DOCSLIB.ORG

On War by Carl Von Clausewitz

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
On War by Carl Von Clausewitz CARL VON CLAUSEWITZ ON WAR Edited and Translated by MICHAEL HOWARD and PETER PARET Introductory Essays by PETER PARET, MICHAEL HOWARD, and BERNARD BRODIE; with a Commentary by BERNARD BRODIE Index by ROSALIE WEST PRINCETON UNIVERSITY PRESS PRINCETON, NEW JERSEY CARL VON CLAUSEWITZ PREPARED UNDER THE AUSPICES OF THE CENTER OF INTERNATIONAL STUDIES PRINCETON UNIVERSITY A LIST OF OTHER CENTER PUBLICATIONS APPEARS AT THE BACK OF THE BOOK CARL VON CLAUSEWITZ ON WAR Edited and Translated by MICHAEL HOWARD and PETER PARET Introductory Essays by PETER PARET, MICHAEL HOWARD, and BERNARD BRODIE; with a Commentary by BERNARD BRODIE Index by ROSALIE WEST PRINCETON UNIVERSITY PRESS PRINCETON, NEW JERSEY Published by Princeton University Press, 41 William Street, Princeton, New Jersey 08540 In the United Kingdom: Princeton University Press, Chichester, West Sussex Copyright O 1976 by Princeton University Press Index copyright O 1984 by Princeton University Press All Rights Reserved Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Clausewitz, Carl von, 1780-183 1. On war. Translation of: Vom Kriege. Includes bibliographical references and index. 1. Military art and science. 2. War. I. Howard, Michael Eliot, 1922- 11. Paret, Peter. 111. Title. U102.C65 1984 355 84-3401 ISBN 0-691-05657-9 ISBN 0-691-01854-5 (pbk.) First Princeton Paperback printing, 1989 Princeton University Press books are printed on acid-free paper and meet the guidelines for permanence and durability of the Committee on Production Guidelines for Book Longevity of the Council on Library Resources Printed in the United States of America pbk. ISBN-10: 0-691-01854-5 (pbk.) CONTENTS Editors' Note xi Note for the 1984 Edition xii Introductorv Essays The Genesis of On War PETER PARET The Influence of Clausewitz MICHAEL HOWARD The Continuing Relevance of On War BERNARD BRODIE On War Author's Preface Author's Comment Preface MARIE VON CLAUSEWITZ Two Notes by the Author BOOK ONE On the Nature of War I What is War? 2 Purpose and Means in War 3 On Military Genius 4 On Danger in War 5 On Physical Effort in War 6 Intelligence in War 7 Friction in War 8 Concluding Observations on Book One CONTENTS BOOK TWO On the Theory of War I Classifications of the Art of War 2 On the Theory of War 3 Art of War or Science of War 4 Method and Routine 5 Critical Analysis 6 On Historical Examples BOOK THREE On Strategy in General Strategy Elements of Strategy Moral Factors The Principal Moral Elements Military Virtues of the Army Boldness Perseverance Superiority of Numbers Surprise Cunning Concentration of Forces in Space Unification of Forces in.Time The Strategic Reserve Economy of Force The Geometrical Factor The Suspension of Action in War The Character of Contemporary Warfare Tension and Rest CONTENTS BOOK FOUR The Engagenlent I Introduction 2 The Nature of Battle Today 3 The Engagement in General 4 The Engagement in General-Continued 5 The Significance of the Engagement Duration of the Engagement Decision of the Engagement Mutual Agreement to Fight The Battle: Its Decision The Battle-Continued: The Effects of Victory The Battle-Continued: The Use of Battle Strategic Means of Exploiting V~C~ON Retreat after a Lost Battle Night Operations BOOK FIVE Military Forces 1 General Survey 3 The Army, the Theater of Operations, the Campaign 3 Relative Strength 4 Relationship between the Branches of the Service 5 The Army's Order of Battle 6 General Disposition of the Army 7 Advance Guard and Outposts 8 Operational Use of Advanced Corps 9 Camps 10 Marches vii CONTENTS 1 1 Marches-Continued 12 Marches-Concluded 13 Billets 14 Maintenance and Supplv 15 Base of Operations 16 Lines of Communication 17 Terrain 18 The Command of Heights BOOK SIX Defense Attack and Defense The Relationship between Attack and Defense in Tactics The Relationship between Attack and Defense in Strategy Convergence of Attack and Divergence of Defense The Character of Strategic Defense Scope of the Means of Defense Interaction between Attack and Defense Types of Resistance The Defensive Battle Fortresses I I Fortresses-Continued 12 Defensive Positions I 3 Fortified Positions and Entrenched Camps 14 Flank Positions 15 Defensive Mountain Warfare 16 Defensive Mountain Warfare-Continued 17 Defensive Mountain