立法會 Legislative Council

LC Paper No. CB(4)682/19-20 (These minutes have been seen by the Administration) Ref : CB4/BC/2/17 Bills Committee on Guangzhou-Shenzhen-Hong Kong Express Rail Link (Co-location) Bill

Minutes of the fifth meeting held on Saturday, 17 March 2018, at 10:00 am in Conference Room 1 of the Legislative Council Complex

Members : Hon Mrs LAU Suk-yee, GBS, JP (Chairman) present Hon CHEUNG Kwok-kwan, JP (Deputy Chairman) Hon James TO Kun-sun Hon LEUNG Yiu-chung Hon Lai-him, GBS, JP Hon Yu-yan, GBS, JP Hon Kin-fung, GBS, JP Hon WONG Ting-kwong, GBS, JP Hon Wai-king, SBS, JP Hon CHAN Hak-kan, BBS, JP Hon CHAN Kin-por, GBS, JP Dr Hon Mei-fun, SBS, JP Hon WONG Kwok-kin, SBS, JP Hon Wai-chun, JP Hon Claudia MO Hon Steven HO Chun-yin, BBS Hon Chi-ming, SBS, JP Hon WU Chi-wai, MH Hon YIU Si-wing, BBS Hon Charles Peter MOK, JP Hon CHAN Chi-chuen Hon CHAN Han-pan, JP Hon LEUNG Che-cheung, SBS, MH, JP Hon Mei-kuen, BBS, JP Dr Hon KWOK Ka-ki Hon KWOK Wai-keung, JP Hon Dennis KWOK Wing-hang Hon Wah-fung, SBS, JP Dr Hon Fernando CHEUNG Chiu-hung - 2 -

Hon IP Kin-yuen Dr Hon , BBS, JP Dr Hon CHIANG Lai-wan, JP Ir Dr Hon LO Wai-kwok, SBS, MH, JP Hon Alvin YEUNG Dr Hon Kwan-yiu, JP Hon HO Kai-ming Hon LAM Cheuk-ting Hon Ho-ding Hon SHIU Ka-fai Hon Chong-shing, MH Hon YUNG Hoi-yan Dr Hon Hon CHAN Chun-ying Hon Tanya CHAN Hon HUI Chi-fung Hon LUK Chung-hung Hon LAU Kwok-fan, MH Hon Ip-keung, BBS, MH, JP Hon KWONG Chun-yu Hon Jeremy TAM Man-ho

Members : Prof Hon Joseph LEE Kok-long, SBS, JP absent Hon Puk-sun, BBS, JP Hon MA Fung-kwok, SBS, JP Hon Kenneth LEUNG Dr Hon Helena WONG Pik-wan Hon Andrew WAN Siu-kin Hon CHU Hoi-dick Hon Jimmy NG Wing-ka, JP Hon SHIU Ka-chun Dr Hon CHENG Chung-tai

Public officers : Agenda Item I attending Transport and Housing Bureau

Mr Frank CHAN Fan, JP Secretary for Transport and Housing

- 3 -

Ms Rebecca PUN Ting-ting, JP Deputy Secretary for Transport and Housing (Transport) 1

Mr Andy LAM Siu-hong Principal Assistant Secretary for Transport and Housing (Transport) 3

Mr Ronald CHENG Long-fung Assistant Secretary for Transport and Housing (Transport) 3C

Department of Justice

Mr Dominic LAI Kai-sang Deputy Law Officer (Civil Law)(Advisory)

Mr Llewellyn MUI Kei-fat Deputy Solicitor General (Constitutional Affairs) (Acting)

