singh Shri (Dehra Dun) Vcima Shri Prem Chand (Hamirpur) Yusuf Shn Mohammad (Siwan) LOK SABHA

T h e Speaker Shn N Sanjiva Reddy

The Depuly-Speakei Shri R K Khadilkar

Punel of Chairmen Shri K Mjnoharan Shn C K Bhattacharyjd Shn G S Dhillon Shri Bal Raj Madhok Shrimati Lakshmikanthainina Shn S M loshi

Secretary Shri S I Shakdher

(ix) GOVERNMENT OP INDIA

M arttn of (he Cabinet The Minister of Health, Family Plan ning and Urban Development—Shri The Prime Minister, Minister of Ato Satya N an y an Sinha. mic Energy. Minister of Planning and Minister of External Affairs—Shri The Minister of Defence—Shri Swaran mati Indira Gandhi. Singh. The Deputy Prime Minister and Minis ter of Finance—Shri Morarji Dcsai. Ministers of State The Minister of Industrial Development and Company Affairs—Shn F A The Minister of State in the Ministry of Ahmed. Education—Shri Bhagwat Jha Azad. The Minister of Home Affairs—Shn The Minister of State in the Ministry Y. B. Chavan. of External Affairs—Shri B. R. Bhagat. The Minister of Commerce—Shri Dinesh Singh. The Minister of State in the Ministry of Health. Family Planning and The Minister of La hour & Rehabilita Urban Development—Dr. S. Chandra tion—Shri Jai Sukhl.il Hathi. sekhar The Minister of Food 4 Agriculture— The Minister of Slate in the Ministry Shri Jagjisan Ram. of Railways—Shn Parinul Ghosh. The Minister of Tourism and Civil The Minister of State in the Department Aviation—Dr. Karan Singh. of Social Welfare—Shrimati Phulrenu Guha. The Minister of Petroleum & Chemicals and Social Welfare—Shn Atoka The Minister of Slate in the Depart Mehta. ments of Parliamentary Affairs and Communications—Shri I. K. Gujral. The Minister of Law—Shri P. Govinda Menon. The Minister of State in the Ministry of Food, Agriculture, Community The Minister of Railways—Shn C. M. Development and Cooperation—Shn Poooacha. M. S. Gurupadaswamy. The Minister of Parliamentary Affairs The Minister of Stale in the Ministry and Communications— Dr. Ram of Defence—Shri L. N. Mishra. Subhag Singh. The Minister of State in the Ministry The Minister of Tam pon and Ship of Finance—Shn K. C. Pant. ping—Dr. V. K. R. V. Rao. The Minuter of State in the Ministry The Minister of Steel, Mine* and Metals of Petroleum and Chemicals and of —Dr. Chenna Reddy. Social Welfare—Shri Raghu Ramaiah. The Mmister of Education—Dr. Tri- The Minister of Works. Housing ft guna Sen. Supply—Shri laganaath Rao. The Minister of Information ft Brand' The Minister o f Irrigation ft Power— catting—Shri K. K. Shah. Dr. K. L. Rao. <*) (*/ )

The Mmister of State in the Ministry The Deputy Minister—Dr. Sarojinr of Industrial Development & Com Mihhhi. pany Affairs—Shri Ragbunath Reddi. The Deputy Minister in the Ministry of The Minister of State in the Ministry Health, Family Planning and Urban of Steel, Mine* & Metals—Shri P. C. Development—Shri B. S. Murthy. Sethi. The Deputy Minister in the Ministry of The Minister of State in the Miniitry Finance—Shri Jagannath Pahadia. of Education—Prof. Sher Singh, The Deputy Minister in the Ministry of The Minister of State in the Ministiy Commerce—Shri Mnhd. Shaft of Food, Agriculture, Community Qureshi. Development and Cooperation—Shri Annasahib P. Shinde. The Deputy Minister in the Ministry of Steel, Mines & Metals—Shri Ram The Minister of State in the Ministry Scwak. of Home Affair*—Shri Vidy* Charan Shukla. The Deputy Minister in the Ministry of Home Affairs—Shn K. S. Rama- swamy. Deputy Ministers The Deputy Minister in the Department The Deputy Minister in the Ministry of of Social Welfare—Shri J. B. Muthyal Transport & Shipping—Shrj Bhakt Rao Darshan. The Deputy Minister m the Ministry of The Deputy Minister in the Ministry of Law—Shn Mohammad Yunus Railways—Shri Rohanlal Qiaturvedi. Salecm The Deputy Minister in the Ministry of The Deputy Minister in the Ministry of Labour. Employment and Rehabili Information and Broadcasting—Shri tation—Shri D. R. Chavan. mati Nandim Satpathy. The Deput) Minister in the Ministry of The Deputy Minister in the Ministry of Food, Agriculture. Community Deve Irrigation and Power—Shri Sidhesh- lopment and Cooperation—Shn D. war Prasad. Ering. The Dcput) Minister in the Ministry of The Deputy Minuter in the Ministry of Industrial Development and Company Tourism and Civil Aviation—Shri Affairs—Shri Bhanu Prakash Singh. mati lahanara Jaipal Singh. The Deputy Afimsrer in tAe Ministry o f The Deputy Minister in the Ministry of Works. Housing and Supply—Shn Labour. Employment and Rehabilita Iqhal Singh. tion—Shri S. C. Jamir. The Deputv Minister in the Ministry of The Deputy Minister in the Ministry of External ’ Affairs—Shri Surendra Pal Defence—Shn M. R. Krishna. Singh LOK SABHA DEBATES 1 Vol . IX] Fint Day of the Third Session of 1-ourth Lok Sabha [No. 1