Warfare-Concluded 18 Defense of Rivers and Streams 19 Defense of Rivers and Streams-Continued CONTENTS A. Defense of Swamps B. Inundations Defense of Forests The Cordon The Key to the Country Operations on a Flank Retreat to the Interior of the Country The People in Amls Defense of a Theater of Operations Defense of a Theater of Operations-Continued Defense of a Theater of Operations-Continued: Phased Resistance Defense of a Theater of Operations-Concluded: Where a Decision Is Not the Objective BOOK SEVEN The Attack Attack in Relation to Defense The Nature of Strategic Attack The Object of the Strategic Attack The Diminishing Force of the Attack The Culminating Point of the Attack Destruction of the Enemy's Forces The Offensive Battle River Crossings Attack on Defensive Positions Attack on Entrenched Camps Attack on a Mountainous Area Attack on Cordons Maneuver Attacks on Swamps, Flooded Areas, and Forests CONTENTS i 5 Attack on a Theater of War: Seeking a Decision 545 16 Attack on a Theater of War: Not Seeking a Decision 548 17 Attack on Fortresses 55l 18 Attack on Convoys 19 Attack on an Enemy Armv in Billets 5 57 20 Diversions 56~ 21 Invasion 565 22 The Culminating Point of Victory 566 BOOK EIGHT War Plans 1 Introduction 5 77 2 Absolute War and Real War 5 79 3 A. Interdependence of the Elements of War 582 B. Scale of the Military Objective and of the Effort To Be Made 585 4 Closer Definition of the Military Objective: The Defeat of the Enemy 5 Closer Definition of the Military Objective-Continued: Limited Aims 60 1 6 A. The Effect of the Political Aim on the Military Objective 603 B. War Is an Instrument of Policy 60 5 7 The Limited Aim: Offensive War 8 The Limited Aim: Defensive War 9 The Plan of a War designed to Lead to the Total Defeat of the Enemv A Commentary A Guide to the Reading of On War BERNARD l3RODIE Index ROSALIE WEST The reader may wonder why another English translation of Vom Kriege is needed when two already exist. The first, made by Colonel J. J. Graham in 1874, was republished in London in 1909. The second, by Professor 0. J. Matthijs Jolles, appeared in New York in 1943. But Graham's translation, apart from its dated style, contains a large num- ber of inaccuracies and obscurities; and while Jolles' translation is more precise, both his version and Graham's were based on German texts that contained significant alterations from the first edition published in 1832. The growing interest in Clausewitz's theoretical, political and histori- cal writings in recent years suggested that the time had come for an entirely new translation. We have based our work on the first edition of 1832, supplemented by the annotated German text published by Profes- sor Werner Hahlweg in 1952, except where obscurities in the original edition-which Clausewitz himself never reviewed-made it seem advis- able to accept later emendations. In all but one respect we have followed the original arrangement of the text. The first edition printed four notes by Clausewitz on his theo- ries, dating from various periods between 1816 and 1830, as introduc- tions to On War itself-a practice adopted by most subsequent German and foreign editions. We have abandoned the haphazard arrangement in which these have always appeared, and instead print them in the order in which we believe the notes to have been written. Read consecutively they help to indicate how On War took shape in Clausewitz's mind, and suggest how it might have further developed had he lived to complete it. We have also included Marie von Clausewitz's Preface to the first edition of Clausewitz's posthumous works, which adds information on the gene- sis of On War, and on the manner in which the manuscript was prepared for publication. A brief note she inserted at the beginning of the third volume of Clausewitz's Works, immediately preceding Book Seven of On War, has been deleted since its primary concern is not with On War but with other historical and theoretical writings. We have attempted to present Clausewitz's ideas as accurately as pos- sible, while remaining as close to his style and vocabulary as modern En- glish usage would permit. But we have not hesitated to translate the same term in different ways if the context seemed to demand it. For instance, we have translated Moral and moralische Kraft variously as "morale," EDITORS' NOTE "moral," and "ps~~chological."Clausewitz