Cooperation Or Competition?
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Exploring the Universe: Cooperation or Competition? European Forum Alpbach 2013 Shuang-Nan Zhang Director, Center for Particle Astrophysics Institute of High Energy Physics Chief Scientist, Space Science Division National Astronomical Observatories Chinese Academy of Sciences 1 Day 1 2 Ways of learning Write down one thing you think you are good at doing Write down how you learnt of doing this Choose and write down one of these answers: (1) From lecturing in classroom (2) By yourself: reading, asking, discussion, practicing (3) Other 3 Importance of asking and discussion The greatest scholar and teacher in Chinese history, Confucius (孔夫子), told us: “Among every three people, there must be someone who know more than me (三人一 行,必有我师)” The Nobel Laureate C.N. Yang (杨振宁) once said “Most of my knowledge comes from asking and discussing with my fellow students”. In Chinese, an intellectual is called “a person learning by asking (有学问的人)” 4 Nobel Laureate C.N. Yang (杨振宁) and me C.N. Yang is the “person learning by asking (有学问的人)” 5 Albert Einstein (爱因斯坦) and me I am the “person learning by asking (有学问的人)” 6 Traditional and interactive teaching Traditional teaching: one directional delivery of information from the teacher to students (notebooks) Role of teacher: information delivery Success measured by rate of information delivered Interactive teaching: asking + discussion Role of teacher: stimulate and moderate the process Success measured by rate of information received Just like communications: it only matters how much is received at the receiver’s end! Barriers must be removed for efficient communications. 7 Interruptions are invited during these seminars You are invited to interrupt me during at any time Asking questions, making points and comments, and even challenging me. Any language is allowed, though I only understand Chinese and English. Of course I will ask you many questions! Please watch out for each and every “?” in my presentations. 8 Day 2 9 10 Explorations vs. Observations Explorations: Be there, do there, and return from there In site, microscope, robotic, human participation Direct knowledge, but limited scope and range Observations: Learn what’s going on elsewhere in the universe, but at or near home Remote, telescope, automatic A lot of guess work, but vast scope and range 11 We all love tourism! 12 But why tourism? Much more beautiful pictures and exhaustive information available on the internet But why do we still want to spend a lot of money, time, energy, and face various risks to go these places, and take photos? Be there, do there, and even showing-off Delicious foods, exotic cultures, different laws, beautiful girls and boys… 13 Power of being there or close-by What can be done only when being there? Collecting, digging, interacting, taking photos with a human in it, and even risking lives… What can be done better when close-by? 2 flux = emitted/4πD D is distance of the source 2 2 received=flux*πR = emitted*(R /2D) R is aperture radius of the telescope/microscope Sometimes easier to get thousands-millions times closer, but hard to make a telescope/microscope thousands-millions times larger! 14 But why (remote) observations? Convenient: telescopes are made at home (earth), so better try them out at home first Cheaper: sending telescopes far away from home is costly Correct: still not possible to send a telescope near a star outside the solar system; never possible beyond the Milky Way 3 C law 15 Why out of earth to observe? 16 Lunar explorations as examples of space explorations http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exploration_of_the_Moon 17 Chang’E: a beautiful girl lives in the palace of moon Princess Kaguya, moon godness of Japan 18 Lunar explorations: again and again, and more and more nations? Cold war? Science? Technology? Military? National pride? Cooperation or competition? 19 1958-1959 space race erupts Year Mission Country Objective Result 1958 Pioneer 0 USA Orbiter Launch failure 1958 Luna E-1 No.1 USSR Impactor Launch failure 1958 Pioneer 1 USA Orbiter Launch failure 1958 Luna E-1 No.2 USSR Impactor Launch failure 1958 Pioneer 2 USA Orbiter Launch failure 1958 Luna E-1 No.3 USSR Impactor Launch failure 1958 Pioneer 3 USA Flyby Launch failure 1959 Luna 1 USSR Impactor Partial success (first successful flyby 5,995 km) 1959 Pioneer 4 USA Flyby Partial success (flyby 60,000 km) 1959 Luna E-1A No.1 USSR Impactor Launch failure USSR Success (first spacecraft reaching the moon surface, impacted east of Mare Serenitatis, discovered time variations 1959 Luna 2 Impactor in the electron flux and energy spectrum in the Van Allen radiation belt) 1959 Pioneer P-1 USA Orbiter Launch failure 1959 Luna 3 USSR Flyby Success (first