DOCSLIB.ORG

Analysis of Maritime Transit Trends in the Arctic Passages

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Analysis of Maritime Transit Trends in the Arctic Passages chapter 9 Analysis of Maritime Transit Trends in the Arctic Passages Frédéric Lasserre and Olga Alexeeva* Introduction An increase in maritime activity will no doubt be one of the most important consequences of climate change in the Arctic region thanks to the unprece- dented melting of sea ice. The development of commercial shipping through newly-accessible routes will, however, raise a number of difficult issues: estab- lishing an effective response capability in the event of accidents, monitoring the exploitation of natural resources and curbing illegal trafficking in all of its forms. An increase in maritime traffic will also bring disagreements about the legal status of the new sea lanes and the right to exercise authority over them to the fore. While all of these questions warrant careful analysis and consider- ation, this contribution will focus on the present situation of commercial ship- ping through Arctic waters, specifically the Northwest Passage (NWP) and the Northeast Passage (NEP), and the potential for an increase in such activity. For several years, media stories have prophesied an Arctic maritime traffic boom. With no concrete economic analysis in support, such predictions have been little more than speculation.1 Some commentators have expressed the view that the Northwest Passage, toll free, will witness an expansion in traffic greater than the Northeast Passage.2 While maritime traffic patterns in the Arctic have been slow to change, since 2009 there has been a clear if modest * Frédéric Lasserre is Professor, Department of Geography and Director, Observatory of International Research on Water, Laval University, Quebec City, Canada. Olga Alexeeva is Assistant Professor, Department of History and Raoul-Dandurand Chair, University of Quebec in Montreal (UQAM), Canada. 1 F. Lasserre, “Changements climatiques dans l’Arctique: vers la disparition de la banquise?,” in Passages et mers arctiques: géopolitique d’une région en mutation, ed. F. Lasserre (Québec: Presses de l’Université du Québec, 2010). 2 See: M. Byers, “Defending the North: Who’s Responsibility?” Presentation at the conference “The United States, Climate Change, and the Arctic. Renewed American Interest in a Changing North,” UQÀM, Montreal, 19–20 April 2007; and R. Huebert, “Climate Change and Canadian Sovereignty in the Northwest Passage,” ISUMA Canadian Journal of Policy Research 2, no. 4 (2001): 86–94. © koninklijke brill nv, leiden, 2015 | doi 10.1163/9789004284593_010 <UN> Analysis of Maritime Transit Trends 181 increase in the commercial use of both Passages. Relying on data provided by databases in Canada and Norway/Russia, this contribution aims to draw a real- istic picture of the future of commercial shipping in the Arctic sea lanes. Methodological Considerations: Diversity of the Data The analysis of transit traffic through the Northwest Passage and the Northeast Passage is based upon two specialized databases, one in Canada, the other in Norway/Russia. For the NWP, the database maintained by the Canadian Coast Guard, tasked with the responsibility of implementing the Northern Canada Vessel Traffic Services Zone Regulations (NORDREG), is an invaluable source of informa- tion. The database indicates the type of vessel, and provides various technical data including its size, ice class, power and cargo volume; the dates of its entry and exit from the NORDREG zone; the number of people on board; and the number of discrete movements completed by the ship within the zone. Details of ships’ movements within the Arctic Canada Traffic Zone are not provided. It is, therefore, not possible to know the specific routes ships take within the Canadian Arctic. This can be reconstructed using the detailed, but process- intensive, INNAV (Information System on Marine Navigation) database set up by the Canadian Coast Guard. While partial and complete transits of the NWP are also indicated, the main focus of the database is on ship movements within the NORDREG zone. On the other side of the Arctic basin, for the NEP, the Centre for High North Logistics (CHNL) is the “international knowledge hub on Arctic transport and logistics for businesses, research institutions and