Analysis and Review of International Working Group on Women and Sport Progress Reports 1994 – 2010
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
ANALYSIS AND REVIEW OF INTERNATIONAL WORKING GROUP ON WOMEN AND SPORT PROGRESS REPORTS 1994 – 2010 Anita White Foundation, University of Chichester FEBRUARY 2012 ANALYSIS AND REVIEW OF INTERNATIONAL WORKING GROUP ON WOMEN AND SPORT PROGRESS REPORTS 1994 – 2010 FEBRUARY 2012 Report authors Jordan J.K. Matthews with Elizabeth C.J. Pike Anita White Anita White Foundation University of Chichester College Lane Chichester West Sussex PO19 6PE United Kingdom www.chi.ac.uk/awf 1 Contents FIGURES AND TABLES 4 GLOSSARY OF ACRONYMS 5 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 6 SECTION 1: INTRODUCTION 7 - 8 SECTION 2: PROGRESS REPORT STRUCTURE 9 - 20 2.1 Introduction 9 2.2 From Brighton to Windhoek 9 - 11 2.3 From Windhoek to Montreal 12 - 14 2.4 From Montreal to Kumamoto 14 - 16 2.5 From Kumamoto to Sydney 16 - 18 2.6 Conclusion 18 SECTION 3: RESULTS 21 - 34 3.1 Introduction 21 3.2 Spread-sheet Structure, and Key Terms and Coding 21 - 23 Explanations 3.2.i Spread-sheet structure 21 3.2.ii Key Terms and Coding 22 3.3 Results 24 - 29 3.3.i Individual Progress Report Results 24 3.3.ii Cumulative Progress Report Results 28 3.4 Challenges in analysing the reports 31 - 32 3.5 Brighton Declaration Anomalies 32 - 33 3.6 Countries never reported 33 3.7 Conclusion 33 Section 4: Reflective Review and Issues Identified 35 - 44 4.1 Introduction 35 4.2 Review of Progress in the four Individual Progress Reports 35 – 39 4.2.i From Brighton to Windhoek 35 4.2.ii From Windhoek to Montreal 37 4.2.iii From Montreal to Kumamoto 38 4.2.iv From Kumamoto to Sydney 38 4.3 Cumulative Record by Different Groups and Countries 39 – 44 4.3.i Section 1 – International and Regional Governmental 39 Organisations 4.3.ii Section 2 – International Multi-Sports Organisations 39 4.4.iii Section 3 – International PE Organisations and Fora 40 4.3.iv Section 4 – International Sport Federations 40 4.3.v Section 5 – International and Regional Women and Sport 41 Groups 4.3.vi Section 6 – National Organisation – Africa 41 4.3.vii Section 7 – National Organisation – Asia and the Middle East 42 4.3.viii Section 8 – National Organisation – Europe 42 4.3.ix Section 9 – National Organisation – North America and the 42 2 Caribbean 4.3.x Section 10 – National Organisation – Central and Southern 43 America 4.3.xi Section 11 – National Organisation – Oceania 43 4.3.xii Section 12 – Other Groups 44 4.4 Conclusion 44 - 45 Section 5: Conclusion and Issues for IWG’s Consideration 46 – 47 5.1 Conclusion 46 - 47 5.2 Issues for IWG’s consideration 47 References 48 Appendices 49 3 Figures and Tables Figure 1. From Brighton to Windhoek Progress Report Structure 10 Figure 2. From Windhoek to Montreal Progress Report Structure 12 Figure 3. From Montreal to Kumamoto Progress Report Structure 15 Figure 4. From Kumamoto to Sydney Progress Report Structure 17 Table 1. IWG Progress Report Structure Statistics 19 Table 2. Individual Progress Report Statistics 26 – 27 Table 3. Cumulative Progress Report Statistics 29 – 30 4 Glossary of Acronyms ASC Australian Sports Commission AWISA African Women in Sport Association AWS Asian Women in Sport B.Dec Brighton Declaration on Women and Sport CAAWS Canadian Association for the Advancement of Women in Sport CEDAW United Nations Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women CIJF International Committee of the Games of La Francophonie CONFEJES Conférence des Ministres de la Jeunesse et des Sports de la Francophonie ESC European Sports Conference EWS European Women and Sport Group FIFA Fédération Internationale de Football Association IAPESGW International Association of Physical Education and Sport for Girls and Women ICSSPE International Council of Sport Science and Physical Education IOC International Olympic Committee IPC International Paralympic Committee ITTF International Table Tennis Federation IWG International Working Group on Women and Sport JWS Japanese Women and Sport MINEPS UNESCO Ministers of Physical Education and Sport NAWIS Nigerian Association of Women in Sport NOC National Olympic Committee ODESUR Organización Deportiva Suramericana (South American National Olympic Committees) PASO Pan American Sports Organization PE Physical Education SAAW Arab Women and Sport Association SCSA Supreme Council for Sport in Africa UK United Kingdom UN United Nations UNESCO United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organisation WASSA Women and Sport South Africa WHO World Health Organisation WSFF UK Women’s Sport and Fitness Foundation WSF(UK) UK Women’s Sport Foundation (now WSFF) WSF(US) USA Women’s Sport Foundation WSI WomenSport International 5 Executive Summary This document presents a report on the four quadrennial progress reports presented by the Secretariats of the International Working Group on Women and Sport since the 1st IWG World Conference in 1994. A content analysis of each individual progress report is presented, along with a cumulative analysis of the