INDUSTRY LAW NL NEWS NAUTILUS AT WORK Call for Brexit safeguards Report reveals scale of Stranded Russian crew All the news from the UK on UK certificates cabotage protection are given support branch conference
Volume 51 | Number 11 | November 2018 | £3.50 €3.70
COURTING TROUBLE? Nautilus survey reveals continued fears over criminalisation
1_cover_Nov18_SR checked.indd 1 17/10/2018 15:24 DON’T FORGET TO INVEST IN YOURSELF With only a few months left, what do you want to achieve by the end of the year? Make time for training and development with Lloyd’s Maritime Academy – have a look at these courses starting this autumn.
Certificate in Marine Consultancy Certificate in Marine Insurance Starts 5 November Starts 12 November Diploma in Marine Surveying Diploma in Harbour Masters Starts 6 November Starts 13 November Diploma in Ship Management Diploma in Marine Engineering Starts 6 November Starts 26 November NEW: Advanced Certificate in Designated NEW: Maritime Cyber Security Person Ashore Starts 4 December Starts 8 November NEW: Certificate in Artificial Intelligence in Shipping Starts 4 December
To find out more about our courses or to request a prospectus, contact us on [email protected] | +44 (0)20 7017 4483 | www.lloydsmaritimeacademy.com CONTENTS telegraphVolume 51 | Number 11 | November 2018
17 WELCOME
General secretary Mark Dickinson looks back at a busy month for the Union
NAUTILUS AT WORK
Nautilus urges minister to act on Brexit threat to CoCs Alarm as master is prosecuted 20 23 over ship’s fuel New moves to create more seatime for cadets Pay deals are keeping pace with in ation
HEALTH & SAFETY
Don’t disable ECDIS alarms, MAIB warns Fresh call for action on Full reports fertiliser cargoes on UK branch conference 30
STAFF ADVERTISING editor: Andrew Linington Century One Publishing Although the Telegraph exercises care and caution Incorporating the Merchant Navy chief sub-editor: Sarah Robinson Alban Row, 27-31 Verulam Road before accepting advertisements, readers are Journal and Ships’ Telegraph advised to take appropriate professional advice ISSN 0040 2575 Dutch correspondent: Hans Walthie St Albans, Herts AL3 4DG, UK before entering into any commitments such as production editor: June Cattini-Walker investments (including pension plans). Publication Published by Head of sales: of an advertisement does not imply any form of Nautilus International recommendation and Nautilus International Printed by Warners Midlands PLC DESIGN AND PRODUCTION Jonathan Knight cannot accept any liability for the quality of CPL 1 Cambridge Technopark tel: +44 (0) 1727 893 894 goods and services o ered in advertisements. Cambridge, CB5 8PB, UK direct: +44 (0) 1727 739193 Organisations o ering nancial services or insurance are governed by regulatory authorities tel: +44 (0) 1223 378000 email: [email protected] and problems with such services should be taken up web: www.cpl.co.uk web: www.centuryonepublishing.uk with the appropriate body.
November 2018 3 nautilusint.org
3-4_contents_SR checked.indd 3 18/10/2018 14:33 CONTENTS
36
NAUTILUS AT WORK
Nautilus ies the ag at Monaco Superyacht Show New survey reveals harassment in the superyacht sector Medals awarded to brave and dedicated seafarers WHERE'S MY All the news from the Nautilus TELEGRAPH? UK branch conference 40 If you have moved recently, your home Nautilus highlights the continued copy may still be trying to catch up with you. threat of criminalisation Nautilus Slater Fund scholars To let us know your new address, go to win awards for outstanding www. nautilusint.org and log in as a member, or contact our membership achievement department on +44 (0)151 639 8454 How the Union is working or membership@ nautilusint.org to improve inland navigation The membership team can also cancel conditions your print copy if you prefer to read the paper on the Telegraph app.
INTERNATIONAL
Research shows the scale of cabotage restrictions around the world
HISTORY GENERAL SECRETARY Mark Dickinson MSc (Econ)
The rst Royal Fleet Auxiliary vessel DEPARTMENT EMAILS general: [email protected] membership: [email protected] REGULARS legal: [email protected] telegraph: [email protected] Maritime book reviews industrial: [email protected] young members: [email protected] Crossword and quiz welfare: [email protected] professional and technical: The face of Nautilus [email protected] 51 Nautilus International also administers the Nautilus Welfare Fund and the J W Slater Fund, which are registered charities.
• Port of Rotterdam provides test site for • New Merchant Navy CBA agreed autonomous shipping • How your Union is involved with works councils and other forms • New staff restructuring plans at Heerema of employee engagement IN THIS Marine Contractors MONTH’S • Trigion taken to task for unsafe bridge and lock operations • Successful fi rst meeting for Nautilus NL • FNV Havens Youngsters supply Russian food for Kuzmin crew DUTCH national lay reps • Maroussia Janssen wins Nautilus prize for the most PAGES • European off shore sector under the microscope p54 socially-minded student • Employer and employee organisations • How Nautilus can help if your employer goes bankrupt introduce model terms of employment for inland navigation • Rivercruise Round Table results
nautilusint.org 4 November 2018
3-4_contents_SR checked.indd 4 17/10/2018 15:30 FOREWORD Welcome Nautilus general secretary Mark Dickinson looks back at a successful UK branch conference and Fair Treatment symposium, and considers what lies ahead for the Union and its members…
ast month the Council of Nautilus Also in October, I attended a meeting of the International met in Liverpool Sectoral Social Dialogue Committee on Maritime L for one of its regular governance Transport where we were briefed by the European meetings. One of the main Commission about Brexit and its impact on discussion points was my report on the ‘2030 seafarer certification. The European Commission Vision’, which is about responding to the changing stated that there are 22,000 holders of UK CoCs nature of the industry, society and our need to who could, in a no-deal Brexit scenario, face adapt and organise in these new realities. I am problems working on E - agged vessels when determined that the Union will remain strong their current endorsements expire. A briefing note as we face the future as a global trade union in is currently being prepared by our professional a global industry. I aim to be able to bring the and technical department which gives members conclusions of this debate to our members at next more information and advice, so please watch out year’s General Meeting in Rotterdam in October. for that. I’ve also written to the shipping minister The Council also bade a fond farewell to Nick and MCA to raise our concerns. Bramley, our international organiser and former It is sad to I also joined a new commission organised by senior national secretary from our Switzerland Unions 21 to examine the collective voice in the branch. Nick has been representing inland hear from workplace. This is an 18-month project exploring waterways and other maritime and shipping our survey how the collective voice at work can play a positive professionals in Switzerland for nearly four that 87% of role in the economy. The commission will gather decades, and was instrumental in bringing them evidence, encourage research and create a into Nautilus International membership in 2011. our members series of recommendations and examples for Alongside the Council meeting, the UK fear being how collective voice can be re-imagined in an branch held its annual conference and industry criminalised, ever-changing economy. symposium. In a change from our usual format, Finally, last month I welcomed new research the branch activities report was presented by and we are by Seafarers’ Rights International (SRI) on several staff members who work behind the scenes working on ‘Cabotage Laws of the World’. As part of our and don’t usually get to step into the limelight. new ways to Jobs, Skills and the Future campaign, Nautilus They did a fantastic job and did the Union proud. has been urging governments to introduce In the afternoon, the symposium focused on protect and cabotage laws to promote employment and our strategic campaign to highlight the increasing support them training opportunities in their coastal trades and criminalisation of maritime professionals. An domestic maritime activity. The evidence from excellent panel of speakers presented some initial this research is that 80% of maritime states have findings from a Nautilus survey of members, some form of cabotage regulation to support local investigated some recent cases of unfair treatment shipping industries, ensuring the retention of and looked at what is currently being done to skilled maritime workers, promoting safety, and support and protect seafarers. It is sad to hear that bolstering national security and resilience. so many of our members – 87% in our survey – still fear being criminalised, and we are working on new Certication after Brexit: see pages 28-29. ways to support and protect them in future. Cabotage: see pages 38-39.
