Curriculum Vitae Danielle Macbeth

Department of Haverford College 370 Lancaster Avenue Haverford PA 19041-1392 610-896-1025 FAX 610-896-4926 [email protected]

Education: Ph.D. (1988) Philosophy, Dissertation: “Making Sense of Intentionality” Director: John Haugeland B.A. (1980) Philosophy and Religious Studies, Honors, First Class, McGill University B.Sc. (1977) Biochemistry, Honors, First Class, University of Alberta

Academic Appointments: Spring 2015 Chair, Department of Philosophy, Haverford College 2009-2012 Chair, Department of Philosophy, Haverford College 2006- T. Wistar Brown Professor of Philosophy, Haverford College 2006 Visiting Professor, Soochow University, Taipei, Taiwan 2005-2006 Professor of Philosophy, Haverford College 1998-2001 Chair, Department of Philosophy, Haverford College 1996-2005 Associate Professor of Philosophy, Haverford College 1989-1996 Assistant Professor of Philosophy, Haverford College 1986-1989 Lecturer in Philosophy, University of Hawaii

Honors and Awards: 2002-2003 Fellow, Center for Advanced Study in the Behavioral Sciences 2000 ACLS Frederick Burkhardt Residential Fellowship 1997 NEH Fellowship for College Teachers and Independent Scholars 1990 NEH Summer Institute Fellowship 1981-1985 Doctoral Fellowship, Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada 1980-1981 MA Scholarship, Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada 1980-1981 MA Scholarship, Fonds F.C.A.C. (Quebec) 1980 University Scholar, McGill University 1980 W. M. Birks Award in Religious Studies, McGill University 1980 E. S. Reford Scholarship in Philosophy, McGill University 1979 University Scholar, McGill University 1979 James McGill Award, McGill University 1979 E. Hurlbatt Scholarship, McGill University 1977 Gold Medal in Biochemistry, University of Alberta

Research Interests: and epistemology, , , philosophy of logic, history and philosophy of mathematics.

Publications: Books: 2014 Realizing Reason: A Narrative of Truth and Knowing (Oxford: Oxford University Press). 2005 Frege’s Logic (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press).

Articles: (2017) “Reading Rorty: A Sketch of a Plan” in A Companion to Rorty, ed. Alan Malachowski (Wiley-Blackwell). 2017 “The Place of Philosophy”, Philosophy East and West 67 (4): 966 – 985. 2017 “Descartes on the Creation of the Eternal Truths”, Acta Baltica Historiae et Philosophiae Scientiarum 5 (1): 5 – 27. 2017 “Précis of Realizing Reason: A Narrative of Truth and Knowing” (DOI: 10.1080/0967559.2016.1275330) and “Responses to Brassier, Redding, and Wolfsdorf” (DOI: 10.1080/09672559.2016.1275332), as part of a book symposium on Realizing Reason with contributions by Ray Brassier, American University of Beirut, Paul Redding, Sydney University, and David Wolfsdorf, Temple University, in the International Journal of Philosophical Studies 24:5. 2017 “Natural Truth” in Sellars and , ed. David Pereplyotchik and Deborah R. Barnbaum (Routledge). 2017 “Being Minded”, in Giving a Damn: Essays in Dialogue with John Haugeland, ed. Zed Adams and Jake Brown (MIT Press). 2016 “Frege and the Aristotelian Model of Science”, in Early : New Perspectives on the Tradition, ed. Sorin Costreie (Springer), pp. 31-48. 2015 “Waiting for the Revolution”, Expositions: Interdisciplinary Studies in the Humanities 9.2: 80-87. Expositions (online) ISSN: 1747-5376. 2015 “Reasoning in Mathematics and Machines: The Place of Mathematical Logic in Mathematical Understanding”, AISB Convention 2015 Proceedings (online). 2014 “Logic Through Its History”, APA Newsletter on Teaching Philosophy 14 (1): 8-12. 2013 “Writing Reason”, Logique et Analyse 221: 25-44. 2013 “Revolution in Philosophy”, GSTF Digital Library. DOI: 10.5176/2382- 5677_PYTT13.19. 2012 “Diagrammatic Reasoning in Frege’s Begriffsschrift”, Synthese 186: 289- 314. Special issue: Diagrams in Mathematics: History and Philosophy. 2012 “Varieties of Analytic Pragmatism”, Philosophia 40 (1): 27-39. 2012 “Proof and Understanding in Mathematical Practice”, Philosophia Scientiae 16 (1): 29-54. 2011 “Reading Rorty: A Sketch of a Plan”, Annales Philosophici 2: 66-73.

