DOCSLIB.ORG

University of Dundee DOCTOR of PHILOSOPHY George Macdonald

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
University of Dundee DOCTOR of PHILOSOPHY George Macdonald University of Dundee DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY George MacDonald and Victorian Society Smith, Jeffrey Wayne Award date: 2013 Link to publication General rights Copyright and moral rights for the publications made accessible in the public portal are retained by the authors and/or other copyright owners and it is a condition of accessing publications that users recognise and abide by the legal requirements associated with these rights. • Users may download and print one copy of any publication from the public portal for the purpose of private study or research. • You may not further distribute the material or use it for any profit-making activity or commercial gain • You may freely distribute the URL identifying the publication in the public portal Take down policy If you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact us providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim. Download date: 28. Sep. 2021 GEORGE MACDONALD AND VICTORIAN SOCIETY JEFFREY WAYNE SMITH Doctor of Philosophy University of Dundee September 2013 ii TABLE OF CONTENTS Acknowledgements iv Declaration v Abstract vi Abbreviations vii Chapter One: Introduction 1 A Brief Guide to Reading the Thesis 3 Part 1: Critical Assessment 5 MacDonald’s Nonfiction: Writings on the Development of the Imagination and Spiritual Progression 15 Part 2: MacDonald’s Social Views and Ideas 20 MacDonald and the Nineteenth-Century Crisis of Change 20 Transitions between Town and Country in MacDonald’s Novels 28 The Ills of Industrialism in The Princess and Curdie and St. George and St. Michael 39 Chapter Two: The City 46 Introduction 46 Part 1: George MacDonald, Octavia Hill, and the Kyrle Society 49 Octavia Hill 49 The Kyrle Society 58 Part 2: Slums and Urban Philanthropy in London, 1860s-1880s 67 Part 3: Urban Philanthropy in Robert Falconer, The Vicar’s Daughter, and Weighed and Wanting 75 The Philanthropists 84 Housing Reform 92 Charity 99 Spiritual Reformation 103 iii Chapter Three: Nature 115 Introduction 115 Part 1: ‘Prophets of Nature’: George MacDonald and William Wordsworth 118 Part 2: Finding God in Nature 131 The ‘Veil’ of Nature 131 Pantheism in What’s Mine’s Mine 137 ‘Divine Air’ and ‘God’s Steeples’ in ‘A Journey Rejourneyed’ and Wilfrid Cumbermede 150 Part 3: Victorian Environmentalism and Urban Green Space in Guild Court 169 Chapter Four: Animals 187 Introduction 187 Part 1: Animal Care: Representations of Vivisection, Vegetarianism, Hunting, and Animal Discipline and Abuse 192 MacDonald and the Vivisection Debate 192 Vegetarianism in Paul Faber, Surgeon and ‘The Golden Key’ 214 The Ethics of Hunting in What’s Mine’s Mine 219 Animal Discipline and Abuse in MacDonald’s Novels 225 Part 2: The Human Animal: Representations of Evolution and Degeneration 238 Chapter Five: Conclusion 260 Thesis Summation 260 Ideas for Future Research 264 Bibliography 268 iv ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS First and foremost, my gratitude is given to my supervisor, Dr David Robb. Not only was David’s advice and guidance essential to the development of my thesis, but his warm friendship was essential to my overall wellbeing as a PhD student. To the School of English at the University of Dundee, whose members always encouraged me to carry on, I am deeply grateful. For providing me with the resources I needed for research as well as a quiet place to study, I offer my express thanks to the University of Dundee library, British Library, National Library of Scotland, Brander Library in Huntly, King’s College London Library and Archives, and Brunel University Library. My family in the USA, who have patiently endured my uninterrupted absence for the past four years, I thank with all my heart. Lastly, my thanks goes to my loving wife, Sericea Stallings-Smith, who, despite her current work as a DrPH research student at Brunel University, constantly supported me. With a clear head and steady heart, I thank you! v DECLARATION This thesis has been composed by myself, and all references cited have been consulted by me. I have researched the work of which the thesis is a record, and declare that it has not been previously accepted for a higher degree. vi ABSTRACT This thesis approaches the ways George MacDonald viewed and represented Victorian society in his novels by analysing select social issues which he felt compelled to address. Chapter