Mr Lawrence PENG Si-yun Senior Assistant Law Draftsman

Mr Henry CHAN Ngai-him Senior Government Counsel

Security Bureau

Ms Maggie WONG Siu-chu, JP Deputy Secretary for Security 3

Mr Parson LAM Chun-wah Principal Assistant Secretary for Security D

Attendance by : Agenda Item I invitation Session one

Mr WONG Ho-wa

Mr LAI Wai-tong

- 4 -

Dr IP Pui-lam

Ms KWOK Ching-yin

Mr LEE Man-long

Civil Force

Mr Stanley TAM Lanny

New People's Party

Miss Dana LAU Sing-she Community Development Officer

Mr NG Pan-pan

Democratic Alliance for the Betterment and Progress of Hong Kong

Mr Frankie NGAN Man-yu 青年民建聯主席

Ms LI Shuk-fong

Maritime Silk Road Society

Mr Frank SIU Assistant Manager

華富愛心協會

張偉楠先生 顧問

Mr LAU Ngai

Mr IP Man-pan

Mr WONG Chun-ting

Ms FONG Shun-yan

Mr CHAN Chim-han - 5 -

Mr IP Chun-yun

Mr TSOI Shing-hin

Ms LAI Ka-man

Mr MUK Ka-chun

鄭楚光先生

Mr LAM Hin-fai

Miss HUI Pui-yan Betty

Mr LEUNG Ping-kin

朱煥釗先生

Miss YIU Ho-yee

莫遠君先生

Mr SHIH Jan-Noel

蔡惠誠先生

Mr LI Ka-leung Philip

Mr YEUNG Kwong-fu Huios

Hong Kong Y.Elites Association

Mr CHUANG Ka-pun Albert Chairman

Session two

香港天津青年會

劉婷小姐 副會長 - 6 -

Music Zone Foundation Association

Mr Jacky KO Chung-kit Chairman

Mr NG Chun-yu

Mr LEUNG Ka-ho

Hong Kong Social Workers and Welfare Employees Union

Mr CHAN Yee-fei Vice-chairman

Mr HO Pok-ho

丘淑明女士

許珊珊女士

Mr HO Chak-ho

Mr IU Chun-yip Lawrence

陳慧靈小姐

Mr SHI Shirong

Mr AU Wing-kwan

Ms CHAN Hoi-yung

Mr LAM Wang-kit

Mr WONG Ka-wing

Mr PAU Ming-hong

Mr YU Hon-kwan

Mr WONG Wai-kit

- 7 -

李琼女士

Miss CHENG Wing-nga

姜淑敏女士

Miss LI Lok-yan

Mr TONG Ho-wai Howard

Mr LAI Jee-shing

Miss LI Ka-ying

Ms HO Yuen-kwan

Ms LAM Ying-wai

Mr MOK Kam-sum

Session three

Prof Louis LOCK Fat-shing

Dr Lisa SHAM Lai-shan

法律界關注一地兩檢聯席

Dr Willy FU Representative

Mr Kacee TING

The Hong Kong Electronic Industries Association

Dr NG Chi-ho Chairman

- 8 -

The Y.Elites Association, Committee on Community and Social Affairs

Dr Calvin KWOK Ho-king Undersecretary for Hong Kong Jiangsu Exchange Promotion Association

Mr LEUNG Ka-wai

Dynamic Island

Mr Felix WU Spokesperson

Hong Kong United Youth Science and Technology Association

Ms Yvonne WONG Vice Chairman

蕭煒忠先生

胡綽謙先生

Hong Kong-Shanghai Youth Association

Mr PAU Hung-fan Executive Vice Chairman

曾柏淇先生

張思穎小姐

杜礎圻先生

Hong Kong Professional And Senior Executives Association

Ir YAM Kong Member

- 9 -

Guangdong-Hong Kong Association for the Promotion of Technology Enterprise (HK) Ltd.

