Science and the Afterlife Experience: Evidence for the Immortality of Consciousness by Chris Carter

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Science and the Afterlife Experience: Evidence for the Immortality of Consciousness by Chris Carter Journal of Scientifi c Exploration, Vol. 28, No. 1, pp. 153–159, 2014 0892-3310/14 BOOK REVIEW Science and the Afterlife Experience: Evidence for the Immortality of Consciousness by Chris Carter. Rochester, VT: Inner Traditions, 2012. xiv + 369 pp. $18.95. ISBN 978-1594774522. Science and the Afterlife Experience is the concluding volume of a trilogy that began with Parapsychology and the Skeptics (Carter 2007; reissued as Science and Psychic Phenomena, Carter 2012) and continued with Science and the Near-Death Experience (Carter 2010). These books provide handy introductions to parapsychology, psychical research, and allied concerns (such as the near-death experience) for a new generation of readers. They may best be described as quasi-scholarly, aimed primarily at a general (non-academic) audience, although they include notes, reference lists, and indexes. Carter, who holds an M.A. from the University of Oxford, England, identifies himself as a philosopher and here and there addresses philosophical concerns, such as the implications of “paranormal” phenomena for concepts of personal identity. One of the hallmarks of the series is the attention given to materialistic skeptical positions, extended in the volume under review to include super-ESP. This new installment consists of 19 chapters arranged in four parts, Reincarnation, Apparitions, Messages from the Dead, and Conclusions, preceded by a Foreword by philosopher Robert Almeder, an Introduction by Carter, and a chapter entitled “Psychic Phenomena and the Near-Death Experience: Background” which summarizes the preceding volumes in the series. Carter does a good job of surveying the classic survival literature and presents a strong case for the persistence of the human personality after death, but this is a book primarily for beginners. More advanced readers may find the survey interesting but are likely to be annoyed by the failure to consider recent works, both of evidence and of criticism. The first chapter sets up the argument of the book by examining the challenge to materialism posed by the experimental findings and theory of quantum physics. Materialism is the philosophical position that all of physical reality, including biological systems, can be explained entirely in terms of material elements and processes. Materialism identifies consciousness with, or reduces it to an epiphenomenon of, brain states, thus ruling out of hand the possibility that it might survive the body’s demise. But in the last century quantum mechanics demonstrated that the materialistic 154 Book Reviews view is incomplete and ultimately unfounded. Some versions of quantum theory, including the orthodox or standard interpretation, see consciousness as standing apart from physical reality. This opens the door to a mind/ body dualism or dualistic interactionism that allows for the survival of consciousness after death and means (as theoretical physicist Henry Stapp (2009) has pointed out) that the judgment about whether or not survival occurs must be based on evidence and not on a priori assumptions. Carter does not say why he chose to start his survey with reincarnation. The decision may strike some readers as strange, because he has not yet established the likelihood of survival, which reincarnation implies. In order for there to be something (let’s agree to call it consciousness) to reincarnate, it must first have survived death, and Carter would have us accept survival before providing the evidence for it. The placement of these chapters seems odd also because the reincarnation data are by and large more recent than those on apparitions and mediumistic communications. Apparitions and mediumship were concerns of SPR investigators from the earliest days, but reincarnation began to be researched intensively only in the 1960s, by Ian Stevenson. The argument might be made that the reincarnation data are at present our strongest evidence of survival, so that data from other areas should be assessed with that in mind. Carter, however, does not make this point, nor does he mount as strong a case for reincarnation as he might have done, principally because he relies on a few relatively old sources and fails to take account of recent work. There are in addition numerous omissions and errors of fact that likewise suggest a superficial acquaintance with the literature. This assessment applies to the book as a whole but is most apparent in the chapters on reincarnation. In Chapter 1, Evidence from India to England, Carter notes the widespread geographical and historical presence of the belief and introduces the reader to Stevenson’s research through three case studies, but he makes several mistakes along the way. In reviewing historical accounts of past-life memories (p. 20), he wrongly attributes them to the Indian Tulsi Das, who recounted the experiences of another person, not of himself. Carter asserts that no cases