DOCSLIB.ORG

Note of Case Hearing on 10 October 2019: Portrait of a Lady by Frans Hals (Case 14, 2019-20)

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Note of Case Hearing on 10 October 2019: Portrait of a Lady by Frans Hals (Case 14, 2019-20) Reviewing Committee on the Export of Works of Art and Objects of Cultural Interest, note of case hearing on 10 October 2019: Portrait of a Lady by Frans Hals (Case 14, 2019-20) Application 1. The Reviewing Committee on the Export of Works of Art and Objects of Cultural Interest (RCEWA) met on 10 October 2019 to consider an application to export Portrait of a Lady by Frans Hals. The value shown on the export licence application was £7,398,000 which represented an agreed sale price. The expert adviser had objected to the export of the painting under the second Waverley criterion on the grounds that its departure from the UK would be a misfortune because (ii) it was of outstanding aesthetic importance. 2. Six of the regular eight RCEWA members were present and were joined by three independent assessors, acting as temporary members of the Reviewing Committee. 3. The applicant confirmed that the value did not include VAT and that VAT would be payable in the event of a UK sale. The applicant also confirmed that the owner understood the circumstances under which an export licence might be refused and that, if the decision on the licence was deferred, the owner would allow the painting to be displayed for fundraising. Expert’s submission 4. The expert adviser had provided a written submission stating that Portrait of a Lady c.1625 was oil on canvas, measuring 116.7 by 91.5 cm. It was a rare example of a particularly fine and characteristic life-size, three-quarter- length portrait by Frans Hals, widely acknowledged to be one of the most important portrait painters in Western art. There were some areas of damage, particularly in the background, but these had been skilfully restored. However, visually these areas of restoration were very good. The sitter had been identified in an article published by Marieke de Winkel in 2012 as Cunera van Baersdorp (1600–1640). This painting, with the possible pendant, now at the Taft Museum of Art, Cincinnati (USA), was most probably painted to commemorate the marriage of Michiel de Wael and Cunera van Baersdorp in 1625. 5. Cunera van Baersdorp’s pose echoed that of her husband, who also had his left arm akimbo. Her right arm hung down beside her body and she held her gloves between two fingers. The imitation or mirroring of gestures was a device that Hals frequently employed in pendant portraits to great effect, with a daring that made him stand apart from his fellow portrait painters. The details of the dress were depicted in exquisite detail but without ever looking stiff, thanks to Frans Hals’s unique bravura brushwork. The stomacher, and also the exact shape of her cap, could be specifically dated to the middle of the 1620s, as not long after the appearance of both changed significantly. 6. The portrait was made when Frans Hals was at the height of his powers and popularity, and its exceptional attraction partly derived from the unorthodox pose; it was the only existing portrait by Hals showing a lady with her arm akimbo, a pose found in many male portraits by Hals and was something of a trademark of the painter. The pose was in fact highly unusual in female portraits throughout the 17th century. Moreover, she wore a resplendent dress, with the various subtle gradations in the blacks of the costume unusually well preserved. Although there were some outstanding works by Frans Hals in British collections, there was only one other three- quarter-length female portrait in a British public collection. Applicant’s submission 7. The applicant had stated in a written submission that they did not consider that the painting met any of the three Waverley criteria. Regarding the first Waverley criterion, the applicant stated that the work was painted in the first half of the 17th century but it only came to the UK relatively recently - after 1910, according to the known provenance. Whilst in the UK, it had largely been unexhibited publicly, and neither the artist nor the sitter had connections to the UK, its history, nor British national life. 8. Regarding the second Waverley criterion, the applicant stated that whilst this was a large-scale fully attributed portrait by Frans Hals, the sitter was actually unknown, the condition was compromised having been significantly damaged in the upper half by bomb damage during WWII, and it also pre-dated the artist’s most famous period - recognisable for its loose brushwork and bold colours. Further to this, its effect was diminished by its being evidently one half of a pair of portraits. 