himself was far from consis- tent in his terminology, as might be expected of a writer who was less concerned with establishing a formal system or doctrine than with achieving understanding and clarity of expression. At times he writes Geisteskrafte, Seelenkrafte, even Psychologie instead of moralische Kraft or moralische Grossen, and a similar flexibility characterizes his use of such terms as "means," "purpose," "engagement," "battle," etc. As he writes in Book Five, Chapter Seven: "Strict adherence to terms would clearly result in little more than pedantic distinctions." The task of translation was initially undertaken by Mr. Angus Malcolm, formerly of the British Foreign Office, who to the deep regret of his many friends died while he was still engaged on the project. He had however already done much valuable preliminary work, for which we are greatly in his debt. \Ye should like to thank Mrs.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Marie Von Clausewitz: the Omw an Behind the Making of on War, by Vanya Eftimova Bellinger John T
    Naval War College Review Volume 69 Article 10 Number 3 Summer 2016 Marie von Clausewitz: The omW an behind the Making of On War, by Vanya Eftimova Bellinger John T. Kuehn Follow this and additional works at: https://digital-commons.usnwc.edu/nwc-review Recommended Citation Kuehn, John T. (2016) "Marie von Clausewitz: The omW an behind the Making of On War, by Vanya Eftimova Bellinger," Naval War College Review: Vol. 69 : No. 3 , Article 10. Available at: https://digital-commons.usnwc.edu/nwc-review/vol69/iss3/10 This Book Review is brought to you for free and open access by the Journals at U.S. Naval War College Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Naval War College Review by an authorized editor of U.S. Naval War College Digital Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. 146 NAVALKuehn: WAR COLLEGEMarie von REVIEW Clausewitz: The Woman behind the Making of On War, by V challenges in the Gulf of Guinea� Indeed, international cooperation� (4) Prevailing the book may be viewed as a compen- regional cooperative processes lack coor- dium of the existing legal regimes in the dination and have suffered several set- Gulf of Guinea� This legal landscape is backs� (5) International support for mar- important to understand as efforts pro- itime security cooperation in the Gulf ceed to combat maritime insecurity and of Guinea is inadequate, uncoordinated, enhance maritime governance through and in some cases driven by national in- cooperation� The section on emerging terests that affect its overall
    [Show full text]
  • The Civilization of War Edited by Alessandro Dal Lago and Salvatore Palidda Conflict, Security and the Reshaping of Society the Civilization of War
    Conflict, Security and the Reshaping of Society This book is an examination of the effect of contemporary wars (such as the ‘War on Terror’) on civil life at a global level. Contemporary literature on war is mainly devoted to recent changes in the theory and practice of warfare, particularly those in which terrorists or insurgents are involved (for example, the ‘revolution in military affairs’, ‘small wars’, and so on). On the other hand, today’s research on security is focused, among other themes, on the effects of the war on terrorism, and on civil liberties and social control. This volume connects these two fields of research, showing how ‘war’ and ‘security’ tend to exchange targets and forms of action as well as personnel (for instance, the spreading use of private contractors in wars and of military experts in the ‘struggle for security’) in modern society. This shows how, contrary to Clausewitz’s belief that war should be conceived of as a ‘continuation of politics by other means’, the opposite statement is also true: that politics, insofar as it concerns security, can be defined as the ‘continuation of war by other means’. This book will be of much interest to students of critical security studies, war and conflict studies, terrorism studies, sociology and international relations in general. Alessandro Dal Lago is Professor of Sociology of Culture and Communica- tion at the University of Genoa. Salvatore Palidda is Professor of Sociology in the Faculty of Education at the University of Genoa. Routledge studies in liberty and security Series editors: Didier Bigo, Elspeth Guild and R.B.J.
