DOCSLIB.ORG

1 Bound by Oath | Season 2 | Episode 5: Under Color of Law John​: In

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
1 Bound by Oath | Season 2 | Episode 5: Under Color of Law John​: In 1 Bound By Oath | Season 2 | Episode 5: Under Color of Law John:​ In 1958, at 5:45 in the morning, Chicago police burst into the home of James and Flossie Monroe and dragged them out of bed at gunpoint. And they scared the hell out James and Flossie’s six children. Houston Stevens:​ The children we made a lot of noise. We screamed. We did a lot of yelling to alert all the neighbors. Cause we didn't know who these were. It was 14 white guys armed with pistols drawn. Jacqui Abrams:​ They pulled out a picture and showed me a picture. “Is this James Monroe?” Of course it is! Yes, that's him, but who are you? Ralph Stevens:​ All I can say is that I tried to block it out like a nightmare because it felt like, and I lived that way for many, many years growing up, like it was a nightmare. It was denial -- my way to suppress and deny how traumatic it was. John:​ James Monroe had not committed the crime he’d been accused of, and the police did not have a warrant to search his home or arrest him. So the family sued, seeking damages from the officers. But rather than suing in state court, James and Flossie did something that Congress had said they could do way back in 1871. They filed suit against the officers in federal court under Section One of the Ku Klux Klan Act. Today Section One is known as Section 1983. And it’s one of the most important and most frequently litigated civil rights laws on the books. But back when the Monroe’s sued, the law had been mostly dormant for nearly a century, and the Supreme Court had never considered whether it could be invoked against a police officer. In the case of M​ onroe v. Pape,​ the Supreme Court decided that it could. On this episode, we’re going 2 to talk to some of the plaintiffs from M​ onroe v. Pape.​ We’ll talk about some old Section 1983 cases from before M​ onroe w​ as decided. And we’re going to talk about a lingering question from the decision that impacts the Supreme Court’s qualified immunity doctrine today. James King:​ When I was being choked, I feared for my life truly. John:​ ​B​ ut first, some breaking news from the Supreme Court. This past Thursday, the Court issued its opinion in Brownback v. King, the case that we featured on Episode 1 of this season. Bystander:​ They’re going to kill this man. John: A​ nd we didn’t win. But we didn’t lose. James King’s case now goes back to the appeals court so it can address an issue it didn’t decide the first time it heard the case. We’ll have more to say about it on a later episode, but the bottom line for now is that we are very confident James will eventually get his day in court. BBO Montage John:​ In 1871, Congress passed Section 1983 to give individuals a way to enforce the guarantees of the 14th Amendment. The 14th Amendment was meant to be a new birth of freedom, and a Section 1983 lawsuit was and is a mechanism to bring the grand ideas and principles embodied in that Amendment into reality. But after it was passed, the law did not do much work. According to o​ne count,​ it generated only 21 cases in its first 50 years. A little later in this episode, we’re going to talk about a handful of those early Section 1983 cases and what they can tell us about the world before 1961 -- the world before the Supreme Court finally opened the doors of federal courthouses to plaintiffs like the Monroe family. But first, the case that changed everything: M​ onroe v. Pape.​ 3 Houston Stevens:​ My mother was a respectable, hardworking, black woman who came up from Alabama. She escaped from behind the Cotton Curtain when I was 13 months old. John:​ That’s Houston Stevens, the oldest child of Flossie Monroe. Flossie was from Opelika, Alabama. Houston Stevens:​ She was a warm, loving person. She had been orphaned at age six. So she was raised by her grandmother. John:​ Within months of Houston’s birth, his father had to flee Alabama for his life, becoming one of the six million African Americans who joined the Great Migration out of the South. Houston Stevens:​ My father and my mother and my mother's sister went to the theater, went to the movies. And in the Deep South, the blacks sat in the balcony. And the whites sat in the main level. Someone threw a box of popcorn down on the white folks. So the usher came up and accused my father of doing it. And my father said he didn't do that. He said he was here with his wife -- this is the way my mother tells the story -- he said, I'm here with my wife and my sister in law. I'm not throwing pop -- and the usher told him he had to leave and he said he’s not going anywhere cause he paid his money. And the usher grabbed him. And that was the mistake that the usher made. He punched his lights out, knocked him down the stairs. Of course, they call for the sheriff right away. The sheriff comes with this group. And they had him out back behind the jail house. Fortunately, my mother's sister had run home to get my