Mr LAU Kin-on Chairman

司徒駿軒先生

鍾秀賢女士

Mr LEE Ching-hang

The Hong Kong Chinese Importers' and Exporters' Association

Mr Michael HUI Wah-kit Vice President

Mr SIN Hiu-pan

The Association of Hong Kong Professionals President

Mr Eugene CHAN Kin-keung

Savantas Policy Institute

Mr Ben KONG Ho-ming Policy Officer

香港公共管治學會

陳德明先生 會長

Hong Kong Jewelry Manufacturers' Association

Dr SHUM Wan-lung Honorary Chairman

Mr Tony PANG Chor-fu

- 10 -

Hong Kong Economic & Trade Association

Dr YEUNG Chi-tit Vice President

雲港台青年交流促進會

Mr Vincent LAM 主席

Mr FAN Yat-ho

Mr CHEUNG Sze-chung

Session four

The Confucian Academy

Mr LUI Tin-tsang Executive Vice President

Civic Party

Mr Henry SIN Ho-fai Executive Committee

The Young Civic

Mr Joshua LI Chun-hei Executive Committee

Mr LAI Tak-keung

Mr Arthur LEE

"Co-location" Concern Group (Expert Group)

Dr LEUNG Kai-chi Member

- 11 -

香港中國旅遊協會

Mr NG Hi-on

Mr LAU Kwok-yan

陳立志先生

Mrs Helen LAU

姚柏良先生

Mr Denny CHAN Kam-chuen

關振瀚先生

Tsuen Wan Kwai Tsing Residents Association

張浩明先生 理事長

盧騰光先生

劉有光先生

范秋華小姐

Mr CHENG Tat-hung

Mr Andy YU Tak-po

劉婉琴女士

Mr Gary TONG Chi-wah

張慕真小姐

Clerk in : Ms Sophie LAU attendance Chief Council Secretary (4)2

- 12 -

Mr Daniel SIN Chief Council Secretary (4)3

Staff in : Mr Timothy TSO attendance Senior Assistant Legal Adviser 1

Miss Joyce CHAN Assistant Legal Adviser 1

Miss Joyce CHING Senior Council Secretary (4)2

Ms Jacqueline LAW Council Secretary (4)2

Miss Mandy LAM Legislative Assistant (4)2

I. Meeting with deputations/ individuals and the Administration

The Bills Committee deliberated (Index of proceedings attached at Annex).

2. The Bills Committee received views from 115 deputations/individuals attending the meeting, and took note of 44 written submissions from deputations/individuals who did not attend the meeting.

3. The Bills Committee requested the Administration to provide the following information:

(a) relevant information on arrangement relating to co- location of boundary control facilities adopted by other places/countries; and provide justifications for the co-location arrangement at the West Kowloon Station of the Guangzhou- Shenzhen-Hong Kong Express Rail Link as proposed under the Bill; and

(b) the reasons for concluding that the Bill would not contravene Articles 4, 11, 19, 22(3), 31, 35, 38, 39, 41, 80 and 87 of the Basic Law. - 13 -

(Post-meeting note: The Chinese and English versions of the Administration's response were issued to members vide LC Paper No. CB(4)870/17-18(01) on 6 and 26 April 2018 respectively.)

4. The Bills Committee also requested the Administration to provide an overall response to the views expressed by deputations/individuals at the meeting.

(Post-meeting note: The Administration's written response was circulated to members vide LC Paper No. CB(4)947/17-18(05) on 20 April 2018.)

II. Any other business

5. Members noted that the next meeting would be held on 23 March 2018 at 10:45 am.

6. There being no other business, the meeting ended at 7:47 pm.

Council Business Division 4 Legislative Council Secretariat 8 June 2020

Annex

Proceedings of the fifth meeting of the Bills Committee on Guangzhou-Shenzhen-Hong Kong Express Rail Link (Co-location) Bill held on Saturday, 17 March 2018, at 10 am in Conference Room 1 of the Legislative Council Complex

Time Speaker(s) Subject(s) Action Marker required Meeting with deputations / individuals and the Administration

Session one 001058- Chairman Welcoming remarks and meeting arrangement 001713 Ms Tanya CHAN

