DOCSLIB.ORG

Canada's Response: the Making and Remaking of the National War

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Canada's Response: the Making and Remaking of the National War Canada’s Response: The Making and Remaking of the National War Memorial by Malcolm Edward Osier Ferguson A thesis submitted to the Faculty of Graduate and Postdoctoral Affairs in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in History Carleton University Ottawa, Ontario ©2012, Malcolm Edward Osier Ferguson Library and Archives Bibliotheque et Canada Archives Canada Published Heritage Direction du 1+1Branch Patrimoine de I'edition 395 Wellington Street 395, rue Wellington Ottawa ON K1A0N4 Ottawa ON K1A 0N4 Canada Canada Your file Votre reference ISBN: 978-0-494-93554-5 Our file Notre reference ISBN: 978-0-494-93554-5 NOTICE: AVIS: The author has granted a non­ L'auteur a accorde une licence non exclusive exclusive license allowing Library and permettant a la Bibliotheque et Archives Archives Canada to reproduce, Canada de reproduire, publier, archiver, publish, archive, preserve, conserve, sauvegarder, conserver, transmettre au public communicate to the public by par telecommunication ou par I'lnternet, preter, telecommunication or on the Internet, distribuer et vendre des theses partout dans le loan, distrbute and sell theses monde, a des fins commerciales ou autres, sur worldwide, for commercial or non­ support microforme, papier, electronique et/ou commercial purposes, in microform, autres formats. paper, electronic and/or any other formats. The author retains copyright L'auteur conserve la propriete du droit d'auteur ownership and moral rights in this et des droits moraux qui protege cette these. Ni thesis. Neither the thesis nor la these ni des extraits substantiels de celle-ci substantial extracts from it may be ne doivent etre imprimes ou autrement printed or otherwise reproduced reproduits sans son autorisation. without the author's permission. In compliance with the Canadian Conformement a la loi canadienne sur la Privacy Act some supporting forms protection de la vie privee, quelques may have been removed from this formulaires secondaires ont ete enleves de thesis. cette these. While these forms may be included Bien que ces formulaires aient inclus dans in the document page count, their la pagination, il n'y aura aucun contenu removal does not represent any loss manquant. of content from the thesis. Canada ABSTRACT In the years following the First World War, the Government of Canada erected a National War Memorial in the capital city of Ottawa. The monument was pre-eminently a commemoration of the service and sacrifices of Canada’s overseas armed forces, but it was also conceived and created as a national project with larger aims emphasising domestic unity and the country’s unique war experience, and presenting a positive and inspiring message to Canadians. The memorial, called The Response to capture Canada’s answer to the call to duty in 1914, was not unveiled until May 1939. After the Second World War, the role and meaning of the monument underwent a remaking. As a result of debates surrounding efforts aimed at another national commemorative war monument in the capital, it became apparent that the National War Memorial had come over the years to represent for Canadians not one war but all of their wars. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to begin by expressing my great appreciation for the assistance offered to me by my supervisor, Professor Norman Hillmer. In the writing of this thesis, his insight, guidance, and expertise have proven invaluable. Without him, this project might never have begun and certainly would not have developed into what it is today. It has been a privilege and an honour to have had him as an advisor, mentor, and a friend. Many thanks are owed to the members of my examination committee. Professors Tim Cook, Ruth Phillips, and Paul Litt each provided valuable insights that have presented me with a number of considerations for the expansion and development of my research. A great debt is also owed to the Graduate Administrator of the department of history, Joan White, whose tireless work behind the scenes, and willingness to answer the many questions I had along the way, made this process much easier. I would also like to thank my family for their love and support throughout this process. In particular, a great debt is owed to my father, whose expert editing skills were always available to me. His help over the years has shaped me into the writer that I am today. Finally, I would like to thank my wife Karolyn. Despite the many long nights working on this thesis, she was always there to provide love and encouragement, and to bring me late night coffees to keep me going. This work I dedicate to her. TABLE OF CONTENTS Abstract. .................................................................................................................................ii Acknowledgements............................................................................................................. iii Table of Contents ............................................................................................................... iv The National War Memorial ................................................................................... v Introduction...........................................................................................................................1 Chapter 1 - 'The Spirit of the Nation': Finding a Representation of Canada's Great War Experience.......................................................................................................17 Chapter 2 — 'The Very Soul of the Nation is Here Revealed': The Making of the Canadian National War Memorial ............................................................................ 50 Chapter 3 - 'A Memorial to All Canadians': The National Shrine of Remembrance and the Remaking of the National War Memorial.............................. 