father's father who was an important person around town. He was well-respected. My grandfather ran up there to the sheriff and pleaded for his life. And his sheriff told him he better get him out of here, get him out of here before sundown. So they put him on the Illinois Central going to Chicago. And that's how 4 he got out. That's why I say my folks escaped from behind the Cotton Curtain. That was fascism living in the South. John:​ Chicago, though, had its own problems. In 1958, the Illinois chapter of the ACLU documented thousands of cases ​per year of Chicago police detaining suspects incommunicado for hours or days in violation of state law, which required suspects to be taken promptly before a magistrate. In many cases, and this was nearly impossible to document, police were accused of subjecting arrestees to the third degree -- that is, rough treatment up to and including torture. Anyway, back to the Monroe family. Houston and his mother Flossie followed Houston’s father from Alabama to Chicago. And from there the family grew. Ralph Stevens:​ She was a great mother. She taught all of us a good work ethics, and we all became to some form of fashion entrepreneurs and had our own little businesses and different things. John:​ That’s Ralph Stevens. To help with make ends meet, both he and Houston started working when they were young. So did their sister Jacqui. Jacqui Abrams:​ I started working when I was 12, actually sooner than that because I was babysitting. But my real job was a paper route. I had 72 customers. John:​ After several years, Flossie got remarried to a man named James Monroe. Houston Stevens:​ He was a general contractor. He was a plasterer and carpenter. He did home renovation, building renovation, porch rebuilding. 5 Jacqui Abrams:​ We had an English basement apartment on 14th and Trumbull. John:​ Early one morning in 1958, Chicago police raided the apartment. Houston Stevens:​ This happened on October the 29th. That’s when they invaded the house. Which happened to be my birthday. I turned 17 at that time. I'm the oldest of six children who were in the home. Jacqui Abrams:​ I was 14 years old. Ralph Stevens:​ I was 12 years old at the time so I don't remember a great amount detail other than these guys are screaming and hollering. Houston Stevens:​ They invaded the house -- seven at the front door and seven at the back with guns drawn. They knocked down the doors and came in, came charging in. Jacqui Abrams:​ We heard this loud noise. And when they came in, they came in running. Ralph Stevens:​ I don't remember how many it was, but it was a lot of guys up in there and they were all caucasian and they were mean looking guys with guns and everything. Donald Moore:​ T​he petitioners in this case are James Monroe, his wife Flossie Monroe, and their six children. John:​ That’s the family’s lawyer, Donald Page Moore, arguing at the U.S. Supreme Court in 1960. 6 Donald Moore:​ The respondent, Deputy Chief of Detectives, Frank Pape and 12 other police officers … entered the Monroe home through the front and rear doors. Houston Stevens:​ The children we made a lot of noise. We screamed. We did a lot of yelling to alert all the neighbors. Ralph Stevens:​ We were all screaming and hollering and just going through what kids would do that were traumatized and not understanding what was going on and why. Jacqui Abrams:​ They busted into my mom's bedroom. Now this I saw. They went into my mom's bedroom and got my mom and my stepfather out of bed. Donald Moore:​ Flashlights were shined on the faces of Mr. and Mrs. Monroe. One of the officers ordered James Monroe to get out of bed. A gun was pointed at Mr.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • “Local Governments and Firearms: Avoiding a Jam”
    A “Local Officials: Stronger, Together” Podcast Publication “Local Governments and Firearms: Avoiding a Jam” (The materials herein become effective September 1, 2021.) (Updated portions, including “permitless” or “constitutional” carry changes, are highlighted in gray.) Scott Houston Member Liaison [email protected] 512-791-4158 www.tmlirp.org (Version 2: Last Updated June 2021) Page 1 of 46 Table of Contents Page What is the “Local Officials: Stronger, Together” Podcast Series and why should I be listening?....................................................................................................... 4 What’s in this paper? ...................................................................................................................... 5 What does the Texas “licensed carry” law authorize? .................................................................... 5 What does the so-called "constitutional" or "permitless" carry legislation authorize?....................5 In what places is a person prohibited by state law from carrying a firearm? ................................. 6 What type of signage is required to provide notice that handgun isn't allowed?...........................10 Handgun without a license.........................................................................................................10 Handgun with a license..............................................................................................................11 How has the statutory prohibition against carrying a firearm onto the premises
