Arxiv:1701.07063V2 [Physics.Ins-Det] 23 Mar 2017 ACCEPTED by IEEE TRANSACTIONS on PLASMA SCIENCE, MARCH 2017 1

Home , Homopolar generator, Pulsed power, Railgun

This work has been accepted for publication by IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science. The published version of the paper will be available online at http://ieeexplore.ieee.org. It can be accessed by using the following Digital Object Identiﬁer: 10.1109/TPS.2017.2686648.

c 2017 IEEE. Personal use of this material is permitted. Permission from IEEE must be obtained for all other uses, including reprinting/republishing this material for advertising or promotional purposes, collecting new collected works for resale or redistribution to servers or lists, or reuse of any copyrighted component of this work in other works. arXiv:1701.07063v2 [physics.ins-det] 23 Mar 2017 ACCEPTED BY IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON PLASMA SCIENCE, MARCH 2017 1

Review of Inductive Pulsed Power Generators for Railguns Oliver Liebfried

Abstract—This literature review addresses inductive pulsed the inductor. Therefore, a coil can be regarded as a pressure power generators and their major components. Different induc- vessel with the magnetic field B as a pressurized medium. tive storage designs like solenoids, toroids and force-balanced The corresponding pressure p is related by p = 1 B2 to the coils are briefly presented and their advantages and disadvan- 2µ tages are mentioned. Special emphasis is given to inductive circuit magnetic field B with the permeability µ. The energy density topologies which have been investigated in railgun research such of the inductor is directly linked to the magnetic field and as the XRAM, meat grinder or pulse transformer topologies. One therefore, its maximum depends on the tensile strength of the section deals with opening switches as they are indispensable for windings and the mechanical support. The upper limit for the inductive storages and another one deals briefly with SMES for energy density W/V follows from the virial theorem and can pulsed power applications. In the end, the most relevant inductor systems which were realized in respect to railgun research are be expressed by summarized in a table, together with its main characteristics. W/V = λσ (1) Index Terms—Railgun, Pulsed power, review. where σ is the tensile strength of the coil material and λ is a coefficient related to the structural efficiency of the coil design [1], [2]. λ = 1 is the maximum value which is achievable by I.INTRODUCTION an ideal coil geometry. In the case of long and thin solenoidal NDUCTIVE storages are used in pulsed power generators 1 coils or toroidal coils, λ gets close to 3 [3], [4]. In practice, I for railguns for several reasons. In combination with a the best value for λ can be achieved with short solenoidal coils homopolar generator (HPG) or a battery, inductors are used 1 like the Brooks coil, where λ can be as high as 2 [1], [4]. to generate the high voltage which is needed to inject current In superconducting coils, the mechanical stress is the major into a railgun at high armature velocities. They are used in limitation of the energy density. In normal conducting coils, capacitor banks to limit the maximum current amplitude and other limitations like resistive losses or heat dissipation might adjust the pulse length to the requirements of the railgun. be more critical than the mechanical stress. Furthermore, they decouple several capacitor modules from each other and allow time-delayed switching and therefore III.COILDESIGN pulse shaping. However, inductor research was not very evi- The optimization of normal conducting coils with respect dent within the electromagnetic launch community in the past to the energy density and L/R is usually performed by as inductors were mostly part of HPG, capacitor bank, or optimizing the inductance per given piece of wire (GPW) [5]. battery system development. Thus, there is no comprehensive The coil with the best inductance per GPW is known as the reference work about inductive storage systems for pulsed Brooks coil (see Fig. 1a) which is a solenoidal coil where the power generation. This paper aims at filling the gap as induc- inner radius corresponds to half the outer radius and is equal tive pulsed power systems are becoming more relevant due to to the height of the coil [5], [6]. Additionally, the number of emerging technologies like Li-ion batteries, supercapacitors, windings in the radial and axial directions is the same. and superconductors. A significant drawback of solenoids is that very high fringe fields appear in the vicinity of the coil. A safety distance II.INDUCTIVESTORAGE between the coil and the operator or sensitive electronics is Charged inductors can be seen as current sources which necessary in most cases if magnetic shielding is not applied can create any voltage, assuming a corresponding insulation. [7]. But even then, a certain distance between the coil and Thus, inductors represent an ideal power source for railguns. the shielding has to be kept in order not to saturate the In an inductive storage, energy is stored by its magnetic field. shielding material [8]. Placing several solenoids in a concentric The interaction between the magnetic field and the current or hexagonal arrangement (see Fig. 1c & 1b) can help to in the windings creates Lorentz forces on the windings of reduce fringe fields [9], [10]. An alternative to the solenoidal coil is the toroidal coil. Manuscript received Jan. 15, 2017; accepted Mar. 20, 2017. Date of current Here, the magnetic field is encased in the windings of the version Mar. 21, 2017. O. Liebfried is with the French-German Research Institute of Saint- coil and, therefore, a fringe field, ideally, does not exist. In Louis (ISL), 5 rue Gen´ eral´ Cassagnou, 68301 Saint-Louis, France, e-mail: actual fact, a fringe field cannot be completely avoided but [email protected]. a toroid made of five or more solenoids has a fringe field The published version of the paper will be available online at http://ieeexplore.ieee.org. at least ten times smaller than a solenoidal coil [11]. Thus, Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TPS.2017.2686648 shielding or a safety distance might not be necessary. On the c 2017 IEEE a a

