Human Ecology Review
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Human Ecology Review Editor Book Review Editor Robert Dyball Thomas Burns Human Ecology Program Department of Sociology Fenner School of Environment and Society University of Oklahoma The Australian National University Copy Editor Philosophy Papers Editor Tracy Harwood Carleton B. Christensen School of Philosophy Assistant Editor Research School of Social Sciences Rachael Wakefield-Rann The Australian National University Contact: [email protected]. Founders Jonathan G. Taylor & Scott D. Wright Editorial Board Annie Booth University of Northern British Columbia Andrew Jorgenson Washington State University Richard J. Borden College of the Atlantic Ardeshir Mahdavi Vienna University of Technology Lee Cerveny USDA Forest Service Angela Mertig Middle Tennessee State University Debra Davidson University of Alberta Floyd Myron North Carolina State University Federico Dickinson Unidad Merida Ehsan Nabavi The Australian National University Thomas Dietz Michigan State University Liam Phelan University of Newcastle Alan Ewert Indiana University Peter Richerson University of California, Davis Myron Floyd University of Florida J. Timmons Roberts College of William & Mary R. Scott Frey University of North Florida Helen Roland California State University, Sacramento Bernhard Glaeser Science Center Berlin Frey Scott University of Northern British Colombia Catherine Gross The Australian National University Pablo Serrano Universidad Técnica Particular de Loja Luc Hens Free University, Brussels Joanne Vining University of Illinois, Urbana Udith Jayasinghe-Mudalige Wayamba Univ. of Sri Lanka Michael Welsh Keene State College Cassandra Y. Johnson USDA Forest Service Richard York University of Oregon Human Ecology Review is the offiil junl o te Scey fr Hmn Eooy ad i publishe in open access online format by ANU Press (press.anu.edu.au). It is also available to member and institutional subscribers in hard copy format. Human Ecology Review is indexed or abstracted in Environment Abstracts, Environmental Knowledgebase, Environmental Periodicals Bibliography, Linguistic and Language Behavior Abstracts, Social Planning and Policy Abstracts, and Sociological Abstracts. Archived back issues are available from the Society for Human Ecology website, societyforhumanecology.org, and via ProQuest. Send submissions in electronic format to http://mstracker.com/submit1.php?jc=her. Please see instructions to authors on inside back cover. © Society for Human Ecology Information for contributors to Human Ecology Review Human Ecology Review is a semi-annual journal that publishes peer-reviewed interdisciplinary research on all aspects of human–environment interactions (Research in Human Ecology). The journal also publishes essays, discussion papers, dialogue, and commentary on special topics relevant to human ecology (Human Ecology Forum), book reviews (Contemporary Human Ecology), and letters, announcements, and other items of interest (Human Ecology Bulletin). As of volume 20(2) Human Ecology Review will also publish an occasional paper series in Philosophy of Human Ecology and Social–Environmental Sustainability. Author instructions the text. Authors must obtain copyright permission to reproduce any material that is not their own. Send submissions, following the guidelines below, to mstracker.com/submit1.php?jc=her Although figures should be embedded in the original submitted paper, if your manuscript Title page, abstract and authorship is accepted you will be required to provide When you access the Human Ecology Review professional quality, high resolution (at least manuscript submission portal at mstracker.com/ 300 dpi) images in separate files. submit1.php?jc=her you will be presented with a manuscript submission form. You will be instructed References to enter the title of your manuscript, an abstract, References should conform to APA style. and your and any co-authors names and contact See below; also see www.apastyle.org details. The abstract should be 150 words or fewer The list of references should be arranged and include four to six keywords. The abstract alphabetically by author. Multiple citations by information will be used when soliciting for reviewers the same author(s) should be listed by name. and should not contain any author identification. Citation of references in the text should follow the format Henry (1998) or (Henry & Wright, 1997) Reviewers or (Henry et al., 1996, pp. 22–24) or (Henry, 1995, Please use the manuscript submission form’s 1998; Wright, 1994). In-text citations should be in cover letter section to provide the names and alphabetical order, in the same order in which they contact information of three suggested reviewers appear in the reference list. Papers with three or