Aboricultural Inspection Report

ARBORICULTURAL INSPECTION REPORT TREE RETENTION AND REMOVAL PROPOSED FOR PRIVATE LOTS, ROAD RESERVE, TREE RESERVE AND WETLAND AREAS MULLUM CREEK ESTATE 112-126 OLD WARRANDYTE ROAD, DONVALE (REVISED FROM JUNE, 2014)

AUGUST 2014

Prepared by Stephen Fitzgerald for: Mullum Pty Ltd

A RBORICULTURE PTY LTD 36 T H E C R E S C E N T S A S S A F R A S 3 7 8 7 abn: 33 139 546 357

TABLE OF CONTENTS

1 BRIEF ………………………………………… 1

2 BACKGROUND ………………………………………… 2

3 METHOD ………………………………………… 2 3.1 Arboricultural Inspection Method ……………………… 2 3.2 Defined Survey Areas ……………………………………… 3 3.3 Retention Value …………………………………………… 4 3.4 The Arborist’s Role in the Development Site ……….. 5 Planning Process

4 TREE REMOVAL JUSTIFICATIONS OTHER THAN ……….. 5 ARBORICULTURAL 4.1 Landscape Vision ……………………………………….. 5 4.2 Built Form ……………………………………….. 6

5 TREE DETAILS SUMMARY ………………………………… 6 5.1 Noteworthy tree specimens …………………………. 11

6 DISCUSSION ……………………………………….. 11 6.1 Tree species requiring special consideration ……….. 11 given site conditions and environment 6.2 Tree defects ……………………………………….. 13

7 RECOMMENDATIONS ……………………………………….. 14

8 REFERENCES 15

APPENDIX 1 – PHOTOGRAPHS ………………………………… 16

APPENDIX 2 –TREE INSPECTION RECORDS …………………… 19 (ORDERED BY LOT/AREA)

APPENDIX 3 – DEFINITIONS AND METHODS …………………… 76

APPENDIX 4 – HISTORY OF MATHEWS PROPERTY TREE ………. 81 PLANTINGS

ATTACHMENT 1 – LANDSCAPE VISION

ATTACHMENT 2 – SCHEDULE TO BUILT FORM ANALYSIS

ATTACHMENT 3 – TREE LOCATION /REMOVAL PLAN

Arboriculture Mullum Creek Tree Retention/Removal - Private Realms & Wetlands Table of Contents

A RBORICULTURE PTY LTD 36 T H E C R E S C E N T S A S S A F R A S 3 7 8 7 abn: 33 139 546 357

13/8/2014 REPORT 10531.62014

Arboricultural Report: Tree Retention and Removal Proposed for Private Lots, Road Reserve, Tree Reserve and Wetland Areas, Mullum Creek Estate, 112-126 Old Warrandyte Road, Donvale (revised 13/8/2014) 1. Brief

This report details trees nominated for removal and retention within lots in private realm areas, tree reserves, road reserves and areas marked as ‘Wetland’ within PCRZ (public conservation and resource zone) zoned areas within Mullum Creek Estate development. The report specifically targets trees requiring a permit for removal under Significant Landscape Overlay schedule 8 (SLO 8) (trees within the private realms area) and Environmental Significance Overlay schedule 3 (ESO 3) (PCRZ area). The following is an extract from Schedule 3 to The Environmental Significance Overlay – 3 Permit Requirement. Vegetation: A permit is only required to remove, destroy or lop: Victorian native vegetation. An Australian native tree that has either: o A trunk circumference of more than 0.35 metre measured at a height of 1.3 metres above natural ground level. o A height of more than 6 metres. A dead eucalypt tree that is both: o More than 20 metres from a building (excluding fences) to the base of the trunk. o Greater than 1 metre (approx 26cm DBH) in circumference, measured at a height of 1.3 metres above natural ground level. A permit is not required for: Dead vegetation except for dead eucalypt trees as specified above. A tree with its trunk within two metres of the roof (including eaves) of an existing building used for accommodation. Any species listed as exempt from a permit requirement in the Table to the Schedule.

SLO Schedule 8 is similar to ESO 3 but applies to exotic as well as Australian native vegetation and does not require a permit for removal of dead

Stephen Fitzgerald BAppSc (Melb. Uni.) AdvCertHort, AdvCertArb. (Burnley) All aspects of tree management, consultancy and arboricultural service Fully insured 9755 2289 Mobile: 0419 377 872 E-mail: [email protected] Page 1 of 81 vegetation or the pruning of trees for regeneration or ornamental shaping. ESO Schedule 3 does not exempt trees having trunks within two metres of the roof of an existing building used for accommodation. Where trees are nominated for removal in this report they include arboricultural (determined by the arborist), built form (determined by project architects) and landscape vision (determined through various project consultants) justifications or combinations. The built form and landscape vision justifications are contributed by others and referenced as such. 2. Background The Mullum Creek estate is located along the western bank of the Mullum Mullum Creek in Donvale, within the Manningham City Council. The site comprises 19.6 hectares of predominantly former farming land (orchard and grazing) of undulating topography. New residential allotments are confined to previously cleared land, and the creek frontage and remnant bushland (approximately 45% of the original property) will become a public reserve. The Mullum Creek Masterplan includes 56 lots that range from 1000 to 3500 sqm and is designed to sit within and enhance the natural features of the site, providing access to the reserves, the Linear Park and Bike Trail, and connecting with the surrounding neighbourhood that will continue to provide habitat for a wide variety of indigenous animals & plants (from Landscape Vision – Attachment 1). The Mathew’s family have owned, lived on and cultivated the Mullum Creek property for more than 50 years. Mr Steve Mathews is responsible for the wide variety and extent of amenity, farm forestry, revegetation and other plantings that exist throughout the property (see Appendix 4, History of Mathews Property Tree Plantings for further details). Several arboricultural tree inspection surveys of the property have been carried out since an initial inspection survey by Stephen Fitzgerald in1999. Major updates of the initial survey were carried out in 2002 and 2010. These and a number of further detailed surveys as well as advice from other consultants has helped identify tree management issues and constraints during the planning of the current development. 3. Method 3.1 Arboricultural Inspection Method Trees located from survey plans provided within the defined areas were visually inspected1 from ground level, their heights estimated and trunk diameters (DBH2) measured as per Australian Standard AS 4970, Protection of trees on development sites. No decay detection (apart from visual identification of fungal fruiting bodies) or intrusive investigation methods were carried out on the trees or their root systems.

1Visual inspection in the case of tree assessment implies certain limitations. See Appendix 2 Definitions and Methods for further explanation.

2 Diameter at breast height – 1.4m above ground level

Arboriculture Mullum Creek Tree Retention/Removal Arboricultural Report 2014 Page 2 of 81 Trees were labelled by a surveyor during a feature survey prior to the current tree inspection. Where labels were found to be missing a label was affixed to the tree using numbers from a previous tree inspection survey of the site. For this reason some trees will be marked with label tags with ‘T’ followed by a number (surveyor’s number) and some without a letter prefix (numbering from the arborist’s previous survey of the property). Occasionally duplicate surveyor’s numbers were found on tree tags during the tree inspection survey. In such cases an ‘x’ was added as a suffix to one of the tags and recorded in the survey data to distinguish the trees. The numbering system does not always follow an orderly system on site due to this complication. Where no tree survey point was found on the survey supplied (the tree had been missed by the surveyor), a geographical point was added to an electronic map using field GIS software application (ESRI Arcpad) and a Trimble professional grade global navigation satellite system (GNSS) receiver with subscription differentia l correction yielding sub-metre accuracy. Arboricultural maintenance requirements recommendations were made where appropriate to minimise risk and prolong the aesthetic and landscape life expectancy of the trees. Maintenance recommendations are prioritised as low, medium, high or urgent with perceived risk being the main determining factor. See Appendix 4 Definitions & Methods – Priority (action) for suggested minimum time schedules for each priority. Where trees were deemed not suitable for retention they were indicated for removal. Some trees were indicated as low retention value but not specifically indicated for removal. It is expected that most of these trees will be removed and replaced where appropriate some time over the next few years as the development proceeds. Tree protection zones (TPZ) were calculated to Australian Standards Australia, 2009, Australian Standard AS4970 – Protection of Trees on Development Sites, NSW. As AS4970 does not specifically prescribe TPZs for dead trees (TPZs are formulated to provide for the viability of the tree), a nominal structural root zone (SRZ) has been used in place to provide for the short-term stability (until the such time as its structural roots decay sufficiently for the tree to collapse) of the tree should it be retained. Tree locations and TPZ area are shown in Attachment 3 - Tree Location Plan. 3.2 Defined Survey Areas Two distinct survey inspection areas were defined and trees outside these areas are not included in this report. The areas are defined as: 1. Public lot areas (Stage 1 and Stage 2) defined as lots on the survey plans provided; 2. Wetlands areas. Trees within the areas indicated in discussions and site meetings as possible extents of wetland areas (north and south). As the final wetland location areas were not defined at the

Arboriculture Mullum Creek Tree Retention/Removal Arboricultural Report 2014 Page 3 of 81 time of the tree inspection survey, additional trees close to but most likely unaffected by the proposed construction have been included in this report.

3.3 Retention Value All trees inspected were assigned a ‘retention value’ to facilitate tree management decisions and inform the design process. Factors contributing to retention value include:

tree origin (indigenous self-propagated or remnant, or exotic);

significance (other than indigenous);

species suitability to the urban residential/naturalistic parkland situation, and,

condition (health and structure). Self-sown, remnant indigenous and planted indigenous trees of known local seed source were generally rated higher than trees from non- indigenous or unknown seed sources. Trees considered as being in a potentially dangerous condition rated lowest regardless of their significance or origins although where it was thought appropriate comment was made that ‘buffer zone’ of a given distance may allow a particular tree to be retained. Tree specimens that rated low were mainly weedy species, tree species regarded as being inappropriate to the urban residential situation and specimens with low life expectancy. Young trees were generally rated medium or low retention reflecting that they are replaceable within a relatively short amount of time given planting or natural recruitment. As such, mature specimens where they were long-lived species, have greater amenity, ecological and other values were generally rated higher reflecting that a great period of time, management and protection is needed for their replacement. Low Retention trees should have low priority compared to development considerations. Trees should be removed if recommended specifically in the Works field of the tree inspection record. Trees considered to have low retention value should, over time, be removed and replaced, if appropriate with more suitable specimens. Medium Retention trees should be retained wherever desirable but could be removed to allow for development. High Retention trees are mainly semi-mature and mature specimens assessed as being most appropriate to the intended purpose of the property and the environment. While these trees should be preserved wherever possible, a few may need to be removed where they impede reasonable use of the land and design possibilities are greatly constrained. Very High Retention trees are mainly mature or overmature indigenous specimens (in the case of large, old remnant specimens). These trees are mostly remnant indigenous trees or exotic trees of particular significance.

Arboriculture Mullum Creek Tree Retention/Removal Arboricultural Report 2014 Page 4 of 81 These trees should be preserved wherever possible and usually justify special design or engineering where appropriate for their retention. For further definition of retention value see Appendix 3, Definitions. Photos were taken with a Panasonic digital camera (see Appendix 1).

3.4 The Arborist’s Role in the Development Site Planning Process This report follows the Australian Standard AS 4970-2009, Protection of Trees on Development Sites, Section 2: Planning and the Tree Management Process where appropriate. The following AS sections have been addressed in part or full in the preparation of this report: 2.3.2 - Preliminary tree assessment; 2.3.3 - Preliminary arboricultural report; 2.3.4 - Development design and review; 2.3.5 - Arboricultural impact assessment. Where there is ongoing design and construction details to be ratified, no specific advice or recommendations for tree protection as indicated in the Australian Standard have been made as yet but general indications and principals have been established with the client. For example, at this stage of the development construction has been designed generally around TPZs of medium, high and very high retention value trees where practical and though a process of consultation with the project arborist, but no specific engineering and tree protection measures nominated (apart from tree T46 which has been treated in separate reports to the client). It is expected tree protection measures will be the subject of future arboricultural impact assessment report(s) as infrastructure engineering is finalised. See Australian Standard AS 4970, Section 2 for further details.

4. Tree Removal justifications other than arboricultural 4.1 Landscape Vision A number of trees require removal due to current and long-term landscape character and management issues outlined in a document entitled ‘Landscape Vision’. These have been nominated under ‘Removal justification’ as ‘Landscape Vision’ and a brief explanation given in under ‘Justification Reference” in the Appendix 1, Tree Inspection Records. Landscape justifications are based on the Landscape Vision for the future development of the property authored by Mr Steve Mathews in consultation with Ecology Australia and Taylor Cullity Lethlean landscape architects and Scape architects. The vision is concerned with the long-term amenity and ecological values of the site as well as its amenity and sustainable living given the development planned. Tree removal justifications given are varied but mainly fall under the categories of:

Arboriculture Mullum Creek Tree Retention/Removal Arboricultural Report 2014 Page 5 of 81 Ecological considerations – trees specimens that are known to be of non-local provenance and present long-term genetic threats to locally indigenous species by interbreeding, trees that have been planted outside their ecological niche and thus have long-term survival issues or are inappropriate for urban lots (Potts, et al. , 2003); Landscape character – to preserve and enhance the natural character of the site afforded by its local indigenous vegetation while acknowledging the exotic cultural elements of the site and encouraging owners/residents to plant home orchard trees and other exotic, non-weedy exotic vegetation; Functional - retain and encourage the planting of trees that are not greatly out of scale with lot size, are well spaced from other trees such that they have the best opportunity to develop optimal form, health and longevity; - retain and plant exotic and indigenous species strategically to minimise fire risk while. 4.2 Built Form Architectural firm, Scape, have reviewed the location and details of trees within the private realm area in relation to the proposed built environment. Taking into account details such as the trees arboricultural retention value and Australian Standard tree protection zone (TPZ) area they have justified removal of certain trees were design and engineering constraints will not allow them to be retained where without significant impacts. Justifications for tree removal based on this analysis has been nominated under ‘Removal justification’ as ‘Built form’ and an explanation code given in under column Justification Reference in the Appendix 2 – Tree Inspection Records. The justification category definitions are in Attachment 2 Schedule to Built Form Analysis. Throughout both of the analysis Built form and Landscape Vision analysis the project arborist was involved in discussions, preliminary plan assessment and site meetings to help minimise impacts and removal of medium, high and very high retention trees. In addition to the above reasons for tree removal construction within road reserves and proposed wetlands also necessitates the removal of trees (discussed below).

5. Tree Details Summary Three-hundred and thirty-seven trees are included in the current inspection survey: approximately 30% of the 1124 surveyed trees existing throughout the greater property (not including numerous indigenous trees along the Mullum Creek not included in survey inspections).

Arboriculture Mullum Creek Tree Retention/Removal Arboricultural Report 2014 Page 6 of 81 See Tables 1 to 5 below for a breakdown of tree removal/retention decisions within different development areas. Of the 515 trees included in this report 228 are within private allotments. All 4 high retention value trees listed for removal within the lots were Australian native (1 x Argyle Apple and 3 x Yellow Box) causing built form issues (access to lots, reasonable building envelope size, etc.) or not appropriate to the Mullum Creek Landscape Vision. The 19 medium retention value trees nominated for removal are mainly mixed planted Eucalypt species but also include an overmature Long-leaved Box and an Oak. The Long-leaved Box (tree T654) has suffered significant structural decline over the past decade or so and, in the opinion of the consultant, is beyond what would be considered reasonable arboricultural maintenance for a residential property owner to have to be responsible for given a short life expectancy for the tree. The 89 low retention value trees listed for removal are mainly mixed Eucalypt species (many non-desirable species such as Blue Gum and Mahogany Gum) and exotics including the Cypress row on Lot 30 nominated for arboricultural reasons such as poor structure and/or health. No very high retention value trees are to be removed due to road reserve construction (see Table 1 below).

Table 1 Tree retention/removal by retention value in private lots Lots Retention Value Remove Retain Total Very High 0 (0%) 13 (100%) 13 High 4 (9%) 39 (91%) 43 Medium 19 (25%) 48 (75%) 67 Low 89 (84%) 16 (16%) 105 Total 112 (49%) 116 (51%) 228

Of the trees within the proposed wetlands development areas all (53) trees are proposed to be removed. Of the trees nominated for removal one (1) is a semi-mature Yellow Box assigned high retention value, 19 are mixed Eucalypts (mainly Yellow Box, River Peppermint, Manna Gum and Red Gum) assigned medium retention value and 33 mixed Eucalypts assigned low retention value (see Table 2 below).

Table 2 Tree retention/removal by retention value in the PCRZ reserve within proposed wetlands sites PCRZ (wetlands areas) Retention Value Remove Retain Total Very High 0 0 0 High 1 0 1 Medium 19 0 19 Low 33 0 33 Total 53 0 53

Arboriculture Mullum Creek Tree Retention/Removal Arboricultural Report 2014 Page 7 of 81

In selecting the wetland areas care was taken to site them where minimum impact would be caused to very high and high retention value trees. Areas immediately surrounding the wetlands developments will require some tree protection actions. The trees surrounding the wetlands are included in the report to highlight trees being retained near the wetlands and the need for protection during wetland development. Of the 68 trees near (but not within) the proposed wetlands development areas ten (10) trees are proposed to be removed due to either impact of the wetland development or for arboricultural reasons. Of the trees nominated for removal none are very high or high retention value, 10 are mixed Eucalypts assigned medium or low retention value (see Table 3 below).

Table 3 Tree retention/removal by retention value in the PCRZ reserve near proposed wetlands sites PCRZ (near wetlands areas) Retention Value Remove Retain Total Very High 0 9 9 High 0 30 30 Medium 3 12 15 Low 7 7 14 Total 10 58 68

Of the 129 trees existing within the proposed road reserve areas, 34 high retention value trees are to be removed due to unavoidable significant impacts to the TPZs (in many case total TPZ removal). These are mainly young to semimature Yellow Box, Swamp Gum, other Eucalypt species and three exotic conifers (two Mexican Cypress and one large, mature Monterey Cypress). No very high retention value trees are to be removed due to road reserve construction (see Table 4 below).

Table 4 Tree retention/removal by retention value in the Road reserves Road Reserve Retention Value Remove Retain Total Very High 0 2 2 High 34 11 45 Medium 33 5 38 Low 44 0 44 Total 111 18 129

Thirty six trees exist in areas allocated as tree reserves. Of the trees indicated for removal seven were nominated for arboricultural reasons such as defects and short life expectancy and three for landscape vision

Arboriculture Mullum Creek Tree Retention/Removal Arboricultural Report 2014 Page 8 of 81 reasons (weedy species). All high and very high retention value trees in the tree reserves are to be retained (see Table 5 below).

Table 5 Tree retention/removal by retention value in the Tree reserves Tree Reserve (Stage 1 & 2) Retention Value Remove Retain Total Very High 0 4 4 High 0 15 15 Medium 3 7 10 Low 7 0 7 Total 10 25 36

Overall most trees are indicated for removal for arboricultural reasons (126 trees) followed by road reserve construction reasons (75 trees). A large portion of the trees nominated for removal for road reserve construction have also been recommended for arboricultural reasons (37 trees). Road construction is the reason for the removal of the greatest number of high retention value trees (34 trees). Issues with trees restricting built form is the reasoning for the removal of 4 high retention value trees. Wetlands construction will necessitate the removal of 1 high retention value trees. See Table 6 below and Figure 1 (following page) for a summary of reasons for tree removal decisions for each tree retention value. Table 7 below summarises the overall number of trees nominated for removal by tree retention category.

Table 6 Reasoning for tree removals for each retention value (see Figure 1 below) Retention Value Very High Medium Low Reason for tree removal High Arborist recommendation 0 1* 5 120 Road reserve construction 0 34 34 7 Wetland construction 0 1 21 34 Built form 0 4 16 3 Landscape vision 0 0 1 16 * One tree, T900, is to be removed due to sewer infrastructure works following discussion with Landplan engineers Table 7 Tree retention/removal by retention value overall (not including PCRZ areas not covered in this report) Trees overall Retention Value Remove Retain Total Very High 0 28 28 High 40 94 134 Medium 77 72 149 Low 180 24 204 Total 297 218 515

Arboriculture Mullum Creek Tree Retention/Removal Arboricultural Report 2014 Page 9 of 81 Arborist Wetland recommendation (0%) construction

Built Form Built Form

Landscape vision Very High Landscape 0% vision Road reserve construction

Arborist Road reserve recommendation construction High 13%

Low 61% Wetland construction Arborist recommendation Medium 26%

Built Form

Landscape Wetland vision construction

Road reserve construction Figure 1 Reasons for tree removal decisions for each retention value category

Arboriculture Mullum Creek Tree Retention/Removal Arboricultural Report 2014 Page 10 of 81

5.1 Noteworthy tree specimens Twenty-two trees were assessed as being very high retention value (13 Yellow Box within allotments and 2 Yellow Box, 2 Candle-bark and 5 Manna Gum within the PCRZ reserve). The Yellow Box trees are considered the ‘signature trees’ of the estate with some most likely in excess of 200 years old. The old Cypress row running across lots 26 and 30 is of landscape significance due to its size and elevated location. The trees are most likely a windbreak or outgrown hedge planted around 100 or so years ago to screen the old farm homestead building (see Appendix 1, Photo 11). The trees are currently overmature and in structural decline. Arboricultural management to retain the trees with reasonable safety would be onerous and expensive and most likely only yield a few more years of landscape life expectancy before they suffered major collapse events in windy weather. The trees have been recommended for removal for this reason. Tree T654 is an overmature specimen of Eucalyptus goniocalyx (Long- leaved Box). The tree would be an indigenous remnant of the local area but has unfortunately suffered accelerated structural decline in the past 5 or so years (see Appendix 1, Photo 1). Retaining the tree with reasonable safety on a residential allotment would require ongoing and onerous inspection and pruning and possibly landscaping to reduce the likelihood of people or property being within its fall zone. The tree has been recommended for removal for arboricultural, Landscape Vision and Built Form reasons.

