Modern Slavery & Human Trafficking

A guide for the Church Community By Alison Ussery, Haven of Light

- Foreword from the Bishop of St Asaph - Introduction - Definitions & Facts : Modern Slavery & Human Trafficking

: Human Trafficking & People Smuggling : The World Today : The Situation in the UK

- Signs & Indicators

- A Biblical Perspective - International Action - Practical suggestions of what we can do

Foreword from the Bishop of St Asaph

Slavery is the sort of word that brings ancient times, or nineteenth century colonialism to mind. We don’t associate it with north Wales in our own society and times. And yet, that is the ugly reality which has been uncovered.

In 2019, the Governing Body of the Church in Wales recognised that human trafficking and modern slavery were crimes against humanity, and committed us to exploring every opportunity to play our part in working to combat modern slavery, its prevention, detection, and in offering support for its victims.

Ali Ussery, who works with north Wales based Haven of Light to combat modern slavery, has been working with the diocese to help us to understand this contemporary injustice, and to respond at a practical level. This booklet is essential reading and a call for action, and I commend it to you.

Bishop Gregory Cameron

Definitions & Facts

Throughout the world today there are over 40 million men, women and children who have lost their freedom as human beings and are being bought and sold as commodities. The terms ‘modern slavery’ and ‘human trafficking’ are used to describe this serious and growing global crime where criminals are taking advantage of vulnerable people to make a profit, with no care for their wellbeing. It does not have to involve the movement across international borders or around a particular country, as ‘trafficking’ may suggest, and there are different forms of modern slavery, including forced labour, sexual exploitation, domestic servitude, organ harvesting, forced criminality, forced marriage or adoption.

Criminals are making an estimated profit of over $150 billion, as individuals are kidnapped, trapped, forced, beaten and coerced into activities against their will. Often people are tricked and caught in bonded labour, deceived by friends or even sold by family members and acquaintances.

Human Trafficking and People Smuggling

Human trafficking and people smuggling are not the same. Victims of trafficking do not need to be taken anywhere to be a victim. Both human trafficking and people smuggling are basically businesses run by criminals to make big profits. They take advantage of the situation that people find themselves in, often through desperation in fleeing conflict or poverty, or simply trying to find a better life for themselves and their loved ones.

Smuggling involves illegal border crossing and usually voluntary payment for the service. Trafficking and slavery involve coercion, force, deception and violence and the crime is committed against the person as a commodity.

Modern Slavery: A Guide for the Church Community 2

The World Today

For those of us living in the so called ‘developed world’, society has become a disposable culture in many ways, where products can easily be replaced. Often, we may not think about from where we are getting our clothes, food and other items. Some of the food products that we consume will have been grown and harvested through slave labour; cocoa, coffee and even fruit and vegetables. As the world develops, with new technology and batteries to replace non-sustainable power, are we aware that the cobalt and coltan needed for our laptops and mobile phones are likely to have been mined by children? Mica is a mineral extracted from dangerous mines in Asia and Africa, for makeup and the sheen in paint for our cars. Children as well as adults are losing their lives in these dangerous mines on a weekly basis, yet very little is being done to save them from such peril. Men and women in Asia are working and living in factories and sweatshops producing clothes for our shops. Often conditions are hazardous with risk of fire and unsafe buildings due to lack of regulations.

“Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere. We are caught in an inescapable network of mutuality, tied in a single garment of destiny. Whatever affects one directly, affects all indirectly.” Martin Luther King Jn.

The Situation in the UK

Modern slavery is happening in cities, towns and rural communities throughout the UK. In 2018, The Walk Free Foundation estimated that there were 136,000 victims of modern slavery in the UK, and the problem is growing.

In the UK, including in Wales, exploitation has been identified and survivors rescued from farms and factories, commercial cleaning companies, care homes, illegal brothels, car washes, nail bars, fast food outlets, scrap yards, situations of domestic servitude, cannabis cultivation, county lines drug dealing and other places of labour and sexual exploitation.

Individuals who find themselves homeless are at great risk of being exploited, as well as vulnerable members of society and young people. Criminals prey on the weak and show no regard for their safety.

In the UK, when concerns are raised about the well-being of an individual who might be in an exploitative situation, law enforcement agencies are called to take the person to safety and work towards bringing the criminals involved to justice, in accordance with the 2015 the Modern Slavery Act. The National Referral Mechanism (NRM) is used as the official framework for identifying potential victims, protecting and supporting each person as their case unfolds. For adults this is voluntary, and numbers continue to rise each year. It is very clear however that many potential victims do not follow this route due to fear of the authorities, or the formality of the system, or may even believe that they are not victims. Conviction rates for criminals are very low, which is a very serious concern as justice is not being done. In fact, globally the conviction rate for this serious crime is known to be 0.02% (US TIP Report). This is unacceptable and should be challenged at all levels in society.