9. Regarding the third Waverley criterion, the applicant stated that further to the reasons listed above, it should be noted that the UK was particularly rich in this artist’s work, and principally in individual portraits of this kind, with plentiful examples found in both public and private hands. 10. In response to the expert’s statement regarding the identity of the sitter, the applicant stated that they did not agree that the identification by Marieke de Winker was definitive. As such, in their opinion, the known provenance of the painting could only be definitively be traced back to Galerie Charles Sedelmeyer, Paris, by 1899. Discussion by the Committee 11. The expert adviser and applicant retired and the Committee discussed the case. It was agreed that this was a visually imposing and attractive picture with great dignity and presence. They observed the painting included several individual elements for which Hals was known, especially the fantastic treatment of the drapery, and the layering of black on black. However, despite these elements, they agreed that overall the painting was not typical of the artist’s work. 12. The Committee discussed whether this was indeed a wedding portrait, and potentially the pendant to the picture at the Taft Museum of Art, Cincinnati. They agreed that portraits by Hals had greater impact in pairs, and that this was most likely a wedding portrait. However, they asserted that it was not possible to definitively state that this was the pendant to the Cincinnati picture. They further noted that UK collections were rich with Hals’s paintings, most of which were more representative of the artist’s style. 13. In regard to the condition of the painting, the Committee noted damage had occurred mainly at the top left of the painting in a relatively unimportant area. They agreed the painting had been expertly restored, however these issues had to a certain extent compromised the work, which was no longer comparable in quality to Hals’s paintings already in UK public collections. The Committee concluded that, while it was an interesting picture which displayed some very accomplished passages of painting, it was not of outstanding significance and did not meet any of the three Waverley criteria. Waverley Criteria 14. The Committee voted on whether the painting met the Waverley criteria. No members voted that it met the Waverley criteria. The painting was therefore not found to meet any of the Waverley criteria. Communication of findings 15. The expert adviser and the applicant returned. The Chairman notified them of the Committee’s decision on its recommendation to the Secretary of State. .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Sztuki Piękne)
    Sebastian Borowicz Rozdział VII W stronę realizmu – wiek XVII (sztuki piękne) „Nikt bardziej nie upodabnia się do szaleńca niż pijany”1079. „Mistrzami malarstwa są ci, którzy najbardziej zbliżają się do życia”1080. Wizualna sekcja starości Wiek XVII to czas rozkwitu nowej, realistycznej sztuki, opartej już nie tyle na perspektywie albertiańskiej, ile kepleriańskiej1081; to również okres malarskiej „sekcji” starości. Nigdy wcześniej i nigdy później w historii europejskiego malarstwa, wyobrażenia starych kobiet nie były tak liczne i tak różnicowane: od portretu realistycznego1082 1079 „NIL. SIMILIVS. INSANO. QVAM. EBRIVS” – inskrypcja umieszczona na kartuszu, w górnej części obrazu Jacoba Jordaensa Król pije, Kunsthistorisches Museum, Wiedeń. 1080 Gerbrand Bredero (1585–1618), poeta niderlandzki. Cyt. za: W. Łysiak, Malarstwo białego człowieka, t. 4, Warszawa 2010, s. 353 (tłum. nieco zmienione). 1081 S. Alpers, The Art of Describing – Dutch Art in the Seventeenth Century, Chicago 1993; J. Friday, Photography and the Representation of Vision, „The Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism” 59:4 (2001), s. 351–362. 1082 Np. barokowy portret trumienny. Zob. także: Rembrandt, Modląca się staruszka lub Matka malarza (1630), Residenzgalerie, Salzburg; Abraham Bloemaert, Głowa starej kobiety (1632), kolekcja prywatna; Michiel Sweerts, Głowa starej kobiety (1654), J. Paul Getty Museum, Los Angeles; Monogramista IS, Stara kobieta (1651), Kunsthistorisches Museum, Wiedeń. 314 Sebastian Borowicz po wyobrażenia alegoryczne1083, postacie biblijne1084, mitologiczne1085 czy sceny rodzajowe1086; od obrazów o charakterze historyczno­dokumentacyjnym po wyobrażenia należące do sfery historii idei1087, wpisujące się zarówno w pozy­ tywne1088, jak i negatywne klisze kulturowe; począwszy od Prorokini Anny Rembrandta, przez portrety ubogich staruszek1089, nobliwe portrety zamoż­ nych, starych kobiet1090, obrazy kobiet zanurzonych w lekturze filozoficznej1091 1083 Bernardo Strozzi, Stara kobieta przed lustrem lub Stara zalotnica (1615), Музей изобразительных искусств им.