November 2018 5 nautilusint.org
5_welcome_SR edit.indd 5 17/10/2018 15:32 LETTERS
What’s on your mind? Tell your colleagues in Nautilus International – and the wider world of shipping. Keep your letter to a maximum 300 words if you can – though longer contributions will be considered. Use a pen name or just your membership number if you don’t want to be identifi ed – say so in an accompanying note – but you must let INBOX the Telegraph have your name, address and membership number. Your space to join the debate on the issues Send your letter to the Editor, Telegraph, Nautilus International, 1&2 The Shrubberies, George Lane, that matter to maritime professionals South Woodford, London E18 1BD, email telegraph@ nautilusint.org or fax to +44 (0)20 8530 1015. Forced retirement left nasty taste
urther to member was approximately 20% worse ETO, and then ETO up until up being treated by employers number 157963’s off fi nancially over a -month September . Over years’ it’s like going back to the F letter in the period. There was no possibility service 1910s/1920s. September 2018 of my SEA not changing, it was I didn’t even receive a decent Neil W. Harrison Telegraph regarding BP Shipping, that or no job. retirement letter, just ‘you have Membership number 429731 my own situation was somewhat I left my last vessel in July , served beyond retirement similar last year. with leave earned taking me age, you must now retire, best My company’s policy (Swire to mid-September. Just prior to wishes in future endeavours, etc’ Brittany Ferries acifi c Ship Management of my leave expiring, I received an contained in the DF letter from has form with Singapore) was retirement at email from ‘Human esources’ the head of H who I had never age 60. When I reached the age advising that I was being ‘retired’ met. And certainly no thought non-French flags of in September , I was at the end of my leave. to any form of retirement With reference to the feature Low asked if I did want to retire. No uestion if, but or maybe, memento, however small. costs, low standards? October My personal circumstances at I was retiring. The email had an All the above has left a very Telegraph), this article includes the time dictated that I could attached PDF copy, reiterating I nasty taste in my mouth. So the claim ‘Brittany Ferries has not afford to retire, and my was being ‘retired’. Interesting ended a -year career at sea, traditionally used the French employment continued by to note that as I had not ‘signed with a whimper, rather than a mainland ag the only previous mutual agreement. and returned the attached letter’ bang. exception to this policy occurred Whilst allowing me to immediately, another copy was Typical of our industry these in 2005.’ continue, the company changed emailed to me two days later. days. There is absolutely no way In , I served as Chief my Seafarer’s Employment I would point out that I joined I could recommend a career at Engineer on M otland, which Agreement, changing my S SM in June , serving with sea to anyone nowadays, because was chartered to Brittany Ferries, salary structure such that I them as radio offi cer, trainee of the way we ultimately end and operated for the summer season on the ortsmouth- Oustreham Caen route. The vessel The View From Muirhead retained the Swedish ag, with a www.thefreakywave.com supervising Swedish master, but the offi cers were from the , ratings from Eire, and catering staff French. As we were led to understand at the time, it was originally intended to be an all-French crew, but due to the threat of strike action by French offi cers the operation was handed to Denholm Ship Management, my then employers. Brian Milton Membership number 079757
nautilusint.org 6 November 2018 November 2018 7 nautilusint.org
6-8_lets_SR checked.indd 6 18/10/2018 09:46 absent from the article, is the routine Follow us Tell the truth about testing, at the insistence of P&I clubs, of Tweets of on Twitter @nautilusint recruits overseas as a part of a selection modern shipping process and condition of employment. the month To Mark Dickinson, our general secretary, Symptoms, particularly Hep C, do not Mark Dickinson I am extremely disappointed that you manifest themselves for decades and @Mdickinson1262 2 October 2018 should compare the bridge of an offshore given the recent availability of effective support vessel with the virtual reality of sea treatment of Hep C, testing should be life (Welcome, September Telegraph). That welcomed, providing treatment is made position has its own difficulties like all areas available to those who fail. of sea life, one of which might be arranging The P&I club position would be credible their 3/4 weeks on/off routine. in these countries if vaccinations were We’ve assembled a brilliant panel of speakers To compare that to deepsea trading of offered free for Hep A and B and referral on Fair Treatment of Seafarers at our industry symposium @nautilusint & we will be joined by any rank is, I’m afraid, demeaning. To join for treatment for those who contract @HelenKelly_LL via video. Packed room too. a ship not knowing how long it will be hepatitis. The reality is that the medical before leave beckons, to spend months on tests of new entrants and serving Nautilus Intl @nautilusint end never stepping foot ashore, working in seafarers in some countries would not 2 October 2018 some trades like the chemical tankers, long be acceptable in developed countries Staff member gruelling hours, is, I’m afraid, far from the without willing consent. Aaron McTaggart reality that you promote. Allan Graveson presents part of the Branch Report May I suggest that promoting Utopia Membership number 143112 to members at as you do, and not the realism, is the #UKBranch. reason seafaring is no longer an appealing profession. Fair Pay At Sea Rotor technology @FairPayAtSea 27 September 2018 I do appreciate that nowadays the Happy 70th birthday @IMOHQ on percentage of our members employed in is nothing new #WorldMaritimeDay and today all in the #maritime British companies is minor compared to my world should ask themselves if the current level days – 1952 to 1997 – but it is important that I was slightly amused to see in the October of the seafarers’ minimum wage is true to the post-war determination to build a better world? honesty comes into the equation. Selling Telegraph article Maersk tanker trials sail #FairPayAtSea fairpayatsea.org Utopia from a market stall nowadays will in power that the company’s chief technical no way benefit British shipping. officer Tommy Thomassen claimed the Nautilus Intl Peter Bennison Maersk Pelican rotors were ground-breaking. @nautilusint 25 September 2018 Nautilus is delighted to welcome the Seafarers’ Membership number 061154 I wonder if he has heard of the German Rights International report on global cabotage engineer Anton Flettner. He experimented laws. 80% of world’s coastal nations protect their with rotors on the converted schooner maritime infrastructure with these laws @ITFglobalunion #seafarers #WorldCabotageStudy No hepatitis tests Buckau in 1920. As a result, the German Admiralty gave orders for the purpose- Shipwrecked Mariners without advice built rotor ship Barbara to be constructed. @ShipwreckedSoc 24 September 2018 She was built in Bremen in 1924 and run Have you enjoyed seeing the photos from our annual competition, #UltimateSeaView? on the fruit service of the Sloman Line. and treatment Well, now you can buy a 2019 calendar featuring There is an entries from previous years! Go to christmas- I was disappointed to see the statement interesting cards.org.uk/shipmariners/ to find out more by the UK P&I Club concerning hepatitis rotor ship Maritime UK (page 16, September Telegraph) go article on page @MaritimeUK unchallenged – be it Hepatitis A, B or C. 398 of Shipping 3 September 2018 Vaccination against Hep A and B is Wonders of the Congratulations to available but not routinely paid for by World, volume our Council member, @Mdickinson1262 shipowners. Hepatitis C is routinely 1, edited by of @nautilusint, for attributed to drug users and sexual Clarence being awarded the contact, whereas the current inquiry in Winchester Merchant Navy Medal. the UK demonstrates that Hep C has prev- and published #MerchantNavyDay iously been contracted from unscreened by The SuperYacht News contaminated blood transfusions and Amalgamated Press in about 1938. I still @SaltySeadog 17 September 2018 blood products. There is also a potential for have my father’s copy and attach a photo The Howorths: Seeking to recruit Superyacht crew @nautilusint the only trade union and mother to child infection: rarely referred to of the Barbara. professional association operating globally because it is rare. Don Johnston for superyacht crew will have representatives What is particularly disturbing, and Membership number 56609 attending this year’s @mys_monaco @YachtPhoto nautilusint.org 6 November 2018 November 2018 7 nautilusint.org
6-8_lets_SR checked.indd 7 17/10/2018 15:37 LETTERS Could you be a Balmoral volunteer?