Modern Slavery: A Guide for the Church Community 3

Signs and Indicators

Signs that Someone may be a Victim

There is no single set of signs that would immediately confirm that someone is a victim, but there are various indicators where concerns might be raised, including;

- does the person act in fear or anxiety? - does he or she seem under the control of someone? - is this person living where they work? - is he or she living in unsuitable or over-crowded accommodation? - does he or she not have money or ID documents? - do they seem unwell or unhealthy? - are they able to communicate with you?

Signs of a possible Venue / Location

Individuals who are caught in situations of exploitation are usually held against their will.

- is there a property that seems to have too many people living there or coming and going? - are these people being taken as a group to work in shifts in vehicles together? - does a property seem to be being used as a brothel? - if you use a local car wash, do the workers have proper clothes and protective equipment? Does one person take the money every time? - if you see groups of workers in the fields picking crops – do they have correct clothing? Are they working excessive hours or not having breaks? - In any business that you may observe, do the workers seem like they suit that job? Is there someone controlling their activities with potential force or violence? - children should not be working in many work places. - are you ever asked to pay by ‘cash only’

Transport and Travel

People are transported into the country or area, through airports, ports and the major (and minor) roads. At this point in their journey they may not know that they are about to be forced into sexual or labour exploitation, and so it can be difficult for authorities to identify or safeguard them.

In 2019 39 bodies were found in a shipping container in Essex, and this account has highlighted the ends that criminals will take to make money at the ultimate expense of others. These individuals were young people from Vietnam who had been promised good jobs and wages. Many of their family members had taken out loans to assist them in their journey for a ‘better life’. The lies and deception, and ultimately their deaths highlight the horrors of smuggling and trafficking.

Minibuses are used by gangs to take groups of workers to and from places of work so that they can control their movement and keep them away from any opportunities to find help. Individuals are controlled by force and fear.

Modern Slavery: A Guide for the Church Community 4

A Biblical Perspective

There are many references throughout the Bible to God’s compassion for the world and its people. God’s character is one of love, and he wants us to bring compassion to others, to speak up for the voiceless and stand against the evils that cause their suffering. As people of faith we are instructed to bring justice and compassion to those who need our help.

As people of faith, we are instructed to “pursue justice and justice alone.” (Deut 16.20).

In Zechariah 7: 9-10 the Lord says, “Administer true justice; show mercy and compassion to one another. Do not oppress the widow or the fatherless, the foreigner or the poor. Do not plot evil against each other.”

We are expected to live our lives showing kindness and compassion to those around us as part of our worship to God. Scripture says, “Is not this the kind of fasting I have chosen: to loose the chains of injustice and untie the cords of the yoke, to set the oppressed free and break every yoke?” Isaiah 58:6

We are living in a time in history where, as human beings ‘we’ are not only failing to care for others adequately, but often turning our backs to the suffering that millions are enduring throughout the world. As William Wilberforce famously said in the 1800s:

“You may choose to look the other way, but you can never say again that you did not know.”

It is important to be reminded of the imbalance in the world and understand that the unethical working practices and supply chains of multinational businesses should be challenged. These are human beings – made in the image of God and we are all equally loved by Him.

One of the world’s leading and most influential experts in this subject is Kevin Hyland OBE (former first UK Anti-Slavery Commissioner). As Senior Advisor for the Santa Marta Group, he gave a speech in the Vatican on November 2019, when he stated that:

“humanity’s moral compass needs to be realigned – what has happened to our world when we need to negotiate a solution to end child abuse and trafficking?”

We have the responsibility to care and be kind to others. As a church community and as individuals we can play our part in recognising and understanding the realities of modern slavery and human trafficking today.

Exploitation is happening in rural communities as well as in towns and cities, affecting children as well as men and women. This is a serious crime that is said to be ‘hidden in plain sight’. Surely it is time that we challenge what is considered to be acceptable within society and our world today? God is just and loving to all people. He wants us to reach out in love and kindness to others and speak out for the injustices that we see around us, and everyone can do something to make a difference.

Modern Slavery: A Guide for the Church Community 5

International Action

The United Nations Sustainable Development Goals clearly lay out the expectations of our world for the next 10 years. It is possible to address the issues of poverty, hunger, climate, education and equality. Goal 8.7 states that we need to “Take immediate and effective measures to eradicate forced labour, end modern slavery and human trafficking and secure the prohibition and elimination of the worst forms of child labour, including recruitment and use of child soldiers, and by 2025 end child labour in all its forms.”