    [Show full text]
  • The Art of War in the Middle Ages, A.D. 378-1515
    Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2007 with funding from IVIicrosoft Corporation http://www.archive.org/details/artofwarinmiddleOOomanuoft otl^xan: ^rt§e ^ssag 1884 THE ART OF WAR IN THE MIDDLE AGES PRINTED BY HORACE HART, PRINTER TO THE UNIVERSITY THE ART OF WAR [N THE MIDDLE AGES A.D. 37^—15^5 BY C. W. C. OMAN, B.A. FELLOW OF ALL SOULS COLLEGE WITH MAPS AND PLANS OXFORD B. H. BLACKWELL, 50 BROAD STREET LONDON T. FISHER UNWIN, 26 PATERNOSTER SQUARE 1885 [^// rights reserved '\ O/M The Author desires to acknowledge much kind help received in the revision and correction of this Essay from the Rev. H. B. George, of New College, and Mr. F. York Powell, of Christ Church. 6/ 37 05 , — — CONTENTS. PAGE ' Introduction . i CHAPTER 1. The Transition from Roman to Medieval forms in War (a.d. 378-582). Disappearance of the Legion.—Constantine's reorgajiization. The German tribes . — Battle of Adrianople.—Theodosius accepts its teaching.—Vegetius and the army at the end of the fourth century. —The Goths and the Huns. Army of the Eastern Empire.— Cavalry all-important . 3— 14 CHAPTER n. The Early Middle Ages (a.d. 476-1066). Paucity of Data for the period.—The Franks in the sixth cen- tury.—Battle of Tours.—^Armies of Charles the Great. The Franks become horsemen.—The Northman and the Magyar.—Rise of Feudalism.—The Anglo-Saxons and their wars.—The Danes and the Fyrd.—Military importance of the Thegnhood.—The House-Carles.—Battle of Hastings . Battle of Durazzo 15 — 27 W — VI CONTENTS.
    [Show full text]
  • Three Theories of Just War: Understanding Warfare As a Social Tool Through Comparative Analysis of Western, Chinese, and Islamic Classical Theories of War
    THREE THEORIES OF JUST WAR: UNDERSTANDING WARFARE AS A SOCIAL TOOL THROUGH COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF WESTERN, CHINESE, AND ISLAMIC CLASSICAL THEORIES OF WAR A THESIS SUBMITTED TO THE GRADUATE DIVISION OF THE UNIVERSITY OF HAWAI‘I AT MĀNOA IN PARTIAL FULFILMENT OF THE REQUIREMENT FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF ARTS IN PHILOSOPHY MAY 2012 By Faruk Rahmanović Thesis Committee: Tamara Albertini, Chairperson Roger T. Ames James D. Frankel Brien Hallett Keywords: War, Just War, Augustine, Sunzi, Sun Bin, Jihad, Qur’an DEDICATION To my parents, Ahmet and Nidžara Rahmanović. To my wife, Majda, who continues to put up with me. To Professor Keith W. Krasemann, for teaching me to ask the right questions. And to Professor Martin J. Tracey, for his tireless commitment to my success. 1 ABSTRACT The purpose of this analysis was to discover the extent to which dictates of war theory ideals can be considered universal, by comparing the Western (European), Classical Chinese, and Islamic models. It also examined the contextual elements that drove war theory development within each civilization, and the impact of such elements on the differences arising in war theory comparison. These theories were chosen for their differences in major contextual elements, in order to limit the impact of contextual similarities on the war theories. The results revealed a great degree of similarities in the conception of warfare as a social tool of the state, utilized as a sometimes necessary, albeit tragic, means of establishing peace justice and harmony. What differences did arise, were relatively minor, and came primarily from the differing conceptions of morality and justice within each civilization – thus indicating a great degree of universality to the conception of warfare.