The March 2018 Telegraph reported the people needed to lead and share their volunteers to come in to help us manage difficulties facing M Balmoral. Sadly, experience in these activities. the ship and later help us with project the charity which owns the classic coastal The berth outside the M Shed Museum management, and to plan and oversee the excursion ship advises that insufficient in Bristol is only available in the work needed to upgrade her for a return progress has been made for her to return winter, and uncertainties over summer to passenger carrying service. to seagoing service in . berthing and timing have frustrated the We continue developing M Balmoral M Balmoral needs a . m upgrade development of onboard activities and as a static venue in Bristol our open days but before the Heritage ottery Fund thus the ability to start serious fund- have been very popular as well as for will entertain a grant towards this work raising. The dedicated maintenance filming. Her next role is in Stan and Ollie they re uire community and educational team have kept the ship in warm lay-up, as the ship in which aurel and Hardy activities to be developed around the ship enabling her to be moved across the arrive in Ireland Our aim is still to get as a static venue in Bristol. This re uires harbour under her own power. M Balmoral back sailing, but timing is the charity to widen its scope, with new Our immediate need is for new uncertain. olunteer or join our mailing list via www.mvbalmoral.org.uk. If you feel Beautiful view you could take on a senior role in moving the project forward, please contact of old and new Mike on or email I took this photo in Haroldswick, [email protected] Unst, in Shetland on a September Our My Donate appeal fund Sunday this year. It caught my eye also remains open at tinyurl.com/ seeing a modern oil ship (Bibby give2Balmoral . Sapphire) sheltering in the bay in Dick Clague front of an old Viking longship. [email protected] Steven Spence on behalf of MV Balmoral Fund Ltd
Participants wanted for piracy research HAVE YOUR SAY As an avid Telegraph reader and current out in line with the protocol that has been Last month we asked: doctoral student at ueen’s niversity approved by ueen’s niversity Belfast, as Is LNG the best way for shipping to reach its emission reduction targets? Belfast, I would like to put a call out to well as including a good level of exibility to Poll results are pictured below. seafarers who would be able to participate in suit the re uirements of the participant. a new stage of my research. The entirety of my research project seeks I am looking for seafarers particularly to investigate the role of I Clubs and their % masters or SSOs who have worked within relationship to counter-piracy practices, 3 the High isk Area and utilised Best such as the BM now in its fifth edition. By 4 Management ractices at any time since ensuring the voices of seafarers are heard, 0 N their inception, to interview about their you will be contributing to new research on
experiences of it. this element of counter-piracy that seeks % 7 I am also seeking participants who have to contribute to the wider conversation on 5 s experienced piracy off the Horn of Africa to seafarer safety. e Y discuss the operational responses and their If you are interested, or would like to experiences of support. know more, please drop me an email to There are varying levels of anonymity that [email protected]. This month we ask: can be selected by anyone who wishes to Jessica Simonds Would you like to see cabotage participate and all interviews will be carried Membership number 1208915 restrictions in your country’s waters? (See report, pages 38-39) Vote now at: www.nautilusint.org nautilusint.org 8 November 2018
6-8_lets_SR checked.indd 8 17/10/2018 15:37 NAUTILUS AT WORK
NAUTILUS COUNCIL ELECTIONS Deadline day! If you want to stand as a candidate for the Nautilus Council elections, don’t forget that nomination papers need to completed and returned by 1700hrs on Monday 19 November. Contact assistant general secretary Ronnie Cunningham at NEWS the Wallasey o ce with any queries. Union calls for special Brexit safeguards for UK certicates
Nautilus has urged the UK government European Maritime Safety Agency (EMSA) submit their endorsement renewals now if to seek special transition arrangements in the event of a ‘no-deal’ scenario. ‘Whilst they have any concerns.’ to ensure that British seafarer certificates the Commission is prepared to prioritise With an increasingly limited timescale in continue to be recognised within the re-recognising the UK, the process can which to put the necessary arrangements European Union following Brexit. only begin after the UK’s withdrawal and into place, Mr Dickinson urged the In a letter to shipping minister Nusrat the success of the process will be very minister to seek a transitional period Ghani, general secretary Mark Dickinson dependent upon EMSA being presented with for seafarers and their employers and to warned that the Union is increasingly all the relevant and up to date information explore the possibility of including special concerned about the threat that the UK’s about UK compliance,’ Mr Dickinson arrangements for the UK in an amended EU withdrawal from the EU poses to the stressed. directive on seafarer certification. current mutual certificate recognition ‘It was also clear from Commission Nautilus also asked the minister for arrangements. briefing that in the event of a no-deal Brexit, assurances that action is being taken to Nautilus took part in a European sectoral , certificate holders and their tackle existing Maritime & Coastguard social dialogue committee meeting in employers will potentially face significant Agency delays in processing certification which Commission officials explained problems when their current endorsements and to ensure that it will be able to cope the way in which UK compliance with the expire,’ he added. ‘The only advice the with any increase in demand arising from STCW Convention will be reassessed by the Commission could offer is that they should early renewals. UK agrees £1bn contracts for refit work on RFA ships
The UK government has announced a package of contracts worth more than £1bn to cover spares, repairs and maintenance work on 17 vessels from the Royal Fleet Auxiliary and the Royal Navy’s survey and hydrographic eet. Ministers say the contracts will sustain more than 700 jobs across the UK. They are worth an estimated £619m for Cammell Laird in Birkenhead to support RFA tankers and £239m for A&P in Falmouth to support the RFA’s Bay class landing ships, as well as RFA Argus and HMS Scott. A further £150m is expected to go to UK Docks in Tyneside to support two survey ships and the ice patrol vessel The Royal Fleet Auxiliary casualty vessel Argus undergoing work at the A&P yard in Falmouth HMS Protector.
November 2018 9 nautilusint.org
9_News_SR checked.indd 9 17/10/2018 15:39 ARE YOU A SERVING OR RETIRED UK SEAFARER? Seafarer Support is a free confidential telephone and online referral service helping to support serving and former UK seafarers and their families in times of need 0800 121 4765
BSc www.seafarersupport.org www.facebook.com/seafarersupport @seafarersupport MARINE OPERATIONS
CENTURY ONE PUBLISHING I S THE UK’S BRIGHTEST Is it time to consider AWARD-WINNING upgrading your HND or CONTRACT PUBLISHING Foundation Degree? AND ADVERTISING SALES AGENCY. W E WORK EXCLUSIVELY Our one year top-up programme WITH MEMBERSHIP will broaden your knowledge of ORGANISATIONS GENERATING the Marine Operations sector ADVERTISING REVENUES and enhance your C V. AND MANAGING ALL OR PART OF THE Enrolling for PUBLISHING FUNCTION January 2019 T o p l a n y our a d ca m p a ig n in T e l e g r a p h m a g a z ine conta ct:
J onny K nig h t Call us on: 0191 427 3616 t: 0 1 7 2 7 7 3 9 1 9 3 www.stc.ac.uk Email: [email protected] e : jonathan@ centuryonepublishing.uk w : w w w.centuryonepublishing.uk /SouthShieldsMarineSchool /SouthShieldsMarineSchool @ssmarineschool /SouthShieldsMarineSchool /SouthShieldsMarine
nautilusint.org 10 November 2018 NAUTILUS AT WORK
In brief
Philippines acts: the Philippines maritime authority says it has taken action to ensure its seafarer certi cates continue to be recognised by the European Union. Ocials said changes have been made to address almost 60 issues raised during a European Maritime Safety Agency audit.
Machinery decline: there has been a ‘dangerous’ decline in Matt carries the standard at St Paul’s the standard of equipment being Recently-quali ed navigating ocer Matt Banks Matt was the rst Trinity House/Jubilee Sailing tted to new ships, the was chosen to carry the Merchant Navy standard Trust cadet. He trained at Warsash, qualifying in International Technical Tanker at this year’s UK Annual National Service for August this year, and is now keen to work in Forum has warned. It says Seafarers. He is pictured with Nautilus general oceanographic research. seafarers’ lives are being put at secretary Mark Dickinson, professional and ‘It was a real privilege to carry the Merchant risk because of quality problems technical ocer David Appleton and Council Navy standard,’ he said. ‘Seafaring runs through with vital items of machinery such member Thomas Cardy at the event, held at St our family, and to represent them here is quite as windlasses. Paul’s Cathedral in London. an honour.’ Stress worry: stress is the biggest concern in UK workplaces, according to the TUC’s 12th Union sounds alarm biennial survey of trade union health and safety reps. Bullying and harassment came second, over emissions case followed by overwork, slips, trips and falls, and violence and Nautilus International has raised concerns But defence lawyer Bertrand Coste argued intimidation. over the prosecution of a cruiseship master by that the European environment rules the French authorities on charges of breaching unfairly distinguish between cruiseships and Scrubber surge: scrubbers European air pollution legislation. cargoships, which have higher sulphur limits. have now been tted to or In the first case of its kind, prosecutors have He sought to have the trial annulled on the ordered for more than 1,850 ships called for a , fine to be imposed on the basis of alleged procedural errors, with the in the world eet, classi cation Captain Evans Hoyt, master of the O Cruises company contending that the . limit applies society DNV-GL has revealed. It vessel A ura, and the vessel’s owners with only to passenger ferries providing regular warned owners still to commit to the company to pay , of the penalty. services to European destinations. scrubbers that ‘the decision to Judgment is expected on 26 November. Nautilus general secretary Mark Dickinson invest should be made yesterday’. The case comes as Nautilus revealed said he was concerned by the prosecution. the results of a new survey showing that ‘As our new survey shows, criminalisation Collision probe: the UK criminalisation remains a major worry for continues to be a significant concern within the Marine Accident Investigation maritime professionals, with nearly industry and it would set a worrying precedent Branch has launched a probe into worried about the risk of prosecution. to hold a master responsible for fuel uality,’ he a collision between the Red The Marseilles court heard that a spot check pointed out. Funnel ferry Red Falcon and the on the ship during a port call in March found ‘Whilst we support the drive to improve motor cruiser Phoenix o Calshot, that it was burning bunker fuel with a . shipping’s environmental performance, we do Hampshire, on 29 September. sulphur content and that this exceeded the question the decision by the French authorities . European limit. rosecutor Franck agier to target a cruiseship and its master in this Canal record: the Panama told the court that the company had ‘wanted to way,’ he added, ‘and we will raise our concerns Canal has announced a record save money at the expense of everyone’s lungs’ with the International Maritime Organisation, year, with trac through the and the master ‘knew for a fact’ that the fuel through the International Federation of Ship waterway rising 9.5% over the taken on in Barcelona was illegal. Masters’ Associations.’ past 12 months to 442m tonnes.
