Finding the Fast Track for Innovation in the Australasian Rail Industry

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Finding the Fast Track for Innovation in the Australasian Rail Industry Finding the fast track for innovation in the Australasian rail industry OCTOBER 2020 WWW.ARA.NET.AU 1 1. Executive summary 3 2. Why innovation matters to Australian rail 6 3. How Australian rail compares globally 10 4. Barriers to rail innovation in Australia 20 5. Opportunities for Australian innovation 29 6. A new compact for Australian rail innovation 33 7. References 37 CONTENTS The Australasian Railway Association (ARA) is the peak body for the rail sector in Australia and New Zealand. We represent more than 150 member organisations including passenger and freight operators, track owners and managers, suppliers, manufacturers, contractors and consultants. Our members include listed and private rail-related companies, government agencies and franchisees. Executive summary When Australia’s first railways were developed But there remains no national agreement on the in the 1800s, they catalysed economic and social signalling, automation or smart rail standards development and connected distant settlements.1 needed for a modern rail system in the 21st century. However, the absence of a national vision meant While technology offers network-scale benefits, that the railways developed separately, with Australia continues to develop different systems in different standards and gauges. different jurisdictions. Nearly two centuries later, successive reforms and There is a wide range of innovations that are ripe for investment have modernised and electrified these application to Australia’s rail systems (Figure 2). railways, and established a standard interstate rail network and a single national rail safety regime. But If Australia is to harness the great benefits of the original fragmentation remains, and continues technology to decongest and decarbonise urban to thwart optimal rail development in Australia. environments, better connect regional communities, and boost land transport productivity, it will need a Australia is embarking on its next major program more unified market for rail innovation, with national of rail transformation – with $155 billion of rail rules and a single playing field. Australia will need a investment planned in the next 15 years. These national focus on rail innovation. projects will embed the next generation of transformative rail technologies, with opportunities Australia currently lags behind global comparators extending across the supply chain to local rail in research and development (R&D) and manufacturing, which is expected to see a return of commercialisation, and in rates of technology growth to 1.5% per year for the next five years. adoption. Figure 1: Current marquee rail projects in Australia Inland Rail Cross River Rail • Responsible for delivery: • Responsible for delivery: ARTC in partnership with the Cross River Delivery Authority private sector in parnership with the • Signalling: ATMS private sector • Automation*: None • Signalling: ETCS L2 • Gauge: Standard and • Automation*: GoA2 (with driver) dual gauge for QLD • Gauge: Narrow Metronet • Responsible for delivery: Sydney Metro Public Transport Authority, WA • Responsible for delivery: • Signalling: HCS TFNSW • Automation*: Planned • Signalling: ETCS L2 Metro Tunnel • Gauge: Narrow • Automation*: GoA4 • Responsible for delivery: • Gauge: Standard Rail Projects Victoria Acronyms • Signalling: HCS ATO Automated train Operation • Automation*: GoA2 GoA Grade of Automation • Gauge: Broad HCS High capacity signaling ETCS European Train Control System ATMS Advanced Train Management System Notes: *Degree of automation is measured by grade of Automation (GoA) means the driver operates the doors and handles emergencies with automated starting and stopping, while GoA4 refers to a fully automated driverless system. Source: Project websites, ANZIP 3 4 Figure 2: Examples of new technology, innovation and digitalisation in rail Cabin based ATMS Internet of Things (IoT) 5G High speed Driverless technology technology Sensors, adaptive Cloud based platforms AI and machine learning monitoring Hydrogen power Fault inspection technology Digital communications Condition monitoring Rail crossing safety Smartphones and apps technology Battery technology Mobility as a Capacity and passenger Automated train service (MaaS) measurement protection Positive train control Contactless ticketing (e.g., ETCS) This research considered global benchmarks The compact would have three objectives, and consulted with ARA members, including each with recommended actions: industry suppliers and public and private rail • To make rail innovation a national priority: owners and operators. The interviews brought to A new national public body would drive national light considerable consensus on the reasons for planning and coordination of investment, Australia’s uneven rail technology performance. support long term R&D and commercialisation Fragmentation across rail planning and investment, and develop national capability and procurement, disconnects across the national rail an export strategy for the sector innovation system, and a culture that has not been • To develop a single market for rail primed for innovation, are all major inhibitors to technology: A single market with common technology-enabled rail productivity. Some of the standards, nationally accredited testing, a impacts of these challenges include: national industry policy, and industry-standard • Multiple rail operators and owners, and training multiple rules and type approvals, make • To build a culture for rail innovation: Australia a