DOCSLIB.ORG

The Educative Experience of Punk Learners

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Educative Experience of Punk Learners University of Denver Digital Commons @ DU Electronic Theses and Dissertations Graduate Studies 6-1-2014 "Punk Has Always Been My School": The Educative Experience of Punk Learners Rebekah A. Cordova University of Denver Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.du.edu/etd Part of the Curriculum and Instruction Commons Recommended Citation Cordova, Rebekah A., ""Punk Has Always Been My School": The Educative Experience of Punk Learners" (2014). Electronic Theses and Dissertations. 142. https://digitalcommons.du.edu/etd/142 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate Studies at Digital Commons @ DU. It has been accepted for inclusion in Electronic Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons @ DU. For more information, please contact [email protected],[email protected]. “Punk Has Always Been My School”: The Educative Experience of Punk Learners __________ A Dissertation Presented to the Faculty of the Morgridge College of Education University of Denver __________ In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy __________ by Rebekah A. Cordova June 2014 Advisor: Dr. Bruce Uhrmacher i ©Copyright by Rebekah A. Cordova 2014 All Rights Reserved ii Author: Rebekah A. Cordova Title: “Punk has always been my school”: The educative experience of punk learners Advisor: Dr. Bruce Uhrmacher Degree Date: June 2014 ABSTRACT Punk music, ideology, and community have been a piece of United States culture since the early-1970s. Although varied scholarship on Punk exists in a variety of disciplines, the educative aspect of Punk engagement, specifically the Do-It-Yourself (DIY) ethos, has yet to be fully explored by the Education discipline. This study attempts to illucidate the experiences of adults who describe their engagement with Punk as educative. To better know this experience, is to also better understand the ways in which Punk engagement impacts learner self-concept and learning development. Through the phenomenological in-depth interviewing of six adult participants located in Los Angeles, California and Gainesville, Florida, narrative data is interpreted to reveal their education journey that contains mis-educative experiences, educative experiences, and ultimately educative healing experiences. Through the framework set of Public Pedagogy, Social Learning Theory, and Self-Directed Learning Development, this research aims to contribute to scholarship that brings learning contexts in from the margins of education rhetoric and into the center of analysis by better understanding and uncovering the essence of the learning experience outside of school. Additionally, it broadens the understanding of Punk engagement in an attempt to have an an increased nuanced perspective of the independent learning that may be perceived as more educative that any formal attempt within our schooling systems. i ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Thank you, first and foremost, the humid forested Ozarks of Missouri. You were my first site of empowered learning and taught me what it means to be a confident person who could navigate any form of wildness. Thank you to my mother, Dr. Karla Haas Moskowitz, my first teacher. Without your guidance and support, this research would have lived on as a desire in my mind instead of a completed work of art. Special thanks to my husband, Joseph Cordova, my incredible children, Anna Lucia, Joaquin, Augustus, and Violet Paloma. You all made the endless hours of writing and research possible and helped me keep going at every turn. Thank you to my sister Jacquelynn McDaniel, your love and support has meant the world to me . Thank you to my committee members, Kate Willink, Bruce Uhrmacher, Nicole Russell, Hava Gordon, and, my advisor, Nick Cutforth, for your tireless years of guidance. Lastly, a most grateful thank you to the rockin’ Razorcake community in Los Angeles, California and the amazing Lay family in Gainesville, Florida - you endlessly supported my work and made me feel at home whenever I was in your company. I am truly a better person because I have known you all. ii TABLE OF CONTENTS INSPIRATION ................................................................................................................... 1 CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION ................................................................................. 4 PROBLEM POSING ............................................................................................................. 6 FRAMEWORK .................................................................................................................. 10 Public Pedagogy ........................................................................................................ 10 Social Learning Theory .............................................................................................. 14 Self-Directed Learning ............................................................................................... 16 CHAPTER TWO: LITERATURE REVIEW AND RESEARCH METHODOLOGY ... 21 LITERATURE REVIEW ...................................................................................................... 21 Historical and Political Roots of Punk ...................................................................... 23 Hardcore Punk ........................................................................................................... 25 Do-It-Yourself (DIY) Ethic ......................................................................................... 27 Punk Music Scene: Punk Shows and Lyrics ............................................................... 30 Punk Zines .................................................................................................................. 38 Punk-Based Activist Organizations ............................................................................ 43 Critique of Punk: Race and Whiteness ....................................................................... 53 RESEARCH METHODOLOGY ............................................................................................ 56 History and Aims of Phenomenology ......................................................................... 57 Research Context ........................................................................................................ 