A07774pfeis Appendices E Pt1.Pdf
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
RC-0445 Archaeological Inventory Survey Update for the ‘O‘oma Beachside Village Project Area (TMK: 3-7-3-09:004 and 022) ‘O‘oma 2nd Ahupua‘a North Kona District Island of Hawai‘i PREPARED BY: Robert B. Rechtman, Ph.D. PREPARED FOR: North Kona Village, LLC C/o Midland Pacific Homes 6955 El Camino Real, Suite 200 Atascadero, CA 93422 June 2007 (Revised October 2008) RC-0445 Archaeological Inventory Survey Update for the ‘O‘oma Beachside Village Project Area (TMK: 3-7-3-09:004 and 022) ‘O‘oma 2nd Ahupua‘a North Kona District Island of Hawai‘i RC-0445 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY At the request of PBR Hawaii & Associates Inc., on behalf of North Kona Village, LLC, Rechtman Consulting, LLC has prepared this update to earlier DLNR-SHPD approved archaeological inventory survey work of an approximately 300 acre project area in ‘O‘oma 2nd Ahupua‘a, North Kona District, Island of Hawai‘i (TMKs: 3-7-3-09:004 and 022) (Figures 1 and 2). Between 1985 and 2002, the current project area (in part and in whole) has been subject to intensive archaeological study, including inventory survey and data recovery. In September of 1998 DLNR-SHPD prepared an update on the historic preservation status of Parcel 004, and concluded that all historic preservation issues, except preservation planning, were completed. In October of 2002 DLNR-SHPD prepared another update on the historic preservation status of Parcel 022. This DLNR- SHPD correspondence likewise indicated that both survey work and data recovery had been acceptably completed and what remained to be done was preservation planning. More recently DLNR-SHPD indicated that for Parcel 004 there were some some sites for which data recovery had not been completed. Given the sensitive nature of archaeological resources in the immediate project area and the recent inadvertent discoveries at neighboring Kohanaiki, the landowner/developer thought it prudent to reexamine the entire project area to assess the current condition of the known preservation and data recovery sites and to identify any additional sites that may have gone undocumented during the earlier work. This approach was confirmed as valid with SHPD staff and with the SHPD administrator. Rechtman Consulting, LLC completed an intensive resurvey of the study area; ten sites (SIHP Site 2, 1910, 1911, 1912, 1913, 10155, 10181, 18027, 18773, and 18775) that had earlier been approved for preservation were investigated to verify current site conditions and site boundaries, five sites (SIHP Site 18774, 18808, 18821, 18822, and 18831) slated for data recovery were reassessed and now three are recommended for preservation (two for no further work), and two sites (SIHP Site 25932 and 26678) were discovered that had not been previously documented. Both sites are lava tubes that contain human skeletal remains; these sites are also recommended for preservation. A burial treatment plan should be prepared for Sites 18773, 25932, and 26678 and submitted to DLNR-SHPD and the Hawaii Island Burial Council, and an archaeological sites preservation plan should be prepared for the other twelve sites and submitted to DLNR-SHPD for approval. ii RC-0445 CONTENTS INTRODUCTION.................................................................................................................................. 1 PROJECT AREA DESCRIPTION AND PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT ACTIVITIES.................... 1 Archaeological Background ................................................................................................................... 5 CULTURE-HISTORICAL BACKGROUND ....................................................................................... 9 Natural and Cultural Resources in a Hawaiian Context ......................................................................... 9 An Overview of Hawaiian Settlement.................................................................................................. 10 Hawaiian Land Use and Resource Management Practices .................................................................. 11 The Environmental Setting of ‘O‘oma ................................................................................................. 12 Native Traditions and Historical Accounts of ‘O‘oma and the Kekaha Region .................................. 13 Land Tenure in ‘O‘oma and Vicinity ................................................................................................... 25 ORAL-HISTORICAL INTERVIEWS................................................................................................. 59 Interview Participants........................................................................................................................... 