Land, Language, and Learning: Inuit Share Experiences and Expectations of Schooling
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
LAND, LANGUAGE, AND LEARNING: INUIT SHARE EXPERIENCES AND EXPECTATIONS OF SCHOOLING ALESHA D. MOFFAT A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF GRADUATE STUDIES IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY GRADUATE PROGRAM IN EDUCATION YORK UNIVERSITY TORONTO, ONTARIO December 2017 © Alesha D. Moffat, 2017 ii ABSTRACT For decades, many Inuit have expressed the need for schooling to reflect Inuit culture, language, values, and worldview. Significant strides have been made to create a school system responsive to Inuit culture and community needs, to increase opportunities for Inuit teachers, and promote Inuit knowledge and language. Despite considerable changes since the establishment of federal day schools across the Eastern Arctic, the imposed school system retains qualities of the southern Canadian model with Qallunaat (non-Inuit) comprising the majority of teaching staff. This critical ethnography focuses on the shared experiences of schooling in Arctic Bay, Nunavut. Interviews with 24 Inuit, all of whom attended or still attend Inuujaq School, form the basis of this work. Prior teaching experience in the community, and elsewhere in Nunavut, contextualizes the research. My goal has been to come to better understandings of Inuit experiences of schooling, and the meanings Inuit attach to their experiences in the hopes that the insights offered may inform teaching practices and pedagogies and contribute to better support for Inuit students. Drawing on Indigenous thought, more specifically Inuit Qaujimajatuqangit, a holistic, diverse, and flexible theory of knowledge, grounded in Inuit culture and worldview, I explore some of the tensions and contradictions between Qallunaat teaching approaches and Inuit cultural values and educational practices through analysis of the narratives of Inuit students. I offer a historical overview of Inuit encounters with Qallunaat on Inuit lands, as well as an examination of the history of Inuit education and schooling in order to understand its influence on current schooling issues. Significantly, the interrelated themes of land, language, and learning emerged from Inuit narratives as critical pieces, central to Inuit experiences of schooling. iii Qallunaat teachers who choose to work in Nunavut have a responsibility to respond to the needs and desires of Inuit students. This research asks how Qallunaat teachers might come to understand and engage with the knowledge embedded in Inuit experiences and perspectives of schooling to work in respectful ways and contribute positively to schooling in Inuit communities. iv DEDICATION To the people of Arctic Bay who continue to show me the meaning and value of tunnganarniq. v ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This research would not have been possible without the generous support and involvement of many people. I begin with thanks to those whose knowledge and experiences are directly reflected in this work. I am deeply indebted to Inuit research participants, who graciously shared their insights with this Qallunaaq researcher. Thank you for your openness, integrity, and your persistent hope in the possibilities of education. My heartfelt thanks to Ikpiarjukmiut, who have always welcomed me into their community with such generosity. I continue to learn more from each of you than I can account for here. Qujannamiik! I am especially grateful for the kindness and friendship of the Qamanirq family, who have shared their knowledge, stories, good food, and laughter, always ensuring there was space for me on the qamutik. My sincere thanks to both Claudette and Audrey for opening your homes and your hearts. This research has been generously supported by funding from the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada; the Ontario Graduate Scholarship Program; the Northern Scientific Training Program, Association for Canadian Universities for Northern Studies; the Faculties of Graduate Studies and Education at York University; and the York Graduate Student Association. I am grateful for the guidance offered by a supervisory committee of patient, encouraging, and knowledgeable teachers, with whom I have had the additional privilege of working alongside in other research endeavours. I feel very fortunate to have had the opportunity to learn from such engaged scholars and have benefitted significantly from their thoughtful questions and insightful comments. My thanks to Anna Hudson, who also acted as chair of the vi oral examination committee, for her support and encouragement. I offer sincere appreciation to Susan Dion, who provided numerous opportunities for me to teach and learn, who continues to offer invaluable advice, and whose own work has helped to prompt a shift in my understandings. I wish to express my gratitude to Karla Jessen Williamson, the external examiner for this dissertation, for her thoughtful engagement with my work and generous feedback. My thanks also to Ian Martin for his close reading and constructive contributions to this research. I am truly grateful to Celia Haig-Brown, my dissertation supervisor, for her endless support, compassion, and friendship. Thank you for introducing me to new ways of thinking, for creating opportunities for me to develop as a researcher, for igniting in me a deep passion and enthusiasm for ethnography, and for trusting me to go for it in all the best ways. I wish to thank my friends, near and far, for their interest in my work and their support along the way. Special thanks go to: Angie Ortlieb-Sinopoli, Kate Knight, and Gillian Chilibeck, all of whom have their own experiences and relationships with Nunavut – the people and the place. Huge thanks belong especially to Sabina Mirza. I am grateful to have gained a close friend in the process of our shared PhD experience. Thanks for enthusiastically cheering me on until the last page was written. Finally, thank you to my family in Ontario and in Northern Ireland; to my mother, who nurtured my curiosity and desire to learn, teaching me that the possibilities for women are endless, and to my father for instilling in me the value of hard work and perseverance. Thanks also to my siblings for their encouragement throughout the years. Last but not least, my thanks to Neill, who became my husband in between fieldwork and the final critical stages of dissertation writing. I could not have done this work without your unwavering support, humour, and kindness. vii TABLE OF CONTENTS ABSTRACT .............................................................................................................................. II DEDICATION........................................................................................................................ IV ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS .................................................................................................... V LIST OF FIGURES ................................................................................................................. X INUIT QAUJIMAJATUQANGIT ....................................................................................... XI CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................ 1 SCHOOLING IN NUNAVUT ........................................................................................................................... 1 THE PEOPLE AND THE PLACE .................................................................................................................... 9 THE SCHOOL ................................................................................................................................................. 21 REFLEXIVITY................................................................................................................................................ 23 A NOTE ABOUT LANGUAGE AND TERMINOLOGY ........................................................................ 25 THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK ................................................................................................................... 27 INUIT QAUJIMAJATUQANGIT ............................................................................................................. 29 INUIT QAUJIMAJATUQANGIT AS A SPACE OR CONTEXT OF LEARNING................................. 42 WORKING TOWARDS TUKISIUMANIQ .............................................................................................. 42 RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND OUTLINE OF DISSERTATION .............................................................. 46 CHAPTER 2: HISTORICAL CONTEXT ........................................................................... 48 DEFINING COLONIALISM .......................................................................................................................... 51 INUIT: PEOPLE OF THE ARCTIC ................................................................................................................ 53 ENCOUNTERS WITH QALLUNAAT .......................................................................................................... 54 FIRST CONTACT .................................................................................................................................. 54 WHALERS .............................................................................................................................................. 56 ETHNOGRAPHERS ............................................................................................................................... 59 TRADERS ..............................................................................................................................................