One introduces the thesis. It contains a review of critical commentary on MacDonald’s work, as well as discussions on his non-fictional texts and essays, industrialism, and the great rural-urban divide of the nineteenth century. Chapter Two concentrates on MacDonald’s representations of the city in Robert Falconer (1868), The Vicar’s Daughter (1872), and Weighed and Wanting (1882) by underscoring parallels between Octavia Hill’s housing and environmental schemes and situations which he experienced firsthand. Chapter Three examines the influence of Nature on MacDonald’s theology and social views. Special emphasis is placed on Wordsworth and the development of MacDonald’s unique pantheism in his texts, such as the short story, ‘A Journey Rejourneyed’ (1865-6), Guild Court (1868), Wilfrid Cumbermede (1872), What’s Mine’s Mine (1886), and Home Again (1887). Chapter Four uncovers MacDonald’s involvement with the animal welfare movement during the latter part of the nineteenth century. Discussions on vivisection, vegetarianism, hunting, animal abuse, evolution, and degeneration are provided with a wide range of MacDonald’s texts, such as Alec Forbes of Howglen (1865), Paul Faber, Surgeon (1879), The Marquis of Lossie (1877), A Rough Shaking (1890), and Heather and Snow (1893). Chapter Five offers a short summation of the thesis. It affirms that MacDonald was deeply troubled by certain social issues that were raised within his society and would use his fiction to express his concerns. The conclusion also offers a few suggestive topics for ongoing research in the field of this thesis. vii ABBREVIATIONS There is no standard edition of MacDonald’s works; however, all have been reprinted and published by Johannesen Printing and Publishing. Most references to MacDonald’s work have been taken from these editions. In some instances, Johannesen has reproduced an American edition which, subsequently, offers certain variants in spelling (e.g. ‘labour’ is spelled ‘labor’). First editions are only available in main libraries (such as the British Library and the National Library of Scotland), and other, antique editions may also be found. Thus, the reader is likely to encounter a variety of editions. As pagination can vary from edition to edition, all references from MacDonald’s texts include the main title, chapter number, chapter title, and page number. Finally, some titles by MacDonald and his son, Greville, have been abbreviated if they have been continually repeated. The following is a list of abbreviations used in this thesis. George MacDonald’s Texts: Greville MacDonald’s Texts: AF Alec Forbes of Howglen GMDW George MacDonald and His Wife ABNW At the Back of the North Wind Rems Reminiscences of a Specialist DE David Elginbrod GC Guild Court: A London Story HA Home Again HG The Hope of the Gospel ML The Marquis of Lossie Orts A Dish of Orts PC The Princess and Curdie PFS Paul Faber, Surgeon PW Poetical Works RF Robert Falconer RS A Rough Shaking SGSM St. George and St. Michael US Unspoken Sermons VD The Vicar’s Daughter WC Wilfrid Cumbermede WMM What’s Mine’s Mine WW Weighed and Wanting 1 CHAPTER ONE Introduction To date, George MacDonald has been largely neglected in critical discussions of socially- conscious nineteenth-century British literature. The reason for this oversight may be that MacDonald’s first champions, such as C.S. Lewis, G.K. Chesterton, and W.H. Auden, have primarily honoured him with accolades for his fantasy fiction and English fairy tales at the expense of his novels. This is unfortunate, and this thesis will go some way to redressing this imbalance. Although some critical attention has been given to the novels, there is a good deal more research to be done, especially regarding the ways in which the events of the nineteenth century informed and shaped MacDonald’s writing with social and political factors. Since the nature of his novels is similar to those written by his contemporaries, like Charles Dickens, George Eliot, and Elizabeth Gaskell, a study considering the social issues that were important to this author will have much to offer not only MacDonald scholars, but also scholars of nineteenth-century literature and society who are interested in literary representations of the city, Nature, and the animal welfare movement. MacDonald lived in an era that was undergoing a crisis of change. The first half of the nineteenth century saw the rapid growth of cities and Britain’s metamorphosis into an industrial power. By the middle of the century, advancements in the fields of science and natural