(a) Brooks coil (cutted view) (b) Concentric (c) Hexagonal solenoids (d) D-shape toroid (e) Force-balanced coil solenoids Fig. 1. Different coil geometries and arrangements other hand, the encapsulation of the magnetic field is attained off currents in the kA range, arrays of such switches are at the expense of the energy density. The inductance per GPW still necessary, which is expensive, heavy and bulky [28]. of a solenoidal filament coil is, for example, 2.6 times higher Wide bandgap semiconductor switches based on materials than that of a toroidal filament coil with a circular turn window like SiC, GaN or diamond promise better electrical properties and a totally filled coil center (toroidal counterpart of a Brooks but the state of the art is still far from required values. An coil) [5]. The inductance of toroids can be further increased by applicable technique in an inductive pulsed power generator choosing the so-called Shafranov D- or Princeton D-shape for is the introduction of an inverse current to a thyristor, allowing the windings (see Fig. 1d) [5], [12], [13]. The D-shape is not the switch to turn-off safely at a low or zero current. Efforts only the optimum shape with respect to the energy density at ISL in this direction resulted in the development of the so- but also an optimum with respect to the mechanical stress called ICCOS switch which utilizes power thyristors in this distribution. respect [29], [30]. Such switch is avoiding the generation of Recent optimizations with respect to the mechanical stresses high commutation voltages by applying the inverse current performed in superconducting coils have led to the devel- also to parasitic circuit inductances. A design study for a opment of the force-balanced coil (see Fig. 1e). It is a 1 MJ inductive generator clearly showed the advantages of this combination of a solenoidal coil with a toroidal one realized by switch compared to other semiconductor switches [28] with adapting an optimized pitch angle to the helical windings of a respect to size, weight and costs. Researchers at Netherlands toroidal coil [2]. It offers a good compromise between storage Organisation for Applied Scientific Research - Pulse Physics efficiency and electromagnetic compatibility. A drawback is Laboratory (TNO) built and tested such kind of opening switch that producing it is very complex. for currents up to 300 kA for their HPG system [31].

IV. OPENING SWITCHES V. PULSEGENERATIONCIRCUITSUSEDFORRAILGUNS In order to transfer the energy from an inductive storage inductor to a load, an opening switch is necessary which A. Single coil interrupts the charging circuit and commutates the current to the load. During the commutation process, a voltage V Single coil setups have been built in combination with depending on the self-inductance L of the circuit and the load HPGs [32], [33] or huge battery banks [18], [34], [35]. They current I is generated equally at the load and the opening are needed for the generation of high voltages, as HPGs dI and batteries are usually operated at a few hundred volts. switch according to V = L dt . This voltage generation is desired when batteries or HPGs are used which are generally Inductances are also widely used in capacitive pulsed-power low voltage sources. But the same voltage is applied to the generators [36], [37]. But in this case, the aim is to achieve opening switch and in case of large railguns, the so called pulse shaping in order to generate the required pulse length speed-voltage can easily amount to several kilovolts [14, p. 8]. and to limit the maximum current. In contrast to other prime Therefore, opening switches for high current applications are energy sources, opening switches are not required. challenging and were often avoided by preferring capacitor Fig. 2 displays a circuit diagram which shows how a railgun based solutions with closing switches. can be supplied by a single coil. First, the inductor Lstore is Three kinds of opening switches are basically available: charged by the voltage source V0. After charging, the current mechanical switches, fuses, turn-off controlled semiconducting is commutated to the railgun by opening switch So and closing switches and hybrids of all of them [15]–[17]. For inductively switch Sc at the same time. powered railgun systems, heavy duty contactors [18], explo- In single coil setups, the amplitude of the load current sively driven switches [19]–[21] and counter-current switch- directly correlates with the maximum current with which the off techniques [22]–[25] were used. Today, considerations inductance is charged. Current amplifying circuit topologies go toward semiconducting switches like GTOs or IGBTs could be a better option, as they need a less powerful current which are now capable to operate for short time in the MW source and opening switch. The following three basic circuit range [26], [27]. The recent availability of such improved topologies are repeatedly suggested in the ﬁeld of railgun components facilitates system designs, but in order to switch applications.

ycrnul.Ahge mlfiaini osbewt more with possible is amplification higher A synchronously. yapemtclydie pnn wth ihramplifica- Higher switch. opening driven pneumatically a by

orecreti mlﬁdb fe wthn l switches all switching after 2 by amplyﬁed is current source h rnfrt h odadplecmrsini initiated is compression pulse and load the to transfer The

h u fteidvda nutrcret.I i.5 the 5, Fig. In currents. inductor individual the of sum the hnapie ytetasomrwt idn ai f20:1. of ratio winding a with transformer the by ampliﬁed then

icag nprle,pouiga uptcretwihis which current output an producing parallel, in discharge us rnfre ihamxmmcreto 0k hc is which kA 70 of current maximum a with transformer pulse

wthdb orsodn pnn n lsn wthsto switches closing and opening corresponding by switched oua 4M obelyrcpctrbn sspliga supplying is bank capacitor layer double MJ 14 modular

urn ore(atr,rttn ahns rohr)are others) or machines, rotating (battery, source current a EILbfrtespl fabuhrign[5.Hr,a Here, [45]. railgun brush a of supply the for Lab GEDI

nteXA ici,idcoseegzdi eisfrom series in energized inductors circuit, XRAM the In nti ytm nte ytmwsvr eetybita the at built recently very was system Another system. this in

ihatrsrtoo :.Plecmrsini o applied not is compression Pulse 5:1. of ratio turns a with .XA generator XRAM D.

ai ftetasomri tmxmm2:,bti soperated is it but 20:1, maximum at is transformer the of ratio

eie aiu urn f10k 3] 3] h turns The [39]. [38], kA 100 of current maximum a deliver

niaiggoigefforts. growing indicating

0 Jcpctv us omn ewr PN hc can which (PFN) network forming pulse capacitive kJ 500

u h nraignme fppr n novdpronlis personnel involved and papers of number increasing the but

opie us rnfre hc a once oa to connected was which transformer pulse a comprised

tteIL[6–6] oto hi oki tl conceptual still is work their of Most [56]–[60]. ISL the at

ea ehUiest TU.Terrignfclt HERA facility railgun Their (TTU). University Tech Texas

TEC etgidrwt h CO wtha developed as switch ICCOS the with grinder meat STRETCH

oe upyfrarignsse a rtrpre ythe by reported ﬁrst was system railgun a for supply power

eitv um od .Y ta.aeivsiaigthe investigating are al. et Yu X. load. dummy resistive a

eerpre.Nntees h s fapletasomras transformer pulse a of use the Nonetheless, reported. were

hyapie hrigcreto 0 o42 Aat kA 4.29 to A 100 of current charging a ampliﬁed They

eprtr nrae mlﬁainfcoso oeta 20 than more of factors Ampliﬁcation increase. temperature

rne ihasprodcigci n GT 5] [55]. [54], IGBTs and coil superconducting a with grinder

ecnutrit h omlcnutn tt ya intended an by state normal-conducting the into perconductor

o2 Awr ulse.Rcnl,W ta.raie meat a realized al. et Wu Recently, published. were kA 21 to

h rmr idnswsrpdyrdcdb ocn h su- the forcing by reduced rapidly was windings primary the

xeietlrslswt urn mlﬁainfo kA 2 from ampliﬁcation current a with results experimental

iutnolya pnn wths[2–4] h urn in current The [42]–[44]. switches opening as simultaneoulsy

f12k ol eahee 5] 5]btol preliminary only but [53] [52], achieved be could kA 172 of

uecnutn ol spiaytasomrwnig and windings transformer primary as coils superconducting