appeared between the early 19th-century case of Katsugoro and a series of Burmese cases published in 1898, whereas Wortabet (1860) described an interesting Syrian Druse case in the interim. He states that most cases reported from India between 1900 and 1960 involved single cases, yet the majority were contributed by two investigators, seven by one (Sahay 1927), and four by the other (Sunderlal 1924). In describing the 1960s British case of the Pollock twins (pp. 23–25), who behaved in strikingly different ways in line with the deceased older Book Reviews 155 sisters whose lives they recalled, and only one of whom had birthmarks, Carter misses the very significant fact that they were shown to be monozygotic. Dizygotic or fraternal twins are no more similar than any two siblings, but monozygotic or identical twins share the same DNA and should not (according to materialistic biology) reveal such differences. Later (p. 37), in discussing the case of Ma Tin Aung Myo, a Burmese girl who claimed memories of a Japanese army cook, he notes that she cross-dressed into adulthood but neglects to mention that she became an open lesbian. Role confusion is common in reincarnation cases in which the subject and previous person are of opposite sexes, but pronounced gender dysphoria of the sort exhibited in this case is extremely rare. All of the references in Chapter 2, Characteristics of Reincarnation Cases, are to a single work, the 1987 edition of Stevenson’s Children Who Remember Previous Lives (Stevenson 1987). Carter does not seem to realize that this was superseded by a second edition in 2001 (Stevenson 2001). Thus, he says (p. 36) that Stevenson found phobias in 50% of cases in which the death of the previous person was violent. This is true per the 1987 edition, but in the 2001 edition, drawing on a larger sample, Stevenson gives the figure as 36%. Carter repeatedly states that children “almost always” (p. 33) stop talking about the previous lives between 5 and 8 years of age, apparently unaware of a study by Haraldsson (2008) which showed that 38% of Sri Lankan subjects who spoke about previous lives in childhood claimed to retain at least some memories into middle adulthood. His brief discussion of intermission memories (memories of the period between lives) (p. 35) would have been enhanced by reference to a paper by Sharma and Tucker (2004). In discussing the continuation of Stevenson’s research (p. 43), he acknowledges a 1994 replication study but not the many later papers by its authors (Antonia Mills, Erlendur Haraldsson, and Jürgen Keil) and 156 Book Reviews others who have greatly expanded our knowledge of reincarnation cases and their subjects. The evidence no longer rests as heavily on Stevenson, so Carter arguably is wrong when he says on p. 53, “If Stevenson’s cases are seriously flawed, then of course the case for reincarnation collapses.” Chapter 3 takes up Alternative Explanations of the Reincarnation Evidence, from fraud to “cultural fantasy.” By “cultural fantasy” Carter means the idea that reincarnation cases can be explained as cultural constructions in the context of prevailing beliefs in and about reincarnation. Chapter 4 is devoted to The Objections of Paul Edwards, a skeptical philosopher. It begins with an error in the first paragraph, in which Carter declares that “the writer most frequently criticized in the book is, not surprisingly, Stevenson” (p. 51). Actually, that distinction goes to Elisabeth Kübler-Ross, who receives 38 pages to Stevenson’s 30 pages. Chapter 5, Reincarnation in Review, concludes Part I of the book. This short (five-page) chapter is mainly concerned with showing why ESP does not adequately account for apparent past-life memories. Carter does not address the super- psi possibilities outlined by Stephen Braude (2003) or David Ray Griffin’s (1997) idea of retrocognitive inclusion, which holds that persons with past- life memories are exercising retrocognitive ESP to access the memories of deceased persons and then incorporating these memory streams into their minds and behaviors. Part II, Apparitions, is better than Part I, although it too is dated in its coverage. Chapter 6, Strange Visits, introduces the subject with cases drawn largely from Green and McCreery’s Apparitions (1975). In Chapter 7, “Characteristics and Theories of Apparitions,” Carter presents the standard classification of apparitions of the living, crisis apparitions, postmortem apparitions, and haunting apparitions, then considers theoretical approaches under the headings, “The skeptical theory,” “The telepathic theory,” and “The physically real theories.” In a lengthy Chapter 8, What Underlies Ghostly Visions?, he supplies additional cases studies. He concludes Part II with a brief Chapter 9, Final Thoughts on Apparitions. Carter’s selection and presentation of apparition cases is generally good and conveys well what is most exciting about the best cases—the suggestion that personality and dispositions, will and intentions, persist beyond death. He is less good in his handling of theory. He conflates Gurney’s earlier and later views and does not deal adequately with the ideas of F.