November 2018 11 nautilusint.org
11_News_SR checked.indd 11 17/10/2018 15:41 NAUTILUS AT WORK Union seeking WELFARE SITE VISIT
cadets’ views Nautilus Council chairman Ulrich Jurgens, vice Cadet members are being invited chairman Wilco van Hoboken, trustee directors to take part in a new Nautilus Steve Clinch and Henk Lafebre, and assistant survey to provide an updated general secretary Ronnie Cunningham are insight into the issues a ecting pictured right during a visit to the Union’s Merchant Navy trainees. Mariners’ Park residential and care facilities in The Union has launched the Wallasey last month. The tour of the 16-acre site online survey to get feedback on included a look at the two new bungalows recently key elements of cadets’ built for veteran seafarers and the 12-apartment experiences, and to build on building funded by the ITF Seafarers’ Trust which is similar research undertaken in due to open early in the new year, as well as some 2004 and 2010. of the improved care home facilities. The condential questionnaire – which can be accessed through the Nautilus website – covers Emission controls ‘are such issues as pay, career propsects, accommodation, and quality of training. posing safety hazards’ ‘We hope all cadet members will take part so we can get a Nautilus members have raised concerns over without sufficient power to cope with extreme fresh perspective on the needs of safety problems arising from measures to conditions at sea. those who represent the future of reduce emissions from shipping. ‘Unfortunately, the easiest and cheapest our industry,’ said strategic Last month’s meeting of the Union’s way to reduce emissions of CO2 is to reduce organiser Martyn Gray. Professional and Technical Committee the power of the engine,’ Mr Appleton noted. heard that compliance with the low-sulphur ‘The IMO’s guidelines on minimum propulsion regulations has created significant technical power do not re uire vessels to be sufficiently Council sets challenges – including incidents of power loss powered to deal with a force 8, as this is new rates when changing fuels, lubrication issues, filter considered an extreme weather condition problems and leaks. which a vessel is very unlikely to meet during Nautilus Council members have Phil Lees said some engineers are having normal operations.’ approved proposals for increases change fuel filters on an almost hourly basis Paul Minter said he considered this to be a in membership subscription rates and are reporting severe wear of fuel pumps disturbing and unrealistic policy. ‘In winter to take e ect from 1 January and high rates of pipework erosion as a result of around the UK, there are force 8 conditions for 2019. They will be matched by the lower levels of lubricity in low sulphur fuel. about 30% of the time,’ he added. increases in the levels of rofessional and technical officer David Malcolm Graves said research had shown that professional protection provided Appleton said that the International Federation extreme weather is becoming more fre uent by the Union. of Ship Masters’ Associations has raised alarm and wave heights are increasing. Ships need the The contribution rates for most at the International Maritime Organisation over power to be able to cope with such deteriorating membership categories will energy-saving proposals that could leave ships conditions, he added. increase broadly in line with ination – between 2.1% and 2.5%. However, they will remain TRIBUTES PAID TO SWISS OFFICIAL unchanged for cadets and yacht Nautilus Council members paid tribute to the Union’s crew. Swiss-based international ocer Nick Bramley, In line with the subscription pictured with general secretary Mark Dickinson, as he increases, the maximum levels of retired last month. nancial support provided to ‘Nick has been a passionate defender of the members under the professional interests of inland navigation workers, and his protection provided by the Union knowledge of the issues that a ect them is will rise from £122,300 to encyclopaedic,’ said Mr Dickinson. ‘With his service as £124,600. president of the ITF and ETF inland navigation sections, Full details will be sent to he has taken their struggles to the highest levels, as members and will be available on well as ghting to build membership and organise in a the Union’s website. very challenging sector.’
nautilusint.org 12 November 2018 November 2018 13 nautilusint.org
12-13_news_SR checked.indd 12 17/10/2018 15:42 DFDS APPRENTICESHIPS HIT ‘TOP 20’ MARK In brief Five apprentice ratings are pictured onboard the Alastair Coupar: tributes DFDS ferry Dunkerque have been paid to former Seaways celebrating the shipmaster Professor Alastair end of their training last Coupar – who founded the month. A total of 20 Seafarers International Research apprentices – 17 deck and Centre at the University of Cardi three engineering – have – following his death last month now passed through the at the age of 87. Prof Coupar scheme since its launch in served with Denholm Shipping 2012. before pursuing an academic career. He also helped to establish the Seafarers’ Rights MNTB move to oer International think-tank. Robo research: the UK more cadet seatime government has awarded £1m funding to the Maritime & Nautilus has welcomed the launch of a new berthing shortfall and we need to get better Coastguard Agency and the Merchant Navy Training Board (MNTB) at thinking outside the box.’ Department for Transport, in scheme to pilot ‘industrial placements’ for She said feedback from the first seven collaboration with the National UK cadets in an effort to combat challenges ‘industrial placement’ cadets had been very Oceanography Centre’s Marine in getting seatime. positive and they had gained some vital Robotics Innovation Centre, to The new arrangements are initially being experience. ‘When cadets are onboard the accelerate research into trialled by final phase engineer cadets in in oyal Navy vessels in a dry-dock scenario, regulating the autonomous and partnership with the Royal Navy, Chiltern they are exposed to new machinery, different ‘smart’ shipping industries. Maritime, Trinity House and the UK procedures and protocols and new routines, Maritime & Coastguard Agency. which makes for a more well-rounded, New helpline: Singapore- The first six-week placements have comprehensive training experience,’ she based shipmanagement rm been offered to cadets on charity training added. Synergy has launched a free 24/7 programmes who are not sponsored by Nautilus professional and technical officer counselling service for seafarers: companies with ships with training berths, David Appleton added: ‘This is a positive iCALL. Synergy Group CEO Captain and there are plans to extend the scheme to development and something that we have Rajesh Unni said statistics show deck cadets at a later date. been seeking for some time. If the industry that almost one in ve deaths at MNTB director Kathryn Neilson is going to hit the targets of increased cadet sea are suicide and the industry commented: ‘Securing quality training intakes that have been promised in return needs to do more to address berths for cadets has always been a challenge, for SMarT Plus, we certainly need to open up mental health issues. especially for charity cadets. Whilst offering new opportunities for trainees to get their quality sea time, we are also addressing the practical experience and seatime.’ Gas deaths: the Apostleship of the Sea has provided support to crew members onboard the CONCERN OVER MEDICINE CARRIAGE Maltese-agged tanker Key Nautilus has received reports from members problems for seafarers with long tours of duty, Fighter after two seafarers died about problems arising from carrying medicines with the UK requiring individuals to obtain a following exposure to toxic gas into foreign countries when joining ships. licence for carrying certain controlled drugs while the ship was sailing in The Professional and Technical Committee when travelling for three months or more. ballast from Norway to the UK. heard that concerns have been raised over the ‘This is putting a lot of onus on the individual diering regulations applying to the types and seafarer to check the requirements and get all Euro protest: European quantities of medicines that are permitted. the paperwork straight, especially if they are shipowners and shipbuilders have Even some medicines that are available over having to join the ship at short notice,’ he added. made a joint call for the European the counter or freely prescribed in one country Deputy general secretary Marcel van den Commission to take ‘concrete and may be prohibited in others, professional and Broek said the problem could be addressed by decisive action’ to combat technical ocer David Appleton said. ensuring that the ship’s medical chest is stocked ‘massive subsidies’ and unfair Russell Downs noted that there are particular to cope with individual needs. competition from the Far East. nautilusint.org 12 November 2018 November 2018 13 nautilusint.org
12-13_news_SR checked.indd 13 17/10/2018 15:42 NAUTILUS AT WORK
In brief P&O FERRIES PRESSED ON PENSIONS
VGG rejection: Nautilus is seeking further talks with VGG (Singapore) after members voted overwhelmingly to reject proposals for a temporary 6% pay cut. National organiser Steve Doran said members were angry that their salaries are being reduced when other oshore rms are restoring conditions.
Crown deal: following talks Pictured above are Nautilus reps attending last newbuild plans. Nautilus national ferry organiser between Nautilus representatives month’s P&O Ferries joint consultative committee Micky Smyth said there had also been extensive and Crown Crewing (Jersey), the meeting in Dover. Items discussed included discussion on pension provision, and of the Union’s Union has accepted a ‘full and onboard services restructuring, deck and technical call for members to be part of the Ensign Master nal’ 2.8% pay oer. The manning, sickness reporting, study leave and Trust scheme. company has also agreed to investigate a possible 4/4 rota in the winter months and further Pay talks seek to keep research into debrillators.
Bibby consult: members pace with inflation serving with Bibby Maritime Crewing Services on Pay settlements secured by Nautilus so far this have managed to negotiate increases in places accommodation units are being year are worth an average of just over 2.6%, and the recovery of some terms and conditions,’ consulted on a 2% pay oer. The Council members heard last month. he added. Union has recommended Head of organising Garry Elliott told the ‘We have also continued to press employers acceptance, on the basis that it is meeting that the Union has been seeking to to provide members with quality access to the the best that can be achieved ensure that members’ salaries keep pace with UK internet at a cost that is not prohibitive and, as a through negotiations. in ation. Average increases have ranged from minimum, to ensure that speeds and company 2.93% in the cruiseship and deepsea sectors, restrictions permit access to personal emails,’ Mr PG pay: Nautilus is consulting to 2.85% in the ferry sector and 1.76% for the Elliott added. members employed by Pritchard- offshore industry. He said Nautilus has made significant Gordon Tankers (Guernsey) on a Negotiations have also sought to deliver long- recruitment gains in the superyacht sector, and ‘full and nal’ pay oer which term agreements and to restore cuts to terms officials are also seeking to boost membership would deliver a 2.6% increase, and conditions in the offshore sector, in line with in the windfarm industry after signing the first along with an increased free the policy objectives set by Council, Mr Elliott collective bargaining agreement for crews in the internet allowance. said. sector. Officials have held a series of meetings ‘It has been a challenging time in the offshore with some of the biggest windfarm vessel Solstad package: members sector, but Nautilus has sought with some operators and met members at key ports around serving with Solstad Oshore are success to minimise the redundancies, and we the UK. being consulted on a 1.5% pay oer, backdated to 1 April, and on a voluntary redundancy scheme WINDSTAR VISIT and the potential to reintroduce Nautilus national organiser Jonathan Havard is 4/4 rotas. pictured left with Captain Roman Krstanovic, master of the 9,975gt Windstar Cruises vessel Havila oer: following talks Star Breeze, during a ship visit in London last on this year’s pay and conditions month. Mr Havard also met other members claim, Havila Marine Guernsey onboard to discuss issues including the has oered a 2% pay rise for forthcoming pay and conditions claim, as well as ocers. Nautilus is consulting meeting sta from the recruitment company members on the proposals. Viking Crew.
nautilusint.org 14 November 2018 November 2018 15 nautilusint.org
14-15_news_SR checked.indd 14 17/10/2018 15:44 In brief
CalMac liaison: Nautilus national ferry organiser Micky Smyth and Caledonian MacBrayne liaison ocers Callum Bryce, Nautilus general secretary Mark Dickinson joined opposition transport minister Andy McDonald and Gavin Jakeman, Archie RMT general secretary Mick Cash at a ‘save our seafarers’ fringe meeting at this year’s Labour party MacDonald and Iain MacKenzie conference. The meeting, which was organised by the RMT, discussed Labour party policies on tackling met management last month for unfair competition and exploitation in the shipping industry, boosting employment and training of talks on issues including sickness levels, rostering, and recruitment British seafarers, and developing a new strategy for UK ports. and retention. Members’ salaries were increased by 3.5% in line with RPI in ation, as agreed in Nautilus warns of last year’s review.