2011 “Seeing How It Goes: Paper-and-Pencil Reasoning in Mathematical Practice”, Philosophia Mathematica 20 (1): 58-85. 2010 “Varieties of Analytic Pragmatism”, Philosophia, online at http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s11406-010-9237-x. 2010 “Inference, Meaning, and Truth in Brandom, Sellars, and Frege”, in Reading Brandom: On Making It Explicit, eds. Bernhard Weiss and Jeremy Wanderer (Routledge). 2010 “Diagrammatic Reasoning in Euclid’s Elements”, in Philosophical Perspectives on Mathematical Practice, Texts in Philosophy, vol. 12, ed. Bart Van Kerkhove, Jonas De Vuyst, and Jean Paul Van Bendegem (London: College Publications). 2009 “Quine on Analytic Truth and A Priori Science”, in Cuvinte, teorii, si lucruri: Quine în perspectiva, ed. Mircea Dumitru and Constantin Stoenescu (Bucharest: Editura Pelican). 2009 “An Antinomy of Empirical Judgment: Brandom and McDowell”, in Italian, Lo Spazio Sociale della Ragione: De Hegel in Avanti, ed. Luigi Ruggiu and Italo Testa (Milan: Mimesis). 2009 “The Problem of Mathematical Truth”, Studies in Logic 2: 1-17. 2009 “Meaning, Use, and Diagrams”, Ethics and Politics 11: 369-384. Special issue on prelinguistic practice, social ontology, and semantics. Available at http://www.units.it/etica. 2008 “The Truth in Pragmatism”, Philosophy of Pragmatism II: Salient Inquiries, ed. Bogdan Dicher and Adrian Ludusan (Cluj-Napoca, Romania: European Studies Foundation). 2008 “The Truths of Logic and Logical Truth”, Manuscrito 31: 51-67. 2008 “Logic and the Foundations of Mathematics”, The Oxford Handbook of , ed. Cheryl Misak (Oxford: Oxford University Press). 2008 “From Contingency to Solidarity: Rorty’s Pragmatist Turn”, Soochow Journal of Philosophical Studies 17: 1-9. 2007 “Understanding the Goodness of Inference: Modality and Relevance in Frege’s System of Logic”, Soochow Journal of Philosophical Studies 16: 133-151. (Special conference proceedings issue.) 2007 “Naturalism in the Philosophy of Mathematics”, in Naturalized Epistemology and Philosophy of Science, Rodopi Philosophical Studies 7, ed. Chienkuo Michael Mi and Ruey-lin Chen (Amsterdam: Rodopi). 2007 “Logical Analysis, Reduction, and Philosophical Understanding”, Croatian Journal of Philosophy 7: 475-485. 2007 “Striving for Truth in the Practice of Mathematics: Kant and Frege”, Grazer Philosophische Studien 75: 65-92. 2007 “Pragmatism and Objective Truth”, in New Pragmatists, ed. Cheryl Misak (Oxford University Press). 2006 “Logical Analysis, Reduction, and Philosophical Understanding”, translated into Hungarian, Pro Philosophia Füzetek 45: 127-139. Also available in Hungarian at http://www.c3.hu/~prophil/profi061/macbeth.html 2005 “Inferentialism and Holistic Role Abstraction in the Telling of Tales”, European Journal of Philosophy 13: 409-420.

2005 “Reading Begriffsschrift”, Harvard Review of Philosophy 13: 4-24. 2004 “Overcoming Kant: McDowell, and Sellars, on Judgment”, Theoria 70: 216-242. 2004 “Viète, Descartes, and the Emergence of Modern Mathematics”, Graduate Faculty Philosophy Journal 25: 87-117. 2004 “Putnam’s New Realism”, translated into Italian, Iride 41: 211-215. 2002 “Frege and Early Wittgenstein on Logic and Language”, in From Frege to Wittgenstein: Essays on Early Analytic Philosophy, ed. Erich Reck (Oxford University Press). 2000 “Empirical Knowledge: Kantian Themes and Sellarsian Variations”, Philosophical Studies 101: 113-142. 1997 “Brandom on Inference and the Expressive Role of Logic”, in Truth: Proceedings of the 9th SOFIA Conference, ed. E. Villanueva (Atascadero: Ridgeview, 1997), pp. 169-179. 1995 “Pragmatism and the Philosophy of Language”, Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 55: 501-523. Also available at: http://csmaclab- www.uchicago.edu/philosophyProject/sellars/macbeth/macbeth.html. Reprinted in Richard Rorty, four volumes, edited Alan Malachowski (Oxford University Press, 2002). 1995 “Names, Natural Kind Terms, and Rigid Designation”, Philosophical Studies 79: 259-281. 1995 “The Logic of Relations and the Ideality of Space”, Journal of Philosophical Research 20: 367-379. 1994 “The Coin of the Intentional Realm”, Journal for the Theory of Social Behavior 24: 143-166.