87 Conclusion..........................................................................................................................120 Bibliography......................................................................................................................128 THE NATIONAL WAR MEMORIAL The National War Memorial, Ottawa (Photo: Malcolm Ferguson, September 15, 2012) INTRODUCTION In May 1923 Prime Minister William Lyon Mackenzie King announced to the House of Commons that the Government of Canada would erect a monument in commemoration of the nation’s accomplishments and sacrifices during the Great War. Shortly thereafter, the government determined the form it wanted the memorial to take and those ideas it believed the monument should convey to Canadians. In 1925 a competition was held that was open to all British subjects, as well as citizens of the allied countries during the war.1 From the 127 submissions, the proposal by British sculptor Vemon March, titled The Response, was selected as the winning design because it most closely fulfilled the government’s original vision of the memorial. The Prime Minister agreed with the competition judges’ selection and wrote that, when the monument was completed, “the capital will, I think, have one of the finest war memorials in the world.”2 Alterations to the memorial’s design, the death of March, the economic depression of the 1930s, and debates surrounding the site for the memorial all delayed the completion of the monument. On May 21, 1939, The Response was officially unveiled by King George VI, only months before the outbreak of another world war. The monument was located in the newly constructed Confederation Square in Ottawa, and dedicated to the Canadian soldiers who fought, were wounded, and died during the conflict. In the decades that followed, the role and purpose of the memorial changed. The National War Memorial evolved to become more than a commemoration of a single conflict. Later efforts to develop additional national commemorations of war indicate that by the late 1 Library and Archives Canada [henceforth LAC], RG 25, vol. 337, “Conditions of Competition for National Commemorative War Monument,” 1925, 6. 2 LAC, RG 11, vol. 4004, William Lyon Mackenzie King [henceforth WLMK] to J.H. King, January 22, 1926. 2 1950s and early 1960s Canadians understood the memorial to remember the Canadians who served in all wars. To understand the origins of the National War Memorial, it is necessary to know the context in which the project emerged. Prior to the First World War, Canada had little experience with the creation of national war memorials.3 While there were many memorials erected to honour particular regiments and commanding officers, few monuments were dedicated to the actions of all participants in Canada’s wars. With the high death tolls and the creation of citizen rather than professional armies, the Great War led to a desire to create memorials that recognized the sacrifices of all those who lost their lives. The years following the First World War witnessed a number of commemorative initiatives undertaken across the country to honour the nearly 620,000 Canadian soldiers who enlisted in the Canadian Expeditionary Force and the country’s 60,000 war dead. The forms that these commemorations took varied significantly, indicative of individual communities’ preferred method of memorializing their dead. Commemorative plaques, monuments, memorial halls, the renaming of streets after European battlefields, and a host of other forms of commemoration were created throughout the country. The post First World War period was a time of unprecedented commemoration. Nearly every community felt it necessary to honour their veterans
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Urban and Historic Context
    Architectural Rejuvenation Project URBAN AND HISTORIC CONTEXT Barry Padolsky Associates Inc., Architects, Urban Design and Heritage Consultants February 13, 2015 Aerial view of National Arts Centre (2010) TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction..................................................................................................................................2 Urban and Historic Context........................................................................................................2 . The Holt/Bennett Plan ................................................................................................................4 The Gréber Plan .........................................................................................................................6 The Parkin Plan ...........................................................................................................................8 Architecture and National Identity: the Centennial Projects .......................................................9 NAC: The Architectural Challenge ............................................................................................10 The Architectural Response .....................................................................................................13 Architectural Style: Polite “Brutalism” ......................................................................................16 Re-inventing “Brutalism”..........................................................................................................17 NCC Canada’s
    [Show full text]
  • Sir Edwin Lutyens Primary Helpsheet
    Sir Edwin Lutyens Sir Edwin Lutyens (29th March 1869 -1st January 1944) was one of the leading British architects of the 20th century. He was known for adapting traditional architectural styles to the needs of the time. His works include houses, bridges and public gardens. He was one of the three principal architects appointed to the Imperial (now Commonwealth) War Graves Commission (IWGC) when the Commission was formed in 1917 designing many memorials and cemeteries in France and Belgium in the years following the end of World War I. He also designed a number of war memorials in the UK, including The Cenotaph in Whitehall. This helpsheet is designed to be used by primary teachers as background information on Sir Edwin Lutyens. There is also a set of Sir Edwin Lutyens fact cards which can be shared with pupils. Both this helpsheet and the fact cards can be used as part of WMT’s Art unit of work: Great artists and war memorials. Early life Lutyens was born in London, the ninth son and tenth child of Charles and Mary Lutyens who went on to have a total of thirteen children. As a child he suffered from rheumatic fever and as such was the only one of the boys in the family not to go to public school or university. He shared his sisters’ governess and received extra schooling from a much older brother in the holidays. While growing up in Thursley, Surrey Lutyens was able to follow his passion of looking at houses and watched all stages of the buildings in the local area going up.
