On Cooperite, Braggite, and Vysotskitel
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
AmericanfrIineralogist, Volume 63 , pages832-839, I 978 On cooperite,braggite, and vysotskitel Louts J. Cesnt, J. H. Gllus Le,rLemltn,JoHN M. SrBwnRr Canada Centre for Mineral and Energy Technology 555Booth Street, Ottawa, CanadaKl A 0GI KsNr TunNsn INP BRtnNJ' SrtNNrn Department of Geology and Geophysics, Yale Uniuersity New Hauen, Connecticut06520 Abstract phase Detailedmineralogical analyses ol cooperite,braggite, and vysotskite,together with of equilibrium studies,reveal that, though there is no uncertaintyregarding the identity cooperite(PtS;P4r/mmc), one may considerbraggite (Pt,Pd)S and vysotskitePdS to be nicfeloanmembers of an isomorphoussolid-solution series (Pd,Pt)S (P4z/ m)' Theresults also the suggestthat this solid-solutionseries (braggite series) may be subdividedby restricting namevysotskite to thosemembers with lessthan about l0 molepercent PtS. Cooperite and is only braggitecan both form at magmatictemperatures of 1000"Cor above,but vysotskite fo.ir"a at submagmatictempiratures, possibly by crystallizationfrom a residualimmiscible sulfide-richmelt or by solid-statereaction. Introduction has since been reported, but not documentedin de- Montana (Cabri Cooperite,braggite, and vysotskiteare the only Pt- tail, from the Stillwater Complex of Isles deposit, Pd sulfide minerals with ideal compositions in the and Laflamme, 1974)and the Lac des system Pt-Pd-S. Cooperite is ideally PtS, braggite Ontario (Cabri and Laflamme,1976). (Pd,Pt)S,and vysotskitePdS. All analyses,however, In this note we report new data on all three miner- of report the presenceof significantamounts of Ni, so als from the Precambrian Stillwater Complex the variations mineralogicallythey must be consideredas being in Montana. Pageet al. (1976) discussed and ultramafic the system Pt-Pd-Ni-S. We aim to clarify the no- of PG-elementsin the different mafic identifiedby Page menclatureand to presentnew data on the composi- layersof the complex.In the layers Zones we have identi- tions of the minerals.It is a pleasureto be able to do et al. as the Banded and Upper minerals in the same so in the Frondel-Hurlbut issue of The American fied, for the first time, the three found in Mineralogist, becausethese two distinguished miner- deposit. The three minerals have not been doesnot alogists have clarified so many similarly confusing contact so it is probablethat the assemblage can issuesin the nomenclatureof minerals. representequilibrium, and its true significance Braggite and cooperite are both important plati- only be guessedat. num-group minerals (PG-minerals) and are known studies from many areasof'the world; in the great Merensky Previous mineralogical Reef deposits of the Bushveld Igneous Complex in Cooperite the Transvaalthey are major ore minerals.Vysotskite samples from the has not so far been found in sufficient quantities to be Cooperite was discovered in (1928) named by Wagner consideredan important ore mineral. First discov- Bushveld by Cooper and Mr. Wartenweiller ered in the Noril'sk deposits of the USSR and re- (lg2g) following a suggestionby a presentationof ported by Genkin andZvyagintsev(1962), vysotskite in a published discussionfollowing Cooper's paper. Bannister and Hey (1932) deter- with a : 4.91 and I MineralsResearch Program, Processing Contribution No. 88. mined the mineral to be tetragonal 832 CABRI ET AL: COOPERITE, BRAGGITE, AND VYS7TSKITE : c 6.10A.Though they recognizedthat this wasa c spacegroup P4r/m, Z : 8, and a compositionap- face-centeredcell and that the true primitivecell was proximating". (Pt,Pd,Ni)Scontaining about 20 : : p4r/mmc, a 3.47, c 6.10,4.,space group they percentPd and 5 percentNi . ." Braggiteis even neverthelessused the centeredcell in order to empha- more abundantthan cooperitein somemines of the size the relationshipto the unit cell of platinum. BushveldComplex. It averages35.9 volume percent Berryand Thompson(1962) reported a unit cellwith of the PG-mineralsfrom four areasin the Western : a: 3.48and c 6.llA, Z:2, in closeagreement Transvaal(Vermaak and Hendriks,1976) and 60 vol- with the primitivecell of Bannisterand Hey. In their umepercent at the Atok Platinummine in theeastern powder pattern,however, they observedbut could Bushveld(Schwellnus et al., 1976). not index three lines at 2.81(2),1.765(6), and The crystalstructure of braggitewas determined by 1.397A(Vr)respectively. Genkin (1968), reporting on Childsand Hall (1973)on a samplefrom the Potgie- cooperitefrom two differentlocations in theNoril'sk tersrustdistrict, Transvaal. They reported cell param- area,presented two new powder patterns.Neither etersof a : 6.380(l),c : 6.570(l)A,Z: 8. Childs pattern included the two weak lines (2.81 and andHall alsoproposedthat2 Pd atomswere ". the 