6. Discussion 6.1 Tree species requiring special consideration given site conditions and environment Tree species existing on the Mathews Property that are considered inappropriate to the intended purpose of the property (identified either in the Landscape Vision or arboricultural assessment or both) include weedy species and those with undesirable traits for retention on residential allotments. A number of tree species were identified throughout the property as having specific problems: in particular: Eucalyptus camaldulensis (River Red Gum); E. globulus (Blue Gum); E. elata (River Peppermint); E. botryoides (Mahogany Gum, also including the closely retaliated E. robusta (Swamp Mahogany) and E. saligna (Sydney Blue Gum)); E. cladocalyx; E. ovata (Swamp Gum), and; Pinus radiata (Radiata Pine).

Arboriculture Mullum Creek Tree Retention/Removal Arboricultural Report 2014 Page 11 of 81 E. camaldulensis (Red Gum), although an attractive long lived landscape tree, has several traits considered undesirable in urban situations. In particular the tendency of mature specimens to shed large limbs without warning and their susceptibility to insect infestation. Their particularly large mature size makes them problematic when in close proximity to development. Research3 has also linked a fungus growing naturally on Red Gums with a meningitis-like disease in humans although it is not known at this stage whether this is prevalent enough to be of concern. Of the specimens inspected none were considered to be indigenous specimens and the species does not occur naturally in the area. E. elata (River Peppermint) originates from lowland coastal regions of southeastern Australia where temperatures are generally cooler and rainfall higher than that in the Mullum Creek estate. Early tree surveys of the property found many of the specimens existing on the property apparently growing vigorously. Since then several specimens have died, are dying or failed due to defects and what is most likely drought damage. The species is not suitable for the local climate or conditions. E. globulus (Blue Gum) and E. botryoides (Mahogany Gum) are very fast growing large species that are prone to insect borer infestation and wood-rot decay. A number of affected Blue Gums have failed since the initial tree inspection in 1999 (see Appendix 1, Photos 3, 7 and 8). Examples of Blue Gums and other specimens (E. botryoides, E. viminalis and E. ovata) likely to fail due to wood rot caused by fungi (mainly Phellinus sp.) occur throughout the property and are reviewed a greater length previous reports, see Appendix 1, Photos 4 for a typical example). Blue Gum species has great weed potential in the area and could, due to its quick growth rate, out-compete indigenous trees. Self-sown seedlings were noted during the inspection survey (see Appendix 1, Photos 5). Most Blue Gum specimens were assessed as having low retention value and should eventually be replaced by more appropriate species. E. ovata (Swamp Gum) is indigenous to the area and important in providing hollows and nesting opportunities for indigenous vertebrates and non-vertebrates. The species grows fairly quickly but is highly prone to decay fungi and defects that lead to tree failure. The species is best suited to the PCRZ reserve areas an not residential allotments (see Appendix 1, Photos 9 for example). E. cladocalyx (Sugar Gum) is considered a threat to riparian (and other) vegetation in Victoria (Carr et al., 1992). Approximately 22 mainly mature and semimature trees exist on the property (not all included in the current report), most being found in the PCRZ path area to the north of lot 1 where they appear to be self-sowing freely. The species is listed in Manningham City Council’s Weeds document (2006, Manningham City Council) as causing problems in the region. Pinus radiata (Radiata Pine) has many traits making it unsuitable for urban parks and gardens. Some of these include, drying and acidifying of soil,

3 Reported in the Sunday Herald 28/7/96 p.28

Arboriculture Mullum Creek Tree Retention/Removal Arboricultural Report 2014 Page 12 of 81 constant needle shedding, weedy nature in bushland situations and dense shade. Most of the large radiata pines have been removed in the past year with a few well formed, large specimens preserved for their landscape contribution and historic context. Acacia species found on the Mathews property and indigenous to the area (A. dealbata, A. mearnsii, A. melanoxylon, A. pycnantha) were generally assigned a maximum of medium retention value. This is due to the species’ relatively short life cycle, tendency to naturally regenerate prolifically if conditions are suitable and its sensitivity to construction damage. It is recommended that Acacias are managed in such a way as to encourage their growth in appropriate areas such as the PCRZ and tree reserves and remove unwanted, senescent or poor specimens as needed, making sure that enough mature specimens of each species exist to disperse seed. Bursaria spinosa (Sweet Bursaria) is another indigenous tree/shrub species that self propagates readily on the Mathews property. In general, Bursaria trees were given medium or high retention values depending on their condition. Where trees are found to be in conflict with proposed construction, they could be removed, or if specimens are small, transplanted. As with Acacias, Bursaria regeneration should be encouraged to grow in appropriate areas by making sure enough seed trees are always present. It has been noted during past tree surveys of the site that Sweet Bursaria freely self-sows in areas where slashing of grass cannot be done or has ceased. Sweet Bursaria is capable of longer life than the Acacia species found on the Mathews property and as such, should be managed for the longer term. Most of the Eucalypt species assessed as not being suitable for the location and environment, especially given its development into residential allotments, are Australian native species that were planted and grown as farm forestry trials by Mr Steve Mathews. 6.2 Tree Defects Bifurcation defects and stem decay caused by wood decay fungi were the most common defects recorded during the inspection survey (see Appendix 1, Photos 2 – 4 and 6 – 9). The defects were seen in indigenous and non-indigenous planted specimens although decay defects were most prominent in Blue Gum and Mahogany Gum. Decay defects can be seen as open wounds or stem swellings indicating reactive growth to internal hollowing. Where fungal fruiting bodies (‘punks’ or ‘conks’) are seen on stems then decay will be present in the stem. Poor stem to height ratio is a tree form defect that many planted trees have developed as a result of being planted and grown in close proximity to each other. Planting trees in close proximity is common in silviculture and farm forestry practices to minimise side branching of the trees. The lots are thinned at an early age to then allow the remaining trees to form better stem taper. Thinning had not occurred in this case and the trees have become prone to failure once exposed. Several semimature Eucalypt specimens suffering poor stem to height ratios failed in the vicinity of lot 8 recently due to exposure following removal of large radiata

Arboriculture Mullum Creek Tree Retention/Removal Arboricultural Report 2014 Page 13 of 81 pine trees along Old Warrandyte Road property boundary late last year (see Appendix 1, Photo 10 for example). Structural decline is a natural process suffered by trees in their overmature or senescent stages of life. Cypress trees T144 to T154 (see Appendix 1, Photo 11) are examples of 27 trees assessed as being overmature in the current inspection survey. While it may be possible to prolong the lives of many large overmature trees, it can be prohibitively expensive and management intensive, often with only a few years added to the landscape life expectancy of the tree.

7. Recommendations It is recommended that permits be sought from Manningham City Council for the removal the trees indicated for removal in the Retention Decision column of Appendix 2 of this report including 12 trees indicated as ‘Retain’ but having low retention value (to be removed at the discretion of the developer as or if the need arises). Where trees are to be retained, it is recommended that: Actions recommended for individual trees in Appendix 2, Tree Inspection Records, should be carried out as per priority schedules recommended (suggested maximum time periods for each priority are given in Appendix 3, Definitions and Methods); Contract arborists should be briefed to report any significant defects (defects likely to lead to failures) found during works and to take immediate appropriate actions if deemed necessary; All pruning should be done to Australian Standards (AS 4373, Pruning of Amenity Trees) as far as possible. Lopping of trees must not be allowed; Tree pruning work should be carried out by suitably qualified and experienced arborists (Arboriculture Certificate Level III minimum and 3 years practice) with sufficient public liability insurance; The trees should be inspected by a suitably qualified arborist (Arboriculture Certificate Level IV minimum and 5 years practice and holding sufficient professional indemnity insurance) again 1 year from the inspection date of this report (i.e. trees should be inspected again around June, 2015); Tree protection strategies and low impact construction techniques should be sought where construction is likely to impact TPZs (as detailed for each tree in Appendix 2) of trees being retained.

Should any matters in this report require clarification please contact me,

Stephen Fitzgerald BAppSc (Melb.) AdvCertHort, AdvCertArb. (Burnley)

Arboriculture Mullum Creek Tree Retention/Removal Arboricultural Report 2014 Page 14 of 81

References

G.W. Carr, J.V. Yugovic and K.E. Robinson (1992) Environmental Weed Invasions in Victoria: Conservation and Management Implications. Department of Conservation and Environment, Ecological Horticulture Pty Ltd, Melbourne.

Manningham City Council (2006) Weeds (pdf document) accessed on 20/6/2014 at http://www.manningham.vic.gov.au/maccwr/_assets/main/lib90021/02%20- %20pdf%20files/weed%20id%20booklet.pdf

Potts, B.M; Barbour, R.C; Hingston, A.B.; and Vaillancourt, R.E. (2003) Genetic pollution of native eucalypt gene pools—identifying the risks: Turner Review no. 6 Australian Journal of Botany 51(3) p333

Arboriculture Mullum Creek Tree Retention/Removal - Private Realms & Wetlands Page 15 of 81

Appendix 1 – Photographs

Photo 1 Tree T654 from south-east. This Photo 2 Tree T283B (Yellow Box) viewed from significant remnant Long-leaved Box specimen south-east. The virulent wood decay Phellinus has suffered structural decline in recent years sp. (pictured) is common on other species on the property but rare in Yellow Box

Photo 3 Tree T341 (Blue Gum) having Photo 4 Tree T280 (Blue Gum) with severe suffered stem failure due to severe wood decay wood decay Phellinus sp. infection Phellinus sp. infection

Arboriculture Mullum Creek Tree Retention/Removal - Private Realms & Wetlands Page 16 of 81

Photo 5 Seedlings of Blue Gum are numerous Photo 6 Tree T347 (Spotted Gum) with throughout the property and grow quickly. bifurcation defect increasing its likelihood of failure

Photo 8 Tree T378 (Mahogany Gum) having Photo 7 Tree T354 (Swamp Mahogany) collapsed due to defects typical of the species in showing typical defects of many of the planted the local environment since the previous survey. trees in the PCRZ areas (fungal fruiting bodies The tree had not reached maturity. & bifurcation defects)

Arboriculture Mullum Creek Tree Retention/Removal - Private Realms & Wetlands Page 17 of 81

Photo 9 Failing branches and stems typical of Photo 10 Tree T312 (left, Red Gum) and other the structural decline found in the indigenous planted trees that have developed in close Swamp Gums (Tree T164 show) proximity have poor stem to height ratios as a result are more prone to failure once exposed

Photo 11 Cypress trees T144 to T154 are overmature and will continue to shed stems as they decline structurally.

Arboriculture Mullum Creek Tree Retention/Removal - Private Realms & Wetlands Page 18 of 81 Appendix 2 ‐ Tree Inspection Records ‐ Mullum Creek Estate Private Lots, Road Reserve, Tree Reserve & Wetland Areas (ordered by Lot/Area)

Colour highlighting has been used to higlight Urgent and High priority actions in Actions / Priority column Trees with "Tree removal" reccommendation have been shaded

ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL Lot 1 T306 Eucalyptus camaldulensis Lot 1 24cm SM 9m Fair Major Low 2.9m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Arborist Damaged by falling pine River Red Gum Poor Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure & (Vic Native) poor form

T307 Eucalyptus elata Lot 1 15cm SM 6m Fair Minor Medium 2m No works required Medium ‐ V3 Species drought Remove Built form, River Peppermint Fair intolerant (other Landscape vision (Vic Native) speciemens of this species have died over the past few years most likely due to dry); ecologically inappropriate position; leading stem has died T309 Eucalyptus globulus subsp. Lot 1 40cm M 22m Fair Major Low 4.8m High Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Failure likely bicostata Poor Tree Removal recommendation Eurabbie (Vic Native)

T310 Eucalyptus globulus subsp. Lot 1 55cm M 24m Fair Major, Low 6.6m High Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Failure likely bicostata Hazard Bifurcation of Tree Removal recommendation Eurabbie stem (Vic Native)

T311 Eucalyptus camaldulensis Lot 1 22cm SM 11m Fair Minor or none Medium 2.6m No works required Medium ‐ V4 / Non‐prefered Remove Built form, River Red Gum Fair noticed Low ‐ B4 species, Landscape vision (Vic Native) inconsistent with Landscape vision

T312 Eucalyptus camaldulensis Lot 1 41cm M 25m Fair Minor Medium 4.9m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ V4 / Non‐prefered Remove Built form, Wound in stem. Poor stem to height ratio ‐ River Red Gum Fair Deadwood Prune Low ‐ B4 species, Landscape vision consider removal if surrounding trees ( (Vic Native) inconsistent with treeT310 in particular ) are to be removed Landscape vision leaving It exposed

T322 Eucalyptus cosmophylla Lot 1 14cm M <5m Poor Minor Low 2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Very poor form & Cup Gum Poor Tree Removal recommendation structu (Aus Native)

* DBH ‐ Multiple stemmed trees measured and recorded as a equivalent single stem as per AS4970. Individual stem measurements for multi‐stemmed trees recorded in Comments ** AGE CLASS Key: OM = Overmature, M = Mature, SM = Semimature, Y = Young *** TPZ (tree protection zone) calculated as a radius from tree stem centre as per AS4970 See Attachment 1 ‐ Landscape Vision (Scape Architects) See Attachment 2 ‐ Schedule to Built Form Analysis (Scape Architects) or final page of this Appendix

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records Lot 1 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 19 of 81 Lot 1 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T323 Corymbia maculata Lot 1 44cm M 25m Fair Minor, Medium 5.3m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1 / Retain bifurcated trunk Spotted Gum Poor Bifurcation of Cable‐brace if retained Medium ‐ B3 (Vic Native) stem

T326 Eucalyptus elata Lot 1 48cm SM 21m Poor Major Low 5.8m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Arborist Decay fungal fruiting bodies on trunk River Peppermint Poor Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure (Vic Native)

T327 Eucalyptus camaldulensis Lot 1 49cm M 24m Fair Minor, Medium 5.9m No works required High ‐ O1, Retain River Red Gum Poor Bifurcation of B1(High (Vic Native) stem Amentiy ‐ good to block road)

T328 Eucalyptus camaldulensis Lot 1 24cm SM 11m Fair Minor Medium 2.9m No works required High ‐ O1, B1 Retain Bifurcation of stem (moderate) River Red Gum Poor (Vic Native)

T337 Eucalyptus camaldulensis Lot 1 33cm SM 19m Fair Minor or none Medium 4m No works required High ‐ O1, B1 Non‐prefered Retain Built form, River Red Gum Fair noticed species, Landscape vision (Vic Native) inconsistent with Landscape vision

T339 Corymbia maculata Lot 1 35cm M 22m Good Major, Low 4.2m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure Spotted Gum Poor Bifurcation of Tree Removal recommendation (Vic Native) stem

T340 Eucalyptus camaldulensis Lot 1 20cm SM 14m Fair Minor or none Medium 2.4m No works required High ‐ O1, B1 Non‐prefered Remove Built form, River Red Gum Fair noticed species, Landscape vision (Vic Native) inconsistent with Landscape vision

T341 Eucalyptus globulus subsp. Lot 1 51cm OM 12m Poor Major, Tree has Low 6.1m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Tree has failed due to fungal decay bicostata Poor completely Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure & Eurabbie collapsed poor form (Vic Native)

T342 Eucalyptus camaldulensis Lot 1 29cm SM 15m Fair Minor Medium 3.5m No works required Medium ‐ O1, Retain River Red Gum Fair B3 (Vic Native)

T345 Eucalyptus robusta Lot 1 36cm M 13m Poor Minor or none Low 4.3m No works required Non‐prefered Remove Landscape vision Swamp Mahogany Poor noticed species, (Aus Native) inconsistent with Landscape vision

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records Lot 1 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 20 of 81 Lot 1 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T346 Eucalyptus robusta Lot 1 43cm M 14m Fair Minor, Low 5.2m Low Priority Actions: Non‐prefered Retain Landscape vision Swamp Mahogany Fair Bifurcation of Structural Prune (minor) species, (Aus Native) stem inconsistent with Landscape vision

T347 Corymbia maculata Lot 1 42cm M 21m Good Bifurcation of Low 5m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure Spotted Gum Poor stem Tree Removal recommendation (Vic Native)

T348 Eucalyptus camaldulensis Lot 1 45cm SM 21m Fair Minor Medium 5.4m No works required High ‐ O1, B1 Non‐prefered Retain Built form, River Red Gum Fair species, Landscape vision (Vic Native) inconsistent with Landscape vision

351 Eucalyptus cosmophylla Lot 1 12cm SM <5m Poor Major Low 2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure & Cup Gum Poor Tree Removal recommendation poor form (Aus Native)

354 Eucalyptus botryoides Lot 1 13cm Y 11m Good Minor or none Low 2m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Next to dead tree, Weedy species Southern Mahogany Good noticed Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Weedy species (Vic Native)

T354 Eucalyptus robusta Lot 1 42cm M 14m Poor Major Low 5m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Bifurcation of stem (moderate), Decay fungal Swamp Mahogany Poor Tree Removal recommendation fruiting bodies on trunk (Aus Native) Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure & poor form (Multi_DBH (cm): 30,30)

T355 Eucalyptus botryoides Lot 1 14cm Y 10m Fair Minor or none Low 2m No works required Non‐prefered Remove Landscape vision Weedy species Southern Mahogany Fair noticed species, (Vic Native) inconsistent with Landscape vision

T356 Eucalyptus robusta Lot 1 27cm M 12m Fair Minor or none Medium 3.2m No works required High ‐ O1 / Retain Swamp Mahogany Fair noticed Medium ‐ B1 (Aus Native)

T362 Eucalyptus leucoxylon Lot 1 15cm M 6m Poor Minor or none Low 2m No works required Non‐prefered Retain Landscape vision subsp. megalocarpa Fair noticed species, Large‐fruited South inconsistent with Australian Blue Gum Landscape vision (Vic Native)

T916 Bursaria spinosa Lot 1 19cm M 5m Poor Minor Medium 2.3m No works required High ‐ O1, B1 Retain Sweet Bursaria Fair & B2 (Multi_DBH (cm): 12,10,10) (Vic Native)

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records Lot 1 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 21 of 81 Lot 1 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T918 Corymbia maculata Lot 1 14cm Y 10m Good None noticed Medium 2m No works required Low ‐ B4 Out of scale as very Retain Landscape vision Spotted Gum Good tall species in local (Vic Native) conditions, inconsistient with MC landscape and ESD vision 1613 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 1 10cm Y 7m Fair Minor or none High 2m No works required High ‐ O1 / Retain Yellow Box Fair noticed Medium ‐ B1 (Vic Native)

Lot 2 T304 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 2 22cm SM 15m Good Minor High 2.6m Low Priority Actions: Medium ‐ V4 / Retain Yellow Box Fair Deadwood Prune Low ‐ B4 (Vic Native)

T305 Eucalyptus botryoides Lot 2 36cm SM 13m Poor Major Low 4.3m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Weedy species Southern Mahogany Poor Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure & (Vic Native) poor form

T330 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 2 27cm SM 17m Fair Minor or none High 3.2m No works required Low ‐ O1 & B3 / Retain Yellow Box Fair noticed (Vic Native)

T331 Eucalyptus cladocalyx Lot 2 40cm M 13m Poor Major Medium 4.8m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Decay fungal fruiting bodies on trunk (in stem Sugar Gum Poor Tree Removal recommendation union) (Weedy (Aus. Native)) Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure & poor form

T332 Corymbia maculata Lot 2 39cm M 20m Good None noticed High 4.7m No works required Low ‐ O1 & B3 / Out of scale as very Retain Landscape vision Spotted Gum Fair tall species in local (Vic Native) conditions; inconsistent with MC landscape and ESD vision; Competing with local indigenous Yellow box trees being retained T330, T304 and 5039 T335 Eucalyptus cladocalyx Lot 2 24cm M 6m Poor Major, Tree has Low 2.88m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Tree has collapsed (2012) Sugar Gum Poor completely Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure & (Weedy (Aus. Native)) collapsed poor form

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records Lot 2 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 22 of 81 Lot 2 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T336 Eucalyptus cladocalyx Lot 2 35cm SM 13m Fair Minor Low 4.2m Low Priority Actions: Species inconsistent Remove Landscape vision Weedy species near ESO area Sugar Gum Fair Deadwood with Landscape (Weedy (Aus. Native)) vision (weedy)

T349 Corymbia maculata Lot 2 28cm SM 17m Good Minor or none High 3.4m No works required Low ‐ O1 & B3 / Non‐prefered Retain Landscape vision Spotted Gum Good noticed species, (Vic Native) inconsistent with Landscape vision

T350 Corymbia maculata Lot 2 42cm M 25m Good None noticed High 5m No works required Low ‐ O1 & B3 / Non‐prefered Retain Landscape vision Spotted Gum Good species, (Vic Native) inconsistent with Landscape vision

