2013 Quebec Steel Design Awards of Excellence Celebrating Outstanding Projects in Steel
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
ADVANTAGE STEEL NO 48 WINTER 2014 2013 Quebec Steel Design Awards of Excellence Celebrating outstanding projects in steel The art of the bridge: Pedestrian bridges experience a renaissance A comparative Life Cycle Assessment: Steel vs. concrete framing Tension-only bracing SteelDay 2013 – A national celebration of steel! CANADIAN INSTITUTE OF STEEL CONSTRUCTION CANADIAN INSTITUTE OF STEEL CONSTRUCTION PM#40787580 SWITCH TO AUTO-PILOT WITH A VOORTMAN! MULTI SYSTEM INTEGRATION NG by Voortman LAYOUT MARKI G LASTIN SHOT B G DRILLIN G UTTIN THERMAL C Eastern Western G SAWIN 418-864-4446 780-980-9661PO Box 6049 Leduc, Alberta Canada T9E 2A2 Toll Free 855-980-9661 • Ph 780.980.9661 • Fax 780.980.9668 E-mail: [email protected] AUTOMATIC SIwwNwG.allfabmachineLE SOry.cURom CE MATERIAL HANDLING: PROVIDER ■ Loads and unloads the ■ Plasma & oxy-fuel cutting processing system ■ Sawing and drilling ■ Intelligently decides which ■ Layout marking system to load next in a ■ Shot blasting & painting Multi System Integration ■ Punching & shearing ■ Unmanned systems which ■ All products are designed reduce man hours and manufactured in house BRIAN RITCHIE FROM SHEPARD STEEL: “The Voortman V808 Robotic Cutting System has been in use in our production facility for over 5 months and has exceeded our expectations. We are using the V808 as a fabrication station cutting to size, burning holes and coping. We could not be happier with the production, service and support on all of our Voortman machines. Great equipment!” VOORTMAN USA CORP. Building F - 450 South Spruce St. | Manteno, IL 60950 (t) 1 815 468 6300 | (f) +1 815 - 468 6333 [email protected] www.voortmancorp.com A VOOR T M A N S TEEL G R OUP C OMP A N Y ADVANTAGE STEEL NO 48 WINTER 2014 I N THIS ISSUE 30 From the President 8 Ed Whalen, P.Eng. FEATURES The art of the bridge: 24 Pedestrian bridges experience a renaissance By Terri Meyer Boake CISC Quebec Steel Design Awards of Excellence: 30 Celebrating outstanding projects in steel SteelDay 2013 – A national celebration of steel! 44 COLUMNS Technical Column 14 Alfred F. Wong, P.Eng. Seismic Corner 16 Tension-only bracing Alfred F. Wong, P.Eng. For Green’s Sake 20 Case study: A comparative Life Cycle Assessment Tareq Ali, RPM News and Events 48 Member and Associate Product/Services Directory 52 24 WINTER 2014 ADVANTAGE STEEL 3 L E A N R G IN Schedule Your FREE Lunch & Learn with the Spec Expert U T E C E U R R S T Earn 1 CE hour! Brad Fletcher, structural engineer at Atlas Tube, spent six years helping S C NCSEA Lunch & Learn attendees O N develop the new ASTM A1085 HSS spec. Now, he'll come to your facility N O T I IN T A receive one Continuing U C to explain how A1085 allows for more economical structures, enhanced IN U G D Education hour. E support for dynamic loads and greater control over your designs. Diamond Reviewed Got questions about A1085? Get answers with Atlas Tube. Sign up and get a preview at atlastube.com/A1085 Don't delay — Brad's calendar is filling up! Through its pipe fabrication operations of Pro-V Manufacturing LP, Supreme Group has a Supplier of Choice Agreement with Cenovus Energy following numerous successful equipment module supply and assembly packages for Foster Creek and Christina Lake operations. - Acheson, AB Steel the Most Trusted Choice Supreme Group and its operating companies have been providing trusted expertise in the steel construction industry for more than a century. Our quality craftsmanship has been the solution for countless large-scale projects at home and abroad. We repeatedly tailor solutions to the requirements of clients that expect and deserve innovation along with the highest levels of proficiency. Our growth has been consistent, strong and stable due to our strategically planned acquisitions and new partnership formulations. Supreme Group’s impressive portfolio of well executed contracts speaks to our wealth of experience, knowledge and capability. This in turn is a testament to the strength of our managerial institution and corporate culture. Inquiries about our specific skill set, project development, qualifications or career opportunities are welcome and appreciated. www.supremegroup.com North Americaʼs largest Brake Forming and Plate Rolling facility delivers cost effective solutions. We serve a wide range of industries including energy, transportation, architectural, 3.5” thick construction, mining, metals, x 40” ID and agricultural as well as x 200” in length OEMs across North America. Plate Rolling up to 10” thick Brake Forming up to 20” thick For all of your rolling, forming Fax 1-905-356-6025 and bending needs, please call Email [email protected] 1-800-263-2547 www.hcrsteel.com F rom the P resident By Ed Whalen, P.Eng. President The bridge to fair trade have presented numerous times in the recent past on the As consumers, we want cheap. We put pressure on need for governments