Recommended publications
  • PSYPIONEER JOURNAL Volume 7, No 11: November 2011
    PSYPIONEERF JOURNAL Founded by Leslie Price Edited by Archived by Paul J. Gaunt Garth Willey EST 2004 VolumeAmalgamation 7, No 11: of NovemberSocieties 2011 Discontinued; a Forgotten Spiritualist Tragedy – Leslie Price 338 Includes: A New Attack by Father Thurston – Psychic News Spiritualism and Suicide - The Tablet All of them are Evil Spirits! – Psychic News The Physical Phenomena of the Past, An Historical Survey – Leslie Curnow 349 Mrs. Mary Marshall – Paul J. Gaunt 355 Anti-Spiritualist Studies – Leslie Price 363 The Beginnings of Full Form Materialisations in England Catherine (Kate) Elizabeth Wood 1854-1884 – continued 366 Some books we have reviewed 374 How to obtain this Journal by email 375 ============================ 337 DISCONTINUED; A FORGOTTEN SPIRITUALIST TRAGEDY Serious students of the pioneers know that the on-line catalogues of major libraries are a treasure trove of information, often revealing unknown material. Sometimes, however, there is a dramatic story behind the catalogue card. So it is with an item in the subsidiary catalogue of British Library newspapers. One of them Spiritual Truth is marked “discontinued”. Behind this word “discontinued” is a tragedy, into which the American medium Arthur Ford, the editor of the then recently launched (1932) Psychic News Maurice Barbanell, and the Jesuit researcher Herbert Thurston were to be drawn. Spiritual Truth was edited by Percival Beddow, a prominent figure in Christian Spiritualism. He was, for example, one of the first to attend a Zodiac circle, and was addressed by Zodiac.1 Beddow also published a script from Philip the Evangelist, on which Sir Arthur Conan Doyle commented in his History of Spiritualism: “Two long scripts have recently appeared which have been written by the hand of the semi- conscious medium, Miss Cummins, the writing coming through at the extraordinary pace of 2,000 words per hour.
    [Show full text]
  • The Science of Mediumship and the Evidence of Survival
    Rollins College Rollins Scholarship Online Master of Liberal Studies Theses 2009 The cS ience of Mediumship and the Evidence of Survival Benjamin R. Cox III [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: http://scholarship.rollins.edu/mls Recommended Citation Cox, Benjamin R. III, "The cS ience of Mediumship and the Evidence of Survival" (2009). Master of Liberal Studies Theses. 31. http://scholarship.rollins.edu/mls/31 This Open Access is brought to you for free and open access by Rollins Scholarship Online. It has been accepted for inclusion in Master of Liberal Studies Theses by an authorized administrator of Rollins Scholarship Online. For more information, please contact [email protected]. The Science of Mediumship and the Evidence of Survival A Thesis Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Liberal Studies by Benjamin R. Cox, III April, 2009 Mentor: Dr. J. Thomas Cook Rollins College Hamilton Holt School Master of Liberal Studies Winter Park, Florida This project is dedicated to Nathan Jablonski and Richard S. Smith Table of Contents Introduction ............................................................................................... 1 The Science of Mediumship.................................................................... 11 The Case of Leonora E. Piper ................................................................ 33 The Case of Eusapia Palladino............................................................... 45 My Personal Experience as a Seance Medium Specializing
    [Show full text]
  • Spirit and Other Writings (By Author from More Prolific Authors)
    Home | Library | E‐Zines | Books | Glossary | Links | FAQ Spirit and Other Writings (by author from more prolific authors) | Johanne Agerskov | Akhenaton | Frank Alper | Rosemary Altea (Gray Eagle) | Elwood Babbitt | Alice Bailey (Djwhal Khul) | Marti Barham | Elsa Barker | Bartholomew (via Mary Moore) | Graham Bernard | Silver Birch | Frances Bird | Anthony Borgia | Sylvia Browne | June Burke | Eileen Caddy | Dolores Cannon | Ken Carey | Mary Carreiro | Hilda Charlton | Edgar Cayce | Barbara Hand Clow | Grace and Ivan Cooke (White Eagle) | Denise Cooney | A Course in Miracles (via Helen Schucman and others) | Benjamin Creme (Maitreya) | Geraldine Cummins | Dolfyn | Emmanuel (via Pat Rodegast, et. al.) | Virginia Essene | Paul Ferrini | Arthur Findlay | Jean K. Foster | Louis Gittner | Brian Grattan | Helen Greaves | David Hess | Hilarion (via Maurice Cooke) | Barbara Marx Hubbard | I Am | Allan Kardec (Leon Rivail) | Ronald G. Kaufmann | L Kelway­Bamber | Eric Klein | Kryon (via Lee Carroll) | Dale Landry | Lazaris (via Jack Pursel ) | David K Johnson and Robert Leichtman | Janet McClure (Vywamus) | Dorothy. MacLean | A. Gates McKibbin | George McMullen | James Merrill | Michael Teachings | Mother Mary (via Annie Kirkwood and others) | MSI | Karl Nowotny | George Vale Owen | James E Padgett | Pearl | Eva Pierrakos | Elizabeth Clare and Mark Prophet | Ramala | Andrew Ramer | Ramtha (via J.Z. Knight) | Dorothy Roeder | Mona Rolfe | Sanaya Roman | Helena Roerich | Kevin Ryerson and Shirley Maclaine | Saint Germain (via Guy Ballard, et.