Serco talks: Nautilus has met anger at RFA oer Serco Ferries management to begin discussions on this year’s Nautilus members serving with the Royal Fleet imposed austerity policy and current in ation pay claim, which seeks an award Auxiliary are being consulted on a pay and levels, but it is offered at a time when others in over the July RPI in ation rate of conditions offer which the Union has described the public sector – including the armed forces, 3.2% together with a more as deeply disappointing. police, prison officers, NHS and fire fighters structured rolling roster pattern. In talks at Navy Command HQ last month, are being offered more,’ he pointed out. ‘To rub National ferry organiser Micky RFA management offered a 1.5% increase for all salt into the wound, there is also the removal of Smyth said a formal response is ranks except Captain (X), who would receive automatic incremental progression to consider.’ now awaited from the company. a 1% increase and a one-off non-consolidated Nautilus has written to RFA Commodore payment of £406. Duncan Lamb to warn of members’ anger and DFDS rst: Nautilus reps have Nautilus national organiser Steve Doran frustration at the proposals. ‘We expressed our taken part in the rst DFDS joint said the offer represented the full extent of deep concern that the loyalty, professionalism consultative committee meeting. the remit given to RFA management and was and high levels of performance from our Subjects discussed included the described as being consistent with government members has not, at the very least, matched new collective bargaining pay policy. the offer made to others – especially those with agreement, training days, and Mr Doran said the Union had taken a ‘robust’ whom the RFA works shoulder to shoulder on a work and rest periods. position against the proposals. ‘The offer not daily basis,’ Mr Doran added. only falls short of our reasonable request for Members have been asked to respond to the Orkney rates: pay rates and an uplift to take into account previous years of consultation by 8 November. overtime were among the issues discussed at a meeting between VIEWS SOUGHT Nautilus and Orkney Ferries in Aberdeen last month to progress ON STENA CLAIM the agreement that ended the pay Nautilus members serving with Stena Line dispute earlier this year. have been asked to submit views on the contents of this year’s pay and conditions Gulfmark call: Nautilus is claim after management told the Union pressing Gulfmark management that they cannot aord to give an increase for a response to this year’s pay in line with September’s 3.5% in ation rate. and conditions claim, as well as National ferry organiser Micky Smyth Nautilus general secretary Mark Dickinson is pictured an update on the proposed said feedback from members is wanted to centre with Marshall Ainley, president of the Marine merger with Tidewater. help shape the Union’s formal claim ahead Engineers’ Benecial Association, left, and Don Marcus, of further negotiations due to take place in international president of the International Organisation Maersk meets: Nautilus has late October and mid-November. of Masters, Mates and Pilots, right, at the start of the arranged a partnership meeting Mr Smyth welcomed the ‘excellent’ news International Transport Workers’ Federation congress in with Maersk Supply in November that Stena Line has chosen the Ensign Singapore last month. A full report on the meeting will in a bid to progress talks on this scheme as its main pension provider. appear in the next Telegraph. year’s pay and conditions claim. nautilusint.org 14 November 2018 November 2018 15 nautilusint.org
14-15_news_SR checked.indd 15 17/10/2018 15:45 HEALTH & SAFETY MAIB warns ocers ‘Name and shame’ call not to silence alarms on reports Seafarers have been warned against disabling over the bridge from the master at midnight. Electronic Chart Display and Information Systems The master told the OOW to revise the route, Bulk carrier owners have suggested (ECDIS) alarms to prevent ‘annoyance and which he did on the ECDIS. The route was checked that the International Maritime distraction’ while on watch. visually but the results of the automatic check Organisation (IMO) should ‘name and The warning comes in the latest UK Marine route function were not inspected. shame’ flag states which fail to Accident Investigation Branch (MAIB) Safety The MAIB says there have been a number of publish accident investigation reports. Digest, which reports on a case in which a small groundings in recent years resulting from revised Delegates attending the annual bulk carrier became grounded on a sandbank for passage plans not being checked thoroughly. It meeting of the owners’ organisation six days. stressed the need for visual checks to be made on Intercargo expressed concern at ‘undue The MAIB said an inspection of the vessel’s larger scale ENCs and for the automatic check to delays’ in the production of casualty ECDIS found the system’s safety frame or ‘look be utilised. The report admits that some ECDIS investigation reports – highlighting the ahead’ was inactive and that its audible alarm had alarms ‘can appear unhelpful and distracting’ but continued lack of information about the been disabled. says they are ‘potential lifesavers’ in open waters loss of the Marshall Islands-agged The vessel had been following a planned track where monitoring of the ship's position is reliant bulker Stellar Daisy and its crew of 22 in on the ECDIS when the second officer had taken on the bridge watchkeeper alone. March 2017. Intercargo said it wanted to see ‘strict compliance’ with the IMO’s casualty ECDIS mistake led to grounding investigation code, and it questioned whether this should be backed up with a A 72,561dwt bulk carrier ran aground on a reef day after leaving Hong Kong to comply with the ‘naming and shaming enforcement after a test route was mistakenly uploaded onto charterer’s suggested route. However, the report process’. the ECDIS. says, ‘it appears likely that on the changeover of Outgoing chairamn John Platsidakis The Maltese-flagged Marbella suffered the route at sea, the test route was inadvertently said Intercargo supports the work of the damage to bottom shell plating and internal clicked and uploaded’. IMO, but is concerned about the structures in a ballast tank after grounding Electronic navigation charts were not checked practicality of recent regulations such as during a ballast passage from Hong Kong to for visual verification and the risks of sailing in ballast water management and Indonesia in September 2017. close proximity to the reef were not recognised, emission reduction measures. A Maltese flag state investigation found that it adds. Investigators said it was possible that ‘Policing the quality of the new the ship’s watchkeeper – who was alone on the the scale was not optimised and the reef was not compliant fuels seems to be a great bridge and navigating mainly by sight and radar viewable on the ECDIS, and that while ECDIS was challenge already, as it has proved – had failed to see the reef when he changed the primary means of navigation, ‘its extremely dicult to address the versy course to avoid some fishing vessels. innumerable functions were not used to their full serious recent problems with existing The original voyage plan had been changed a potential’. fuels,’ he added.
The Tunisian ferry Ulysse Ferry collides struck the anchored with boxship boxship CSL Virginia Clean-up and salvage operations were Image: Marine Nationale launched last month after a Tunisian ferry struck an anchored containership some 15 miles o the coast of Corsica. The 17,907gt ro-pax Ulysse was reported to have been sailing at 19 knots when it ran into the 54,592gt CSL Virginia during a voyage between Italy and Tunisia. No one was injured, but the collision resulted in a signicant fuel leak and 4km-long slick. Local authorities said that a judicial inquiry into the accident will be undertaken.