challenging market for technology Ensuring best practice procurement and suppliers, who have multiple paths to market contracting, the development of states’ smart for each product rail strategies to build an investment pipeline for • Weak linkages across the value chain, and digital technology, and building the brand for the recent closure of the Rail Manufacturing Australian rail innovators globally Cooperative Research Centre (RM CRC), This is an ambitious compact that requires deep will see the continuation of a small pool of partnership across governments, industry and local commercialisation operators. The ARA is committed to policies that are • State local content requirements inhibit the in the national interest for rail innovation. achievement of scaled rail manufacturing in Australia • Rail planning, investment and procurement is risk averse and does not incentivise innovation well On the other hand, there is a ‘virtuous circle’ between strong national rail research and productive and efficient railways. The implication is that rail innovation in Australia needs a focus both on driving collaborative research and on building a culture that demands innovation and continuous improvement. This paper recommends a new national compact to boost the economic contribution and legacy of Australian research and industry for planned rail investment over the next 15 years. 5 2. Why innovation matters to Australian rail 2.1 The benefits of rail • Cost savings: Building Information Modelling innovation on complex rail construction in Germany reduced costs by 10%, with ongoing energy and 4 The global market for rail technology is worth maintenance savings AU$362 billion, and is growing at 3.2% per year,2 • Capacity: The Rail Sector Deal in the United with almost all aspects of modern rail systems Kingdom (UK) is investing in data, digital experiencing digital and technological disruption. technology and sustainability, with an initial In particular, the convergence of information estimate that it will deliver up to £31 billion pounds and communications technologies (ICT) with rail in benefits from more capacity, more frequent and operational technologies has changed the way that reliable services5 railways are planned, built, run and maintained. • Reliability: The sensor arrays and artificial There is evidence that the pace of innovation in rail intelligence of MOXI, being used by VicTrack and transport is quickening. One measure is the number East Japan Railway, have been able to predict of rail patents submitted globally each year, which adverse car and track conditions to better than has almost quadrupled in the past 20 years, with 90% accuracy, improving safety, maintenance costs 6 China alone submitting 8,500 patents in 2019.3 and allowing earlier action on faults • Time savings: ICT tools used to optimise online Applications that are being used in energy, rail operations halved wait times between trains manufacturing and defence are also transforming on Berlin’s U-Bahn network, and enabled safer the opportunities for rail, with intelligent systems, operation on high risk corridors7 automation, sensors, predictive maintenance, advanced asset monitoring, traction and train • Safety: In the United States (US), preventative control technologies, and energy efficiency. maintenance technology such as wayside detectors, smart sensors and infrared lasers New technology and innovation can involve high assess the condition of bearings, axles and wheels, deployment costs and complexity when integrating reducing mainline equipment-caused accidents by with legacy rail systems, but can deliver higher 36% over a decade8 relative benefits than traditional projects, including: • Energy Efficiency: Energy Storage Systems on Tehran metro yielded daily energy savings of 25%9 Figure 3: Rail patents submitted globally each year 12,000 CAGR % 7.1 8.907 7,810 8,000 6,894 5,608 5,075 4,692 4,460 4,000 3,508 3,548 3,007 3,136 3,174 2,849 2,890 2,953 2,677 2,724 2,643 2,437 Number of rail related patent
Recommended publications
  • Cincinnati's Hard-Won Modern Tram Revival
    THE INTERNATIONAL LIGHT RAIL MAGAZINE www.lrta.org www.tautonline.com NOVEMBER 2016 NO. 947 CINCINNATI’S HARD-WON MODERN TRAM REVIVAL InnoTrans: The world’s greatest railway showcase Russian cities’ major low-floor orders Stadler and Solaris join for tram bids Doha Metro tunnelling is complete ISSN 1460-8324 £4.25 Berlin Canada’s ‘Radial’ 11 Above and below the Exploring Ontario’s streets of the capital Halton County line 9 771460 832043 LRT MONITOR TheLRT MONITOR series from Mainspring is an essential reference work for anyone who operates in the world’s light and urban rail sectors. Featuring regular updates in both digital and print form, the LRT Monitor includes an overview of every established line and network as well as details of planned schemes and those under construction. POLAND POZNAŃ Tramways play an important role in one of of the main railway station. Poland’s biggest and most historic cities, with In 2012 a line opened to the east of the city, the first horse-drawn tramline opening in 1880. with an underground section containing two An overview Electrification followed in 1898. sub-surface stations and a new depot. The The network was badly damaged during World reconstruction of Kaponiera roundabout, an A high-quality War Two, resuming operations in 1947 and then important tram junction, is set for completion in of the system’s only east of the river Warta. Service returned to 2016. When finished, it will be a three-level image for ease the western side of the city in 1952 with the junction, with a PST interchange on the lower development, opening of the Marchlewski bridge (now named level.