    [Show full text]
  • Peackeeping, Peace, Memory: Reflections on the Peacekeeping Monument in Ottawa
    Canadian Military History Volume 11 Issue 3 Article 6 2002 Peackeeping, Peace, Memory: Reflections on the eacekP eeping Monument in Ottawa Paul Gough University of the West of England, Bristol, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://scholars.wlu.ca/cmh Recommended Citation Gough, Paul "Peackeeping, Peace, Memory: Reflections on the eacekP eeping Monument in Ottawa." Canadian Military History 11, 3 (2002) This Canadian War Museum is brought to you for free and open access by Scholars Commons @ Laurier. It has been accepted for inclusion in Canadian Military History by an authorized editor of Scholars Commons @ Laurier. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Gough: Peackeeping, Peace, Memory Peacekeeping, Peace, Memory Reflections on the Peacekeeping Monument in Ottawa Paul Gough The Announcement In 1988, the Nobel Peace Prize was ince 1948, under the auspices of the awarded to the United Nations to mark United Nations (UN), Canada has S 40 years of international peacekeeping. contributed over 80,000 men and That same year the Department of women from all branches of the armed National Defence (DND) announced that forces to global peacekeeping. During a monument would be erected in the 1950s and 1960s, Canada was, in Ottawa, dedicated to Canadian forces fact, the greatest contributor of 'Blue that had served in peacekeeping duties. Helmet' soldiers to UN peacekeeping endeavours DND launched the so-called "Peacekeepers and became the undisputed leader in global Monument" competition in 1990, managed by a peacekeeping. Although peacekeeping was never committee consisting of representatives from the sole preoccupation of Canada's foreign policy, DND, the National Capital Commission, and Canadian politicians liked to be seen as Public Works Canada.
    [Show full text]
  • A Brief History of War Memorial Design
    A BRIEF HISTORY OF WAR MEMORIAL DESIGN War Memorials in Manitoba: An Artistic Legacy A BRIEF HISTORY OF WAR MEMORIAL DESIGN war memorial may take many forms, though for most people the first thing that comes to mind is probably a freestanding monument, whether more sculptural (such as a human figure) or architectural (such as an arch or obelisk). AOther likely possibilities include buildings (functional—such as a community hall or even a hockey rink—or symbolic), institutions (such as a hospital or endowed nursing position), fountains or gardens. Today, in the 21st century West, we usually think of a war memorial as intended primarily to commemorate the sacrifice and memorialize the names of individuals who went to war (most often as combatants, but also as medical or other personnel), and particularly those who were injured or killed. We generally expect these memorials to include a list or lists of names, and the conflicts in which those remembered were involved—perhaps even individual battle sites. This is a comparatively modern phenomenon, however; the ancestors of this type of memorial were designed most often to celebrate a victory, and made no mention of individual sacrifice. Particularly recent is the notion that the names of the rank and file, and not just officers, should be set down for remembrance. A Brief History of War Memorial Design 1 War Memorials in Manitoba: An Artistic Legacy Ancient Precedents The war memorials familiar at first hand to Canadians are most likely those erected in the years after the end of the First World War. Their most well‐known distant ancestors came from ancient Rome, and many (though by no means all) 20th‐century monuments derive their basic forms from those of the ancient world.