pictures of Moon far side) 1959 Pioneer P-3 USA Orbiter Launch failure 7/yr, mostly failures, but USSR won anyway 20 1960-1965 space race continues 1960 Luna E-3 No.1, 2 USSR Flyby Launch failure 1960 Pioneer P-30, 31 USA Orbiter Launch failure 1962 Ranger 3, 4, 5 USA Impactor Failure (flyby; crashed at Moon far-side; flyby) 1963 Luna E-6 No.2, 3 USSR Lander Launched into wrong orbit; Launch failure 1963 Luna 4 USSR Lander Failure (flyby) 1964 Ranger 6 USA Impactor Failure (TV camera, only instrument, did not work) 1964 Luna E-6 No.5, 6 USSR Lander Launch failure 1964 Ranger 7 USA Impactor Success 1965 Ranger 8 USA Impactor Success 1965 Cosmos 60 USSR Lander Failed to leave Earth orbit 1965 Ranger 9 USA Impactor Success 1965 Luna E-6 No.8 USSR Lander Launch failure 1965 Luna 5, 6 USSR Lander Failure (crashed at Sea of Clouds; flyby) 1965 Zond 3 USSR Flyby Success 1965 Luna 7, 8 USSR Lander Failure (crashed at Oceanus Procellarum) 3.8/year, still mostly failures, but USA faired better 21 1966-1967 space race speeds up USSR Success (first pictures from Moon surface, landed 1966 Luna 9 Lander at Oceanus Procellarum) 1966 Cosmos 111 USSR Orbiter Launched into wrong orbit 1966 Luna 10 USSR Orbiter Success (first lunar orbiter) 1966 Surveyor 1 USA Lander Success (landed at Oceanus Procellarum) 1966 Lunar Orbiter 1 USA Orbiter Success 1966 Luna 11 USSR Orbiter Success 1966 Surveyor 2 USA Lander Failure (crashed near Copernicus crater) 1966 Luna 12 USSR Orbiter Success 1966 Lunar Orbiter 2 USA Orbiter Success 1966 Luna 13 USSR Lander Success (landed at Oceanus Procellarum) 1967 Lunar Orbiter 3 USA Orbiter Partial success (picture acquisition cut short) 1967 Surveyor 3 USA Lander Success 1967 Lunar Orbiter 4 USA Orbiter Partial success (picture acquisition cut short) 1967 Surveyor 4 USA Lander Failure 1967 Lunar Orbiter 5 USA Orbiter Success 1967 Surveyor 5, 6 USA Lander Success 8.5/year, mostly successes, USA began to lead 22 1968-1969 space race heats up: Apollo Program 1968 Surveyor 7 USA Lander Success 1968 Luna E-6LS No.112 USSR Lander Launch failure 1968 Luna 14 USSR Orbiter Success USSR Success (first spacecraft and living beings to 1968 Zond 5, 6 Flyby return to Earth from lunar flyby); Partial success 1968 Apollo 8 USA Orbiter Success (first manned lunar orbiter) 1969 Luna E-8 No.201 USSR Rover Launch failure 1969 Apollo 10 USA Orbiter Success (lander test in Moon orbit) 1969 Luna E-8-5 No.402 USSR Sample return Launch failure 1969 Luna 15 USSR Sample return Failure (crashed at Mare Crisium) 1969 USA Orbiter Success Apollo 11 USA Success (21.5 kg of lunar rocks retrieved, 1969 Sample return first humans on the Moon surface) 1969 Zond 7 USSR Flyby Success 1969 Cosmos 300, 305 USSR Sample return Launched into wrong orbit 1969 USA Orbiter Success Apollo 12 1969 USA Sample return Success 8.5/year, mostly successes, USA won: Armstrong on the moon! 23 1970-1971 space race continues 1970 Apollo 13 USA Sample return Failure (flyby, crew returned to Earth) 1970 S-IV USA Impactor Success 1970 Luna E-8-5 No.405 USSR Sample return Launch failure 1970 Luna 16 USSR Sample return Success (first robotic lunar sample return, 101 g) 1970 Zond 8 USSR Flyby Success 1970 Luna 17 USSR Lander Success (soft-landed the Lunokhod 1) 1970 Lunokhod 1 USSR Rover Success (First lunar rover, travelled 10,54 km) 1971 USA Orbiter Success Apollo 14 1971 USA Sample return Success 1971 USA Orbiter Success Apollo 15 1971 USA Sample return Success (first manned Lunar Roving Vehicle) USA Success (measured plasma, energetic particle 1971 PFS-1 Orbiter intensities and lunar magnetic fields) 1971 Luna 18 USSR Sample return Failure 1971 Luna 19 USSR Orbiter Success 7/year, mostly successes, USA continued to lead. 24 1972-1976 space race ends! USSR Sample 1972 Luna 20 Success return 1972 USA Orbiter Success Apollo 16 USA Sample 1972 Success return 1972 PFS-2 USA Orbiter Partial success (orbit decayed earlier than anticipated) 1972 USA Orbiter Success Apollo 17 USA Sample 1972 Success (first geologist on the Moon) return 1973 Luna 21 USSR Lander Success (soft-landed the Lunokhod 2) 1973 Lunokhod 2 USSR Rover Success (longest rover journey on a celestial body, 37 km) 1974 Luna 22 USSR Orbiter Success USSR Sample 1974 Luna 23 Partial success (sample drilling failed) return USSR Sample 1976 Luna 24 Success return USA finished Apollo program with a clear victory; USSR ended its lunar program in 1976, coincided with the death of Mao that ended culture revolution in China. 25 1990-2011 new lunar exploration: global space race? 1990 Hiten Japan Orbiter first aerobraking maneuver by a deep space probe) 1994 Clementine USA Orbiter 1998 Lunar Prospector USA Orbiter 2003 SMART-1 Europe Orbiter first use of an ion engine to reach the Moon 2007 SELENE (Kaguya) Japan Orbiter 2007 Chang'e 1 China