(PBF) Project Portfolio in Somalia Evaluation

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

(PBF) Project Portfolio in Somalia Evaluation Evaluation of the Peacebuilding Fund (PBF) Project Portfolio In Somalia Evaluation Report 27 December 2019 Evaluation Team: • Dr. Terrence Jantzi (Team Leader) • Anara Alymkulova (Peacebuilding Specialist) • Mohamed Adnan (National Context Specialist) KonTerra Support: • Erisa Yzeiraj Pereira (Research Analyst) TABLE OF CONTENTS Executive Summary ........................................................................................... iii 1 Introduction ................................................................................................. 1 1.1 Country Context ............................................................................................................ 1 1.2 PBF Overview and History in Somalia ........................................................................ 2 1.3 PBF Portfolio of Support Response in Somalia: 2015-2019 ........................................ 4 1.4 PBF Portfolio Operationalization and Stakeholders ................................................... 6 2 Evaluation Features .................................................................................... 11 2.1 Evaluation Scope and Key Questions ......................................................................... 11 2.2 Evaluation Methodology ............................................................................................. 14 2.3 Evaluation Limitations ............................................................................................... 15 3 Evaluation Findings .................................................................................... 16 3.1 Relevance, Results and Contributions ........................................................................ 17 3.1.1 Relevance .................................................................................................................................. 17 3.1.2 Results and Contributions ...................................................................................................... 21 3.1.3 Catalytic and Cascade Effects ................................................................................................ 28 3.2 PBF Portfolio Structure and Management Processes ............................................... 32 3.2.1 Efficiency ................................................................................................................................. 32 3.2.2 Effectiveness ............................................................................................................................ 38 3.2.3 Portfolio Lessons Learned ...................................................................................................... 43 3.2.4 Sustainability and Future Directions .................................................................................... 47 4 Conclusions and Recommendations ........................................................... 51 4.1 Conclusions ................................................................................................................. 51 4.2 Recommendations ..................................................................................................... 53 4.2.1 Strategic Directions ................................................................................................................ 53 4.2.2 PBF Systems, Management and Coordination .................................................................... 54 5 Annexes ..................................................................................................... 55 5.1 Annex 1: Statement of Work ...................................................................................... 55 5.2 Annex 2: Project Summaries ...................................................................................... 71 5.2.1 Overall Summary .................................................................................................................... 71 5.2.2 Individual Project Briefs ........................................................................................................ 74 5.3 Annex 3: PPP and Individual Project Results Frameworks and Summaries ............ 94 5.3.1 Individual Project Logframe Output and Outcome Indicators ........................................... 94 5.3.2 PPP Results Framework ......................................................................................................... 97 5.3.3 PPP Theory of Change ............................................................................................................ 99 5.3.4 PBF Priority Area 1: Support to Implementation of Peace Agreements .......................... 100 5.3.5 PBF Priority Area 2. Promote coexistence and peaceful conflict resolution .....................110 5.3.6 PBF Priority Area 2. Promote coexistence and peaceful conflict resolution .....................110 5.3.7 PBF Priority Area 3: Revitalize the economy and immediate peace dividends ............... 117 5.3.8 PBF Priority Area 4: Essential administrative services and infrastructure .................... 119 5.4 Annex 4: Evaluation Matrix..................................................................................... 130 5.5 Annex 5: Evaluation Team Mission Schedule ......................................................... 138 5.6 Annex 6: List of Persons Interviewed ...................................................................... 140 5.7 Annex 7: Project by Project ToC Analysis ................................................................. 144 5.8 Annex 8: Documents Reviewed ................................................................................ 149 5.9 Annex 9: Data Collection Tools ................................................................................ 151 5.9.1 Document Review Tool Example .......................................................................................... 151 5.9.2 Semi-Structured Guides ....................................................................................................... 152 5.9.3 Thematic FGD Exercises ....................................................................................................... 166 5.9.4 Response Matrixes ................................................................................................................ 168 5.10 Annex 10:List of Acronyms ....................................................................................... 