    [Show full text]
  • Master Thesis
    1 Master Thesis THE VALUE OF METACRITIC AND ITS RELATIONSHIP WITH VIDEO GAME SALES FLAVIO TONA SHNEIDER MIKE-E January, 2020 2 3 Contents 1 INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................................ 5 2 LITERATURE REVIEW ..................................................................................................................... 8 3 MARKET ANALYSIS ....................................................................................................................... 13 3.1 METASCORE ............................................................................................................................ 14 3.1.1 GRADE CONVERSION .................................................................................................... 17 3.2 HARDWARE MARKET ............................................................................................................ 19 3.3 SOFTWARE MARKET ............................................................................................................. 20 4 - VALUE ..................................................................................................................................................... 21 4.1 CONSUMER ....................................................................................................................................... 21 4.2 - VALUE FOR THE INDUSTRY AND USAGE ......................................................................................... 22 4 METHODOLOGY
    [Show full text]
  • 67Th Legislature HR 4.1
    67th Legislature HR 4.1 1 HOUSE RESOLUTION NO. 4 2 INTRODUCED BY A. OLSEN 3 4 A RESOLUTION OF THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES OF THE STATE OF MONTANA TO LIMIT THE 5 PRODUCTION AND FIRST USE OF NUCLEAR WEAPONS. 6 7 WHEREAS, the use of even a small number of nuclear weapons could have catastrophic human, 8 environmental, health, and economic consequences globally; and 9 WHEREAS, the United States is currently planning to spend nearly $2 trillion over the next 30 years 10 rebuilding its entire nuclear weapons arsenal, which is a gross misuse of funds that could be devoted instead to 11 improving security, health, and education; and 12 WHEREAS, Montana is home to Malmstrom Air Force Base, the common center for L50 Minuteman III 13 intercontinental nuclear missiles located throughout north central Montana; and 14 WHEREAS, Montanans have a special responsibility to advocate for no first use because the 15 intercontinental nuclear missiles buried in their prairie give them a heightened awareness of the reality and 16 threat of nuclear armaments; and 17 WHEREAS, the United States currently reserves the right to use nuclear weapons in response to 18 nonnuclear attacks by Russia, China, or North Korea, which could respond by using their own nuclear 19 weapons, resulting in a nuclear war that could have devastating consequences; and 20 WHEREAS, the sole purpose of United States nuclear weapons should be to deter a nuclear attack on 21 the United States, its forces, and its allies, so that there is no reason for the United States to ever use nuclear
    [Show full text]
  • English II RELEASED
    STAAR® State of Texas Assessments of Academic Readiness English II Administered April 2019 RELEASED Copyright © 2019, Texas Education Agency. All rights reserved. Reproduction of all or portions of this work is prohibited without express written permission from the Texas Education Agency. STAAR English II 09/17/2019 EN2SP19R_rev00 STAAR English II 09/17/2019 EN2SP19R_rev00 REVISING English II Page 3 STAAR English II 09/17/2019 EN2SP19R_rev00 Read the selection and choose the best answer to each question. Then fill in the answer on your answer document. J.T. wrote this paper about a unique Japanese activity. Read the paper and look for any revisions J.T. should make. Then answer the questions that follow. In Sync (1) Texas is known for its superb high school marching bands. (2) Each week during football season, thousands of students take to the field to display their musical and marching talents. (3) These same students also compete in local, state, and national competitions and exhibitions. (4) However, marching bands aren’t found in just this state or even just this country. (5) But in one country there are marchers who skip the music component all together. (6) Students at Japan’s Nippon Sports Science University, NSSU, participate in an intricate marching-like exhibition known as precision walking. (7) NSSU students have perfected the nearly 50-year-old tradition of shuudan koudou, which means “collective action.” (8) The collective action is a carefully choreographed display of synchronized walking. (9) Identically dressed students walk forward and backward to form lines and shapes, even crossing between one another at times.
