1 Division of Administration Quarterly Litigation Report March 2021
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Division of Administration Quarterly Litigation Report March 2021 – May 2021 Docket Court Plaintiffs Defendants Cause of Action Relief Sought Current Status Counsel Number (At Any (At Any Time) Information Time) 658310 19th DOA, FP&C Lincoln Builders of Ruston, et al Breach of construction Damages, Petition for Damages filed by In house- Sec. 21 JDC contract related to leaks in interests, costs and the State on 5/30/2017; parties Bridget Denicola roof fees are working on remediation Matthew Darouse plan; remediation plan received on 1/29/2018 and Lincoln Builders working on lining up subcontractors to complete the remediation work; although it was agreed by all parties that remediation work should commence and be completed during summer break (between Memorial Day and Labor Day, 2019), the recent tornados in that area impacted the construction schedule; Settlement agreement was signed on January 22, 2020. Dismissal was signed June 11, 2020. 671,252, 19th DOA, LPAA Brown’s Auction Co., LLC & Jacob Conversion $175,342.67 Petition filed on July 6, 2018; In house-Carlos Sec. 24 JDC Brown Jacob Brown was personally Romanach served on 6-21-2019;order of preliminary default signed by the Court on July 9, 2020. 647,500 19th DOA, FP&C The Migues Deloach Company, Breach of construction Damages, Petition for Damages filed by In house- Sec. 27 JDC LLC and Hartford Fire Insurance Co contract related to corrosion in interests, costs and the State on 4/12/16; Consent Bridget Denicola Hallmark Specialty Ins. Co (third- sprinkler system piping fees Judgment dismissing only tort party defendant) claims and maintaining contract claim entered on 10/13/16 in response to Exception of Prescription filed 1 by Migues (contractor); FPC hired Mid-South Fire Solutions to remove and replace corroded pipes which is only a portion of the system; during the litigation discovery process, expert witnesses identified the cause of corrosion as a manufacturing defect; demand has been made upon the manufacturer as well as the contractor to pay amounts expended thus far as well as those that will be expended in order to repair remaining corrosion in sprinkler system; settlement discussions were not successful, so the manufacturer and fabricator as well as their insurers were added as defendants to the litigation; all defendants have answered the supplemental and original petitions and discovery is on-going 546,704 19th DOA, ORM Chennel Lite Clark a/k/a Chennel Conversion Damages Judgment obtained and In house- Carlos JDC Lite, Alfred Clark, JPMorgan Chase recorded, awaiting judgment Romanach Bank, N.A., and Hancock Bank of debtor to finish paying the Louisiana obligation. 641,774 19th DOA, FP&C Yeates and Yeates Architects, Problems with the air Damages, judicial Supplemental & Amending In house- Sec. 23 JDC The Lathan Company, Inc., conditioning due to oversized interest, costs of Petition for Damages filed by Bridget Denicola Satterfield & Pontikes Construction, units specified by the court, and expert State to name additional Spartan Building Corporation, designer’s engineer. Paint fees. defendants/insurers. Steadfast Lafayette Insurance Company. permeability issues causing Insurance dismissed by State The Continental Insurance condensation build-up in (policy not in force at time Company, Steadfast Insurance houses. of commencement of project; rule set for 3/7/16 re 2 Company, Crum & Forster exceptions filed by defendants Specialty Insurance Co., in response to original petition Bitco National Insurance Company for damages; matter passed a/k/a Bituminous Insurance pending mediation on Company, 11/7/2016; Amerisure Mutual Insurance State settled with Spartan Company, Building Corp and its insurers; The Guarantee Company of North State settled with Satterfield & America, Pontikes and its insurers; State Western Surety Company/Safeco filed 2nd amending and Insurance Company of America, supplemental petition; State Hartford Casualty Insurance settled with Lathan, its Company insurers and sub-contractor; Exception of Peremption/Motion to Strike 2nd amending petition filed by Yeates with hearing on 8/28/17; exception sustained and claims outside of the HVAC system were struck; additional discovery responses have been received and forwarded to State’s experts for review; discovery depositions of 2 state witnesses have taken place and additional discovery is being conducted in order to prepare this matter for trial and possible mediation C-688,482 19th DOA,OGB Zata Ard Reconventional demand for Recovery of OGB’s Answer and In house- Marjorie Section JDC premium underpayments. premium Reconventional Demand was O’Connor, Bridget 21/D underpayments filed on January 23, Denicola totaling 2020. Plaintiff answered the $25,350.21. Reconventional Demand on February 10, 2020. Plaintiff responded to OGB’s discovery 3 on May 17, 2021. Discovery is ongoing. 