nautilusint.org 16 November 2018 November 2018 17 nautilusint.org
16-17_H&S_Nov18_SR checked.indd 16 18/10/2018 09:56 Insurers seek action to cut boxship res
Marine insurers are set to table proposals at the International Maritime Organisation for new measures to cut the risks posed by containership fires. The International Union of Marine Insurance (IUMI) said it is concerned at the potential for huge losses arising from incidents involving ultra- large containerships, and it is seeking to tighten SOLAS Convention fire protection requirements. ‘On large containerships where around 20% of boxes are empty, we are likely to see a combined cargo and hull value of around US$1.5bn, and that doesn’t include any wreck removal or pollution costs,’ said IUMI Emergency services deal with the decomposing cargo onboard Purple Beach Image: Haveriekommando president Dieter Berg. IUMI is seeking improved fire detection, monitoring and IMO urged to tackle extinguishing systems, as well as divisions such as bulkheads and hatch covers, above and below decks, to fertiliser hazards prevent fires from spreading. Meanwhile, Maersk Line has taken The International Maritime ammonium nitrate-based fertilisers as steps to improve the carriage of Organisation is facing a fresh call a Group B, rather than Group C, cargo dangerous goods following a review from accident investigators to tighten to more clearly reflect the risk of a conducted in response to the fire the rules governing the carriage of chemical reaction. onboard Maersk Honam in March, in fertiliser cargoes. BSU also called for the IMO to delete which five crew members died. Barely two months after an Isle the solid bulk cargo ‘non-hazardous’ ‘All cargo aboard the Maersk of Man probe into the loss of the definition suffix ‘because it fails to Honam was accepted as per the Bibby bulk carrier Cheshire revealed account for the hazards actually posed requirements of the International shortfalls in the existing regulations, during loading and carriage’. Maritime Dangerous Goods Code and a German report has recommended The investigation failed to determine stowed onboard the vessel action to close loopholes in the the cause of the cargo decomposition, accordingly,’ said head of fleet International Maritime Solid Bulk but the report criticises the decision to technology Ole Graa Jakobsen. Cargoes Code (IMSBC). carry out welding work in the vicinity ‘Despite this, as the fire originated The call comes in a report on of the cargo hold to attach additional in a cargo hold in front of the an incident in May 2015 when the D-rings to secure the load. accommodation which held several Marshall Islands-flagged vessel Purple BSU said the ship’s crew had containers with dangerous goods, it Beach had to be evacuated in the mistakenly assumed the cargo was on had an unbearably tragic outcome,’ German Bight when the decomposition fire, and the use of CO2 to deal with the he continued. ‘This clearly showed us of ammonium nitrate fertiliser caused incident ‘was not appropriate’ that the international regulations dense smoke, heat and fumes. However, investigators said the and practices with regards to The German investigation board, emergency procedures within the dangerous goods stowage needs to BSU, said ‘ambiguous’ rules resulted in cargo information given to the crew be reviewed in order to optimally the cargo being misleadingly classed as had only addressed the outbreak of protect crew, cargo, environment and not harmful. fire and made no mention of possible vessels.’ It urged the IMO to reclassify decomposition. nautilusint.org 16 November 2018 November 2018 17 nautilusint.org
16-17_H&S_Nov18_SR checked.indd 17 17/10/2018 15:50 INTERNATIONAL
In brief CANADA
Judgment call: a French Owners warn on plight of appeal court has dropped nes of €30,000 and €1m imposed on the crew held for over a year master and owner of a Liberian- agged bulk carrier who were A Canadian maritime union has claimed a the country’s waters. found guilty of ‘voluntary pollution’ major victory after the country’s government The union had filed more than lawsuits o the coast of Brittany in February agreed to clamp down on the employment of against the Canadian government complaining 2016. The court held that Liberia foreign seafarers in Canada’s coastal waters. that it was violating the temporary foreign had the rights to judge the case Following a long campaign by the Seafarers’ worker programme by systematically issuing under the terms of the Montego International Union of Canada (SIU), the work permits to non-Canadian crew members Bay Convention. government has changed the rules governing on hundreds of foreign ships engaged in the use of temporary foreign workers to ensure cabotage services. It uncovered evidence that Indian corridor: India has that Canadian seafarers retain the first right to some foreign seafarers were being paid as announced the creation of a be employed in any available jobs in the coastal little as C . . an hour while serving in maritime corridor 15 miles o its trades. Canadian coastal trades. west coast in a bid to cut the Under the new rules, Canadian seafarers will ‘This is a significant and hard-fought victory increasing number of serious have to be offered jobs before companies can for Canadian seafarers and the collective collisions between merchant ships gain a work permit to employ a foreign crew Canadian maritime industry,’ said SIU president and shing vessels, which are member for more than 30 days. The SIU says James Given. ‘The next step will be ensuring particularly prevalent o Kerala. the move will help to protect foreign seafarers that there are enforcement and regulatory The 20-mile corridor may from exploitation by ensuring that they have procedures in place to ensure these policy ultimately become a trac Canadian pay and conditions while working in changes are being strictly enforced.’ separation scheme.
Mexico move: French-owned Mexican operator Baja Ferries has taken delivery of the former French ferry Stena Carrier, which was on charter in the North Sea with P&O Ferries this summer. The 21,174gt vessel has been re-christened Mexico Star and will operate on a service between Mexico and California.
Master jailed: a Russian shipmaster has been jailed for four months by a Swedish court after RUSSIA prosecutors alleged that he had been drunk when the 7,138gt ITF helps stranded seafarers general cargoship BBC Lagos ran onto a sandbank o Helsingborg Netherlands-based International Transport May for unpaid bills. It is one at least eight ships while sailing from Lithuania to Las Workers’ Federation inspector Gijs Mol has gone owned by the Murmansk Shipping Company Palmas in August earlier this year. to the aid of the crew of a Russian ship who have which have been seized in recent months in ports been stranded in the port of Terneuzen since in Europe, the US, Asia and Africa as a result of Corsica boost: Corsica Ferries May. nancial problems a ecting the rm. is set to open new services He helped with local community e orts to The Seafarers Union of Russia has voiced between France and Sicily next provide the 21 seafarers onboard the 23,169dwt concern about the conditions being experienced April ahead of the expected bulk carrier Kuzma Minin, above, with food and by the ships’ crews, and the Russian Investigative renewal of public service contracts other essential supplies after they ran out of Committee has opened legal proceedings over for ‘lifeline’ operations between fresh fruit and vegetables and started to run low the non-payment of wages for more than three Marseilles and ve Corsican ports on water last month. months. The company has denied reports it will in October 2019. The Russian-agged vessel was arrested in le for bankruptcy.
nautilusint.org 18 November 2018 November 2018 19 nautilusint.org
18-19_int_SR checked.indd 18 17/10/2018 15:52 In brief
German slump: Germany’s merchant eet has shrunk by more than one-third in the past six years, according to new gures from the The 75,100gt Color Line cruiseferry Color Magic is one of two vessels which may leave the mainland register country’s shipowners. The German NORWAY share of the global orderbook has fallen from more than 25% in 2008 to just 2.3% now, and the owners Unions seek to head o blame the decline on nancing plan to ag-out ferries problems. Nigerian pledge: Nigeria’s Battle lines are being drawn in Norway nion president Johnny Hansen. maritime administration says it is for a final push by unions against the The unions took heart from the note in aiming to make the country the government’s plans to allow ferry company last month’s finance bill that, under current largest supplier of seafarers in west Color ine to switch two ferries from the NO subsidy arrangements, Color ine would not and central Africa and has domestic ag to the international NIS register be at a cost disadvantage against Denmark’s promised to ensure that the a move that could throw Norwegian international register DIS if it kept the two country’s cadets get seatime seafarers out of work and allow cheaper ships on the Norwegian mainland register. opportunities within the shortest foreign labour to be hired. ‘It’s a uestion of whether the current subsidy time possible. The government last month gave the arrangement is to be continued. If parliament final go-ahead to Color ine to re ag the two wants to continue it, there is no danger of Wages won: the International ferries which operate between Oslo and iel. agging out,’ Mr Hansen said. ‘This is an Transport Workers’ Federation has But at the same time it recommended that important partial victory for the Seafarers’ secured some US$324,000 in back the two ships stay under the NO register, as nion and our members.’ pay for 19 Russian and Ukrainian it would be more profitable with the current Terje Aasland, from Norway’s abour seafarers who had been stranded subsidy regime. arty, called the government’s decision on the Maltese-agged tanker ‘The government says it will allow NIS an ‘unnecessary and needless attack on Natig Aliyev in Denmark for eight registration of international ferries on fixed Norwegian seafarers’ and ‘a sad day for months. routes, so it’s now up to the Norwegian Norway as a maritime nation’. parliament to prevent several hundred jobs Lay-up toll: French oshore being sacrificed,’ said Norwegian Seafarers’ More on Norway: see feature, pages 46-47 support vessel operator Bourbon says continued depressed market NEW ZEALAND conditions have resulted in 185 of the 505 ships in its eet remaining CRUISESHIP MASTER FINED FOR RUNNING in lay-up over the rst half of the year, despite a slight increase in AGROUND IN MARITIME EXCLUSION ZONE the utilisation rate.