0k fidcieysoe nry notu urn amplitude current output an energy, stored inductively of kJ 30

ihrsett us rnfre,svrlrsace applied researcher several transformer, pulse to respect With

spiayeeg ore[1,[2.I a lie htwith that claimed was It [52]. [51], source energy primary as

urn ntela ici uigcharging. during circuit load the in current

eto rosci,GO soeigsice n batteries and switches opening as GTOs coil, Brooks section

c switch once otescnaywnig lcsthe blocks windings secondary the to connected S

orsodn eosrtrwihwsraie yamulti- a by realized was which demonstrator corresponding

h eodr idnsb antcculn.A additional An coupling. magnetic by windings secondary the

5] hyrpre ucsflrigneprmnswt a with experiments railgun successful reported They [50].

rmr idnsrpdy hsgnrtn ihcretin current high a generating thus rapidly, windings primary

trg aaio n aldi h TEC etgrinder meat STRETCH the it called and capacitor storage

o sn noeigswitch opening an using odces h urn nthe in current the decrease to S

er ae,Stmne l mrvdtecnetb diga adding by concept the improved al. et Sitzman later, years

ssoni i.3 us opeso a eahee by achieved be can compression Pulse 3. Fig. in shown as

stefs pnn wthddntoe ntm.Twenty time. in open not did switch opening fuse the as

sue o hrigtepiaywnig ftetransformer the of windings primary the charging for used is

odce u i o ettepeitdcretampliﬁcation current predicted the meet not did but conducted

4]o yapyn us opeso faD otg source voltage DC a if compression pulse applying by or [41]

nriso pt 2k n urn mltdso 5 Awere kA 150 of amplitudes current and kJ 42 to up of energies

aaiosit h rmr idnso h rnfre [38]– transformer the of windings primary the into capacitors

sla yLnnre l 4] xeiet ihprimary with Experiments [49]. al. et Lindner by load as

te.Ple o aluscnb eeae ydischarging by generated be can railguns for Pulses other.

igese etgidrwstse iha1mln railgun m-long 1 a with tested was grinder meat step single

rnfrainrto fcretadvlaeaeivr oeach to invers are voltage and current of ratios transformation

oe orefrmr hn3 er.I hsrset a respect, this In years. 30 than more for source power

rnfre tefi o oe mlﬁao eas the because ampliﬁcator power a not is itself transformer a

h etgidrhsbe ne osdrto srailgun as consideration under been has grinder meat The

hycnas eue o urn mlﬁain u oethat note But ampliﬁcation. current for used be also can they

en insulated. being

1 2 ), ( 1 than less is windings primary and secondary 1 < /N N

n eodr idnsaeglaial once nta of instead connected galvanically are windings secondary and

o otg mlﬁain u ftetrsrtobtenthe between ratio turns the if but ampliﬁcation, voltage for

ese saseiltp fpletasomrweeprimary where transformer pulse of type special a as seen be

e ewe w ope ol.Tasomr r sal used usually are Transformers coils. coupled two between fer

nrae rdcesd[7,[8.I at h etgidrcan grinder meat the fact, In [48]. [47], decreased or increased

us rnfresaebsdo h antceeg trans- energy magnetic the on based are transformers Pulse

ol ymgei edculn.Tu h odcretcnbe can current load the Thus coupling. ﬁeld magnetic by coils

.Pletransformer Pulse B. nryo h icnetdci staserdt h remaining the to transferred is coil disconnected the of energy

3 lssads n.Drn ahsicigpoes the process, switching each During on). so and closes S

2 r wthdlkws nsbeun tp ( steps subsequent in likewise switched are pn when opens S

i.3 ipye us rnfre circuit transformer pulse Simplyﬁed 3. Fig.

scoe iutnol.Tesice ftefloigstages following the of switches The simultaneosly. closed is

2 1 etdt h od nteﬁs step, ﬁrst the In load. the to nected soee and opened is S S

ol rmtecrututloeci slf hc scon- is which left is coil one until circuit the from coils

Railgun

pnn wthsaeue osbeunl icnetthe disconnect subsequently to used are switches Opening

+ V

hre nsre yacmo urn ore(e i.4). Fig. (see source current common a by series in charged −

ntema rne ocp,svrlculdcisare coils coupled several concept, grinder meat the In o S

.Ma Grinder Meat C.

c S

2 kA. 120

i.2 ipye ici o igeci usdpwrgenerator power pulsed coil single a for circuit Simplyﬁed 2. Fig.

htsvrlsae a mlf urn f50At oethan more to A 500 of current a amplify can stages several that

ml cl xeietadsmlto eut,i a estimated was it results, simulation and experiment scale small

load

I charge I

urn f10Awsapie o47k 4] ae nthis on Based [41]. kA 4.7 to ampliﬁed was A 100 of current Railgun

wthswr sd igesaeeprmnsso htaseed a that show experiments stage Single used. were switches