173 i List of Figures Figure 1: Chronology of Projects under Review .......................................................................................... 7 Figure 2: Field Visit Locations – Evaluation Team ................................................................................... 15 List of Tables Table 1: PPP Key Outcomes .......................................................................................................................... 5 Table 2: Overview PBF Portfolio Projects in Evaluation (2015-2018)........................................................ 8 Table 3: Stakeholder Categories in Analysis .............................................................................................. 16 Table 4: Relevance SoW Questions ............................................................................................................. 17 Table 5: Impact Related SoW Questions .................................................................................................... 21 Table 6: Project Contributions to Impact .................................................................................................. 24 Table 7: Efficiency related SoW Questions ................................................................................................ 32 Table 8: PBF Portfolio Efficiency Measures .............................................................................................. 33 Table 9: Project Expenditure Rates............................................................................................................. 33 Table 10: Effectiveness SoW Questions ..................................................................................................... 38 Table 11: Lessons Learned for Project Effectiveness ................................................................................. 45 Table 12: Sustainability SoW Questions .................................................................................................... 47 Table 13: Leveraged Funding by Project .................................................................................................... 48 ii Executive Summary Country Context and Peacebuilding Fund Support 1. Somalia has made important strides on its peacebuilding and state-building agenda. After 25 years of civil war, the country carried out an indirect election and established the Federal government in 2012. This development in combination with other military and political transitions created an opportunity for a new political agreement in the country.1 In 2013, the country signed the New Deal Compact2 as an agreement among all levels of the Somali government and the international community for inclusive political dialogue, reconciliation and rehabilitation of Somalia. The Compact focused on imperative political and socio-economic priorities: building inclusive politics, security, justice, the country's economic foundations, revenue collection and the provision of services.3 2. According to a study done by the Overseas Development Institute (2017), the New Deal Compact has contributed to key results such as the re-engagement of the International
Recommended publications
  • Integrated Nutrition and Mortality Smart Survey
    INTEGRATED NUTRITION AND MORTALITY SMART SURVEY REPORT ELBARDE DISTRICT, BAKOOL REGION, SOMALIA NOVEMBER 2020 I ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Action against Hunger (ACF), would like to acknowledge all the support provided during the preparation, training and field activities of the survey, which includes but not limited to; ➢ Technical and logistical support provided by Elbarde Municipality and the Ministry of Health in South West state of Somalia, facilitation during the training and field work. ➢ We would like to acknowledge the roles of the assessment teams including the team leaders, enumerators and community field guides and all the parents/caregivers who provided valuable information to the survey team, and participated the assessment. ➢ Assessment Information Management Working Group (AIMWG) members for the technical inputs and validations. ➢ Appreciation also goes to SIDA, for the generous financial supports to conduct this nutrition and mortality survey. Statement on Copyright © Action Against Hunger Unless otherwise indicated, reproduction is authorized on condition that the source is credited. If reproduction or use of texts and visual materials (sound, images, software, etc.) is subject to prior authorization, such authorization will render null and void the above-mentioned general authorization and will clearly indicate any restrictions on use. II Table of contents ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ................................................................................................................................. II Table of contents ....................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Somalia Nutrition Cluster
    SOMALIA NUTRITION CLUSTER GEDO Sub-National Nutrition Cluster Meeting Minutes (SRDA Dolow Office -17th January 2018 -10:00 – 11:00 am) Agenda Discussions Action points Welcome and As scheduled on 17th January 2018, the Gedo Nutrition Cluster was held at SRDA main Hall Closed Introduction –Dolow Office, the meeting officially opened by Gedo NCCo Mr. Aden Ismail with a word of prayer from Hussein From Trocaire. The meeting was poorly attended Review of the The chair reviewed the previous meeting minute which took place the same venue on 20th Closed previous December 2017 in discussion with the rest of the partners for their confirmation and meeting endorsement an agreed as a true record. minutes and action points Key nutrition The general situation of the region is discussed regarding the drought situation in the region services and which is almost rescaling up again as the rain performed poorly most of the District which situation didn’t left any impact for already devastating ago-pastoralist inhabiting along the Juba river, highlights this resulted internal movement between an area which had received less rain performance to a better place, hence leaving the fragile Women and Children behind to take look after the domestic livestock. Generally the Malnutrition rate across the region reported stable and decreased Mr. Burale from UNOCHA who usually attend the cluster emphasized the important of coordination’s at District level specially agencies implementing programs with the some district. Internal Coordination Between HIRDA, AMA and Trocaire at Bula Hawa District has been conducted in the presence of Aden Ismail NCco and Mr Abdirizak DMO beledhawa District, to address referral challenges.