LOK SABHA • As all of ns know. Dr. Lohia joined the national movement for tbo indepen Monday, November 13, 1967/Knriika dence of our country with the zed of 22, 1889 (Saka) a missionary. He took a very active pan in the Quit India Movement of 1942. After India attained indepen dence, Dr. Lohia played aa active part The Lok Scbha met at Eleven of the in the freedom movement o f Goa. He Clock. suffered imprisonment nearly 18 times tor his participation in vinous move [M*. S plakir in the ChairJ ments in India. Goa and Nepal. He was a believer in socialism which was MEMBl-R SWORN of a secular order. He made ceaseless efforts in the realms of thought and Shri Rupnath Brahma (Kokrajhar— action, to fight out the social tynumy. Assam) Dr Lohia entered Parliament in 1963 when he was elected to Third Lok Sabha in a bye-election from Farrukha- OBITUARY REFERENCES M constituency o f Uttar Pradesh. As a member of this Howe be raised a MR. SPEAKER : I have to inform number of debates which aroused great the House of the sad demise of nine interest not only in (his House but in of our fnends namely Shn M. K. the country also. He was a powerful Shivaoanjappa. |Dr. Ram Maaohar speaker. No one could even think that Lohia. Shn G D. Patii. Shri H. P. death would take him assay so soon Dr. K. B. Menon, Shri from us. His death removes from the Riouheb MihinoDkir. Indian political scene and this House Start Ud*i Shanker Dube, Pandit Bhag- one of the outstanding leaders. wati Charan Shukla and Pandit Nilkan- tha D u . Shn G. D. Patii was a silting Mem ber of this House from Bijapur consti Shri SUvananpppa was a sitting tuency of Mysore. His tenure in this Member of Shu House from Maadya House was very short-lived. He took constituency of Mysore. He passed his seat in the House on the 6th April. away at Mysore on the 2nd September. 1967 sad Ve passed away at Bijapur 1967, at the voung age of 47. He had on the 1st November, 1967, at the also been a Member of Pint. Second very young age of 45. and TMrd Lok Sabha during the yean 1952—67. Ho was a member of the Shn H. P. Chatterjec was a sitting Committer on Absenoe o f Members Member of this Hoose from Krishnagar and ObmbiHi— oo M t io a during the constituency o f West Bengal. He was Seoood and Third Lok Sabha. He made aho a member o f the Third Lok Sabha use(id ooMributioaa in the House and dunn* the years 1962—67. He was the Cosamltf cs. aa active membts of the House and used to make useful contributions m Dr. R aa Maaohar Lotua was a su debates. He suddenly passed assay at ing Msmber of dus House from Kan- New Delhi on the 1 Ids November, nauj constituency of Ultar Pradesh. 1967 at the age of 70. He passed away at New Delhi on the I2ih Oetobsr. 1967 His deafii was Dr. K. B. Meaou was a Member of Second Lok Sabha during the jm n 3 Obituary Refer**** NOVEMBER 13, 1967 OMmaijr Jfc/twnee* 4