0 store L

+ V

rnfre ihsprodcigpiaywnig n IGBT and windings primary superconducting with transformer −

icisi nXA-ietplg sdn n[6.Hr a Here [46]. in done as topology XRAM-like an in circuits o S infcoscnb xetdb obnn us transformer pulse combining by expected be can factors tion

neetooiepafr,oecnepc hta energy an that expect can one platform, electromobile an nraeteci oueadms.Adtoal,tecooling the Additionally, mass. and volume coil the increase

h nryeﬁiny fterignsse sisaldon installed is system railgun the If efﬁciency. energy the ohtemcaia upr n h lcrclioainwill isolation electrical the and support mechanical the Both

umnigtediigmgei edadtu improving thus and ﬁeld magnetic driving the augmenting ftecnutrmtra n t ehnclsrnt [71]. strength mechanical its and material conductor the of

h nutv trg a eitgae noterignitself, railgun the into integrated be can storage inductive the h aiu radw otg,teoeaigconditions operating the voltage, breakdown maximum the

o o ttoayapiain.I sepcal neetn when interesting especially is It applications. stationary for not nryadpwro uecnutn oli iie by limited is coil superconducting a of power and energy

hscnb nastwe oiepafrsaecnendbut concerned are platforms mobile when asset an be can This h oln ytmhv ob osdrd h maximum The considered. be to have system cooling the

lentv ocpctr,det hi ihreeg density. energy higher their to due capacitors, to alternative iepros nta feetia oss hra ossof losses thermal losses, electrical of Instead periods. time

eeaosbsdo nutv trg r nattractive an are storage inductive on based Generators ol.I hscs,tecretcudb trdfrvr long very for stored be could current the case, this In coils.

hi osscnb vie yuigsuperconducting using by avoided be can losses Ohmic lcrmgei launch. electromagnetic

nutv eeaoswihwr eeoe ihrsetto respect with developed were which generators inductive

I S VI. PRODCIGMGEI NRYSTORAGE ENERGY MAGNETIC UPERCONDUCTING

rpris al umrzssm ftems considerable most the of some summerizes I Table properties.

euigtesrs noeigsice ycretamplifying current by switches opening on stress the reducing

RMgn[2,[0,[73]. [70], [62], XRAM-gun

etgidro RMtplge r osbemasof means possible are topologies XRAM or grinder meat

oehrwt nagetdrign hnas nw as known also then railgun, augmented an with together

alu ytm.Svrlidciecruttplge iethe like topologies circuit inductive Several systems. railgun

osprodcigcis[] 7] 7] ti lopromising also is It [72]. [71], [9], coils superconducting to

etda neeg n oe hc srqie o large for required is which power and energy an at tested

7] h RMcnetwsaraypoe ob applicable be to proven already was concept XRAM The [70].

eiodcigsice ilb osbebtwr o yet not were but possible be will switches semiconducting

r ne netgto nJpn hn n rne[6,[68]– [56], France and China Japan, in investigation under are

eetdvlpet hwta pnn wthsbsdon based switches opening that show developments Recent

SI(e a.I.Crety RMgnrtr o railguns for generators XRAM Currently, I). Tab. (see ESRI

n wthsfrcret nterneo megaamperes. of range the in currents for switches ing

6] n nXA ytmwt 0M nutv trg at storage inductive MJ 20 a with system XRAM an and [67],

hleg eadn nutv trgsaesilteopen- the still are storages inductive regarding challenge A

ytmwti h -a etfclt AKLa TRINITI at BAIKAL facility test X-ray the within system

industry.

idwr ul nrsi o te plctos 25MJ- 12.5 a applications: other for russia in built were kind

atr ehooydet ag neetfo h automotive the from interest large a to due technology battery

alus[] 6][6.Hwvr h ags eie fsuch of devices largest the However, [62]–[66]. [9], railguns

oadbteisa hr r ueavne nteﬁl of ﬁeld the in advances huge are there as batteries toward

oooywsivsiae eea ie sapwrsuc for source power a as times several investigated was topology

r vial pin nti epc.Telts eerhtends research latest The respect. this in options available are

ihcret.Frtpooe yKc n16 6] this [61], 1967 in Koch by proposed First currents. high

osdrd lwel,bteisaddul-ae capacitors double-layer and batteries Flywheels, considered.

onepr oteMr eeao n t oli ogenerate to is goal its and generator Marx the to counterpart

urn oteci,tecmlt ytmcmateshst be to has compactness system complete the coil, the to current

h emXA niae httegnrtri h inductive the is generator the that indicates XRAM term the

ihapiayeeg trg hc a eie high a deliver can which storage energy primary a with

aallt eeaehg otgs yrvrigteletters, the reversing By voltages. high generate to parallel

u escmatta yhes ste edt eoperated be to need they As ﬂywheels. than compact less but

hr aaiosaecagdi eisaddshre in discharged and series in charged are capacitors where

Cs.Te r hoeial oecmatta capacitors than compact more theoretically are They FCGs).

eeao rgntsfo h elkonMr generator Marx well-known the from originates generator

atre)adi te ae o us hpn (capacitors, shaping pulse for cases other in and batteries)

h xes fmr ope wthn.Tetr XRAM term The switching. complex more of expense the

oe eeaos nsm ae o otg eeain(HPGs, generation voltage for cases some in generators, power

utpirtcnqesmlﬁstepiaypwrdsg at design power primary the simpliﬁes technique multiplier

nutv trg ytm r ple onal l pulsed all nearly to applied are systems storage Inductive

hn2sae.I iheeg usdpwrsses this systems, pulsed-power high-energy In stages. 2 than

I.C VII. ONCLUSION

i.5 ceai o nXA eeao ih2stages 2 with generator XRAM an for Schematic 5. Fig.

olple oe eeao speetdi 7] [77]. [76], in presented is generator power pulsed coil

ocpinldsg o ihtmeauesuperconducting temperature high a for design conceptional

etn tqec nproe[2,[4,[5.A2 J1MA MJ/1 20 A [75]. [44], [42], purpose on quench it letting

12 c

tg 2 Stage

hmapidtesprodco tefa pnn wthby switch opening as itself superconductor the applied them

nsalsaedmntaos[1,[3,[4,[0.Sm of Some [70]. [54], [43], [41], demonstrators scale small in

oee,svrlrsacesapidsprodcigcoils superconducting applied researchers several However,

Railgun

oeaporaei iheeg est sdesired. is density energy high a if appropriate more

21 c 0 2 o S S V rmr.Teeoe omlcnutn olsespresently seems coil conducting normal a Therefore, more. or +

con,tevlm a aiyb utpidb atro two of factor a by multiplied be easily can volume the account, −

esl aumpmsadcoigeupetaetkninto taken are equipment cooling and pumps vacuum vessel,

22 c

tg 1 Stage

etmtdfo 7].We h orsodn vacuum corresponding the When [74]). from (estimated m 2

1 L

ytm nteodro J1M aeavlm exceeding volume a have MW MJ/1 1 of order the in systems

h elzdsprodcigmgei nrysoae(SMES) storage energy magnetic superconducting realized the

o ihpwrapiain r tl eybly Nowadays, bulky. very still are applications high-power for

ytmhst ecnierd hrfr,sprodcigcoils superconducting Therefore, considerred. be to has system 11 c 1 o S S

i.4 ai etgidrcircuit grinder meat Basic 4. Fig.

