Blackbeard's Beads

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Blackbeard's Beads BLACKBEARD’S BEADS: IDENTIFICATION AND INTERPRETATION OF THE BEADS RECOVERED FROM THE SHIPWRECK 31CR314 QUEEN ANNE’S REVENGE by Kimberly A. Urban December 2017 Director of Thesis: Charles R. Ewen, PhD Major Department: Anthropology Glass trade beads are one of the most notable artifacts of the Transatlantic Slave Trade and played an important role in African culture spiritually, metaphysically, and historically. Since its discovery in 1996, 798 glass beads have been recovered from the Queen Anne’s Revenge Shipwreck. This thesis seeks to identify the beads recovered from the Queen Anne’s Revenge shipwreck and interpret their relationship to the ship and the Transatlantic Slave Trade. The thesis opens with the history of the slave trade, specifically the role of the French, as well as an historical overview of Blackbeard, the Queen Anne’s Revenge, and of bead manufacture. Following the archaeology and recovery of the shipwreck along with its conservation program and previous research conducted on the Queen Anne’s Revenge bead assemblage is discussed. Other contemporaneous archaeological sites, both terrestrial and maritime, are presented to compare the Queen Anne’s Revenge bead assemblage to other sites. This research is designed to provide data on the types of beads recovered from the Queen Anne’s Revenge shipwreck for both conservators at the Queen Anne’s Revenge Conservation Laboratory and future archaeologists. This research provides insight into the ship’s former role as a slaver and addresses the ship’s link between Africa and the slave trade. BLACKBEARD’S BEADS: IDENTIFICATION AND INTERPRETATION OF THE BEADS RECOVERED FROM THE SHIPWRECK 31CR314 QUEEN ANNE’S REVENGE A Thesis Presented to the Faculty of the Department of Anthropology East Carolina University In Partial Fulfilment of the Requirements for the Degree Masters of Arts in Anthropology by Kimberly A. Urban December 2017 © Kimberly A. Urban, 2017 BLACKBEARD’S BEADS: IDENTIFICATION AND INTERPRETATION OF THE BEADS RECOVERED FROM THE SHIPWRECK 31CR314 QUEEN ANNE’S REVENGE by Kimberly A. Urban APPROVED BY: DIRECTOR OF THESIS: Charles R. Ewen, PhD COMMITTEE MEMBER: I. Randolph Daniel Jr., PhD COMMITTEE MEMBER: Benjamin A. Saidel, PhD COMMITTEE MEMBER: Lynn B. Harris, PhD CHAIR OF THE DEPARTMENT OF ANTHROPOLOGY: I. Randolph Daniel Jr., PhD DEAN OF THE GRADUATE SCHOOL: Paul J. Gemperline, PhD ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to thank my advisor and director of thesis, Dr. Charles Ewen for his continued support, advice, and patience during my thesis research and writing as well as for the opportunities I was provided as a student, particularly my assistantship with the Queen Anne’s Revenge Conservation Laboratory and my teaching assistantship with East Carolina University’s Summer Ventures in Science and Mathematics program. I also want to thank my committee members, Dr. Randolph Daniel Jr., Dr. Benjamin Saidel, and Dr. Lynn Harris for their feedback and advice throughout my research and writing process. I have overwhelming gratitude to the employees of the North Carolina Department of Natural and Cultural Resources, Office of State Archaeology’s Queen Anne’s Revenge Conservation Laboratory (QAR Lab), including Sarah Watkins-Kenney, Kimberly Kenyon, Erik Farrell, Courtney Page, Elise Carroll, Terry Williams, Stephen Atkinson, Jeremy Borrelli, Karen Martindale, Arianna DiMucci, and Tim Smith for fielding my questions, ideas, discussions, and frustraions. I am grateful for the training and experience they have provided me that has allowed me to gain invaluable experience for my career. Additionally, I thank the Laboratory as well as the North Carolina Maritime Museum Beaufort for providing me the opportunity, space, and tools to examine the Queen Anne’s Revenge bead assemblage. I also want to acknowledge Dr. Linda Carnes-McNaughton and Susan G. Meyers for their guidance and previous bead research which provided the foundation for this project. I would like to thank my Anthropology cohort for being an outlet for my thoughts and frustrations while also making my graduate school experience enjoyable. Most of all, I would like to thank my parents, siblings, and boyfriend whose endless support for my wellbeing, education, and success, has meant more than I could ever express. TABLE OF CONTENTS ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ...................................................................................................... iv LIST OF TABLES ................................................................................................................. viii LIST OF FIGURES .................................................................................................................. ix CHAPTER ONE – INTRODUCTION ...................................................................................... 1 Contents .................................................................................................................................. 3 CHAPTER TWO – HISTORICAL BACKGROUND .............................................................. 5 Transatlantic Slave Trade ....................................................................................................... 5 France in the Eighteenth Century ........................................................................................... 6 Piracy and the Slave Trade ..................................................................................................... 8 Blackbeard ............................................................................................................................ 