001714- Chairman Introduction 002153 Administration

002154- Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 002445 Mr WONG ho-wa Paper No. CB(4)768/17-18(13) (Chinese version only))

002446- Chairman Presentation of views 002750 Mr Lai Wai-tong

002751- Chairman Presentation of views 003057 Dr IP Pui-lam

003058- Chairman Presentation of views 003409 Ms KWOK Ching- yin

003410- Chairman Presentation of views 003709 Mr LEE Man-long

003710- Chairman Presentation of views 003959 Civil Force

004000- Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission 004229 New People's Party (LC Paper No. CB(4)768/17-18(14) (Chinese version only))

004230- Chairman Presentation of views 004526 Mr NG Pan-pan

004527- Chairman Presentation of views 004801 Democratic Alliance for the Betterment and Progress of Hong Kong

- 2 -

Time Speaker(s) Subject(s) Action Marker required 004802- Chairman Presentation of views 004838 Ms LI Shuk-fong

004839- Chairman Presentation of views 005135 Maritime Silk Road Society

005136- Chairman Presentation of views 005411 華富愛心協會

005412- Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 005634 Mr LAU Ngai Victor Paper No. CB(4)733/17-18(01) (Chinese version only))

005635- Chairman Presentation of views 005849 Mr IP Man-pan

005850- Chairman Presentation of views 010022 Mr Wong chun-ting

010023- Chairman Presentation of views 010338 Ms FONG shun-yan

010339- Chairman Presentation of views 010536 Mr Chan Chim-hang

010537- Chairman Presentation of views 010849 Mr IP Chun-yun

010850- Chairman Presentation of views 011108 Mr TSOI shing-hin

011109- Chairman Presentation of views 011306 Ms LAI Ka-man

011307- Chairman Presentation of views 011613 Mr MUK Ka-chun

011614- Chairman Presentation of views 011923 鄭楚光先生

011924- Chairman Presentation of views 012211 Mr LAM Hin-fai

012212- Chairman Presentation of views 012427 Miss HUI Pui-yan Betty

- 3 -

Time Speaker(s) Subject(s) Action Marker required 012428- Chairman Presentation of views 012733 Mr LEUNG Ping- kin

012734- Chairman Presentation of views 012934 朱煥釗先生

012935- Chairman Presentation of views 013123 Miss YIU Ho-yee

013124- Chairman Presentation of views 013417 莫遠君先生

013418- Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 013639 Mr SHIH Jan-Noel Paper No. CB(4)733/17-18(02) (Chinese version only))

013640- Chairman Presentation of views 013829 蔡惠誠先生

013830- Chairman Presentation of views 013957 Mr LI Ka-leung Philip

013958- Chairman Presentation of views 014251 Mr YEUNG Kwong- fu Huios

014252- Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 014600 Hong Kong Y.Elites Paper No. CB(4)768/17-18(10) (Chinese version Association only))

014601- Chairman The Administration's response to the views expressed 015201 Administration by deputations/individuals at the meeting.

015202- Chairman Mr TAM's enquiry on the preclearance arrangements 015706 Mr Jeremy TAM between the United States and Canada and his enquiry Administration on the comparison between the aforesaid arrangements and the co-location arrangement at the West Kowloon Station ("WKS") of the Guangzhou- Shenzhen-Hong Kong Express Rail Link ("XRL") as proposed under the Bill.

The Administration's explanation on the justifications for the co-location arrangement at the WKS of the XRL as proposed under the Bill.

- 4 -

Time Speaker(s) Subject(s) Action Marker required 015707- Chairman Dr CHEUNG's concern on whether the Bill would 020257 Dr Fernando contravene Article 18 of the Basic Law and the CHEUNG Administration's response. Administration

020258- Chairman Mr LEUNG's enquiry on whether possible judicial 020750 Mr LEUNG Che- review/court proceedings in relation to the co-location cheung arrangement would delay the commissioning of the Administration Hong Kong Section (“HKS”) of the XRL. The Administration undertook to make all necessary arrangements with a view to meeting the target commissioning of the HKS of the XRL in the third quarter of 2018.