    [Show full text]
  • Nepean Point
    ON DESIGN COMPETITION NEPEAN POINT STAGE 01 - REQUEST FOR QUALIFICATIONS - AL1682 // 19.01.2017 Request for Qualifications - Stage 01 1 Cover: View of Nepean Point ON POINT ON POINT Design Competition for Nepean Point Stage 01 - Request for Qualifications - AL1682 19.01.2017 Nepean Point - Detail of existing fence TABLE OF CONTENTS A. Summary........................................................................................... p.06 01. Canada’s Capital ........................................................................... p.09 02. The Project .................................................................................... p.13 03. The Design Competition ................................................................ p.29 04. Stakeholders and Partners ........................................................... p.39 05. Additional Information ................................................................... p.46 Appendix 1 - Jury Biographies ............................................................ p.49 A SUMMARY The National Capital Commission (NCC) is pleased to launch the first COMPETITION PROCESS phase of a two-stage international design competition for Nepean Point, a promontory at the symbolic heart of Canada’s Capital, Ottawa. In the midst All interested design teams are invited to participate, but teams must be of numerous important public and private cultural institutions, the Nepean led by a landscape architect eligible to be licensed in Ontario, Canada. Point competition site, including two entranceways, is
    [Show full text]
  • THE MINISTRY 71 2.—The Ministry. a System of Government Based Upon
    THE MINISTRY 71 2.—The Ministry. A system of government based upon the British, by which a Cabinet or Ministry (composed of members of the House of Commons or the Senate), responsible to Parliament, holds office while it enjoys the confidence of the people's representatives, is found in Canada. The Cabmet is actually a committee of the King's Privy Council for Canada. Without enlarging upon the features of the system, it may be sufficient to note that the Cabmet is responsible to the House of Commons, and, following established precedent, resigns office when it becomes evident that it no longer holds the confidence of the people's representatives. Members of the Cabinet are chosen by the Prime Minister; each of them generally assumes charge of one of the various Departments of the Government, although one Minister may hold two portfolios at the same time, while other members may be without portfolio. The Prime Ministers since Confederation and the dates of their tenures of office, together with the members of the twelfth, thirteenth and fourteenth Minis­ tries, as on June 28, 1926, Aug. 31, 1926, and Oct. 15, 1926, are given in Table 2. 2.—Ministries since Confederation. NOTE.—A complete list of the members of Dominion Ministries from Confederation to 1913 appeared in the \ear Book of 1912, pp. 422-429. A list of the members of Dominion Ministries from 1911 to 1921 appeared in the Year Book of 1920, pp. 651-653. 1. Rt. Hon. Sir John A. Maodonald, Premier. From July 1,1867 to Nov. 6,1873.
    [Show full text]
  • Myth Making, Juridification, and Parasitical Discourse: a Barthesian Semiotic Demystification of Canadian Political Discourse on Marijuana
    MYTH MAKING, JURIDIFICATION, AND PARASITICAL DISCOURSE: A BARTHESIAN SEMIOTIC DEMYSTIFICATION OF CANADIAN POLITICAL DISCOURSE ON MARIJUANA DANIEL PIERRE-CHARLES CRÉPAULT Thesis submitted to the University of Ottawa in partial Fulfillment of the requirements for the Doctorate in Philosophy degree in Criminology Department of Criminology Faculty of Social Sciences University of Ottawa © Daniel Pierre-Charles Crépault, Ottawa, Canada, 2019 ABSTRACT The legalization of marijuana in Canada represents a significant change in the course of Canadian drug policy. Using a semiotic approach based on the work of Roland Barthes, this dissertation explores marijuana’s signification within the House of Commons and Senate debates between 1891 and 2018. When examined through this conceptual lens, the ongoing parliamentary debates about marijuana over the last 127 years are revealed to be rife with what Barthes referred to as myths, ideas that have become so familiar that they cease to be recognized as constructions and appear innocent and natural. Exploring one such myth—the necessity of asserting “paternal power” over individuals deemed incapable of rational calculation—this dissertation demonstrates that the processes of political debate and law-making are also a complex “politics of signification” in which myths are continually being invoked, (re)produced, and (re)transmitted. The evolution of this myth is traced to the contemporary era and it is shown that recent attempts to criminalize, decriminalize, and legalize marijuana are indices of a process of juridification that is entrenching legal regulation into increasingly new areas of Canadian life in order to assert greater control over the consumption of marijuana and, importantly, over the risks that this activity has been semiologically associated with.
