INVESTIGATION INTO the EFFECTS of PLAYING POSTURE on FATIGUE in VIOLINISTS and VIOLISTS by Ethan Thomas Triplett Honors Thesis A
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
! "#$%&'"()'"*#!"#'*!'+%!%,,%-'&!*,!./)0"#(!.*&'12%!*#!,)'"(1%!"#! $"*/"#"&'&!)#3!$"*/"&'&! ! 45! %6789!'7:;8<!'=>?@A66! ! +:9:=<!'7A<><! )??8@8B7>89!&686A!19>CA=<>65!! &D4;>66AE!6:!67A!3A?8=6;A96!:F!+A8@67!89E!%GA=B><A!&B>A9BA! 89E!'7A!+:9:=<!-:@@AHA! >9!?8=6>8@!FD@F>@@;A96!:F!67A!=AID>=A;A96<!F:=!67A!EAH=AA!:F!! J8B7A@:=!:F!&B>A9BA! K85L!MNMO! ! ! ! ! PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP! +A=;89!C89!QA=R7:CA9L!.7S3SL!'7A<><!3>=AB6:=! ! ! PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP! %=>B!T::96UL!3K)L!&AB:9E!2A8EA=! ! ! PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP! +A=;89!C89!QA=R7:CA9L!.7S3SL!3A?8=6;A968@!+:9:=<!3>=AB6:=! ! ! PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP! VAFF:=E!$87@4D<B7L!.7S3SL!3A89L!'7A!+:9:=<!-:@@AHA! ! !"#$%&!'(&!)"*!"&)*&+$*$,,$-&*),*./(0!"'*.)%&12$*)"*,(&!'1$*!"*#!)/!"!%&%*("3*#!)/!%&%* "#$%&'(%! ! .@85>9H!8!;D<>B8@!>9<6=D;A96!><!8!B:;;:9!?8<6>;A!8=:D9E!67A!W:=@E!89E!F:=!<:;AL!>6! ><!8!B8=AA=!89E!7:W!67A5!;8RA!67A>=!@>C>9HS!KD<>B>89<X!4:E>A<!8=A!?D6!D9EA=!B:9<6896!<6=A<<! F=:;!?@85>9H!89!>9<6=D;A96S!&686><6>B<!78CA!<DHHA<6AE!6786!D?W8=E<!:F!YNZ!:F!?=:FA<<>:98@! ;D<>B>89<!<DFFA=!F=:;!8!?A=F:=;89BA[=A@86AE!;D<BD@:<RA@A68@!E><:=EA=!\.2K3<]!6786!B89!@A8E! 6:!67A!>984>@>65!6:!?@85!67A!>9<6=D;A96!F:=!8!?A=>:E!:F!6>;A!89E!67A=AF:=A!8FFAB6!67A>=!84>@>65!6:! W:=RS!KD<>B>89<!8=A!4A>9H!E>8H9:<AE!W>67!.2K3<!86!A8=@>A=!8HA<L!A<?AB>8@@5!67:<A!>9!<B7::@<! F:=!;D<>BS!$>:@>9><6<!89E!C>:@><6<!F:=;!:9A!:F!67A!H=:D?<!6786!><!;:<6!@>RA@5!6:!AG?A=>A9BA!8! .2K3S! K:<6! =A<A8=B7! 78<! B:9B@DEAE! 6786! 8@:9H! W>67! :CA=D<A! >9^D=>A<L! 67A! 8<5;;A6=>B8@! ?@85>9H! ?:<>6>:9! ?@85<! 8! 7DHA! =:@A! >9! >9^D=>A<! AG?A=>A9BAE! 45! C>:@>9><6<! 89E! C>:@><6<S! .8<6! =A<A8=B7!78<!F:D9E!6786!<>66>9H!W7>@A!?@85>9HL!8!7>H7!<6=>9H!;D<>B>89!?D6<!89!D948@89BAE!@:8E! :9!67A!7>?!4:9A<!89E!;D<>B>89<!FAA@!;:=A!?8>9!W7A9!<>66>9HS!'7A=A!><!@>;>6AE!?=AC>:D<!=A<A8=B7! :9!67A!AFFAB6<!:F!F86>HDA!>9!C>:@>9><6<!89E!C>:@><6<L!A<?AB>8@@5!7:W!?@85>9H!?:<6D=A!\>SASL!<>66>9H! :=!<689E>9H]!8FFAB6<!;A8<D=A<!:F!F86>HDAS!'7A!?D=?:<A!:F!67><!<6DE5!W8<!6:!