[Mr. Speaker] in the oountry. His untimely death r»> moves from our midst a vigorous mind 1957 —62. He passed away at Calicut and a dynamic character. Tbit Home oa the M i September, 1967, at the will not be the tame without H a. q » o f 70. Shri Bhausaheb Ramabeb Mshagaon- “ C HutU 1BO HUH 301 9 B r m B U y p p * W « u i Member of Seeond Lok and Shri G. D. Patil, both titling Mem S M i during the yean 1957—62. He bers from Mysore. Their pawing away paned iv iy at Kolhapur on the 16th has uddcwad us all. October, 1967, at the age o f 50. The late Dr. K. B. Menon and Shri Shri Udai Sbanker Dube was a Mem Mahagaankar were Memben of the ber of Pint Lok Sabha during the yean Second Lok Sabha. Dr. Menon was 1952—57. He passed away at Bash one of the gen (Jest o f men and actively on the 25th October. 1967 at the age participated in the work of the Indian of 64. States Peoples Conference and (he In dian Civil Liberties Union. Pandit Bhagwatj Charan Shufcfa was a Member of Fmt Lok Sabha during Shn Udai Shanker Dube and Shri the yean 1952—57. He was acciden- Bhagwati Charan Shukla were both taHy drowned in the Narmada at Jabal Members of the First Lok Sabha. Shri pur oo the 30th October, 1957 at the ShuUa. son of the late Pandit Ravi age of 54. Shankar Shukla. died an untimely and tragic death by drowning. We offer our Pandit Niikaniha Das was a Member deepest condolences to our colleague. of the Central Legislative Assembly Shri Vidya Charan Shukla and the during the years 1923— W and 1935— 45. He was for some time the Speaker famil) of Hie Onssa Legislative Assembly also. He paned away at Cuttack on the 6th Ciomg back further m time. Shri November. 1967 at the age of 85 Nilkantha Das was a Member of the old Central legislative Assembly. He We deeply mourn the los» of all time was a poet, a writer and an educartoniet friends and 1 am sure the House will having been connected with the Univer join me in conveying our condolences sities of Calcutta and Delhi. A r to the bereaved families tome time he was Speaker of the Orissa Assembly and the recipient of our na THE PRIME MINISTER. MINIJ»- tional honour of Padma Bhushan. TSft OF ATOMIC ENERGY. MINIS TER OF PLANNING AND MINIS We were looking forward 10 seeing TER OF EXTERNAL AFFAIRS the familiar face of our coMaegwi Shri (SHRIMATI INDIRA GANDHI). Mr. H P Charterjee during this seerian. Speaker, Sir we reassemble here this hut only a couple of days ago death hat morning under the shadow of grief at aho taken him away from us. He wat the departure from our midst ol a an old freedom fighter and an active of our valued colleagues and parliamentarian with a long record of comrades. 11m pariiailar inter session service in the came of the country. Tim period has taken a rather heavy loll. House wiB remember that k was abort T V Home will miss Dr. Ram Mano- three yean ago dial hit only son laid h r Lolita, who was one of oar leading down his life in the defence o f the fmfhmenunam. Hu whole life was a countr) alniggte for causes he held dear, for 4 m downtrodden and the under-privi It is with som w m our heart* that leged. He played a memorable pari we remember them Mambcn. wto In our freedom struggle, specially in the have served their country *■ (, each Quit India movement, and was among according u> his own light. We pay f e founders of the Socialist movement them our humble tribute and oCar our 5 O bit—ry KAfcTKA 22, 1W (SAK A) Obttaary 6 R tftrtn c v R tfertn cu •taam condolences to the bereaved this House as well aa the State legis tH/BS) latures undentand what Is meant by starvation in a different manner, with SHU RANOA (Siikakulam) : The very good results, so far as the recent nwrnben of our party and myself ssso- famines in Uttar Pradesh, Bihar and date ourselves with what you have aaid Orissa were concerned. aad what the Prim* Minister has aaid about all thaw valued comrades and Sir, Dr. Lofeia passed away much too colleagues of ours in this House and soon. The country cannot afford it noi also in the previous Home*. tide House. The Prime Minister said the right thing, on our behalf, what was Dr. Lohia was one of our national very much in our mind, (hit the House leaden. It was given to him to have cannot be the same after his death. We taken part in many popular movement* mourn hia death and (he whole country that raged in our country during the also feels the same. last three decades. It was my privilege to have enjoyed his comradeship in the Mr. Paul waa one of our colleagues kiaan movement When 1 waa trying to in tha House; he had been a good build up the unit* in West Bengal Swatantnte. He waa an MLA in My Though he hailed from Rajasthan, and sore. He had also served the people was working in U.P., he had ao much in the local bodies. He did a lot of ■nWnMieo m West Bengal alio even as social work. early aa 1935. And then in Goa, in Nepal, in NEFA and ui ao many other Pandit Nilkaniha Das was one of my places where he felt the need for cour old colleagues. We came together into ageous leadership be placed himself un this House under the leadership of hesitatingly in the vanguard, faced the Bhulabhai Desai. He was one of the nsks of that position and advanced the Secretaries of our party here in this cause of the people m their fight lor House. We used to come and work freedom. together on this side of the House •gainst the British who then used to Like ao many of us, he also bad the occupy those Benches He was such a privilege of working under the leader great fighter. Aa you said, he was a ship of Mahatma Gandhi. His seme of poet, a great writer in Onya. He made discipline was so great that when a great contribution to the development Mahatma Gandhi did not agree with of Onya literature and language. He his proposition ut regard to South sacrificed everything that he had; the Africa which was accepted by the only other man I can think of m equal AlOC, and Mahatma Gandhi wanted measures a Mr. Prakasam of Andhra the AJCC to m ile from its poaition, Pradesh. like a loyal soldier he accepted Mahatma Gandhi's suggestion. And he Then there is this gnat man, H. P. allowed the A1CC to rcacmd its own Chatterjee. There are very few of is reaolutioo. This, I am mentioning, be here Who love trees and forests half as cause he baa always beak known as « much aa be has done. When be was rebel among rabeis and yet he had also making his Iasi, long speech in this that itrau of discipline wilhm tiimsslf. House, bolding forth in favour of m e In tins Houae, as wall as in the country development and forest development is a whole, ha played a notable pari and forest wealth, I waa remiaded of and he always had the genius to give the ancient R uhit, aad he did behave a turn which has not bean taken by tin like aa ancient MM when ha one and others aad to asake (ha issue look verj only aon gave up his Bfe in the cause different when he began to handle it- of the country in that war that waa That is why It was feat as soon ss be imposed upon us by Pakistan in 1965 came into this Houae he draw the atten We mourned ha son's death, also, but tion of tha Houae to the existence of Mr. Chatterjee waa glad that it ws> starvation ss he oooceived it and made given to him to make that sacrifioe u> 1 OMMqr Rxftrtnoa N O V M B I 13, I96 T MUumiy Htflimum «