    [Show full text]
  • "MAN with a BEER KEG" ATTRIBUTED to FRANS HALS TECHNICAL EXAMINATION and SOME ART HISTORICAL COMMENTARIES • by Daniel Fabian
    Centre for Conservation and Technical Studies Fogg Art Museum Harvard University 1'1 Ii I "MAN WITH A BEER KEG" ATTRIBUTED TO FRANS HALS TECHNICAL EXAMINATION AND SOME ART HISTORICAL COMMENTARIES • by Daniel Fabian July 1984 ___~.~J INDEX Abst act 3 In oduction 4 ans Hals, his school and circle 6 Writings of Carel van Mander Technical examination: A. visual examination 11 B ultra-violet 14 C infra-red 15 D IR-reflectography 15 E painting materials 16 F interpretatio of the X-radiograph 25 G remarks 28 Painting technique in the 17th c 29 Painting technique of the "Man with a Beer Keg" 30 General Observations 34 Comparison to other paintings by Hals 36 Cone usions 39 Appendix 40 Acknowl ement 41 Notes and References 42 Bibliog aphy 51 ---~ I ABSTRACT The "Man with a Beer Keg" attributed to Frans Hals came to the Centre for Conservation and Technical Studies for technical examination, pigment analysis and restoration. A series of samples was taken and cross-sections were prepared. The pigments and the binding medium were identified and compared to the materials readily available in 17th century Holland. Black and white, infra-red and ultra-violet photographs as well as X-radiographs were taken and are discussed. The results of this study were compared to 17th c. materials and techniques and to the literature. 3 INTRODUCTION The "Man with a Beer Keg" (oil on canvas 83cm x 66cm), painted around 1630 - 1633) appears in the literature in 1932. [1] It was discovered in London in 1930. It had been in private hands and was, at the time, celebrated as an example of an unsuspected and startling find of an old master.
    [Show full text]
  • Walk Among Teyler and Hals
    Verspronckweg Schotersingel Kloppersingel Staten Bolwerk Kennemerplein Rozenstraat Prinsen Bolwerk Kenaustraat Stationsplein singel Parkeergarage Stationsplein Garenkookerskade Kenaupark Kinderhuis Parklaan Parklaan Parklaan Kruisweg Jansweg Parklaan Hooimarkt Spaarne Nieuwe Gracht Nieuwe Gracht Nassaustraat Zijlweg Kinderhuissingel Kinderhuisvest Ridderstraat BakenessergrachtBakenessergracht Koudenhorn Kruisstraat Molen De Adriaan Grote or St. Bavokerk (20, St Bavo’s Church) was built in Gothic Walk left of the town hall into Koningstraat. Halfway down this street, on your Jansstraat 22 Nassaulaan style in the spot where a smaller church, which was largely destroyed in right, you can see the former school for Catholic girls, ‘Inrichting voor Onderwijs Route 1 - Starting point: Frans Hals Museum Route map WALK AMONG a fire in the 14th century, once stood. St Bavo is the patron saint of the aan Katholieke Meisjes’ and then on your left at No. 37, the asymmetrically shaped Zijlstraat Papentorenvest Route 2 - Starting point: Teylers Museum Smedestraat TEYLER AND HALS Kennemerland region. In 1479, the building was rebuilt as a collegiate church. former bakery (24) in Berlage style (1900). Decorative Jugendstil carvings by Brouwersvaart The remarkable thing about this church is that it was built without piles in G. Veldheer embellish both sides of the freestone façade frame. The figure of a Bakenessergracht the ground. Grote or St. Bavokerk is sometimes also referred to as ‘Jan met baker is depicted in the keystone above the shop window. Gedempte Oude Gracht Zijlstraat Raaks 15 de hoge schouders’ (high-shouldered John) because the tower is rather small Barteljorisstraat compared to the rest of the building. The church houses the tombs of Frans At the end of Koningstraat, cross Gedempte Oude Gracht and continue straight on Grote 16 Parkeer- Drossestraat 23 19 Hals, Pieter Teyler Van der Hulst and Pieter Jansz.