    [Show full text]
  • The Art of War: the Protection of Cultural Property During the "Siege" of Sarajevo (1992-95)
    DePaul Journal of Art, Technology & Intellectual Property Law Volume 14 Issue 1 Special Section: Art and War, 2004 Article 5 The Art of War: The Protection of Cultural Property during the "Siege" of Sarajevo (1992-95) Megan Kossiakoff Follow this and additional works at: https://via.library.depaul.edu/jatip Recommended Citation Megan Kossiakoff, The Art of War: The Protection of Cultural Property during the "Siege" of Sarajevo (1992-95), 14 DePaul J. Art, Tech. & Intell. Prop. L. 109 (2004) Available at: https://via.library.depaul.edu/jatip/vol14/iss1/5 This Case Notes and Comments is brought to you for free and open access by the College of Law at Via Sapientiae. It has been accepted for inclusion in DePaul Journal of Art, Technology & Intellectual Property Law by an authorized editor of Via Sapientiae. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Kossiakoff: The Art of War: TheCOMMENT Protection of Cultural Property during the "S THE ART OF WAR: THE PROTECTION OF CULTURAL PROPERTY DURING THE "SIEGE" OF SARAJEVO (1992-95) I. INTRODUCTION Throughout the night of August 25, 1992, shells from Serb gunners fell on the National and University Library of Bosnia and Herzegovina in Sarajevo. The attack set off a blaze fueled by a collection representing hundreds of years of Bosnian history and culture. Librarians and community members, risking sniper fire, formed a human chain to move books to safety.' Despite emergency efforts, ninety percent of the collection was ash by daybreak.2 Unfortunately, this incident was not unique. The destruction of cultural artifacts during the "Siege" of Sarajevo was a loss not only to Bosnia,3 but also to the heritage of the world which now suffers a gap that cannot be closed.
    [Show full text]
  • The Political Alignment of the Centre Party in Wilhelmine Germany: a Study of the Party's Emergence in Nineteenth-Century Württemberg
    The Political Alignment of the Centre Party in Wilhelmine Germany: A Study of the Party's Emergence in Nineteenth-Century Württemberg The Harvard community has made this article openly available. Please share how this access benefits you. Your story matters Citation Blackbourn, David. 1975. The political alignment of the Centre Party in Wilhelmine Germany: A study of the party's emergence in nineteenth-century Württemberg. Historical Journal 18(4): 821-850. Published Version doi:10.1017/S0018246X00008906 Citable link http://nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:3629315 Terms of Use This article was downloaded from Harvard University’s DASH repository, and is made available under the terms and conditions applicable to Other Posted Material, as set forth at http:// nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:dash.current.terms-of- use#LAA The Historical Journal, XVIII, 4 (I975), pp. 82I-850 821 Printed in Great Britain THE POLITICAL ALIGNMENT OF THE CENTRE PARTY IN WILHELMINE GERMANY: A STUDY OF THE PARTY'S EMERGENCE IN NINETEENTH-CENTURY WURTTEMBERG By DAVID BLACKBOURN Jesus College, Cambridge LESS than a month before Bismarck's dismissal as German chancellor, the Reichstag elections of February I890 destroyed the parliamentary majority of the Kartell parties - National Liberals and Conservatives - with whose support he had governed. The number of Reichstag seats held by these parties fell from 22I to I40, out of the total of397; they never again achieved more than I69. To the multitude of problems left by Bismarck to his successorswas there- fore added one of parliamentaryarithmetic: how was the chancellor to organize a Reichstag majority when the traditional governmental parties by themselves were no longer large enough, and the intransigently anti-governmental SPD was constantly increasing its representation? It was in this situation that the role of the Centre party in Wilhelmine politics became decisive, for between I890 and I9I4 the party possessed a quarter of the seats in the Reichstag, and thus held the balance of power between Left and Right.