    [Show full text]
  • Cops Use Polygraph Less Often
    Friday, November 29, 2013 Cops use polygraph less often Examiners now questioning job hopefuls, fewer crime suspects BY DUAA ELDEIB After decades of relying on controversial polygraph examinations to help solve crimes, the Chicago Police Department has drastically scaled back on giving so-called lie-detector tests in the course of criminal investigations. In what appears to be a shift in focus, the department’s polygraph unit examiners, who previously worked under the forensic services division, have been relocated to human resources, where their primary responsibility is administering the tests to police officer candidates. The examiners’ new unit follows industry standards for conducting polygraphs. The move was said to be temporary, but one year later, the examiners are still with the personnel unit. “The temporary detail was made to address the backlog in pre-employment screenings needs,” police spokesman Adam Collins said. “There hasn’t been a move away from polygraphs as a part of criminal investigations.” Collins did not say how long the three Center on Wrongful Convictions client Nicole examiners would remain with human Harris, to whom a polygraph examiner lied, resources, which has seen a significant saying she’d failed the test. increase in the number of pre-employment polygraphs. He said only that it would be Yet the number of criminal polygraphs has “until the need has been met.” The examiners dropped considerably, from about 400 in continue to conduct criminal polygraphs as 2011 to 50 in the first eight months of 2013. the need arises, Collins said. The timing of the examiners’ move to the personnel unit corresponded with a Tribune investigation into the polygraph unit’s role in obtaining false confessions.
    [Show full text]
  • Flying the Line Flying the Line the First Half Century of the Air Line Pilots Association
    Flying the Line Flying the Line The First Half Century of the Air Line Pilots Association By George E. Hopkins The Air Line Pilots Association Washington, DC International Standard Book Number: 0-9609708-1-9 Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 82-073051 © 1982 by The Air Line Pilots Association, Int’l., Washington, DC 20036 All rights reserved Printed in the United States of America First Printing 1982 Second Printing 1986 Third Printing 1991 Fourth Printing 1996 Fifth Printing 2000 Sixth Printing 2007 Seventh Printing 2010 CONTENTS Chapter 1: What’s a Pilot Worth? ............................................................... 1 Chapter 2: Stepping on Toes ...................................................................... 9 Chapter 3: Pilot Pushing .......................................................................... 17 Chapter 4: The Airmail Pilots’ Strike of 1919 ........................................... 23 Chapter 5: The Livermore Affair .............................................................. 30 Chapter 6: The Trouble with E. L. Cord .................................................. 42 Chapter 7: The Perils of Washington ........................................................ 53 Chapter 8: Flying for a Rogue Airline ....................................................... 67 Chapter 9: The Rise and Fall of the TWA Pilots Association .................... 78 Chapter 10: Dave Behncke—An American Success Story ......................... 92 Chapter 11: Wartime.............................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Introduction to Monetary Damages
    CHAPTER 1 Introduction to Monetary Damages Chapter Contents § 1.01 Introduction § 1.02 Historical Background to Monetary Damages § 1.03 General Principles of Monetary Damages [1] Determining Whether Injuries May Be Compensated by Damages [a] Proximate Cause [b] The Standard of Certainty [2] Calculating the Damages Award [a] Compensatory Damages [i] Market Value Measure [ii] Lost Opportunity Measure [b] Unjust Enrichment [c] Augmented Damages [i] Punitive Damages [ii] Statutory Enhanced Damages [d] Interest [e] Attorneys’ Fees and Costs § 1.01 Introduction Monetary damages are a form of judicial remedy that can be awarded to a claimant in compensation for an injury or loss wrong- fully inflicted.1 This form of remedy is most commonly referred to simply as “damages.” The essence of damages is the payment of money as a release from civil liability. 1 See 1 Dobbs Law of Remedies, 3 (2d ed. 1993). 1-1 (Rel. 24) § 1.01 INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY DAMAGES 1-2 Because damages in Anglo-American jurisprudence are awarded by a jury of lay persons under the supervision of a judge, it is neces- sary to have certain guiding principles by which the judge can direct the jury. The rules that were developed by the judiciary to guide juries in their damages deliberations are essentially the law of damages. As one commentator has said: “The law of damages consists of the rules, standards, and methods used by the courts for measuring in money the compensation given for losses and injuries.”2 The law of intellectual property damages did not develop in a vac- uum; it is very much a product of this general law of damages.
