Phylogenetic and Taxonomic Position of the Genus Wollea with the Description of Wollea Salina Sp
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Fottea, Olomouc, 16(1): 43–55, 2016 43 DOI: 10.5507/fot.2015.026 Phylogenetic and taxonomic position of the genus Wollea with the description of Wollea salina sp. nov. (Cyanobacteria, Nostocales) Eliška KozlíKová–zapomělová1, Thomrat CHATCHAWAN2, Jan KaštOVSKÝ3 & Jiří KOMÁREK3,4,* 1 Biology Centre of AS CR, Institute of Hydrobiology, Na Sádkách 7, CZ 37005 České Budějovice, Czech Re- public 2 Maejo University Phrae Campus, Mae Sai, Rong Kwang, 54140, Thailand 3 Department of Botany, Faculty of Science, University of South Bohemia, Branišovská 31, CZ–370 05 České Budějovice, Czech Republic 4 Institute of Botany AS CR and University of South Bohemia, Dukelská 135, CZ – 379 82 Třeboň, Czech Re- public; e–mail: [email protected] Abstract: The taxonomic separation of the related heterocytous cyanobacterial genera Wollea and Anabaena is unclear according to traditional taxonomic features, as modern polyphasic approach has not yet been applied to compare them. However, comparison of the type species of these genera and their polyphasic analyses enable the separation of both generic entities. Definitions of their diacritical characters follow from the combination of their phylogenetic and morphological criteria. The concepts of Anabaena sensu stricto (particularly without planktic types with gas vesicles in cells – Dolichospermum) and Wollea, derived from their types are proposed in the article and their review is presented in the table. A new species from saltworks in southern Thailand, W. salina, is described. Key words: Anabaena, Cyanobacteria, ecology, molecular analyses, morphology, polyphasic approach, taxonomy, Wollea INTRODUCTION larly with respect to molecular evaluation (16S rRNA gene sequences; zapomělová et al. 2013, in litt.). From The little known cyanobacterial genus Wollea is taxo- the traditional concept of Anabaena (GEITLER 1932; nomically classified in the vicinity of the wide, poly- FRITSCH 1949; HOLLERBACH et al. 1953; PRESCOTT 1962; morphic and heterogeneous group of Anabaena–types, BOURRELLY 1970), the generic clades of Chrysosporum, according to the modern combined genetic and mor- Dolichospermum, Sphaerospermopsis and Trichormus phological criteria (polyphasic approach). The mor- have already been separated according to both genetic phological diacritical markers that determine taxa be- and morphological criteria (KOMÁREK & ANAGNOSTIDIS longing to the genus Wollea are fasciculated trichomes 1989; RAJANIEMI et al. 2005a, b; KomáreK & zapomělo- (agglomerated usually in finger–like delimited colo- VÁ 2007, 2008; WACKLIN et al. 2009; zapomělová et al. nies), widely oval akinetes, their position in isopolar fi- 2012; KOMÁREK 2013). However, the part of the origi- laments from both sides of the intercalary heterocytes, nal genus Anabaena sensu stricto (particularly without form of more or less barrel–shaped vegetative cells and planktic and aerotopated genera Dolichospermum and ± rounded conical apical cells. However, according to Sphaerospermopsis) is still heterogeneous according to several authors (e.g., KISELEV from HOLLERBACH et al. phylogenetic analyses (HALINEN et al. 2008; zapomělo- 1953; KOMÁREK 1975), these characters are considered VÁ et al. 2013, in litt.). The different Anabaena clades not to be taxonomically important, and are similar in a (following from the phylogenetic studies) can only be few populations of the type species of the genus Ana- partially characterized by morphological markers, e.g., baena, An. oscillarioides. In principle, both genera (re- by the position and form of akinetes, form of vegetative specting concepts of the type species) contain similar cells, form of apical cells, etc., which have not yet been morphological characters. considered as taxonomically important. Another com- The genus Anabaena is very diverse, particu- plication is that several strains, identified as Anabaena 44 KozlíKová–zapomělová et al.: Position of the genus Wollea oscillarioides, are similar (both morphologically and Molecular analysis. The biomass was harvested in the expo- genetically) to several strains of Wollea saccata, which nential growth phase by repeated centrifugation (centrifuge Z is the type species of the genus Wollea (comp. GEITLER 233 MK–2; Hermle Labortechnik GmbH, Wehingen, Germa- ny), during which the trichomes were washed several times 1932, 1942; DROUET 1978; HINDÁK 2008; KOZHEVNIKOV by physiological solution (NaCl solution, concentration 1 g & KOZHEVNIKOVA 2011; KOMÁREK 2013; and others). .L–1) to remove mucilaginous substances. The biomass sam- The problem is also that the strains isolated and identi- ples were stored at 20 °C until DNA extraction. DNA was fied by various authors as An. oscillarioides and used extracted using the UltraClean (tm) Microbial DNA Isola- in the construction of later phylogenetic trees, occur in tion Kit (MO BIO Laboratories Inc., Carlsbad, CA, USA). a few distant places in the phylogenetic scheme (Fig. The 16S rRNA gene and ITS region were amplified using 1). It is therefore difficult to exactly identify from this