    [Show full text]
  • Seelsorgeeinheit Neresheim
    NACHRICHTENBLATT 08/2020 Amtsblatt der Stadt Neresheim Freitag, den 21. 02. 2020 60. Jahrgang Unglaublich schnell vergeht die Zeit, am Rosenmontag ist es wieder so weit. Die Narren wollen mein Rathaus stürmen, Rathaussturm wir werden es jedoch besonders schirmen. Absetzung des Der Bauhof als Verstärkung, der wird wieder kommen, Bürgermeisters durch DJ „Black Sun“ das Rathaus wird so leicht nicht eingenommen. Jetzt Termin Einfach mach ich´s Euch auch dieses Jahr nicht. die vier Faschingszünfte vormerken und Dieses Jahr schiebt ihr ne extra Schicht! mitfeiern! der Stadt Neresheim Die Bevölkerung ist herzlich eingeladen, Die Stadt Neresheim lädt die Bevölkerung der um zu sehen der Narren Verzagen. Gesamtgemeinde Neresheim recht herzlich ein. see Bürgermeister z Gerberggas n Parkplal tz zugsg beb giinnn latz Thomas Häfele UUmm amm Mara ienp AbAAbsetzungsetztzunung am Marienpla “ Rosenmontag t i Narrenheim mit anschl. Megaparty im „Narrenheim 24. Februar 2020, 10:00 Uhr und in der Marktstraße Dienstag, 25. Februar 2020 1144.000 Uhhr Auch diiese ess JaJahrh sos lll dder Neresheimer Fastnachtsumzug amm Dieiennstaagg,, demem 225. Feebbruuar 2002020, 114.00 Uhr did e BBeessuucheer aus Nah und Ferrnn aannziziehehenen. DDie Naarrrennzunfft Neereesshheieim bib ttet ddaheher alllel Vereeinne und diie BBevöölkkeerruung der GeGessammtgeg mmeini dee Neerer shheieim wiiede eer umu reegeg BeBeteteiligung. Diee Narrenzunft 3,3 0000 suchht gegen UUmmzzugsprpreeis: EEuroo. g Ummssatzbeteiligun DDaas Weerrfenn voon Kuunssttstot ff-,-, StStaannz-z- unnd Paapip errababfäf llenn o.. Ä.Ä. und das wiieeder Verkäufer Versprriitzeen vvon ÖlÖl isi t aus UmUmwweellttscchhuttzzggrrünündden vev rbbototene . Zuwiw dderhhandelnde n voonn Festabzeiche werdenn zuzur BeBeglleiichhunung ddeer Reeinniigununggskok ststene heheraanggeezogenen. füür den Fastnachtss- ummzug. ZZwwischeenn ZuZugffaha rzr eeug und WaW gen mmüsseen zuzur AAufsf ici hth zwz eii Beegglleeiittpersonen geesttele lltt werdden.