59 Phenomenological In-Depth Interviewing ................................................................. 60 Data Analysis: Interpretive Phenomenological Analysis (IPA) ................................. 61 Pilot Study .................................................................................................................. 64 Research Study Design ............................................................................................... 68 Limitations of Study .................................................................................................... 72 CHAPTER THREE: PARTICIPANT NARRATIVE PROFILES ................................... 74 AARON L. ....................................................................................................................... 78 YAM ............................................................................................................................... 91 SEAN C ........................................................................................................................... 98 ERIN B .......................................................................................................................... 105 DAVE D ........................................................................................................................ 116 TODD T ......................................................................................................................... 126 CHAPTER FOUR: PUNK AND EDUCATION HORIZONS ...................................... 136 PHENOMENOLOGICAL HORIZONS .................................................................................. 137 Punk as: Learner Self-Concept Awareness .............................................................. 139 Punk as: Mis-Educative Experience Awareness ...................................................... 143 Punk as: Educative Healing ..................................................................................... 151 iii CHAPTER FIVE: DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION .............................................. 170 PUNK AS: PUBLIC PEDAGOGY ....................................................................................... 172 PUNK AS: SOCIAL LEARNING THEORY .......................................................................... 175 PUNK AS: SELF-DIRECTED LEARNING .......................................................................... 178 ROLE OF MIS-EDUCATION ............................................................................................ 185 ROLE OF EDUCATIVE HEALING ..................................................................................... 190 SUMMARY AND FUTURE RESEARCH ............................................................................. 198 CONCLUSION: A DESIRE PATH ..................................................................................... 201 REFERENCES ................................................................................................................. 205 APPENDICES ................................................................................................................. 228 Appendix A: Research Solicitation ..........................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Concert Hall As a Medium of Musical Culture: the Technical Mediation of Listening in the 19Th Century
    The Concert Hall as a Medium of Musical Culture: The Technical Mediation of Listening in the 19th Century by Darryl Mark Cressman M.A. (Communication), University of Windsor, 2004 B.A (Hons.), University of Windsor, 2002 Dissertation Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the School of Communication Faculty of Communication, Art and Technology © Darryl Mark Cressman 2012 SIMON FRASER UNIVERSITY Fall 2012 All rights reserved. However, in accordance with the Copyright Act of Canada, this work may be reproduced, without authorization, under the conditions for “Fair Dealing.” Therefore, limited reproduction of this work for the purposes of private study, research, criticism, review and news reporting is likely to be in accordance with the law, particularly if cited appropriately. Approval Name: Darryl Mark Cressman Degree: Doctor of Philosophy (Communication) Title of Thesis: The Concert Hall as a Medium of Musical Culture: The Technical Mediation of Listening in the 19th Century Examining Committee: Chair: Martin Laba, Associate Professor Andrew Feenberg Senior Supervisor Professor Gary McCarron Supervisor Associate Professor Shane Gunster Supervisor Associate Professor Barry Truax Internal Examiner Professor School of Communication, Simon Fraser Universty Hans-Joachim Braun External Examiner Professor of Modern Social, Economic and Technical History Helmut-Schmidt University, Hamburg Date Defended: September 19, 2012 ii Partial Copyright License iii Abstract Taking the relationship
    [Show full text]
  • The Anti-Authoritarian Chَros
    E. DIMITRIS KITIS The Anti-Authoritarian Chóros A Space for Youth Socialization and Radicalization in Greece (1974–2010) he Balkan historian Mark Mazower, highlighting that there is a conundrum posed by anarchist groups in Greece, observed: “We Thave, to my knowledge, no serious study of this subject, nor of the ways labels, such as ␣␯␣␳␹␫␬␱´ι (anarchists) and ␣␯␶␫␧␰␱␷␴␫␣␴␶␧´␵ (anti- authoritarians) have been deployed sometimes by people in their own name and others by their opponents.”1 The purpose of this article is to address this question and give a preliminary genealogy of the anarchist phenomenon in Greece since 1974. The history of Greece since World War II includes a civil war (1946–49), which unofficially started before the liberation of the country from the Axis powers, and a military dictatorship (1967–74). These watershed events occurred in the backdrop of a vicious rift between rightists and leftists that permeated the whole of Greek society for the rest of the Cold War. The article sets out to examine the origins (and the makings) of a particular type of disaffection that developed among youth during the period of the Metapolitefsi. The Metapolitefsi, which is the time frame for this article, was the historical period after the fall of the military dictatorship in Greece (1974) that was marked by liberalization or democratization and greater integration into Europe. It is important to note that the fall of the dictatorship was precipitated by the Polytechnic Journal for the Study of Radicalism, Vol. 9, No. 1, 2015, pp. 1–36. ISSN 1930-1189 © 2015 Michigan State University.