primers 16S27F (5´–AGAGTTTGATCCTGGCTCAG–3´) situation, which modifications (resp. clusters) of “Ana- and 23S30R (5´– CTTCGCCTCTGTGTGCCTAGGT–3´) baena oscillarioides” correspond to the types of Ana- (TATON et al. 2003). Amplification was carried out as follows: baena or Wollea. one cycle of 5 min at 94 °C; 10 cycles of 45 s at 94 °C, 45 s at 57 °C, and 2 min at 72 °C; 25 cycles of 45 s at 94 °C, 45 s at The type species of Wollea is not available in 54 °C, and 2 min at 72 °C; followed by a final elongation step exsiccates. Only the typification of Anabaena accord- of 7 min at 72 °C. The PCR product was used as a template ing to the original material is possible, and can be mor- for sequencing with primers 16S27F (TATON et al. 2003) CY- phologically indicated by study of the type slide of An. A781F (a) (5´–AATGGGATTAGATACCCCAGTAGTC–3´) oscillarioides (from Museum National d´Historie Na- (NÜBEL et al. 1997), K6 (5´–GACGGGCCGGTGTGTA- turelle – PC; cf. DROUET 1978). The results presented CA–3´), which is the reverse complement of Primer14 of in this paper and meant to answer the problems stated WILMOTTE et al. (1993), and K8 (5´–AAGGAGGTGAT- above are: CCAGCCACA–3´) (FLECHTNER et al. 2002). Partial sequen- (i) The type exsiccate of Anabaena oscillarioides ces of the 16S rRNA gene (1369 bp) were aligned using the (from PC) has been revised and the concept of the program BioEdit version 7.0.9.0 (HALL 1999) and the alig- nment was edited manually. Phylogenetic trees were con- original genus Anabaena was derived. structed by maximum–likelihood (ML) maximum parsimo- (ii) The positions of strains morphologically iden- ny (MP) and neighbour–joining (NJ) (SAITOU & NEI 1987) tified as An. oscillarioides and distinguishable one algorithms in the program PAUP* version 4.0b10 (SWOFFORD from another according to molecular analysis (the 2003). The topology for the phylogenetic tree was derived 16S rRNA gene sequencing) were determined in from ML. The GTR+I+G evolutionary model of substitution the phylogenetic tree, and the clade morphologica- was found for the best fit to the data using ModelTest 3.7 lly corresponding to the type of An. oscillarioides (POSADA 2008). The parameters (base frequencies, rate ma- was determined. trix of substitution types and shape of gamma distribution) (iii) Phylogenetic relations of cultures, prelimina- were estimated from the data. 100 and 1000 bootstrap repli- cates were performed for ML and NJ analysis, respectively. rily identified as various Wollea–strains (including Nucleotide sequences were deposited at GenBank under the the type species W. saccata) are described, and accession numbers (comp. Tab. S1). comparisons of the genus Wollea to different strains of “Anabaena oscillarioides” (with respect either to the type, or in the sense of the later authors) are presented. ESULTS (iv) The review of the genus Wollea is summarized R in the table, respecting all material available (mor- Separation of the type species of the genera Ana- phological descriptions and results from the 16S baena and Wollea rRNA gene sequencing). The type species of the genus Anabaena, An. oscillari- (v) The taxonomic description of a new species of oides, occurs in literature in several concepts, differing Wollea from halophilic habitats from the marine co- in the form of akinetes (cylindrical up to oval, widely asts of Petchaburi Province, Thailand, is presented. oval to almost spherical), situated either side of the het- erocytes. However, the correct concept must be derived from the type specimen (exsiccate) of An. oscillarioi- METHODS des, which is deposited in the PC Museum collection in Paris. This material was microscopically studied with Optical microscopy. The material used in this study was ob- the following results (Fig. 2): The exsiccate, designat- served using Leitz Dialux 22 and Olympus BX51 microsco- ed MNHN–PC–PC0558651, contains a natural sample pes up to 1000× magnification. Samples of W. salina were with a macroscopic blue–green mat of probably one collected from artificial ponds in solar salterns at 13.30˚N la- morphologically homogeneous colony of densely en- titude and 100.07˚E longitude in Petchaburi Province, Thai- tangled, joined, ± straight or mostly irregularly flexu- land, in November and December 2009 and cultured from the same soil samples on agarised BG11 medium (STANIER ous, not branched and not ensheated filaments or their et al. 1971; with various salt concentrations) at 25 °C, light fragments. Trichomes were composed of wider parts intensity of 28 µmol.m–2.s–1 and a light cycle of 12:12 light/ (segments) with barrel–shaped up to almost spherical dark periods. cells, 4˗6.5 µm wide, transient sometimes immediately DOI: 10.5507/fot.2015.026 Fottea, Olomouc, 16(1):43–55,2016 Table 1. Described species of the traditional genera Wollea, Anabaena (typical, without planktic genera Dolichospermum, Sphaerospermopsis and Chrysosporum), Hydrocoryne and Trichormus, ordered in the table ac- cording to 16S rRNA gene sequencing and morphology (mainly according to the position and form of akinetes), alphabetically ordered in genera. Sequencing of the 16S rRNA gene was only performed in strains from taxa marked by asterisks.