f w j k m s M Hm M ad gsasnttion aha. He was ana a t the w y (nr heroic paopis tn ft *WF *t %* *ntr tar, ft we « n o n w w u l l i k i privilege wwt(Kww*^i| « * * < * % U M d 10 have bad him ta this Haw* % fln? w w rfr *mt Iwnfc f t as one o f our coleagQOs.

Dr. K. B. Meoon «w tha feattrst w r it ntfw tiftir % *fgw f[ •w ifT sww ^T% leatier of die mamea, aotbiaf to do *T» lft^*T f*f & ¥5 «n? I *1W % with the people ia die ivory tower. He disquieted tibe oppreason aad reaamred 1*HT WftX *I*C *I>T flWf %ftsW iha suppreawd. Hit words alight have *WT f iftr W*IT I 'jm'M beea hanh, attacfca might ba«a baaa invidious, criticisms m i^ have been >?fPT iftt wfwimft uror vr Ie completely for the wdl-being and ^ Hflw vr w, w a ^ weWare of this couatty. The ways w wpiT, 5TRI, ^ iftr JIT wnnr T t adopted by him ia axpUaiag Us yimm l{t% WT^

^ I i *iw | st6 ^nft f I Jifif Despite the nncere attempt on die IW ^ W f *f HfXftlfl ^!T% TT part of the Govermaaat, despite the wiwvt A v| sftr iwrft meticulous attention showa by the mat- ed and experienced docton, we could nhiftiijtA I not save Dr. Lohia. Let o> not brood ovar that Lai us try to giva *ew Ufe SH U MANOHAKAN (Madraa to die prittc^>lea of Dr. L 6hia aad let Nonb) : Mr. SpMlur. Sir, oo biteU us try to give them a oonact w> ooo* of my p«9 , dM D.MJL Puty ia Fv- Crete shape. llim c^ 1 twor im mjrxlf with the wnHMW opntMd by th» Laate of S r. on behalf of my party, I offer tht Hoom m dM i t a k m ol Dr. Loliu my beartfeh coodolcoces to t e bcfaav- aad o t e * . ed family of aB diasa fiaast leaden of our country who are not wtth na. It k m lljr • t n f i 4r lltai tU* oooa- trjr h iMiat h« iont t e m tn p « M i- ^ wif (itprtTfl) ; 4WI whM Ab !■ paaiat dvou|^ criiM ww % ^ % ftW T TW aNtire ■ficr crtaM. It odglM be a aatnral oknaaMMM. bM tte iteMk k ■m»«*»«i»« Wlf^iT, WT iprft caaMt ba « te i4 «ad dw womb K W w wiWHrt % sfH iftt cTMMi oaMM ba fliad op. w n ipwrft irtr fwrtt 7t ( f ^ Dr. LoMa. ooa a( * a vaMvaa mMo- nal liadan ihta m m m f baa a w p n - w w m f c w j I I T * T I W A ^ T iJl^W T <>iicad. wkoaa owHribH oB to iha aoMa ^ wrolhi wf^Nv % t^vwn- o u ia I t «Ui ailiaa’b t m t a m w m bb- k)rtc m i TW flMJt, !• w omi* ■ T W ♦ i f t t wnw % 1! Ohintary Rt/*renc*s NOVBMUK 13, 1967 Obkutry Rtftrmcu 12