020751- Chairman Dr QUAT's views on the constitutional and legal basis 021206 Dr Elizabeth QUAT of the Bill.

021207- Chairman Ms CHAN's enquiry on whether the Hong Kong 021714 Ms Tanya CHAN Clearance Area and Passenger Corridor in the WKS Administration would be administered as a closed area and her enquiry on issues related to boundary control, and the Administration's response.

021715- Chairman The Chairman shared her experience about the 021923 arrangements relating to co-location of boundary control facilities adopted by other places/countries, including the preclearance arrangements between the United States and Canada.

021924- Chairman Mr LEUNG's views on the constitutional and legal 022524 Mr LEUNG Yiu- basis of the Bill and the Administration's response. chung Administration The Administration was requested to provide relevant information on arrangements relating to co- Admin to location of boundary control facilities adopted by provide other places/countries; and provide justifications for paper. the co-location arrangement at the WKS of the XRL Para 3(a) as proposed under the Bill. of the minutes refers.

022525- Chairman Dr KWOK expressed that the Bill, if passed, would 023038 Mr Dennis KWOK have the effect of removing the jurisdiction of the Administration courts of Hong Kong Special Administrative Region ("HKSAR") from an area of Hong Kong. He asked whether there were any precedents in other common law jurisdictions in this regard.

The Administration explained its stance on the above

- 5 -

Time Speaker(s) Subject(s) Action Marker required matter, and the meaning of Article 19(2) of the Basic Law.

023039- Chairman Ms MO's query on the legal and constitutional basis of 023558 Ms Claudia MO the Bill, in particular whether the Bill would Administration contravene Article 18 of the Basic Law, and the Administration's response.

Session two 030303- Chairman Introduction 030823

030624- Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 030836 香港天津青年會 Paper No. CB(4)768/17-18(07) (Chinese version only))

030837- Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 031206 Music Zone Paper No. CB(4)733/17-18(03) (Chinese version Foundation only)) Association 031207- Chairman Presentation of views 031520 Mr NG Chun-yu

031521- Chairman Presentation of views 031804 Mr LEUNG Ka-ho

031805- Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 032126 Hong Kong Social Paper No. CB(4)768/17-18(08) (Chinese version Workers and only)) Welfare Employees Union

032127- Chairman Presentation of views 032431 Mr HO Pok-ho

032432- Chairman Presentation of views 032640 丘淑明女士

032641- Chairman Presentation of views 032722 許珊珊女士

032723- Chairman Presentation of views 033032 Mr HO Chak-ho

033033- Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 033339 Mr IU Chun-yip Paper No. CB(4)733/17-18(04) (Chinese version Lawrence only))

- 6 -

Time Speaker(s) Subject(s) Action Marker required 033340- Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 033707 陳慧靈小姐 Paper No. CB(4)768/17-18(03) (Chinese version only))

033708- Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 033825 Mr SHI Shirong Paper No. CB(4)733/17-18(05) (Chinese version only))

033826- Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 033948 Mr AU Wing-kwan Paper No. CB(4)733/17-18(06) (Chinese version only))

033949- Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 034050 Ms CHAN Hoi-yung Paper No. CB(4)733/17-18(07) (Chinese version only))

034051- Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 034237 Mr LAM Wang-kit Paper No. CB(4)733/17-18(08) (Chinese version only))