    [Show full text]
  • The Strategic Paradox of Truly Autonomous Weapons
    The strategic paradox of autonomous weapons ZIPAR Policy Brief February 2018 Marko Kovic ZIPAR About ZIPAR The Zurich Institute of Public Aairs Research is devoted to identifying and addressing the major challenges for humankind in the short-term, in the medium- term, and in the long-term future. ZIPAR is an independent nonprot think tank based in Zurich, Switzerland. Recommended citation Marko Kovic (2018): The strategic paradox of autonomous weapons systems. ZIPAR Policy Brief. Zurich, Switzerland. Copyright This document is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial- NoDerivatives 4.0 International license. You can freely distribute this document and reference it in other works. For any questions about copyright, feel free to contact the author ([email protected]). 2 The strategic paradox of autonomous weapons ZIPAR Policy Brief Abstract Progress in articial intelligence makes the technology increasingly relevant to military applications. In particular, autonomous weapons could be of great military use: Autonomous weapons could achieve goals more ef- fectively and more eciently than humans or human-operated weapons. In this policy brief, the potential impact of implementing autonomous weapons on the behavior and decision-making of the military is discussed. The most probable positive impact, greater adherence to humanitarian law on the battleeld, is outweighed by the most probable negative impact, a disruption of the military chain of command and the security risks that follow from that disruption. This creates a strategic paradox: Even though autonomous weapons could help the military achieve goals more eectively and more eciently, autonomous weapons would strategically undermine the military by disrupting the chain of command and by creating a great security risk.
    [Show full text]
  • A Study of Sun Tzu's Art of War and Clausewitz's On
    features 68 A Study of Sun Tzu’s Art of War and Clausewitz’s On War by LTC Ong Cher Howe Abstract: Sun Tzu and Clausewitz are both known to be most recognised and proficient writers on the subject of war and strategies. Although they wrote in different times and were from different backgrounds, their philosophies on war and strategy are still proven to be extremely helpful and effective in current times. This essay serves to compare both Sun Tzu and Clausewitz’s famous texts written on the subject of war: Art of War and On War, as well as prove how both works are not extremely different even when they were written in a divergent, historical, cultural and technological context. Instead, what both Sun Tzu and Clausewitz tried to express were not diametrically opposed. Hence, any contradiction arises from their own slightly unique points of analysis. While both of them defined war as means to rational policy ends, they were both well aware of the power of moral influence and the paradoxical trinity. This essay also studies how both their works can be applied to today’s military applications despite the advanced technology of the modern era. Keywords: Government, People, Philosophy, Technology, Doctrine, Law INTRODUCTION ‘different sides of the same coin.’ Instead of diametrically opposed, they advanced largely similar Sun Tzu’s Art of War and Clausewitz’s On War are the ideas that operate within degrees of contradiction. most studied philosophies on war and strategy. These Those apparent degrees of contradiction are the result two texts were written in eras more than 2,000 years of their different starting point of analysis.
    [Show full text]
  • Wiest Must Have War and Society List
    War and Society Graduate Reading List Drs. Allison Abra, Mao Lin, Heather M. Stur, Kenneth Swope, Susannah Ural, Andrew A. Wiest, & Kyle F. Zelner NOTE: In addition to the titles listed below, students should familiarize themselves with the important journals in the field, especially The Journal of Military History and War & Society, in addition to relevant articles in more general history journals. VALID DATES: Approved for students entering program in 2010 and forward (or by agreement with faculty advisor). * designates a classic, must-read, essential work. (67 total) ************************************************************************************* HISTORIOGRAPHICAL WORKS: The following—required—historiographical works offer students a firm understanding of current issues in the field of war and society: *Black, Jeremy. Rethinking Military History. New York: Routledge, 2004. *Citino, Robert M. “Military Histories Old and New: A Reintroduction.” American Historical Review 112, no. 4 (2007): 1070-1090. *Grenier, John. “Recent Trends in the Historiography on Warfare in the Colonial Period (1607-1765)” History Compass 8 no. 4 (2010): 358-367. *Hughes, Matthew and William Philpott, eds. Palgrave Advances in Modern Military Histor. New York: Palgrave Macmillian, 2007. *Kohn, Richard H., “The Social History of the American Soldier: A Review and Prospectus for Research.” American Historical Review 86, no. 3 (1981): 553-67. *Lee, Wayne E. “Early American Ways of War: A New Reconnaissance, 1600-1815.” The Historical Journal 44, no. 1 (2001): 269-289. *Lee, Wayne E. “Mind and Matter - Cultural Analysis in American Military History: A Look at the State of the Field.” Journal of American History 93, no. 4 (2007): 1116-1142. *Linn, Brian McAllister. “‘The American Way of War’ Revisited.” Journal of Military History 66, no.