(^1 W t w l ] mnwr * wi* H* snflr # ait hr «ft t o ^ tflftn 4H^tr arror ir< ti*r •flftfl apRTT % WTBT-4K W T t *r*frgT*M^in %*flr 5^fTT I gaflr flww, Jwrofiw flWW tot — . r* » *v *» __ ^ • f n W W JT h Tw R fT Wfff f f ? %vr «rf?r 3*wr Tt aftvr »nrf «mw % at? Hfm t w airflrty w $ w? *sr h r % afttrcTrcfhr WRmmr ^ %vr apr% m W t wftur »mm fartt «ct «**, w hr % 'rfferr hr *t. g w Jr wm *iSr t |p fpmrfr t | t anrihft h r fr aftrr sw ft, w hft *ftt ♦ flpntf *i ajim W ill % JflfW 39JWT *T «nfm ^ ^ c^inr t| i anrt wr aftr n f % 4ttm 3 «w | f t w f i v i m f>re«n m asjfft arnw an^ffcw # art nrwrr w m m a t v p «r 3»r% A ^tt jpnft n firw * * r *fr, 3i?% t o * f w i**r ^ t v r w n smrff arwft snvwiif iSt trajtar *rwtw ^ «i Of w imrH % *ft»r aMV * sfrarfam Sr^rr itfT «tffm 4 ?*i^ *T* UWIT | ft a rrtt a n ftft J *T T P T 1 R^RTT-^nn* 4 to *j* awi fro 4 **^W h *t writ % w w i «nf wit Pnn i f*rtt jh 4 *>ft AIM *T TTCft I ¥To qtfW lI *re arm ft fr *T3?* Tjcjfai * t f t T?T ^ H* Pf *T* Tt **T *n*t*nr ^ v ft^r *txraft 4 4 to *r* Tf x ft artr^Nt* aw*- 4, aft an* *jw ft t* *?f »nj ^ i jV ft J IW I T1*% jf aftr «jfT*t, *f?«it aftr 4t**-*4*r Treft* *nroft% ft»r in rl *^5 aft **f 4 T T 3 ft fr*T 4 tr f% r * 5 tp tt *5t 4 rr % wtuS **T t HS^FTH fft wq4 ntan amn* *ft ft*r, ** *r U * H I« 3 * *4 4* 44 rrtt «4U 0t Wtr A m w tjt tt’tt % w w r qr **T **rar * 1** * ** 4 *f4 tto vjtf^vr 4 *f*r

wiNWv ift *if wfih ^ t, ifK wft I^JWW "wwtMHm W ifc 1 H W ^ ftfft ^ ft vmftw n fu m % ^ " fin fttftir m^nc«n«(t frtK V <* \ ftvT W I "Wr, fn m m * w tw v tlv VRTT ^ >rt>rt ^ ^ f#w itwJ # ft i*siiw r ^ ^ fljw *FT*n' ^ tftr ^R*r % ftt^ vM W ^rrw ("UllRIT % fW T « fr f t >jft t»Ww# w ^ # « w - ^ iw i '4 t, < ftr wrw-w7flr WTf Wrfff-*nWTT w ®*>pPT % % »W nr WT ift 9 If. ft^ i M tH |*rrft m l^ti «*|T t ftr JrtH Tf I f t t[V ^ w f t i m k f t I *fr ft nwf fPw w