034238- Chairman Presentation of views 034541 Mr WONG Ka-wing

034542- Chairman Presentation of views 034727 Mr PAU Ming-hong

034728- Chairman Presentation of views 035102 Mr YU Hon-kwan

035103- Chairman Presentation of views 035429 Mr WONG Wai-kit

035430- Chairman Presentation of views 035711 李琼女士

035712- Chairman Presentation of views 035846 Miss CHENG Wing- nga

035847- Chairman Presentation of views 040023 姜淑敏女士

040024- Chairman Presentation of views 040236 Miss LI Lok-yan

040237- Chairman Presentation of views 040530 Mr TONG Ho-wai Howard

- 7 -

Time Speaker(s) Subject(s) Action Marker required 040531- Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 040815 Mr LAI Jee-shing Paper No. CB(4)733/17-18(49) (Chinese version only))

040816- Chairman Presentation of views 040934 Miss LI Ka-ying

040935- Chairman No view was expressed. 040949 Ms HO Yuen-kwan

040950- Chairman Presentation of views 041233 Ms LAM Ying-wai

041234- Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 041436 Mr MOK Kam-sum Paper No. CB(4)733/17-18(50) (Chinese version only))

041437- Chairman The Administration's response to the views expressed 041804 Administration by deputations/individuals at the meeting.

041805- Chairman Ms CHAN's enquiry about the Administration's stance 042359 Ms Tanya CHAN on the views expressed by the Hong Kong Bar Administration Association ("HKBA") in paragraph 9 of its submission dated 12 March 2018 (LC Paper No. CB(4)743/17-18(29)) and the Administration's response.

042400- Chairman Mr LAM's views on the constitutional and legal basis 042927 Mr Jeffrey LAM of the Bill and his enquiry on whether the Administration Administration would consider enhancing the proposed operational arrangements at the WKS to address the public's concern.

The Administration undertook to make appropriate enhancements.

042928- Mr CHAN Chun- Mr CHAN's enquiry on why Article 20 of the Basic 043336 ying Law was not invoked to grant powers to the HKSAR Administration to implement the co-location arrangement and the Administration's response.

043337- Chairman Ms CHAN's further enquiry about the Admin to 043949 Ms Tanya CHAN Administration's stance on the views expressed by the provide Administration HKBA in its submission and the Administration's response in response. writing. Para 3(b) The Administration was also requested to provide the of the reasons for concluding that the Bill would not minutes contravene Articles 4, 11, 19, 22(3), 31, 35, 38, 39, refers.

- 8 -

Time Speaker(s) Subject(s) Action Marker required 41, 80 and 87 of the Basic Law.

043950- Chairman Mr TSE's view on the Decision made by the Standing 044814 Mr Paul TSE Committee of the National People's Congress Administration ("NPCSC") on 27 December 2017 and his proposal that the Administration should consider seeking an interpretation of relevant provisions of the Basic Law from the NPCSC to allay the concerns of some members of the Bills Committee and the HKBA. The Administration's response.

044815- Chairman Closing remarks 044844

Session three 053407- Deputy Chairman Introduction 053815

053816- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 054012 Prof Louis LOCK Paper No. CB(4)768/17-18(17) (English version Fat-shing only))

054013- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 054221 Dr Lisa SHAM Lai- shan

054222- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 054534 法律界關注一地兩 Paper No. CB(4)757/17-18(07) (Chinese version 檢聯席 only))

054535- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 054839 Mr Kacee TING Paper No. CB(4)757/17-18(03) (Chinese version only)) 054840- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 055038 The Hong Kong Electronic Industries Association

055039- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 055337 The Y.Elites Association, Committee on Community and Social Affairs

055338- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 055643 Mr LEUNG Ka-wai

- 9 -

Time Speaker(s) Subject(s) Action Marker required 055644- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 055951 Dynamic Island

055952- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 060249 Hong Kong United Paper No. CB(4)733/17-18(51) (Chinese version Youth Science and only)) Technology Association

060250- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 060521 蕭煒忠先生

060522- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 060829 胡綽謙先生

060830- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 060950 Hong Kong- Paper No. CB(4)768/17-18(16) (Chinese version Shanghai Youth only)) Association

060951- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 061204 曾柏淇先生

061205- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 061437 張思穎小姐

061438- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 061659 杜礎圻先生

061700- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 061932 Hong Kong Paper No. CB(4)768/17-18(09) (Chinese version Professional And only)) Senior Executives Association

061933- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 062247 Guangdong-Hong Paper No. CB(4)768/17-18(15) (Chinese version Kong Association only)) for the Promotion of Technology Enterprise (HK) Ltd.

