Some Factors Historically Affecting the Distribution and Abundance of Fishes in the Gunnison River
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
fib SOME FACTORS HISTORICALLY AFFECTING THE DISTRIBUTION AND ABUNDANCE OF FISHES IN THE GUNNISON RIVER Final Report for Tishery Investigations of *the Lower Gunnison River Drainage by William J. Wiltzius Wildlife Researcher C Financed with Section 8 Funds of the Colorado River Storage Project Administered by . United States Bureau of Reclamation Colorado Division of Wildlife Jack R. Grieb, Director Department of Natural Resources Harris D. Sherman, Executive Director Colorado Division of Wildlife Fort Collins, Colorado September 25, 1978 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page LIST OF TABLES ................................................. iv LIST OF FIGURES ............................................... vi LIST OF APPENDICES ............................................. vii INTRODUCTION ................................................... 1 LOCATION AND DESCRIPTION OF STUDY AREA ........................... 7 GUNNISON RIVER DRAINAGE BASIN ............................... 7 DAMS AND RESERVOIRS ........................................ 15 DIVERSIONS--Gunnison Tunnel ................................. 17 METHODS AND MATERIALS 22 LIMNOLOGICAL CHARACTERISTICS 22 Stream Flows .......................................... 22 Temperatures .......................................... 22 Water Analyses ........................................ 24 Bottom .Fauna Collections.and.Identificationg ; . " 24 FISHERIES STUDIES .......................................... 25 Fish Collections and Identification ...................... 25 Marked Fish Studies .................................... 28 Fluorescent Pigment Marking ........................ 28 Tetracycline Marking ............................... 30 Fin-clip Marking .................................. 31 Creel Census Studies .................................. 31 Early Questionnaires, 1973-74 ...................... 31 1977 Random Survey of Lower Gunnison ................ 33 Age and Growth ........................................ 39 STATISTICAL ANALYSES ........................................ 40 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION .......................................... 41 HISTORIC STREAMFLOWS ........................................ 42 Influence of Taylor Dam ................................. 42 Influence of Gunnison Tunnel and Curecanti Dams on Flows . 45 EFFECTS OF DAMS ON STREAM TEMPERATURE ........................ 47 Taylor Park Reservoir .................................. 47 Curecanti Unit Reservoirs ............................... 50 EFFECTS OF DAMS ON WATER QUALITY AND BOTTOM FAUNA ............. 54 GUNNISON RIVER SALMONID FISHERY ............................. 61 Early Renown .......................................... 61 Influence of Railroads ................................. 67 Contests, Record Trout, Stocking, and Catch Composition. 70 Influence of Taylor Park Reservoir ...................... 78 Fisherman Use and Harvest Trends--Pre- and Post-Curecanti. 81 1977 Random Survey of Lower Gunnison . 91 Lower River Rainbow Harvest--from Stocking, Natural Reproduction, or Reservoirs above? ................ 94 Fish Growth in Lower Gunnison River (National Monument). 99 HISTORIC DISTRIBUTION OF NON-SALMONID SPECIES ................ 101 Cyprinidae ............................................ 103 Roundtail chub--(Gila robusta Baird and Girard) . 103 Colorado squawfish--(FtychocheiZus Zucius Girard) . 106 Speckled dace--(Rhinichthys oscuZus Girard) ......... 113 Longnose dace--(Ainichthys cataractae Valenciennes). 113 ii TABLE OF CONTENTS (cont.) Page Fathead minnow- -(Pimephales promelas Rafinesque) . 115 Carp -- (Cprinus carpio Linnaeus) ...................... 118 Red shiner- - (Notropis lutrensis Baird and Girard). 119 Sand shiner- - (Notropis stramineus Cope) ................ 120 Catostomidae ............................................ 122 Flannelmouth sucker- - (Catostomus Zatipinnis Baird and Girard) .............................................. 122 Bluehead sucker -- (Catostomus discobolus Cope) .......... 126 Plains mountain sucker- - (Catostomus platyrhynchus Cope) 130 White sucker- - (Catostomus commersoni Lacepede) ....... 131 Longnose sucker- - (Catostomus catostomus Forster) . 135 Humpback sucker- - (Xyrauchen texanus Abbott) ............ 138 Bluehead sucker x white sucker hybrid .................. 141 ,.FlannelmOuth sucker x.white sucker. hybrid. 143 - Longnose sucker x white sucker hybrid .................. 145 Bluehead sucker x flannelmouth sucker hybrid .......... 145 Bluehead sucker x longnose sucker hybrid .............. 146 Ictaluridae 147 Channel catfish- - (Ictalurus punctatus Rafinesque). 147 Black bullhead -- (Ictalurus meZas Rafinesque) ......... 148 Centrarchidae .......................................... 