10 Queen Anne’s Revenge ......................................................................................................... 13 Glass Trade Beads................................................................................................................. 15 CHAPTER THREE – ARCHAEOLOGICAL BACKGROUND ........................................... 20 Discovery and Excavation .................................................................................................... 20 Conservation ......................................................................................................................... 23 CHAPTER FOUR – BEAD ASSEMBLAGES FROM OTHER RELEVANT ARCHAEOLOGICAL SITES ................................................................................................. 30 Henrietta Marie .................................................................................................................... 30 Elmina Shipwreck ................................................................................................................. 31 Elmina, Ghana....................................................................................................................... 33 Newton Cemetery ................................................................................................................. 34 New York African Burial Ground ........................................................................................ 35 House for Families, George Washington’s Mount Vernon .................................................. 37 CHAPTER FIVE – METHODS .............................................................................................. 39 Previous Research ................................................................................................................. 39 Data Acquisition ................................................................................................................... 44 Analysis................................................................................................................................. 45 Artifact Distribution Analysis ............................................................................................... 46 CHAPTER SIX – RESULTS................................................................................................... 48 Bead Identifiaction and Classification .................................................................................. 48 Color ..................................................................................................................................... 55 Comparative Analysis ........................................................................................................... 56 Bead Distribution Analysis ................................................................................................... 58 CHAPTER SEVEN – DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION ................................................. 61 Identification ......................................................................................................................... 61 Comparison of Bead Assemblages ....................................................................................... 63 Artifact Distribition Analysis ................................................................................................ 64 Interpretations ....................................................................................................................... 65 Significance........................................................................................................................... 65 Recommendations for Future Work...................................................................................... 66 Conclusion ............................................................................................................................ 67 REFERENCES .......................................................................................................................
Recommended publications
  • Blackbeardblackbeard Dominoesdominoes Starterstarter
    BlackbeardBlackbeard DominoesDOMINOES StarterStarter BEFORE READING Activity pages 18–19 1 a treasure READING CHECK b ship b F (He tells him ‘You can be one of my crew’.) c pirate c T Key d pistol d F (The Spanish crew fight well.) e governor e F (Blackbeard puts the Spanish on a small island.) f sword f T Activity Key 2 a pirate g F (Blackbeard’s pirates cannot go into Charleston because b ships they will be captured and killed there.) c governor…governor WORD WORK d sword…pistol b fever e treasure c doctor 3 Open answers. d medicine e firing Activity pages 6–7 f small READING CHECK g jump b Hornigold h sword c Hornigold i pistol d Teach…Hornigold GUESS WHAT e the Mary Anne’s lookout Encourage students to guess but do not tell them the answers f Teach now. They will find out as they read that the answers are: g Teach…the French captain a and d h Louis Arot…Teach WORD WORK Activity pages 24–25 1 b ship READING CHECK c cabin b Charleston d gold c Governor of South Carolina e gun d medicine f pirate e Charleston 2 b war f Three days c starboard g happy d crew h go home e fight i North f aboard j King George g attack h captures WORD WORK GUESS WHAT b surrender c chest Encourage students to guess but do not tell them the answers d abandoned now. They will find out as they read that the answers are: e sugar a 1,2 f sending b 1,3 g pardon c 1,3 h letter d 2,3 GUESS WHAT Activity pages 12–13 Encourage students to guess but do not tell them the answers now.