Reviews: 2014 Of Patricia Blanchette, Frege’s Conception of Logic (Oxford University Press, 2012) in Journal of the History of Philosophy 52 (1): 176-7. 2008 Of Guillermo E. Rosado Haddock, A Critical Introduction to the Philosophy of (Aldershot, England: Ashgate, 2006), in History and Philosophy of Logic 29 (3): 280-1. 2006 Of Tyler Burge, Truth, Thought, Reason: Essays on Frege (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 2005), in Philosophy in Review 26: 79-82. 2002 Of Willem deVries and Tomm Triplett, Knowledge, Mind and the Given (Indianapolis and Cambridge: Hackett, 2000), in Philosophical Review 111: 281-284. 1993 Of Bruce Aune, Knowledge of the External World (London and New York: Routledge, 1991), in History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences 15: 258-260.

Encyclopedia articles: 2010 “Language, Natural and Symbolic”, Cambridge Encyclopaedia of the Language Sciences, ed. Patrick Hogan (Cambridge University Press). 2010 “Pragmatism and Language”, Cambridge Encyclopaedia of the Language Sciences, ed. Patrick Hogan(Cambridge University Press).

2006 “McDowell, John”, The Encyclopedia of Philosophy, second edition, (Detroit: Macmillan Reference USA). 1999 “Sellars, Wilfrid”, Encyclopedia Americana electronic version (CD).

Dictionary entry: 2015 “McDowell, John”, The Cambridge Dictionary of Philosophy, third edition, ed. Robert Audi (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).

Lectures: (2018) Keynote lecture, Workshop: Around Peirce, Sixth World Congress and School on Universal Logic, Vichy, France. (2018) Keynote lecture, 32nd International Symposium Logica 2018, Institute of Philosophy, Czech Academy of Sciences, Hejnice, Czech Republic. (2017) TBA, Roundtable: “Emerging Approaches, Methodologies in Mathematics and the Humanities”, Society of Literature, Science and the Arts, Arizona State University, Tempe. (2017) “Visualizing and Knowing in Mathematical Practice”, Workshop on Varieties of Visualization in Mathematics, Fourth International Meeting of the Association for the Philosophy of Mathematical Practice, Salvador da Bahia, Brazil. (2017) “Formal Proof in Mathematical Practice”, joint meeting of the Ninth French PhilMath Workshop (FPMW 9) and the ANR/DFG research project “Mathematics: by Representation”, Nancy, France. (2017) “Ampliative Deductive Proof in Mathematical Practice: Lessons from Kant and Frege”, Philosophy Colloquium, Department of Philosophy, University of Pittsburgh. 2017 “Proof in Mathematics and in Logic”, 31st International Symposium Logica 2017, Institute of Philosophy, Czech Academy of Sciences, Hejnice, Czech Republic. 2017 “Reasoning in Minds and Machines”, Women in Philosophy: Philosophy in Action, Uppsala University, Sweden. 2017 Invited speaker (five hours per day for three days), Spring Meeting of PAF (Performing Arts Forum), St. Erme, France. 2016 “Inferentialism After Kant”, Why Rules Matter: Workshop on Inferentialism, Institute of Philosophy, Czech Academy of Science, Prague, Czech Republic 2016 Haverford Faculty Publication Talk, Haverford College, Haverford, Pennsylvania. 2016 “Sellars on the Rationality of Empirical Inquiry”, Amherst College, Amherst, Massachusetts. 2016 “Ampliative Deductive Proof in Mathematical Practice”, Conference IV of the Brazilian Society for Analytic Philosophy, State University of Campinas (Unicamp), Campinas, Brazil. 2016 “A Non-Structuralist Alternative to Formalism”, Charles University and the Czech Academy of Sciences, “The Emergence of Structuralism and Formalism”, Prague, Czech Republic 2016 “Logic in Revolution”, 12th International Conference, “Logic Today:

Developments and Perspectives”, St. Petersburg State University, Saint Petersburg, Russia. 2016 “The Place of Philosophy”, 11th East-West Philosophers’ Conference, Honolulu, Hawaii, topic: Place. 2016 Author-Meets-Critics session on Realizing Reason: A Narrative of Truth and Knowing, meeting of the Society in conjunction with the Pacific APA meeting, San Francisco. Critics: Ray Brassier, American University of Beirut, and Paul Redding, University of Sydney, with author’s response. 2015 “Revolution in Philosophy”, The NYC Wittgenstein Workshop, New School for Social Research, New York City. 2015 “Logical Form, Mathematical Practice, and Frege’s Begriffsschrift”. Invited lecture, Third International Meeting of the Association for the Philosophy of Mathematical Practice (APMP), Paris. 2015 “Logical Form, Mathematical Practice, and Frege’s Begriffsschrift”, invited lecture, Georgetown University. Georgetown. 2015 Author-Meets-Critics: Realizing Reason: A Narrative of Truth and Knowing, session of the Greater Philadelphia Philosophy Consortium (GPPC), Haverford College. Speakers were Emily Grosholtz, Penn State University, David Wolfsdorf, Temple University, and Alan Baker, Swarthmore College, response by me. 2015 “Yet Another Consequence of Pragmatism”. Invited lecture in the session Neo-Pragmatism and Metaphysics at the European Pragmatism Conference II, Paris. 2015 Symposium on Realizing Reason: A Narrative of Truth and Knowing, at the 15th Congress of Logic, Methodology, and Philosophy of Science (CLMPS 2015). Speakers were José Ferreirós, University of Seville, Juliette Kennedy, University of Helsinki, response by me. 2015 “Logical Form, Mathematical Practice, and Frege’s Begriffsschrift”, plenary lecture, the 2015 European Summer Meeting of the Association for Symbolic Logic, Logic Colloquium 2015, Helsinki. 2015 “Natural Truth”, invited lecture, Sellars Conference, “Sellars’s Legacy: Consequences, Ramifications, New Directions”, American University of Beirut, Beirut, Lebanon. 2015 “Natural Truth”, invited lecture, Sellars Conference, Sellars in a New Generation”, Kent State University. 2015 “Reasoning in Mathematics and Machines: The Place of Mathematical Logic in Mathematical Understanding”, keynote address, Society for the Study of and Simulated Behavior (AISB) convention, session on Social Aspects of Cognition and Computing, University of Kent, Canterbury, England. 2015 “Mathematical Meaning in Mathematics Pedagogy”. Cultures of Mathematics IV, New Delhi, India. 2015 “Revolution in Philosophy”, invited lecture, Philosophy Club, Kutztown University of Pennsylvania. 2014 “The Myth of the Given, Again”, invited lecture, The Wilfrid Sellars Society Group Meeting of the American Philosophical Association,

Eastern Division Meeting. 2014 “Mathematical Logic, Mathematical Understanding”. Keynote address, International Workshop on Logic and Philosophy of Mathematics, Vrije Universiteit Brussel, Brussels. 2014 “Revolution and Realism?” New Thinking About Scientific Realism Conference, Cape Town, South Africa. 2014 “Revolution and Realism?” HOPOS 2014, Congress of the International Society for the History and Philosophy of Science, Ghent, Belgium. 2014 “Mathematics and the Metaphysics of Mind”, The Mind Initiative, Tri-Co Mellon Seed Grant initiative. 2014 “Names and Definite Descriptions”, invited lecture to Shizhe Huang’s semantics class. 2014 “Reasoning in Mathematics” in two lectures, “Ancient and Early Modern Practice” and “Contemporary Practice”, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, El Instituto de Investigaciones Filosóficas. 2013 “Revolution in Philosophy”, PYTT 2013, first annual meeting of Philosophy: Yesterday, Today, and Tomorrow, Singapore. Awarded best paper. 2013 “Rigor, Deduction, and Knowledge in the Practice of Mathematics”, Second International Meeting of the Association for the Philosophy of Mathematical Practice, University of Illinois, Urbana-Champagne. 2013 “Conceptions of Logical Form”, World Congress of Philosophy 2013, Athens, Greece, invited session on The Character of Classical Logic. 2013 “Logical Form in Mathematical Practice”, annual meeting of the Society for the Study of the History of Analytic Philosophy, Indiana University, Bloomington, Indiana. 2013 “Logical Form in Mathematical Practice”, meeting of the Society for the Study of the History of Analytic Philosophy, in conjunction with the American Philosophical Association Central Meeting, New Orleans. 2013 “Logic Through Its History”, Invited session on Logic in Undergraduate Philosophy Education, Association for Symbolic Logic, 2013 Joint Meeting with the American Philosophical Association, New Orleans. 2012 “The Puzzle of Logic in Relation to Mathematics”, Keynote address, inaugural meeting of the Philosophy of Mathematics Association, . 2012 Five lectures at the Centro de Investigaciones de la Facultad de Filosofia y Humanidades, Universidad Nacional de Cordoba, Cordoba, Argentina. (1) “Realizing Reason: The Power of Reason as a Power of Knowing”; (2) Seeing How It Goes: Ancient Diagrammatic Practice and Early Modern Algebraic Practice”; (3) “Seeing How It Goes: Deductive Reasoning from Defined Concepts”; (4)“The Metaphysics of Judgment: Truth and Knowledge in the Exact Sciences”; and (5) “Being Minded”. 2011 “Reading Rorty: A Sketch of a Plan”. The New School for Social Research, New York. 2011 “Seeing How It Goes: The Peculiar Role of Writing in Mathematical Reasoning”, The Fifth Joint Conference of The British Society for the History of Mathematics and The Canadian Society for History and