    [Show full text]
  • Glossary of Spiritualist Terms and Techniques
    A PPENDIX A Glossary of Spiritualist Terms and Techniques automatic writing. A Spirit uses the medium’s hand to write replies to any number of questions posed; also practiced by amateurs as a way of strengthening their spiritual powers. As an added feature, a magic pencil sometimes floats. In such instances, the Spirits are asking the medium to begin writing. How it is done: The pencil hangs on thin metal or glass wires. clairgustance or clairlience. A taste or smell associated with the Spirit. For example, if you are trying to contact your mother, who was fond of gardening, a waft of rose water might be introduced. How it is done: aromatherapy. dermography, also known as skin writing. The Spirits literally write words or pictures on the medium’s flesh. How it is done: Invisible ink, likely lemon juice, is used. When held up to a candle, the ink grows increasingly visible. ectoplasm. A pale, filmy materialization of the soul, produced by the medium when in a trance state. Likely invented by Leah Fox (circa 1860). The last manifestation of ectoplasm seems to have taken place in 1939. Cambridge University has a sample; it looks and feels like cheesecloth or chiffon. Female mediums sometimes stuffed ectoplasm in their vaginas, necessitating strip- searches. See also soul and Spirit’s progress. lampadomancy. Flame reading. The messages might be conveyed by changes in flame intensity, color, or direction. How it is done: Chemicals can be added to a segment of the candle to make the flame flicker or change color. On the direction of the flame: a small hole in the table may allow 164 Glossary of Spiritualist Terms and Techniques for a flue to affect air- current.
    [Show full text]
  • Where There Is Life There Is Spirit
    PAGE 2 PSYCHIC NEWS, AUGUST 21,1976 Where there is life there is spirit whether animal, vegetable, there is life there is spirit.” WRITING to me about life must be thekey of all Wolverhamp- mineral, or even the etherie Spirit after death, a movement, motion, or life, YOUR comments, criticisms or complaints ton reader asked if we could realms. that is Brother process, operating while matter, unless ener- . “'M are welcome. Please see your name walk, talk, etc, in the next Such a posfcoop The the universe, can gised, does not move and will legible, in block letters, if not typed. world, were we “just a throughout letters. or nor also decay. So matter, of itself Editor reserves the right to shorten light floating in space”? Yes, be neither automatic We letters cannot be or fortuitous. The underlying and in its own degree, serves regret answered those are his words. Perhaps spirit acknowledged unless a SAE is enclosed. principle is the same in a no useful purpose until they indicate some of the yet appears. And we are not con- diversity of forms, each could not have ignorance which exists responds to an aware of spirit till matter Wake up, Britain! happen and cerning spirit life. initial happened, but know. impulse. moves. a week goes by we It is, of impossible HARDLY we build as a course, acorn always produces In our present environ- praise for George The structures actually to what spirit The without that knowledge may be, define oak, seed of wheat its ment we cannot see, feel, or Chapman and his healing guide result of is.