# 1^ % M ) f|(>(%iTWfiwt 4 •Hiwi ^ ftw ft TOWif I h t i f W tt, «r «MT nr I ilM «K- WÎWW % 1^ wre’TT w tw H t Iw ^ wf iw ¥> ¥y <*T>f if’nrf ^\ irfvw nr♦ liflm nTtik VR% ^ wm ww, liV f>T *iW srni I XHVt *rrtw ’f f ft* *i? stfrtr < t f t ; ^ v f i t ^ w f r r p j*W » w iw » ? t wf « rt» »™+T- m ^nnH, rm w tifim V lTlfl »»TT HKPfhrx ♦i4’W ^ fifipur vw % yrr % % WT W W » ^ «TT *T 3PTO 5?^ ^ ftvlft (SW Vf • n w n fiPTt SfRTT ?ft ^ T?!n, %VT ^ ir t r . 3*WT f«f^ ^ I V i W V I W5 ^ * fwdrf> w, w w n <1*1 ^ Jftt f ’fft % flrthft %ftpr iH^rfrtr iftr f»rti- *Î TT ftt aWT Jrt»r ftffT ft ^T iiT k fWrf> !»Cf ^ I 5«fW . «row TTW, f»»TT W % »itn «tf)wr, % m -JRW ftnw- >nft ^ f»r ^ri pi TOn« ^ wfw aftf% ^nr v r t m «r'i 3JTTW l¥*rt «WT f t 3?wft THPftftr ^>TT «rn ftt art wm * t w i m fvÔTST ^ I ^ «nw f ft 3>|^ m , fK ^ ^ |wi I « VTVfrflT ^ Jô4n ^ l|fr WT— ?»rf»rt w «PT % M w v # h T am npR ^ fsiraiif— w * f* ifWWr, ftm ftw t fitK f s f i n r f f % 9 « « t i At TT ewTTT ift iftr ^*n[ Tt ^ ♦ v tiS T ft>r an tp t iftt ^ ft n n m ftiili (wwiw w ^ ^ V( fiw^, ^ Hfiw* * TW •wi, *wtT urA m3, 1*6T Obituary Xl/M Kit 20 wm • fearless fighter, aad it was sur {alt prising that dsy b«fon yesterday just jpTt aft anft n* i after a law boun of my meeting h i % Stftf H *T» TPT he passed away.

% was also impatient with his nwa collea gues. Such a spirit is no more in ear boo. friend Limaye aaid. as far as the movement in the country u concerned country. A void has bean crattd •hich will remain unfilled aad the Dr. K. B. Mcnoo was with us in the younger generation o f this ooustiy, 1 Seoood Lok Sabha. Apart from Parlia hope and trau, would rally togrther to ment, we had been working together in take up the cause of the d w i U odder Kenla, aad about him it hat been saul so that a n e w revohmoa can he brought that he was a loyal worker to the caiuc about for the social transformation of of social am and that ha was a gentle the society ta a whofc. man. Mr. H. r. Chauartea. whom pnhaMy Aa far as Shn H P. CbMUrjet is m this Turiiamaot all of ua k am , was oooceraed, we all know about him He a bold rod coungacm fighter I Sad 21 Obituary KAKTTKA 22, 1M» (SAKA) Obituary 22 R e fm ttc u Referencei very few ia the political life who had 1 hope that so far as others are con- gone through such sacrifices. He loet cerned, you will send our condolence* h it eon in the lart Indo-Pakistan war. to the bereaved families. But so far as Wheo some of ua tried to conceal this Dr. Lohia is concerned, while we pay news from him, and after all when he tributes to him. we know he was a non lieaid it—personally speaking, I could conformist. From the way his crema not myself have Mood that tragedy with tion took place, and the way he had such aa equanimity and we felt that gone through ail his personal life, be after all he wa* hu only aon—he felt remained a non-conformist. Today, that hi* ion had died aa a soldier and a when we are mourning his death, prob valiant fighter for freedom and inte ably there is no occasion for us to send grity o f the country. He waa not con any message to any member of bis cerned about himself. He asked some family. The country aa a whole should of ua who met him, “Please go to my consider that he was her too and we all house and console the members of my should mourn his loss. family. So far as I am concerned, ! shall tty my best to tell them that we SHRI FRANK ANTHONY (Nomi have lost nothing by losing our son.” nated—Anglo-Indians) : Mr. Speaker Very few in our country would be found Sir, I would like to associate the Inde in such a bold spirit on an occasion tike pendent Parliamentary Group with the that. sentiments that have been expressed on the passing away of so many of our Dr. K. B. Menon was not only a valued colleagues. Member o f this House for a brief period; he waa also a freedom-lighter and a 1 would hke to say a few words spe- sponsor of the movement o f civil liber cialy about Dr Lohia. I knew him well ties in this country He was associated enough to call him by hi* first name not only with the S’ates freedom move Quite frankly. I did not agree with some ment but wi.h ll>: freedom movemen' of of hn act om. But however much one the country and *>ith the socialist move might have d.sagrecd wtth some of 'he ment from the very beginning He was views and actions of Ram Manohar such a spirit that if we recall the way Lohia, one could not but help like him he brought the question of civ.l liberties personally and like him intensely. He when he was a Member of this House, projected certain image ig public life. It all of ua should a bo think about persons was the image essentially of a rebel. As like him wherever they are, whether in my friend. Shri Surendranath Dwivedy, Parliament or outside, who always spon- said, he waa a confirmed non-confor aorad the cause of the down-trodden and mist. the crvil liberties in the country. Whatever else one may have accused Laatly. we have lost another veteran. Ram Manohar Lohia of. no one could Pandit Nilkantha Das. He was a vete accuse him of not being original both ran o f the nauooalot movement He in his ihink'ng and m ka action. waa a pioneer in many respects in the social, cultural, educational end political Not so long ago when we met at * M ds in Onata. He was a member of par'y, he asked me why whenever I met tW old Central Legislative Assembly him, I had a broad smile on my face. 1 wtth Bhulabhai Desai as the leader. Sir, asked him. "Have you ever looked hie contribution not only to Indian poli- closely at vour own face T He said, tica but to Indian culture end literature why ’ I said : "It ia a penooificatioo stoufd remain outstanding for all times of impishness. It ia a puckish face. U» eonae. We have lost him. of course, You must have been a personification at hie old age, bin he has left a heritage of an imp when you were a young and which an o f us should remember and naughty boy. You protected that into dMrtfc. your public life." Whatever he prod ded or goaded or crihbaed, there was WUh thaae w gnh, 1 again associate tha quality of imphhnaar There waa a q M lf with A a featkagp expressed hate not any maboe—at least that waa my 23 Obiiumy fbtftrtncts NOVBMMR H, 1W7 QHmary JU/artnccf 24