A French cruiseship master has been ned Prosecutors said L’Austral had 356 passengers Jobs scam: the Philippines NZ$30,000 (€16,874) after his vessel ran and crew onboard and was found to have had National Bureau of Investigation is aground in a UNESCO World Heritage site in New inadequate passage plans. The crew had failed seeking to prosecute two Italian Zealand’s sub-Antarctic islands. to monitor the ship’s position near navigational nationals and three Filipinos for Captain Regis Daumesnil was found guilty of hazards, and although the hull was punctured in ‘syndicated and large-scale illegal endangering human life and entering a three places during the incident, Capt Daumesnil recruitment of seafarers’. prohibited zone when the 10,944gt L’Austral ran had continued on the cruise schedule by sailing onto an uncharted rock at the Snares Islands in 154nm further south rather than return to the Italian alarm:Italian unions January 2017. nearest port. have demanded an urgent meeting The ship’s owners, Compagnie du Ponant, Maritime NZ regional compliance manager with ferry operator Liberty Lines were ned NZ$70,000 by the court in Mike Vredenburg said the case could have ended after it issued a redundancy notice Wellington after admitting that the ship had in tragedy and served as a ‘graphic warning’ of to 72 seafarers working on the entered a 300m exclusion zone around the the importance of passage planning for all parts service between the ports of islands. of a voyage. Messina and Reggio di Calabria. nautilusint.org 18 November 2018 November 2018 19 nautilusint.org
18-19_int_SR checked.indd 19 18/10/2018 09:47 SUPERYACHTS
admitted. ‘But the MCA Maritime & Coastguard Agency] and Nautilus are in discussion to facilitate and streamline this process, and the MCA is open-minded to improvements.' Commenting on the range of international regulations that had recently come into force to protect yacht crew, Mr Wendt said there were positive signs that owners were starting to pay more attention to their obligations. 'There is still a widespread assumption, however, that private yachts don't have regulations, and some people find it surprising you MARITIME FACETIME cannot have slaves onboard,' he added only partially joking. Masters and senior officers need to Nautilus International staged a lively event at this year’s make themselves aware of the various regulations, including the Large Yacht Monaco Yacht Show offering advice and support to Code, he added, ‘as they cover safe superyacht crews. DEBORAH MCPHERSON dropped in… manning, security, and stability of machinery, and it doesn't do any harm With the high-altitude artistry of a Red free legal support and an international for junior officers to be aware of these Arrows air display going on overhead, network of helpful connections, she as well.’ Nautilus aimed to bring a similar level pointed out but you must sign up Looking back on a successful three of expertise to its three-day drop-in before you go to sea. days of listening and information- session at the ACREW lounge in the 'The most important thing for sharing, Nautilus strategic organiser famous La Rascasse bar. seafarers is to ensure they know who Danny McGowan told the Telegraph: Jorg Wendt of their key contact is before they set sail,' It’s clear from what we have heard at Antibes-based she stressed. 'Often, when crew are Monaco that being prepared for the Nautilus partner D&B Services contacting us, it is too late.’ unexpected before you set off is really and Corine nion officials can also help crew important even if you think you are Archambaud of French union CFDT on issues as diverse as employment on a well-run yacht. contracts, working hours, sexual ‘Nautilus’s package of benefits and harassment and tax, Ms Archambaud protections are unmatched by any added. She cited a recent example other union or crew association. With where she had been called to help assistance from our colleagues in an abandoned charter yacht officer the unions affiliated to the Nautilus The event, from 26-28 September unfairly dismissed in Nice. Thanks Federation, access to our 24/7 2018, provided information on matters to support from the international helpline, legal support and worldwide such as sea service verification and network of unions, as well as directory of lawyers, joining Nautilus the impact of the Large Yacht Code, coastguard and port state control should be the first thing all maritime and emphasised the benefits of nion inspectors, the wages owed to the crew professionals do in the superyacht membership in the superyacht sector. member were paid. industry so they know where to go in Nautilus personnel were on hand Jorg Wendt of Antibes-based D&B an emergency.’ to share their knowledge and answer Services reminded visitors of the questions, alongside representatives Nautilus strategic importance of the Nautilus Service from the nion’s yacht sector partners organiser Danny ecord Books a free benefit of McGowan (left of D&B Services, Hemisphere, Sovren, picture) assisting membership and reported that, SA and oyonic and from two a visitor to the thanks to feedback from members, Nautilus drop-in unions in the Nautilus Federation: event efforts were underway to improve the CFDT (France) and SPH (Croatia). Image: Vana Bosto format of these. Corine Archambaud of CFDT spoke 'The wording is not as crystal clear of the help she provides to union as some people would wish it to be, members facing unfair dismissal and in terms of logging onboard seatime, abandonment. Belonging to a Nautilus standby time or whatever hours, and Federation union gives crews access to it is causing a lot of confusion,’ he
nautilusint.org 20 November 2018 November 2018 21 nautilusint.org
20-21_superyacht_SR checked.indd 20 17/10/2018 15:54 #METOO, SAY YACHT CREW Behind the glitz and glamour of the superyacht sector can be found some highly unsavoury behaviour, heard DEBORAH MCPHERSON at a special seminar…
The yachting industry must take action on sexual abuse and 'Yacht managers are telling me there is burnout, or people taking harassment, delegates were told at the Monaco Yacht Show 2018. a lot of sick leave,’ she reported. ‘Mental health conditions that can Research by the Professional Yachting Association (PYA) was exhibit as a result of abuse include depression, OCD, personality presented to the yacht show’s Sea Changes seminar in September, disorder and substance abuse.' showing that 40% of yacht crew have experienced unwanted sexual Having a safe place and someone to approach who can be trusted contact, mostly from colleagues. with confidential information is key to managing abuse, emphasised Drawing on a survey of yacht officers, interior crew the PYA speakers. Crew should also receive training on what bullying and shoreside staff, the findings showed abuse was not and harassment means, and employers should have anti- confined to women although women tended to bullying policies and take action against perpetrators. describe the abuse in the survey in more harrowing 40% The seriousness of the problem in the yacht industry detail. Examples were read out to the seminar of of the yacht crew was illustrated by a well-publicised American yachting gender coercion, groping, and being drugged and surveyed by the PYA sexual harassment case, cited at the seminar, where a raped while on a night out with crewmates. had experienced crew member won a US$70m settlement. The PYA said it had decided to investigate sexual In Europe, duty-of-care issues have been highlighted unwanted sexual harassment after seeing a marked increase in the by a case where a long-serving stewardess, who had been number of incidents of unwanted sexual contact contact drinking with crewmates during World Cup celebrations, reported by crew members, and in light of the recent global was put to bed inebriated in her cabin, but found dead the next #metoo movement, which revealed the prevalence of sexual day. Investigations are ongoing. assault and harassment against women in all careers. In another tragic example, a 21-year-old Australian deckhand had Commenting on the findings, Sea Changes panel member arine suffered a 'series of issues regarding job performance and issues with ayson who runs The Crew Coach professional development crew and hanged herself.' web service and blog said it was no coincidence the industry was The survey also noted a potentially worrying trend that the experiencing a costly high turnover of crew, many of whom had majority of respondents had secured jobs though social media and did longstanding vessel knowledge or were crucial to running the vessel. not come through the safer option of crew agencies. nautilusint.org 20 November 2018 November 2018 21 nautilusint.org
20-21_superyacht_SR checked.indd 21 17/10/2018 15:54 WERE YOU AWARE that following the successul outcome of a judicial review in respect of two Seatax clients, (brought before the Courts by Nautilus in collaboration with Seatax Ltd as expert advisors on the Seafarers Earnings Deduction), it was deemed that the two Seatax clients did have a legitimate expectation in applying the only published Revenue Practice with regard to the application of a day of absence in relation to a vessel sailing between UK ports. HMRC did not want to accept this practice (although referred to in their very own publications) but have now accepted that expectations of a claim based on such practice would be valid until the published practice is withdrawn. Following on from this, HMRC have now confi rmed that this Practice is withdrawn as of the 14 February 2014. Seatax was the only Advisory Service that challenged HMRC on this point. Please visit our website for full details of the case. WHY TAKE CHANCES WITH YOUR TAX AFFAIRS? Let Seatax use their knowledge and 35 years experience to ensure you do not fall foul of the rules OUR FEES ARE AS FOLLOWS: Annual Return ...... £225.00 inclusive of VAT at 20%
NAUTILUS members in the UK sailing under a foreign fl ag agreement on gross remuneration can obtain a 10% reduction on the above enrolment fee by quoting their NAUTILUS membership number and a 5% reduction on re-enrolment.