to “think Canadian” when it comes governments to lift duties and increase trade with countries Ito procurement. As each level of government is trying to that have perceived cheaper products. What we fail to develop new programs to stimulate new businesses and realize is that those Canadian duties are in place because improve productivity, the low hanging fruit is right in front products are being dumped. The net effect is an unfair of them. hollowing-out of our industries and our middle class. While Canadian companies are getting bombarded with unfair Canadian governments at all levels should implement trade competition here at home, we are being locked out of procurement policies in favour of Canadian companies markets in those same countries that are taking our market within their trade obligations. This would be done not share at home. It has been proven that countries need to be through protection or bias but by leveling the playing field manufacturing to have a strong and healthy economy. For taking into consideration reciprocal market access, product those that are quick to state that manufacturing is dead in component dumping, government and other subsidies, and developed countries, one only needs to look at Germany to currency manipulation. Fair trade is a popular concept see that this type of thinking is very wrong. But as individuals these days, and why not? More and more Canadian we don’t have an eye on the big picture, and this is why we manufacturing jobs are being lost, while imports increase, need governments with the help of industry to do that for us. exports decrease and our balance of trade goes negative. When governments procure from non-Canadian companies The federal government has a great opportunity. It recently they are themselves negatively affecting Canada’s trade announced that it will spend over $40 billion in much imbalance, which by the way is in a deficit as of the fall needed infrastructure replacement. The first sizable project of 2013. Canada needs to have exporting opportunities is the Champlain Bridge replacement in Quebec. Here and that can only be done by having a fair chance at home is the opportunity for the federal government to send a and abroad. message to the rest of the world to free up market access and trade fairly by implementing a reciprocity and fair CISC is working with governments at all levels to realize the trade provision for this project and for the rest of the power of procurement. Only with their help will Canada $40 billion. grow and prosper in the ever-global economy. ADVANTAGE STEEL CHAIRMAN Jim McLagan, Canron Western Constructors Ltd. Professional engineers, architects, structural steel fabricators On the Cover: Bibliothèque du Boisé, MANAGING EDITOR Tareq Ali, CISC and others interested in steel construction are invited to inquire St. Laurent, Montreal, QC Advantage Steel and the French-language edition Avantage Acier about CISC membership. Readers are encouraged to submit (available on request) are published by the Canadian Institute of Steel PUBLISHER MediaEdge Publishing Inc. their interesting steel construction projects for consideration for Construction (CISC) on behalf of its members. 33 South Station Street inclusion in this publication by contacting CISC. CISC is not responsible for the opinions ex- North York, ON M9N 2B2 CANADIAN INSTITUTE OF STEEL CONSTRUCTION ISSN 1192-5248 PUBLICATIONS NUMBER 40787580 pressed in this publication by those contributing Toll-Free: 1-866-480-4717 ext. 229 articles. Visit us at www.cisc-icca.ca or Tel 905-946-0864, [email protected] PLEASE RETURN UNDELIVERED COPIES TO: Fax 905-946-8574 Canadian Institute of Steel Construction 8 www.mediaedgepublishing.com WINTER 2014 ADVANTAGE STEEL 3760 14th Avenue, Suite 200 Markham, Ontario, Canada L3R 3T7 ™ Energy BUILD 300 megawatts. The lifeblood of our connected world. & WIN! Powering the towns, tools and technologies that drive us Show us what you build for forward. With pipe expertly welded by Tony Fischer and a chance to win a dream the skilled craftsmen at Team Industries. trip to New York City! Together, we build energy. MillerWelds.com/webuild The Power of Blue® WE BUILD The most demanding request The Triangle. Proudly Canadian www. .com Ask for The Triangle. Your construction site. No hassles. No worries. No surprises. Imagine that… At Canam, this is how we operate. Over the last 50 years we have developed a fast, reliable construction method that adapts to all your commercial, industrial, institutional or multi-residential projects. Whether you are building structures, floors, walls or steel building envelopes, our construction solutions are simple and straightforward, so you don’t get any surprises. 1-877-499-6049 canam-construction.com CANAM Paul (227) 9871_AvantageAcierMagAN_A01.indd Olivier (240) 8,625” x 11,125” Dimitri (236) A01 4C Rafik (232) DATA:LIVE:Studio_MTL:CANAM:9871_HON_développement_nouveau_branding:PRODUCTION:9871_AvantageAcierMagAN_A01.indd 23/11/12 à 13:51 T echnical C olumn By Alfred F.