59 Summary of Oral-Historical Information............................................................................................. 60 ARCHAEOLOGICAL FIELDWORK................................................................................................. 61 Previously Identified Preservation Sites............................................................................................... 61 Newly Discovered Site......................................................................................................................... 83 SIGNIFICANCE EVALUATION AND TREATMENT RECOMMENDATION ............................. 87 REFERENCES CITED ........................................................................................................................ 89 APPENDIX A ...................................................................................................................................... 92 FIGURES 1. Portion of USGS 7.5 minute series Keahole Point, HI 1996 showing project area location.............. 2 2. Portion of Tax Map Key 3-7-3 showing current project areas. .......................................................... 3 3. Proposed development plan................................................................................................................ 4 4. Approximate locations of sites described by Reinecke (n.d.:37) projected on USGS Keahole Quad, 1928.......................................................................................................... 6 5. Distribution of archaeological preservation sites within the project area. (Includes the newly recorded Sites 25932 and 26678)...................................................................... 8 6. Copy of Native Register Vol. 8:543 Helu 9162, claim of Kahelekahi for kuleana at ‘O‘oma. ....... 26 7. Portion of 1882 Register Map No. 1280 showing original boundaries of Grant No. 1590, to Kauhini. ............................................................................................................ 35 8. 1902 homestead map No. 6 showing Ooma-Kalaoa Homestead Lots (State Survey Division)....... 39 9. 1899 Grant Map No. 4536 showing makai portion of ‘O‘oma 2nd to John A. Maguire. ................ 42 10. J. S. Emerson, field notebook map, Book 253:53 (State Survey Division).................................... 45 iii RC-0445 11. J. S. Emerson, field notebook map, Book 253:55 (State Survey Division).................................... 46 12. J. S. Emerson, field notebook map, Book 253:69 (State Survey Division).................................... 47 13. J. S. Emerson, field notebook map, Book 253:73 (State Survey Division).................................... 48 14. J. S. Emerson, field notebook map, Book 254:77 (State Survey Division).................................... 49 15. Kii o na alanui o Kona Akau (diagram of the roads of North Kona): J. Kaelemakule Sr., Road Supervisor (HSA—Roads, Hawaii: December 22, 1890)...................................................... 58 16. Portion of the Alanui Aupuni (SIHP Site 2) crossing ‘O‘oma 2nd; view toward Kohanaiki. ........ 59 17. SIHP Site 18808 Feature C view to the northeast. ......................................................................... 64 18. Alignment of pāhoehoe slabs “Site 18831,” view to the west..............................................................66 19. Evidence of modern quarrying activity to the south of the slab alignment.........................................67 20. Rubbish (Mountain Dew cans) located between the slab alignment and the modern quarry area..67 21. Portion of 1928 U.S.G.S. 7.5 minute series quadrangle Keahole HI showing SIHP Site 2. .......... 69 22. Aerial view of mauka portion of property showing route of SHIP Site 2. ..................................... 70 23. State Survey map depicting old Government Road alignment through ‘O‘oma 1st and 2nd......... 71 24. SIHP Site 1910 (D15-1) Feature C, view to the east...................................................................... 74 25. SIHP Site 1910 (D15-1) Feature E, view to the east...................................................................... 75 26. SIHP Site 1910 (D15-1) Feature B, view to the south. .................................................................. 75 27. SIHP Site 1910 (D15-2) Feature B, view to the east...................................................................... 76 28. SIHP Site 1910 (D15-2) Feature c, view to the west...................................................................... 76 29. SIHP Site 1911 collapsed western wall of enclosure in foreground and stacked eastern wall in background. The heavily utilized road is immediately adjacent to the site............ 77 30. SIHP Site 1911 southeastern corner of enclosure documenting current state of wall collapse...... 78 31. SIHP Site 1911 platform, view to the east.....................................................................................