T351 Eucalyptus botryoides Lot 2 41cm M 20m Poor Major Low 4.9m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Decay fungal fruiting bodies on trunk Southern Mahogany Poor Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure & (Vic Native) poor form

T352 Eucalyptus camaldulensis Lot 2 20cm Y 15m Fair Minor Medium 2.4m No works required Low ‐ O1 & B3 / Non‐prefered Retain Landscape vision River Red Gum Fair species, (Vic Native) inconsistent with Landscape vision

T353 Eucalyptus elata Lot 2 59cm M 22m Poor Minor Low 7.1m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Arborist Declining health River Peppermint Fair Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Short life expectancy (Vic Native)

5039 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 2 11cm Y <5m Good Minor Medium 2m Low Priority Actions: Low ‐ O1 & B3 / Retain Yellow Box Poor Structural Prune (minor) (Multi_DBH (cm): 5,5,8) (Vic Native)

Lot 3 T303 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 3 27cm Y 16m Fair Minor High 3.2m Low Priority Actions: Retain Yellow Box Fair Formative prune crossing limbs (Vic Native)

679 Pyrus communis cv. Lot 3 20cm M 6m Good Major Medium 2.4m No works required Retain Pear (cultivar unknown) Poor (Exotic)

Lot 4

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records Lot 4 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 23 of 81 Lot 4 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

1600 Pyrus communis Lot 4 33cm OM 6m Fair Major Medium 4m No works required Retain Common Pear Poor (Multi_DBH (cm): 15,15,15,20) (Exotic)

Lot 5 T264 Corymbia maculata Lot 5 39cm SM 21m Good Minor Medium 4.7m Low Priority Actions: Low ‐ B3 Inconsistent with Retain Landscape vision Spotted Gum Poor Cable‐brace if retained MC landscape and (Vic Native) ESD vision; strong bifurcation; suppressing and outcompeting nearby higher value indigenous Yellow Box T268, 265, T266. T265 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 5 26cm SM 15m Fair Minor or none High 3.1m No works required Retain Yellow Box Fair noticed (Vic Native)

T266 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 5 25cm SM 16m Fair Minor High 3m No works required Retain Yellow Box Fair (Vic Native)

T267 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 5 25cm SM 15m Fair Minor High 3m No works required Retain Yellow Box Fair (Vic Native)

T268 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 5 28cm SM 21m Fair Minor High 3.4m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O2 / Retain Yellow Box Fair Weight reduce (tree 286) Medium ‐ B1 & (Vic Native) B2

T269 Eucalyptus mannifera Lot 5 40cm M 14m Fair None noticed Medium 4.8m No works required High ‐ O2 / Retain Red Spotted Gum Fair Medium ‐ B1 & (Vic Native) B2

T270 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 5 17cm SM 8m Poor Minor Medium 2m No works required High ‐ O2 / Non‐indigenous Retain Built form, Suppressed or younger specimen Yellow Box Poor Medium ‐ B1 & genetic source (risk Landscape vision (Vic Native) B2 of genetic pollution)

T273 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 5 39cm M 19m Good Minor High 4.7m No works required Low ‐ B4 Retain Yellow Box Good (Vic Native)

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records Lot 5 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 24 of 81 Lot 5 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

273 Pyrus communis cv. Lot 5 10cm SM <5m Poor Minor Low 2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Short life expectancy Pear (cultivar unknown) Poor Tree Removal recommendation (Exotic)

274 Eucalyptus sp. Lot 5 10cm SM <5m Poor Major Low 2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure & Eucalypt Poor Tree Removal recommendation poor form (Vic Native)

T281 Eucalyptus scoparia Lot 5 14cm SM <5m Poor Minor Low 2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Short life expectancy Wallangarra White Gum Poor Tree Removal recommendation (Aus Native)

T926 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 5 12cm SM 6m Fair Minor or none Low 2m No works required Low ‐ B3 Retain Very poor form and unlikely to make a suitable Yellow Box Fair noticed tree (Vic Native)

5035 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 5 11cm Y 8m Fair Minor or none Medium 2m No works required High ‐ O2 / Retain Yellow Box Fair noticed Medium ‐ B1 & (Vic Native) B2

5036 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 5 21cm SM 10m Fair Minor or none High 2.5m No works required Low ‐ B3 Retain Yellow Box Good noticed (Vic Native)

5037 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 5 19cm SM 12m Fair Minor or none High 2.3m No works required Low ‐ B4 Retain Yellow Box Fair noticed (Vic Native)

Lot 6 T218 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 6 41cm M 17m Fair Minor High 4.9m No works required Retain Yellow Box Fair (Vic Native)

T248 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 6 18cm SM 12m Fair Minor or none High 2.2m No works required Low ‐ B4 Retain impact wound on trunk Yellow Box Fair noticed (Vic Native)

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records Lot 6 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 25 of 81 Lot 6 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T249 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 6 70cm M 20m Good Minor Very High 8.4m Medium Priority Actions: Retain Yellow Box Fair Root butress inspection if (Vic Native) retained

T250 Allocasuarina verticillata Lot 6 22cm SM 15m Fair Minor or none Medium 2.6m No works required High ‐ O1 / Competing with Remove Built form, River Oak Good noticed Low ‐ B1, B2 significant mature Landscape vision (Aus Native) Yellow box trees being retained to the south and northeast (T252, T249, T245), and will increasingly impact on these trees T252 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 6 86cm M 25m Fair Minor Very High 10.3m Medium Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, V2, Retain Possible internal crack in trunk Yellow Box Fair Weight reduce, Aerial inspection, V3, Medium ‐ (Vic Native) Deadwood B1, B2,

T253 Eucalyptus ovata Lot 6 29cm SM 9m Fair Major Low 3.5m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Decay fungal fruiting bodies on trunk Swamp Gum Poor Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure (Vic Native)

T254 Eucalyptus botryoides Lot 6 58cm M 16m Fair Minor Low 7m Low Priority Actions: Non‐prefered Remove Landscape vision Weedy species Southern Mahogany Fair Deadwood Prune species, (Vic Native) inconsistent with Landscape vision

T256 Corymbia maculata Lot 6 29cm SM 16m Fair None noticed Medium 3.5m No works required High ‐ O1 / Retain Spotted Gum Good Medium ‐ B1, (Vic Native) B2

T257 Angophora costata Lot 6 50cm M 18m Fair Minor High 6m No works required High ‐ O1, B2 Unbalanced form ‐ Remove Built form, bifurcated trunk Smooth‐barked Apple Fair strong growth to Landscape vision (Aus Native) north due to suppression by trees to south

T258 Corymbia citriodora Lot 6 27cm SM 14m Fair Minor Low 3.2m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Poor form due to oveshading & suppression by Lemon‐scented Gum Poor Tree Removal recommendation other trees (Aus Native) Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure & poor form

259A Bursaria spinosa Lot 6 2cm M <5m Poor Minor Medium 2m No works required High ‐ V4 / Retain Sweet Bursaria Fair Low B4 (Vic Native)

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records Lot 6 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 26 of 81 Lot 6 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T260 Eucalyptus nicholii Lot 6 56cm M 13m Poor Minor Low 6.7m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1 / Retain Arborist Reason for tree removal: Short life expectancy Narrow‐leaved Peppermint Fair Tree Removal Medium ‐ B1 & recommendation (Aus Native) B2

5034 Corymbia maculata Lot 6 16cm SM 12m Good Major Low 2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure Spotted Gum Poor Tree Removal recommendation (Multi_DBH (cm): 11,11) (Vic Native)

Lot 7 122 Allocasuarina verticillata Lot 7 17cm SM 8m Fair Minor or none Low 2m No works required Low ‐ B4 Retain Wounds on trunk River Oak Poor noticed (Aus Native)

163 Eucalyptus camaldulensis Lot 7 9cm Y 11m Good Minor Medium 2m No works required High ‐ O1 / Non‐prefered Retain Built form, River Red Gum Fair Medium ‐ B2 species, Landscape vision (Vic Native) inconsistent with Landscape vision

170 Eucalyptus ovata Lot 7 8cm Y <5m Fair Minor Low 2m No works required Non‐prefered Remove Landscape vision Stump suckers Swamp Gum Poor species, (Multi_DBH (cm): 6,5,3) (Vic Native) inconsistent with Landscape vision

T229 Melaleuca linariifolia Lot 7 29cm M 6m Fair Major Low 3.5m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Decline of landscape Snow‐in‐Summer Poor Tree Removal recommendation val (Aus Native) (Multi_DBH (cm): 25,15)

T241 Melaleuca linariifolia Lot 7 19cm SM <5m Poor Minor Low 2.3m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Decline of landscape Snow‐in‐Summer Fair Tree Removal recommendation val (Aus Native)

T242 Eucalyptus globulus subsp. Lot 7 16cm SM 6m Fair Minor Low 2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Poorly formed specimen bicostata Poor Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure & Eurabbie poor form (Vic Native)

T243 Eucalyptus cladocalyx Lot 7 30cm M 12m Poor Minor Low 3.6m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Inappropriate species Sugar Gum Fair Tree Removal recommendation (Weedy (Aus. Native))

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records Lot 7 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 27 of 81 Lot 7 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T245 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 7 54cm M 25m Fair Minor Very High 6.5m Medium Priority Actions: Retain bifurcated trunk Yellow Box Fair Aerial canopy inspection if (Vic Native) retained, Deadwood Prune

T246 Eucalyptus cladocalyx Lot 7 23cm M 15m Poor Major Low 2.76m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Decline of landscape Sugar Gum Poor Tree Removal recommendation value (Weedy (Aus. Native))

T247 Eucalyptus camaldulensis Lot 7 40cm M 22m Fair Minor or none Medium 4.8m No works required High ‐ O1, B1, Non‐prefered Retain Built form, River Red Gum Fair noticed B2 species, Landscape vision (Vic Native) inconsistent with Landscape vision, Competing with prefered retained indigenous Yellow box trees (T252, T249, T245). 252 Corymbia maculata Lot 7 14cm SM 10m Fair Minor or none Medium 2m No works required Low ‐ B4 / Retain Spotted Gum Fair noticed High ‐ V4 (Vic Native)

T436 Eucalyptus botryoides Lot 7 17cm SM 12m Fair Minor Low 2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Weedy species Southern Mahogany Fair Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure & (Vic Native) poor form

T438 Eucalyptus spathulata Lot 7 19cm M 10m Fair Minor or none Medium 2.3m No works required High ‐ O1 / Retain Swamp Mallet Fair noticed Medium ‐ B1, (Aus Native) B2

T439 Eucalyptus botryoides Lot 7 38cm SM 17m Fair None noticed Medium 4.6m No works required High ‐ O1 / Non‐prefered Remove Built form, Weedy species Southern Mahogany Fair Medium ‐ B1 species, Landscape vision (Vic Native) inconsistent with Landscape vision

T440 Eucalyptus cladocalyx Lot 7 26cm SM 16m Fair Major Low 3.12m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Poor height to stem ratio Sugar Gum Poor Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure (Weed (Aus. Native))

T911 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 7 14cm SM 6m Fair Minor or none High 2m No works required Low ‐ B4 Retain Yellow Box Fair noticed (Vic Native)

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records Lot 7 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 28 of 81 Lot 7 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T912 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 7 9cm Y <5m Poor Minor Low 2m Low Priority Actions: Retain Arborist Reason for tree removal: Short life expectancy Yellow Box Poor Tree Removal recommendation (Vic Native)

1594 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 7 13cm Y 8m Fair Minor Low 2m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, B1, Non‐indigenous Remove Built form, Root defects Yellow Box Poor Tree Removal V2, V3 genetic source (risk Landscape vision Reasons for tree removal: Future failure likely (Vic Native) of genetic pollution)

Lot 8 115 Melaleuca ericifolia Lot 8 6cm M 6m Poor Minor Low 2m Low Priority Actions: Retain Arborist Also weedy Prunus Swamp Paperbark Fair Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure & (Vic Native) poor form

230 Acacia melanoxylon Lot 8 10cm SM <5m Fair Major, Tree has Low 2m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure & Blackwood Fair completely Tree Removal & B2 / recommendation poor form (Vic Native) collapsed Medium ‐ V2 & V3

T442 Eucalyptus botryoides Lot 8 40cm SM 16m Fair Minor Medium 4.8m No works required High ‐ O1, B1 Non‐prefered Remove Built form, Weedy species Southern Mahogany Good species, Landscape vision (Vic Native) inconsistent with Landscape vision

T443 Eucalyptus botryoides Lot 8 46cm M <5m Dead Tree has Low 3m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Weedy species Southern Mahogany Poor completely Remove failed stem and stump recommendation (Vic Native) collapsed

T444 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 8 22cm SM 11m Fair Minor Medium 2.6m No works required High ‐ O1, B1 Non‐indigenous Remove Built form, Suspected poor root system Yellow Box Poor genetic source (risk Landscape vision (Vic Native) of genetic pollution)

T445 Eucalyptus globulus subsp. Lot 8 85cm M 21m Fair Major Low 10.2m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Bifurcation of stem (moderate), Decay fungal bicostata Poor Tree Removal recommendation fruiting bodies on trunk (east) Eurabbie Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure (Vic Native)

T446 Eucalyptus cladocalyx Lot 8 12cm SM <6mm Fair Major Low 2m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Poor height to stem ratio Sugar Gum Poor Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Failure likely (Weedy (Aus. Native))

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records Lot 8 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 29 of 81 Lot 8 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T447 Eucalyptus spathulata Lot 8 16cm SM <5m Fair Major, Tree has Low 2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure & Swamp Mallet Fair partially collapsed Tree Removal recommendation poor form (Aus Native)

T449 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 8 21cm SM 14m Fair Minor Medium 2.5m No works required High ‐ O1, B1 Non‐indigenous Remove Built form, Suspected root problems, poor stern taper Yellow Box Poor genetic source (risk Landscape vision (Vic Native) of genetic pollution)

T450 Eucalyptus obliqua Lot 8 43cm SM 17m Good Major Low 5.2m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist bifurcated trunk has failed recently Messmate stringybark Poor Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure (Vic Native)

T451 Eucalyptus globulus subsp. Lot 8 60cm M 17m Fair Major Low 7.2m No works required High ‐ O1, V4 Non‐prefered Remove Built form, Swelling in stem indicates internal decay and bicostata Fair species, Landscape vision probable failure point given history of this Eurabbie inconsistent with species on the site (Vic Native) Landscape vision

T452 Eucalyptus botryoides Lot 8 52cm M 16m Fair Minor Low 6.2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Weedy species Southern Mahogany Poor Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Weedy species (Vic Native)

T463 Eucalyptus globulus subsp. Lot 8 82cm M 23m Fair Major Low 9.8m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Decay fungi in stem bicostata Poor Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure Eurabbie (Vic Native)

T464 Eucalyptus globulus subsp. Lot 8 51cm SM 24m Poor Major Low 6.1m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Decay fungal fruiting bodies on trunk & hollow, bicostata Poor Tree Removal recommendation poor stem taper Eurabbie Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure (Vic Native)

T465 Eucalyptus acaciiformis Lot 8 25cm SM 11m Poor Minor Medium 3m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, B1 / Retain Health has Improved since last inspection Wattle leaved peppermint Fair Deadwood Prune Low ‐ V1 (Aus Native)

T466 Eucalyptus camaldulensis Lot 8 30cm SM 14m Fair Major Low 3.6m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Arborist Heavy lean to south west, poor stem taper River Red Gum Poor Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure (Vic Native)

Lot 9

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records Lot 9 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 30 of 81 Lot 9 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T457 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 9 26cm SM 15m Fair Minor High 3.1m No works required High ‐ V2, V3 Non‐indigenous Remove Built form, Yellow Box Good genetic source (risk Landscape vision (Vic Native) of genetic pollution)

T461 Eucalyptus globulus subsp. Lot 9 68cm M 18m Poor Minor Low 8.2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Declining health bicostata Good Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Short life expectancy Eurabbie (Vic Native)

T462 Eucalyptus botryoides Lot 9 26cm SM 12m Fair Minor Low 3.1m No works required Non‐prefered Remove Landscape vision Weedy species Southern Mahogany Fair species, (Vic Native) inconsistent with Landscape vision

T468 Eucalyptus viminalis Lot 9 47cm SM 16m Fair Minor Medium 5.6m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O3 / Retain Built form Manna Gum Good Deadwood Prune Low ‐ B3 (Vic Native)

1595 Eucalyptus cladocalyx Lot 9 13cm Y 13m Good Major Low 2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Poor stem to height ratio ‐ prone to failure Sugar Gum Poor Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure (Weedy (Aus. Native))

5018 Bursaria spinosa Lot 9 8cm M <5m Fair Minor High 2m No works required Low ‐ B3 Retain Sweet Bursaria Poor (Vic Native)

5019 Bursaria spinosa Lot 9 8cm M <5m Fair Minor High 2m No works required Medium ‐ B3 Retain Sweet Bursaria Poor (Vic Native)

5020 Bursaria spinosa Lot 9 8cm M <5m Fair Minor High 2m No works required Medium ‐ B3 Retain Sweet Bursaria Poor (Vic Native)

5021 Bursaria spinosa Lot 9 8cm M <5m Fair Minor High 2m No works required Medium ‐ B3 Retain Sweet Bursaria Poor (Vic Native)

5022 Bursaria spinosa Lot 9 8cm M <5m Fair Minor High 2m No works required Medium ‐ B3 Retain Sweet Bursaria Poor (Vic Native)

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records Lot 9 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 31 of 81 Lot 9 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

5023 Bursaria spinosa Lot 9 8cm M <5m Fair Minor High 2m No works required Low ‐ B3 Retain Sweet Bursaria Poor (Vic Native)

5024 Bursaria spinosa Lot 9 8cm M <5m Fair Minor High 2m No works required Medium ‐ B3 Retain Sweet Bursaria Poor (Vic Native)

5025 Bursaria spinosa Lot 9 8cm M <5m Fair Minor High 2m No works required Low ‐ B3 Retain Sweet Bursaria Poor (Vic Native)

5026 Bursaria spinosa Lot 9 8cm M <5m Fair Minor High 2m No works required Low ‐ B3 Retain Sweet Bursaria Poor (Vic Native)

Lot 10 195h Bursaria spinosa Lot 10 4cm Y <5m Fair None noticed Medium 2m No works required Retain Sweet Bursaria Fair (Vic Native)

T497 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 10 24cm SM 12m Good Minor or none High 2.9m No works required Retain Yellow Box Good noticed (Vic Native)

T501 Eucalyptus viminalis Lot 10 81cm M 23m Fair None noticed High 9.7m No works required High ‐ B1, B2, Species drought Retain Built form, Manna Gum Fair V2, V3 intolerant (other Landscape vision (Vic Native) Manna gums outside ecological niche have died over the past few years most likely due to dry); ecologically inappropriate position, species accumulates fire trash which will be problematic for future residents T601 Eucalyptus ovata Lot 10 25cm SM 12m Fair Major Low 3m No works required Non‐prefered Remove Landscape vision Swamp Gum Fair species, (Vic Native) inconsistent with Landscape vision

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records Lot 10 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 32 of 81 Lot 10 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T604 Eucalyptus viminalis Lot 10 48cm SM 17m Fair Minor Medium 5.8m No works required Low ‐ B3 Retain Manna Gum Fair (Multi_DBH (cm): 48) (Vic Native)

Lot 11 31 Callistemon cv. Lot 11 14cm SM 7m Good Minor Low 2m No works required Non‐prefered Remove Landscape vision Bottlebrush Fair species, (Multi_DBH (cm): 11,5,6,4) (Aus Native) inconsistent with Landscape vision

32 Callistemon cv. Lot 11 9cm M 6m Fair Bifurcations of Low 2m No works required Non‐prefered Remove Landscape vision Bottlebrush Poor stem species, (Multi_DBH (cm): 4,5,5,3,3,2) (Aus Native) inconsistent with Landscape vision

T502 Eucalyptus macrorhyncha Lot 11 33cm SM 8m Fair Major Low 4m Low Priority Actions: Low ‐ B3 Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure Red Stringybark Poor Tree Removal recommendation (Multi_DBH (cm): 30,13) (Vic Native)

T503 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 11 16cm SM <5m Fair Bifurcation of Low 2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure & Yellow Box Poor stem Tree Removal recommendation poor form (Vic Native) (Multi_DBH (cm): 13,10)

T597 Eucalyptus viminalis Lot 11 51cm M 15m Fair Major, Low 6.1m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure Manna Gum Poor Bifurcation of Tree Removal recommendation (Vic Native) stem

Lot 12 T504 Eucalyptus viminalis Lot 12 65cm M 18m Good Bifurcations of Low 7.8m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure Manna Gum Poor stem, Major Tree Removal recommendation (Vic Native)

T505 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 12 50cm M 12m Fair Major, Low 6m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure Yellow Box Poor Bifurcations of Tree Removal recommendation (Multi_DBH (cm): 36,27,21) (Vic Native) stem

T506 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 12 30cm Y 14m Fair Minor High 3.6m No works required Retain Yellow Box Fair (Vic Native)

Lot 13

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records Lot 13 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 33 of 81 Lot 13 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T261 Corymbia maculata Lot 13 32cm SM 10m Fair None noticed Medium 3.8m No works required Low ‐ B3 Retain Suppressed Spotted Gum Fair (Vic Native)