    [Show full text]
  • Proceedings of the Annual Meeting of the Association for Education in Journalism and Mass Communication (75Th, Montreal, Quebec, Canada, August 5-8, 1992)
    DOCUMENT RESUME ED 349 622 CS 507 969 TITLE Proceedings of the Annual Meeting of the Association for Education in Journalism and Mass Communication (75th, Montreal, Quebec, Canada, August 5-8, 1992). Part XV: The Newspaper Business. INSTITUTION Seneca Nation Educational Foundation, Salamanca, N.Y. PUB DATE Aug 92 NOTE 324p.; For other sections of these proceedings, see CS 507 955-970. For 1991 Proceedings, see ED 340 045. PUB TYPE Collected Works Conference Proceedings (021) EDRS PRICE MF01/PC13 Plus Postage. DESCRIPTORS *Business Administration; *Economic Factors; *Employer Employee Relationship; Foreign Countries; Journalism History; Marketing; *Mass Media Role; Media Research; *Newspapers; Ownership; *Publishing Industry; Trend Analysis IDENTIFIERS *Business Media Relationship; Indiana; Newspaper Circulation ABSTRACT The Newspaper Business section of the proceedings contains the following 13 papers: "Daily Newspaper Market Structure, Concentration and Competition" (Stephen Lacy and Lucinda Davenport); "Who's Making the News? Changing Demographics of Newspaper Newsrooms" (Ted Pease); "Race, Gender and White Male Backlash in Newspaper Newsrooms" (Ted Pease); "Race and the Politics of Promotion in Newspaper Newsrooms" (Ted Pease); "Future of Daily Newspapers: A Q-Study of Indiana Newspeople and Subscribers" (Mark Popovich and Deborah Reed); "The Relationship between Daily and Weekly Newspaper Penetration in Non-Metropolitan Areas" (Stephen Lacy and Shikha Dalmia); "Employee Ownership at Milwaukee and Cincinnati: A Study in Success and
    [Show full text]
  • Piracy, Illicit Trade, and the Construction of Commercial
    Navigating the Atlantic World: Piracy, Illicit Trade, and the Construction of Commercial Networks, 1650-1791 Dissertation Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Graduate School of The Ohio State University by Jamie LeAnne Goodall, M.A. Graduate Program in History The Ohio State University 2016 Dissertation Committee: Margaret Newell, Advisor John Brooke David Staley Copyright by Jamie LeAnne Goodall 2016 Abstract This dissertation seeks to move pirates and their economic relationships from the social and legal margins of the Atlantic world to the center of it and integrate them into the broader history of early modern colonization and commerce. In doing so, I examine piracy and illicit activities such as smuggling and shipwrecking through a new lens. They act as a form of economic engagement that could not only be used by empires and colonies as tools of competitive international trade, but also as activities that served to fuel the developing Caribbean-Atlantic economy, in many ways allowing the plantation economy of several Caribbean-Atlantic islands to flourish. Ultimately, in places like Jamaica and Barbados, the success of the plantation economy would eventually displace the opportunistic market of piracy and related activities. Plantations rarely eradicated these economies of opportunity, though, as these islands still served as important commercial hubs: ports loaded, unloaded, and repaired ships, taverns attracted a variety of visitors, and shipwrecking became a regulated form of employment. In places like Tortuga and the Bahamas where agricultural production was not as successful, illicit activities managed to maintain a foothold much longer.
    [Show full text]
  • Ghana's Glass Beadmaking Arts in Transcultural Dialogues
    Ghana’s Glass Beadmaking Arts in Transcultural Dialogues Suzanne Gott PHOTOS BY THE AUTHOR EXCEPT WHERE OTHERWISE NOTED hanaian powder-glass beads first captured spread of West African strip-weaving technologies. my attention in 1990, when closely examin- With the beginnings of European maritime trade in the late ing a strand of Asante waist beads purchased fifteenth century, an increasing volume of glass beads and glass in Kumasi’s Central Market. Looking at the goods were shipped to trade centers along present-day Ghana’s complex designs of different colored glasses, Gold Coast,1 stimulating the growth of local beadworking and I was struck with the realization that each powder-glass beadmaking industries. The flourishing coastal bead had been skillfully and painstakingly crafted. This seem- trade achieved a more direct engagement between European Gingly humble and largely unexamined art merited closer study merchants and trading communities than had been possible and greater understanding (Fig. 1). I worked with Christa Clarke, with the trans-Saharan trade, and enhanced European abilities Senior Curator for the Arts of Global Africa at the Newark to ascertain and respond to local West African consumer pref- Museum, to develop the 2008–2010 exhibition “Glass Beads of erences. This interactive trade environment also facilitated the Ghana” at the Newark Museum to introduce the general public impact of the demands of Gold Coast consumers on European to this largely overlooked art (Fig. 2). The following study pro- product design and production, a two-way dynamic similar to vides a more in-depth examination of Ghanaian glass beadmak- the trade in African-print textiles (Nielsen 1979; Steiner 1985).