    [Show full text]
  • Secondhand Books Available from Penny Hayward [email protected]
    www.pennyhayward.co.uk Secondhand books available from Penny Hayward [email protected] Date / Publication Book Title Author Publisher Description / Edition Price £ The Initiation of the World Vera Stanley Alder Rider and Company 1957, Seventh Paperback. Used copy, name inside cover. Fair condition. 1.00 Edition The Philosophy of White Ray. Psychic Press Limited unsure Hard cover with some small marks, no dust jacket. Some browning to pages. Overall 4.50 Through the mediumships of good condition. Paulette Austen The Philosophy of White Ray. Psychic Press Limited unsure Hard cover with with foxing marks, no dust jacket. Some browning to pages. Occasional 2.00 Through the mediumships of light pencil marking on pages otherwise fair condition. Paulette Austen Teachings of Silver Birch A W Austin Psychic Book Club 1938 Hardcover no dust jacket. Some water damage to front cover, some wear to spine, pages 3.00 in good condition. Forward by Hannen Swaffer. Ex-church copy. Spirit Guidance A W Austin Psychic Book Club 1941 Hard cover. Held together with celotape, no cover to spine. Foxing to many pages. 5.00 Spirit Guidance A W Austin Psychic Book Club 1941 Hard cover with water damage otherwise intact, Very well warn pages, some loose pages 2.00 with foxing, ex church copy. I Hear a Voice. A bibliogrphy Maurice Barbanell Spiritualist Press 1962 Hard Cover in very good condition. No dust jakcet. Good condition with photos. Some 30.00 of E. G. Fricker the Healer foxing to pages. First page cut out. This Is Spiritualism Maurice Barbanell Tandem Books unsure Paperback, with creases and wear to spine.
    [Show full text]
  • Understanding (1748), L.A. Selby-Bigge (Ed.) Enquiries Concerning
    Notes Introduction 1. Hume, 'Of Miracles', Sect. X of An Enquiry concerning the Human Understanding (1748), L.A. Selby-Bigge (ed.) Enquiries concerning Hu­ man Understanding and concerning the Principles of Morals (Oxford: Oarendon, 1902) 3rd edn., 1975, pp. 109-31, p. 115 note. Chapter 1: THE CRISIS IN MODERN THEOLOGY 1. Later published in Kerygma und Mythos: Ein theologisches Gespriich, H. W. Bartsch (ed.) (Hamburg: Reich, 1947), 2 vols., I, pp. 15--48. The quotations which follow are given to the English translation of this work by R. H. Fuller, Kerygma and Myth: A Theological Debate, with contributions 1fy Rudolf Bultmann, Ernst Lohmeyer, Julius Schniewind, Friedrich Schumann, Helmut Thielicke and Austin Farrer (London: S.P.C.K., 1953) 2 vols., I, pp. 1-44. These, together with wider references, will be given in the text under the prefix 'KM'. 2. Bonhoeffer, Letters and Papers from Prison, translated from Widerstand und Ergebung: Briefe und Aufzeichnungen aus der Haft by R. H. Fuller, P. Clarke and others (London: SCM, 1953); enlarged edition, ed. E. Bethge (London: SCM, 1971) p. 285. The German edition, as may be noted, appeared in 1970. 3. Robinson (London: SCM, 1963). Further references to this work will be given in the text under the prefix 'HG'. 4. Robinson, 'The Debate Continues', D. L. Edwards (ed.), The Honest to God Debate: Some reactions to the book 'Honest to God' with a new chapter 1fy its author John A. T. Robinson (London: SCM, 1963) pp. 232-75, p. 262. Further references to this work will be given in the text under the prefix 'HGD'.
    [Show full text]
  • SPIRITUALISM the Past, the Present and the Future?