T508 Agonis flexuosa Lot 13 20cm M 6m Fair Minor, Low 2.4m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure & Willow Myrtle Poor Bifurcations of Tree Removal & B2 recommendation poor form (Aus Native) stem (Multi_DBH (cm): 14,12,5,2,3,3,3)

T509 Eucalyptus nicholii Lot 13 75cm OM 13m Fair Minor High 9m Medium Priority Actions: Medium ‐ B1 Retain Narrow‐leaved Peppermint Fair Prune to reduce weight of heavy (Aus Native) and/or large limbs

T510 Corymbia citriodora Lot 13 59cm M 22m Good Major, Tree is Low 7.1m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist History of limb shedding is likely to continue Lemon‐scented Gum Poor declining Tree Removal recommendation (major limbs are forming collars) (Aus Native) structurally Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure

8918 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 13 41cm M 16m Good Minor, High 4.9m Medium Priority Actions: Retain Yellow Box Fair Bifurcation of Weight reduce stems with (Vic Native) stem bifurcations

Lot 14 T259 Eucalyptus nicholii Lot 14 80cm M 17m Fair Major, Major, Low 9.6m High Priority Actions: High ‐ O1 / Remove Arborist Decay fungal fruiting bodies on trunk, Narrow‐leaved Peppermint Poor Tree has partially Tree Removal Medium ‐ B1 & recommendation Bifurcation of stem (moderate) ‐failed recently (Aus Native) collapsed B2 Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure

T272 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 14 99cm M 26m Fair Major Very High 11.9m Medium Priority Actions: Retain Cable bracing & pruning has been carried out Yellow Box Fair Check & adjust or replace cable‐ (Vic Native) bracing as required

T283 Allocasuarina torulosa Lot 14 54cm M 13m Fair Minor, Low 6.5m No works required Non‐prefered Remove Landscape vision Forest Oak Poor Bifurcations of species, (Multi_DBH (cm): 36,40) (Aus Native) stem inconsistent with Landscape vision

T283B Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 14 30cm SM 14m Poor Major Low 3.6m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist wood decay fungi on trunk Yellow Box Poor Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure (Vic Native)

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records Lot 14 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 34 of 81 Lot 14 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T533 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 14 54cm M 22m Good Minor Very High 6.5m Low Priority Actions: Retain Yellow Box Good Deadwood Prune (Vic Native)

T534 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 14 28cm M 14m Fair Minor Medium 3.4m Medium Priority Actions: Retain poorly formed specimen due to suppression Yellow Box Fair Deadwooding (Vic Native)

T535 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 14 46cm M 23m Fair Minor Very High 5.5m Medium Priority Actions: Retain Yellow Box Fair Deadwood (Vic Native)

T536 Corymbia citriodora Lot 14 22cm SM 15m Fair Minor Medium 2.6m No works required High ‐ O1 Retain Lemon‐scented Gum Fair (Aus Native)

T537 Eucalyptus nicholii Lot 14 22cm SM 11m Poor Minor Low 2.6m No works required High ‐ O1 Remove Arborist Narrow‐leaved Peppermint Fair recommendation (Aus Native)

T538 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 14 73cm M 29m Fair Minor Very High 8.8m Medium Priority Actions: Low ‐ B4 Retain Yellow Box Fair Deadwooding (Vic Native)

T539 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 14 97cm M 30m Fair Major, Very High 11.6m Medium Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, V4 Retain large old indig tree ‐ weight reduction pruning Yellow Box Poor Bifurcations of Cable‐brace done since last inspection, Bifurcations of stem (Vic Native) stem (severe)

T581 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 14 62cm M 15m Good Minor Very High 7.4m Medium Priority Actions: Retain Tree T581 has lean to southeast ‐ weight reduce Yellow Box Fair Deadwooding), Weight Reduction canopy (Vic Native)

T582 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 14 75cm M 25m Fair Minor or none Very High 9m Low Priority Actions: Retain Yellow Box Fair noticed Deadwood Prune (Vic Native)

Lot 15

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records Lot 15 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 35 of 81 Lot 15 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

478A Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 15 14cm Y 7m Good None noticed High 2m No works required High ‐ O1 / Retain Yellow Box Good Medium ‐ B1 (Vic Native)

T511 Eucalyptus sideroxylon Lot 15 48cm M 12m Good Major, Tree has Low 5.8m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist tree has split & lost crown Red Ironbark Poor partially collapsed Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure (Vic Native)

T512 Eucalyptus sideroxylon Lot 15 50cm M 14m Fair Minor High 6m No works required High ‐ O1, B1 Retain Built form Red Ironbark Fair (Vic Native)

T513 Agonis flexuosa Lot 15 10cm SM <5m Fair Minor, Medium 2m No works required High ‐ O1 / Retain Willow Myrtle Poor Bifurcations of Medium ‐ B1 (Multi_DBH (cm): 6,6,5) (Aus Native) stem

T514 Quercus robur Lot 15 34cm SM 6m Good Minor Medium 4.1m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Built form English Oak Fair Deadwood (Exotic)

T515 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 15 27cm SM 14m Poor Minor or none Medium 3.2m No works required High ‐ O1, B1 Non‐indigenous Remove Built form, Yellow Box Fair noticed genetic source (risk Landscape vision (Vic Native) of genetic pollution)

T516 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 15 13cm SM 6m Fair Minor or none High 2m No works required High ‐ O1, B1 Non‐indigenous Remove Built form, Yellow Box Fair noticed genetic source (risk Landscape vision (Vic Native) of genetic pollution), Lot already has 2 large, mature remnant Yellow box trees (T530 and 532) T517 Eucalyptus leucoxylon Lot 15 16cm SM 6m Fair Minor or none Medium 2m No works required High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Built form Yellow Gum Fair noticed (Vic Native)

T519 Eucalyptus sideroxylon Lot 15 34cm M 12m Good Minor Medium 4.1m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Built form Red Ironbark Fair Prune to reduce weight of heavy (Vic Native) and/or large limbs

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records Lot 15 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 36 of 81 Lot 15 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T520 Eucalyptus leucoxylon Lot 15 23cm SM 9m Fair Minor Low 2.8m No works required High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Built form Multiple bark wounds due to Sugar gliders Yellow Gum Fair feeding on sap (Vic Native)

T521 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 15 26cm SM 12m Fair Minor or none Medium 3.1m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Arborist Heavy lean to northwest ‐ Inteferes with Oak Yellow Box Fair noticed Tree Removal recommendation (T514) which is of greater retention value (Vic Native) Reasons for tree removal: Interfering with other trees

T528 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 15 32cm SM 13m Fair Minor High 3.8m No works required High ‐ O1, B1 Non‐indigenous Remove Built form, Yellow Box Fair genetic source (risk Landscape vision (Vic Native) of genetic pollution), Lot already has 2 large, mature remnant Yellow box trees (T530 and 532) T529 Eucalyptus sideroxylon Lot 15 42cm M 11m Fair Minor Medium 5m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Built form Weight reduce north stem if retained Red Ironbark Fair Structural Prune (minor) (Vic Native)

T530 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 15 78cm M 26m Good Minor Very High 9.4m Medium Priority Actions: Retain Yellow Box Fair Deadwood (Vic Native)

T532 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 15 59cm M 18m Fair Minor Very High 7.1m Medium Priority Actions: Retain Yellow Box Poor Deadwooding, Remove hanging (Vic Native) branches

T584 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 15 33cm SM 16m Good Minor High 4m No works required High ‐ V4 / Retain Yellow Box Fair Low ‐ B4 (Vic Native)

Lot 16 47 Melaleuca styphelioides Lot 16 27cm M 9m Fair Major Low 3.2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Bifurcation of stem (moderate) Prickly‐leaved Paperbark Poor Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure & (Aus Native) poor form (Multi_DBH (cm): 21,17)

T615 Eucalyptus saligna Lot 16 20cm Y 13m Good Minor Medium 2.4m No works required High ‐ O1, B1 Non‐prefered Retain Built form, Sydney Blue Gum Good species, Landscape vision (Multi_DBH (cm): 20) (Vic Native) inconsistent with Landscape vision

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records Lot 16 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 37 of 81 Lot 16 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T629 Eucalyptus nicholii Lot 16 26cm SM 11m Good Minor or none Medium 3.1m No works required Low ‐ B3 Remove Arborist Needs to be removed due to sewer Narrow‐leaved Peppermint Fair noticed recommendation infrastructure (following discussion with (Aus Native) Landplan) (Multi_DBH (cm): 26)

T630 Acacia melanoxylon Lot 16 20cm M 8m Fair Minor or none Medium 2.4m No works required High ‐ O1, B1 Short‐lived species Retain Built form, Also 3 smaller trees near Blackwood Fair noticed in local conditions, Landscape vision (Multi_DBH (cm): 20) (Vic Native) poorly positioned for use of land

T631 Eucalyptus cephalocarpa Lot 16 27cm M 8m Fair Minor Medium 3.2m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, B1 Retain Silver Stringybark Poor Deadwood Prune (Multi_DBH (cm): 27) (Vic Native)

T632x Eucalyptus viminalis Lot 16 73cm M 23m Fair Major Low 8.8m Medium Priority Actions: Retain Arborist Possible to retain with major reduction pruning Manna Gum Poor Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure & (Vic Native) poor form (Multi_DBH (cm): 73)

T634 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 16 34cm SM 17m Good None noticed High 4.1m No works required Retain Changed from T633 to T634 (as per label on Yellow Box Fair tree) (Vic Native) (Multi_DBH (cm): 34)

T637 Eucalyptus elata Lot 16 48cm M 20m Good Minor High 5.8m No works required High ‐ O1, B1, Species drought Retain Built form, River Peppermint Good V3 intolerant (other Landscape vision (Multi_DBH (cm): 48) (Vic Native) speciemens of this species have died over the past few years most likely due to dry); ecologically inappropriate position; leading stem has died T639 Eucalyptus viminalis Lot 16 16cm Y 7m Good Minor Medium 2m No works required Low ‐ B4 Non‐indigenous Retain Landscape vision Manna Gum Fair specimen with (Multi_DBH (cm): 16) (Vic Native) potential for genetic pollution; inappropriate ecological position; species drought intolerant; out of scale; species accumulates fire trash; species inappropriate for urban development area

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records Lot 16 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 38 of 81 Lot 16 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T901 Eucalyptus cladocalyx Lot 16 52cm M 22m Poor Minor Low 6.24m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Also smaller tree 2m to north Sugar Gum Fair Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure (Weedy (Aus. Native))

T902 Eucalyptus leucoxylon Lot 16 26cm M 10m Fair Minor Medium 3.1m Low Priority Actions: High O1 / Low Retain subsp. megalocarpa Fair Deadwood Prune B3 (Multi_DBH (cm): 26) Large‐fruited South Australian Blue Gum (Vic Native)

1700 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 16 17cm SM 11m Fair Minor or none High 2m No works required High ‐ O1 / Retain Yellow Box Fair noticed Low B 1 (Multi_DBH (cm): 17) (Vic Native)

1886 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 16 36cm M 16m Good Bifurcation of Low 4.3m Medium Priority Actions: High ‐ O1 / Retain Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure Yellow Box Poor stem Tree Removal Medium ‐ B1 & recommendation (Multi_DBH (cm): 36) (Vic Native) B2

5054 Eucalyptus viminalis Lot 16 9cm Y 7m Good Bifurcations of Medium 2m No works required High ‐ V4 / Species drought Retain Built form, Manna Gum Fair stem Low ‐ B4 intolerant (other Landscape vision (Multi_DBH (cm): 8,3) (Vic Native) Manna gums outside ecological niche have died over the past few years most likely due to dry); ecologically inappropriate position, species accumulates fire trash which will be problematic for future residents 5055 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 16 14cm Y 7m Good Minor High 2m No works required Low ‐ B4 Retain Yellow Box Fair (Multi_DBH (cm): 14) (Vic Native)

5056 Corymbia ficifolia Lot 16 16cm Y 6m Fair Minor Medium 2m No works required High ‐ O1, B1 Retain Red‐flowering Gum Fair (Multi_DBH (cm): 16) (Aus Native)

Lot 17 T636 Eucalyptus viminalis Lot 17 30cm SM 16m Fair Minor or none Medium 3.6m No works required High ‐ O1 / Retain Manna Gum Fair noticed Medium ‐ B3 (Multi_DBH (cm): 30) (Vic Native)

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records Lot 17 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 39 of 81 Lot 17 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T638 Eucalyptus viminalis Lot 17 88cm M 22m Fair Minor High 10.6m Medium Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, B1 / Species drought Retain Built form, Most likely a planted specimen as not usually Manna Gum Fair Aerial canopy inspection Medium ‐ O3 intolerant (other Landscape vision found on higher ground (Vic Native) Manna gums (Multi_DBH (cm): 88) outside ecological niche have died over the past few years most likely due to dry); ecologically inappropriate position, species accumulates fire trash which will be problematic for future residents T641 Acacia melanoxylon Lot 17 22cm SM 8m Fair Major, Tree has Low 2.6m Medium Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, B1 Retain Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure & Blackwood Poor partially collapsed Tree Removal & B2 / recommendation poor form (Vic Native) Medium ‐ V2 & (Multi_DBH (cm): 22) V3

T642 Acacia melanoxylon Lot 17 20cm SM 8m Fair Minor or none Low 2.4m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1 / Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Poor structure Blackwood Poor noticed Tree Removal Medium ‐ B1 recommendation (Multi_DBH (cm): 20) (Vic Native)

T648 Acacia implexa Lot 17 45cm OM 9m Fair Major, Low 5.4m Medium Priority Actions: Retain Arborist Close proximity to house in neighbouring Lightwood Poor Bifurcations of Tree Removal recommendation property (Vic Native) stem Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure (Multi_DBH (cm): 45)

T651 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 17 61cm M 15m Fair Minor Very High 7.3m No works required High ‐ O1 / Retain Yellow Box Good Medium ‐ B3 (Multi_DBH (cm): 61) (Vic Native)

1884 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 17 24cm SM 10m Good Minor or none Low 2.9m Low Priority Actions: Low ‐ B4 Non‐prefered Retain Arborist Poor form and suspected root defects Yellow Box Poor noticed Structural Prune (minor) species, recommendation (Multi_DBH (cm): 24) (Vic Native) inconsistent with Landscape vision

Lot 18 T650 Eucalyptus ovata Lot 18 62cm M 12m Fair Major Low 7.4m High Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: High risk structure Swamp Gum Poor Tree Removal recommendation (Multi_DBH (cm): 62) (Vic Native)

Lot 19

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records Lot 19 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 40 of 81 Lot 19 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

5 Citrus reticulata Lot 19 16cm OM <5m Poor Major Low 2m No works required Non‐prefered Remove Landscape vision Citrus Poor species, (Multi_DBH (cm): 12,7,6,6) (Exotic) inconsistent with Landscape vision

T654 Eucalyptus goniocalyx Lot 19 99cm OM 15m Fair Major Medium 11.9m High Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, B1, High landscape, Remove Built form, Significant crown reduction required if retained Long‐leaved Box Poor Prune to reduce weight of heavy V2, V3 biological and Landscape vision (Vic Native) and/or large limbs, Prune to habitat value, but reduce risk of collapse, retention requires Deadwood high ongoing cost and relatively intensive management. Major stem has collapsed receently due to decay; possibility of rot in remaining stem; exposed wounds at 5m, with borer Lot 20 5006 Eucalyptus goniocalyx Lot 20 6cm Y <5m Good Minor or none Medium 2m No works required Low ‐ B4 Retain Long‐leaved Box Good noticed (Vic Native)

Lot 21 T658 Acacia melanoxylon Lot 21 56cm M 10m Good Major, Low 6.7m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, B1 Retain Arborist Two trees growing very close or1 tree with Blackwood Poor Bifurcation of Tree Removal & B2 / recommendation bifurcated stem (Vic Native) stem Medium ‐ V2 & Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure V3 (Multi_DBH (cm): 38,41)

Lot 22 T659B Acacia melanoxylon Lot 22 45cm M 8m Good Major, Low 5.4m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, B1 Retain Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure Blackwood Poor Bifurcation of Tree Removal & B2 / recommendation (Multi_DBH (cm): 32,31) (Vic Native) stem Medium ‐ V2 & V3

Lot 24 T142 Eucalyptus camaldulensis Lot 24 57cm M 17m Fair None noticed Medium 6.8m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, B1 Retain River Red Gum Good Deadwood Prune (Vic Native)

814 Eucalyptus botryoides Lot 24 11cm M 7m Good Minor Low 2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Tree has failed & only stump suckers remain, Southern Mahogany Poor Tree Removal recommendation Weedy species (Vic Native) Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure & poor form

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records Lot 24 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 41 of 81 Lot 25 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL Lot 25 T158 Eucalyptus ovata Lot 25 16cm SM 7m Fair Minor Low 2m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1 / Remove Arborist Heavy lean to north east Swamp Gum Poor Tree Removal Medium ‐ B1 & recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Failure likely (Vic Native) B2

Lot 26 T150 Cupressus macrocarpa Lot 26 68cm OM 24m Fair Major, Low 8.2m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure Monterey Cypress Poor Bifurcations of Tree Removal recommendation (Exotic) stem, General decline of structure

T151 Cupressus macrocarpa Lot 26 59cm OM 24m Fair Major, Low 7.1m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure Monterey Cypress Poor Bifurcations of Tree Removal recommendation (Exotic) stem, General decline of structure

T152 Cupressus macrocarpa Lot 26 54cm OM 23m Fair Major, Low 6.5m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure Monterey Cypress Poor Bifurcations of Tree Removal recommendation (Exotic) stem, General decline of structures

T153 Cupressus macrocarpa Lot 26 121cm OM 24m Good Major, Low 14.5m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure Monterey Cypress Poor Bifurcations of Tree Removal recommendation (Exotic) stem, General decline of structure

T154 Cupressus macrocarpa Lot 26 95cm OM 26m Fair Major, Low 11.4m High Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Poor form & structural decline Monterey Cypress Poor Bifurcations of Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure (Exotic) stem, General (Multi_DBH (cm): 91,26) decline of structure

T159 Eucalyptus ovata Lot 26 43cm M 16m Fair Minor Medium 5.2m No works required Low ‐ B3 Retain Also small Blackwood at base‐ remove due to Swamp Gum Fair defects (Vic Native)

817 Acacia melanoxylon Lot 26 10cm M 6m Fair Major, Low 2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Approximately 20 other specimens in the area, Blackwood Poor Bifurcations of Tree Removal recommendation Older specimens have collapsed (Vic Native) stem Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure

5040 Acacia melanoxylon Lot 26 11cm M 5m Fair Minor Medium 2m No works required Low ‐ B3 Retain Blackwood Poor (Vic Native)

Lot 27

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records Lot 27 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 42 of 81 Lot 27 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T155 Eucalyptus globulus subsp. Lot 27 45cm M 12m Fair Minor Low 5.4m No works required Low ‐ B3 Non‐prefered Remove Landscape vision bicostata Poor species, Eurabbie inconsistent with (Vic Native) Landscape vision

T156 Eucalyptus sideroxylon Lot 27 37cm M 12m Fair Minor Medium 4.4m No works required Low ‐ B3 Retain Red Ironbark Fair (Vic Native)

T778 Acacia melanoxylon Lot 27 25cm M 3m Fair Major, Tree has Medium 3m No works required Medium ‐ V4 / Retain Many young specimens have self‐sown in this Blackwood Poor partially collapsed Low ‐ B4 area,not posing risk ‐ could be retained if (Vic Native) desired

4040 Acacia melanoxylon Lot 27 20cm SM 20m Fair Major, Tree has Medium 2.4m No works required Medium ‐ V4 / Retain Blackwood Poor completely Low ‐ B4 (Vic Native) collapsed

Lot 29 T47 Eucalyptus globulus subsp. Lot 29 103cm OM 24m Fair Minor Low 12.4m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: High risk structure bicostata Poor Tree Removal recommendation Eurabbie (Vic Native)

T48 Eucalyptus cladocalyx Lot 29 56cm M 16m Fair Major Low 6.72m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Major wound in stem with heavily biased Sugar Gum Fair Tree Removal recommendation crown ‐failure likely once near by Blue Gum has (Weedy (Aus. Native)) been removed Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure & poor form

T49 Eucalyptus cladocalyx Lot 29 10cm Y 6m Fair Minor or none Low 2m Species inconsistent Remove Landscape vision Sugar Gum Fair noticed with Landscape (Weedy (Aus. Native)) vision (weedy)

T50 Acacia dealbata Lot 29 13cm SM 6m Fair Minor or none Medium 2m No works required Low ‐ B4 Retain Silver Wattle Fair noticed (Multi_DBH (cm): 10,8) (Vic Native)

T778x Corymbia maculata Lot 29 44cm SM 16m Good Major, Low 5.3m No works required Non‐prefered Remove Landscape vision Poor form Spotted Gum Poor Bifurcations of species, (Multi_DBH (cm): 34,28) (Vic Native) stem inconsistent with Landscape vision

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records Lot 29 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 43 of 81 Lot 29 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T780 Eucalyptus mannifera Lot 29 47cm M 17m Poor Major, Low 5.6m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist fungal fruiting bodies Red Spotted Gum Poor Bifurcation of Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Failure likely (Vic Native) stem

844 Eucalyptus cladocalyx Lot 29 39cm M 14m Poor Major Low 4.68m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Fungal fruiting bodies in mainstem wound, Sugar Gum Poor Tree Removal recommendation declining health (Weedy (Aus. Native)) Reasons for tree removal: Decline of landscape value