Railgun

0 3 2 n S S V S +

− 1 S

3 2 1 n L L L L TABLE I EXAMPLESOFREALIZEDPULSEDPOWERGENERATORSAPPLYINGINDUCTIVESTORAGES Feeding Inductively Max. load power supply Switches stored energy Load current Size Operator Year Ref. Single coil topology Battery Fuse 1.5 MJ Resistor 28.5 kA 0.4 m3 ELR, UK 1985 [1] HPG N/A 3.1 MJ Railgun 1000 kA 1 m3 a CEM-UT, USA 1985 [78] HPG Exp. switch 10 MJ Railgun 2000 kA 3 m3 a Westinghouse, USA 1986 [33] Capacitors Thyristor/Diodes 40 kJ Railgun 52 kA N/A ISL, FR 1995 [79] Capacitors Ignitrons 0.7 MJ Railgun 250 kA 0.5 m3 IAT, USA 1995 [80] Capacitors Thyristor/Diode 60 kJ n/a 68 kA > 6 dm3 ESRI, RU 2009 [81] Pulse transformer topology Battery SCR/GTO 16 kJ short-circuit 150 kA N/A TNO, NL 1989 [82] PFN Ignitrons/Diode 550 kJ ? Railgun 500 kA 1 m3 TTU/USA 1993 [38], [39] DC supply Quenched SC 500 J N/A 23.3 kA 3 m3 a IGE/CREEBEL, FR 1999 [44] DC supply IGBT/Diode 69 J Resistor 4.26 kA 12 dm3∗ SJU, CN 2012 [41] Meat grinder topology Capacitors Fuse/Varistor 19.1 kJ Railgun 135 kA N/A ECR, USA 1987 [49] 1 3∗ Li-ion batteries GTOs 30 kJ Railgun 172 kA ∼ 8 m IAT, USA 2007 [51]–[53] DC supply IGBT 78 J Resistor 4.29 kA 0.003˜ m3 SJU, CN 2013 [54], [55] XRAM topology HPG Exp. switch 20 MJ N/A 6000 kA 316 m3 ESRI, RU 1977-1992 [83] Generator Exp. switches 12.5 MJ X-ray system 1500 kA N/A TRINITI, RU 2001 [67] Battery GTO/Varistor 25 kJ Resistance 10 kA N/A SNRC, Israel 1993 [65], [84] Capacitors ICCOS 4725 J Cable 60 kA 0.2 m3 ISL, FR 2011 [85] Capacitors ICCOS 200 kJ Railgun 40 kA 0.4 m3 ISL, FR 2013 [69] Capacitors Spark gap/Diode 93 kJ Aug. Railgun 200 kA integrated ISL, FR 2014 [73] Supercaps IGBTs 25 kJ Cable∗ 24 kA < 1 m3 NIFS/JSW, Japan 2014 [68] ? capacitively stored ∗ estimated a just coil ELR - Electromagnetic Launch Research, Inc.; CEM-UT - Center for Electromechanics, The University of Texas at Austin; IAT - Institute of Advanced Tech.; ESRI - Efremov Scientific Research Institute; TNO - Netherlands Organisation for Applied Scientific Research - Pulse Physics Laboratory; TTU - Texas Tech Univ.; IGE - Energy Eng. Institute; CREEBEL - Belfort Research Center in Electrical Eng.; SJU - Southwest Jiaotong Univ.; ECR - Energy Compression Research Corp.; SNRC - Soreq Nuclear Research Center; NIFS - National Institute for Fusion Science; JSW - Japan Steel Works, Ltd. storage system such as a battery or a flywheel is already [24] T. Ding et al., “A 35 kA disc-shaped thyristor DC switch for batteries available. In this case, an inductive pulsed power generator is power supply of flat-top pulsed magnetic field,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Supercond., vol. 22, no. 3, Jun. 2012. the most convenient choice as it does not require an additional [25] B. Fridman et al., “Counter pulse capacitor bank for 70 kA, 10 kV energy converter. The compactness of an inductive pulsed commutation system,” in 19th IEEE Int. Pulsed Power Conf. (PPPS). power generator should be even more pronounced compared Dig. Techn. Pap., Jun. 2013, pp. 1–6. [26] S. Scharnholz et al., “Investigation of IGBT-devices for pulsed power to capacitors if bursts of repetitive discharges are envisaged. applications,” in 14th IEEE Int. Pulsed Power Conf. (PPPS). Dig. Techn. Pap., vol. 1, Dallas, US-TX, Jun. 15-18, 2003, pp. 349–352. [27] A. Sitzman et al., “Operational limits of a commercial gate turn-off REFERENCES thyristor for inductive-store systems,” IEEE Trans. Plasma Sci., vol. 39, no. 1, pp. 316–321, Jan. 2011. [1] L. Gredin, P. Mongeau, and H. Kolm, “Modular storage inductor,” in [28] O. Liebfried, V. Brommer, and S. Scharnholz, “Development of XRAM 5th IEEE Int. Pulsed Power Conf. (PPPS). Dig. Techn. Pap., Arlington, generators as inductive power sources for very high current pulses,” US-VA, 1985, p. 594. in 19th IEEE Int. Pulsed Power Conf. (PPPS). Dig. Techn. Pap., San [2] S. Nomura et al., “Advanced configuration of superconducting magnetic Francisco, US-CA, Jun. 16-21, 2013, pp. 646–651. energy storage,” Energy, vol. 30, no. 1112, pp. 2115 – 2127, 2005. [29] P. Dedie, V. Brommer, and S. Scharnholz, “ICCOS countercurrent- [3] F. C. Moon, “The virial theorem and scaling laws for superconducting thyristor high-power opening switch for currents up to 28 kA,” IEEE magnet systems,” J. Appl. Phys., vol. 53, no. 12, pp. 9112–9121, 1982. Trans. Magn., vol. 45, no. 1, pp. 536 –539, Jan. 2009. [4] Y. Eyssa and R. Boom, “Considerations of a large force balanced [30] V. Brommer and E. Spahn, “XRAM generator with an opening switch,” magnetic energy storage system,” IEEE Trans. Magn., vol. 17, no. 1, US patent US7495357 B2, Saint-Louis, France, Feb. 2009. pp. 460–462, Jan. 1981. [31] E. van Dijk, “Experimental results obtained with the 1 ma resonant series [5] P. N. Murgatroyd, “The optimal form for coreless inductors,” IEEE counterpulse opening switch