>9CA<6>H86A!67A!AFFAB6<! :F!<>66>9H!89E!<689E>9H!:9!F86>HDA!>9!7>H7!<6=>9H!;D<>B>89<!>9!7:?A<!:F!F>9E>9H!W85<!6:!=AEDBA! .2K3<!>9!C>:@>9><6<!89E!C>:@><6<S!)!CA=5!67:=:DH7!@>6A=86D=A!=AC>AW!=ACA8@AE!6786!<>66>9H!W7>@A! ?@85>9H!=A<D@6<!>9!7>H7!@ACA@<!:F!?A=BA>CAE!F86>HDA!>9!D??A=!<6=>9H!;D<>B>89<!89E!6786!8!?@89!:F! >96=:EDB>9H!?A=>:E<!:F!<689E>9H!B:D@E!?:<<>4@5!EAB=A8<A!67A!@ACA@<!:F!F86>HDA!67A!;D<>B>89<! AG?A=>A9BAS!)9!AG?A=>;A968@!=A<A8=B7!<6DE5!><!?=:?:<AE!>9!:=EA=!6:!CA=>F5!67A!F>9E>9H<!:F!67A! @>6A=86D=A!=AC>AWS!! ! )*+,-&.$/! $"*/"#L! $"*/)L! .2K3&L! ,)'"(1%L! &"''"#(L! &')#3"#(L! K1&"-L! +%)/'+L!.*&'12%L!-/)&&"-)/!K1&"-")#&! !"#$%&!'(&!)"*!"&)*&+$*$,,$-&*),*./(0!"'*.)%&12$*)"*,(&!'1$*!"*#!)/!"!%&%*("3*#!)/!%&%* ! ! ! ! ! ! ! &.%-")/!'+)#T&!'*!K0!'+%&"&!-*KK"''%%L!32S!+%2K)#!$)#!Q%2T+*$%#! )#3!32S!%2"-!T**#'_!,*2!'+%"2!-*#'"#1%3!&1..*2'!)#3!$)/1)J/%! "#&"(+'!312"#(!'+"&!'+%&"&!.2*-%&&S! ! )/&*L!'+)#T!0*1!'*!32S!%2"-!T**#'_!)#3!32S!#)#-0!J)2(%2&'*-T!,*2! &+)2"#(!'+%"2!T#*Q/%3(%!*,!$"*/"#!)#3!$"*/)!.%3)(*(0!)#3! .2*$"3"#(!1#"`1%!.2*&.%-'"$%&!"#'*!'+%!/"$%&!*,!K1&"-")#&S! ! '+)#T!0*1!)//a! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !"#$%&!'(&!)"*!"&)*&+$*$,,$-&*),*./(0!"'*.)%&12$*)"*,(&!'1$*!"*#!)/!"!%&%*("3*#!)/!%&%* ! 0'#1*!-2!3-4%*4%$! ! ! "#'2*31-'"*#bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbO! "#V12"%&!"#!$"*/"#"&'&!)#3!$"*/"&'&bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbM! ./)0"#(!.*&'12%!"#!$"*/"#"&'&!)#3!$"*/"&'&bbSSSSbbbbbbbbbSc! &"''"#(!$&S!&')#3"#(!"#!*'+%2!.2*,%&&"*#&!bbbbbbbbbbbSbSd! ,)'"(1%e!Q+)'!"'!"&!)#3!+*Q!'*!K%)&12%!"'bbbbbbbbbSSbbbf! ! ,86>HDA!KAB789><;<bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbSSbSSSg! ! &D4^AB6>CA!,86>HDA!KA8<D=A;A96<bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbSbbSON! ! *4^AB6>CA!,86>HDA!KA8<D=A;A96<bbbbbbbbbbbbbSSSbbbbbOM! ! %@AB6=:;5:H=8?75!2A<A8=B7!>9!+>H7!&6=>9H!bbbbbbbbbbbbSbbSOh! ! ! KD<>B>89<!"9^D=>A<!89E!,86>HDA!! ! &D4^AB6>CA!C<S!*4^AB6>CA!,86>HDA!KA8<D=A;A96<bbbbbbbbbbbbbOd! -*#-/1&"*#bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbSSOf! .2*.*&%3!&'130bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbSbOg! 2%,%2%#-%&bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbSSSMi! )..%#3"j!O! OSO!.8=6>B>?86>:9!