for your manuscript. more authors should use et al. This is an exception to APA style. Manuscript The manuscript should not exceed 6,500 words. Sample references Do not include author information. Please limit Altman, I., & Low, S. (Eds.). (1992). Place references to 50 or fewer. attachment. New York: Plenum. The manuscript should be in the form of a single Cohen, J. (1995). How many people can the Earth Word document file that includes tables and figures support? New York: W. W. North. rather than sending multiple files. It should be in 12 Schoenfeld, A. C., Meier, R., & Griffi, R J (1979) point font, line spacing 1.5. The entire manuscript Constructing a social problem: The press and the should be free of underlining or boldface type; environment. Social Problems, 27, 38–61. use italics only for emphasis and in references (see below). Headings and subheadings should be flush Varner, G. (1995). Can animal rights activists be left, sentence capitalization. environmentalists? In C. Pierce & D. VanDeVeer (Eds.), People, penguins, and plastic trees (2nd Style followed is that of the Publication Manual ed.) (pp. 254–273). Belmont, CA: Wadsworth. of the American Psychological Association (APA style; www.apastyle.org). The dictionary used is Merriam-Webster. Information for subscribers Footnotes Footnotes, not endnotes, should be used. Human Ecology Review is published by ANU Press Tables and figures The Australian National University Canberra ACT 0200, Australia Tables should be clear and concise and able to Email: [email protected] stand alone, that is, complete headings and table This title is available online at press.anu.edu.au notes should be used to clarify entries. Figures may be in color, but authors should be mindful of loss of ISSN 1074-4827 (print) resolution or clarity if figures are printed in black and ISSN 2204-0919 (online) white. All tables and figures must be referred to in Printed by Griffi Pres Cover and page layout by ANU Press HUMAN ECOLOGY REVIEW Volume 20, Number 2, 2014 RESEARCH AND THEORY IN HUMAN ECOLOGY Conservation Science Policies Versus Scientific Practice: Evidence from 3 a Mexican Biosphere Reserve Gabriela Alonso-Yañez and Conny Davidsen Human Ecology as Philosophy 31 Carleton B. Christensen Use of Cultivated and Harvested Edible Plants by Caiçaras—What can 51 Ethnobotany Add to Food Security Discussions? Mariana Giraldi and Natalia Hanazaki Community-Based Water Systems: Preserving Livelihood, Ecology, 75 and Community David S. Henkel Qualitative Indicators of Social Resilience in Small-Scale Fishing 97 Communities: An Emphasis on Perceptions and Practice Teresa R. Johnson, Anna M. Henry, and Cameron Thompson Place Matters: An Investigation of Farmers’ Attachment to Their Land 117 Courtney E. Quinn and Angela C. Halfacre Environmental Identity and Community Support for the Preservation 133 of Open Space Janet K. Swim, Stephanie J. Zawadzki, Jessica L. Cundiff, and Bruce Lord Visualizing Stakeholder Perspectives for Reflection and Dialogue on 157 Scale Dynamics in Social–Ecological Systems J. M. Vervoort, M. A. Hoogstra, K. Kok, R. van Lammeren, A. K. Bregt, and R. Janssen BOOK REVIEWS The Sixth Extinction: An Unnatural History, by Elizabeth Kolbert 185 Reviewed by Jordan Fox Besek Energy and Electricity in Industrial Nations: The Sociology and 189 Technology of Energy, by Allan Mazur Reviewed by Richard York Defensive Environmentalists and the Dynamics of Global Reform, 193 by Thomas K. Rudel Reviewed by Thomas J. Burns Contributors to this issue 197 On the Cover College of the Atlantic’s historic Seaside Garden. Image courtesy of the College of the Atlantic Archives. RESEARCH AND THEORY IN HUMAN ECOLOGY Conservation Science Policies Versus Scientific Practice: Evidence from a Mexican Biosphere Reserve Gabriela Alonso-Yañez1 Werklund School of Education University of Calgary, Canada Conny Davidsen Geography Department University of Calgary, Canada Abstract This paper interrogates the activities, perspectives, and positions of scientists conducting research in Sierra de Huautla Biosphere Reserve, Mexico. Biosphere reserve conservation models are specifically designed for a sustainable integration of social and natural environments, a mandate that relies on both natural and social scientific research to improve conservation of nature and human well-being. Seen through the analytical lens of a social worlds/arenas framework, integrative scientific research in this particular case proves to be challenging in practice and fraught with paradoxes and contradictions. The findings suggest that academic and institutional factors (funding, publication avenues, and scholarly status) force, or at least strongly invite, scientists to pursue academic research agendas which, in fact, may conflict with or override the researchers’