    [Show full text]
  • The Traveling Beads
    The Traveling Beads What does this colorful 21st century Venetian glass necklace have in common with glass beads found by archeologists at Manzanar? A close look reveals that all the found beads were made of the same material, of similar color and shape, served the same functions, and originated from the same part of the world. How could beads from southern Europe appear thousands of miles away in the sand at Manzanar amongst American Indian artifacts? What do they reveal about the Owens Valley Paiute (Numu) who inhabited Manzanar long before it was a WWII War Relocation Center? For centuries, Europeans have created beautiful glass objects that have served as beads, jewelry, money, vases, lamps and art objects. As early as 1291, there is evidence that artisans working in the glass factories of Italy have molded some of the most beautiful glass products in the world. When European explorers from Spain, Portugal, Italy and France began their land explorations in the New World, they brought these beautiful objects with them to trade with the people they hoped to find in the new land. Archeologists have documented many American Indian sites in all parts of California that contain glass objects and beads of European origin. Trade networks existed throughout the country along river ways and trails allowing indigenous people to exchange resources (or goods) including manufactured items, such as beads. Regional exchanges must have occurred between the Spaniards and the Indians as the missions were built along the west coast of California. The establishment of the mission system was most likely responsible for the mass distribution of glass beads throughout California.
    [Show full text]
  • How Goldsmiths Created Money Page 1 of 2
    Money: Banking, Spending, Saving, and Investing The Creation of Money How Goldsmiths Created Money Page 1 of 2 If you want to understand money, you have got to start with its history, and that means gold. Have you ever wondered why gold is so valuable? I mean, it is a really weak metal that does not have a lot of really practical uses. Maybe it is because it reminded people of the sun, which was worshipped in ancient times, that everyone decided they wanted it. Once everyone wants it, it is capable as serving as a medium of exchange. That is, gold can be used as money, and it is an ideal commodity to serve as a medium of exchange because it’s portable, it’s durable, it’s divisible, and it’s standardizable. Everybody recognizes what they want, it can be broken into little pieces, carried around, it doesn’t rot, and it is a great thing to serve as money. So, before long, gold is circulating in the form of coins. When gold circulates as coins, it is called commodity money, that is, money that has intrinsic value made out of something people want. Now, once gold coins begin to circulate as the medium of exchange, we have got another problem. That problem is security. Imagine that you are in the ancient world, lugging around bags and bags of gold. You are going to be pretty vulnerable to bandits. So what you want to do is make sure that there is a safe place to store your gold because you can store all of your wealth in the form of this valuable commodity, but you do not want it all lying around somewhere that it is easy for somebody else to pick off.
    [Show full text]
  • Queen Anne's Revenge Shipwreck Project Volume 5, Number 1 Spring 2005
    Update from the Queen Anne's Revenge Shipwreck Project Volume 5, Number 1 Spring 2005 Origins of the Queen Anne's Revenge Recently we had an inquiry from Nick Glenister in England asking about information that would help him build "a reasonably accurate model of the Queen Anne's Revenge". We asked Dave Moore, Curator of Nautical Archaeology at the North Carolina Maritime Museum, to reply. Remember that the QAR is believed to have originally been the French ship, Concorde, captured, refitted, and renamed by Blackbeard. Dave gave such a good response that we excerpted parts of it for your information. "The museum has actually had a hypothetical model constructed although no plans or drawings have been generated from that effort. We did quite a bit of research leading up to the construction and ended up using data from Jean Boudriot's treatise on the French merchant ship, Mercure.c.1730, as the primary framework for building the model. We figured we were probably safe building a model of an early 18th century French merchant ship. But there were two things wrong with that assumption that have come to light through additional research over the past couple of years. We now suspect the Concorde may have been built along the lines of a typical light French frigate, hence a bit different from our current model. Also, a document located in French archives strongly suggests that Blackbeard exchanged the ship, shortly after taking her, for a similar sized and armed English ship that may make all our assumptions mute. So, bottom line, we simply do not know what the QAR may have looked like apart from a general idea of her size, numerous guns, and three masts.