-=>6A=>8!,:=;bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbSbbSiN! OSM!KD<BD@:<RA@A68@!.8>9!"96A9<>65!89E!"96A=FA=A9BA!bbbbbSbbSbbbSSiO! `DA<6>:998>=A!F:=!$>:@>9><6<!89E!$>:@><6<!! OSi!.=A[&A<<>:9!.8>9!89E!,86>HDA!&D=CA5bbbbbbbbbbbbSbbbSic! OSc!.:<6[&A<<>:9!.8>9!89E!,86>HDA!&D=CA5bbbbbbbbSbbbbbbbih! ! !"#$%&!'(&!)"*!"&)*&+$*$,,$-&*),*./(0!"'*.)%&12$*)"*,(&!'1$*!"*#!)/!"!%&%*("3*#!)/!%&%* Introduction .@85>9H!8!;D<>B8@!>9<6=D;A96!><!8!CA=5!B:;;:9!?8<6>;A!F:=!?A:?@A!:F!E>FFA=A96!8HA<! 67=:DH7:D6!67A!W:=@ES!KD<>B>89<!8=A!=AID>=AE!6:!EACA@:?!F>9A!;:6:=!<R>@@<!89E!?A=F:=;!CA=5! B:;?@AG!4:E5!;:CA;A96<!6:!8B7>ACA!67A!=AID>=AE!?:<6D=A<!89E!6AB79>IDA<!6786!8BB:;?895! ?@85>9H! 89! >9<6=D;A96S! VD<6! @>RA! 867@A6A<L! 67A! <6=8>9! 6786! ><! ?D6! :9! 67A! 4:E5! F=:;! ?@85>9H! 8! ;D<>B8@!>9<6=D;A96!B89!@A8E!6:!;895!;D<>B>89<!4AB:;>9H!>9^D=AE!\ASHSL!T8DF;89!89E!286U:9L! MNOOk! (D?6>@@! 89E! (:@A;L! MNNYk! T:R! A6! 8@SL! MNOYk! _8U8L! OggMk! &6A>9;A6U! A6! 8@SL! MNOMk! )BRA=;899!A6!8@SL!MNOM]S! ! "9!8!<6DE5!:F!?=:FA<<>:98@!;D<>B>89<!>9!67A!#A67A=@89E<L!>6!W8<!F:D9E!6786!:CA=!dNZ!:F! 67A!;D<>B>89<!<DFFA=AE!F=:;!8!;D<BD@:<RA@A68@!<5<6A;!>9^D=5!6786!?=ACA96AE!67A!;D<>B>89<!F=:;! ?A=F:=;>9H!F:=!86!@A8<6!<:;A!?A=>:E!:F!6>;AS!K:<6!:F!67A<A!>9^D=>A<!:BBD==AE!F=:;!89!>;48@89BA! :F!@:8E!B8D<AE!45!A>67A=!?@85>9H!6::!;DB7!\:CA=D<A]!:=!D<>9H!67A!W=:9H!6AB79>IDA!\;><D<A]S!)! B789HA!:F!?75<>B8@!l;D<>B8@X!@:8E!:=!67A!>96A9<>65!>9!W7>B7!67A!?A=F:=;A=!?@85<!><!67A!;8>9!W85! 6786!:CA=D<A!>9^D=>A<!:BBD=!>9!;D<>B>89<S!'7A<A!B789HA<!>9!@:8E!B89!B:;A!F=:;!8!B789HA!>9! >9<6=D;A96L!6A8B7A=L!:=!ACA9!?=8B6>BA!=:D6>9A<S!\2>A6CA@EL!MNOi]! ! '7A! 6A=;! .A=F:=;89BA! 2A@86AE! KD<BD@:<RA@A68@! 3><:=EA=! \.2K3<]! W8<! B=A86AE! 6:! EA<B=>4A!67A!;D<BD@:<RA@A68@!E><:=EA=<!6786!;D<>B>89<!AG?A=>A9BA!8<!8!=A<D@6!:F!?@85>9H!67A>=! >9<6=D;A96!\_8U8!89E!,8=AWA@@L!Oggf]S!'7A!EAF>9>6>:9!<686A<!6786!8!.2K3!><!m?8>9L!WA8R9A<<L! 9D;49A<<L!6>9H@>9HL!:=!:67A=!<5;?6:;<!6786!>96A=FA=A!W>67!5:D=!84>@>65!6:!?@85!5:D=!>9<6=D;A96! 86!67A!@ACA@!6:!W7>B7!5:D!8=A!8BBD<6:;AEnS!'7><!EAF>9>6>:9!E:A<!9:6!>9B@DEA!;>@E!8B7A<!89E! ?8>9<S!\_8U8!89E!,8=AWA@@L!Oggfk!_8U8!A6!8@SL!OggY]S!"6!><!>;?:=6896!6:!D9EA=<689E!67A!=><R<!89E! :D6B:;A<! 6786! 8=A! 8<<:B>86AE! W>67! ;D<BD@:<RA@A68@! >9^D=>A<! >9! ;D<>B>89<S! VD<6! 8<! 