Write, or phone now for more details: Elgin House, 83 Thorne Road, Doncaster DN1 2ES. Tel: (01302) 364673 - Fax No: (01302) 738526 - E-mail: [email protected] www.seatax.ltd.uk
Christmas CENTURY ONE PUBLISHING Card Appeal I S THE UK’S BRIGHTEST AWARD-WINNING Every year the Shipwrecked Mariners’ Society pays over £1m in grants to the dependants of those lost at sea, as well CONTRACT PUBLISHING as sick, disabled and retired seafarers struggling to make AND ADVERTISING SALES AGENCY. ends meet. Please help us to continue this important work. T o p l a n y our a d ca m p a ig n in J onny K nig h t T e l e g r a p h m a g a z ine conta ct: t: 0 1 7 2 7 7 3 9 1 9 3 e : jonathan@ centuryonepublishing.uk w : w w w.centuryonepublishing.uk
QUALITY CHRISTMAS CARDS • GIFT ITEMS CORRESPONDENCE CARDS • BIRTHDAY CARDS MARITIME PHOTOGRAPHY CALENDAR To receive a copy of our new 2018 brochure and order form please contact: Dept NUK, 1 North Pallant, Chichester PO19 1TL Tel: 01243 789329 • Fax: 01243 530853 www.irishseafarerstax.ie e-mail: [email protected] www.shipwreckedmariners.org.uk Shipwrecked Mariners’ Society Reg Charity No 212034 Supporting the seafaring community for over 175 years Inst. 1839
nautilusint.org 22 November 2018 PEOPLE
Pictured at Trinity House London with HRH The Princess Royal are the 2018 Gatti, Capt Nigel Jardine, George Lonie, Michael Morley, Capt Nicholas Nash, awardees of the Merchant Navy Medal for Meritorious Service: Capt Belinda Capt John Rankin, Capt Michael Reeves, Capt Andrew Schofi eld, Capt Ian Bennett, Derek Cardno, Lieutenant Commander David Carter, Stephen Shields, and Keith Thompson. Three further recipients were unable to be Chamberlain, Capt Timothy Charlesworth, Mark Dickinson, Capt Antonio present: John Halsall, Capt Robin Lock OBE, and Capt Thomas Woolley THE HIGHEST HONOUR Nautilus members were represented in force among this year's awardees of the UK Merchant Navy Medal for Meritorious Service. SARAH ROBINSON reports…
he Merchant honoured,’ said Mr promotion of the maritime young women will see her Navy Medal for Dickinson, ‘and very proud se tor he is the fi rst oman doing her job and follow in T Meritorious to stand alongside them at to have received the medal her footsteps. Service is British the ceremony. On behalf of since it became a state award, shipping’s highest honour, the Union, I would like to and the fi rst person of olour and since 2015 has been a congratulate all the recipients Capt Bennett grew up on state award – part of the UK and thank them for the the British Overseas Territory honours system with a place work they have done for the of St Helena, and started her in the Order of Wear. maritime community.’ career at sea in 1994 with This year, there are 19 After the ceremony, the an offi er adetship on the recipients, of whom eight Nautilus members spoke to the island’s lifeline vessel RMS are Nautilus members – Telegraph about their maritime St Helena. Having worked including the Union’s general careers and voluntary service her ay up to se ond offi er secretary Mark Dickinson. that had been honoured. Their she transferred to Windstar The awards were presented stories follow, on this page and Cruises, where she continued on 26 September by HRH overleaf. to rise through the ranks The Princess Royal at Trinity and too her fi rst ommand House in London. Captain Belinda Bennett in 2016. This, she says, was ‘I was pleased to see received the Merchant Navy the proudest moment in her so many of our members Medal for services to the career, and she hopes other
November 2018 23 nautilusint.org
23-25_mnmedal_SR checked.indd 23 18/10/2018 09:48 PEOPLE
Mark Dickinson received the Medal for services to seafarer employment, training and welfare. Having gone to sea in 1978 at the age of 16, he has been involved in the Merchant Navy for 40 years, and in 2009 was elected as the general secretary of Nautilus International. Mr Dickinson’s career highlights include: leading a trade union mission to locate the wreck of the bulk carrier Derbyshire; being involved in the development of the Maritime Labour Convention, 2006 from concept to adoption; and promoting Captain Nicholas Nash received the decent work for seafarers. Medal for services to maritime training. A serving master with Princess Cruises, Lieutenant Commander David Carter Captain Antonio Gatti was awarded he is also the president of the Nautical was awarded the Medal for services to the the Medal for services to UK research Institute and a Younger Brother of Trinity careers of young seafarers and seafarer expeditions. He started his career in 1984 House. A training captain, he teaches welfare. He was at sea in the Merchant with a Ben Line cadetship, and has worked bridge resource management and ship- Navy for 34 years, from cadet to master for the National Environmental Research handling at Carnival Corporation’s with 16 years in command, and worked Council since 1992 – where his role in the CSMART Arison Maritime Centre, and has on some of the largest gas carriers in the written numerous educational articles world, specialising in ice class LNG for the and textbooks. northern sea route. Capt Nash said he was proud to be Lt Cdr Carter is now the Royal Navy’s still at sea after 41 years, and that his er hant avy liaison offi er and is example shows how far it was possible active in safety, training and maritime to rise in this industry after starting out charitable causes. Looking back at ith ust evel ualifi ations he t o the highlights of his career at sea, he highlights of his career to date have been remembers an incident that showed his taking command of the Royal Princess efforts to instil a strong safety culture and becoming president of the Nautical onboard ship were paying dividends. Institute. ‘After years of stressing the need for everyone to share responsibility for safety, I knew we were on the right track one day when a young Filipino crew British Antarctic Survey has included member overcame his reluctance to time on the celebrated research vessel speak up to authority and let me know James Clark Ross. Five years ago, he my shoelaces were undone,’ he smiles. e ame the fi rst master of is overy and his next tour of duty with the vessel will take him to the oceans off Brazil and To be eligible for the Chile. Merchant Navy Medal, Capt Gatti described the Merchant Navy Medal as ‘unbelievable – a great recipients will usually honour which acknowledges the value of have given 20 years of the ocean research work we do.’ He looks forward to continuing to promote science exemplary service around the world.
nautilusint.org 24 November 2018 November 2018 25 nautilusint.org
23-25_mnmedal_SR checked.indd 24 17/10/2018 16:00 autilus elfare und ommittee for nearly 20 years. apt eeves spo e enthusiasti ally about his work with the Union’s registered harity hi h is ased at the retirement DUAL AWARDS FOR estate ariners Par on the an s of the iver ersey he dedi ation of the WIGHTLINK LIFESAVER ariners Par staff is so marvellous Wightlink Ferries seafarer Stephen Chamberlain is he said adding that their or had een pictured above right receiving a Skill and Gallantry greatly enhanced over the past two Award last month from Shipwrecked Mariners’ Captain John Rankin was awarded the decades by the construction of modern Society president Sir George Zambellas – just a few Medal for services to the Merchant Navy. retirement accommodation and welfare days after being awarded the Merchant Navy He spent 11 years at the beginning of his facilities – starting with the Mariners’ Medal for Meritorious Service. areer in hell s orld ide tan er eet Par are ome and ontinuing to this Both awards were in recognition of his ‘quick followed by 29 years as master of all classes day ith the rinity ouse u its thinking, determination and exceptional bravery’ of offshore support vessels. Throughout Seafarers UK wing and new bungalows for in entering the freezing waters of Portsmouth this time he or ed to support olleagues independent living. harbour to save the life of a member of the public. and enhance the reputation of the At approximately 23.00 hrs on 3 February this Merchant Navy – participating in activities Keith Thompson was awarded the year, Mr Chamberlain and his colleagues were su h as saving lives at sea innovative Medal for services to a maritime charity. carrying out maintenance duties on the car deck of seamanship and leadership s ills sharing After working for various companies at the St Clare in Camber Dock, in preparation for the seafaring knowledge and working sea he as assistant purser on the ferry midnight sailing to the Isle of Wight. A cry went up alongside HM Forces. MV Norland in 1982 when it was sent to that a man had been spotted in the water – o retired apt an in is urrently the al lands on i t e formed and is probably after falling in from the quayside – and supporting a study into dementia among hairman of the orland re oluntary the St Clare crew alerted the emergency services seafarers and is or ing ith Plymouth roup hi h raises funds for the ull while throwing the man a life ring. ity oun il on a pro e t to ere t a herapy roup supporting veterans from However, he seemed too cold and shocked to er hant avy monument on Plymouth all four services and their families who reach the ring, and Mr Chamberlain realised he was Hoe. He is glad to be working on these likely to slip under the water and drown before a pro e ts ith his ife hris an in of he rescue boat could arrive. ‘I’ve always been a strong at h shore also pi tured ho as a swimmer,’ he told the Telegraph, ‘and I knew I recipient of the Merchant Navy Medal in its needed to act straight away or we could lose him. I previous incarnation. took my coat o and let myself down about four or ve metres into the water, swam over and helped Captain Michael Reeves received the him get the ring over his head and shoulders.’ Medal for services to the careers of young The seafarer’s actions bought the man some seafarers and seafarer welfare. He had a time until a launch could reach them both and pull year areer ith i y ine iverpool the casualty from the water. The man was taken to in luding years as a master on P hospital with hypothermia and subsequently made and hemi al tan ers and sin e retiring a full recovery. in 2006 has been actively involved with Did Mr Chamberlain never feel concerned for his cadet training at Liverpool John Moores own safety, or that he might also end up needing University. He has also served on the may be suffering with mental and physical to be rescued? ‘No, because everyone else was issues. there,’ he explains. ‘I knew my colleagues were Mr Thompson has campaigned tirelessly watching over me from the ship, and that the for a memorial to all merchant seafarers launch was on its way. And I drew condence from to stand alongside those of the armed all the years of swimming I did when I was growing for es in ull and he organises veterans up on the Naval base in Hong Kong – it was just services and parades at Hull Minster. He part of our lives there to go to the pool every day.’ was closely involved in the publication of a Having gained this recognition from the book about the Norland in the Falklands – maritime community, the seafarer is considering All in the Same Boat y arren it erald whether the awards could mark a turning point in and as pleased to report that a fi lm his career, spurring him on to further achievement based on the book is looking likely to go in the Merchant Navy by embarking on rating-to- into production in 2019. ocer training. But for now he is just waiting for the excitement to die down so he can go back on nautilusint.org 24 November 2018 November 2018 25 nautilusint.org duty for another run of night shifts.
23-25_mnmedal_SR checked.indd 25 17/10/2018 16:00 INDUSTRY CHOPPY WATERS AHEAD Trade wars and protectionism are threatening to reverse a recovery in global shipping operations, a United Nations report has warned…
orldwide seaborne trade increased by 4% W in 2017 – the fastest gro th in fi ve years and is likely to rise at a similar rate over the ne t fe years That's the headline prediction from the latest annual revie of maritime trade produced by the UN Conference on Trade & evelopment But the study says this trend ould e derailed y developments such as the ‘tariff war’ between the and hina hile the prospects for seaborne trade are positive these are threatened y the outbreak of trade wars and in reased in ard loo ing poli ies se retary general u hisa ituyi said ‘Escalating protectionism and tit-for-tat tariff battles will potentially disrupt the global trading system which underpins demand for maritime transport