062248- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 062552 司徒駿軒先生

062553- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 062824 鍾秀賢女士

- 10 -

Time Speaker(s) Subject(s) Action Marker required 062825- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 063007 Mr LEE Ching-hang

063008- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 063312 The Hong Kong (LC Paper No. CB(4)768/17-18(06) (Chinese version Chinese Importers' only)) and Exporters' Association

063313- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 063614 Mr SIN Hiu-pan Paper No. CB(4)768/17-18(11) (Chinese version only))

063615- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 063858 The Association of Hong Kong Professionals

063859- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 064149 Savantas Policy Institute

064150- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 064437 香港公共管治學會 Paper No. CB(4)757/17-18(08) (Chinese version only)) 064438- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 064751 Hong Kong Jewelry Manufacturers' Association

064752- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 065006 Mr Tony PANG Paper No. CB(4)768/17-18(12) (Chinese version Chor-fu only))

065007- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 065315 Hong Kong Paper No. CB(4)757/17-18(04) (Chinese version Economic & Trade only)) Association

065316- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 065452 雲港台青年交流促 Paper No. CB(4)757/17-18(01) (Chinese version 進會 only))

065453- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 065651 Mr FAN Yat-ho

065652- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 065958 Mr CHEUNG Sze- chung

- 11 -

Time Speaker(s) Subject(s) Action Marker required

065959- Deputy Chairman Meeting arrangement 070102 Administration

070103- Deputy Chairman Dr LEUNG's views on the constitutional and legal 070943 Dr Priscilla LEUNG basis of the Bill and the Administration's response. Administration

070944- Deputy Chairman Mr CHAN's concerns on whether the Bill would 071555 Mr CHAN Chi- contravene Article 18 of the Basic Law and the chuen Administration's response. Administration

071556- Deputy Chairman Dr KWOK's concerns on the constitutional and legal 072239 Dr KWOK Ka-ki basis of the Bill and the Administration's response. Administration

072240- Deputy Chairman Mr CHOW's views on the implementation of the co- 072510 Mr Holden CHOW location arrangement at the WKS.

072511- Deputy Chairman Dr LO's views on the economic benefits to be brought 072925 Ir Dr LO Wai-kwok by the XRL to Hong Kong and his concerns over the progress of the scrutiny work of the Bills Committee.

072926- Deputy Chairman Mr WONG's views on the implementation of the co- 073506 Mr WONG Ting- location arrangement at the WKS and his enquiry on kwong the immigration and customs clearance arrangement Administration at the WKS, and the Administration's response.

073507- Deputy Chairman The Administration's response to the views expressed 073949 Administration by deputations/individuals at the meeting.

Session four 080338- Deputy Chairman Introduction 080816

080817- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 081122 The Confucian Paper No. CB(4)868/17-18(01) (Chinese version Academy only))

081123- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 081435 Civic Party Paper No. CB(4)768/17-18(05) (Chinese version only))

081436- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 081740 The Young Civic

- 12 -

Time Speaker(s) Subject(s) Action Marker required 081741- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 081926 Mr LAI Tak-keung Paper No. CB(4)733/17-18(53) (Chinese version only))

081927- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 082117 Mr Arthur LEE Paper No. CB(4)969/17-18(02) (Chinese version only))

082118- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 082353 "Co-location" Paper No. CB(4)768/17-18(04) (Chinese version Concern Group only)) (Expert Group)