history began to collide fiercely with conservative religious attitudes. Eventually, as Queen Victoria’s empire expanded across the globe, the core of Britain’s society was riddled with political debate and plagued by religious doubt. MacDonald struggled to understand the consequences of these 2 large developments and conflicts. Religious debates, especially, played a significant part in MacDonald’s moral and intellectual life. Indeed, having been forced to resign from his first and only pulpit ministry due to allegations of potential heresy, MacDonald expressed his singular theological ideas through lay sermons and, more publically, through spiritually-themed novels. While this thesis would not claim that MacDonald was a socially-conscious novelist, as may be argued with Dickens or Gaskell, it will suggest that he was, indeed, concerned with certain social issues during his day and expressed these concerns with his fiction. As long as the ongoing lack of scholarly interest in MacDonald’s non-fantasy literature remains, there will be an incomplete portrait of MacDonald.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • A Checklist of George Macdonald's Books Published in America, 1855-1930
    North Wind: A Journal of George MacDonald Studies Volume 39 Article 2 1-1-2020 A Checklist of George MacDonald's Books Published in America, 1855-1930 Richard I. Johnson Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.snc.edu/northwind Recommended Citation Johnson, Richard I. (2020) "A Checklist of George MacDonald's Books Published in America, 1855-1930," North Wind: A Journal of George MacDonald Studies: Vol. 39 , Article 2. Available at: https://digitalcommons.snc.edu/northwind/vol39/iss1/2 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the English at Digital Commons @ St. Norbert College. It has been accepted for inclusion in North Wind: A Journal of George MacDonald Studies by an authorized editor of Digital Commons @ St. Norbert College. For more information, please contact [email protected]. A Checklist of George MacDonald Books Published in America, 1855-1930 Richard I. Johnson Many of George MacDonald’s books were published in the US as well as in the United Kingdom. Bulloch and Shaberman’s bibliographies only provide scanty details of these; the purpose of this article is to provide a more accurate and comprehensive list. Its purpose is to identify each publisher involved, the titles that each of them published, the series (where applicable) within which the title was placed, the date of publication, the number of pages, and the price. It is helpful to look at each of these in more detail. Publishers About 50 publishers were involved in publishing GMD books prior to 1930, although about half of these only published one title.
    [Show full text]
  • Memorial Review of “George Macdonald: a Study of Two Novels.” by William Webb, Part of Volume 11 of Romantic Reassessment
    Memorial review of “George MacDonald: A Study of Two Novels.” by William Webb, part of volume 11 of Romantic Reassessment. Salzburg, 1973. Deirdre Hayward illiam Webb’s aim in this study is to examine two “rather neglected”W novels of George MacDonald in order to bring out “what is most characteristic in them of the author’s undoubted genius” (105). He sets out to demonstrate that Mary Marston is “a capable piece of fiction” (58), and his discussion of Home Again, though brief, brings out several interesting features of the novel. I have chosen to comment on aspects of his study which give the reader fresh insights, and illuminate less well-known areas of MacDonald’s writing. The study itself is rather loosely structured, with the plan and links between the topics not always clear; and it is frustrating that Webb almost never gives sources for the many quoted passages, and often drops in references—for example a comparison with Dickens in Hard Times or Our Mutual Friend—without any supporting detail to contextualise his comments. Having said this, I found myself impressed by many of the issues discussed, and interested in the directions (sometimes quite obscure and fascinating) in which he points the reader. Additionally, his exploration of some of the literary sources and artistic relationships recognisable in Mary Marston contribute with some authority to MacDonald scholarship. Webb recognises the influence of seventeenth-century English literature on Mary Marston (1881), and observes that in chapter 11, “William Marston,” where Mary’s father, the saintly William Marston, dies, the theme of poetry is related to the plot (83).