public authorities.”3 It is based in Kirkenes, Norway, with a branch in Murmansk, Russia. With the help of the Russian Northern Sea Route Administration (NSRA), it compiles data on transits across the Northern Sea Route between the Kara Gates and the Bering Strait, which includes the Northeast Passage. In addition, the NSRA provides real-time information on ship movements along the Northern Sea Route (NSR).4 At present, no information regarding a ships’ origin or destination is recorded, nor is the data from previous years conserved. It remains to be seen whether such data will at some point in the future be consolidated as is cur- rently being done in the NORDREG system. 3 Centre for High North Logistics, website at www.chnl.no/. 4 NSRA, “Daily Diagram of Vessel Movements in the Water Area of the Northern Sea Route,” http://www.nsra.ru/en/grafik_dvijeniya_po_smp/. <UN>.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • End of an Eraagent
    Kapitan Khlebnikov: End of an Era The world’s most legendary polar expedition vessel will retire from passenger service in March 2012. Join us as we mark the End of an Era with special guests and remarkable itineraries. 2 Only 112 people will participate in any one of these historic voyages. As a former guest you can save 5% off the published price of these remarkable expeditions, and be one of the very few who will be able to say—I was on the Khlebnikov at the End of an Era. The legendary icebreaker Kapitan Khlebnikov will retire as an expedition vessel in March 2012, returning to escort duty for ships sailing the Northeast Passage. As Quark's flagship, the vessel has garnered more polar firsts than any other passenger ship. Under the command of Captain Petr Golikov, Khlebnikov circumnavigated the Antarctic continent, twice. The ship was the platform for the first tourism exploration of the Dry Valleys. The icebreaker has transited the Northwest Passage more than any other expedition ship. Adventurers aboard Khlebnikov were the first commercial travelers to witness a total eclipse of the sun from the isolation of the Davis Sea in Antarctica. In 2004, the special attributes of Kapitan Khlebnikov made it possible to visit an Emperor Penguin rookery in the Weddell Sea that had not been visited for 40 years. 3 End of an Era at a Glance Itineraries Start End Special Guests Northwest Passage: West to East July 18, 2010 August 5, 2010 Andrew Lambert, author of The Gates of Hell: Sir John Franklin’s Tragic Quest for the Northwest Passage.
    [Show full text]
  • The Lore of the Stars, for Amateur Campfire Sages
    obscure. Various claims have been made about Babylonian innovations and the similarity between the Greek zodiac and the stories, dating from the third millennium BCE, of Gilgamesh, a legendary Sumerian hero who encountered animals and characters similar to those of the zodiac. Some of the Babylonian constellations may have been popularized in the Greek world through the conquest of The Lore of the Stars, Alexander in the fourth century BCE. Alexander himself sent captured Babylonian texts back For Amateur Campfire Sages to Greece for his tutor Aristotle to interpret. Even earlier than this, Babylonian astronomy by Anders Hove would have been familiar to the Persians, who July 2002 occupied Greece several centuries before Alexander’s day. Although we may properly credit the Greeks with completing the Babylonian work, it is clear that the Babylonians did develop some of the symbols and constellations later adopted by the Greeks for their zodiac. Contrary to the story of the star-counter in Le Petit Prince, there aren’t unnumerable stars Cuneiform tablets using symbols similar to in the night sky, at least so far as we can see those used later for constellations may have with our own eyes. Only about a thousand are some relationship to astronomy, or they may visible. Almost all have names or Greek letter not. Far more tantalizing are the various designations as part of constellations that any- cuneiform tablets outlining astronomical one can learn to recognize. observations used by the Babylonians for Modern astronomers have divided the sky tracking the moon and developing a calendar. into 88 constellations, many of them fictitious— One of these is the MUL.APIN, which describes that is, they cover sky area, but contain no vis- the stars along the paths of the moon and ible stars.