    [Show full text]
  • RLTP – Submissions from Local Boards, Partners and Key Interest Groups
    Submissions on the Draft Regional Land Transport Plan 2021-2031 from local boards, partners and key interest groups Contents Part A – Local Board submissions on the RLTP .............................................................. 1 Albert-Eden Local Board ................................................................................................... 2 Aotea-Great Barrier Local Board ....................................................................................... 6 Devonport-Takapuna Local Board ..................................................................................... 8 Franklin Local Board ........................................................................................................ 14 Henderson-Massey Local Board ...................................................................................... 20 Hibiscus and Bays Local Board ....................................................................................... 25 Howick Local Board ......................................................................................................... 28 Kaipātiki Local Board ....................................................................................................... 30 Māngere-Ōtāhuhu Local Board ....................................................................................... 35 Manurewa Local Board .................................................................................................... 43 Maungakiekie-Tāmaki Local Board .................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Honouring Fallen Workers 2 Contents Editorial ISSUE 3 • SEPTEMBER 2016
    THE SEPTEMBER 2016 TRANSPORThe journal of the RMTU – NZ'sT largest WORKER specialist transport union Honouring fallen workers 2 CONTENTS EDITORIAL ISSUE 3 • SEPTEMBER 2016 13 KIWIRAIL'S INCONSISTENCIES GS Wayne Butson writes an open letter to KiwiRail CEO Peter Reidy about their hypocritical position regarding electric vehicles. Wayne Butson General secretary 15 NEW PICTON HOIST RMTU Kic team welcomes advances in cooperation and the new giant hoist for Picton. Disappointing suburban rail 19 RAIL WELDING MACHINE changeover New facility in HERE are some things we take for granted in the RMTU and one is that we Auckland for mostly deal with employers who want to have a meaningful relationship welding rail could with the union of choice of its workers so they play the employment game be a fore by the rules and pretty fairly. That is not to say that there aren't occasions runner for similar when we have to blow the whistle and call a penalty or ask for a manager to be sent Tfrom the field of play but, by and large, things go according to plan. machines in the South Island. It has therefore been a disappointing, but not wholly unexpected, reawakening to the trickery of some employers for us since 3 July 2016. This is when Transdev Wellington and their sub contractor partner Hyundai Rotem (THR) were handed the keys to the Wellington suburban trainset. Despite working with them for more than three months in the run up to the handover and laboriously working through the mechanics of achieving the "same or more favour- COVER PHOTOGRAPH: Paying respects at able" (S or MF) terms and conditions of employment for our members, it was truly Strongman Mine Disaster Memorial are Ian amazing to behold how quickly they set about trying to change what was just agreed.
    [Show full text]
  • Transdev Australasia Modern Slavery Statement 2020
    Transdev Australasia Modern Slavery Statement 2020 Transdev Australasia Modern Slavery Statement 2020 1 Contents CEO introduction and purpose of this statement 4 Section 1: About Transdev Australasia 6 Section 2: Structure, operations and supply chain of Transdev Australasia 9 Section 3: Modern slavery risks 12 Section: 4: Approach to combating modern slavery at Transdev Australasia 15 Section 5: Measuring Performance and Effectiveness 18 Section 6: Future outlook 20 Section 7: Stakeholder coordination and engagement 21 What is Modern Slavery? The Australian Commonwealth Modern Slavery Act 2018 defines modern slavery as including eight types of serious exploitation: trafficking in persons; slavery; servitude; forced marriage; forced labour; debt bondage; deceptive recruiting for labour or services; and the worst forms of child labour. The worst forms of child labour include situations where children are subjected to slavery or similar practices, or engaged in hazardous work. Transdev Australasia Modern Slavery Statement 2020 2 Transdev Australasia Modern Slavery Statement 2020 3 CEO introduction and purpose of this statement I am pleased to present Transdev Australasia’s modern slavery statement for the reporting year ending 31 December 2020 (this “Statement”), prepared for the purpose of section 16 of the Australian Modern Slavery Act 2018 (Cth) (the “Act”). This is an inaugural statement pursuant to section 14 of the Act made by reporting entity Transdev Australasia Pty Ltd (Transdev Australasia), a proprietary company limited by shares incorporated under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). Transdev Australasia is the parent company and principal governing body of Transdev Australasia’s group of entities and has prepared this Statement on behalf of those entities constituting reporting entities as defined under the Act.