    [Show full text]
  • ALBUM? Peter Gabriel and St~Ng,These I Dudesdohaveasenseofhumor, ~IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII~ As the "If I Were A...I'dt' Series and "Nasty Man" Can Attest To
    . - .. - . -. ~. A ~ , - . , . , . , . , -. ::*--.i'_'.-. ~-----.~.7. '. .,.? 7 . ~ $ .. ,, t-c. * .A?. ' - a -. .-? ' '9' . " -, , -,, &., ,:.--: .: .. ., . , y , - . ,,;.? .. .- . .. -- 8 ' . ,"<, ' ~..D. ? PAGE 3 k SLUG To Mike Carlson, wereright, though.mestagewas me, industrial always was shit ENTEIWAINMENT Once again you have con- PM~..---. like ELP, Kraftwerk, Laibach, GUIIBE AN11 firmed the fact that you are a 4. Mary Annerules. She is the This guy 1tEVIEW complete geek Do you ever tire AlternativeCultural Icon for this what's of public humiliation? month. Next up, I submit Chris Youn in warm regards, -1 -1 T. Stinson Robin. Love and bullets, 5. Matt Taylor is right on the Charlee X Nine Editor /Publisher Dearest Dickheads, ball, friends and neighbors. To J.R. Ruppel Controversy, controvesy, controversy! After reading the Sales & Production SlugNo.30/June'91 issue,I must Natalie Kaminski respond to the following: 1. Mike Carlson, suck mine. Photographs Your.bullshit attitude is right Robert DeBerry from the pages of Maximum Special Thanx To: Rock And Roll. "Getting signed Lara Bringard to the maprs and being bled dry Matt Taylor for the bloodsucking consumer Scott Bringard machine?" That shit happens on quite a few indies, too, but why AND OUR TWANX TOOOOOO: 'even bother to record or tour JanBny, Jon Shum~,Brd OWu. Woody Gonulu, Bud Bmrkrq dthout somedegreeof success? Rlck Ruppl, Dan Kw. MuhMron, Sorry, babycake<but the money Xotl Bdngud, Kwh Uk,Charlea Johmn, BUI Ward, Hofflnc Rlnthg, goes along with this and it's not CopperfleldPublbhlng the cash that makes things bad, ?he opinions and views expressed but what you do with it. If this in this rag are those of the writem wasn't the case, records would and arc nM necessarily those of the be free of charge to make and people who pur this shit together.
    [Show full text]
  • Doctor Who 4 Ep 17.GREENS
    Doctor Who 4 Episode 17 By Russell T Davies Shooting Script GREENS 18th April 2009 Prep starts: 23rd Feb Shooting starts: 30th March Tale Writer's The Doctor Who 4 Episode 17 SHOOTING SCRIPT 20/03/09 page 1 1 FX SHOT - PLANET EARTH 1 FX: THE EARTH, suspended in space, in all its beauty. Over this, the NARRATOR. An old, wise man. NARRATOR It is said that in the final days of Planet Earth, everyone had bad dreams. MIX TO: 2 EXT. SHOPPING STREET - NIGHT 1 2 CAMERA craning down a huge, outdoor CHRISTMAS TREE... NARRATOR To the west of the north of that world, the Human Race did gather, in celebration of a pagan rite, to banish the cold and the dark. ...craning down to find a SALVATION ARMY BRASS BAND. God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen; the most mournful of carols. Moving round to find a few ONLOOKERS Tale(SHOPPERS in b/g). People, just dotted about, pausing. A woman & gran. Three teenagers. A family, mum, dad and little daughter... NARRATOR (CONT'D) Each and every one of those people had dreamt of the terrible things to come. But they forgot, because they must; they forgot their nightmares, of fire and war and insanity. Writer's They forgot... ...then finding WILFRED MOTT. NARRATOR (CONT'D) TheExcept for one. Wilf's troubled, uneasy, and on his CLOSE UP - INTERCUT, fast, violent - CU of a FACE, bleached, against black - manic laughter - a familiar face, it's - Wilf blinks. Shakes it off. Turns away... CUT TO WIDER. Wilf wandering along. Lost in thought.