2004- CDC OGB Kimberly Mathes, The City of New Enforcement of OGB’s $219,480.62 in A Consent Judgment was In house- 15572 (Plaintiff-in- Orleans, Sanitation Department, and subrogation and/or issued medical issued on December 13, 2011, Angela McCulloch intervention) Progressive Security Insurance reimbursement rights against benefits. ordering judgment in favor of Marjorie O’Connor Department, Chubb Insurance Jane Sumner plaintiff, Jane Sumner, and Company, and Vigilant Insurance against the City of New Company Orleans for the sum of $900,000.00, together with judicial interest beginning one year from the date of this judgment, until paid; and ordering judgment in favor of OGB for the amount of $88,000.00 to be paid by plaintiff out of the proceeds paid by the City of New Orleans. Since the Consent Judgment is set to prescribe on December 13, 2021, a motion to revive the judgment will be filed in the near future. 2010-3845 CDC U.S. Bank Seander Wright Johnson Intervention and establishment Recovery of Judicial sale on hold GOHSEP Legal National of claim in judicial sale $7,500.00 owed Association back to State - (DOA HMGP Intervenor) 2014- CDC Roubion Irma Dorsey Intervention and establishment Recovery of Dorsey has filed for removal GOHSEP Legal 02919 Construction of claim in judicial sale $80,000.00 owed from state court to federal Co., LLC back to State - court; Awaiting ruling (DOA HMGP Intervenor) 122,455 17th HSBC Bank John Clark and Tracy Brock Intervention and establishment Recovery of Applicants’ names submitted GOHSEP Legal JDC USA of claim in judicial sale $23,400.00 owed to DHS-OIG for investigation (DOA back to State - Intervenor) HMGP 4 15-2454 CDC Deutsche Alfredo Apolinar and Betty Intervention and establishment Recovery of Judicial sale scheduled for GOHSEP Legal Bank Apolinar of claim in judicial sale $50,000.00 owed June 18, 2015 but was stopped National back to State - Trust Co. HMGP (DOA Intervenor) 2015-2821 DOA- Melissa H. Neill State intervened in case in Declaratory and Counsel are in negotiation of a GOHSEP Legal Div. F CDC HMGP which plaintiff alleges Injunctive relief on settlement (intervenor) defendant/homeowner owes Melissa H. Neill more money than actually collecting on the owed $95K prom. note 749-049 24th DOA – Bridges Builders Construction, State intervened after surety Declaratory Parties attempted resolution to GOHSEP Legal Div. I JDC HMGP Companion Property and Casualty refused to comply with its judgment and no avail as of current (intervenor) Insurance, and Gemini Insurance contractual obligations Recovery of $80,000 for advanced payment to Bridges Builders on 7/8/14 80149 29th DOA- Bernice Cornish Recoupment of HMGP funds. $7,500.00 Answer Filed GOHSEP Legal JDC HMGP GOHSEP 2015- 22nd DOA- Betty Clark Recoupment of HMGP funds. $48,269.50 Mot Prelim Def. filed 9/23/15. GOHSEP Legal 13024 JDC HMGP GOHSEP Default judgment pending. 2015- CDC DOA- Cheryl Garrison Recoupment of HMGP funds. $73,259.89 Ext. filed 09/21/2016 GOHSEP Legal 07926 HMGP She has the Road Home GOHSEP information and we are trying to meet with her to clarify debt owed. 175061 32nd DOA- Dan Livingston Recoupment of HMGP funds. $27,578.40 Lawsuit Filed. GOHSEP Legal JDC HMGP Defendant deceased. GOHSEP No succession filed. 150721 34th DOA- Dana White Recoupment of HMGP funds. $7,205.53 Lawsuit Filed. GOHSEP Legal JDC HMGP GOHSEP Default judgment pending. 2015- CDC DOA- Deidre Gaines Recoupment of HMGP funds. $7,500.00 Lawsuit Filed GOHSEP Legal 07946 HMGP GOHSEP 5 2015- 22nd DOA- Denise Hall Recoupment of HMGP funds. $44,121.25 Lawsuit Filed. GOHSEP Legal 13031 JDC HMGP GOHSEP Default judgment pending. 150724 34th DOA- Donnatte Maurice Recoupment of HMGP funds. $6,511.00 Motion for Prelim Def. filed GOHSEP Legal JDC HMGP 10/30/15. GOHSEP Default judgment pending. 2015- 22nd DOA- Ellisha Powell Recoupment of HMGP funds. $16,894.50 Answer Filed GOHSEP Legal 13154 JDC HMGP Matter has been continued GOHSEP 150730 34th DOA- Eloise Jackson Recoupment of HMGP funds. $6,834.48 Motion for Prelim Def. filed GOHSEP Legal JDC HMGP 10/30/15. GOHSEP Default judgment pending. 2015- 22nd DOA- Felicia Barnes Recoupment of HMGP funds. $7,500.00 Lawsuit Filed. GOHSEP Legal 13029 JDC HMGP GOHSEP Default judgment pending. 2015- 22nd DOA- Jacob Thonn Recoupment of HMGP funds. $7,500.00 Mot Prelim Def. filed 9/23/15. GOHSEP Legal 13032 JDC HMGP GOHSEP Default judgment pending. 2015-7382 CDC DOA- James Anderson Recoupment of HMGP funds. $7,397.78 P.D. against J. Anderson filed GOHSEP Legal HMGP 11/4/2015 GOHSEP 2015- 22nd DOA- Karl Stiegman Recoupment of HMGP funds. $7,500.00 Lawsuit Filed (Amended GOHSEP Legal 12950 JDC HMGP petition filed on 11/30 to GOHSEP include estate of deceased app) 2015- CDC DOA- Kenneth Jackson Recoupment of HMGP funds. $7,471.21 P.D. filed 11/4/2015 GOHSEP Legal 08355 HMGP GOHSEP 2015- CDC DOA- Kenneth Warron Recoupment of HMGP funds. $80,000.00 Answer Filed GOHSEP Legal 08330 HMGP GOHSEP Matter has been continued 80151 29th DOA- Kissy Jackson Recoupment of HMGP funds.