system, developed at tno,” in 11th IEEE Trans. Magn., vol. 25, no. 3, pp. 2670–2677, 1989. Int. Pulsed Power Conf. (PPPS). Dig. Techn. Pap., vol. 1, June 1997, [6] F. Grover, Inductance Calculations: Working Formulas and Tables, ser. pp. 287–292. Dover phoenix editions. Dover Publications, 1946. [32] J. Gully, S. Pretap, and M. Spann, “Design of a compact inductor [7] C. Polk, R. Boom, and Y. Eyssa, “Superconductive magnetic energy matched to a homopolar generator,” in 4th IEEE Int. Pulsed Power Conf. storage (SMES) external fields and safety considerations,” IEEE Trans. (PPPS). Dig. Techn. Pap., Albuquerque, NM, USA, 1983. Magn., vol. 28, no. 1, pp. 478–481, Jan. 1992. [33] D. Hackworth et al., “A 10 MJ cryogenic inductor,” IEEE Trans. Magn., [8] A. Pokryvailo, I. Ziv, and M. Shapira, “Repetitive inductive storage vol. 22, no. 6, pp. 1495–1498, Nov. 1986. supply for an ETC tank gun,” IEEE Trans. Magn., vol. 39, no. 1, pp. [34] A. Pokryvailo et al., “Design and testing of a 5 MW battery-based 257–261, Jan. 2003. inductive power supply,” IEEE Trans. Plasma Sci., vol. 26, no. 5, pp. [9] W. Weck et al., “Superconducting inductive pulsed power supply for 1444–1453, 1998. electromagnetic launchers: Design aspects and experimental investiga- [35] A. Pokryvailo, “Development of long-charge inductive storage systems tion of laboratory set-up,” IEEE Trans. Magn., vol. 33, no. 1, pp. 524– at Soreq NRC,” in 15th IEEE Int. Pulsed Power Conf. (PPPS). Dig. 527, 1997. Techn. Pap., Monterey, US-CA, 2005, pp. 100–103. [10] G. Schonwetter et al., “Optimization of SMES solenoids with regard to [36] E. Spahn, M. Lichtenberger, and F. Hatterer, “Pulse forming network for their stray fields,” IEEE Trans. Magn., vol. 31, no. 3, pp. 1940–1943, the 10 MJ-railgun PEGASUS,” in Proc. 5th Europ. Symp. Electromagn. May 1995. Launch Techn., Toulouse, France, Apr.10-13 1995. [11] M. Kanter et al., “Factors in inductive storage system design,” in [37] T. Wolfe et al., “Preliminary design of a 200 MJ pulsed power system 10th IEEE Int. Pulsed Power Conf. (PPPS). Dig. Techn. Pap., vol. 1, for a naval railgun proof of concept facility,” in Proc. 12th Symp. Albuquerque, US-NM, Jul. 1995, pp. 186–191. Electromagn. Launch Techn., May 2004, pp. 490–494. [12] V. Shafranov, “Optimum shape of a toroidal solenoid,” Soviet Physics - [38] M. Wofford, M. Baker, and M. Day, “Design, simulation, and testing of Techical Physics (Engl. Transl.), vol. 17, no. 9, pp. 1433–1437, 1973. a pulse forming network- transformer power supply for the Texas Tech [13] P. Birkner, “Toroide mit idealem Feld,” Electrical Engineering (Archiv railgun,” in 8th IEEE Int. Pulsed Power Conf. (PPPS). Dig. Techn. Pap., fur¨ Elektrotechnik), vol. 74, no. 4, pp. 275–287, 1991. San Diego, US-CA, Jun. 1991, pp. 138–140. [14] R. A. Marshall and W. Ying, Railguns: Their science and technology. [39] M. Day, M. Baker, and G. Grant, “HERA railgun facility at Texas Tech 22 Baiwanzhuang Road, Beijing 100037 China: China Machine Press, University,” IEEE Trans. Magn., vol. 29, no. 1, pp. 787–791, Jan. 1993. 2004, iSBN 7-111-14013-3. [40] R. Wu et al., “Design and experimental realization of a new pulsed [15] A. Pokryvailo, V. Maron, and D. Melnik, “Review of opening switches power supply based on the energy transfer between two capacitors and for long-charge fieldable inductive storage systems,” in 12th IEEE Int. an HTS air-core pulsed transformer,” IEEE Trans. Plasma Sci., vol. 41, Pulsed Power Conf. (PPPS). Dig. Techn. Pap., vol. 2, Monterey, US-CA, no. 4, pp. 993–998, Apr. 2013. 1999, pp. 1341–1344. [41] H. Li et al., “Design and testing of a high-temperature superconducting [16] K. H. Schoenbach, M. Kristiansen, and G. Schaefer, “A review of pulsed-power transformer,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Supercond., vol. 22, no. 2, opening switch technology for inductive energy storage,” Proceedings pp. 5 500 205–5 500 205, 2012. of the IEEE, vol. 72, pp. 1019–1040, 1984. [42] M. Hilal and E. Leung, “Energy compression and transfer using hybrid [17] H. Bluhm, Pulsed power systems: Principles and applications, pulse power transformer (HPPT),” in 6th IEEE Int. Pulsed Power Conf. ser. Power systems. Springer, 2006. [Online]. Available: http: (PPPS). Dig. Techn. Pap., Arlington, US-VA, 1987. //books.google.de/books?id=kE1iQgAACAAJ [43] S. Singh et al., “Designs of pulsed power cryogenic transformers,” IEEE [18] J. Sterrett et al., “Design of a battery power supply for the electromag- Trans. Magn., vol. 24, no. 2, pp. 1504–1507, Mar. 1988. netic gun experimental research facility,” in 6th IEEE Int. Pulsed Power [44] E. Floch et al., “Modelization and test of a 500 J superconducting pulsed Conf. (PPPS). Dig. Techn. Pap., vol. 29, Arlington, US-VA, 1987, pp. power transformer,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Supercond., vol. 9, no. 2, pp. 42–45. 