    [Show full text]
  • New Zealand Rail 2018 14 – 15 June 2018 | Pullman Hotel Auckland
    New Zealand Rail 2018 14 – 15 June 2018 | Pullman Hotel Auckland Rail: Driving sustainable and inclusive growth FEATURING INSIGHTS FROM OVER 40 INDUSTRY LEADERS INCLUDING: The Hon Phil Twyford, Minister of Transport Ruth Venter, Inaugural Winner, Young Rail Professionals Pitching Competition The Hon Phil Goff,Mayor of Auckland Kate Jorgensen, CFO, KiwiRail Peter Reidy, CEO, KiwiRail Gary Seabury, Executive General Manager, Rail, John Holland Robert Brodnax, Director, Transport Access Delivery, NZ Transport Agency Anna Squire, Australasia Rail Business Leader, Arup Jenny Chetwynd, General Manager Strategy, Policy and Planning, Andrew Lezala, Managing Director, Metro Trains Australia NZ Transport Agency James Pinder, CEO, V/Line Bryn Gandy, Deputy Chief Executive, Strategy and Investment, Michel Ladrak, Managing Director, Transdev Auckland Ministry of Transport Katie McMahon, Group General Manager, Zero Harm, KiwiRail Shane Ellison, CEO, Auckland Transport Kate Bowman, General Counsel and Company Secretary, Pacific National René Lalande, CEO, Transdev Belinda de Zwart, People and Culture Manager, Jeanine Benson, Network Services Manager, KiwiRail North Canterbury Transport Infrastructure Recovery John Williamson, Interim Chief Executive, CRL Ltd Evan Jensen, Chairman, Nga Kaitiaki o te Ara Whanake John Fullerton, CEO, ARTC Brendan Miller, General Manager Global Supply Chain Development, Alan Beacham, Strategic Advisor, UGL Ltd Fonterra HIGHLIGHTS INCLUDE: TOPICS INCLUDE: – Young Rail Professionals Pitching Competition – Rail planning project
    [Show full text]
  • RETRO PROSPECTIVE Yearbook 17/18 TRANSDEV - Retro-Prospective
    RETROPROSPECTIVE Yearbook 17/18 TRANSDEV - Retro-prospective MOVING FORWARD 8 New clients 10 A trusted partner 12 New developments 14 Energy transition 16 Corporate Social Responsibility 18 Awards 22 The future of mobility is now STAYING AHEAD 28 Personalized 30 Autonomous 34 Connected 36 Electric Retro-prospective TRANSDEV - 2 Transdev in 2017 82,000 €138 m employees Ordinary operating income +€15 m (+12%) VS 2016 13 transportation modes 43,300 vehicles operated Retro-prospective TRANSDEV - 3 €6.6 bn net revenue +3.7% VS 2016 (excluding Netherlands) 19 countries €76 m Group net profi t +€10 m VS 2016 €528 m net fi nancial debt -€65 m VS 2016 Retro-prospective TRANSDEV - Proud to 5 transport Leading private rail operator 10 million Leader in streetcar operations: 21 networks people #1 European operator of zero emission electric buses around Leader in the operation of autonomous shuttles the world with over 2 million passengers carried Retro-prospective Retro-prospective TRANSDEV - every day. TRANSDEV - 5 Leading private rail operator Leader in streetcar operations: 21 networks #1 European operator of zero emission electric buses Leader in the operation of autonomous shuttles with over 2 million passengers carried Retro-prospective TRANSDEV - 6 PART ONE MOVING FORWARD Understanding and meeting the needs of our clients every day… Retro-prospective TRANSDEV - TRANSDEV - Retro-prospective 7 New clients 8 FULL SPEED AHEAD FOR INTERMODALITY IN AVEIRO Portugal For over 2o years, we have been Aveiro progressively building up our presence in Portugal, and Aveiro has become the 13th local transit authority to award us a contract to operate its transit network.