    [Show full text]
  • Deterioration and Conservation of Unstable Glass Beads on Native
    Issue 63 Autumn 2013 Deterioration and Conservation of Unstable Glass Beads on Native American Objects Robin Ohern and Kelly McHugh lass disease is an important issue for (MAI), established in 1961 by financier George museums with Native American col- Gustav Heye. Heye’s personal collecting began in G lections, and at the National Museum 1903 and continued over a fifty-four year period, of the American Indian (NMAI) it is one of the resulting in one of the largest Native American most pervasive preservation problems. Of 108,338 collections in the world. The Smithsonian Insti- non-archaeological object records in NMAI’s col- tution took over the extensive MAI holdings in lection database, 9,687 (9%) contain glass beads. 1989, establishing the National Museum of the Of these, 200 object records (22%) mention the American Indian. While the collection originally presence of glass disease on the objects. Determin- served Heye’s mission, “The preservation of every- ing how quickly the unstable glass is deteriorating thing pertaining to our American tribes”, NMAI will help with long term collection preservation places its emphasis on partnerships with Native (Figure 1). Additionally, evaluating the effective- peoples and on their contemporary lives. ness of different cleaning techniques over several When the museum joined the Smithsonian years may help to develop better protocols for Institution, the decision was made to construct treating glass beads. This ongoing research project a new building on the National Mall and move will focus on continuing research on glass disease the collection from New York to a storage facil- on ethnographic beadwork in the collection of the ity near Washington, D.C.
    [Show full text]
  • New Monetarist Economics: Methods∗
    Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis Research Department Staff Report 442 April 2010 New Monetarist Economics: Methods∗ Stephen Williamson Washington University in St. Louis and Federal Reserve Banks of Richmond and St. Louis Randall Wright University of Wisconsin — Madison and Federal Reserve Banks of Minneapolis and Philadelphia ABSTRACT This essay articulates the principles and practices of New Monetarism, our label for a recent body of work on money, banking, payments, and asset markets. We first discuss methodological issues distinguishing our approach from others: New Monetarism has something in common with Old Monetarism, but there are also important differences; it has little in common with Keynesianism. We describe the principles of these schools and contrast them with our approach. To show how it works, in practice, we build a benchmark New Monetarist model, and use it to study several issues, including the cost of inflation, liquidity and asset trading. We also develop a new model of banking. ∗We thank many friends and colleagues for useful discussions and comments, including Neil Wallace, Fernando Alvarez, Robert Lucas, Guillaume Rocheteau, and Lucy Liu. We thank the NSF for financial support. Wright also thanks for support the Ray Zemon Chair in Liquid Assets at the Wisconsin Business School. The views expressed herein are those of the authors and not necessarily those of the Federal Reserve Banks of Richmond, St. Louis, Philadelphia, and Minneapolis, or the Federal Reserve System. 1Introduction The purpose of this essay is to articulate the principles and practices of a school of thought we call New Monetarist Economics. It is a companion piece to Williamson and Wright (2010), which provides more of a survey of the models used in this literature, and focuses on technical issues to the neglect of methodology or history of thought.