    [Show full text]
  • History of Remembrance Day
    History of Remembrance Day On this sheet you will learn: lack of opportunity and support they had How Remembrance commemorations received since returning home and have changed since 1919. disagreeing with continued concentration on the dead when survivors needed help, History of Remembrance Day disrupted the service at the Cenotaph and this was repeated throughout the 1920s. At Remembrance Day in the UK takes place the same time, some young people began on 11th November, with the formal Act of holding celebrations on November 11th to Remembrance (usually a minute or two of celebrate the fact that the war was over silence) occurring at 11 o’ clock. This was and they could have fun once again, the exact moment the First World War although this had begun to decline in ended in 1918 – the eleventh hour of the favour of more sombre events by the mid- eleventh day of the eleventh month. 1920s. Today Remembrance Day is widely observed but, like war memorials themselves, the nature of the commemorations and people’s attitudes to them have changed over the years. After the initial jubilation at the signing of the Armistice in 1918, the first and second anniversaries of the end of the First World War had a solemn rather than victorious atmosphere and focused on mourning the dead rather than celebrating victory. The Cenotaph in Whitehall, at first a temporary structure but replaced in 1920 with a replica made of Portland stone, newly passing the coffin The Unknown Warrior’s London, 1920. Cenotaph in unveiled quickly became the focus for events as crowds gathered to lay wreaths.
    [Show full text]
  • Monuments and Memories in Ontario, 1850-2001
    FORGING ICONOGRAPHIES AND CASTING COLONIALISM: MONUMENTS AND MEMORIES IN ONTARIO, 1850-2001 By Brittney Anne Bos A thesis submitted to the Department of History In conformity with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Queen’s University Kingston, Ontario, Canada (September 2016) Copyright ©Brittney Anne Bos, 2016 ii Abstract Commemorations are a critical window for exploring the social, political, and cultural trends of a specific time period. Over the past two centuries, the commemorative landscape of Ontario reaffirmed the inclusion/exclusion of particular racial groups. Intended as static markers to the past, monuments in particular visually demonstrated the boundaries of a community and acted as ongoing memorials to existing social structures. Using a specific type of iconography and visual language, the creators of monuments imbued the physical markers of stone and bronze with racialized meanings. As builders were connected with their own time periods and social contexts, the ideas behind these commemorations shifted. Nonetheless, creators were intent on producing a memorial that educated present and future generations on the boundaries of their “imagined communities.” This dissertation considers the carefully chosen iconographies of Ontario’s monuments and how visual symbolism was attached to historical memory. Through the examination of five case studies, this dissertation examines the shifting commemorative landscape of Ontario and how memorials were used to mark the boundaries of communities. By integrating the visual analysis of monuments and related images, it bridges a methodological and theoretical gap between history and art history. This dissertation opens an important dialogue between these fields of study and demonstrates how monuments themselves are critical “documents” of the past.