1289–1292, Jun. 1999. [19] E. Aivaliotis and M. Peterhans, “Explosive opening switch work at [45] Y. A. Dreizin, D. Rebrov, and A. Recksiedler, “Figure-8 inductive store Westinghouse,” IEEE Trans. Magn., vol. 25, no. 1, pp. 40–45, Jan. 1989. for EM brushgun,” in 20th IEEE Int. Pulsed Power Conf. (PPPS). Dig. [20] D. Peterson et al., “Heavy-duty explosively operated pulsed opening Techn. Pap., Austin, US-TX, May 31 - Jun. 4 2015, pp. 122–125. and closing switches: reducing cost and turnaround time [railgun power [46] H. Li et al., “Inductive pulsed power supply consisting of supercon- supplies],” IEEE Trans. Magn., vol. 27, no. 1, pp. 369–373, Jan. 1991. ducting pulsed power transformers with Marx generator methodology,” [21] R. Klug et al., “Ten megacoulomb switching operation for the air IEEE Trans. Appl. Supercond., vol. 22, no. 5, 2012. force battery powered inductive storage launcher research facility,” IEEE [47] O. Zucker and J. Long, “The Meatgrinder: A reversible inductive storage Trans. Magn., vol. 27, no. 1, pp. 380–383, Jan. 1991. and transfer system,” in 4th IEEE Int. Pulsed Power Conf. (PPPS). Dig. [22] E. Van Dijk and P. Van Gelder, “A resonant series counterpulse technique Techn. Pap., Alberque, US-NM, 1983, pp. 375–379. for high current opening switches,” IEEE Trans. Magn., vol. 31, no. 1, [48] R. Kratz and P. Wyder, Principles of Pulsed Magnet Design, ser. pp. 84–89, Jan. 1995. Engineering Materials and Processes. Springer, 2002. [23] E. Leung, R. Bailey, and P. Michels, “Using a small hybrid pulse power [49] K. Lindner et al., “Enhanced energy transfer to an EM gun,” in 6th IEEE transformer unit as component of a high-current opening switch for a Int. Pulsed Power Conf. (PPPS). Dig. Techn. Pap., Arlington, US-VA, railgun,” IEEE Trans. Magn., vol. 25, no. 2, pp. 1779–1782, Mar. 1989. 1987, pp. 749–752. [50] A. Sitzman, D. Surls, and J. Mallick, “Stretch meat grinder: A novel [73] O. Liebfried and M. Roch, “Augmented railgun with integrated XRAM circuit topology for reducing opening switch voltage stress,” in 15th current multiplication,” in Proc. IEEE Int. Power Modulator and High IEEE Int. Pulsed Power Conf. (PPPS). Dig. Techn. Pap., Monterey, US- Voltage Conf. (IPMHVC), Santa Fe, US-NM, Jun. 1-4, 2014, pp. 279– CA, 2005, pp. 493–496. 282. [51] ——, “Design, construction, and testing of an inductive pulsed-power [74] T. Mito et al., “Summary of a 1 MJ conduction-cooled LTS pulse coil supply for a small railgun,” IEEE Trans. Magn., vol. 43, no. 1, pp. 270 developed for 1 MW, 1 s UPS-SMES,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Supercond., –274, Jan. 2007. vol. 19, no. 3, pp. 1999–2003, 2009. [52] ——, “Modification and testing of a battery-inductor repetitive pulsed [75] W. Weck et al., “Demonstration of a superconducting inductive pulsed power supply for a small railgun,” in 16th IEEE Int. Pulsed Power power supply at simulated load conditions,” IEEE Trans. Magn., vol. 35, Conf. (PPPS). Dig. Techn. Pap., vol. 2, Albuquerque, US-NM, 2007, no. 1, pp. 383 –387, Jan. 1999. pp. 1793–1798. [76] Y. Aso and S. Yamada, “Current multiplier by inductive storage (CMIS) [53] I. McNab, “Pulsed power options for large EM launchers,” IEEE Trans. cooled by LN2 and design of mega-ampere CMIS,” IEEE Trans. Plasma Plasma Sci., vol. 43, no. 5, pp. 1352–1357, May 2015. Sci., vol. 39, no. 1, pp. 247–250, Jan. 2011. [54] R. Wu et al., “Design and testing of a novel inductive pulsed power [77] S. Yamada, Y. Hishinuma, and Y. Aso, “Multi-functional current supply consisting of HTS pulse power transformer and ZnO-based multiplier by high temperature superconducting magnet energy storage,” nonlinear resistor,” IEEE Trans. Plasma Sci., vol. 41, no. 7, pp. 1781– Physics Procedia, vol. 36, pp. 741 – 746, 2012. [Online]. Available: 1786, 2013. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1875389212019736 [78] M. Driga et al., “Homopolar generator charged inductors,” in 5th IEEE [55] ——, “Simulation and experimental investigation of an inductive pulsed Int. Pulsed Power Conf. (PPPS). Dig. Techn. Pap., Arlington, US-VA, power supply based on the head-to-tail series model of an HTS air-core 1985, p. 606. pulsed transformer,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Supercond., vol. 23, no. 4, pp. [79] E. Spahn, G. Buderer, and F. Hatterer, “Compact 50 kJ pulse forming 5 701 305–5 701 305, 2013. unit, switched by semiconductors,” IEEE Trans. Magn., vol. 31, no. 1, [56] X. Yu and X. Chu, “Comparisons of three inductive pulse power pp. 78–83, Jan. 1995. supplies,” IEEE Trans. Plasma Sci., vol. 41, no. 5, pp. 1340–1345, May [80] J. Parker, D. Berry, and P. Snowden, “The IAT electromagnetic launch 2013. research facility,” IEEE Trans. Magn., vol. 33, no. 1, pp. 129–133, Jan. [57] ——, “STRETCH meat grinder with ICCOS,” IEEE Trans. Plasma Sci., 