    [Show full text]
  • Master Education in Arts
    Course title Art 160: Dutch Art and Architecture (3 credits) Course description Introduction to the history of Dutch Art and Architecture, from the Middle Ages to the Present day. The program contains a lot of excursions to view the various artworks ’live’. The program will bring insight in how to look at art and how the Dutch identity is reflected in artworks and the importance of the works in culture and history. This will be achieved by presentations of classmates, lectures, reading and fieldtrips. Instructor: Ludie Gootjes-Klamer Artist and Master Education in Arts. Textbooks Reader: Introduction to Dutch Art and Architecture by Ludie Gootjes- Klamer Students learning Goals and Objectives Goals 1. Insight in Dutch Art and Architecture 2. Learning in small groups 3. Use the ‘Looking at art’ method. 4. Practise in giving an interesting, informing and appealing presentation to classmates. 5. Essay writing. 6. Reflect on artworks and fieldtrips Objectives - Dutch Old masters (such as Rembrandt, Frans Hals, and Vermeer.) - Building styles (Roman, Gothic, Nieuwe Bouwen, Berlage.) - Cobra movement (Appel, Corneille, Lucebert) - De Stijl ( Rietveld, Mondriaan) - Temporary Artists Methods 1. Lectures 2. Excursions 3. Reading 4. Presentations by the students for their classmates. 5. Essay writing Class Attendance an Participation Minimal 90% Attendance. Participation in excursions and presentation in small groups are mandatory. Written reflections on excursion and presentations are mandatory. Examination First and Final impression(A) 0,5 Essay (B) 0,5 Presentation (C) 0,5 Reflection on Fieldtrips (D) 0,5 Final Exam (E) 1 -------------------------------------- 3 ECTS Tentative Course Outline Week 4 20 jan. Lecture and excursion Zwolle Week 5 30 jan.
    [Show full text]
  • Case 16 2010-11 a Painting by Frans Hals, Family Portrait- Expert's
    Case 16 2010-11 : A painting by Frans Hals, Family Portrait in a Landscape Expert Adviser’s Statement Reviewing Committee Secretary’s note: Please note that the illustrations referred to have not been reproduced on the MLA website EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Frans Hals (ca.1582/3-1666) and Salomon de Bray (1597-1664) Family Portrait in a Landscape, ca. 1621-22, 1628 Signed with monogram, left: FH ; signed and dated, lower left: S. de Bray / 16(2)8 Oil on canvas, 151 x 163.6 cm CONDITION The painting is in very good condition overall. The canvas has been lined. There are no significant losses to the paint layer, just some scattered areas of retouching most notable in the apron of the girl at lower left. The varnish layer is somewhat discoloured. PROVENANCE [possibly] sale J. de Nooy, Haarlem (de Nooy), 30 April 1811, lot 7 (‘De Portraiten van negen Personen ten voeten uit, zijnde een Heer en Dame, met Kinderen van verschillende groote, allen in een bevallige Houding, en een der beste stukken’ [‘The Portraits of nine Persons, full length, a Man and a Woman, with Children of varying sizes, all in attractive poses, and one of the best pieces (of the artist)’]; 59 x 65 duim [c. 151.8 x 167.3 cm]) Sale J. A. Bennet, Leiden (van der Hoek), 10 April 1829, lot 57 (fl. 45, bought in) Collection Gustavus William Hamilton-Russell, 9th Viscount Boyne (1864– 1942), Bridgnorth, Shropshire (by 1929) On extended loan to the National Museums and Galleries of Wales (1971- 2004) EXHIBITIONS London, Royal Academy, Exhibition of Dutch Art 1450-1900 , 1929, no.