    SPIRITUALISM The Past, The Present and The Future? Stewart Alexander Introduction My deep involvement in Spiritualism may be traced back almost fifty years, during which time I have gradually amassed an extensive library of books, cassette and CD recordings plus various Spiritual paraphernalia. Amongst the collection are long out-of-print Spiritualist and Psychical Research books and also recordings of elderly Spiritualists (most of whom have since have departed this earth) recollecting their past séance room experiences with Physical mediums who today we can only read about. Additionally, I am the proud possessor of such items as Mrs Maud Gunning’s one time celluloid séance room trumpet. Although a powerful Physical medium, she was in many ways a private medium whose name rarely came before the public, so that sadly her wonderful séance room manifestations are largely unknown to present day Spiritualists. In respect of the fascinating experience recordings in my possession, they have now sat on my library shelves for (in most instances) well over 20 years, during which time doubtlessly they have sadly deteriorated. However, in recent times, I have determined to preserve them whilst there is still time. Therefore the long process of transferring them onto CD has begun, and for that I am greatly indebted to several of my aquaintances who, with the necessary equipment, kindly undertook the task on my behalf. Once completed, various extracts were selected and then grouped together onto ‘Compilation’ CD’s which are now available to Spiritualists and all other interested parties. For anyone interested in the Physical phenomena of the Séance room, those accounts may well transcend the ‘boggle factor’ and will perhaps convey to the listener the reason why the Spiritualist movement was once so very vibrant and progressive.
    [Show full text]
  • Robe~ Crookall
    Robe~ Crookall ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS FOR permission to make brief extracts from copyright material, the writer tenders grateful thanks to the publishers and authors listed below. Special acknowledgement is made to the American Society for Psychical Research for permission to quote from their Journal (Vol. X. 1916, pp. 632-60; 679-708; Vol. XII, 1918, pp. 39-60) and to Laura A. Dale, the Editor of the Journal, for her kind replies to his various enquiries. Those who are interested in astral projection owe much more to the publishing house of Rider & Co. Ltd. than to all the others put together: we are indebted to them for such works as The Projection of the Astral Bodyby Sylvan J. Muldoon and Hereward Carrington (1929), The Phenomenaof Astral Projection (1951) by the same authors, Practical .Astral Projection by Yram, Astral Projection by Oliver Fox, The Mystery of {he ~juman Double by the Hon. Ralph Shirley, Psychic Certainties and Man Outside Himselfboth by Prevost Battersby, My Ocmlt CaseBook by Frank Lind, Man's Unknown Journry by Staveley Bulford, etc., repre- senting pilot studies for the subsequent work of Professor Hornell Hart, Director of the International Project for Research on E.S.P. Projection (Proc. S.P.R., 50, 1956) and others. Thanks are due from the writer to Psychic News for permission to reprint (in Appendix V) part of an article by him which was printed in that Journal in Dec. 1955. Alcuin Press: Stanley Bedford, Death--An Interesting Journry, pp. 53, II4· Alfred A. Knopf: Wilfred Brandon, Open the Door, 1936, p. 24. American S.P.R.: X, 1916, pp.
    [Show full text]
  • Hamiltont.Pdf
    1 A critical examination of the methodology and evidence of the first and second generation elite leaders of the Society for Psychical Research with particular reference to the life, work and ideas of Frederic WH Myers and his colleagues and to the assessment of the automatic writings allegedly produced post-mortem by him and others (the cross- correspondences). Submitted by Trevor John Hamilton to the University of Exeter as a thesis for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in History by Publication (PT) in June 2019.This thesis is available for Library use on the understanding that it is copyright material and that no quotation from the thesis may be published without proper acknowledgement. I certify that all material in this thesis which is not my own work has been identified and no material has been previously submitted and approved for the award of a degree by this or any other University. Signature…………………………… 2 Abstract This thesis outlines the canons of evidence developed by the elite Cambridge- based and educated leaders of the Society for Psychical Research to assess anomalous phenomena, and second, describes the gradual shift away from that approach, by their successors and the reasons for such a partial weakening of those standards, and the consequences for the general health of the SPR .It argues that, for a variety of reasons, this methodology has not always been fully appreciated or described accurately. Partly this is to do with the complex personality of Myers who provoked a range of contradictory responses from both contemporaries and later scholars who studied his life and work; partly to do with the highly selective criticisms of his and his colleagues’ work by TH Hall (which criticisms have entered general discourse without proper examination and challenge); and partly to a failure fully to appreciate how centrally derived their concepts and approaches were from the general concerns of late-Victorian science and social science.