    [Show full text]
  • Discover Canada the Rights and Responsibilities of Citizenship 2 Your Canadian Citizenship Study Guide
    STUDY GUIDE Discover Canada The Rights and Responsibilities of Citizenship 2 Your Canadian Citizenship Study Guide Message to Our Readers The Oath of Citizenship Le serment de citoyenneté Welcome! It took courage to move to a new country. Your decision to apply for citizenship is Je jure (ou j’affirme solennellement) another big step. You are becoming part of a great tradition that was built by generations of pioneers I swear (or affirm) Que je serai fidèle before you. Once you have met all the legal requirements, we hope to welcome you as a new citizen with That I will be faithful Et porterai sincère allégeance all the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. And bear true allegiance à Sa Majesté la Reine Elizabeth Deux To Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth the Second Reine du Canada Queen of Canada À ses héritiers et successeurs Her Heirs and Successors Que j’observerai fidèlement les lois du Canada And that I will faithfully observe Et que je remplirai loyalement mes obligations The laws of Canada de citoyen canadien. And fulfil my duties as a Canadian citizen. Understanding the Oath Canada has welcomed generations of newcomers Immigrants between the ages of 18 and 54 must to our shores to help us build a free, law-abiding have adequate knowledge of English or French In Canada, we profess our loyalty to a person who represents all Canadians and not to a document such and prosperous society. For 400 years, settlers in order to become Canadian citizens. You must as a constitution, a banner such as a flag, or a geopolitical entity such as a country.
    [Show full text]
  • Alexander Manson Fonds (RBSC- ARC-1350)
    University of British Columbia Library Rare Books and Special Collections Finding Aid - Alexander Manson fonds (RBSC- ARC-1350) Generated by Access to Memory (AtoM) 2.4.0 Printed: January 29, 2019 Language of description: English University of British Columbia Library Rare Books and Special Collections Irving K. Barber Learning Centre 1961 East Mall Vancouver British Columbia V6T 1Z1 Telephone: 604-822-2521 Fax: 604-822-9587 Email: [email protected] http://rbsc.library.ubc.ca/ http://rbscarchives.library.ubc.ca//index.php/alexander-manson-fonds Alexander Manson fonds Table of contents Summary information ...................................................................................................................................... 3 Administrative history / Biographical sketch .................................................................................................. 3 Scope and content ........................................................................................................................................... 4 Arrangement .................................................................................................................................................... 5 Notes ................................................................................................................................................................ 5 Access points ................................................................................................................................................... 6 Physical
    [Show full text]
  • PART III.—REGISTER of OFFICIAL APPOINTMENTS* the Following List Includes Official Appointments for the Period Sept
    1164 MISCELLANEOUS DATA PART III.—REGISTER OF OFFICIAL APPOINTMENTS* The following list includes official appointments for the period Sept. 1, 1962 to Nov. 15, 1963, continuing the list published in the 1962 Year Book at pp. 1176-1181. Appointments to the Governor General's staff, judicial appointments other than those to the Supreme Court of Canada, and appointments of limited or local importance are not included. Queen's Privy Council for Canada.—1962. Oct. 15, Mark Robert Drouin, Sillery, Que.; and Roland Michener, Toronto, Ont.: to be members. Dec. 21, Rt. Hon. John George Diefenbaker, Prime Minister of Canada: to be President. 1963. Feb. 12, Marcel- Joseph-Aime Lambert, Edmonton, Alta.: to be a member. Feb. 20, Major-General Georges P. Vanier, Governor General of Canada: to be a member. Mar. 18, J.-H. Theogene Ricard, St. Hyacinthe, Que.; Frank Charles McGee, Don Mills, Ont.; and Martial Asselin, La Malbaie, Que.: to be members. Apr. 22, Walter Lockhart Gordon, Toronto, Ont.; Mitchell Sharp, Toronto, Ont.; Azellus Denis, Montreal, Que.; George James Mcllraith, Ottawa, Ont.; William Moore Benidickson, Kenora, Ont.; Arthur Laing, Vancouver, B.C.; John Richard Garland, North Bay, Ont.; Lucien Cardin, Sorel, Que.; Allan Joseph Mac- Eachen, Inverness, N.S.; Jean-Paul Deschatelets, Montreal, Que.; Hedard Robichaud, Caraquet, N.B.; J. Watson MacNaught, Summerside, P.E.I.; Roger Teillet, St. Boniface, Man.; Miss Judy LaMarsh, Niagara Falls, Ont.; Charles Mills Drury, Westmount, Que.; Guy Favreau, Montreal, Que.; John Robert Nicholson, Vancouver, B.C.; Harry Hays, Calgary, Alta.; Rene Tremblay, Quebec, Que.; and Maurice Lamontagne, Montreal, Que.: to be members, Maurice Lamontagne to be also President.
    [Show full text]