    [Show full text]
  • Framing Farming: Communication Strategies for Animal Rights Critical Animal Studies 2
    Framing Farming: Communication Strategies for Animal Rights Critical Animal Studies 2 General Editors: Helena Pedersen, Stockholm University (Sweden) Vasile Stănescu, Mercer University (U.S.) Editorial Board: Stephen R.L. Clark, University of Liverpool (U.K.) Amy J. Fitzgerald, University of Windsor (Canada) Anthony J. Nocella, II, Hamline University (U.S.) John Sorenson, Brock University (Canada) Richard Twine, University of London and Edge Hill University (U.K.) Richard J. White, Sheffield Hallam University (U.K.) Framing Farming: Communication Strategies for Animal Rights Carrie P. Freeman Amsterdam - New York, NY 2014 Critical Animal Studies 2. Carrie P. Freeman, Framing Farming: Communication Strategies for Animal Rights. 1. Kim Socha, Women, Destruction, and the Avant-Garde. A Paradigm for Animal Liberation. This book is printed on recycled paper. Cover photo: Jo-Anne McArthur / We Animals The paper on which this book is printed meets the requirements of “ISO 9706:1994, Information and documentation - Paper for documents - Requirements for permanence”. ISBN: 978-90-420-3892-9 E-Book ISBN: 978-94-012-1174-1 © Editions Rodopi B.V., Amsterdam – New York, NY 2014 Printed in The Netherlands Table of Contents List of Images 9 Foreword 11 Author’s perspective and background 11 Acknowledgements 14 Dedication 15 Chapter 1: Introduction 17 Themes and Theses in This Book 19 The Unique Contributions of This Book 20 Social Significance of Vegetarianism & Animal Rights 22 The Structure and Content of This Book 26 Word Choice 29 PART I OVERVIEW OF ANIMAL RIGHTS, VEGETARIANISM, AND COMMUNICATION Chapter 2: Ethical Views on Animals as Fellows & as Food 33 Development of Animal Activism in the United States 34 Western Thought on Other Animals 36 Western Vegetarian Ethics 43 Human Eating Habits 62 Chapter 3: Activist Communication Strategy & Debates 67 Communication and the Social Construction of Reality 68 Strategies for Social Movement Organizations 75 Ideological Framing Debates in U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • A Read of at the Back of the North Wind
    A Read��� of At the Back of the North Wind Col�� Ma�love acDonald’s At the Back of the North Wind (1871) was first serialised inM Good Words for the Young under his own editorship, from October 1868 to November 1870. It was his first attempt at writing a full-length “fairy-story” for children, following on his shorter fairy tales—including “The Selfish Giant,” “The Light Princess,” and “The Golden Key”—written between 1862 and 1867, and published in Dealings with the Fairies (1867). At the Back of the North Wind is, in fact, longer than either of the Princess books that were to follow it, The Princess and the Goblin (1872) and The Princess and Curdie (1882). It tells of the boy Diamond’s life as a cabman’s son in a poor area of mid-Victorian London, and of his meetings and adventures with a lady called North Wind; and it includes a separate fairy tale called “Little Daylight,” two dream-stories, and several poems. Generally well received by the public, it has hardly been out of print since. At the Back of the North Wind is MacDonald’s only fantasy set mainly in this world. In Phantastes (1858), Anodos goes into Fairy Land and in Lilith Mr. Vane finds himself in the Region of the Seven Dimensions. In the Princess books we are in a fairy-tale realm of kings, princesses, and goblins; and the worlds of the shorter fairy tales are all full of fairies, witches, and giants. But Diamond’s story nearly all happens either in Victorian London or in other parts of the world where North Wind takes him.
    [Show full text]
  • A Horse: Macdonald's Theodicy in at the Back of the North Wind
    32 Stott This is (Not) a Horse: MacDonald’s Theodicy in At the Back of the North Wind G. St. John Stott I George MacDonald insisted in his essay “The Fantastic Imagination” that the meaning of a work should be evident to its readers. He did not mean by this that there was only one meaning to a text, or that the author’s intent in writing was privileged, but that if a reader could not make any sense of what was written and the author had to step in, something had gone wrong. Under such circumstances commentary was a mistake. As he noted, using a simple analogy, “[I]f I cannot draw a horse, I will not write THIS IS A HORSE under what I foolishly meant for one” (LP xii). We might remember this when we read in At the Back of the North Wind (1871) a conversation between what might (or might not be) two cab horses: Diamond and Ruby. It is a puzzling scene which MacDonald refuses to make clear. Cab horse conversations can be easy to understand. In Anna Sewell’s Black Beauty (1877), a work that was perhaps written as a response to At the Back of the North Wind,1 the eponymous Beauty discusses with Captain (a former army horse) the latter’s experiences in the Crimea: I said, ‘I have heard people talk about war as if it was a very fine thing.’ ‘Ah!’ said he, ‘I should think they never saw it. No doubt it is very fine when there is no enemy, when it is just exercise and parade and sham fight.