Philosophy of Mathematics, Trinity College, Dublin. 2011 “Proof and Understanding in Mathematical Practice”, Association for the Philosophy of Mathematical Practice, Affiliated Session of the 14th Congress of Logic, Methodology and Philosophy of Science, Nancy, France. 2011 “Reasoning in the Languages of Mathematics”, Third Pittsburgh Summer School in Philosophy of Mathematics, University of Pittsburgh. 2011 “Seeing How It Goes: The Peculiar Role of Writing in Mathematical Reasoning”, Bucharest Colloquium in Analytic Philosophy: Frege’s Philosophy of Mathematics and Language, Bucharest, Romania. 2011 “Names and Definite Descriptions”, presentation to Shizhe Huang’s linguistic students, Haverford College. 2011 “Proof and Understanding in Mathematical Practice”, Waikato University, Hamilton, New Zealand. 2011 “Proof and Understanding in Mathematical Practice”, Victoria University, Wellington, New Zealand. 2011 “Seeing How It Goes: The Peculiar Role of Writing in Mathematical Practice”, Keynote lecture, Conference on Logical Pragmatism, University of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand. 2011 “Seeing How It Goes: The Peculiar Role of Writing in Mathematical Practice”, Otago University, Dunedin, New Zealand. 2011 “Seeing How It Goes: The Peculiar Role of Writing in Mathematical Practice”, Massey University, Palmerston North, New Zealand. 2011 “Proof and Understanding in Mathematical Practice”, Keynote lecture, Conference on the Notion of Form in 19th and 20th Century Logic and Mathematics, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam. 2011 “Seeing How It Goes: The Peculiar Role of Writing in Mathematical Practice”, History of Philosophy Colloquium, Utrecht University. 2010 “Frege and the Aristotelian Model of Science”, First International Meeting of the Association for the Philosophy of Mathematical Practice, Brussels, Belgium. 2010 “Logical Expressivism and Semantic Inferentialism in Frege” and “Frege’s Analytic Pragmatism”, ISSCSS 2010, University of Latvia, Riga Latvia. 2010 “Reasoning in the Languages of Mathematics”, “From Practice to Results in Logic and Mathematics”, conference of the PratiScienS group, Nancy, France. 2010 “Diagrammatic Reasoning in Frege’s Begriffsschrift”, University of Paris VII (Diderot). 2010 “Frege’s Proof of Theorem 133: A Case Study in Ampliative Proof”, Conference on Early Analytic Philosophy, University of Bucharest. 2010 “Seeing How It Goes: The Peculiar Role of Writing in Mathematical Reasoning”, Faculty Research Talk, Haverford College. 2010 “Reasoning in Diagrams: The Case of Begriffsschrift”, Unilog 2010, Third World Congress on Universal Logic, Lisbon, Portugal; keynote lecture in the Diagrams in Logic session. 2010 “Ampliative Deductive Proof: A Case Study”, Program in Pure and

Applied Logic, Indiana University. 2010 “Names and Definite Descriptions”, presentation to Shizhe Huang’s linguistic students, Haverford College. 2010 “Mathematical Reasoning in Euclid and Frege”, Swarthmore College. 2009 “The Role of Diversity in a Liberal Arts Education”, Multicultural Open House, Haverford College. 2009 “Ampliative Deductive Proof: A Case Study”, Conference on Practice- Based Philosophy of Logic, Amsterdam. 2009 “Reasoning in Frege’s Begriffsschrift”, National Chung Cheng University, Chai Yi, Taiwan. 2009 “Pictures of Meaning: Language in the Tractatus and the Philosophical Investigations”, National Taiwan University, Taipei, Taiwan. 2009 “Reasoning in Frege’s Begriffsschrift”, Workshop on Logic, Soochow University, Taipei, Taiwan. 2009 “Varieties of Analytic Pragmatism”, Workshop on Analytic Pragmatism, University of Genoa. 2008 “Reasoning from Definitions by Logic Alone: A Case Study in Ampliative Proof”, University of Bucharest. 2008 “Quine on Analytic Truth and A Priori Science”, Conference on Quine, University of Bucharest. 2008 “Reasoning from Definitions by Logic Alone: A Case Study in Ampliative Proof”, University of Buenos Aires. 2008 “Pictures of Meaning: Language in the Tractatus and the Philosophical Investigations”, IX International Philosophy Colloquium, Bariloche, Argentina. 2008 “The Relation of Mind and World, and the Shapes of Spirit: A Dialectical Play on Some Main Themes in McDowell and Brandom”, Wittgenstein Conference, Buenos Aires, Argentina. 2008 “Mathematical Reasoning: Some Lessons from Frege”, Leipzig Institute of Philosophy, University of Leipzig, Germany. 2008 “Reading Rorty: A Sketch of a Plan”, Pecs Conference on the work of Richard Rorty, Pecs, Hungary. 2008 “Mathematical Reasoning, Following Peirce and Frege”, Conference on Early Analytic Philosophy, University of Iowa. 2008 “Reasoning in Frege’s Begriffsschrift”, Association of Symbolic Logic, annual meeting, Irvine, California. 2008 “Meaning, Use, and Diagrams”, Workshop on Pragmatics and Semantics, Luiss University, Rome, Italy. 2008 “An Antinomy of Empirical Judgment: Brandom and McDowell”, University of Rome, La Sapienza, Rome, Italy. 2008 “Reasoning in Frege’s Begriffsscrhift”, University of Rome, Tor Vergata, Rome, Italy. 2007 “The Truth in Pragmatism”, Conference on the Philosophy of Pragmatism: Salient Inquiries, Babes-Bolyai University, Cluj-Napoca, Romania. 2007 “Diagrammatic Reasoning in Euclid’s Elements” (submitted), Workshop on Diagrams in Mathematics, . 2007 “Understanding the Goodness of Inference: Modality and Relevance in