5049 Eucalyptus leucoxylon Lot 29 13cm SM <5m Fair Minor or none Medium 2m No works required Low ‐ B3 Retain subsp. megalocarpa Fair noticed Large‐fruited South Australian Blue Gum (Vic Native)

5050 Melaleuca styphelioides Lot 29 29cm M 7m Fair Minor, Low 3.5m No works required Retain Prickly‐leaved Paperbark Poor Bifurcations of (Multi_DBH (cm): 16,15,15,12) (Aus Native) stem

5051 Ulmus glabra 'Lutescens' Lot 29 18cm SM 30m Fair Major, Low 2.2m No works required Retain Golden Elm Poor Bifurcations of (Multi_DBH (cm): 12,13) (Exotic) stem

Lot 30 T144 Cupressus macrocarpa Lot 30 156cm OM 24m Fair Major, Low 15m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure Monterey Cypress Poor Bifurcations of Tree Removal recommendation (Exotic) stem, General decline of structure

T145 Cupressus macrocarpa Lot 30 94cm OM 23m Fair Major, Low 11.3m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure Monterey Cypress Poor Bifurcations of Tree Removal recommendation (Exotic) stem, General decline of structure

T146 Cupressus macrocarpa Lot 30 73cm OM 24m Fair Major, Low 8.8m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure Monterey Cypress Poor Bifurcations of Tree Removal recommendation (Exotic) stem, General decline of structure

T147 Cupressus macrocarpa Lot 30 56cm OM 24m Fair Major, Low 6.7m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure Monterey Cypress Poor Bifurcations of Tree Removal recommendation (Exotic) stem, General decline of structure

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records Lot 30 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 44 of 81 Lot 30 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T148 Cupressus macrocarpa Lot 30 54cm OM 24m Fair Major, Low 6.5m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure Monterey Cypress Poor Bifurcations of Tree Removal recommendation (Exotic) stem, General decline of structure

T149 Cupressus macrocarpa Lot 30 78cm OM 24m Fair Major, Low 9.4m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure Monterey Cypress Poor Bifurcations of Tree Removal recommendation (Exotic) stem, General decline of structure

Lot 56 T53 Eucalyptus melliodora Lot 56 23cm SM 6m Good Minor Medium 2.8m No works required Medium ‐ V4 / Remove Built form suspected poor root formation Yellow Box Poor Low ‐ B4 (Multi_DBH (cm): 16,17) (Vic Native)

PCRZ T2 Eucalyptus viminalis PCRZ 153cm OM 24m Fair Major, Tree is in Medium 15m Medium Priority Actions: Retain wood decay fungi presant. If people can be Manna Gum Poor early stages of Removal or special management excluded from fall zone, tree may be retained. (Vic Native) collapse (see comments)(Medium), Yearly Deadwood, Crown reduction. Inspection(Medium)

T3 Eucalyptus viminalis PCRZ 58cm M 23m Fair Minor or none High 7m Low Priority Actions: Retain Manna Gum Fair noticed Deadwood Prune (Vic Native)

T4 Eucalyptus viminalis PCRZ 65cm M 15m Good Bifurcation of Medium 7.8m Medium Priority Actions: Retain Weight reduce if infrastructure or occupancy Manna Gum Poor stem Structural Prune (minor) within 12m on west side (Vic Native) (Multi_DBH (cm): 43,49)

T5 Eucalyptus viminalis PCRZ 35cm SM 20m Fair High 4.2m No works required Retain Poor stem to height ratio increases likelihood of Manna Gum Fair failure in strong weather conditions ‐ review if (Vic Native) surrounding trees are removed and exposure increased

T6 Eucalyptus viminalis PCRZ 36cm SM 18m Fair Major Low 4.3m Low Priority Actions: Retain Swelling in stem indicates internal decay and Manna Gum Poor Tree Removal likely future failure (Vic Native) Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure

T7 Eucalyptus melliodora PCRZ 25cm SM 15m Fair Minor or none High 3m No works required Retain Yellow Box Fair noticed (Vic Native)

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records PCRZ trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 45 of 81 PCRZ ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T8 Eucalyptus melliodora PCRZ 18cm Y 13m Fair Minor or none Medium 2.2m No works required Retain Yellow Box Fair noticed (Vic Native)

T9 Eucalyptus viminalis PCRZ 44cm SM 18m Good Minor or none High 5.3m Low Priority Actions: Retain Yellow Box Fair noticed Formative Prune(Low) (Vic Native)

T10 Eucalyptus melliodora PCRZ 34cm SM 17m Fair Bifurcation of High 4.1m No works required Retain Yellow Box Fair stem (Multi_DBH (cm): 26,22) (Vic Native)

T11 Eucalyptus melliodora PCRZ 21cm SM 12m Fair Minor or none High 2.5m No works required Retain Yellow Box Fair noticed (Vic Native)

T12 Eucalyptus melliodora PCRZ 27cm SM 14m Fair Minor or none High 3.2m No works required Retain Yellow Box Fair noticed (Multi_DBH (cm): 20,18) (Vic Native)

T13 Eucalyptus melliodora PCRZ 17cm Y 11m Dead General decline Low 2m Low Priority Actions: Retain 18/12/2013 dead Yellow Box of structure Tree Removal Reasons for tree removal: Dead (Vic Native)

T14 Acacia dealbata PCRZ 17cm OM 6m Dead Major, Tree has Low 2m Low Priority Actions: Retain 18/12/2013 dead & collapsed Silver Wattle Poor partially collapsed Tree Removal Reasons for tree removal: Dead (Vic Native)

T26 Eucalyptus melliodora PCRZ 40cm SM 15m Fair Bifurcation of High 4.8m Low Priority Actions: Retain Weight reduce. Wetlands construction may Yellow Box Poor stem Structural Prune (minor) impact heavily on TPZ. Tree may survive if care (Vic Native) and arborist guidance is followed during construction. (Multi_DBH (cm): 26,30)

T27 Eucalyptus melliodora PCRZ 39cm SM 16m Fair High 4.7m No works required Retain Wetlands construction may impact heavily on Yellow Box Poor TPZ. Tree may survive if care and arborist (Vic Native) guidance is followed during construction. (Multi_DBH (cm): 27,28)

T28 Eucalyptus melliodora PCRZ 32cm SM 16m Fair Minor or none High 3.8m No works required Retain Wetlands construction may impact heavily on Yellow Box Fair noticed TPZ. Tree may survive if care and arborist (Vic Native) guidance is followed during construction. (Multi_DBH (cm): 28,16)

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records PCRZ trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 46 of 81 PCRZ ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T29 Eucalyptus melliodora PCRZ 31cm SM 19m Good Minor or none High 3.7m No works required Retain Yellow Box Fair noticed (Multi_DBH (cm): 27,15) (Vic Native)

T30 Eucalyptus melliodora PCRZ 30cm SM 17m Fair Minor or none High 3.6m No works required Retain Yellow Box Fair noticed (Multi_DBH (cm): 23,19) (Vic Native)

T31 Eucalyptus melliodora PCRZ 31cm SM 16m Fair Minor or none High 3.7m No works required Retain Yellow Box Fair noticed (Vic Native)

T32 Eucalyptus melliodora PCRZ 71cm M 23m Fair Bifurcation of Very High 8.5m Medium Priority Actions: Retain Weight reduce in general it area is to have Yellow Box Poor stem Structural Prune (minor) infrastructure that may be damaged or be (Vic Native) occupied

T33 Eucalyptus rubida PCRZ 78cm M 23m Fair Minor (? ‐ see Very High 9.4m High Priority Actions: Retain Wound with fungal‐fruiting body @ 3m on Candlebark Poor notes) Deadwood Prune, Further northeast side. Further investigation only (Vic Native) Investigation of Defects required if fall zone of tree is likely to be occupied frequently

T34 Eucalyptus melliodora PCRZ 56cm M 17m Fair Minor High 6.7m No works required Retain Yellow Box Fair (Multi_DBH (cm): 37,17,38) (Vic Native)

T35 Eucalyptus melliodora PCRZ 42cm M 20m Poor Major Medium 5m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Wetland 18/12/2013 worth retaining Yellow Box Poor Yearly Inspection, construction (Vic Native) Deadwooding,(Medium), Weight Reduction(Medium)

T37 Eucalyptus radiata PCRZ 40cm M 9m Dead General decline Medium 3m Medium Priority Actions: Retain 18/12/2013 dead Narrow‐leaved Peppermint Poor of structure Weight Reduction(Medium), (Vic Native) Deadwooding(Medium)

T38 Eucalyptus melliodora PCRZ 28cm SM 12m Fair Bifurcations of Medium 3.4m No works required Retain Yellow Box Poor stem (Multi_DBH (cm): 18,21) (Vic Native)

T39 Eucalyptus melliodora PCRZ 68cm M 24m Good Minor or none Very High 8.2m No works required Retain Yellow Box Fair noticed (Vic Native)

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records PCRZ trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 47 of 81 PCRZ ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T40 Eucalyptus melliodora PCRZ 53cm M 22m Fair Minor High 6.4m Low Priority Actions: Retain Yellow Box Fair Deadwooding(Medium) (Vic Native)

T44 Eucalyptus melliodora PCRZ 85cm M 23m Fair Major, Medium 10.2m Medium Priority Actions: Retain Cable bracing may be required Yellow Box FOOTPATH Poor Bifurcations of Deadwooding, Yearly (Vic Native) stem Inspection(Medium), Weight Reduction(Medium)

T45 Eucalyptus melliodora PCRZ 60cm M 21m Fair Minor or none High 7.2m Medium Priority Actions: Retain Yellow Box FOOTPATH Fair noticed Structural Prune (minor) (Vic Native)

T46 Eucalyptus rubida PCRZ 135cm M 23m Fair Bifurcations of Very High 15m Medium Priority Actions: Retain Bifurcation of stem (moderate) Slight crown Candlebark Fair stem Deadwood, Weight reduce bias to south, cable bracing may be required (Vic Native) (Multi_DBH (cm): 111,76)

T359 Eucalyptus cladocalyx PCRZ 31cm M 10m Poor Minor Low 3.72m No works required Remove Wetland Weedy species near EOS area Sugar Gum Fair construction (Multi_DBH (cm): 24,19) (Weedy (Aus. Native))

T410 Eucalyptus viminalis PCRZ 43cm M 25m Fair High 5.2m No works required Retain Manna Gum Fair (Vic Native)

T411 Eucalyptus viminalis PCRZ 48cm M 23m Fair Minor or none High 5.8m No works required Retain Bifurcation does not appear to have defect Manna Gum Fair noticed (Vic Native)

T412 Eucalyptus viminalis PCRZ 42cm M 22m Fair High 5m Priority Actions: Retain Manna Gum Fair (Vic Native)

T413 Eucalyptus ovata PCRZ 20cm SM 16m Poor Minor or none Low 2.4m No works required Retain Swamp Gum Fair noticed (Vic Native)

T414 Eucalyptus ovata PCRZ 25cm SM 20m Fair Minor or none High 3m No works required Retain Swamp Gum Fair noticed (Vic Native)

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records PCRZ trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 48 of 81 PCRZ ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T415 Eucalyptus viminalis PCRZ 23cm SM 14m Poor Minor or none Medium 2.8m No works required Retain Manna Gum Fair noticed (Vic Native)

T416 Eucalyptus ovata PCRZ 45cm M 23m Fair Minor or none High 5.4m No works required Retain Swamp Gum Fair noticed (Vic Native)

T417 Eucalyptus viminalis PCRZ 61cm M 25m Good Minor or none Very High 7.3m No works required Retain Manna Gum Good noticed (Vic Native)

T418 Eucalyptus viminalis PCRZ 59cm M 29m Good Minor or none High 7.1m No works required Retain Manna Gum Fair noticed (Vic Native)

T419 Eucalyptus viminalis PCRZ 37cm SM 20m Fair Minor or none Medium 4.4m Low Priority Actions: Retain Northwest canopy appears to be declining Manna Gum Fair noticed Deadwood Prune (Vic Native)

T420 Eucalyptus viminalis PCRZ 29cm SM 21m Fair Major (?) Medium 3.5m Low Priority Actions: Retain suspected root defects Manna Gum Poor No works required (Vic Native)

T421 Eucalyptus melliodora PCRZ 32cm SM 23m Fair Minor or none High 3.8m Low Priority Actions: Retain Yellow Box Fair noticed Deadwood Prune (Vic Native)

T422 Eucalyptus ovata PCRZ 44cm M 18m Fair Minor (? see High 5.3m Low Priority Actions: Retain Wound with possible decay @ 4m Swamp Gum Fair notes) Further Investigation of Defects (Vic Native)

T423 Eucalyptus obliqua PCRZ 29cm SM 15m Fair Minor Medium 3.5m No works required High ‐ O1 / Retain Messmate Fair Medium ‐ B1 & (Vic Native) B2

693 Eucalyptus viminalis PCRZ 26cm SM 15m Fair Minor or none Medium 3.1m No works required Remove Wetland Manna Gum Fair noticed construction (Vic Native)

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records PCRZ trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 49 of 81 PCRZ ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

707 Eucalyptus viminalis PCRZ 23cm SM 13m Dead General decline Low 2.8m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Manna Gum Poor of structure Tree Removal recommendation (Vic Native)

708 Eucalyptus viminalis PCRZ 74cm M 22m Fair Minor or none Very High 8.9m Medium Priority Actions: Retain 17/12/2013 good tree worth retaining Manna Gum Fair noticed Deadwooding(Medium), (Vic Native) Climbing inspection(Medium)

709 Eucalyptus viminalis PCRZ 61cm OM 8m Dead Major, Tree has High 3m No works required Retain 17/12/2013 dead tree long time, habitat value Manna Gum Poor partially collapsed (Vic Native)

712 Eucalyptus viminalis PCRZ 64cm M 24m Fair Minor or none Very High 7.7m No works required Retain Manna Gum Fair noticed (Vic Native)

713 Eucalyptus viminalis PCRZ 54cm M 25m Fair Minor or none Very High 6.5m Medium Priority Actions: Retain habitat hollows Manna Gum Fair noticed Deadwooding(Medium) (Vic Native)

715 Eucalyptus viminalis PCRZ 46cm M 25m Fair Bifurcation of Medium 5.5m No works required Retain Manna Gum Poor stem (Vic Native)

716 Eucalyptus viminalis PCRZ 46cm M 26m Dead General decline Low 3m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist No habitat hollows noticed, reduce size for Manna Gum Poor of structure Tree Removal recommendation stability if retained (Vic Native) (early stages)

717 Eucalyptus viminalis PCRZ 37cm SM 24m Fair Minor or none High 4.4m No works required Retain Will most likely fall to east doe to embankment Manna Gum Good noticed erosion (Vic Native)

718 Eucalyptus viminalis PCRZ 35cm SM 25m Dead Low 3m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist No habitat‐hollows noticed Manna Gum Poor Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Dead (Vic Native)

719 Eucalyptus viminalis PCRZ 74cm M 31m Fair Very High 8.9m No works required Retain Tree may fall to west if embankment erosion Manna Gum Good continues (Vic Native)

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records PCRZ trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 50 of 81 PCRZ ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

869 Eucalyptus rubida PCRZ 45cm M <5m Dead Major, Tree has Low 3m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Stems are on ground‐ could be retained for Candlebark Fair completely Tree Removal recommendation habitat value (Vic Native) collapsed

889 Bursaria spinosa PCRZ 20cm OM 6m Poor Major, Tree has Low 2.4m No works required Retain Mag be retained far habitat value Sweet Bursaria Poor partially collapsed (Multi_DBH (cm): 11,10,13) (Vic Native)

898 Eucalyptus viminalis PCRZ 23cm Y 11m Poor Minor or none Medium 2.8m No works required Retain suppressed poorly formed specimen Manna Gum Fair noticed (Vic Native)

1604 Eucalyptus viminalis PCRZ 19cm SM 19m Fair Minor or none Medium 2.3m No works required Retain Manna Gum Fair noticed (Vic Native)

1606 Eucalyptus viminalis PCRZ 66cm OM 19m Poor Major Low 7.9m Medium Priority Actions: Retain Tree only needs to be removed if people or Manna Gum Poor Tree Removal property likely to be in fall zone to northwest, (Vic Native) fungal fruiting bodies Reasons for tree removal: Failure likely

1607 Eucalyptus viminalis PCRZ 27cm SM 19m Fair Minor or none High 3.2m No works required Retain Manna Gum Fair noticed (Vic Native)

2113 Eucalyptus sp. PCRZ 34cm M 13m Dead General decline Low 3m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reduce height if retained for habitat value Eucalypt Poor of structure Tree Removal recommendation (Vic Native)

5058 Eucalyptus viminalis PCRZ 60cm M 24m Fair Minor (?) ‐ High 7.2m Low Priority Actions: Retain Large dead branches Manna Gum Fair swelling in stem Deadwood Prune (Vic Native) may indicate internal decay

5059 Eucalyptus sp. PCRZ 110cm OM 22m Dead Major, Tree has High 3m No works required Retain Habitat Value, large hollows Eucalypt Poor partially collapsed (Aus Native)

5060 Eucalyptus viminalis PCRZ 45cm M 23m Good Minor or none High 5.4m No works required Retain Manna Gum Fair noticed (Vic Native)

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records PCRZ trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 51 of 81 PCRZ ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

5061 Eucalyptus sp. PCRZ 84cm OM 27m Dead Minor or none Low 3m Medium Priority Actions: Retain Arborist May provide habitat opportunities if retained Eucalypt Poor noticed Tree Removal recommendation but should be reduced to improve stability (Vic Native) Reasons for tree removal: Failure likely

5062 Bursaria spinosa PCRZ 12cm OM <5m Fair Major, Tree has Low 2m No works required Retain May be retained for habitat value Sweet Bursaria Poor partially collapsed (Vic Native)

TREE RESERVE STAGE 1 T765 Eucalyptus polyanthemos TREE RESERVE 67cm M 15m Fair Minor High 8m Low Priority Actions: Retain Red Box STAGE 1 Poor Prune to reduce weight of heavy (Multi_DBH (cm): 64,19) (Vic Native) and/or large limbs

T766 Eucalyptus polyanthemos TREE RESERVE 65cm M 18m Fair Minor Very High 7.8m Medium Priority Actions: Retain Weight reduction of southwest limb with Red Box STAGE 1 Fair Weight Reduction, Deadwood included bark. (Vic Native)

T767 Eucalyptus melliodora TREE RESERVE 35cm M 12m Fair Major, Tree has Low 4.2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Tree has partially collapsed and will be prone to Yellow Box STAGE 1 Poor partially collapsed Tree Removal recommendation further failures in future (Vic Native) Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure & poor form

T769 Eucalyptus polyanthemos TREE RESERVE 34cm M 9m Fair Major High 4.1m Medium Priority Actions: Retain Red Box STAGE 1 Fair Weight reduce (Vic Native)

1734 Acacia melanoxylon TREE RESERVE 23cm OM 6m Poor General decline Medium 2.8m No works required Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Short life expectancy Blackwood STAGE 1 Poor of structure recommendation (Multi_DBH (cm): 17,16) (Vic Native)

TREE RESERVE STAGE 2 181A Bursaria spinosa TREE RESERVE 6cm M <5m Fair None noticed High 2m No works required Retain Sweet Bursaria STAGE 2 Fair (Multi_DBH (cm): 2,6) (Vic Native)

195j Bursaria spinosa TREE RESERVE 4cm Y <5m Fair None noticed Medium 2m No works required Retain Sweet Bursaria STAGE 2 Fair (Vic Native)

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records TREE RESERVE STAGE 2 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 52 of 81 TREE RESERVE STAGE 2 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

195c Bursaria spinosa TREE RESERVE 10cm Y 2m Fair None noticed Medium 2m No works required Retain Sweet Bursaria STAGE 2 Fair (Vic Native)

195A Bursaria spinosa TREE RESERVE 2cm Y <5m Fair None noticed Medium 2m No works required Retain Sweet Bursaria STAGE 2 Fair (Vic Native)

195k Bursaria spinosa TREE RESERVE 10cm Y 1m Fair None noticed Medium 2m No works required Retain Sweet Bursaria STAGE 2 Fair (Vic Native)

T603 Eucalyptus sideroxylon TREE RESERVE 65cm M 16m Good Minor High 7.8m Low Priority Actions: Retain Red Ironbark STAGE 2 Fair Deadwood (Multi_DBH (cm): 65) (Vic Native)

T607 Eucalyptus botryoides TREE RESERVE 25cm SM 12m Fair Minor Low 3m No works required Species inconsistent Remove Landscape vision Weedy species Southern Mahogany STAGE 2 Fair with Landscape (Multi_DBH (cm): 25) (Vic Native) vision (weedy)

T608 Eucalyptus botryoides TREE RESERVE 34cm SM 10m Fair Minor Low 4.1m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Weedy species Southern Mahogany STAGE 2 Fair Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Weedy species (Vic Native) (Multi_DBH (cm): 34)

T609 Eucalyptus saligna TREE RESERVE 48cm M 18m Fair None noticed Medium 5.8m No works required Species inconsistent Remove Landscape vision Sydney Blue Gum STAGE 2 Fair with Landscape (Multi_DBH (cm): 48) (Aus Native) vision (weedy)