    [Show full text]
  • An Analysis of Airspace Violations and Pilot Report Data
    NASA/CR—2005-213923 Violations of Temporary Flight Restrictions and Air Defense Identification Zones: An Analysis of Airspace Violations and Pilot Report Data Michael Zuschlag John A. Volpe National Transportation Systems Center, Cambridge, Massachusetts September 2005 The NASA STI Program Office ... in Profile Since its founding, NASA has been dedicated to • CONFERENCE PUBLICATION. the advancement of aeronautics and space Collected papers from scientific and science. The NASA Scientific and Technical technical conferences, symposia, Information (STI) Program Office plays a key seminars, or other meetings sponsored or part in helping NASA maintain this important co-sponsored by NASA. role. • SPECIAL PUBLICATION. Scientific, The NASA STI Program Office is operated by technical, or historical information from Langley Research Center, the lead center for NASA programs, projects, and missions, NASA’s scientific and technical information. The often concerned with subjects having NASA STI Program Office provides access to the substantial public interest. NASA STI Database, the largest collection of aeronautical and space science STI in the world. • TECHNICAL TRANSLATION. English- The Program Office is also NASA’s institutional language translations of foreign scientific mechanism for disseminating the results of its and technical material pertinent to research and development activities. These results NASA’s mission. are published by NASA in the NASA STI Report Series, which includes the following report types: Specialized services that complement the STI Program Office’s diverse offerings include • TECHNICAL PUBLICATION. Reports of creating custom thesauri, building customized completed research or a major significant databases, organizing and publishing research phase of research that present the results of results ... even providing videos.
    [Show full text]
  • Netflix Adds to Original Shows with Sony Deal 15 October 2013
    Netflix adds to original shows with Sony deal 15 October 2013 programming to make itself a preferred location for on-demand streaming. "We were spellbound after hearing Todd, Glenn and Daniel's pitch, and knew Netflix was the perfect home for this suspenseful family drama that is going to have viewers on the edge of their seats," said Netflix vice president of original content Cindy Holland. Netflix scored a recent hit with its political drama "House of Cards," tossing conventional TV wisdom out the window when it released a full season in one fell swoop early this year. The Netflix company logo is seen at Netflix headquarters The series, which was nominated for a 2013 Emmy in Los Gatos, CA on Wednesday, April 13, 2011 for best drama, joins a recent spate of original Netflix programming that includes new episodes of "Arrested Development," plus the series "Orange is the New Black" and "Hemlock Grove." Netflix on Monday announced a deal with Sony to create a psychological thriller series for the online Netflix sees original programming as part of a streaming and DVD service, ramping up original formula to gain and hold subscribers at its $7.99-a- programming to win subscribers. month fee that covers a vast catalog of pre- released TV shows and movies. "Damages" creators Todd Kessler, Daniel Zelman, and Glenn Kessler will begin production of a © 2013 AFP 13-episode first season of the show from Sony Pictures Television early next year. The yet-unnamed series will broadcast exclusively on Netflix, according to the California-based Internet company.