    [Show full text]
  • Volume 1 a Collection of Essays Presented at the First Frances White Ewbank Colloquium on C.S
    Inklings Forever Volume 1 A Collection of Essays Presented at the First Frances White Ewbank Colloquium on C.S. Lewis & Article 1 Friends 1997 Full Issue 1997 (Volume 1) Follow this and additional works at: https://pillars.taylor.edu/inklings_forever Part of the English Language and Literature Commons, History Commons, Philosophy Commons, and the Religion Commons Recommended Citation (1997) "Full Issue 1997 (Volume 1)," Inklings Forever: Vol. 1 , Article 1. Available at: https://pillars.taylor.edu/inklings_forever/vol1/iss1/1 This Full Issue is brought to you for free and open access by the Center for the Study of C.S. Lewis & Friends at Pillars at Taylor University. It has been accepted for inclusion in Inklings Forever by an authorized editor of Pillars at Taylor University. For more information, please contact [email protected]. INKLINGS FOREVER A Collection of Essays Presented at tlte First FRANCES WHITE EWBANK COLLOQUIUM on C.S. LEWIS AND FRIENDS II ~ November 13-15, 1997 Taylor University Upland, Indiana ~'...... - · · .~ ·,.-: :( ·!' '- ~- '·' "'!h .. ....... .u; ~l ' ::-t • J. ..~ ,.. _r '· ,. 1' !. ' INKLINGS FOREVER A Collection of Essays Presented at the Fh"St FRANCES WHITE EWBANK COLLOQliTUM on C.S. LEWIS AND FRIENDS Novem.ber 13-15, 1997 Published by Taylor University's Lewis and J1nends Committee July1998 This collection is dedicated to Francis White Ewbank Lewis scholar, professor, and friend to students for over fifty years ACKNOWLEDGMENTS David Neuhauser, Professor Emeritus at Taylor and Chair of the Lewis and Friends Committee, had the vision, initiative, and fortitude to take the colloquium from dream to reality. Other committee members who helped in all phases of the colloquium include Faye Chechowich, David Dickey, Bonnie Houser, Dwight Jessup, Pam Jordan, Art White, and Daryl Yost.
    [Show full text]
  • Short Stories (PDF)
    The Works of George MacDonald Short Stories Table of Contents Books of Short Stories............................................................................................................................... 2 Paperback Editions........................................................................................................................................ 4 Short Stories: Articles, Videos, & Stage Productions.................................................................. 5 ! ⟵ Click here for Table of Contents PROSE: 1 Books of Short Stories Various compilations of MacDonald’s short stories exist. The hard cover books available from Johannesen Printing & Publishing are reproductions of editions published during MacDonald’s lifetime or, in the case of The Portent and Other Stories, shortly after his death. While some publishers have classified The Wise Woman as a short story, we have, like Johannesen Printing & Publishing, classified it as a (short) novel. Stories for Young Readers and Adults A number of MacDonald’s short stories—often classified as “fairy tales”—are equally for young readers and adults. These would include all of the stories listed in The Light Princess and Other Fairy Tales, below, as well as Photogen and Nycteris. Novels suitable for young readers are listed in the Novels PDF. Johannesen Printing & Publishing: Hand bound cloth cover editions The Light Princess and Other Fairy Tales Originally published between 1860 and 1890; reproduced from the 1893 edition by G.P. Putnam’s Sons, New York, with photolithography. Contents: 1. The Light Princess 2. The Giant’s Heart (also known as Tell Us a Story) 3. The Shadows 4. Cross Purposes 5. The Golden Key 6. The Carasoyn 7. Little Daylight ! ⟵ Click here for Table of Contents PROSE: 2 The Portent and Other Stories Originally published between 1854 and 1871; reproduced from the 1909 edition of Fisher Unwin, London. Contents: 1. The Portent 2.