    [Show full text]
  • The Direct Action Politics of US Punk Collectives
    DIY Democracy 23 DIY Democracy: The Direct Action Politics of U.S. Punk Collectives Dawson Barrett Somewhere between the distanced slogans and abstract calls to arms, we . discovered through Gilman a way to give our politics some application in our actual lives. Mike K., 924 Gilman Street One of the ideas behind ABC is breaking down the barriers between bands and people and making everyone equal. There is no Us and Them. Chris Boarts-Larson, ABC No Rio Kurt Cobain once told an interviewer, “punk rock should mean freedom.”1 The Nirvana singer was arguing that punk, as an idea, had the potential to tran- scend the boundaries of any particular sound or style, allowing musicians an enormous degree of artistic autonomy. But while punk music has often served as a platform for creative expression and symbolic protest, its libratory potential stems from a more fundamental source. Punk, at its core, is a form of direct action. Instead of petitioning the powerful for inclusion, the punk movement has built its own elaborate network of counter-institutions, including music venues, media, record labels, and distributors. These structures have operated most notably as cultural and economic alternatives to the corporate entertainment industry, and, as such, they should also be understood as sites of resistance to the privatizing 0026-3079/2013/5202-023$2.50/0 American Studies, 52:2 (2013): 23-42 23 24 Dawson Barrett agenda of neo-liberalism. For although certain elements of punk have occasion- ally proven marketable on a large scale, the movement itself has been an intense thirty-year struggle to maintain autonomous cultural spaces.2 When punk emerged in the mid-1970s, it quickly became a subject of in- terest to activists and scholars who saw in it the potential seeds of a new social movement.
    [Show full text]
  • Juin 2013 À 20H30 Le Plus En Vue Du Moment: the Upbeats
    la programmation de Forde bénéficie le Moloko ne bénéficie pas d’autre soutien que de celui de ses nombreux-ses ami-es le Zoo ne bénéficie pas d’autre soutien que de celui de ses amis Nous voila rendus au dernier stade du processus : le grand du soutien de la Ville de Genève Samedi 22 Juin oral final ! Selon le principe de l'autogestion (qui nous est chère) Salle ... de nuit IN THE MOOD FOR tou.te.s les membres sont appelé à élire leur futur.e col- 4 place des volontaires, VIOLENCE [DUBSTEP] JUIN 201 JUIN lègue et représentant.e. 1er étage, droite BAR9 Z Audio, Audio Freaks, Dark Circles / UK Chaque candidat se présente donc devant l’association + : www.lezoo.ch (une cinquantaine de membres environ y assiste) qui, sui- BARE NOIZE Eight:FX, Audio Freaks, Buygore / UK te à ces entretiens grandeur nature, vote. WICKED ONE Cover Your Face / CH Fin du processus !! ... Wow wow wow! Watch out Genève, deux pointures de la ... qui recommence à chaque tournus au sein de la dubstep débarquent en ville! Pour cette deuxième soirée de permanence ! 1er étage, gauche , la fête de la musique, le Zoo vous offre LE plateau dont vous Buvette 4 place des volontaires rêvez. Tout d'abord le genevois Wicked One, qu'on a pu L'Usine dépense donc sans compter son temps et son www.darksite.ch/moloko écouter au côté de Datsik il y a peu de temps, viendra nous énergie pour élire ses permanent.e.s ! socio-culturelle préchauffer les oreilles avant de laisser la place à deux pontes C'est qu'elle les aime ! (et qu'illes le lui rendent bien!) Ouvert de 20h à 3h (non-fumeur) de la dubstep dirty, les anglais Bar9 et Bare Noize.