    [Show full text]
  • The Queen's Report Update from the Queen Anne's Revenge Shipwreck Project Volume 1, Number 1, February 2001
    The Queen's Report Update from the Queen Anne's Revenge Shipwreck Project Volume 1, Number 1, February 2001 Exploring Blackbeard's Cannon - Cannon C-4 measures five feet, six inches long, weighs 763 pounds, and is the third of five recovered so far from the wreck of Queen Anne's Revenge (QAR) It came up on October 12, 1998 with a four-pound cast iron shot ball stuck in its throat. Divers brought it up early because it was a different size from the others, and had interesting elements attached to it. From some angles, it appeared to be a big lizard with a funny looking rod and ring sticking out of one end. The four-pound shot was sandwiched in the bore between two wads of cordage, a typical practice for early 18th century ships' cannon. Cordage consisted of heavy towing rope, lines, or fiber from a ship's rigging. The outer wad held the shot in place while the ship was at sea, and the inner wad was used to create a seal between gunpowder charge and shot. Project Conservator Wayne Lusardi, found stitched paper powder cartridge in the bore. In short, C-4 was armed and ready to fire when the ship went down. Kim Eslinger is a QAR intern and a graduate student in Maritime Studies at East Carolina University. Her task is to remove artifacts that may be in the "interesting elements", or concretion, a heavy layer of debris, mostly sand and shells, bonded by a lengthy rusting process. Careful separation of its contents has so far yielded a tiny gold-plated silver spangle, glass fragments, pig bones, nails, and musket parts.
    [Show full text]
  • "A Country Worth Fighting For: the History of the 128Th Pa"
    November 11, 2015 The One Hundred and Fiftieth Year of the Civil War "A Country Worth Fighting For: The History of the 128th Pa" Notes from the President... As the weather cools and we get closer to General Meade's 200th birthday, our Round Table continues to prosper with new members, ideas and energy. It is your group; please share your excitement and enthusiasm with others directing them to our outstanding website. If you are unable to join us on the 11th, have a safe and relaxing Thanksgiving with your families. We are grateful to have you all on our team. Herb assures me we will have the Irish fluted glasses at the meeting, bring your $7. There was a great turnout for the screening of Joe Wilson's documentary, thank you to all who publi- cized it and those who came out to see it. Last month Join us at on , at 7:15 PM Wednesday, November 11 Dr. Robert Hicks explained Civil War Medicine by walking Camden County College in the Connector Building, us through the treatment of two wounded soldiers. Even Room 101. This month’s topic is Paula Gidjunis those familiar with the topic departed with new information. "A Country Worth Fighting For: The History of the This month longtime friend of Old Baldy Paula Gidjunis 128th Pa" will share the history of the 128th PA. Remember the The 128th Pennsylvania Volunteer Infantry men came from November meeting is on Wednesday the 11th. We are ex- the counties of Bucks, Berks and Lehigh. These volunteers pecting a good crowd as viewers of the prison film come to enlisted in August 1862 for nine months in response to check us out.
    [Show full text]
  • Death Records from the Salem Press Collected and Compiled by Susan Wade, First Washington County Historian
    Death records from the Salem Press collected and compiled by Susan Wade, first Washington County Historian Published 2 Jan. 1874 In Salem, Dec. 16, Mrs. HANNAH L. FIFIELD, wife of Frank N. Fifield, aged 25 years. In Salem, Dec. 23, at the residence of Mr. Daniel Rich of typhoid fever, JAMES MCNISH, in the 26th year of his age. In New York City, Dec. 27, at the residence of Robert McMurray, M. D., Mrs. MARY GRACE MCMURRAY, wife of Hon. Ebenezer McMurray of this town, aged 53 years. In Easton, on Saturday evening, December 20th, Capt. FREDERICK MARSHALL, aged about 78 years. In Lakeville, on Wednesday, Dec. 10th, EUNICE, wife of Walter G. STEWART, aged 54 years. Published 9 Jan. 1874 In Rupert, Jan, 3d ASHER LOVELAND, aged 62. In Rupert, Jan, 5th, little CHARLIE son, of Cyrus F. and Elizabath SHELDON, aged 11 months. Published 16 Jan. 1874 In Salem, January 10th, 1874, JOHN M. CLAPP, in the 32d year of his age. In this village, December 29th, 1873, DAVID HILL, aged about 6 years. JAMES BALDWIN, at the residence of his brother, aged about 28 years. In Jackson, Jan. 11th, 1874, ELIZABETH, wife of Thomas MCMORRIS, aged 64 years. In Argyle, January 1, Mrs. MARY, relict of John FLACK, aged 73 years. Published 23 Jan. 1874 In Salem, at the Central House, Jan. 22, PATRICK MCCLEAR, in the 27th year of his age. In Salem, Jan. 19, MARIA E., infant daughter of Martin and Ellen MALTHANER, aged 2 months and 4 days. In Salem, Jan. 19, EDWARD C., infant son of Horace P.
    [Show full text]