    [Show full text]
  • Magnetic North: Artists and the Arctic Circle
    Magnetic north Artists And the Arctic circle On view May 28, 2014 through August 29, 2014 Magnetic North is organized by The Arctic Circle in association with The Farm, Inc. The exhibition is sponsored by the 1285 Avenue of the Americas Art Gallery, in partnership with Jones Lang LaSalle, as a community based public service. IN MEMORY OF TERRY ADKINS (1953–2014) 2013 Arctic Circle Expedition Sarah Anne Johnson Circling the Arctic, 2011 Magnetic North How do people imagine the landscapes they find themselves in? How does the land shape the imaginations of people who dwell in it? How does desire itself, the desire to comprehend, shape knowledge? —Barry Lopez, Arctic Dreams he Arctic Circle is a non-profit expeditionary residency program that brings together international groups of artists, writers, composers, architects, scientists, and educators. For Tseveral weeks each year, participants voyage into the open seas and fjords of the Svalbard archipelago aboard a specially equipped sailing vessel. The voyagers live and work together, aiding one another in the daily challenges of conducting research and creating new work based on their experiences. The residency is both a journey of discovery and a laboratory for the convergence of ideas and disciplines. Magnetic North comprises a selection of works by more than twenty visual and sound artists from the 2009–2012 expeditions. The exhibition encompasses a wide range of artistic practices, including photography, video, sound recordings, performance documentation, painting, sculpture, and kinetic and interactive installations. Taken together, the works of art offer unique and diverse perspectives on a part of the world rarely seen by others, conveying the desire to comprehend and interpret a largely uninhabitable and unknowable place.
    [Show full text]
  • Kapitan Khlebnikov
    kapitan khlebnikov Expeditions that Mark the End of an Era 1991-2012 01 End of an Era 22 Circumnavigation of the Arctic 03 End of an Era at a Glance 24 Northeast Passage: Siberia and the Russian Arctic 04 Kapitan Khlebnikov 26 Greenland Semi-circunavigation: Special Guests 06 The Final Frontier 10 Northwest Passage: Arctic Passage: West to East 28 Amundsen’s Route to Asia 12 Tanquary Fjord: Western Ross Sea Centennial Voyage: Ellesmere Island 30 Farewell to the Emperors 14 Ellesmere Island and of Antarctica Greenland: The High Arctic 32 Antarctica’s Far East – 16 Emperor Penguins: The Farewell Voyage: Saluting Snow Hill Island Safari the 100th Anniversary of the Australasia Antarctic Expedition. 18 The Weddell Sea and South Georgia: Celebrating the 34 Dates and Rates Heroes of Endurance 35 Inclusions 20 Epic Antarctica via the Terms and Conditions of Sale Phantom Coast and 36 the Ross Sea Only 112 people will participate in any one of these historic voyages. end of an era Join us as we mark the End of an Era with special guests and remarkable itineraries. The legendary icebreaker Kapitan Khlebnikov will retire transited the Northwest Passage more than any other as an expedition vessel in March 2012, returning to expedition ship. Adventurers aboard Khlebnikov were the duty as an escort ship in the Russian Arctic. As Quark’s first commercial travelers to witness a total eclipse of the flagship, the vessel has garnered more polar firsts than sun from the isolation of the Davis Sea in Antarctica. In any other passenger ship. Under the command of Captain 2004, the special attributes of Kapitan Khlebnikov made it Petr Golikov, Khlebnikov circumnavigated the Antarctic possible to visit an Emperor Penguin rookery in the Weddell continent, twice.
    [Show full text]
  • Transits of the Northwest Passage to End of the 2020 Navigation Season Atlantic Ocean ↔ Arctic Ocean ↔ Pacific Ocean
    TRANSITS OF THE NORTHWEST PASSAGE TO END OF THE 2020 NAVIGATION SEASON ATLANTIC OCEAN ↔ ARCTIC OCEAN ↔ PACIFIC OCEAN R. K. Headland and colleagues 7 April 2021 Scott Polar Research Institute, University of Cambridge, Lensfield Road, Cambridge, United Kingdom, CB2 1ER. <[email protected]> The earliest traverse of the Northwest Passage was completed in 1853 starting in the Pacific Ocean to reach the Atlantic Oceam, but used sledges over the sea ice of the central part of Parry Channel. Subsequently the following 319 complete maritime transits of the Northwest Passage have been made to the end of the 2020 navigation season, before winter began and the passage froze. These transits proceed to or from the Atlantic Ocean (Labrador Sea) in or out of the eastern approaches to the Canadian Arctic archipelago (Lancaster Sound or Foxe Basin) then the western approaches (McClure Strait or Amundsen Gulf), across the Beaufort Sea and Chukchi Sea of the Arctic Ocean, through the Bering Strait, from or to the Bering Sea of the Pacific Ocean. The Arctic Circle is crossed near the beginning and the end of all transits except those to or from the central or northern coast of west Greenland. The routes and directions are indicated. Details of submarine transits are not included because only two have been reported (1960 USS Sea Dragon, Capt. George Peabody Steele, westbound on route 1 and 1962 USS Skate, Capt. Joseph Lawrence Skoog, eastbound on route 1). Seven routes have been used for transits of the Northwest Passage with some minor variations (for example through Pond Inlet and Navy Board Inlet) and two composite courses in summers when ice was minimal (marked ‘cp’).