    [Show full text]
  • 25-29 Music Listings 4118.Indd
    saturday–sunday MUSIC Ladysmith Black Mambazo Guantanamo Baywatch, Hurry Up, SUNDAY, MARCH 8 [AFRIcA’S GoLDEn tHRoAtS] the Cumstain, Pookie and Poodlez legendary, Grammy-hoarding South [GARAGE RocK] on its new single African vocal group, now halfway Retox, Whores, ”too Late,” Portland’s Guantanamo through its fifth decade, has tran- Rabbits, Phantom Family Baywatch trades its formerly scended the Western pop notori- [HARDCORE] Fatalist, nihilist, blis- reverb-flooded garage-rock sound ety that followed its contributions tering, brutal—these are just a few for tamer, Motown-influenced bal- to Paul Simon’s Graceland, becom- of the better words to describe ladry. It’s a signal that the upcom- ing a full-fledged ambassador for hardcore crew Retox, a group whose ing Darling…It’s Too Late, dropping the culture of its homeland. But pedigree includes members of sim- in May on Suicide Squeeze, may one doesn’t need familiarity with ilarly thorny outfits such as the fully shift the band away from that its lengthy history to be stirred Locust, Head Wound city and Holy signature Burger Records’ sound, by those golden voices. Aladdin Molar. one adjective that doesn’t which has flooded the market Theater, 3017 SE Milwaukie Ave., get used very often, though it with pseudo-psychedelic surf-rock 234-9694. 8 pm. $35. 21+. should, is “funny.” It’s understand- groups indistinguishable from one able that this quality wouldn’t trans- another. LUcAS cHEMOTTI. The late through singer Justin Pearson’s Low Cut Connie Know, 2026 NE Alberta St., 473- larynx-ripping screech. But Retox [tHE WHItE KEYS] An invasive 8729.
    [Show full text]
  • Here Were Homeless People All Around Us and a Lot of Fighting Going On
    GUILT Ati Moran (Breaking Free Fanzine) on hardcore: Hardcore for me is definitely an idea, an expression of feelings and [an attitude of] never giving up on what you believe in. [It’s] an emotion you feel strong about that no one can take away from you! I also be- lieve hardcore has a lot to do with the people I met in the last 22 years who were apart of the scene - they weren’t everyday people. Besides hardcore being music, it was a place to get away from the normal world! Charles Maggio (Rorschach, Gern Blandsten Records) on hardcore: John Brannon said it best: hardcore is the “blues of the suburbs.” QUICKsaND Walter Schreifels (Quicksand, Gorilla Biscuits) on fighting/ disagreements in hardcore: In the scene there were homeless people all around us and a lot of fighting going on. There was the whole punks versus skins thing. There was that back drop, so it was a pretty obvious place to say something about it, and it’s cool to have a scene that allows for that discussion. That’s what gives it power in a way. The hardcore scene is like high school. There’s the typical bullshit that goes on everywhere, but it’s cooler because it’s like a musical high school and there’s something kind of romantic about that. There was also a lot of back and forth between hip- hop and hardcore at the time, too. There was a time when there was a lot of racism but there was a whole backlash against that.
    [Show full text]
  • Razorcake Issue
    PO Box 42129, Los Angeles, CA 90042 #19 www.razorcake.com ight around the time we were wrapping up this issue, Todd hours on the subject and brought in visual aids: rare and and I went to West Hollywood to see the Swedish band impossible-to-find records that only I and four other people have RRRandy play. We stood around outside the club, waiting for or ancient punk zines that have moved with me through a dozen the show to start. While we were doing this, two young women apartments. Instead, I just mumbled, “It’s pretty important. I do a came up to us and asked if they could interview us for a project. punk magazine with him.” And I pointed my thumb at Todd. They looked to be about high-school age, and I guess it was for a About an hour and a half later, Randy took the stage. They class project, so we said, “Sure, we’ll do it.” launched into “Dirty Tricks,” ripped right through it, and started I don’t think they had any idea what Razorcake is, or that “Addicts of Communication” without a pause for breath. It was Todd and I are two of the founders of it. unreal. They were so tight, so perfectly in time with each other that They interviewed me first and asked me some basic their songs sounded as immaculate as the recordings. On top of questions: who’s your favorite band? How many shows do you go that, thought, they were going nuts. Jumping around, dancing like to a month? That kind of thing.