    [Show full text]
  • YEARBOOK of The
    YEARBOOK of the IRISH PHILOSOPHICAL SOCIETY Special Issue Humans and Other Animals Fealsúnacht Φ 2017/18 Edited by: Noel Kavanagh Cara Nine Noel Kavanagh 4 Elderwood, Philosophy Department of Humanities University College Cork Carlow College, St. Patrick’s Cork College St., Co. Cork Carlow, Co. Carlow IRELAND IRELAND E-mail: [email protected] E-mail: [email protected] Board of Editorial Advisors: Maeve Cooke (UCDublin) Richard Kearney (Boston College) William Desmond (KULeuven) Cynthia Macdonald (QUBelfast) John Dillon (TCDublin) Dermot Moran (UCDublin) John Hayes (MI Limerick) Graham Parkes (UCCork) Teresa Iglesias (UCDublin) Peter Simons (TCDublin) Markus Wörner (NUIGalway) The Yearbook of the Irish Philosophical Society is a publication of the Irish Philosophical Society. It publishes peer-reviewed articles on a bi-annual basis, often originating in the Society’s conferences, and shares the Society’s purpose of promoting philosophy in Ireland. Papers to be considered for publication should be sent to the General Editor, or to the Associate Editor at their respective addresses above. Please comply with the Society’s style guide available on the society’s website and include an abstract of c. 100 words. See, www.irishphilosophicalsociety.ie The price of the Yearbook to members of the Irish Philosophical Society is €10; to non-members: €25. Institutional membership and subscription can be arranged. Please contact: Katherine Furman (Honorary Secretary) 4 Elderwood, Philosophy University College Cork Co. Cork IRELAND Email: [email protected] The views and opinions expressed in the articles do not necessarily represent those of the editors. The articles published are indexed in the Philosopher’s Index.
    [Show full text]
  • Internal Brakes on Violent Escalation: a Descriptive Typology FULL REPORT
    FEBRUARY 2019 The Internal Brakes on Violent Escalation: A Descriptive Typology FULL REPORT Joel Busher, Coventry University Donald Holbrook, University College London Graham Macklin, Oslo University We would like to thank the CREST team and stakeholders for their support and guidance throughout the course of this project. We would also like to thank Tam Sanger for their excellent transcription services, Rachel Monaghan for their comments on an earlier draft of this report, and the interviewees who kindly gave up their time to share their experiences and insights with us. This is the full report from the The Internal Brakes on Violent Escalation: A Descriptive Typology programme, funded by CREST. To find out more information about this programme, and to see other outputs from the team, visit: www.crestresearch.ac.uk/projects/internal-brakes-violent-escalation/ About CREST The Centre for Research and Evidence on Security Threats (CREST) is a national hub for understanding, countering and mitigating security threats. It is an independent centre, commissioned by the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) and funded in part by the UK security and intelligence agencies (ESRC Award: ES/N009614/1). www.crestresearch.ac.uk ©2019 CREST Creative Commons 4.0 BY-NC-SA licence. www.crestresearch.ac.uk/copyright TABLE OF CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ..........................................................................................................................5 1.1 The typology ...................................................................................................................................................................5
    [Show full text]
  • Cheerful Words. from the Writings of George Macdonald
    SPARE MINUTE SERIES. CHEERFUL WORDS, FROM THE WRITINGS OF GEORGE MACDONALD. SELECTED BY E. E. BROWN WITH AN INTRODUCTION BY JAMES T. FIELDS > i '"£" BOSTON^ D. LOTHROP & CO., FRANKLIN STREET CORNER OF HAWLEY. - Oh 5? Copyright by D. LOTHROP & COMPANY. 1880. INTRODUCTION. IT must be a very remote corner of America, indeed, where the writings of George MacDonald would not only be knowrv but ardently loved. David Elginbrod, Ranald Ban- nerman. Alec Forbes, Robert Falconer, and Little Diamond have many friends by this time all over the land, and are just as real personages, thousands of miles west of New York and Boston, as they are hereabouts. Now there must be some good reason for this exceptional universality of recognition, and it is not at all difficult to discern why MacDonald's characters should be welcome guests every- where. The writer who speaks through his beautiful crea- tures of imagination, imploring us to believe that " Every human heart is human. That in even savage bosoms There are longings, yearnings, strivings For the good they comprehend not. That the feeble hands and helpless Groping blindly in the darkness 3 " 4 Introduction. Touch God's right hand in that darkness And are lifted up and strengthened — that writer, if he be a master of his art, like MacDonald, will be a light and a joy in every household, however situated. It is pleasant, always, to hold up for admiration the authors who have borne witness to the eternal beauty and cheerful capabilities of the universe around us, whatever may be our own petty sufferings or discomforts ; who con- tinually teach us that Optimism is better than Pessimism, and much more moral as a conduct of life, and are lovingly reminding us, whenever they write books or poems, of the holiness of helpfulness.