Frege’s System of Logic”, Conference on Analytic Philosophy, Taipei, Taiwan. 2007 “Diagrammatic Reasoning in Euclid’s Elements” (submitted), Conference: Perspectives on Mathematical Practice 2007, Brussels, Belgium. 2006 “The Role of Begriffsschrift in the Striving for Truth”, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada. 2006 “The Role of Begriffsschrift in the Striving for Truth”, the New School for Social Research, New York. 2006 “An Antinomy of Empirical Judgment: Brandom and McDowell”, The Social Space of Reason: From Hegel Onward, Second “Contemporary Hegel” International Conference, Venice, Italy. 2006 “Construction and Inference: The Use of Language in Modern Mathematical Practice”, VIII Coloquio Internacional Bariloche de Filosofía, San Carlos de Bariloche, Argentina. 2006 “Frege’s Begriffsschrift”, Kwansei Gakuin University, Osaka, Japan. 2006 “The Role of Begriffsschrift in the Striving for Truth”, Kyoto University, Kyoto, Japan. 2006 “The Role of Begriffsschrift in the Striving for Truth”, National Taiwan University, Taipei, Taiwan. 2006 “The Role of Begriffsschrift in the Striving for Truth”, Kutztown University. 2006 “The Role of Begriffsschrift in the Striving for Truth”, Swarthmore College. 2005 “The Role of Begriffsschrift in the Striving for Truth”, Franklin and Marshall College. 2005 “The Role of Begriffsschrift in the Striving for Truth”, Conference “Frege on Truth”, Santa Maria, Brazil. 2005 “Logical Analysis, Reduction, and Philosophical Understanding”, Conference on “Description, Denotation, Meaning: ‘On Denoting’ One Hundred Years Later”, Philosophy Institute of Eötvös University and the MTA–ELTE Philosophy of Language Research Group, Budapest, Hungary. 2005 “Frege’s Begriffsschrift”, keynote speaker, Fourth International Conference on Logic and Cognition, Zhongshan University, Guangzhou, China. 2005 “Inferentialism and Holistic Role Abstraction in the Telling of Tales”, Pecs Conference on the work of , Pecs, Hungary. Response by Robert Brandom, University of Pittsburgh. 2005 “Inferentialism and Holistic Role Abstraction in the Telling of Tales”, “Author Meets Critics” session, APA, Pacific Division meeting, San Francisco. Response by Robert Brandom, University of Pittsburgh. 2003 “Mathematical Notation and Mathematical Thought”, History and Philosophy of Mathematics Workshop, University of Pittsburgh. 2003 “An Antinomy of Empirical Judgment”, International Conference on Analytical Pragmatism, Lublin, Poland. 2002 “Frege’s Begriffsschrift, a formula language of pure thought”, Center for Advanced Study in the Behavioral Sciences, Stanford, CA.