    [Show full text]
  • Scenario and Campaign List - Introduction
    Republican Bayonets on the Rhine Scenario and Campaign List - Introduction List Comments The scenario list for Republican Bayonets on the Rhine includes 28 historical battles and over 200 scenarios that are in the main folder. This also includes Bonus, select campaign scenarios and also 15 min turn format scenarios. The players should note that the scenario file name lists whether a scenario is HTH - Head to Head or SOLO - meaning that it has AI scripts and can be played against the program. There were several HTH scenarios in the game which because of their complexity do not have a Solo counterpart. Others were simplified to allow for a more balanced situation when converted to a Solo setting. Three design scenarios are included for Scenarios Designers to use as well as those that would like to see all of the uniforms for the soldiers for this time period. They show the layout of the images that are part of the game. Key to the List Each scenario has a filename, scenario name and amount of turns on each line. Filename - has a number, the name of the action/battle and whether it is a Head to Head (HTH) or Solo (SOLO) scenario. If the scenario is a variant then the letter V followed by a number is listed after the name of the action/battle. Examples: Filename Title 001_Valmy_FB-H_HTH.scn 001. The Battle of Valmy FB-Full Battle, H-Historical, HTH-meant for Head to Head play 016_Jemappes_SG-H_SOLO.scn 016. Jemappes: Assaulting the Northern Flank SG-A segment of the full battle, H-Historical, SOLO-meant for Solo play Other abbreviations: V-Variant (V1, V2, etc) V1-1st Variant of the historical scenario 1D-1st Day of the battle, 2D-2nd Day (etc) Bonus - Bonus scenario Camp - Campaign scenario Order of Battle Review Scenarios See the OB_View folder No listing is provided for these scenarios.
    [Show full text]
  • The Public Morality of Carl Von Clausewitz
    DRAFT The Public Morality of Carl von Clausewitz A Paper for Presentation at the Annual Meeting of the International Studies Association 24-27 March 2002 Suzanne C. Nielsen Assistant Professor Department of Social Sciences West Point, NY 10996 [email protected] The views expressed are those of the author and not necessarily those of the Department of the Army, the U.S. Military Academy, or any other U.S. government agency. Please do not cite or reproduce without permission from the author. DRAFT “Nowadays, anyone reflecting on war and strategy raises a barrier between his intelligence and his humanity.” - Raymond Aron Clausewitz, Philosopher of War (1976) Introduction The ideas of Carl von Clausewitz, Prussian soldier and scholar, have been the subject of endless controversy since the posthumous publication of his great work, On War , in 1832. Did he produce a timebound and even faulty analysis of the wars of his age, or a classic that provides timeless insights? Was he an objective analyst of the complex nature of war, or an advocate of absolute wars of annihilation? Characterizations of Clausewitz and his writings vary tremendously. In the wake of the First World War, Liddell Hart attributed at least indirect responsibility for its destructiveness to Clausewitz. To Hart, Clausewitz was the “evil genius of military thought” and the “apostle of total war” who advocated mass and offensive above all else. 1[1] Bernard Brodie gave a quite different interpretation in the 1970s. He emphasized Clausewitz’s denial that war could be waged according to a list of axioms, and his belief that even valuable generalizations admit exceptions.
    [Show full text]