T610 Eucalyptus ovata TREE RESERVE 52cm M 8m Fair Major Medium 6.2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Tree has partially collapsed Swamp Gum STAGE 2 Poor Tree Removal recommendation (Multi_DBH (cm): 52) (Vic Native)

T613 Eucalyptus polyanthemos TREE RESERVE 27cm SM 13m Fair Minor High 3.2m No works required Retain Red Box STAGE 2 Fair (Multi_DBH (cm): 27) (Vic Native)

T614 Eucalyptus melliodora TREE RESERVE 46cm M 17m Good Major Very High 5.5m Medium Priority Actions: Retain Yellow Box STAGE 2 Fair Weight reduce south stem with (Multi_DBH (cm): 42,19) (Vic Native) bifurcation

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records TREE RESERVE STAGE 2 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 53 of 81 TREE RESERVE STAGE 2 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T616 Eucalyptus melliodora TREE RESERVE 48cm M 21m Good Minor or none Very High 5.8m No works required Retain Yellow Box STAGE 2 Good noticed (Multi_DBH (cm): 48) (Vic Native)

T617 Eucalyptus melliodora TREE RESERVE 35cm M 20m Fair Minor High 4.2m No works required Retain Yellow Box STAGE 2 Fair (Multi_DBH (cm): 35) (Vic Native)

T619 Grevillea robusta TREE RESERVE 16cm SM 8m Fair Minor or none Medium 2m No works required Retain Silky Oak STAGE 2 Fair noticed (Multi_DBH (cm): 16) (Aus Native)

T622 Eucalyptus botryoides TREE RESERVE 26cm SM 10m Poor Minor Low 3.1m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Weedy species Southern Mahogany STAGE 2 Poor Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure & (Vic Native) poor form (Multi_DBH (cm): 26)

T623 Melaleuca styphelioides TREE RESERVE 35cm M 7m Poor Minor Low 4.2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Bifurcation of stem (moderate) Prickly‐leaved Paperbark STAGE 2 Poor Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Short life expectancy (Aus Native) (Multi_DBH (cm): 35)

T624 Eucalyptus melliodora TREE RESERVE 51cm M 22m Fair None noticed Very High 6.1m Low Priority Actions: Retain Yellow Box STAGE 2 Fair Deadwood (Multi_DBH (cm): 51) (Vic Native)

T625 Corymbia ficifolia TREE RESERVE 20cm SM 10m Fair Minor or none Low 2.4m No works required Competition with Remove Landscape vision Red‐flowering Gum STAGE 2 Fair noticed larger high (Multi_DBH (cm): 20) (Aus Native) retention Yellow box

T628 Eucalyptus botryoides TREE RESERVE 62cm M 21m Fair Minor Low 7.4m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Weedy species Southern Mahogany STAGE 2 Fair Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Weedy species (Vic Native) (Multi_DBH (cm): 62)

T900 Eucalyptus melliodora TREE RESERVE 15cm Y 8m Fair Minor High 2m No works required High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Arborist Poor form due to over shading by other tree Yellow Box STAGE 2 Fair recommendation (Multi_DBH (cm): 15) (Vic Native)

5013 Bursaria spinosa TREE RESERVE 8cm M <5m Fair Minor High 2m No works required High ‐ O1, xx Retain Sweet Bursaria STAGE 2 Poor (Vic Native)

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records TREE RESERVE STAGE 2 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 54 of 81 TREE RESERVE STAGE 2 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

5014 Bursaria spinosa TREE RESERVE 8cm M <5m Fair Minor High 2m No works required High ‐ O1, xx Retain Sweet Bursaria STAGE 2 Poor (Vic Native)

5015 Bursaria spinosa TREE RESERVE 8cm M <5m Fair Minor High 2m No works required High ‐ O1, xx Retain Sweet Bursaria STAGE 2 Poor (Vic Native)

5016 Bursaria spinosa TREE RESERVE 8cm M <5m Fair Minor High 2m No works required High ‐ O1, xx Retain Sweet Bursaria STAGE 2 Poor (Vic Native)

5017 Bursaria spinosa TREE RESERVE 8cm M <5m Fair Minor High 2m No works required High ‐ O1, xx Retain Sweet Bursaria STAGE 2 Poor (Vic Native)

5027 Bursaria spinosa TREE RESERVE 8cm M <5m Fair Minor High 2m No works required Retain Sweet Bursaria STAGE 2 Poor (Vic Native)

5028 Bursaria spinosa TREE RESERVE 8cm M <5m Fair Minor High 2m No works required Retain Sweet Bursaria STAGE 2 Poor (Vic Native)

5032 Eucalyptus melliodora TREE RESERVE 5cm Y <5m Good Minor or none Medium 2m No works required Retain Yellow Box STAGE 2 Fair noticed (Vic Native)

5053 Eucalyptus viminalis TREE RESERVE 11cm Y 7m Good Minor or none Medium 2m No works required Retain Manna Gum STAGE 2 Good noticed (Multi_DBH (cm): 11) (Vic Native)

5057 Acacia implexa TREE RESERVE 9cm Y <5m Good Minor or none High 2m No works required Retain Lightwood STAGE 2 Fair noticed (Multi_DBH (cm): 9) (Vic Native)

ROAD RESERVE STAGE 1

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records ROAD RESERVE STAGE 1 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 55 of 81 ROAD RESERVE STAGE 1 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T137 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 17cm Y 9m Fair Minor or none High 2m No works required Remove Road reserve Yellow Box RESERVE Fair noticed construction (Vic Native) STAGE 1

T138 Eucalyptus ovata ROAD 55cm M 16m Fair Minor High 6.6m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Road reserve Weight reduce if retained, lean to southeast Swamp Gum RESERVE Fair Structural Prune (minor), construction (Vic Native) STAGE 1 Deadwood Prune

T139 Eucalyptus ovata ROAD 29cm M 18m Fair Minor or none High 3.5m No works required High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Road reserve Swamp Gum RESERVE Fair noticed construction (Vic Native) STAGE 1

T140 Acacia melanoxylon ROAD 26cm M 10m Poor Minor or none Low 3.1m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Short life expectancy Blackwood RESERVE Fair noticed Tree Removal & B2 recommendation (Vic Native) STAGE 1 , Road reserve construction

T160 Eucalyptus ovata ROAD 49cm M 13m Poor Major Low 5.9m High Priority Actions: Remove Arborist wood decay fungi, hollows may provide habitat Swamp Gum RESERVE Hazard Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure (Vic Native) STAGE 1 , Road reserve construction

T161 Eucalyptus ovata ROAD 37cm M 18m Poor Minor Medium 4.4m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Road reserve Poorly formed specimen Swamp Gum RESERVE Fair Deadwood construction (Vic Native) STAGE 1

T162 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 40cm SM 17m Fair Minor High 4.8m No works required Remove Road reserve Yellow Box RESERVE Fair construction (Vic Native) STAGE 1

T163 Eucalyptus ovata ROAD 35cm M 20m Poor Major Low 4.2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Poorly formed specimen swelling at base most Swamp Gum RESERVE Poor Tree Removal recommendation likely due to internal decay (Vic Native) STAGE 1 , Road reserve Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure construction

T164 Eucalyptus ovata ROAD 99cm OM 20m Fair Major, Tree has Low 11.9m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist wood decay fungi on east trunk wound Swamp Gum RESERVE Hazard partially collapsed Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure (Vic Native) STAGE 1 , Road reserve (Multi_DBH (cm): 77,63) construction

T165 Acacia melanoxylon ROAD 39cm OM 10m Fair Major, General Low 4.7m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Short life expectancy Blackwood RESERVE Poor decline of Tree Removal & B2 recommendation (Vic Native) STAGE 1 structure , Road reserve construction

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records ROAD RESERVE STAGE 1 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 56 of 81 ROAD RESERVE STAGE 1 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T166 Eucalyptus radiata ROAD 37cm M 8m Fair Major, Tree has Medium 4.4m Low Priority Actions: Retain Poorly formed multi‐stemmed specimen Narrow‐leaved Peppermint RESERVE Poor partially collapsed Structural Prune (minor) (Multi_DBH (cm): 23,12,20,18) (Vic Native) STAGE 1

T167 Eucalyptus ovata ROAD 30cm M 30m Poor Major Low 3.6m No works required Remove Road reserve Hollows in stem may provide habitat Swamp Gum RESERVE Poor construction (Vic Native) STAGE 1

T170 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 24cm SM 17m Fair Minor High 2.9m No works required Remove Road reserve Also small stunted tree at base Yellow Box RESERVE Fair construction (Vic Native) STAGE 1

T172 Eucalyptus ovata ROAD 36cm M 10m Poor Minor Low 4.3m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure & Swamp Gum RESERVE Poor Tree Removal recommendation poor form (Vic Native) STAGE 1 , Road reserve construction

T173 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 14cm Y 12m Good Minor or none High 2m No works required Remove Road reserve Yellow Box RESERVE Good noticed construction (Vic Native) STAGE 1

T174 Eucalyptus ovata ROAD 23cm SM 19m Poor Major, Poor stem Low 2.8m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure Swamp Gum RESERVE Poor taper Tree Removal recommendation (Vic Native) STAGE 1 , Road reserve construction

T176 Eucalyptus ovata ROAD 26cm SM 20m Fair Minor or none High 3.1m No works required High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Road reserve Swamp Gum RESERVE Fair noticed construction (Vic Native) STAGE 1

642 Eucalyptus ovata ROAD 11cm SM 13m Fair None noticed Medium 2m No works required Remove Road reserve Swamp Gum RESERVE Fair construction (Vic Native) STAGE 1

643 Exocarpos cupressiformis ROAD 36cm M 9m Poor Major, tree is Low 4.3m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure & Cherry Ballart RESERVE Poor 90% dead Tree Removal recommendation poor form (Vic Native) STAGE 1 , Road reserve (Multi_DBH (cm): 33,12,8) construction

757 Exocarpos cupressiformis ROAD 6cm M 3m Good Tree has partially High 2m No works required High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Road reserve Cherry Ballart RESERVE Fair collapsed construction (Vic Native) STAGE 1

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records ROAD RESERVE STAGE 1 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 57 of 81 ROAD RESERVE STAGE 1 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T757x Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 34cm M 21m Good Minor or none High 4.1m No works required Remove Road reserve Yellow Box RESERVE Good noticed construction (Vic Native) STAGE 1

T758 Eucalyptus ovata ROAD 43cm M 17m Poor Major, Low 5.2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Weight reduce east canopy if retained Swamp Gum RESERVE Poor Bifurcation of Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure (Vic Native) STAGE 1 stem , Road reserve construction

758 Bursaria spinosa ROAD 7cm M 5m Fair Minor High 2m No works required High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Road reserve Sweet Bursaria RESERVE Poor & B2 / construction (Vic Native) STAGE 1 Medium ‐ V2 & V3

T760 Eucalyptus viminalis ROAD 66cm M 24m Fair Minor High 7.9m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Road reserve Manna Gum RESERVE Fair Deadwood Prune construction (Vic Native) STAGE 1

760 Bursaria spinosa ROAD 11cm M 2m Fair Bifurcations of High 2m No works required High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Road reserve Sweet Bursaria RESERVE Poor stem, Minor & B2 / construction (Multi_DBH (cm): 6,6,5,4) (Vic Native) STAGE 1 Medium ‐ V2 & V3

T761 Eucalyptus viminalis ROAD 62cm M 22m Good Minor High 7.4m No works required High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Road reserve Manna Gum RESERVE Fair construction (Vic Native) STAGE 1

T762 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 27cm SM 16m Fair Minor, High 3.2m No works required Remove Road reserve Yellow Box RESERVE Fair Bifurcation of construction (Multi_DBH (cm): 22,15) (Vic Native) STAGE 1 stem

768 Eucalyptus ovata ROAD 42cm M 19m Poor Major, General Low 5m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure & Swamp Gum RESERVE Poor decline of Tree Removal recommendation poor form (Vic Native) STAGE 1 structure , Road reserve construction

T770 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 74cm M 25m Good Minor Very High 8.9m No works required Retain Yellow Box RESERVE Good (Vic Native) STAGE 1

770 Eucalyptus ovata ROAD 16cm SM 15m Fair Minor or none Medium 2m No works required Remove Road reserve Swamp Gum RESERVE Fair noticed construction (Vic Native) STAGE 1

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records ROAD RESERVE STAGE 1 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 58 of 81 ROAD RESERVE STAGE 1 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T771 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 47cm M 25m Good Minor Very High 5.6m Low Priority Actions: Retain Yellow Box RESERVE Fair Deadwood (Vic Native) STAGE 1

772 Eucalyptus ovata ROAD 10cm Y 9m Good Minor Medium 2m No works required Remove Road reserve Swamp Gum RESERVE Good construction (Vic Native) STAGE 1

T773 Eucalyptus ovata ROAD 31cm SM 13m Poor Minor Medium 3.7m No works required Remove Road reserve Poor form and health due to over shading by Swamp Gum RESERVE Fair construction other tree (Vic Native) STAGE 1

T774 Eucalyptus polyanthemos ROAD 21cm SM 14m Fair Minor High 2.5m No works required High ‐ O1, B1 Retain Red Box RESERVE Fair (Vic Native) STAGE 1

T775 Eucalyptus polyanthemos ROAD 39cm M 21m Good Minor, High 4.7m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Road reserve Bifurcation of stem (moderate) Red Box RESERVE Fair Bifurcation of Weight reduce stems with construction (Vic Native) STAGE 1 stem bifurcations

779 Acacia melanoxylon ROAD 30cm OM 12m Poor Major, Tree has Medium 3.6m No works required Remove Road reserve Blackwood RESERVE Poor partially collapsed construction (Multi_DBH (cm): 17,19,16) (Vic Native) STAGE 1

805 Eucalyptus ovata ROAD 46cm M 12m Poor Major Low 5.5m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure Swamp Gum RESERVE Poor Tree Removal recommendation (Vic Native) STAGE 1 , Road reserve construction

T1006 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 22cm SM 15m Good Minor High 2.6m No works required Remove Road reserve Yellow Box RESERVE Good construction (Vic Native) STAGE 1

T1007 Eucalyptus ovata ROAD 31cm M 13m Poor Major, General Low 3.7m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure Swamp Gum RESERVE Poor decline of Tree Removal recommendation (Vic Native) STAGE 1 structure , Road reserve construction

T1008 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 14cm Y 9m Fair None noticed High 2m No works required Remove Road reserve Form & health has improved since pine has Yellow Box RESERVE Fair construction been removed (Vic Native) STAGE 1

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records ROAD RESERVE STAGE 1 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 59 of 81 ROAD RESERVE STAGE 1 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T1009 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 23cm SM 13m Fair Minor or none High 2.8m No works required Remove Road reserve Yellow Box RESERVE Fair noticed construction (Multi_DBH (cm): 19,13) (Vic Native) STAGE 1

5041 Acacia melanoxylon ROAD 13cm M 6m Fair Minor Medium 2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Road reserve Blackwood RESERVE Poor Structural Prune (minor) construction (Vic Native) STAGE 1

5042 Eucalyptus radiata ROAD 14cm M 5m Fair Minor High 2m No works required Remove Road reserve Narrow‐leaved Peppermint RESERVE Poor construction (Vic Native) STAGE 1

5044 Eucalyptus ovata ROAD 16cm SM 10m Good Minor Medium 2m No works required Remove Road reserve Heavy lean to west Swamp Gum RESERVE Fair construction (Vic Native) STAGE 1

5045 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 28cm SM 16m Good Minor or none High 3.4m No works required Remove Road reserve Yellow Box RESERVE Good noticed construction (Vic Native) STAGE 1

5046 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 10cm Y 8m Good Minor High 2m No works required Remove Road reserve Yellow Box RESERVE Fair construction (Vic Native) STAGE 1

5047 Eucalyptus ovata ROAD 9cm Y 9m Fair Minor or none Medium 2m No works required Remove Road reserve Swamp Gum RESERVE Fair noticed construction (Vic Native) STAGE 1

5048 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 13cm SM 7m Good Minor or none High 2m No works required Remove Road reserve Yellow Box RESERVE Good noticed construction (Vic Native) STAGE 1

ROAD RESERVE STAGE 2 T204 Corymbia maculata ROAD 45cm M 25m Good Minor or none Medium 5.4m No works required Retain Spotted Gum RESERVE Good noticed (Vic Native) STAGE 2

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records ROAD RESERVE STAGE 2 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 60 of 81 ROAD RESERVE STAGE 2 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T207A Eucalyptus saligna ROAD 38cm SM 15m Fair Minor Medium 4.6m No works required Remove Road reserve Suppressed (prior to removal of large pine) Sydney Blue Gum RESERVE Fair construction (Aus Native) STAGE 2

T213 Melaleuca linariifolia ROAD 23cm M 6m Fair Bifurcations of Low 2.8m No works required Remove Road reserve Snow‐in‐Summer RESERVE Poor stem construction (Multi_DBH (cm): 13,13,14) (Aus Native) STAGE 2

T216 Eucalyptus botryoides ROAD 35cm SM 14m Fair Bifurcation of Low 4.2m No works required Remove Road reserve Weedy species Southern Mahogany RESERVE Fair stem construction (Multi_DBH (cm): 25,25) (Vic Native) STAGE 2

T217 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 18cm SM 12m Fair Bifurcations of High 2.2m No works required Retain Yellow Box RESERVE Fair stem (Vic Native) STAGE 2

T222 Eucalyptus globulus subsp. ROAD 46cm M 16m Fair Minor Medium 5.5m No works required Remove Road reserve bicostata RESERVE Fair construction Eurabbie STAGE 2 (Vic Native)

T223 Eucalyptus botryoides ROAD 36cm SM 15m Fair Major Low 4.3m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Weedy species Southern Mahogany RESERVE Poor Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure (Vic Native) STAGE 2 , Road reserve construction

T224 Eucalyptus botryoides ROAD 38cm M 17m Fair Minor or none Low 4.6m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Weedy species Southern Mahogany RESERVE Fair noticed Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Weedy species (Vic Native) STAGE 2 , Road reserve construction

T225 Eucalyptus botryoides ROAD 39cm SM 18m Fair Minor Low 4.7m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Weedy species Southern Mahogany RESERVE Fair Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Weedy species (Vic Native) STAGE 2 , Road reserve construction

T227 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 18cm SM 14m Fair Major Low 2.2m Low Priority Actions: Low ‐ B3 Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure & Yellow Box RESERVE Poor Tree Removal recommendation poor form (Vic Native) STAGE 2 , Road reserve construction

T228 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 17cm Y 12m Good Minor or none High 2m No works required Retain Yellow Box RESERVE Fair noticed (Vic Native) STAGE 2

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records ROAD RESERVE STAGE 2 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 61 of 81 ROAD RESERVE STAGE 2 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T230 Eucalyptus globulus subsp. ROAD 68cm M 17m Fair Major Low 8.2m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Bifurcation of stem (moderate) bicostata RESERVE Poor Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure & Eurabbie STAGE 2 , Road reserve poor form (Vic Native) construction

T233 Eucalyptus botryoides ROAD 35cm SM 15m Poor Minor Low 4.2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Weedy species Southern Mahogany RESERVE Fair Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Weedy species (Vic Native) STAGE 2 , Road reserve construction

T235 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 19cm SM 13m Good Minor or none Medium 2.3m No works required High ‐ O1 / Retain Yellow Box RESERVE Good noticed Medium ‐ B1 & (Vic Native) STAGE 2 B2

T236 Eucalyptus globulus subsp. ROAD 34cm SM 8m Fair Major Low 4.1m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Suspected root problems bicostata RESERVE Poor Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Very poor form, Eurabbie STAGE 2 , Road reserve weedy sp (Vic Native) construction

T237 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 16cm SM 6m Fair Minor or none Medium 2m No works required High ‐ O1 / Retain Yellow Box RESERVE Fair noticed Medium ‐ B1 & (Vic Native) STAGE 2 B2

T238 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 26cm Y 14m Fair Minor Medium 3.1m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1 / Remove Road reserve Yellow Box RESERVE Good Formative prune ‐ remove Medium ‐ B1 & construction (Vic Native) STAGE 2 bifurcated stems (tree 323) B2

T240 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 27cm SM 13m Fair Minor or none Medium 3.2m No works required High ‐ O1 / Remove Road reserve Yellow Box RESERVE Fair noticed Medium ‐ B1 & construction (Vic Native) STAGE 2 B2

264 Corymbia maculata ROAD 13cm Y 7m Fair Minor Low 2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Very poor form Spotted Gum RESERVE Fair Tree Removal recommendation (Vic Native) STAGE 2 , Road reserve construction

268 Melaleuca sp. ROAD 17cm M 6m Fair Major Low 2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure & Paperbark RESERVE Poor Tree Removal recommendation poor form (Aus Native) STAGE 2 , Road reserve (Multi_DBH (cm): 13,10,5) construction

270 Melaleuca linariifolia ROAD 15cm SM 8m Fair Minor Low 2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Inappropriate species Snow‐in‐Summer RESERVE Good Tree Removal recommendation (Aus Native) STAGE 2 , Road reserve construction

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records ROAD RESERVE STAGE 2 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 62 of 81 ROAD RESERVE STAGE 2 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

271 Corymbia maculata ROAD 6cm Y <5m Poor Minor Low 2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Inappropriate location Spotted Gum RESERVE Fair Tree Removal recommendation (Vic Native) STAGE 2 , Road reserve construction