1997. vol. 41, no. 5, pp. 1346–1351, May 2013. [81] N. Kovrizhnykh et al., “Inductive storage - inductor for a capacitor [58] X. Yu, S. Ma, and Z. Li, “System implementation and testing of the cell,” in 17th IEEE Int. Pulsed Power Conf. (PPPS). Dig. Techn. Pap., STRETCH meat grinder with ICCOS,” IEEE Trans. Plasma Sci., vol. PP, Washington, DC, Jun. 2009, pp. 646–651. no. 99, pp. 1–1, 2015. [82] E. Tuinman, “Characterization and optimization of the Kapitza facility [59] X. Yu et al., “Discussion on the discharging effects of two STRETCH at PML-Pulse Physics.” in 7th IEEE Int. Pulsed Power Conf. (PPPS). meat grinder modules with different triggering delays,” IEEE Trans. Dig. Techn. Pap., Arlington, US-VA, 1989, pp. 134–139. Plasma Sci., vol. PP, no. 99, pp. 1–1, 2015. [83] A. Druzhinin et al., “Pulse power systems using inductive energy [60] ——, “Study on the collaborative triggering of multiple STRETCH meat storage,” IEEE Trans. Magn., vol. 28, no. 1, pp. 410–413, Jan. 1992. grinder with ICCOS modules,” IEEE Trans. Plasma Sci., vol. PP, no. 99, [84] M. Kanter et al., “Capillary discharge response to XRAM inductive pp. 1–1, 2015. generator,” in 8th IEEE Int. Pulsed Power Conf. (PPPS). Dig. Techn. [61] W. Koch, “Ein induktiver Stoßstromgenerator fur¨ Hochstromexperi- Pap., San Diego, US-CA, Jun. 1991, pp. 792–794. mente,” German Federal Ministry for Scientific Research [Bundesmin- [85] P. Dedie and, V. Brommer, and S. Scharnholz, “Twenty-stage toroidal isterium fur¨ wiss. Forschung], Tech. Rep. BMwF-FB K 67-35, 1967. XRAM generator switched by countercurrent thyristors,” IEEE Trans. [62] J. G. H. Salge, M. J. Loeffler, and U. E. Braunsberger, “Integrated Plasma Sci., vol. 39, no. 1, pp. 263 –267, Jan. 2011. magnetic acceleration - and energy storage system,” in 5th IEEE Int. Pulsed Power Conf. (PPPS). Dig. Techn. Pap., Arlington, US-VA, 1985, pp. p.548–551. [63] M. J. Loffler,¨ “Uber¨ die Einkopplung elektromagnetischer Energie in lineare Hochleistungspulsbeschleuniger,” Ph.D. dissertation, Technische Oliver Liebfried was born in 1980 in Bottrop, Universtat¨ Braunschweig, 1988. Germany. He received the Dipl.Ing.(FH) degree in [64] R. Ford, R. Hudson, and R. Klug, “Novel hybrid XRAM current electrical engineering in 2004 and the M.Eng. de- multiplier,” IEEE Trans. Magn., vol. 29, no. 1, pp. 949–953, Jan. 1993. gree in energy system technology in 2006 from [65] M. Kanter et al., “Repetitive operation of an XRAM circuit,” in 9th IEEE the Gelsenkirchen University of Applied Sciences, Int. Pulsed Power Conf. (PPPS). Dig. Techn. Pap., vol. 1, Albuquerque, Gelsenkirchen, Germany. He received his Ph.D. de- US-NM, Jun. 1993, pp. 92–. gree from the Vilnius Gediminas Technical Univer- [66] C. Stallings, F. Warren, and J. Naff, “A novel energy storage device,” sity in Vilnius, Lithuania. As Ph.D. student he was in 13th IEEE Int. Pulsed Power Conf. (PPPS). Dig. Techn. Pap., vol. 1, with the State Research Institute Center for Physical Las Vegas, US-NV, Jun. 2001, pp. 624–627 vol.1. Sciences and Technology, Vilnius, Lithuania, and the [67] E. Grabovsky et al., “Development of X-ray facility ”Baikal” based on French-German Research Institute of Saint-Louis, 900 MJ inductive store and related problems,” in 13th IEEE Int. Pulsed France, where he is currently working as research scientist. His research Power Conf. (PPPS). Dig. Techn. Pap., vol. 1, Las Vegas, Jun. 2001, interests are capacitive and inductive pulsed power generators, electromagnetic pp. 773–776 vol.1. accelerators, battery technology and metrology. Dr. Liebfried is an executive [68] S. Yamada, H. Nakayama, and Y. Aso, “Switching properties of liquid board member of the International Society on Pulsed Power Applications e.V. nitrogen cooled IGBTs and 24 kA demonstration of current multiplier (www.pulsed-power.org). by inductive storage,” Journal of Physics: Conf. Series, vol. 507, no. 3, 2014. [Online]. Available: http://stacks.iop.org/1742-6596/507/i= 3/a=032059 [69] O. Liebfried and V. Brommer, “A four-stage XRAM generator as inductive pulsed power supply for a small-caliber railgun,” IEEE Trans. Plasma Sci., vol. 41, no. 10, pp. 2805–2809, Oct. 2013. [70] A. Badel, P. Tixador, and M. Arniet, “Optimized use of superconducting magnetic energy storage for electromagnetic rail launcher powering,” Superconductor Science and Technology, vol. 25, no. 1, p. 014006, 2012. [Online]. Available: http://stacks.iop.org/0953-2048/25/i=1/a=014006 [71] A. Badel, “Superconducting magnetic energy storage using high temperature superconductor for pulse power supply,” Ph.D. dissertation, INPG, Universite´ de Grenoble, Sep. 2010. [Online]. Available: http://tel.archives-ouvertes.fr/tel-00654844 [72] P. Dedie et al., “Three-stage superconducting XRAM generator,” IEEE Trans. Dielectr. Electr. Insul., vol. 18, no. 4, pp. 1189 –1193, Aug. 2011.