    [Show full text]
  • Bibliography of Occult and Fantastic Beliefs Vol.1: a - D
    Bruno Antonio Buike, editor / undercover-collective „Paul Smith“, alias University of Melbourne, Australia Bibliography of Occult and Fantastic Beliefs vol.1: A - D © Neuss / Germany: Bruno Buike 2017 Buike Music and Science [email protected] BBWV E27 Bruno Antonio Buike, editor / undercover-collective „Paul Smith“, alias University of Melbourne, Australia Bibliography of Occult and Fantastic Beliefs - vol.1: A - D Neuss: Bruno Buike 2017 CONTENT Vol. 1 A-D 273 p. Vol. 2 E-K 271 p. Vol. 3 L-R 263 p. Vol. 4 S-Z 239 p. Appr. 21.000 title entries - total 1046 p. ---xxx--- 1. Dies ist ein wissenschaftliches Projekt ohne kommerzielle Interessen. 2. Wer finanzielle Forderungen gegen dieses Projekt erhebt, dessen Beitrag und Name werden in der nächsten Auflage gelöscht. 3. Das Projekt wurde gefördert von der Bundesrepublik Deutschland, Sozialamt Neuss. 4. Rechtschreibfehler zu unterlassen, konnte ich meinem Computer trotz jahrelanger Versuche nicht beibringen. Im Gegenteil: Das Biest fügt immer wieder neue Fehler ein, wo vorher keine waren! 1. This is a scientific project without commercial interests, that is not in bookstores, but free in Internet. 2. Financial and legal claims against this project, will result in the contribution and the name of contributor in the next edition canceled. 3. This project has been sponsored by the Federal Republic of Germany, Department for Social Benefits, city of Neuss. 4. Correct spelling and orthography is subject of a constant fight between me and my computer – AND THE SOFTWARE in use – and normally the other side is the winning party! Editor`s note – Vorwort des Herausgebers preface 1 ENGLISH SHORT PREFACE „Paul Smith“ is a FAKE-IDENTY behind which very probably is a COLLCETIVE of writers and researchers, using a more RATIONAL and SOBER approach towards the complex of Rennes-le-Chateau and to related complex of „Priory of Sion“ (Prieure de Sion of Pierre Plantard, Geradrd de Sede, Phlippe de Cherisey, Jean-Luc Chaumeil and others).
    [Show full text]
  • Bibliography of Occult and Fantastic Beliefs Vol.2: E-K
    Bruno Antonio Buike, editor / undercover-collective „Paul Smith“, alias University of Melbourne, Australia Bibliography of Occult and Fantastic Beliefs vol.2: E-K © Neuss / Germany: Bruno Buike 2017 Buike Music and Science [email protected] BBWV E28 Bruno Antonio Buike, editor / undercover-collective „Paul Smith, alias University of Melbourne, Australia Bibliography of Occult and Fantastic Beliefs - vol.2: E-K Neuss: Bruno Buike 2017 CONTENT Vol. 1 A-D 273 p. Vol. 2 E-K 271 p. Vol. 3 L-R 263 p. Vol. 4 S-Z 239 p. Appr. 21.000 title entries - total 1046 p. ---xxx--- 1. Dies ist ein wissenschaftliches Projekt ohne kommerzielle Interessen. 2. Wer finanzielle Forderungen gegen dieses Projekt erhebt, dessen Beitrag und Name werden in der nächsten Auflage gelöscht. 3. Das Projekt wurde gefördert von der Bundesrepublik Deutschland, Sozialamt Neuss. 4. Rechtschreibfehler zu unterlassen, konnte ich meinem Computer trotz jahrelanger Versuche nicht beibringen. Im Gegenteil: Das Biest fügt immer wieder neue Fehler ein, wo vorher keine waren! 1. This is a scientific project without commercial interests, that is not in bookstores, but free in Internet. 2. Financial and legal claims against this project, will result in the contribution and the name of contributor in the next edition canceled. 3. This project has been sponsored by the Federal Republic of Germany, Department for Social Benefits, city of Neuss. 4. Correct spelling and orthography is subject of a constant fight between me and my computer – AND THE SOFTWARE in use – and normally the other side is the winning party! Editor`s note – Vorwort des Herausgebers preface 1 ENGLISH SHORT PREFACE „Paul Smith“ is a FAKE-IDENTY behind which very probably is a COLLCETIVE of writers and researchers, using a more RATIONAL and SOBER approach towards the complex of Rennes-le-Chateau and to related complex of „Priory of Sion“ (Prieure de Sion of Pierre Plantard, Geradrd de Sede, Phlippe de Cherisey, Jean-Luc Chaumeil and others).
    [Show full text]