    [Show full text]
  • Press Release (PDF)
    YA L E U N I V E R S I T Y A R T PRESS For Immediate Release GALLERY RELEASE September 26, 2014 AN OUTSTANDING LOAN TO THE YALE UNIVERSITY ART GALLERY OF 30 DUTCH 17TH-CENTURY PAINTINGS FROM THE ROSE-MARIE AND EIJK VAN OTTERLOO COLLECTION New Haven, Conn., September 26, 2014—The tremendous commercial and political success enjoyed by the Dutch Republic during the 17th century led to an unprecedented period of cultural, artistic, and scientific accomplishment in the Netherlands. This era is generally considered the Golden Age of Dutch art, when painters developed a range of new styles and subjects and achieved levels of quality unparalleled by any other European school at the time. Already coveted by collectors in 18th-century Britain, paintings by the Dutch masters have been the object of fierce competition among Jacob van Ruisdael, View of Haarlem, ca. 1670–75. Oil on canvas. Rose-Marie and Eijk van Otterloo French, German, and American collectors since the middle of the Collection 19th century, and today they command pride of place on the walls of museums and galleries around the world. Over the past two decades, Rose-Marie and Eijk van Otterloo have assembled one of the most magnificent private collections of 17th-century Dutch art in the world, comprising superb examples of nearly all the major categories of subject matter explored by artists of the time: portraits, landscapes, church interiors, still lifes, genre scenes, and more. All of the works in the van Otterloo collection are distinguished by their remarkable quality, enviable condition, and dazzling display of pictorial craft.
    [Show full text]
  • RCEWA – Portrait of a Lady by Frans Hals Statement of the Expert
    RCEWA – Portrait of a Lady by Frans Hals Statement of the Expert Adviser to the Secretary of State that the painting meets Waverley criterion two. Further Information The ‘Applicant’s statement’ and the ‘Note of Case History’ are available on the Arts Council Website: www.artscouncil.org.uk/reviewing-committee-case-hearings Please note that images and appendices referenced are not reproduced. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 1. Brief Description of item(s) Frans Hals (1582/3–1666) Portrait of a Lady (Portrait of Cunera van Baersdorp, 1600–1640) c.1625 Oil on canvas, 116.7 x 91.5 cm Condition: the lined canvas appears to have a large triangular inlay extending from the top edge, to the left of the sitter’s head. This could be a tear and/or fold repair, or an insert of new canvas. The painting appears to have been conserved and is in good condition. There are numerous areas of restoration, particularly in the background and substantial in places. Visually these areas of restoration are very good. 2. Context Provenance: By inheritance via the 9th child (Josijntje) of Michiel de Wael and the sitter, Cunera van Baersdorp, to Kornelis Johannes de Vriese (1768–1803), in whose collection it was seen and described by the lawyer and antiquarian Jacobus Scheltema (1767– 1835), who probably bought it (together with its pendant) after the death of Kornelis Johannes de Vriese; sale Hendrik Adriaan van den Heuvel et al. (supplementary, anonymous part, including works brought in by Jacobus Scheltema), Utrecht, 27 June 1825 and following days (Lugt 10935), lot 153 (together with its pendant); Dealer C.
    [Show full text]
  • Portrait of a Girl Wearing a Gold-Trimmed Cloak and Saint Bavo
    DATE: October 16, 2009 FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE EXCEPTIONAL REMBRANDT LOANS COMPLEMENT THE GETTY MUSEUM’S MONUMENTAL REMBRANDT DRAWINGS EXHIBITION Seven Rembrandt paintings on view at the Getty Center include Portrait of a Girl Wearing a Gold-Trimmed Cloak and Saint Bavo LOS ANGELES—In conjunction with the Getty Museum’s major international loan exhibition Drawings by Rembrandt and His Pupils: Telling the Difference, visitors to the Getty Center will also have the opportunity to experience Rembrandt’s artistic genius in the Museum’s East Pavilion paintings galleries through a number of special loans that will be on view in conjunction with this special exhibition. In addition to the Getty’s own Rembrandt paintings, An Old Man in Military Costume, The Abduction of Europa, Daniel and Cyrus Before the Idol Bel, and Saint Bartholomew, which always reside in these galleries as part of the museum’s permanent collection, the Getty will also exhibit several Rembrandt masterpieces on long-term loan, including Rembrandt’s Portrait of a Girl Wearing a Gold-Trimmed Cloak from a private collection and Saint Bavo from the Göteborgs konstmuseum in Sweden. Portrait of a Girl Wearing a Gold-Trimmed Cloak The work, which has not been on public view since the 1970s, is on loan from a private collection in New York. The sitter, an unknown woman, is richly dressed in the fanciful costume Rembrandt favored for biblical and mythological paintings. He scratched in the thick, wet paint to create the pleats of the subject's white shirt, and rendered gold embroidery on her black gown with almost an abstract series of daubs.