    [Show full text]
  • International Dimensions
    CHAPTER 9 International Dimensions NATIONAL ISSUES REPORT NATIONAL ISSUES REPORT 624 Coordinating lead author Jimena Eyzaguirre, ESSA Technologies Ltd. Lead authors Cedar Morton, PhD, ESSA Technologies Ltd. Colette Wabnitz, PhD, University of British Columbia and Stanford University Michael Copage, Environment and Climate Change Canada Robert McLeman, PhD, Wilfrid Laurier University Contributing authors Danica Lassaline, Environment and Climate Change Canada Juliano Palacios-Abrantes, PhD, University of British Columbia Kamleshan Pillay, PhD,, Independent Adaptation Finance Specialist Recommended citation Eyzaguirre, J., Morton, C., Wabnitz, C., Copage, M. and McLeman, R. (2021): International Dimensions; Chapter 9 in Canada in a Changing Climate: National Issues Report, (ed.) F.J. Warren and N. Lulham; Government of Canada, Ottawa, Ontario. NATIONAL ISSUES REPORT 625 Table of contents Key messages 627 9.1 Introduction 628 9.1.1 Overview of findings from past assessments 630 9.2 Climate change affects Arctic shipping and threatens sovereignty 631 9.2.1 Introduction 631 9.2.2 Climate, sea ice and Arctic navigation 631 9.2.3 Climate-related risks to Canada’s control over the Northwest Passage 637 9.2.4 Strategies to adapt to increased shipping activity in the Northwest Passage 640 Case Story 9.1: Adaptation strategies for cruise ship tourism in the Canadian Arctic 643 9.3 Transboundary marine and freshwater agreements generally do not consider climate change 644 9.3.1 Introduction 645 Case Story 9.2: The Canada–U.S. Pacific Salmon Treaty 646 9.3.2 Marine agreements 648 9.3.3 Freshwater agreements 652 Case Story 9.3: Modernizing the Canada–U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • MARITIME ACTIVITY in the HIGH NORTH – CURRENT and ESTIMATED LEVEL up to 2025 MARPART Project Report 1
    MARITIME ACTIVITY IN THE HIGH NORTH – CURRENT AND ESTIMATED LEVEL UP TO 2025 MARPART Project Report 1 Authors: Odd Jarl Borch, Natalia Andreassen, Nataly Marchenko, Valur Ingimundarson, Halla Gunnarsdóttir, Iurii Iudin, Sergey Petrov, Uffe Jacobsen and Birita í Dali List of authors Odd Jarl Borch Project Leader, Nord University, Norway Natalia Andreassen Nord University, Norway Nataly Marchenko The University Centre in Svalbard, Norway Valur Ingimundarson University of Iceland Halla Gunnarsdóttir University of Iceland Iurii Iudin Murmansk State Technical University, Russia Sergey Petrov Murmansk State Technical University, Russia Uffe Jakobsen University of Copenhagen, Denmark Birita í Dali University of Greenland 1 Partners MARPART Work Package 1 “Maritime Activity and Risk” 2 THE MARPART RESEARCH CONSORTIUM The management, organization and governance of cross-border collaboration within maritime safety and security operations in the High North The key purpose of this research consortium is to assess the risk of the increased maritime activity in the High North and the challenges this increase may represent for the preparedness institutions in this region. We focus on cross-institutional and cross-country partnerships between preparedness institutions and companies. We elaborate on the operational crisis management of joint emergency operations including several parts of the preparedness system and resources from several countries. The project goals are: • To increase understanding of the future demands for preparedness systems in the High North including both search and rescue, oil spill recovery, fire fighting and salvage, as well as capacities fighting terror or other forms of destructive action. • To study partnerships and coordination challenges related to cross-border, multi-task emergency cooperation • To contribute with organizational tools for crisis management Project characteristics: Financial support: -Norwegian Ministry of Foreign Affairs, -the Nordland county Administration -University partners.