8! ;D<BD@:<RA@A68@!E><:=EA=!B8D<A<!E><B:;F:=6!89E!>9!<:;A!B8<A<!89!>984>@>65!6:!?A=F:=;!W:=R[ ! O! !"#$%&!'(&!)"*!"&)*&+$*$,,$-&*),*./(0!"'*.)%&12$*)"*,(&!'1$*!"*#!)/!"!%&%*("3*#!)/!%&%* =A@86AE! 68<R<! >9! 89! :BBD?86>:98@! <A66>9HL! .2K3<! B89! 8@<:! @A8E! 6:! 67A! @:<<! :F! FD9B6>:9! 89E! ?@85>9H!84>@>65!F:=!;D<>B>89<!\_8U8L!OggY]S!"6!><!E>FF>BD@6!6:!HA6!8!EAF>9>6>CA!<686><6>B!:F!67A!@A9H67! 6786! ;D<>B>89<! 8=A! :D=! 4AB8D<A! ACA=5! >9^D=5! ><! E>FFA=A96L! 89E! ACA=5! ;D<>B>89! 789E@A<! >6! E>FFA=A96@5S!"6!><!B:;;:9!>9!67A!;D<>B!>9ED<6=5!6:!>H9:=A!67A!?8>9!W7A67A=!>6!4A!B:9<B>:D<@5!:=! <D4B:9<B>:D<@5!89E!?@85!67=:DH7!67A!?8>9!:D6!:F!FA8=!:F!@:<>9H!67A>=!^:4!:=!E><=D?6>:9<!>9!B8=AA=! 8EC89BA;A96!\3:;;A=7:@6L!MNNg]S!)BB:=E>9H!6:!8!MNNh!JD=A8D!:F!/84:=!&686><6>B<!=A?:=6L! ;D<>B>89<!7A@E!=:DH7@5!McgLNNN!^:4<!>9!MNNcS!cNZ!W:=R>9H!?8=6[6>;A!89E!8@;:<6!78@F!4A>9H! <A@F[A;?@:5AES!\,:G;89!A6!8@SL!MNNd]S!'7><!>984>@>65!6:!?A=F:=;!>9!89!>9ED<6=5!6786!><!8@=A8E5! D9<684@A!89E!B:;?A6>6>CA!B89!E=8<6>B8@@5!7>9EA=!8!;D<>B>89X<!B8=AA=L!<:!>6!><!C>68@!6:!D9EA=<689E! ;:=A!84:D6!67A<A!>9^D=>A<!<:!6786!;D<>B>89<!B89!9:6!:9@5!=AB:CA=!F=:;!>9^D=>A<!F8<6A=!4D6!?=ACA96! 67A;!>9!67A!F>=<6!?@8BAS!'7A<A!>9^D=>A<!B89!@A8E!6:!F>989B>8@!78=E<7>?!F:=!67A!;D<>B>89<L!89E!<>9BA! ;:<6!W:=R!:9@5!?8=6[6>;A!:=!8=A!<A@F[A;?@:5AEL!67A5!@8BR!67A!7A8@67!>9<D=89BA!6786!><!9AAEAE! 6:!RAA?!67A;!<8FA!89E!7A8@675!\,:G;89!A6!8@SL!MNNd]S!#:6!:9@5!B89!67A!@:<<!:F!?@85>9H!84>@>65! 8FFAB6!67A!;D<>B>89!F>989B>8@@5L!4D6!>6!B89!:F6A9!@A8E!6:!<A@F[E:D46!89E!?<5B7:@:H>B8@!EAB@>9A<! EDA!6:!67A!E><=D?6>:9!:F!67A!>96>;86A!=A@86>:9<7>?!;895!;D<>B>89<!EA<B=>4A!78C>9H!W>67!67A>=! >9<6=D;A96!89E!@:<<!:F!67A>=!?8<<>:9!\(D?6>@@L!MNOO]S!! ! Injuries in Violinists and Violists '7A! ;:<6! B:;;:9@5! 8FFAB6AE! H=:D?! :F! ;D<>B>89<! 6786! <DFFA=! F=:;! ;D<BD@:<RA@A68@! E><:=EA=<!8=A!<6=>9H!;D<>B>89<S!2>A6CA@E!\MNOi]!=A?:=6AE!6786!4:WAE[<6=>9H!>9<6=D;A968@><6<!89E! HD>68=><6<!B:;4>9AE!;8EA!D?!hiZ!:F!>9^D=AE!;D<>B>89<!W>67!C>:@>9><6<!<?AB>F>B8@@5!;8R>9H!D?! i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fk!,>@7:!89E!E8!&>@C8L! MNMNk!2>A6CA@EL!MNOik!'D4>898!A6!8@SL!OgYg]S!*F!8@@!:CA=D<A!E><:=EA=<!>9!C>:@>9><6<!89E!C>:@><6<L! fhZ!:BBD==AE!>9!67A!D??A=!AG6=A;>65!\2A9<>9H!A6!8@SL!MNOY]S!2A9<>9H!E><BD<<AE!67A!>;?@>B86>:9<!