    [Show full text]
  • Policy Manual 2020
    Rail & Maritime Transport Union POLICY MANUAL 2020 Incorporating amendments from the October 2020 Biennial Conference TABLE OF CONTENTS ACC Policy 1. ACC advice and support .............................................................. 7 Bargaining – Rail specific Advanced capacity appraisal & promotion 2. Advertising of positions ................................................................. 7 3. Delayed promotion ........................................................................ 7 4. Performance appraisal – Trades .................................................... 7 Hours of work - Rosters 5. Basis for roster negotiations .......................................................... 7 6. Rostering safeguards ...................................................................... 7 7. Safeguard compliance .................................................................... 7 Locomotive running rosters 8. Roster committees .......................................................................... 8 9. Special rosters ................................................................................ 8 10. Starred weekends .......................................................................... 8 11. Alterations to rosters ...................................................................... 8 12. Crews travelling passenger ............................................................ 8 13. Identification cards ........................................................................ 8 Overtime and penal rates 14. Employees to be
    [Show full text]
  • Financial Report 2015 Financial Report
    2015 FINANCIAL REPORT 2015 FINANCIAL REPORT CAISSE DES DÉPÔTS GROUP 001 ♦ Introduction 002 ♦ Consolidated financial statements CDC-FI 2015_GB.indb 2 27/05/2016 18:51 INTRODUCTION AUDIT OF Article 518-2 of the French Monetary and Financial Code (Code monétaire et financier) defines Caisse des Dépôts as: THE FINANCIAL “[...] a State-owned group at the service of the public interest and the country’s economic development. The said group fulfils public interest functions in support of the policies pursued by the State and local author- STATEMENTS ities, and may engage in competitive activities. […] Caisse des Dépôts et Consignations is a long-term investor promoting business development in line with its own patrimonial interests. In compliance with Article L.518-15-1 of the French Monetary and Caisse des Dépôts et Consignations is closely supervised by the French Financial Code. Parliament and the legislative process.” “Each year, Caisse des Dépôts et Consignations shall present its parent Caisse des Dépôts prepares separate annual accounts under French company and consolidated financial statements, audited by two statu- GAAP for each of its constituent sectors: tory auditors, to the Finance Committees of the National Assembly and - Central Sector; the Senate.” - Savings Funds. Caisse des Dépôts Group is unique as a public institution with subsidi- aries and affiliates that operate in the competitive sector. It publishes consolidated financial statements under IFRS. These combine the financial statements of the Central Sector and those of the entities over which Caisse des Dépôts exercises exclusive or joint control to form the consolidated financial statements of Caisse des Dépôts Group.
    [Show full text]
  • 2019 Financial Report 2019 Financial Report
    2019 Financial report 2019 Financial report Introduction 3 Consolidated financial statements 7 Introduction 1 — Our model We safely manage the funds entrusted to us: these include escrow accounts, the assets of vulnerable populations and deposits from notaries “Caisse des dépôts et consignations and its subsidiaries constitute a and other regulated legal professionals. As banker to the social security state-owned group at the service of France’s public interest and of the system, we deliver administrative, financial and banking management country’s economic development. The Group fulfils public interest functions services, in the context of the mandates entrusted to us by the French in support of the policies pursued by the State and local authorities, and State. We are also developing a fiduciary business. As a trusted third party, may engage in competitive activities. […] Caisse des dépôts et we manage part of the budgets of the Investments for the Future consignations is a longterm investor promoting business development in Programme (PIA) on behalf of the French State. Our main customers are line with its own ownership interests.” the French public justice system (notaries, receivers, judicial represen- Article L. 518-2 of the French Monetary and Financial Code (Code moné- tatives, etc.), the French social security system and public interest players taire et financier) (amended by the 2008 Economic Modernisation Act). (social housing bodies, local public institutions, etc.). Our one-of-a-kind model: We centralise and manage regulated savings (Livret A, LDD, LEP) securely, and transform them into very long-term loans serving the public interest, in Trusted custodian and manager.