T277 Eucalyptus ovata ROAD 67cm M 21m Fair Minor High 8m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Road reserve Swamp Gum RESERVE Fair Deadwood Prune construction (Vic Native) STAGE 2

T278 Eucalyptus macrorhyncha ROAD 69cm M 23m Fair Major Medium 8.3m High Priority Actions: Remove Road reserve Bifurcations of stem (severe) Red Stringybark RESERVE Poor Cable‐brace, Weight reduce (if construction (Vic Native) STAGE 2 retained)

T280 Eucalyptus globulus subsp. ROAD 70cm M 19m Fair Major Low 8.4m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist bifurcated trunk, wood decay fungi bicostata RESERVE Poor Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure Eurabbie STAGE 2 , Road reserve (Vic Native) construction

T282 Eucalyptus globulus subsp. ROAD 112cm M 30m Fair Major, Low 13.4m High Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure bicostata RESERVE Poor Bifurcation of Tree Removal recommendation (Multi_DBH (cm): 78,80) Eurabbie STAGE 2 stem , Road reserve (Vic Native) construction

T300 Eucalyptus botryoides ROAD 57cm SM 18m Fair Major Low 6.8m Low Priority Actions: Remove Road reserve Weedy species Southern Mahogany RESERVE Poor Deadwood Prune construction (Vic Native) STAGE 2

T301 Eucalyptus botryoides ROAD 20cm Y 14m Poor Minor Low 2.4m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Weedy species Southern Mahogany RESERVE Poor Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Weedy species (Vic Native) STAGE 2 , Road reserve construction

312 Pinus halepensis ROAD 14cm SM 9m Fair Minor Low 2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Weedy species Allepo Pine RESERVE Fair Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Weedy species (Exotic (weedy)) STAGE 2 , Road reserve construction

314 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 26cm Y 7m Good Minor Low 3.1m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Poor stem taper prone to failure Yellow Box RESERVE Fair Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Weedy species (Vic Native) STAGE 2 , Road reserve construction

430 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 8cm Y <5m Fair Minor Medium 2m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Road reserve Yellow Box RESERVE Fair Formative prune crossing limbs construction (Vic Native) STAGE 2

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records ROAD RESERVE STAGE 2 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 63 of 81 ROAD RESERVE STAGE 2 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T455 Corymbia maculata ROAD 58cm M 22m Good Minor Medium 7m Low Priority Actions: Remove Road reserve Bifurcation of stem (moderate) Spotted Gum RESERVE Poor Cable‐brace construction (Vic Native) STAGE 2

T456 Eucalyptus globulus subsp. ROAD 27cm SM 10m Fair Minor Low 3.2m No works required Remove Road reserve bicostata RESERVE Fair construction Eurabbie STAGE 2 (Vic Native)

T542 Corymbia citriodora ROAD 42cm SM 23m Good None noticed, Medium 5m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Road reserve Over extended branches prone to failure Lemon‐scented Gum RESERVE Fair Minor Prune to reduce weight of heavy construction (Aus Native) STAGE 2 and/or long limbs

T543 Eucalyptus kitsoniana ROAD 16cm M <5m Poor Major, Tree has Low 2m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Arborist could be coppiced if retention is required Gippsland Mallee RESERVE Poor completely Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure & (Vic Native) STAGE 2 collapsed , Road reserve poor form construction

T557 Corymbia maculata ROAD 28cm SM 17m Good Minor Medium 3.4m No works required Remove Road reserve Bifurcation of stem (moderate) Spotted Gum RESERVE Fair construction (Vic Native) STAGE 2

T558 Eucalyptus globulus subsp. ROAD 40cm M 15m Poor Minor Low 4.8m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Suppressed form bicostata RESERVE Fair Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Very poor form Eurabbie STAGE 2 , Road reserve (Vic Native) construction

T575 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 13cm Y 11m Fair Minor or none High 2m No works required Remove Road reserve Yellow Box RESERVE Good noticed construction (Vic Native) STAGE 2

T577 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 27cm SM 14m Fair Minor or none High 3.2m No works required Remove Road reserve Yellow Box RESERVE Good noticed construction (Vic Native) STAGE 2

T578 Corymbia maculata ROAD 40cm M 18m Good Minor or none Medium 4.8m No works required Remove Road reserve Spotted Gum RESERVE Good noticed construction (Vic Native) STAGE 2

T579 Corymbia maculata ROAD 45cm M 22m Good None noticed Medium 5.4m No works required Remove Road reserve Spotted Gum RESERVE Good construction (Vic Native) STAGE 2

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records ROAD RESERVE STAGE 2 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 64 of 81 ROAD RESERVE STAGE 2 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T580 Eucalyptus saligna ROAD 36cm SM 17m Fair Minor or none Medium 4.3m No works required Remove Road reserve Sydney Blue Gum RESERVE Fair noticed construction (Aus Native) STAGE 2

T585 Eucalyptus sideroxylon ROAD 58cm M 14m Fair Major Low 7m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Recent major limb failures (2014), further Red Ironbark RESERVE Poor Tree Removal recommendation failures likely due to form and increased (Vic Native) STAGE 2 , Road reserve exposure of remaining canopy construction Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure

T586 Corymbia maculata ROAD 18cm SM 8m Poor Minor Low 2.2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Defective structure & Spotted Gum RESERVE Poor Tree Removal recommendation poor form (Vic Native) STAGE 2 , Road reserve construction

T588 Allocasuarina torulosa ROAD 24cm M 9m Fair Bifurcation of Medium 2.9m Low Priority Actions: Remove Road reserve Forest Oak RESERVE Poor stem Formative Prune(Low) construction (Aus Native) STAGE 2

T591 Cupressus macrocarpa ROAD 150cm M 25m Good Minor High 15m Medium Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Road reserve Tree would need to be in reserved space too at Monterey Cypress RESERVE Fair Prune to reduce weight of heavy & B2 construction least 1m beyond canopy edge if retained, (Exotic) STAGE 2 and/or large limbs, Deadwood, Further ID required Remove broken branches

T592 Cupressus lusitanica ROAD 46cm M 19m Fair Minor High 5.5m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Road reserve Mexican Cypress RESERVE Fair Deadwood Prune construction (Exotic) STAGE 2

T593 Cupressus lusitanica ROAD 60cm M 16m Fair Minor High 7.2m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Road reserve Bifurcation of stem (moderate) Mexican Cypress RESERVE Poor Deadwood Prune construction (Multi_DBH (cm): 53,29) (Exotic) STAGE 2

T593A Eucalyptus goniocalyx ROAD 20cm Y 9m Fair Minor Medium 2.4m No works required Remove Road reserve Long‐leaved Box RESERVE Fair construction (Vic Native) STAGE 2

T597A Eucalyptus goniocalyx ROAD 36cm M 13m Good Major Low 4.3m Low Priority Actions: Remove Road reserve Long‐leaved Box RESERVE Poor Structural Prune (minor) construction (Vic Native) STAGE 2

T599 Eucalyptus globulus subsp. ROAD 129cm M 24m Fair Major Low 15m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Wood decay fungi in trunk bicostata RESERVE Poor Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure Eurabbie STAGE 2 , Road reserve (Vic Native) construction

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records ROAD RESERVE STAGE 2 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 65 of 81 ROAD RESERVE STAGE 2 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T600 Eucalyptus leucoxylon ROAD 35cm M 8m Fair Minor Medium 4.2m No works required Low ‐ B3 Inconsistent with Remove Road reserve Yellow Gum RESERVE Poor Landscape vision construction (Multi_DBH (cm): 29,20) (Vic Native) STAGE 2

602 Eucalyptus goniocalyx ROAD 7cm Y 6m Fair None noticed High 2m No works required Retain Long‐leaved Box RESERVE Fair (Vic Native) STAGE 2

T602 Eucalyptus sideroxylon ROAD 23cm SM 11m Fair Minor or none Medium 2.8m Low Priority Actions: Remove Road reserve Red Ironbark RESERVE Fair noticed Structural Prune (minor) construction (Vic Native) STAGE 2

T720 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 25cm SM 14m Fair Minor or none High 3m No works required Retain Yellow Box RESERVE Good noticed (Vic Native) STAGE 2

T721 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 21cm SM 14m Fair Minor or none High 2.5m No works required Retain Yellow Box RESERVE Good noticed (Vic Native) STAGE 2

T722 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 20cm SM 14m Fair Minor or none High 2.4m No works required Remove Road reserve Yellow Box RESERVE Fair noticed construction (Vic Native) STAGE 2

T723A Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 27cm SM 15m Fair Minor or none High 3.2m No works required Retain Yellow Box RESERVE Fair noticed (Vic Native) STAGE 2

T723 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 15cm SM 9m Fair Minor or none High 2m No works required Remove Road reserve Yellow Box RESERVE Fair noticed construction (Vic Native) STAGE 2

T724 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 34cm SM 16m Fair Minor or none High 4.1m No works required Remove Road reserve Yellow Box RESERVE Fair noticed construction (Vic Native) STAGE 2

T725 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 12cm SM 7m Fair Minor or none High 2m No works required High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Road reserve Yellow Box RESERVE Fair noticed construction (Vic Native) STAGE 2

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records ROAD RESERVE STAGE 2 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 66 of 81 ROAD RESERVE STAGE 2 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T726 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 14cm SM 11m Fair Minor or none High 2m No works required Retain Yellow Box RESERVE Fair noticed (Vic Native) STAGE 2

T727 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 29cm SM 14m Fair Minor or none High 3.5m No works required Retain Yellow Box RESERVE Fair noticed (Vic Native) STAGE 2

T728 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 18cm SM 15m Fair Minor High 2.2m Low Priority Actions: Retain Yellow Box RESERVE Fair Structural Prune (minor) (Multi_DBH (cm): 18) (Vic Native) STAGE 2

T740 Eucalyptus goniocalyx ROAD 22cm SM 8m Fair Bifurcations of Medium 2.6m No works required Remove Road reserve Long‐leaved Box RESERVE Poor stem construction (Vic Native) STAGE 2

T741 Eucalyptus goniocalyx ROAD 18cm Y 8m Good Minor Medium 2.2m No works required Remove Road reserve Long‐leaved Box RESERVE Poor construction (Vic Native) STAGE 2

T904 Eucalyptus goniocalyx ROAD 12cm SM 8m Fair Minor or none Medium 2m No works required Remove Road reserve Long‐leaved Box RESERVE Fair noticed construction (Vic Native) STAGE 2

T905 Eucalyptus goniocalyx ROAD 26cm SM 7m Good Bifurcations of Medium 3.1m Low Priority Actions: Remove Road reserve Long‐leaved Box RESERVE Poor stem Structural Prune (minor) construction (Multi_DBH (cm): 20,12,11) (Vic Native) STAGE 2

T907 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 11cm Y 8m Fair Minor Medium 2m No works required Remove Road reserve Yellow Box RESERVE Fair construction (Vic Native) STAGE 2

T921 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 14cm SM 10m Fair Minor or none High 2m No works required Retain Yellow Box RESERVE Fair noticed (Vic Native) STAGE 2

T922 Eucalyptus botryoides ROAD 12cm Y 10m Fair Minor or none Low 2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Weedy species Southern Mahogany RESERVE Fair noticed Tree Removal recommendation Reasons for tree removal: Weedy species (Vic Native) STAGE 2 , Road reserve construction

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records ROAD RESERVE STAGE 2 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 67 of 81 ROAD RESERVE STAGE 2 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T925 Callistemon salignus ROAD 10cm SM <5m Poor None noticed Low 2m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Short life expectancy Willow Bottlebrush RESERVE Good Tree Removal & B2 / recommendation (Aus Native) STAGE 2 Medium ‐ V2 & , Road reserve V3 construction

1596 Eucalyptus globulus subsp. ROAD 11cm Y 8m Good Minor or none Low 2m No works required Remove Road reserve bicostata RESERVE Good noticed construction Eurabbie STAGE 2 (Vic Native)

5003 Eucalyptus sp. ROAD 13cm Y 7m Good Bifurcation of Medium 2m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, xx Remove Road reserve Possibly Eucalyptus goniocalyx Eucalypt RESERVE Fair stem Structural Prune (minor) construction (Multi_DBH (cm): 11,7) (Vic Native) STAGE 2

5004 Eucalyptus sp. ROAD 10cm Y <5m Fair Minor or none Medium 2m No works required High ‐ O1, xx Remove Road reserve Possibly Eucalyptus goniocalyx Eucalypt RESERVE Good noticed construction (Vic Native) STAGE 2

5005 Eucalyptus globulus subsp. ROAD 7cm Y 6m Good Minor or none Low 2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Inappropriate species bicostata RESERVE Fair noticed Tree Removal recommendation Eurabbie STAGE 2 , Road reserve (Vic Native) construction

5010 Bursaria spinosa ROAD 9cm M <5m Fair Minor or none High 2m No works required High ‐ O1, xx Remove Road reserve Sweet Bursaria RESERVE Fair noticed construction (Multi_DBH (cm): 4,5,4,5) (Vic Native) STAGE 2

5011 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 4cm Y <5m Fair Minor or none High 2m No works required High ‐ O1, xx Remove Road reserve Yellow Box RESERVE Good noticed construction (Vic Native) STAGE 2

5012 Acacia dealbata ROAD 7cm Y <5m Good Minor or none Medium 2m No works required High ‐ O1, xx Remove Road reserve Silver Wattle RESERVE Fair noticed construction (Vic Native) STAGE 2

6077 Melaleuca linariifolia ROAD 24cm M 7m Poor Minor Low 2.9m Low Priority Actions: Remove Arborist Reason for tree removal: Decline of landscape Snow‐in‐Summer RESERVE Fair Tree Removal recommendation val (Aus Native) STAGE 2 , Road reserve construction

ROAD RESERVE STAGE 3

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records ROAD RESERVE STAGE 3 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 68 of 81 ROAD RESERVE STAGE 3 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

5052 Eucalyptus melliodora ROAD 8cm Y 30m Good Minor Medium 2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Road reserve Yellow Box RESERVE Fair Structural Prune (minor) construction (Vic Native) STAGE 3

WETLAND STAGE 2 T358 Eucalyptus camaldulensis WETLAND 45cm M 16m Fair Minor or none Medium 5.4m No works required Remove Wetland River Red Gum STAGE 2 Fair noticed construction (Vic Native)

T360 Eucalyptus camaldulensis WETLAND 46cm M 16m Poor Major, Tree has Low 5.5m Low Priority Actions: High ‐ O1, B1 Remove Wetland Reason for tree removal: Defective structure & River Red Gum STAGE 2 Poor partially collapsed Tree Removal construction poor form (Vic Native)

T365 Eucalyptus globulus subsp. WETLAND 62cm M 26m Poor Minor ~ possible Low 7.4m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Wetland Declining health ‐possible Armillaria infection bicostata STAGE 2 Poor internal decay Tree Removal construction (see photo) Eurabbie Reasons for tree removal: Short life expectancy (Vic Native)

T368 Eucalyptus robusta WETLAND 26cm SM 14m Poor Minor or none Low 3.1m No works required Remove Wetland Swamp Mahogany STAGE 2 Fair noticed construction (Aus Native)

T369 Eucalyptus globulus subsp. WETLAND 53cm M 21m Fair Minor Medium 6.4m No works required Remove Wetland Weedy species bicostata STAGE 2 Poor construction Eurabbie (Vic Native)

T370 Eucalyptus globulus subsp. WETLAND 53cm M 25m Fair Major (?) Low 6.4m Low Priority Actions: Remove Wetland Possible fungal fruiting bodies on main stem at bicostata STAGE 2 Poor Tree Removal construction 7m west side ‐ further investigation if retention Eurabbie required (Vic Native) Reasons for tree removal: Weedy species, poor stru

T371 Eucalyptus camaldulensis WETLAND 17cm SM 13m Poor Minor Low 2m No works required Remove Wetland River Red Gum STAGE 2 Fair construction (Vic Native)

T374 Eucalyptus botryoides WETLAND 39cm M 18m Fair Minor or none Low 4.7m No works required Remove Wetland Poor stem to height ratio‐ not ideal to retain if Southern Mahogany STAGE 2 Fair noticed construction other larger trees are cleared (Vic Native)

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records WETLAND STAGE 2 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 69 of 81 WETLAND STAGE 2 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T375 Eucalyptus camaldulensis WETLAND 29cm SM 14m Fair Medium 3.5m No works required Remove Wetland River Red Gum STAGE 2 Fair construction (Vic Native)

T376 Eucalyptus camaldulensis WETLAND 17cm Y 10m Poor Minor Low 2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Wetland Reason for tree removal: Defective structure & River Red Gum STAGE 2 Poor Tree Removal construction poor form (Vic Native)

T377 Eucalyptus globulus subsp. WETLAND 39cm M 24m Fair Minor or none Low 4.7m No works required Remove Wetland globulus STAGE 2 Fair noticed construction Tasmanian Blue Gum (Vic Native)

T379 Eucalyptus botryoides WETLAND 25cm SM <5m Dead Major, Tree has Low 3m Low Priority Actions: Remove Wetland Reason for tree removal: Dead Southern Mahogany STAGE 2 Poor completely Tree Removal construction (Vic Native) collapsed

T380 Eucalyptus botryoides WETLAND 40cm M 23m Fair Minor or none Low 4.8m Low Priority Actions: Remove Wetland Reason for tree removal: Weedy species Southern Mahogany STAGE 2 Fair noticed Tree Removal construction (Vic Native)

T381 Eucalyptus elata WETLAND 23cm SM 10m Poor Low 2.8m Low Priority Actions: Remove Wetland Reason for tree removal: Poor aesthetic quality River Peppermint STAGE 2 Poor Tree Removal construction (Vic Native)

T382 Eucalyptus globulus subsp. WETLAND 96cm M 38m Good Major, Low 11.5m High Priority Actions: Remove Wetland North stem is bifurcated with defects and is globulus STAGE 2 Poor Bifurcation of Tree Removal construction likely to fail and reach road to north Tasmanian Blue Gum stem, fungal Reasons for tree removal: Failure likely (Vic Native) decay

T383 Eucalyptus globulus subsp. WETLAND 63cm M 24m Fair Major Low 7.6m Low Priority Actions: Remove Wetland Fungal fruiting body on sooth side @ 4m globulus STAGE 2 Poor Tree Removal construction Reasons for tree removal: Failure likely Tasmanian Blue Gum (Vic Native)

T384 Eucalyptus globulus subsp. WETLAND 83cm M 30m Fair Major Low 10m Low Priority Actions: Remove Wetland Fungal fruiting bodies @ 6m on north side globulus STAGE 2 Poor Tree Removal construction Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure Tasmanian Blue Gum (Vic Native)

T385 Eucalyptus globulus subsp. WETLAND 60cm SM 25m Fair Bifurcation of Medium 7.2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Wetland Weedg species prone to wood decay fungi globulus STAGE 2 Fair stem (no defect Structural Prune (minor) construction Tasmanian Blue Gum noticed) (Vic Native)

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records WETLAND STAGE 2 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 70 of 81 WETLAND STAGE 2 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T387 Eucalyptus robusta WETLAND 24cm SM 14m Fair Low 2.9m Low Priority Actions: Remove Wetland Likely to be weedy similar to E. botryoides Swamp Mahogany STAGE 2 Fair Tree Removal construction Reasons for tree removal: Weedy species (Vic Native)

T388 Eucalyptus globulus subsp. WETLAND 101cm M 26m Fair Bifurcation of Low 12.1m High Priority Actions: Remove Wetland Decay fungal fruiting bodies on northeast side globulus STAGE 2 Poor stem, Major Tree Removal construction Reasons for tree removal: High risk structure Tasmanian Blue Gum (decay) (Vic Native)

T389 Eucalyptus botryoides WETLAND 41cm M 24m Fair Minor Low 4.9m Low Priority Actions: Remove Wetland Weedy species Southern Mahogany STAGE 2 Fair Tree Removal construction Reasons for tree removal: Weedy species (Vic Native)

T390 Eucalyptus botryoides WETLAND 55cm M 24m Fair Major Low 6.6m Low Priority Actions: Remove Wetland Progressive root plate failure Southern Mahogany STAGE 2 Fair Tree Removal construction Reasons for tree removal: High risk structure (Vic Native)

T391 Eucalyptus elata WETLAND 62cm M 15m Poor Bifurcations of Low 7.4m Low Priority Actions: Remove Wetland Defective root system River Peppermint STAGE 2 Poor stem Tree Removal construction Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure (Vic Native) (Multi_DBH (cm): 34,21,47)

T392 Eucalyptus elata WETLAND 30cm SM 11m Poor Major Low 3.6m Low Priority Actions: Remove Wetland Reason for tree removal: Poor health & River Peppermint STAGE 2 Poor Tree Removal construction structure (Vic Native)

T393 Eucalyptus camaldulensis WETLAND 22cm SM 12m Poor Minor Low 2.6m Low Priority Actions: Remove Wetland Reason for tree removal: Poor health & River Red Gum STAGE 2 Poor Tree Removal construction structure (Vic Native)

T394 Eucalyptus elata WETLAND 60cm M 20m Poor Low 7.2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Wetland Reason for tree removal: Short life expectancy River Peppermint STAGE 2 Poor Tree Removal construction (Multi_DBH (cm): 33,50) (Vic Native)

T395 Eucalyptus elata WETLAND 86cm M 27m Fair Major Medium 10.3m No works required Remove Wetland Large wounds & hollows ‐ remove if area is River Peppermint STAGE 2 Poor construction going to be high occupancy (Vic Native)