    [Show full text]
  • Shipping in the Arctic
    FACT SHEET CURRENT KNOWLEDGE ON THE THEME: Shipping in the Arctic The consequences of climate change are more clearly 8 felt in the Arctic than in any other region of the world. The particularly strong rise in temperatures in the high 7 latitudes causes a rapid decline in sea ice (Fig. 1) and threatens the existence of highly sensitive ecosystems 6 (see AWI Fact Sheet „Climate Change in the Arctic“). But the dwindling ice is also making regions and sea routes 5 more accessible, which for a long time were reserved for Million km² adventurers, research expeditions and indigenous peo- ples: The Arctic sea routes, connecting the Pacific and 4 Atlantic north of the continents. In addition to shorter distances between world markets, intra-Arctic traffic, 3 1980 1990 2000 2010 2018 combined with resource depletion, is also playing an in- Year creasingly important role in this region. Figure 1: September means of sea ice expansion in the Arctic 1979 What are the impacts of climate change on Arctic sea to 2018. From September 1979 to 2018, sea ice decreased by 37%. ice? This means a decrease in sea ice extent in September months of 13% per decade2. Adapted from Grosfeld et al. (2019)A. The phenomenon of „polar amplification“ has led to a par- ticularly high temperature rise in the Arctic since the be- ginning of industrialization - two to three times as high » The average thickness of sea ice has decreased as the global average. This has resulted, among other within the last 30 years from over three metres to things, in an ever-earlier onset of ice melting in spring less than two metres3.
    [Show full text]
  • Arctic Navigation: Reflections on the Northern Sea Route
    Chapter 19 Arctic Navigation: Reflections on the Northern Sea Route Said Mahmoudi* Introduction International interest in the Arctic Ocean has increased since the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) entered into force in 1994. The reason is the greater attention now being paid to the consequences of global warming1 and the new possibilities opening up due to climate change. Access to resources, including previously unknown biological ones, and increased use of navigational routes, are just two of such possibilities. One example of this increased attention to the Arctic waters is the meeting of the ministers of transport of Japan, China and South Korea in Yokohama on 25 August 2014. Their purpose was to agree on an arrangement for the safety of ship operations in Arctic waters and to establish an efficient logistic system in that area. This was the fifth recent meeting of these ministers about Arctic navigation. The two main sea routes in the Arctic Ocean today are the Northwest Passage, which runs along the northern coast of North America, and the Northeast Passage, which follows the coasts of Norway, Russia and Alaska. The major part of its Russian section, the Northern Sea Route, is the focus of this paper. A third route, the Central Arctic Ocean Route, which is in interna- tional waters, is considered as a potential trans-Arctic transport seaway. The Northern Sea Route is the most attractive option for transport due to its more favorable ice conditions and available infrastructure, including nuclear- powered ice breakers. This may be compared with the Northwest Passage with relatively scant infrastructure2 for shipping and perhaps lack of clear * Professor of International Law, Stockholm University.