2002 “Frege’s Begriffsschrift, a formula language of pure thought”, University of New South Wales. 2002 “Getting About in the Modern World”, keynote speaker, Conference on Natural Representation, Sydney, Australia. 2002 “Frege’s Begriffsschrift, a formula language of pure thought”, University of Sydney. 2002 “Getting About in the Modern World”, University of Adelaide. 2002 “Frege’s Begriffsschrift, a formula language of pure thought”, University of Melbourne. 2001 “From Contingency to Solidarity: Rorty’s Pragmatist Turn”, Conference on Rorty’s writings, Pecs, Hungary. Response by Richard Rorty. 2001 “Frege’s Begriffsschrift, a formula language of pure thought”, Northwestern University. 2000 “An Antinomy of Empirical Judgment: Brandom and McDowell”, Workshop on Experience, University of Pittsburgh. 2000 “Frege’s Begriffsschrift, a formula language of pure thought”, University of Pittsburgh. 2000 “The Language of Thought: Reflections on Frege”, Bryn Mawr College 2000 “When Derivations Explain: Logical Generality and Fruitful Proof” (submitted), HOPOS 2000: Third International History of Philosophy of Science Conference, Vienna, Austria 2000 “An Antinomy of Empirical Judgment: Brandom and McDowell”, Conference on Brandom’s Making It Explicit, Pecs, Hungary. 1998 “Writing for the Eye”, Literature Colloquium lecture, Haverford College. 1997 “Logical Form and Conceptual Content in Frege’s Begriffsschrift”, APA Eastern Division meeting, Philadelphia. Comments by Thomas Ricketts, University of Pennsylvania, and Sanford Shieh, Wesleyan University. 1997 “Two Concepts of Concepts”, Faculty Research Talk, Haverford College. 1996 “Brandom on Inference and the Expressive Role of Logic”, 9th SOFIA (Sociedad Filosofica Ibero Americana) Conference, Mexico. Topic for 1996: Truth. Response by Robert Brandom, University of Pittsburgh. 1996 “Frege's Grundlagen Definition of Number” (submitted), the APA Central Division meeting, Chicago. Response by Patricia Blanchette, University of Notre Dame. 1994 “An Austere Theory of Fregean Sense” (submitted), the APA Central Division meeting, Kansas City. Response by Marga Reimer, Arizona State University. 1993 “The Logic of Relations and the Ideality of Space” (submitted), the APA Eastern Division meeting, Atlanta. Response by Paul Tang, California State University. 1993 “The Logic of Relations and the Ideality of Space” (submitted), the New Jersey Regional Philosophy Association Fall Conference, Rutgers University. Response by Tim Maudlin, Rutgers University. 1992 “What's in a Name?” (submitted), the APA Eastern Division meeting, Washington D.C.. Response by Simon Blackburn, UNC Chapel Hill 1992 “Empirical Concepts” (submitted), the APA Central Division meetings, Louisville. Response by William Blattner, Georgetown University.

1991 “Crediting Minds”, Albright College.

Comments Presented: 2016 “Platonism and Philosophy: Comments on Lloyd P. Gerson’s ‘Platonism Versus Naturalism’”, Greater Philadelphia Philosophy Consortium, Temple University, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. 2012 “The Science of Logic: Comments on Tolley’s ‘The Necessity of Receptivity in Logic’”, Society for the Study of the History of Analytic Philosophy, APA Pacific Division, Seattle, Washington. 2009 Response to Dwayne Moore’s “Reconciling Anomalous Monism and Scheme-Content Dualism”, APA Pacific Division meeting, Vancouver, Canada. 2007 “Experience in McDowell: Response to Kumar”, APA Pacific Division meeting, San Francisco. 2006 “Replies to Sanford Shieh and Fabrice Pataut”, panel on Frege’s Logic at the Logic Colloquium 2006, International Summer meeting of the Association for Symbolic Logic, Radboud University, Nijmegen, the Netherlands. 2005 “Whose Practice? Which Meaning?”, comments on Mark Lance’s “From Practice to Meaning”, the 39th Chapel Hill Colloquium. 2001 “Two Conceptions of Content: Response to Graham”, the APA Pacific Division meeting, San Francisco. 2000 On McDowell’s “Transcendental Empiricism”, Symposium in the History and Philosophy of Science and Technology, Rethymnon, Crete. 1999 “It’s A Priori Knowledge Alright, Just Not Learned A Priori Knowledge: Response to McCullagh”, the APA Eastern Division meeting, Boston. 1999 “Knowledge by Fiat: Response to Jeshion”, the APA Pacific Division meeting, Berkeley. 1998 “Unconventional Wisdom: Response to Rysiew”, the APA Eastern Division meeting, Washington. 1998 “The Logic of Epistemic Possibility: Response to Kochiras”, the APA Pacific Division meeting, Los Angeles. 1997 “Externalism and Privileged Access: Response to Vinueza”, the APA Pacific Division meeting, Berkeley. 1996 “Thinking Persons and Thinking Things: Response to deVries”, the APA Eastern Division meeting, Pittsburgh.

Other Professional Activities: 2017 Reviewer for Journal of Logic, Language, and Information, Synthese, British Journal of the History of Philosophy, Journal for the History of Analytic Philosophy 2017 External Reviewer for promotion, Georgetown University. 2017 Associate Editor of Frege: A Philosophical Biography by Dale Jaquette, for posthumous publication (Cambridge University Press). 2016 Book manuscript reviewer for Polity Books. 2016 External reviewer for promotion, Washington and Lee University.