    [Show full text]
  • FRANS HALS (Antwerp 1582/3 – 1666 Haarlem)
    CS0309 FRANS HALS (Antwerp 1582/3 – 1666 Haarlem) A Portrait of a Man holding a Pair of Gloves Inscribed: ÆTAT. SVÆ 37-/ANo 1637- On canvas, 36 ½ x 26 ½ ins. (93 x 67 cm) and A Portrait of a Woman holding a Pair of Gloves Inscribed: ÆTAT.SVÆ 36./ANo 1637. On canvas, 36 ½ x 26 ½ ins. (93 x 67 cm) PROVENANCE Comte de Thiènnes, Kasteel Rumbeke, Belgium, acquired in the 19th century His granddaughter, Comtesse de Limburg-Stirum, Warmond, The Netherlands M. E. van Gelder, Château Zeecrabbe, Uccle, Belgium, by 1911 Sir William van Horne, Montreal, by 1912 Miss Adaline van Horne, by 1936 Gifted to Mrs. William van Horne, 14 June 1944i Wildenstein and Co., New York From whom acquired by Ambassador J. William Middendorf II, March 1973 Anonymous sale, London, Sotheby’s, 8 December 1986, lots 52 and 53 (as property of an American Collector) With Robert Noortman Gallery, London and Maastricht From whom acquired by a Belgian private collector, in 1996 Anon. sale, Sothebys, New York, 29 January 2009, lots 45 & 46 (unsold) Private Collection, Belgium, 2016 EXHIBITED Montreal, Art Association of Montreal, Inaugural Loan Exhibition of Paintings, December 1912, no. 66 Montreal, Art Association of Montreal, A Selection from the Collection of Paintings of the Late Sir William van Horne, K.C.M.G., 16 October – 5 November 1933, no. 30 Montreal, Art Association of Montreal, Loan Exhibition of Great Paintings: Five Centuries of Dutch Art, 9 March to 9 April, 1944, no. 34 On loan to and exhibited at the Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam, 1973-79 On loan to and exhibited at the Fogg Art Museum, Harvard University, Cambridge, Mass., 1979-86 LITERATURE C.
    [Show full text]
  • News Release
    NEWS RELEASE FOURTH STREET AT CONSTITUTION AVENUE NW WASHINGTON DC 20565 . 737-4215/842-6353 FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE CONTACT: Deborah Ziska Elizabeth Kimball (202) 842-6353 NATIONAL GALLERY TO PRESENT FIRST MAJOR EXHIBITION OF FRANS HALS PAINTINGS OUTSIDE THE NETHERLANDS WASHINGTON, D.C., July 12, 1989 - The first major exhibition of paintings by the great seventeenth-century portrait painter Frans Hals to be held outside the Netherlands will be presented in the West Building of the National Gallery of Art, October 1- December 31, 1989. The exhibition has been organized by the Royal Academy of Arts, London, in association with the National Gallery of Art, Washington, and the Frans Halsmuseum in Haarlem, the Netherlands. Frans Hals is supported at the National Gallery of Art by a generous grant from Republic National Bank of New York. The National Gallery will be the first venue and the only one in the United States for the exhibition. The exhibition contains more than sixty paintings and small oil sketches drawn from all phases of Hals' remarkable career. They have been borrowed from major public and private collections in Europe, the United States, and the Soviet Union. Examples of all facets of his work will be shown, including his earliest known painting, a portrait of Jacobius Zaffius (1611), genre scenes, among them Merry Drinker (c. 1628), family portraits such as the large Family Group in a Landscape (1648) , and his remarkable regent portraits, including the portraits of the regents and regentesses of the Old Men's Alms House in Haarlem, painted c. 1665. -more- page two .