    [Show full text]
  • Amazon and IMDB Sued for Not Respecting Elders | Page 1
    Amazon And IMDB Sued FOr Not Respecting Elders | Page 1 Amazon And IMDB Sued FOr Not Respecting Elders By: Jack Greiner on October 19, 2011 on graydon.law Well, sort of. An actress who identifies herself as Jane Doe has sued the Internet Movie Database Web site, and its parent company, Amazon, for revealing her actual age. I’m not making that up. Here’s the actual complaint, which was filed in a federal court in Seattle. In case you haven’t used it, IMDB is a Web site that has detailed information on any movie ever made. I personally love it. I can’t tell you the number of times I’ve watched a movie on TV and wondered who the actor was in some small role, and where I’d seen him before. IMDB has all that information. But I digress. According to the complaint, Jane Doe is of Asian descent, and her given name is difficult for Americans to spell and pronounce. She has for that reason used a stage name throughout her career. She is also very careful not to provide personal information, including her true age. According to the complaint, “[i]n the entertainment industry, youth is king. If one is perceived to be “over-the-hill” i.e., approaching 40, it is nearly impossible for an up-and-coming actress, such as plaintiff, to get work.” IMDB also offers a service called IMDbPro, which offers “industry insider” information to paying customers. Ms. Doe signed up for the service and in so doing, provided her name, birth date and other personal information.
    [Show full text]
  • POLYGRAPH PROTECTION ACT of 1981 Act 44 of 1982 an ACT To
    POLYGRAPH PROTECTION ACT OF 1981 Act 44 of 1982 AN ACT to prohibit employers and employment agencies from requiring polygraph examinations of employees and applicants for employment; to prohibit employers and employment agencies from discriminating against employees and applicants for employment because they refuse or decline to take a polygraph examination; to provide that an employer or employment agency shall not take any action against an employee because of an alleged or actual opinion that an employee did not tell the truth during a polygraph examination; to regulate the use of polygraph examinations by employers and employment agencies; to regulate the administration of polygraph examinations to employees and applicants for employment; and to provide remedies and penalties for violations of this act. History: 1982, Act 44, Eff. Mar. 30, 1983. The People of the State of Michigan enact: 37.201 Short title. Sec. 1. This act shall be known and may be cited as the "polygraph protection act of 1981". History: 1982, Act 44, Eff. Mar. 30, 1983. 37.202 Definitions. Sec. 2. As used in this act: (a) "Employee" means an individual who works for another person for compensation. (b) "Employer" means a person who employs 1 or more persons or who accepts applications for employment, including an agent of an employer. (c) "Employment agency" means a person regularly undertaking with or without compensation to procure, refer, recruit, or place for an employer or person the opportunity to work for an employer, and includes an agent of that person. (d) "Examiner" means any person who does any of the following: (i) Purports to detect deception, verify truthfulness, or provide a diagnostic opinion of either of these through instrumentation or the use of a mechanical device.
    [Show full text]
  • Using User Created Game Reviews for Sentiment Analysis: a Method for Researching User Attitudes
    Using User Created Game Reviews for Sentiment Analysis: A Method for Researching User Attitudes Björn Strååt Harko Verhagen Stockholm University Stockholm University Department of Computer Department of Computer and Systems Sciences and Systems Sciences Stockholm, Sweden Stockholm, Sweden [email protected] [email protected] ABSTRACT provide user ratings and review services, e.g. products on This paper presents a method for gathering and evaluating amazon.com online store, tourist guides such as Yelp.com, user attitudes towards previously released video games. All and TripAdvisor.com, movie reviews such as user reviews from two video game franchise were collected. rottentomatoes.com, and many more. The video game The most frequently mentioned words of the games were community is no different. The content provider service derived from this dataset through word frequency analysis. Steam allows the users to vote and comment on games, and The words, called “aspects” were then further analyzed the website Metacritic.com present both expert- and user through a manual aspect based sentiment analysis. The final created reviews. User created content offers a vast and analysis show that the rating of user review to a high degree varied source of data for anyone who wish to explore the correlate with the sentiment of the aspect in question, if the user sentiment beyond the basic rating of previously data set is large enough. This knowledge is valuable for a released products. developer who wishes to learn more about previous games success or failure factors. In this study, we have performed an Aspect Based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) [2] based on data gathered Author Keywords from user reviews regarding two video game series, on Sentiment; sentiment analysis; user created content; reviews Metacritic.com.
    [Show full text]