A Critical Assessment of Sahih Bukhari and Sahih Muslim
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
A series of ideological researches (35) A Critical Assessment of Sahih Bukhari and Sahih Muslim Ayatollah Sayyid Ali Milani Translated by: Sayyid Abdur Rauf Afzali www.al-milani.com In the Name of God the Beneficent the Merciful A Critical Assessment of Sahih Bukhari and Sahih Muslim ...................................... 1 Table of Contents Forward ............................................................................................................ 4 A critical assessment of Sahih Bukhari and Sahih Muslim ..................... 6 Part One .............................................................................................................. 8 A Critical Assessment of Sahih Bukhari ........................................................ 8 Chapter One ....................................................................................................... 9 Bukhari as a Narrator .................................................................................... 9 Abu Zar’ah and Abu Hatam on Bukhari ..................................................... 9 A glance at the biography of Abu Zar’ah Razi ........................................ 11 A glance at biography of Abu Hatam Razi ............................................... 12 Zuhli and his criticism of Bukhari .............................................................. 13 A glance at Duhli’s life ................................................................................. 14 Bukhari and his deviation from the path of Ahl al-Bayt ....................... 15 Ibn Dihya’s opinion ................................................................................... 15 A glance at Ibn Dihya’s life ........................................................................ 19 Bukhari and Ghadir tradition ...................................................................... 21 Major Sunni scholars and Ghadir tradition .............................................. 21 Ibn JAzer and Ghadir tradition................................................................... 22 Bukhari and his skepticism about Imam Sadiq’s traditions ................. 23 Sunni scholars and issue of loving Prophet’s progeny .......................... 24 Are they truthful in making this claim? .................................................... 26 Qattan and his criticism of Imam Sadiq (a.s) ......................................... 27 Who is Mujalid bin Sa’eed? ......................................................................... 28 Dahabi and Imam Sadiq (a.s) ................................................................... 29 Who is Qattan? ............................................................................................. 30 Incredible claims .......................................................................................... 32 The story of Ibn Madini’s al-Ilal ................................................................. 33 Chapter Two ..................................................................................................... 35 Baseless Traditions in Sahih Bukhari........................................................ 35 The tradition of ‘[Prophet’s] proposing to 'Aisha ................................... 35 The tradition of ‘intercession of Ibrahim for Azer’ ................................. 36 Fakhr Razi’s opinion ..................................................................................... 37 Ibn Hajar Asqalani and justification of this tradition ............................. 40 Falsity of Ibn Hajar's view .......................................................................... 43 The tradition of Prophet's ‘praying on the corpse of Ibn Abu Sulul’... 46 Why this tradition was fabricated? ........................................................... 47 The tradition of ‘three lies told by Prophet Ibrahim’ ............................. 48 Fakhr Razi rejects this tradition ................................................................ 49 The tradition of ‘a prophet setting ant’s nest on fire’ ........................... 50 Fakhr Razi rejects this tradition ................................................................ 50 A Critical Assessment of Sahih Bukhari and Sahih Muslim ...................................... 2 The tradition of ‘eating forbidden meat’ .................................................. 51 Distortion in a fabricated tradition ............................................................ 52 Justification of meaning of tradition ......................................................... 55 Some Sunni scholars accept this false tradition ..................................... 57 Others are after solution ............................................................................. 58 An evacuation of this solution .................................................................... 59 The tradition ‘Prophets do not leave behind inheritance’ ..................... 63 The tradition of ‘Ali’s quarrel with Prophet over nightprayer’ ............. 65 A glance at Imam Ali’s excellences ........................................................... 66 Fabricated tradition and the objection of fatalism ................................. 72 Falsity of fatalism from the viewpoint of Ibn Taymiyya ....................... 72 Ibn Taymiyya and appealing to a fabricated tradition .......................... 74 The tradition of Ali's ‘proposing to Abu Jahl’s daughter’ ...................... 78 The tradition of 'the cause of the revelation of Quranic verse' ........... 80 The tradition that allows taking wage for reciting from the Holy Quran .............................................................................................................................. 84 The tradition of 'asking for rain' narrated by Asbat .............................. 86 The tradition 'traditions will increase after me' ...................................... 87 The tradition that prohibits (playing) musical instruments .................. 89 The tradition 'a believing adulterer does not in fact commit adultery' .............................................................................................................................. 90 Three persons take Prophet to Mi'araj ..................................................... 92 Monkey stoned to death for fornication ................................................... 99 Bukhari and three other fabricated traditions ..................................... 100 Great Sunni leaders and these fabricated traditions .......................... 102 A critique of Asqalani's point of view ..................................................... 105 The Tradition Masruq Narrates from Um Ruman ................................ 107 Great memorizers and this fabricated tradition .................................. 109 A glance at the life account of some the [said] memorizers ............ 111 An account of the life of 'Alai, a memorizer ......................................... 111 Ibn Sikkin and the said fabricated tradition ......................................... 113 An evaluation of the opinion of author of al-Huda ............................. 113 Temporary Marriage forbidden in Khaibar year .................................. 116 Great Sunni scholars and this fake tradition ....................................... 117 Ibn Hajar 'Asqalani .................................................................................... 120 Dehlavi ........................................................................................................ 121 Imam Shaf'ai .............................................................................................. 123 Abstract ....................................................................................................... 124 Part Two ......................................................................................................... 125 An evaluation of Sahih Muslim ................................................................... 125 Ibrahim bin Abdullah Sa'adi and Sahih Muslim ................................... 126 A Critical Assessment of Sahih Bukhari and Sahih Muslim ...................................... 3 Abu Zar'ah Razi and Sahih Muslim ........................................................ 126 Fabricated traditions in Sahih Bukhari .................................................. 127 A fabricated tradition on Abu Talib ........................................................ 127 Fabricated tradition rejected ................................................................... 128 Tradition indicative of caliphate of Abu Bakr ....................................... 130 Sunni scholars on this fabricated tradition ........................................... 131 Umar orders calling to prayer ................................................................. 133 Two contradictory traditions ................................................................... 134 First verse revealed to Prophet .............................................................. 138 Bibliography ............................................................................................... 141 A Critical Assessment of Sahih Bukhari and Sahih Muslim ...................................... 4 Forward With the prophetic mission of Prophet Muhammad (s), the seal of the prophets, the last and the most perfect divine religion was conveyed to humanity and prophethood came to an end. The religion of Islam emerged in Mecca but after twenty three years of arduous efforts made by the Messenger Allah (s) and