1.397A)of Berry and Thompson,suggesting they minimum requirementin the formationof the pdS were probably due to impurity admixturesin the (braggiteor vysotskite)structure rather than the ptS Berry and Thompsonsample. Both of the Noril'sk (cooperite)structure." However, four of the sixbrag- samplepatterns contained the strongestline reported gite analysesreported by Schwellnuset al. (1976\ by Berry and Thompson,observed at 1.763and haveless than two atomsof Pd per cell,thus casting 1.770Arespectively, thus stronglysuggesting that it considerabledoubt on the Childs and Hall sugges- belongsto the pattern.The solutionto the problem ' tion. becomesapparent from the work of Grdnvold et al. (1960),who studiedsynthetic PtS, for which they Vysotskite : obtaineda cellwith q 3.4700and c :6.1096,{. The In 1962,Genkin andZvyagintsevreported the min- Grdnvoldpowder pattern contains a strongreflection eral vysotskite,for which theyindicated the formula at 1.7544,which is indexedas (103). (Pd,Ni)S,though they did not considerNi to be an Cooperitemakes up a significantfraction of the essentialconstituent. They found the mineralto be PG-mineralspresent in areasof the BushveldCom- tetragonalwith a : 6.371and c : 6.5404,and the plex wherethe MerenskyReef is mined le.g. 13.36 powderpattern was very similar to that reportedfor volumepercent average from four areasin the West- braggite.The powder pattern was also very similar to ern Transvaal,Vermaak and Hendriks(1976); 10.3 that of syntheticPdS, for whichGaskell (1937) had volumepercent at the WesternPlatinum mine, Bry- reporteda : 6.43(2)and c : 6.63(2)A,space group nardet al. (1976);and 25 volumepercent at the Atok P4r/m, Z : 8. Thesedata suggestedstrongly that Platinummine, Schwellnus el al. (1976)1.Inspite of braggiteand vysotskitewere membersof an iso- the significanceof cooperitein the MerenskyReef, morphousseries of which PdSwas the end-member the only publishedmicroprobe analyses are thoseof composition. Schwellnuset al. (1976)and Brynardet al. (1976), togetherwith a singleanalysis by A. M. Clark re- Phasesin the systemPt-Pd-S ported by Cabri (1972).The fivecooperite analyses of The ternaryphase relations for Pt-Pd-Sat 1000"C Schwellnuset al. (1976)are from samplesfrom the were reportedby Skinneret al. (1976).Those at easternBushveld, and they reveal a rangeofcomposi- 800'C havenow beencompleted and arereported in tion for Pd (by weight)from 0.15to 5.78percent and Figure l. No solidphases more sulfur-richthan PtS for Ni from 0.68to l.l8 percent;the analysesalso or PdSappear, thus we canconfine discussion to the revealPb (1.14to 1.35percent) and Bi (0.41to 0.71 phase-volumePtS-PdS-Pd-Pt. Four phasesappear: percent).Six analysesof cooperitefrom the western a continuousalloy from Pt to Pd, a liquid field lo- Bushveldby Brynardet al. (1976)have a narrower catedon the Pd-PdSjoin, andtwo sulfides.The first rangefor Pd from 0.5to 1.5percent, with Ni ranging sulfideis a solid solutionidentical with cooperite from 0.6 to 1.6percent and tracesof Rh. extendingfrom PtS,along the compositionjoin to- ward PdS, to (Pt'.zoPdo.a0)Sat 1000.C Braggite and (Pto.b4Pdo.G)Sat 800oC. The secondis a phaseidenti- Braggitewas named by Bannisterand Hey (1932) cal in propertiesto braggite.At 1000'Cthe braggite- : : for a tetragonalmineral with a 6.37,c 6.584, like phaseranges in compositionfrom (Pdo.ooPto60)5 834 CABRI ET AL,, COOPERITE, BRAGGITE, AND VYSOTSKITE S cumulate layer situated some 6 feet stratigraphically below the main olivine cumulate horizon (main marker) which contains large pyroxene oikocrysts; sample 2 came from the "dark anorthosite" which forms part of the ore horizon immediatelyabove the main marker; and sample4 camefrom an adjoining section of the same ore horizon, referred to as the "tri-colored anorthosite." The three samples pro- vided by the Corporation are located as follows: sample 5(1824-PP-20)is a sulfide concentrate milled and floated from a bulk sampletaken from the West Fork adit. Sample 6(DDH 77-73-13) is from the Camp zone, located within the lower part of the Banded zone and 4.7 miles WNW along strike from the West Fork adit. Sample 7(789-T-l-l) is from a pyroxenecumulate layer in a trench in the southeast corner of claim Coors 8, located 6.5 miles WNW along strike from the adit. The Lac des Islesvysotskite sample was discovered in a partly crusheddrill core sample,Pl4-7, and the Pt to il arroy r o ;-- Pd Rustenburg (M19398) and Potgietersrust(MI9388) from the Fig. l. Phase relations in the Pt-Pd-S system at 1000' and samples were PG-mineral concentrates 800'C. The braggite solid solution at 800"C includesvysotskite. Royal Ontario Museum collections' : PtS : PdS, in atomic percent, for specificpoints are: A : 70: 30; B The samplesthat neededcrushing and concentra- = : = 60:40; C 16:84; D 54:46:E 24:'76. tion were