2016 Reviewer for Australasian Journal of Philosophy, History and Philosophy of Logic 2016 Research grant reviewer, Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada (SSHRC). 2015 Chair, External Review Committee, Department of Philosophy, Colgate University. 2015 Project proposal reviewer for Cambridge University Press. 2015 Reviewer for Synthese, Foundations of Science. 2015 External reviewer for a tenure and promotion case, Hamilton College. 2015 Book manuscript reviewer for Press. 2014-17 Member of the Scientific Committee to assess the project “Logic and Philosophy of Mathematical Practices” undertaken by the Center for Logic and Philosophy of Science, Vrije Universiteit Brussel. 2014 Reviewer for the American Council of Learned Societies (ACLS) Ryskamp Fellowships and Burkhardt Fellowships. 2014 Reviewer for Rhetorica, British Journal of the History of Philosophy, Journal of Philosophical Research. 2014 External Review Committee, Department of Philosophy, Dickinson College. 2013 Reviewer for American Council of Learned Societies (ACLS) Ryskamp Fellowships and Burkhardt Fellowships. 2013 External Reviewer for tenure and promotion case, Dickinson College 2013 Reviewer for Rhetorica 2013 External Review Committee, Department of Philosophy and Religion, Ursinus College. 2013 External reviewer for tenure and promotion case, University of Massachusetts, Boston. 2013 External reviewer for tenure and promotion case at Vassar College. 2012 Reviewer for American Council of Learned Societies (ACLS) Ryskamp Fellowships and Burkhardt Fellowships. 2012 Book manuscript reviewer for Oxford University Press. 2012 External Reviewer, Research Foundation, Flanders (Fonds Wetenschappelijk Onderzoek – Vlannderen, FWO) 2012 External Reviewer, promotion case, Georgetown University, School of Foreign Service in Qatar. 2011 Book project reviewer for Polity Press, Cambridge 2011 External Reviewer, tenure and promotion case, Willamette University. 2011 Expert Evaluator, Review panel for Methuselum, Brussels. 2011 Member, Organizing Committee, Conference on the Classical Model of Science II: The Axiomatic Method, the Order of Concepts, and the Hierarchy of Sciences from Leibniz to Tarski, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam. 2011 Book manuscript reviewer for Palgrave Macmillan

2011 Reviewer for European Journal of Analytic Philosophy, Dialectica, Logica Universalis, Mind, Philosophia Scientiae 2010 Chair, External Review Committee for Philosophy, Macalester College. 2010 Reviewer for Dialectica; East Asian Science, Technology, and Society: An International Journal; Science in Context 2009 Reviewer for Mind, Australasian Journal of Philosophy 2008 Reviewer, Oxford University Press 2008 Reviewer and panelist for NEH Fellowship applications 2008 Chair, External Review Committee for Philosophy, Wesleyan University. 2008 Referee for the Canadian Philosophical Association 2008 Reviewer for Foundations of Science, Mind, Journal of Philosophical Research 2007-10 Advisory to the program committee, 20th Century philosophy, Eastern Division of the American Philosophical Association. 2007 Reviewer, Acumen Press (UK) 2007 Reviewer, Erkenntnis, Philosophical Quarterly, Inquiry 2007 External Review Committee, Department of Philosophy, Occidental College, Los Angeles. 2006 Reviewer, Oxford University Press. 2006 Reviewer, European Journal of Philosophy, Philosophical Quarterly, Synthese, Inquiry 2005 Reviewer, Dialogue, Inquiry, Journal of Philosophical Research. 2004 Reviewer, European Journal of Philosophy, Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, Philosophical Quarterly. 2003 Reviewer, Philosophy and Phenomenological Research. 2002 Interviewed on Eastside Radio 89.7 FM Sydney, Australia, “Ghost in the Machine” with host Doris McIlwain. 2002 Reviewer, Australasian Journal of Philosophy 2000 Panelist, ACLS program session on recently tenured faculty, Conference of Administrative Officers of the ACLS, Pittsburgh 2000 Participant, national conversation with ACLS about the future of the humanities, Eugene, Oregon 1997-2000 Dissertation Committee, John MacFarlane, Department of Philosophy, University of Pittsburgh. Title: “What does it mean to say that logic is formal?”. 1999 Reviewer, Acumen Press (UK) 1999-2001 Prescreener, ACLS Fellowship applications 1999 Participant, conversation with ACLS about the future of the humanities, New York 1998-99 Reviewer, Dialogue. 1997 Reviewer, Nous. 1997 Reviewer, Harvard University Press. 1991 External Honors Examiner, Philosophy of Psychology, Swarthmore College.

Professional Memberships: American Philosophical Association American Association of University Women Association for the Philosophy of Mathematical Practice Philosophy of Mathematics Association