progress made world-wide in women and sport organisations between 1994- 2010. Findings indicate broad consistency in the structure of the progress reports, with variable detail presented in the different sections. A summary is presented of activities within the key international and regional organisations, as well as activities within individual countries, in order to highlight which groups are most and least actively engaged with issues related to women and sport. Particular attention is given to identifying which groups have signed the Brighton Declaration, and what action has taken place within groups who have, and who have not, signed this Declaration. The progress reports are dependent on reporting from the various organisations which appears to lead to both under- and over- reporting of action and progress. The IWG is congratulated on the excellent monitoring and evaluation of progress, and is encouraged to promote this work more widely and consider how best to maintain this exemplary practice in the future. 6 Section 1 Introduction This report presents a content analysis and review of progress made worldwide in addressing issues related to women and sport. The materials analysed are those reported by the International Working Group on Women and Sport (IWG) since the 1st IWG World Conference on Women and Sport held in Brighton, United Kingdom (UK) in 1994. The IWG has produced quadrennial progress reports that monitor and evaluate: action for advancing women and sport issues, developments, and awareness. The four progress reports have been produced in sequence with the five IWG World Conferences and were seen as fulfilling one of the core roles of each IWG secretariat. The four progress reports analysed were: From Brighton to Windhoek – produced in 1998 and distributed after the 2nd IWG World Conference in Windhoek, Namibia. This progress report covered the four years following the 1st IWG World Conference. From Windhoek to Montreal – produced in 2002 and distributed before the 3rd IWG World Conference in Montreal, Canada. This progress report covered the four years following the 2nd IWG World Conference. From Montreal to Kumamoto – produced in 2006 and distributed before the 4th IWG World Conference in Kumamoto, Japan. This progress report covered the four years following the 3rd IWG World Conference. From Kumamoto to Sydney – produced in 2010 and distributed before the 5th IWG World Conference in Sydney, Australia. This progress report covered the four years following the 4th IWG World Conference. This report has been requested by the current (at the time of writing) IWG secretariat based in Helsinki, Finland, which will be the venue for the 6th IWG World Conference in 2014. The purpose of this report is to provide a critical analysis of sixteen years of IWG monitoring and evaluation as evidenced through their progress reports. It will be the first time that the progress reports have been analysed cumulatively, and it is hoped that this analysis will inform the current IWG in its decisions about monitoring and evaluating in the present quadrennium and over the 20 years that will have passed between the Brighton Conference and the Helsinki Conference. This work, commissioned by the IWG Secretariat, has been undertaken by Jordan Matthews on behalf of the Anita White Foundation which is based at the University of Chichester, UK. The four progress reports were analysed and reviewed using a variety of coding techniques that provide a comprehensive and detailed account of progress reported by the IWG. The data collected was inputted into two Microsoft Excel spread-sheets (Appendix 1 and 2) where it was further categorised and totalled. This data analysis was combined with an identification of patterns and trends regarding which groups have and have not undertaken work towards advancing women and sport. Additionally, the Brighton Declaration on Women and Sport formed a key unit of analysis because it is, in effect, the accepted policy statement for international women and sport organisations and activities, and its adoption seen as a first step for organisations to commit to gender equality in sport. The 2010 version of the Brighton Declaration signatories was received from the IWG (2010b), and this was reviewed alongside the United Nations (UN) member state list (UN, 2012) for comparative analysis. 7 This report is organised into six sections. Following this introduction, the structure and method used for data collection of each progress report is examined and described. Tables and charts are presented to highlight and compare statistics calculated from each progress report. The third section of this report outlines the results from content analysis of the reports and a number of methodological issues encountered while undertaking this work. The fourth section offers a critical analysis of patterns and trends found in each individual progress report and across all the progress reports cumulatively. Each section of this report also includes an introduction, conclusion, and issues the IWG may wish to consider in the future.