    [Show full text]
  • Michael Sweerts (1618-1664) and the Academic Tradition
    ABSTRACT Title of Document: MICHAEL SWEERTS (1618-1664) AND THE ACADEMIC TRADITION Lara Rebecca Yeager-Crasselt, Doctor of Philosophy, 2013 Directed By: Professor Arthur K. Wheelock, Jr., Department of Art History and Archaeology This dissertation examines the career of Flemish artist Michael Sweerts (1618-1664) in Brussels and Rome, and his place in the development of an academic tradition in the Netherlands in the seventeenth century. Sweerts demonstrated a deep interest in artistic practice, theory and pedagogy over the course of his career, which found remarkable expression in a number of paintings that represent artists learning and practicing their profession. In studios and local neighborhoods, Sweerts depicts artists drawing or painting after antique sculpture and live models, reflecting the coalescence of Northern and Southern attitudes towards the education of artists and the function and meaning of the early modern academy. By shifting the emphasis on Sweerts away from the Bamboccianti – the contemporary group of Dutch and Flemish genre painters who depicted Rome’s everyday subject matter – to a different set of artistic traditions, this dissertation is able to approach the artist from new contextual and theoretical perspectives. It firmly situates Sweerts within the artistic and intellectual contexts of his native Brussels, examining the classicistic traditions and tapestry industry that he encountered as a young, aspiring artist. It positions him and his work in relation to the Italian academic culture he experienced in Rome, as well as investigating his engagement with the work of the Flemish sculptor François Duquesnoy (1597-1643) and the French painter Nicholas Poussin (1594-1665). The breadth of Sweerts’ artistic and academic pursuits ultimately provide significant insight into the ways in which the Netherlandish artistic traditions of naturalism and working from life coalesced with the theoretical and practical aims of the academy.
    [Show full text]
  • DISSOLUTE SELF-PORTRAITS in SEVENTEENTH-CENTURY DUTCH and FLEMISH ART In
    ABSTRACT Title of Document: HOE SCHILDER HOE WILDER: DISSOLUTE SELF-PORTRAITS IN SEVENTEENTH-CENTURY DUTCH AND FLEMISH ART Ingrid A. Cartwright, Ph.D., 2007 Directed By: Professor Arthur K. Wheelock, Jr., Department of Art History and Archaeology In the seventeenth century, Dutch and Flemish artists presented a strange new face to the public in their self-portraits. Rather than assuming the traditional guise of the learned gentleman artist that was fostered by Renaissance topoi , many painters presented themselves in a more unseemly light. Dropping the noble robes of the pictor doctus, they smoked, drank, and chased women. Dutch and Flemish artists explored a new mode of self-expression in dissolute self-portraits, embracing the many behaviors that art theorists and the culture at large disparaged. Dissolute self-portraits stand apart from what was expected of a conventional self-portrait, yet they were nonetheless appreciated and valued in Dutch culture and in the art market. This dissertation explores the ways in which these untraditional self- portraits functioned in art and culture in the seventeenth century. Specifically, this study focuses on how these unruly expressions were ultimately positive statements concerning theories of artistic talent and natural inclination. Dissolute self-portraits also reflect and respond to a larger trend regarding artistic identity in the seventeenth century, notably, the stereotype “ hoe schilder hoe wilder ” that posited Dutch and Flemish artists as intrinsically unruly characters prone to prodigality and dissolution. Artists embraced this special identity, which in turn granted them certain freedoms from social norms and a license to misbehave. In self- portraits, artists emphasized their dissolute nature by associating themselves with themes like the Five Senses and the Prodigal Son in the tavern.
    [Show full text]