Modern slavery is one of the world’s most horrific and serious crimes, which is growing and revealing all kinds of terrible evil coming from the minds and actions of men and women. There are more slaves in the world today than ever before, and there must be a new and determined stand against this injustice if we as believers are seen to take our faith seriously.

Practical Suggestions of what we can do

Within our church communities there are practical things that we can do. As congregations and individuals, it is important that we pray and take the issues of modern slavery seriously, believing that God will work and use people to bring about freedom and justice, and to be voices for the voiceless.

Imagine this scenario where a victim of slavery is living in your community and is only permitted to leave their captor to attend church once a week.

In most cultures around the world a church is seen as a safe place to be. This person arrives late and slips into the back of the church, keeping their eyes to the ground, nervously taking part in the service and then slipping out just before the end. Would you be able to recognise that something might be wrong with that person? Would you know what to do? This is known to have happened in Wales in recent years and the church community was able to help the young woman and help her to find freedom.

Be the eyes and ears of your church and community

Be aware of any visitors who may attend church on a Sunday and take a moment to make eye contact and a say few words with them. If you have any concerns about their demeanour or behaviour, please do something about it.

Take some time to ‘map’ your community - either on your own or as a church group. Create a form, or request a template, and make it into a small project for our community concern. Some examples of what to look out for include: - Make a note of any businesses where there might be risks of exploitation (eg nail bars, fast food outlets, car washes, agriculture or factories …)

Modern Slavery: A Guide for the Church Community 6

- Look out for unusual activities in houses or flats – many people living in over-crowded accommodation or coming and going. - Are there vulnerable people in your community who might be at risk of being exploited? Cuckooing is a term used when gangs use force to take over the home of someone without consent. - Look out for young people who might be forced into criminality by gangs. ‘County Lines’ is a crime that mainly affects young people who are groomed and then forced to sell drugs. - Are you aware of people who are living rough and might be at risk? Are homeless shelters, food banks, etc in your community? - Make a note of anyone offering ‘odd jobs’ door to door.

If you are suspicious of activities or the behaviour of people in your community, please do not hesitate to report your concerns. If you are concerned about someone within the church setting, find the person responsible for safeguarding and tell them.

Ask some questions

If you are interested in finding out more about the reality of exploitation that is happening in your local area and be aware of the risks and signs, you can ask questions to those in public office. The information that you receive is very important in creating a picture that the Church and local organisations can use in developing informed and appropriate projects to support survivors, raise awareness, teach our young people, reach out to the homeless and other vulnerable people living among us.

The Home Office and Welsh Government have a responsibility to act in line with the Modern Slavery Act, the European and International protocols and conventions. By asking the right questions, we can support the work that is being done. We know that our public services are stretched financially and with resources, and tackling crimes such as modern slavery is very complex.

Who to write to:  Your MP and MS  Home Office and Welsh Government  Local Authority, County Council and Town Council  The Police and Crime Commissioner and Chief Constable

Ask for information about issues such as:  How many potential victims of modern slavery were in your county over the past year and what were the types of exploitation?  How many convictions were there in the last year, under the Modern Slavery Act?  What are the long-term care services for survivors in this area?

Pray for

 The global situation where injustice is common.  Men, women and children are living in fear and abusive situations; some dying as slaves.  The national level in the UK, as cases of modern slavery are increasing.  The statutory agencies who have a responsibility to deal with all aspects from law enforcement, for the arrests and convictions of criminals.

Modern Slavery: A Guide for the Church Community 7

 Local authorities and third sector agencies who work to identify, rescue and support victims.  For individuals who are caught in slavery and so desperate to be found and taken to safety.  Professionals who are in positions to implement laws, policies and influence governments and multi-national businesses to recognise their responsibilities to care for people over money.

What should I do if I have concerns?

If you are concerned about a person or situation, please report it.

Within the Church setting to your Safeguarding Officer

North Wales Police:

999 in an emergency or 101 in non-emergency

CrimeStoppers:

0800 555 111 This service is available 24/7 and is always anonymous Online at crimestoppers-uk.org

For More Information

For information about modern slavery including training and awareness raising sessions

Contact: The Office of the Diocese of St Asaph Tel. 01745 582245

Haven of Light (charitable organisation) Email. [email protected] Tel. 07929777347

Modern Slavery: A Guide for the Church Community 8