150 Largemouth bass -- (Micropterus saZmoides Lacepede). 150 Green sunfish- - (Lepomis cyanellus Rafinesque) ......... 151 Cyprinodontidae ........................................ 152 Plains killifish- - (FunduZus kansae Garman) ............ 152 Cottidae ............................................... 154 Mottled sculpin--(Cottus bairdi Girard) ................ 154 Piute sculpin--(Cottus beldingi Eigenmann and Eigenmann) 156 Esocidae ............................................... 157 Northern pike- - (Esox Zucius Linnaeus) .................. 157 MANAGEMENT PLANS AND RECOMMENDATIONS ................................ 159 BLUE MESA RESERVOIR AND UPPER GUNNISON RIVER .................... 159 MORROW POINT AND CRYSTAL RESERVOIRS .............................. 164 LOWER GUNNISON RIVER (BELOW CRYSTAL DAM) ........................ 166 SUMMARY .............................................................. 171 LITERATURE CITED .................................................... 189 APPENDICES .......................................................... 195 iii LIST OF TABLES Table Page 1 Curecanti Unit-specifications of dams, reservoirs and powerplants ...................................... 16 2 Quarterly fisherman questionnaire used during 1973-74 ............................................. 32 3 Sampling dates for lower Gunnison creel census, 1977 ............................................... 34 4 Historic mean monthly discharge (cfs) of Taylor River at Almont with estimated effects of Taylor Park and Curecanti reservoirs ......................... 44 ' • . .• ' ..• , - • Mean monthly and annual flows and diversions at the Tunnel area of the Gunnison River during various time periods, 1904-1975 ....................... 46 6 Historical effect of Taylor Dam on flows at various stations below the dam ............................... 49 Monthly mean maximum and minimum temperatures (F) of Blue Mesa Reservoir discharge after initial impoundment in October 1965 .................... 51 8 Mean monthly temperature at various stations below Curecanti reservoirs with estimated effect of the dams on temperatures in the Tunnel area of the Gunnison River ................................. 53 9 Mean monthly water temperature (F) of Gunnison River. at Grand Junction, Colorado, 195171973 . - ..... 55 10 Historical flow pattern of Gunnison River before and after Curecanti dams at two stations below the reservoirs during some months when tempera- tures were significantly lowered at Grand Junction, Colorado ............................................ 56 11 Historic creel-census and stocking data from the Gunnison River above the Cimarron River, 1942-1965 ............................................ 76 12 Creel-census and stocking data for Blue Mesa Reservoir, 1966-1976 ................................. 77 13 Estimates and projections of fisherman-use and harvest for various sections of the Gunnison River below North Beaver Creek ........................ 84 iv LIST OF TABLES (cont.) Table page 14 Comparison of fisherman-use and harvest estimates for some area of the Gunnison River with that of Blue Mesa Reservoir in various years ................ 86 15 Creel-census estimates for various areas of the Gunnison River below Crystal dam, April 16 - October 11, 1977 .................................... 93 16 Comparison of 1977 fisherman-use, harvest and stocking costs for various areas of the Gunni- son River below North Beaver Creek with Curecanti (W.C.) and without Curecanti Unit (W.O.C.) ..... 98 17 . Comparison of rainbow trout rota]. length ranges (in.). for iraiicitis ages, pre- and post-Curecanti Unit in the Gunnison National Monument ................ 100 18 Comparison of species composition, mean length (in.), and ranges for the fish captured within the Gunnison National Monument, pre- and post- Curecanti Unit ...................................... 102 19 Percent of years with mean monthly flow above long-term historic average flow (cfs) in various historic periods for the Gunnison River at Grand Junction ...................................... 110 20 Composition comparison for the sucker species taken in various years pre- and post-Curecanti Unit in different sections of the Gunnison River below the dams and above the North Fork junction ............................................ 125 LIST OF FIGURES Figure .1218!. 1 Curecanti Unit-Colorado River Storage Project ............ 3 2 Gunnison-Uncompahgre drainage basin and popula- tion, 1965 .............................................. 8 3 Topographic overlay of Gunnison-drainage basin with gradient of Gunnison River above Delta, Colorado ................................................ 9 4 Main fisherman-access roads for Gunnison River below Blue Mesa Dam 11 5 Post-card questionnaire, lower Gunnison creel • survey 9, 1977. O O O O O • .. • • • • . • •• • • • • • • • • 36 •.•