TABLE OF CONTENTS

FRONTISPIECE IV

GENERAL INTRODUCTION TO THE LIBRARY OF LIVING PHILOSOPHERS Vll

FOUNDER'S GENERAL INTRODUCTION TO THE LIBRARY OF LIVING PHILOSOPHERS IX

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Xll

PREFACE XV

PART ONE: INTELLECTUAL AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF P.F. STRAWSON 1 FACSIMILE OF STRAWSON'S HANDWRITING 2 INTELLECTUAL AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF P. F. STRAWSON 3

PART TWO: DESCRIPTIVE AND CRITICAL ESSAYS ON THE PHILOSOPHY OF P. F. STRAWSON, WITH REPLIES 23

1. RUTH GARRETT MILLIKAN: Proper Function and Convention in Speech Acts 25 REPLY TO RUTH GARRETT MILLIKAN 44 2. SUSAN HAACK: Between the Scylla of Scientism and the Charybdis of Apriorism 49 REPLY TO SUSAN HAACK 64 3. E. M. ADAMS: On the Possibility of a Unified World View 69 REPLY TO E. M. ADAMS 86 4. PAN AYOT BUTCHVAROV: The Relativity of Reallys 91 REPLY TO PAN AYOT BUTCHVAROV 106 XIV TABLE OF CONTENTS

5. RICHARD BEHLING: Two Kinds of Logic? III REPLY TO RICHARD BEHLING 127 6. JOHN McDoWELL: Referring to Oneself 129 REPLY TO JOHN McDoWELL 146 7. SIMON BLACKBURN: Relativization and Truth 151 REPLY TO SIMON BLACKBURN 168 8. T ADEUSZ SZUBKA: Strawson and Antirealism 175 REPLY TO T ADEUSZ SZUBKA 192 9. DAVID FREDERICK HAIGHT: Reference and Reality 199 REPLY TO DAVID FREDERICK HAIGHT 214 10. JOSEPH S. Wu: P. F. Strawson's Criticism of Formal Logic 217 REPLY TO JOSEPH S. Wu 224 11. ANDREW G. BLACK: Naturalism and Cartesian Skepticism 227 REPLY TO ANDREW G. BLACK 242 12. DA VID PEARS: Strawson on Freedom and Resentment 245 REPLY TO DAVID PEARS 259 13. ROBERT BOYD: Strawson on Induction 263 REPLY TO ROBERT BOYD 272 14. HILARY PUTNAM: Strawson and Skepticism 273 REPLY TO HILARY PUTNAM 288 15. PAUL F. SNOWDON: Strawson on the Concept of Perception 293 REPLY TO PAUL F. SNOWDON 311 16. ARINDAM CHAKRABARTI: Experience, Concept- Possession, and Knowledge of a Language 315 REPLY TO ARINDAM CHAKRABARTI 324 17. WENCESLAO J. GONZALEZ: P. F. Strawson's Moderate Empiricism: The Philosophical Basis of His Approach in the Theory of Knowledge 329 REPLY TO WENCESLAO J. GONZALEZ 359 18. ERNEST SOSA: P. F. Strawson's Epistemological Naturalism 361 REPLY TO ERNEST SOSA 370 19. CHUNG M. TSE: Strawson's Metaphysical Theory of Subject and Predicate 373 REPLY TO CHUNG-M. TSE 383 TABLE OF CONTENTS xv

20. JOHN R. SEARLE: Truth: A Reconsideration of Strawson's Views 385 REPLY TO JOHN R. SEARLE 402

PART THREE: BIBLIOGRAPHY OF THE WRITINGS OF P. F. STRAWSON 405 INDEX 419