T396 Eucalyptus camaldulensis WETLAND 30cm SM 15m Fair Minor Medium 3.6m No works required Remove Wetland Poor stem to height ratio‐ not ideal to retain if River Red Gum STAGE 2 Fair construction other larger trees are cleared (Vic Native)

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records WETLAND STAGE 2 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 71 of 81 WETLAND STAGE 2 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T397 Eucalyptus botryoides WETLAND 45cm M 18m Fair Major Low 5.4m Low Priority Actions: Remove Wetland Reason for tree removal: Weedy species Southern Mahogany STAGE 2 Poor Tree Removal construction (Vic Native)

T398 Eucalyptus camaldulensis WETLAND 19cm SM 8m Fair Major Low 2.3m Low Priority Actions: Remove Wetland Reason for tree removal: Defective structure & River Red Gum STAGE 2 Poor Tree Removal construction poor form (Vic Native)

T399 Eucalyptus camaldulensis WETLAND 23cm SM 18m Fair Minor Medium 2.8m No works required Remove Wetland Poor stem to height ratio River Red Gum STAGE 2 Fair construction (Vic Native)

T400 Eucalyptus botryoides WETLAND 43cm SM 22m Fair Major Low 5.2m Low Priority Actions: Remove Wetland fungal fruiting bodies in south east side of stem Southern Mahogany STAGE 2 Poor Tree Removal construction Reasons for tree removal: Poor structure, (Vic Native) Weedy sp

T401 Eucalyptus botryoides WETLAND 48cm M 24m Good Major Low 5.8m Low Priority Actions: Remove Wetland Signs of internal cracking and decay Southern Mahogany STAGE 2 Poor Tree Removal construction Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure, (Vic Native) wee

T402 Eucalyptus camaldulensis WETLAND 57cm M 17m Fair Minor or none Medium 6.8m Low Priority Actions: Remove Wetland River Red Gum STAGE 2 Fair noticed Deadwood Prune construction (Vic Native)

T403 Eucalyptus viminalis WETLAND 25cm SM 15m Fair Minor or none Medium 3m No works required Remove Wetland Manna Gum STAGE 2 Fair noticed construction (Vic Native)

T404 Eucalyptus ovata WETLAND 16cm SM 13m Fair Minor or none Medium 2m No works required Remove Wetland Swamp Gum STAGE 2 Fair noticed construction (Vic Native)

T405 Eucalyptus ovata WETLAND 10cm SM 18m Fair Major Low 2m No works required Remove Wetland Poor stem to height ratio increases likelihood of Swamp Gum STAGE 2 Fair construction failure in strong weather conditions ‐ review if (Vic Native) surrounding trees are removed and exposure increased Reasons for tree removal: Defective structure

T406 Eucalyptus viminalis WETLAND 30cm SM 12m Poor Major, Tree has Low 3.6m Low Priority Actions: Remove Wetland Reason for tree removal: Defective structure & Manna Gum STAGE 2 Poor partially collapsed Tree Removal construction poor form (Vic Native)

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records WETLAND STAGE 2 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 72 of 81 WETLAND STAGE 2 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

T407 Eucalyptus viminalis WETLAND 40cm SM 22m Poor Minor Medium 4.8m Low Priority Actions: Remove Wetland Fungi appearing at base in Autumn are most Manna Gum STAGE 2 Fair Remove smaller stems at base construction likely Gymnopilus junonius which is not parasitic (Vic Native) or pathogenic

T408 Eucalyptus viminalis WETLAND 37cm SM 18m Fair Major Medium 4.4m Low Priority Actions: Remove Wetland Poor stem to height ratio‐ not ideal to retain if Manna Gum STAGE 2 Poor Tree Removal construction other larger trees are cleared, signs of internal (Vic Native) decay Reasons for tree removal: Poor structure

T409 Eucalyptus viminalis WETLAND 15cm SM 15m Fair Major Low 2m No works required Remove Wetland Tree appears to have root defects,Poor stem to Manna Gum STAGE 2 Poor construction height ratio increases likelihood of failure in (Vic Native) strong weather conditions ‐ review if surrounding trees are removed and exposure increased

690 Eucalyptus viminalis WETLAND 16cm Y 12m Fair Minor or none Medium 2m No works required Remove Wetland Manna Gum STAGE 2 Good noticed construction (Vic Native)

691 Eucalyptus viminalis WETLAND 21cm Y 11m Fair Minor or none Medium 2.5m No works required Remove Wetland Manna Gum STAGE 2 Fair noticed construction (Vic Native)

695 Eucalyptus viminalis WETLAND 14cm Y 14m Poor Medium 2m No works required Remove Wetland Manna Gum STAGE 2 Fair construction (Vic Native)

1448 Eucalyptus globulus subsp. WETLAND 32cm SM 19m Dead Low 3m Medium Priority Actions: Remove Wetland No habitat hollows noticed globulus STAGE 2 Poor Tree Removal construction Reasons for tree removal: Dead Tasmanian Blue Gum (Vic Native)

1449 Eucalyptus botryoides WETLAND 24cm SM 11m Dead Low 2.9m Low Priority Actions: Remove Wetland Reason for tree removal: Dead Southern Mahogany STAGE 2 Poor Tree Removal construction (Vic Native)

1456 Eucalyptus melliodora WETLAND 14cm SM 11m Good Minor Medium 2m No works required Remove Wetland Stump regrowth but appears stable Yellow Box STAGE 2 Fair construction (Vic Native)

1462 Salix babylonica WETLAND 64cm OM 13m Poor Low 7.7m Low Priority Actions: Remove Wetland Reason for tree removal: Weed species Weeping Willow STAGE 2 Poor Tree Removal construction (Weed (Exotic))

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records WETLAND STAGE 2 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 73 of 81 WETLAND STAGE 2 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

1475 Eucalyptus botryoides WETLAND 35cm M 17m Dead General decline Low 3m Low Priority Actions: Remove Wetland Reason for tree removal: Failure likely Southern Mahogany STAGE 2 Poor of structure Tree Removal construction (Vic Native)

WETLAND STAGE 1 T36 Eucalyptus melliodora WETLAND 21cm SM 12m Fair Bifurcation of Medium 2.5m No works required Remove Wetland Yellow Box STAGE 1 Poor stem construction (Multi_DBH (cm): 15,15) (Vic Native)

T41 Eucalyptus melliodora WETLAND 24cm SM 9m Fair Bifurcation of Medium 2.9m Low Priority Actions: Remove Wetland Yellow Box STAGE 1 Poor stem Deadwood Prune construction (Multi_DBH (cm): 14,14,13) (Vic Native)

T42 Eucalyptus melliodora WETLAND 21cm Y 12m Fair Minor or none Medium 2.5m No works required Remove Wetland Yellow Box STAGE 1 Fair noticed construction (Vic Native)

T43 Eucalyptus melliodora WETLAND 23cm SM 13m Fair Minor or none High 2.8m No works required Remove Wetland Yellow Box STAGE 1 Fair noticed construction (Vic Native)

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records WETLAND STAGE 1 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 74 of 81 WETLAND STAGE 1 ID # SPECIES Area DBH* AGE HEIGHT HEALTH/ DEFECTS RETENTION TPZ*** ACTIONS / PRIORITY BUILT LANDSCAPE RETENTION REMOVAL COMMENTS (Arborist) COMMON NAME (stems) CLASS* STRUCT VALUE (Arborist) FORM VISION DECISION JUSTIFICATION (Origin) CLASS IMPACTS APPRAISAL

Built Form Categories (from Attachment 2 Schedule to Built Form Analysis)

B :: Buildability

Issues of Buildability include:‐ Item B1 ‐ Once excised around the tree, resultant building envelope is spatially impacted:‐ Quality of building envelope impacted which detrimentally affects quality of built form (eg. spatially not left with reasonable envelope in proportion) Severely impacts buildability (eg. spatially not left with reasonable envelope in size or orientation ‐ particularly when read in relation to density or adjacency of other trees. Item B2 ‐ Unable to comply with design guidelines (eg. tree location pushes construction into a flood zone or the steepest part of the site so the cut fill criteria maybe contravened) Item B3 ‐ Minor impact on building envelope. Potentially design around the tree/s. Item B4 ‐ Outside building envelope.

V :: Vehicular access

Issues of Vehicular access include:‐ Item V1 ‐ To avoid trees, vehicular route within the site would be unreasonably circuitous. Item V2 ‐ Driveway route likely to detrimentally encroach upon tree protection zone (TPZ). Item V3 ‐ Tree obstructs access to site /or building (eg. proposed crossover clashes with tree locaons) Item V4 ‐ Tree potentially affected by public realm causeway construction (eg. TPZ impinged by construction equipment or cutback, so may not survive in perpetuity).

O :: Other

Issues that are Site Specific include:‐ Item O1 ‐ Combination issue. The tree may not be detrimental in its own right, but the combination of issues imposed by multiple trees throughout the site, makes removal of majority of trees on this site imperative for reasons of buildability and vehicular access. Item O2 ‐ Low combination issue. As above but could be easily remedied by removal of a few strategic trees only.

Arboriculture Pty Ltd Appendix 2 Tree Inspection Records WETLAND STAGE 1 trees, Mullum Creek Estate Page 75 of 81

Appendix 3 Definitions and Methods

Tree Number A number referencing a tree location record to the tree location plans. Species Botanical Name (field identified) Common Common name for species (Horticultural Flora of South-Eastern Name Australia (R. Spencer, volumes 1-5, 1995-2005) are referenced wherever possible) Age (class) This field describes the stage of maturity of the tree or dominant specimens in a tree group as indicated by its form. Young Seedling or sapling stage

Semi-mature Approaching its expected form and size

Mature Expected ultimate form and size of tree before decline Over-mature Mature tree exhibiting signs of age related structural decline Occasionally stunted or atypical specimens were found that, despite being old in years, appeared semi-mature.

Young Semi- Mature Over-mature mature

Health Health of a tree as determined by factors such as leaf colour and size, shoot growth extension and percentage of living canopy: Dead < 10% of canopy living (shoots & stems dead) Poor Determined by any single or combination of factors above. Tree health is declining or has declined usually due to pest, disease, senescence, unsuitable site conditions or physiological damage such as root severance or root death due to soil cut, fill or compaction. Fair Tree is in ‘normal’ health. Some pests, diseases, deadwood, minor crown dieback may be present but not considered to be severely affecting the tree’s health. Good Tree is largely unaffected by pests, diseases and has no significant deadwood or crown dieback.

Arboriculture Mullum Creek Tree Retention/Removal - Private Realms & Wetlands Page 76 of 81

Structure Determined by both the existence of defects in the tree’s structure. Hazard Tree structures that are highly likely to fail in the near future causing a hazard threat to people or property in its vicinity. Poor Trees with structural defects such as bifurcated trunks, significant wounds or cavities, noticeable girdling roots. Poor tree structures are common and not necessarily a cause for concern. Remedy with pruning or cable bracing may be an option. Fair Indicates trees with some minor structural defects. Good Trees with few if any significant form or structural defects

DBH Trunk diameter measured at breast height (1.4m above ground). If the trunk divides into branches or stems at or below 1.4 metres then an equivalent single stem diameter is calculated from the DBH measurements of the individual stems using the formula: 2 2 2 Total DBH (DBH1) (DBH 2) (DBH 3)

If a buttress or deformity exists at 1.4m then the DBH is measured immediately above this point. See Australian Standard AS 4970, Protection of Trees on Development Sites, Appendix A for details of procedure used. DBH measurement is useful for categorising the size of trees for analysis and is also used in calculations: e.g. calculating the nominal TPZ. Actions List of recommended works. Works are specified as required to mitigate (works) hazard or improve the landscape life expectancy of the tree. Where possible, terms specified in Australian Standard AS 4373-2007 Pruning of Amenity Trees are used.

Priority Action Priorities were categorised as Low, Medium, High or Urgent. (action) Low work priorities are those that are not concerned with conditions that affect the immediate health and safety of trees (or people and property) and/or trees that are not considered valuable enough to warrant immediate attention. These works are mostly removal of small branches lodged in the tree crown or removal of branch stubs. It is recommended that these works be carried out optionally and when convenient over the next 24 months. Tree work priorities may be increased to Medium on subsequent inspections if required.

Medium work priorities are specified if the work will improve the tree’s health, safety and/or aesthetics or the safety of the area (people or property) if carried out in the short term. These works are often specified for trees with larger broken lodged branches and occupying a high profile position or frequently used area within the landscape. Tree removals in this category are those that do not pose high-risk danger to persons or property. It is recommended that these works be carried out within the next 12 months.

High work priorities are specified where a tree condition poses a potential safety hazard to people or property or the tree and works are considered significant enough to warrant immediate attention. Trees requiring high priority work will include those with large broken lodged branches, flawed or damaged structures (crown, trunk or roots) that are likely to lead to failure causing property damage, injury or death. Works in this classification should be carried out within 3 to 6 months or sooner if

Arboriculture Mullum Creek Tree Retention/Removal - Private Realms & Wetlands Page 77 of 81

budgets and convenience allow. Urgent work priorities are usually specified where a tree condition causes an imminent safety hazard to people or property. Works in this classification should be carried out as soon as possible. Retention All trees surveyed were assigned a ‘retention value’. Retention value Value can aid in decision making regarding cost vs. benefit as well as prioritisation or resources and planning. Factors contributing to retention value include: tree origin; age; significance; habitat value (hollows being used by fauna, etc); species suitability to the urban residential/naturalistic parkland s i t u a t i o n , a n d condition (health and structure). Self-sown, remnant indigenous and planted indigenous trees of known local seed source were generally rated higher than trees from non- indigenous or unknown seed sources. Trees considered as being in a potentially dangerous condition rated lowest regardless of their significance or origins. Other tree species that rated low were weedy species, tree species regarded as being inappropriate to the urban residential situation and specimens with low life expectancy. No Retention Value trees are those that would usually be best removed if landscape renovation or development were to take place in their vicinity. Trees should be removed if recommended specifically or if they are dead or have poor structure/health. Low Retention trees should have low priority compared to development considerations. Trees considered to have low retention value should be eventually removed or replaced whether or not development goes ahead. Medium Retention trees could be retained if desired but could be removed to allow for development at the discretion of the developer or planner. They are trees that are considered to be appropriate to their planting situation but not necessarily of high cultural, historical or landscape value. They range from young specimens with fair to good health with no significant structural defects, to mature trees in fair to good health with defects that may be managed by arboricultural or landscape planning techniques. Trees may contribute to the immediate landscape but would not contribute greatly to the wider landscape. High Retention trees are those assessed as being of significant environmental, cultural or other significance and in suitable condition to be safely retained (remedial arboricultural works or landscape planning may be required for their retention). These trees should be preserved wherever possible and may justify some alterations of design.

Very High Retention trees are similar to High Retention trees but are considered to be remnant indigenous specimens or trees with other significance that may be of or eligible for State or National recognition. These trees should be preserved wherever possible and would usually justify alterations of development design to allow for their preservation.

Arboriculture Mullum Creek Tree Retention/Removal - Private Realms & Wetlands Page 78 of 81

Risk Evaluation of risk using recognised published method. In this case the Bartlett Method’ (Smiley, E. T., Fraedrich, B. R., Hendrickson, N. (2002) Tree Risk Management, Charlotte NC, Bartlett Tree Research Laboratories) Each tree receives a score out of 15 as the result of multiple site and tree factors assessed. Risk Rating Method The method is basic and capable of being used in large scale tree data capture situations. The arborist makes an estimate of tree failure potential and the consequences of failure including the frequency of occupation of a site based on their experience. Limitations are that the method is not based on quantitative data and is very simple – as such it should be used as a guide only. Total Risk Score is derived by the addition of 2 criteria: Failure Potential/Defect Severity (F) Score Critical Risk – Failure imminent 10 High Risk – Failure likely especially in storms 7 Moderate Risk – Failure possible especially in severe storms 4 Low Risk – Failure unlikely 1 Consequence of Failure (C) Considers potential for injury/loss should a failure occur based on such factors as size of defective part, target value and frequency of use Severe Consequence 5 Moderate Consequence 3 Low Consequence 1 Total Risk Rating (= F + C) 13-15 Critical Risk: Failure imminent; Personal Injury and/or property damage inevitable (lower end of scale indicates lower potential for injury) 10-12 High Risk: Failure likely especially during storms; Personal injury and/or property damage likely (lower end of scale indicates lower potential for injury/property damage) 7-9 Moderate Risk: Failure unlikely, and/or high risk of failure but low risk of property damage/personal injury <7 Low Risk: Failure unlikely and low risk of property damage

SRZ The structural root zone (SRZ) is the area around the base of a tree required for its stability in the ground. The woody root growth and soil cohesion in this area are necessary to hold the tree upright. The SRZ is nominally circular with the trunk at its centre and is expressed by its radius in metres. This zone considers a tree’s structural stability only, not the root zone required for a tree’s vigour and long-term viability, which will usually be a much larger area (AS 4970, Protection of trees on development sites). An indicative SRZ radius can be determined from the trunk diameter measured immediately above the root buttress (DAB or diameter above buttress) according to AS 4970, Protection of trees on development sites.

Arboriculture Mullum Creek Tree Retention/Removal - Private Realms & Wetlands Page 79 of 81

TPZ The tree protection zone (TPZ) is a specified area above and below ground and at a given distance from the trunk set aside for the protection of a tree’s roots and crown to provide for the viability and stability of a tree to be retained where it is potentially subject to damage by development (AS 4970, Protection of trees on development sites). The nominal TPZ is calculated from the DBH according to AS 4970, Protection of trees on development sites.

Comments General comments regarding individual trees or conditions.

Visual Inspection Visual tree inspection is part of a process of assessing trees for conditions that may affect safety. An inspection is made of a tree for signs or symptoms of defects. Only when indications of defects are found which are considered serious enough, is further investigation recommended or undertaken. Further investigation may be a closer visual examination (such as accessing the tree canopy via climbing techniques or by way of an Elevated Platform Vehicle) or a rigorous, detailed technical examination using mechanical or electronic instruments (eg. sound or stress-wave timer device or devices that measure the force needed to drill test holes into the tree). Visual Tree Assessment (VTA) is a method described by biomechanical engineer Dr Claus Mattheck in his book The Body Language of Trees (Mattheck & Breloer 1994). It involves visual inspection of the tree and provides guidelines for identifying symptoms of stress in trees caused by defects. It is based on the Axiom of uniform stress in which trees grow in such a way that all stresses on their surfaces are distributed evenly (Mattheck & Breloer 1994). Where this state is disturbed the tree repairs its structure by forming locally thicker annual rings. These reparative structures are recognised as symptoms of internal defects in the tree. References Mattheck, C., and Breloer, H. 1994, The Body Language of Trees: A Handbook for Failure Analysis., HMSO Publications. London

Arboriculture Mullum Creek Tree Retention/Removal - Private Realms & Wetlands Page 80 of 81

Appendix 4 - History of Mathews Property Tree Plantings (Steve Mathews, May, 2014)

The current landscape character is the result of activities by the Mathews family, starting in the 1960s with plantings ceasing in the early 2000's. The original landscape when the Mathews took ownership in 1958 consisted of orchard to the south of the site (Illawong Drive – Berrima Road precinct) with the balance open grazing land, with a small number of large mature Yellow Box trees and Radiata Pines. Some indigenous remnants also occurred in the vicinity of the Kern Place tributary and along the Mullum Mullum Creek. The area to the north of the Mathews home was planted to orchard in the late 1950s (Lots 7-12). Areas around the Mathews home were planted with Australian and non-indigenous natives sourced from the Natural Resources Conservation League (NRCL) starting in 1962 (Lots 5, 6, 13, 14), with later farm plantings of similarly sourced species in the far northeast corner of the site in the early 1970s (Lots 1 & 2). Similar plantings were undertaken around a house on what was then a neighbouring property in the 1960s (Lots 16-18). Further farm forestry trials were planted in 1975, again sourced from the NRCL (Lots 6, 7, 8 & 9). Many of the species used proved to be unsuited to the site, over time showing signs of suffering from fungal attack, insect attack (eg Longicorn Beetle, Lerp), inability to tolerate site conditions such as waterlogging (Lots 1, 7-9), and susceptibility to drought, high temperatures and wind storms. Thinning to the general standard for farm forestry plantings to achieve optimal development of superior trees of 100 to 300 stems per hectare (e.g. approx 6 -10 m spacings between trees) (Bird 2000 p183) were not undertaken. This has resulted in trees that are too close together to achieve the best expression of species’ form and appearance, and many specimens now demonstrate negative impacts of excessive competion including poor and unstable relationship between root development, stem diameter, stem height and crown diameter (susceptible to windthrow and broken stems; suppression of trees; unbalanced crown development; leaning stems, and poor form. From the mid 1990s to early 2000s a number of indigenous trees were propagated from local sources and planted in several areas, to re-establish a connection with the original indigenous biological and landscape character of the site. A number of trees on the site are self-sown from original plantings, from species with the capacity to act as environmental weeds (e.g. orchard rootstock, Tasmanian Bluegum, Sugar Gum)

References Bird, P.R. (2000) Farm forestry in southern Australia Deparment of Natural Resources and Environment, Victoria

Arboriculture Mullum Creek Tree Retention/Removal - Private Realms & Wetlands Page 81 of 81