    [Show full text]
  • Aaate Workshop Final Presentation Smb Uitp
    10th of September, 2020 Workshop on Communication in Accessible Urban Transport AAATE and Trips Project ICCHP 2020 conference Presentatio n by Steven Barbosa on behalf of UITP 10th of September, 2020 MEETING AGENDA STATE OF ART OF ACCESSIBILITY IN PUBLIC TRANSPORT IN EUROPE CASE STUDY: RATP CASE STUDY: MyAid APP CASE STUDY/ TRANSDEV ACCESSIBILITY IN URBAN PUBLIC TRANSPORT C ONTEXT THE ROLE OF PUBLIC TRANSPORT • Public Transport being the one closer to the citizens can play an important part on understanding the local needs and specificities to ensure better investment towards accessibility. • Public Transport being the enabler of movement for the citizens inside their cities, and therefore for social cohesion and inclusion, must ensure transportation for all citizens. CONTEXT • Persons with disability represent in the European Union 17.6 % of the population. • This share is likely to increase with an ageing population, given that people are more prone to develop disabilities with age . • The EU Charter of Human Rights (articles 1, 21 and 26) and the Treaty on the Functioning of the EU (articles 10 and 19) respect the right of all citizens, including those with disability, to fully participate in society. • Specific legislation also exists to better include citizens with disabilities in public transport (i. e. Rail: EU Regulations No 1371/2007; 1300/2014. 2016/797 ; Bus (Note: Applicable mostly on long distance travel): EU Regulations No 181/2011 (Bus) ; Multimodal EU ITS 2010/40 (missing an important directive). LEGAL FRAME • The progresses made in terms of legislation are hard to be translated into progress. • There is no standard definition in the EU of “Persons with Reduced Mobility” or “severe disability”.
    [Show full text]
  • WL 2020 Road-Rail Interface
    Watchlist Safety for pedestrians and vehicles using level crossings What is the problem? What is the solution? Safety for pedestrians and vehicles The regulator, business operators, using railway level crossings is being and road control authorities need to compromised because of ambiguities in work closely to ensure the interface the responsibilities between the road between rail and surrounding and rail authorities; and because the infrastructure provides the implications for the road-rail interface appropriate level of protection for are sometimes not recognised when pedestrians, road vehicles, trains, and changes are made to vehicle those on board. technology or rail infrastructure. Even when accidents cause limited train damage or minor injuries, such events can be traumatic for all involved. Commission investigations have highlighted safety improvements that could have been, or should be, made for road vehicles or pedestrians using level crossings. Recent inquiries have found ambiguities in who is responsible for the safety of pedestrians crossing rail lines, a particular concern in metropolitan areas with growing patronage, and growing frequency of trains. Other inquiries have shown that changes to rules and standards for road vehicles such as permissible lengths and clearances are incompatible with the conditions at some level crossings such as sight lines and road camber. The potential remains for serious accidents to continue to occur as a result of these problems identified through our inquiries. Background When pedestrians or vehicles use level crossings, the potential exists for serious accidents to occur. Safety measures depend on infrastructure, technology, systems, and users working together. A change in one of these factors must take account of its effect on the others if safety is not to be compromised.
    [Show full text]
  • Rail and Tram News
    AUSTRALASIAN TIMETABLE NEWS No. 281, January 2016 ISSN 1038-3697, RRP $4.95 Published by the Australian Timetable Association www.austta.org.au RAIL AND TRAM NEWS Pacific National future “These contracts will ensure cattle producers continue to Table Talk has not been reporting the ins and outs of the have access to more than 300 cattle train services each year prolonged corporate shenanigans concerning ownership of to transport livestock from regional hubs such as Cloncurry, Pacific National, being waged by Brookfield and a Julia Creek, Winton, Clermont and Quilpie. That’s in addition consortium including Qube. However, it is relevant for to the 624 rail freight services which will continue to be students of timetabling to note the following about this battle: provided annually to support the import and export trade in Queensland and general freight rail services in the Central If Brookfield’s bid is successful, there is concern about the West.” The contracts have been improved in a number of possibility of market dominance. One area of concern is that ways, [including] the introduction of performance targets and Brookfield already controls the WA rural railway network. an increased focus on customer service. Additionally, the Hence, if they are successful, this would partially recreate an Palaszczuk Government has also agreed to purchase new integrated railway, contrary to government policies of recent cattle crates to provide more diverse transport options for years. On 22 December Brookfield provided an assurance to customers and rail operators,” he said. the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission that they would divest PN’s limited bulk freight operations in WA.
    [Show full text]