082354- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 082606 香港中國旅遊協會 Paper No. CB(4)733/17-18(54) (Chinese version only))

082607- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 082718 Mr LAU Kwok-yan

082719- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 082917 陳立志先生

082918- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 083011 Mrs Helen LAU

083012- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 083101 姚柏良先生

083102- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 083245 Mr Denny CHAN Kam-chuen

083246- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 083319 關振瀚先生

083320- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 083553 Tsuen Wan Kwai Paper No. CB(4)768/17-18(02) (Chinese version Tsing Residents only)) Association

083554- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 083734 盧騰光先生

083735- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 083837 劉有光先生

- 13 -

Time Speaker(s) Subject(s) Action Marker required 083838- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 083939 范秋華小姐

083940- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 084247 Mr CHENG Tat- hung

084248- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 084556 Mr Andy YU Tak-po

084557- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 084902 劉婉琴女士

084903- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views as set out in submission (LC 085210 Mr Gary TONG Chi- Paper No. CB(4)757/17-18(05) (Chinese version wah only))

085211- Deputy Chairman Presentation of views 085243 張慕真小姐

085244- Deputy Chairman The Administration's response to the views expressed 085735 Administration by deputations/individuals.

085736- Deputy Chairman Mr YIU's views on the economic benefits to be 090159 Mr YIU Si-wing brought by the XRL to Hong Kong, the Administration implementation of the co-location arrangement at the WKS and the time management of the Bills Committee.

In response to Mr YIU's enquiry, the Administration advised that WKS open days would be arranged after the completion of the construction works of the project.

090200- Deputy Chairman Mr KWOK's views on the constitutional and legal 090610 Mr KWOK Wai- basis of the Bill and the economic benefits to be keung brought by the XRL to Hong Kong.

090611- Deputy Chairman Ms LEE's support for the constitutional and legal 091011 Ms Starry LEE basis of the Bill, her views on the economic benefits to be brought about by the XRL to Hong Kong and the implementation of the co-location arrangement at the WKS.

091012- Deputy Chairman Dr CHEUNG's concern on the implementation of the 091600 Dr Fernando co-location arrangement at the WKS, the CHEUNG constitutional and legal basis of the Bill, and the Administration economic benefits to be brought by the XRL to Hong

- 14 -

Time Speaker(s) Subject(s) Action Marker required Kong, and the Administration's response.

091601- Deputy Chairman Further discussion on the related issues raised by Dr 092034 Dr KWOK Ka-ki CHEUNG above on the economic benefits to be Administration brought by the XRL to Hong Kong.

092035- Deputy Chairman Mr CHAN's concerns on the constitutional and legal 092446 Mr CHAN Chi- basis of the Bill and his views on the need for the chuen Administration to address the public's and Members' concerns that the Bill would contravene the Basic Law.

092447- Deputy Chairman Further discussion on the related issues raised by Dr 093149 Ms Tanya CHAN Fernando CHEUNG in respect of the economic Administration benefits to be brought by the XRL to Hong Kong.

093150- Deputy Chairman Mr HO sought clarification on the views expressed by 093559 Mr Steven HO deputations/individuals and showed his support for the implementation of the co-location arrangement at the WKS, as well as his views on the constitutional and legal issues relating to the Bill.

093600- Deputy Chairman Mr LUK's views on the overall benefits and 094004 Mr LUK Chung- convenience to be brought about by the XRL, his hung enquiry on the constitutional and legal basis of the Administration Bill as well as the Administration's response.

094005- Deputy Chairman Mr YICK's views on the financial returns to be 094419 Mr Frankie YICK brought by the XRL and the beneficial effects on the development of Hong Kong as a whole.

094420- Deputy Chairman The Administration's overall response to the views 095109 Administration expressed by deputations/individuals at the meeting.

Any other business

095110- Deputy Chairman Closing remarks 095127

Council Business Division 4 Legislative Council Secretariat 8 June 2020