    [Show full text]
  • The Operational Aesthetic in the Performance of Professional Wrestling William P
    Louisiana State University LSU Digital Commons LSU Doctoral Dissertations Graduate School 2005 The operational aesthetic in the performance of professional wrestling William P. Lipscomb III Louisiana State University and Agricultural and Mechanical College, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.lsu.edu/gradschool_dissertations Part of the Communication Commons Recommended Citation Lipscomb III, William P., "The operational aesthetic in the performance of professional wrestling" (2005). LSU Doctoral Dissertations. 3825. https://digitalcommons.lsu.edu/gradschool_dissertations/3825 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate School at LSU Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in LSU Doctoral Dissertations by an authorized graduate school editor of LSU Digital Commons. For more information, please [email protected]. THE OPERATIONAL AESTHETIC IN THE PERFORMANCE OF PROFESSIONAL WRESTLING A Dissertation Submitted to the Graduate Faculty of the Louisiana State University and Agricultural and Mechanical College in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in The Department of Communication Studies by William P. Lipscomb III B.S., University of Southern Mississippi, 1990 B.S., University of Southern Mississippi, 1991 M.S., University of Southern Mississippi, 1993 May 2005 ©Copyright 2005 William P. Lipscomb III All rights reserved ii ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I am so thankful for the love and support of my entire family, especially my mom and dad. Both my parents were gifted educators, and without their wisdom, guidance, and encouragement none of this would have been possible. Special thanks to my brother John for all the positive vibes, and to Joy who was there for me during some very dark days.
    [Show full text]
  • Qualified Products List
    OREGON DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION CONSTRUCTION SECTION QUALIFIED PRODUCTS LIST PUBLISHING DATE: JULY 2021 The Qualified Products List is updated every six months or amended as needed. QUALIFIED PRODUCTS LIST OREGON DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION The "QUALIFIED PRODUCTS LIST" (QPL) is a comprehensive list of all finished products which have been evaluated and/or used by the Oregon DOT. Description Page # The "QUALIFIED PRODUCTS LIST" is made up of two types of lists: Index by Category, for Spec #................................. I-III Traffic Control Devices…...............……........…....... IV 1. The QUALIFIED LIST - “Q” is for products that have been Erosion Control Devices ........................………..... V - VI reviewed and found to be suitable for use in a specific category. Job Pavement Markings ………....................……….... VII - VIII control testing may still be necessary. Consult the ODOT Nonfield- Qualified & Approved List.....................................1 – 212 Tested Materials Acceptance Guide", the "ODOT Field-Tested by Spec Number . Reinforcing Steel ……….........................………... A1-A18 Materials Acceptance Guide", and the Project Specifications 2. The APPROVED LIST - “A” is for commercially available products having a low consequence of failure. These products are only usable for appropriate applications. May Require a Field Inspection Report. The “QPL” and submittal forms are accessible from the Internet: State existence on the Approved List and recognition of the product. No additional sampling or testing is needed. Qualified Products Web Page Although the products listed may be approved for use, they are not Specific questions regarding products on the un-published exempt from State Purchasing Rules, practices and guidelines, or CONDITIONAL LIST can be answered by calling 503/986-3059. manufacturer’s warrantees or guarantees. “Conditionally Approved” products need specific, prior If you have questions, contact: approval for each project.
    [Show full text]
  • Reed First Pages
    4. Northern England 1. Progress in Hell Northern England was both the center of the European industrial revolution and the birthplace of industrial music. From the early nineteenth century, coal and steel works fueled the economies of cities like Manchester and She!eld and shaped their culture and urban aesthetics. By 1970, the region’s continuous mandate of progress had paved roads and erected buildings that told 150 years of industrial history in their ugly, collisive urban planning—ever new growth amidst the expanding junkyard of old progress. In the BBC documentary Synth Britannia, the narrator declares that “Victorian slums had been torn down and replaced by ultramodern concrete highrises,” but the images on the screen show more brick ruins than clean futurescapes, ceaselessly "ashing dystopian sky- lines of colorless smoke.1 Chris Watson of the She!eld band Cabaret Voltaire recalls in the late 1960s “being taken on school trips round the steelworks . just seeing it as a vision of hell, you know, never ever wanting to do that.”2 #is outdated hell smoldered in spite of the city’s supposed growth and improve- ment; a$er all, She!eld had signi%cantly enlarged its administrative territory in 1967, and a year later the M1 motorway opened easy passage to London 170 miles south, and wasn’t that progress? Institutional modernization neither erased northern England’s nineteenth- century combination of working-class pride and disenfranchisement nor of- fered many genuinely new possibilities within culture and labor, the Open Uni- versity notwithstanding. In literature and the arts, it was a long-acknowledged truism that any municipal attempt at utopia would result in totalitarianism.
    [Show full text]