p b i i Frank Anthony) U H i*. own (M om ent—about what ha Mid or We at* an pwod of hkn Bo fH did. Of coarse, in a way, that amtdit know wtut be whs tailing a a . He mm otter qualities was responsible for the telling ite : “Chatterjea sahib : 1 ham not inconsiderable following he bad and got to go. My cad b near. What iMI hb apecial capacity to attract not only happen to this poor widow? I ha** loyalty hut affection. nothing. How will die maintain bnwjtt She is qualified. She ia an M.A-" I Mr. Speaker, I would like to ask >ou said : “Why don’t you talk to tha M a c to convey our deepest condolences to Minister. It it the duty o f tha M g * the members of the bereaved families. Minister to help the widow o f one o f SHRI N. C. CHATTERJEE (Burd- the most heroic son* of India who sacri wan) : Mr. Speaker. Sir, on behalf of ficed his life in this manner." Ha M id: myself and the member* of the Pro “No. 1 can never do that. I have never gressive Group. 1 associate myself with bent my head before anybody. 1 can the tributes which have been paid. Thu not make a request.” I said : *1 can Parliament today is meeting under the speak to her". His reply w as: ~No. shadow of a true national calamity Dr. I can speak to you and if you can do Lohia is gone Thai create^ a ' o'd something I will be happy”. Yesterday. whch cannot be filled u-> He was not Si i. this young girt was going with me merely one of the greatest fighter* in n the funeral procesaon She was the Indian liberation movement bm » • ' •I'ting next to me I asked: “Why a passionate champion of the oppressed didn't \ou come to me? Why did not and down-trodden He did so much Han Pada Babu come to me?" She for helping all backward peop'e and said “No He was a peculiar man people who were down-trodden and sup He would never do that, never make pressed. References have been made any request for him self He was a by one of the previous speaker* to his jewel of man His whole life was devot pass onate plead ng for (he Hindi lan ed to one passion, the upl'ft of this guage Although there is a grca* deal country, the uplift of the nation. Oar of controversy o»cr tha’ in tm part of duly n in mourn his loss, to pay tribute India—West Bengal—hr was vill he to him as father of the heroic lighter* idol of the youth of Beng-il Volunta of India's liberation and one who play rily. without mv ask ng, he came to my ed a magn ficcnt part •» that fight constituency—Burdwan—during the elec tion and he captured the audience by Sir. I associate myself with the tri ha wond:rful speeches in Bengali. butes paid to our friends wh* have You know he spent a good part of his paned away life in Bengal and actually We looked upon him as a fellow Bengali in every «fl ■•IWfU WINft « v n t crisis, he stood by us and helped us We could never forget his services We t o , **re r shall mas him for all time to come w*rc ir Referencu iefertn eet ® R ^ W l * ^ «Ft tiR n ^ WR % T f t 'nswwfif f)l4 »VKI4^ I I ^ I *Wip»T HTfW fip ^ t % >np «*iFT »rroft>T irwurt ^ « T * TUf ^ r s r ^ w fim y n fTJri t ?ft »T» ^ «r? ^ iftr ^ wftv vnhr ^ ?r«ni *ft (t frTTT, fc n ( Wfr’Tfr-Tift