    [Show full text]
  • The Immanence of Heaven in the Fiction of CS Lewis and George
    Shadows that Fall: The Immanence of Heaven in the Fiction of C. S. Lewis and George MacDonald David Manley Our life is no dream; but it ought to become one, and perhaps will. (Novalis) Solids whose shadow lay Across time, here (All subterfuge dispelled) Show hard and clear. (C.S. Lewis, “Emendation for the End of Goethe’s Faust”) .S. Lewis’s impressions of heaven, including the distinctive notions ofC Shadow-lands and Sehnsucht, were shaped by George MacDonald’s fiction.1 The vision of heaven Lewis and MacDonald share is central to their stories because it constitutes the telos of their main characters; for example, the quest for heaven is fundamental to both Lewis’s The Pilgrim’s Regress and MacDonald’s “The Golden Key.” Throughout their fiction, both writers reveal a world haunted by heaven and both relate rapturous human longing after the source of earthly glimpses; both show that the highest function of art is to initiate these visions of heaven; and both describe a heaven that swallows up Earth in an all-embracing finality. The play Shadowlands is aptly named; for Lewis, the greatest earthly joys were merely intimations of another world where beauty, in Hopkins’s words, is “kept / Far with fonder a care” (“The Golden Echo” lines 44-45). He was repeatedly “surprised by Joy,” overcome with flashes ofSehnsucht during which he felt he had “tasted Heaven” (Surprised 135). For Lewis, “. heaven remembering throws / Sweet influence still on earth . .” (“The Naked Seed” 19-20). This “sweet influence” is a desire, not satisfaction; in his words, it is a “hunger better than any other fullness” (“Preface” from Pilgrim 7).
    [Show full text]
  • Animal Abuse As a Sentinel for Human Violence: a Critique ∗ Emily G
    Journal of Social Issues, Vol. 65, No. 3, 2009, pp. 589--614 Animal Abuse as a Sentinel for Human Violence: A Critique ∗ Emily G. Patterson-Kane American Veterinary Medical Association Heather Piper Manchester Metropolitan University It has been suggested that acts of violence against human and nonhuman an- imals share commonalities, and that animal abuse is a sentinel for current or future violence toward people. The popular and professional acceptance of strong connections between types of violence is beginning to be used to justify social work interventions and to influence legal decision making, and so requires greater scrutiny. Examination of the limited pool of empirical data suggests that animal abuse is relatively common among men, with violent offenders having an increased probability of reporting prior animal abuse—with the majority of violent offend- ers not reporting any animal abuse. Causal explanations for “the link,” such as empathy impairment or conduct disorder, suffer from a lack of validating research and, based on research into interhuman violence, the assumption that violence has a predominant, single underlying cause must be questioned. An (over)emphasis on the danger that animal abusers pose to humans serves to assist in achieving a consensus that animal abuse is a serious issue, but potentially at the cost of failing to focus on the most common types of abuse, and the most effective strategies for reducing its occurrence. Nothing in this review and discussion should be taken as minimizing the importance of animals as frequent victims of violence, or the co-occurrence of abuse types in “at-risk” households.
    [Show full text]