    [Show full text]
  • No More Hot Air
    www.nature.com/nature Vol 446 | Issue no. 7132 | 8 March 2007 No more hot air European heads of state gathered in Brussels today must show they are serious about climate change. hen the European Union’s 27 heads of state meet today, little to change behaviour over the past two decades, so the EU’s they are expected to endorse an energy policy for the con- leaders must now endorse a package of mandatory measures — if only Wtinent whose implementation will provide the ultimate to back up their own well-worn rhetoric on the importance of the test of Europe’s ability to meet the challenge of climate change. climate-change issue. Such mandatory commitments are clearly European leaders such as Tony Blair and Angela Merkel have talked needed to provide the incentives that will increase research and a good game on the climate-change issue for many years. But Europe’s investment in clean-energy technologies, energy efficiency and the actions to confront stubborn, continued growth in greenhouse-gas other steps needed to reverse the growth in emissions. emissions have been far less impressive. Today’s rhetoric will doubt- The national circumstances of the leaders gathered in Brussels less imply that this is about to change. However, it is the actual are varied. Italy, Spain and Portugal, for example, are failing to meet implementation of the plan, rather than the flourish with which it is even the modest targets allocated to them as their share of the EU’s presented, that will show whether the European Union (EU) is seri- commitment under the Kyoto Proto- ous about cutting emissions.
    [Show full text]
  • Global Methodology for Mapping Human Impacts on the Biosphere
    t r 3 o UNEP/DEWA/TR.01-3 p e R l a c i n GLOBIO h GLOBIO GLOBAL METHODOLOGY c FOR MAPPING HUMAN IMPACTS Global methodology for mapping e T ON THE BIOSPHERE human impacts on the biosphere t n e m s s e s s A d n a n o i t a m r o f n I t n e m n o r i v n E A word from the Executive Director For thousands of years, humankind has relied and depended upon the Earth’s resources to meet growing demands for food, medicine, shelter and water. Our entire existence and the diversity of cultures and economies has been built upon goods and services from nature. However, far too often, these activities have taken a heavy toll on our environment. Waste, desertification, pollution, deforestation, loss of communication and foresight. We simply need to clearly biodiversity and the degradation of land and fresh water visualize and communicate the long-term impacts of the are continually putting greater and greater strain on growth in human resource use in a manner that is sustainable economic, cultural and environmental understandable. Not by predicting the future, but by development. We are becoming increasingly aware that scientifically documenting the likely future impacts of the we not only rely on the environment for its many services, choices that are being made today. in fact, our health, economy and political world is largely built on the Earth’s resources. What happens to the Earth, The impacts of growing human resource demands are now happens to humankind.
    [Show full text]
  • With CRYSTAL CRUISES
    Present ���� WEBINAR SERIES with CRYSTAL CRUISES JOIN TRAVEL DAILY EDITOR, JASMINE O’DONOGHUE FOR THE FINAL EDUCATIONAL WEBINAR WITH CRYSTAL’S SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT AND MANAGING DIRECTOR, AUSTRALASIA, KAREN CHRISTENSEN AN D EXPEDITION LEADER, CRYSTAL ENDEAVOR, DAVID SINCLAIR CRYSTAL EXPEDITION CRUISES 17 July at 2:00pm AEST Crystal Endeavor, Where Luxury Roams Freely. From Antarctica, the Russian Far East and the Northeast Passage to Japan, Indonesia, Australia, New Zealand and more, learn about what Crystal Endeavor will offer discerning travellers – bold adventure and fascinating insight into faraway lands and remote locales. CLICK HERE TO REGISTER TO WATCH THE FINAL WEBINAR FEATURING CRYSTAL EXPEDITION CRUISES, AND BE IN WITH A CHANCE TO WIN A LUXURY CRUISE* CRYSTALCRUISES.COM *T&Cs apply, see Eventbrite registration page. www.cruiseweekly.com.au Monday 8th July 2019 Regent launches new travel agent hub REGENT Seven Seas Cruises en route to (RSSC) has announced the Budapest launch of a new online trade portal called RegenTrade Hub, a resource that aims to equip travel agents with up-to-date Today’s issue of CW is information online via videos and coming to you courtesy of fun quizzes. APT, which this week will New content available to formally name the brand agents also includes toolkits, new AmaMagna. customisable content, images, APT and its partner company videos and a new training library. AmaWaterways have just Regent Seven Seas Cruises Vice launched the AmaMagna President of Sales, Australia and which is sailing from Budapest to Vienna for a VIP christening New Zealand Lisa Pile said the RegenTrade, RSSC is giving Aussie The prize also includes, return ceremony this Thu.
    [Show full text]