^ «f=T ff I I »I® «r <^TVTH % i JTT- ^5TT 1 arWTW »T?K^, 3 »ITT z??l *rr T?T Tl 4*^ 7^T nrre ^ mr >?»■ m ^ ? 31^ T stJ^fTPTt Tt sii^sn rfT 11 57W f r ??? f*TTf?r jt 9=r> icnfl ?<3?t jn f<-'-Ti an f r 'n ^ Tt rnr- «r? XT*ft w n HfT^f 5»i ir f^ .w tm'r t 3R'ffTTHi r r =jR»»n r t "T STT tq-a froT arrn i ^IT '('■■i T7 f'trr % f5rf;s7'>r » 3(fs»w T^TfT «i Ti 0 m M>7 sqTRn T»=ft ▼ rf;^ I « r f i m C « iJ-i 377- :3fCT mtn «r c t fimr ^ 5 f^ ffw ffi f»^o >flo ^ a j f ^:t

fw t »T r« Hrfjfiii « in»* « «R « rr:g f, ?TTTft ^ ra f«»Wt I Tfm « arf fij »rm 5 f w i ajTT ^ HW ^ ft: ^ t * ?«I « t =t T t n Wt 3i^ m napfif^ w»r ^ «TR ^ rm rsf « »fr wWli ^ v « ^ irfVr f«fW

TT lf> ftwif ^ I < j» s irr r t ? t m «ft % % w w ^ ftT tw « n % « i %v^4^«pr«^) wT >r{ I ?w snFTT % cjv n n n * 3WT<^* OT % o r *TTh fpn^ *rw »f 3s »nj f I ll imwi sirt iwi ’fi f« «T * tft *t Hpipww % wtf % w W w #snrf % ni% |r wnef^ i ^ «m 98^ wfir H i ifeiiw ^ ilEt VR 27 Obituary Rtjtrtnca NOVEMBER 13, IN ? Obkmry Affatmcn 28

[n m f t f i 4%ifafWafthwtww ftr i ^ t < n r «ft, 1 1 % f*r v ft an sftitaftr# * «rarafir wfrr v»?n ipt ^ i t J1 nfr wrf % t n 1 ' prnjftr i ft n% ftrj |4 wnr tu t I, vtr # 8f % ^ fi r « at^w ?«r ?rtm M fanrtt snwr fi ** «m % w fr farr »n» i tio m f i^ V t ?rt(pjrr ^ gar Tmf q r h r | i la f aaft ^ WT fr^TT* T> w i t 3ITCT m uiT vt *wii«i fWr aftr ift m% w w i> ?n *r s’* ^ i <*»n sfir wHt awnrf»r »ft ^ «n*ft 11 *nnn $ *nn aronrr ft i * «rc «mi> aft firw r r «F»WT ■ffw ^ flnwr am r y a *r^t *t, aft fv wr an* hr «t «r i MR. SPEAKER : As a mark of re% pect to the memory o f tim e friend*. the n f t a r t % ** »rfWt % fin* anrt House m»v stand in silence for a short x | i mm * aw *r* ift fh rtt % wr # while. ap* «rfrtf «ft «T| % ami fll% faR The Membert then Hood in silence for %Aw * f fipqift *rc aw & x|*i aft a thort while. Tmtnpjjftft»i*ta«flTOfw«iT* frq ftim I, M N apnrcf «ft WTO t, MR. SPEAKER : An a mark of res pect to the departed members, the arm v r aft awiar 3 s m fr, aft f a House suods adjourned tilt tomorrow •I 0*1 V f»pr q rtf ^ ftm Wfl | TO