    [Show full text]
  • Export Agreement Coding (PDF)
    Peace Agreement Access Tool PA-X www.peaceagreements.org Country/entity Somalia Region Africa (excl MENA) Agreement name Declaration of National Commitment (Arta Declaration) Date 05/05/2000 Agreement status Multiparty signed/agreed Interim arrangement No Agreement/conflict level Intrastate/intrastate conflict ( Somali Civil War (1991 - ) ) Stage Framework/substantive - partial (Multiple issues) Conflict nature Government/territory Peace process 87: Somalia Peace Process Parties The Transnational Government of Somalia Third parties [Note: Several references to the international community] Description Agreement outlines the responsibilities of the Transitional National Assembly, the election of the Chief Justice, the roles of the President and Prime Minister, particularly, the limitations of power of the President. It includes 17-points of binding principles. The Annexes include a ceasefire; a plan of reconstrution and recovery; and the foundations for representation of the Somali population in the TNA and the national dialogue. Agreement document SO_000505_Declaration of national commitment.pdf [] Groups Children/youth No specific mention. Disabled persons No specific mention. Elderly/age No specific mention. Migrant workers No specific mention. Racial/ethnic/national Substantive group [Summary] Contains substantive consideration of inter-group representation in the Transitional National Assembly. Page 1, • Representation in the Conference and in the "Transitional National Assembly" shall be on the basis of local constituencies (regional /clan mix) Page 3, TOWARD THIS END WE ... 8. pledge to place national interest above clan self interest, personal greed and ambitions Page 6, ANNEX IV BASE OF REPRESENTATION IN THE ... WHAT TO GUARD AGAINST • It must be stressed that representation based on clan affiliations or the assumed strength or importance of certain clan, including the size of territories presumed or traditional belonging to certain clans, would only succeed in perpetuating or reinforcing the division of the nation.
    [Show full text]
  • World Bank Final Report
    The Common Social Accountability Platform Deploying the Common Social Accountability Platform to inform the 2020 World Bank Performance and Learning Review January 2020 Africa’s Voices Project Team: Africa’s Voices Project Team: Anna Tomson (Governance & Accountability Senior Programme Manager), Khadija Mohamed (Programme Officer), Nasri Ali (Programme Officer), Zakaria Sheikh (Research Assistant), Alexander Simpson (Software Engineer), Lucas Malla (Senior Quantitative Researcher), and Samuel Kimeu (Executive Director). © 2019 Africa’s Voices Foundation Ltd Africa’s Voices Foundation Africa’s Voices Foundation Kenya Riverside Suites, Riverside Lane, Nairobi UK Centre for Global Equality, 8C King’s Parade CB2 1SP Cambridge africasvoices.org @africas_voices This report was written by Anna Tomson, Senior Programme Manager, Governance & Accountability and Khadija Hussein at Africa’s Voices Foundation 2 Africa’s Voices Foundation List of acronyms 4 1. INTRODUCTION 5 1.1 Context 5 1.2 Project Objectives 5 1.3 The Common Social Accountability Platform 6 1.4 AVF’s Interactive Radio Method 6 2. Methodology 8 2.1 Building inclusive community engagement at scale 8 2.2 Gathering insight on public opinion 10 2.3 Limitations of the methodology 10 3. Engagement 11 3.1 Content of the radio dialogue 11 3.2 Who participated in the dialogue 11 4. Insights into citizen perspectives 14 4.1 Citizen priorities for development 14 4.2 Citizen access to decision making and grievance mechanisms 21 ANNEX 1: List of radio stations 26 ANNEX 2: Thick description 27 ANNEX
    [Show full text]
  • Punishment on Stage
    Punishment on Stage -Application of Islamic Criminal Law by Harakat al-Shabaab al-Mujahideen- Michael Skjelderup Master’s Degree Thesis in History of Religion (60sp) Department of Culture Studies and Oriental Languages The Faculty of Humanities University of Oslo Autumn 2011 © Michael Skjelderup Autumn 2011 Punishment on Stage: Application of Islamic Criminal Law by Harakat al-Shabaab al- Mujahideen Michael Skjelderup http://www.duo.uio.no/ Trykk: Reprosentralen, Universitetet i Oslo II Executive summary Harakat al-Shabaab al-Mujahideen, usually referred to as al-Shabaab (“the youth”), is mostly known as a Somali terrorist group. But since the end of 2008 it has functioned as a state power in large parts of Southern and Central Somalia. In this study I sketch out the structure and function of the legal system of the group. Over the last three years they have developed an administrative structure and a legal system which is unprecedented in the Somali conflict, which has lasted for more than 20 years. In order to establish law and order in their territories al-Shabaab has applied their own version of sharī’a and issued strict religiously inspired decrees. The present study is based on information acquired through interviews with Somali refugees in Nairobi who have direct experiences with al-Shabaab’s judicial practice. It reveals that al-Shabaab’s application of criminal law follows the inherent logic of classical Islamic legal doctrines on several points. However, the al-Shabaab courts tend to overlook many of the strict requirements regarding evidence and procedure which was outlined by the medieval Muslim scholars in order to humanize Islamic law.
    [Show full text]
  • Somalia Assessment
    Somalia, Country Information Page 1 of 47 SOMALIA ASSESSMENT October 2002 Country Information and Policy Unit I SCOPE OF DOCUMENT II GEOGRAPHY III HISTORY IV STATE STRUCTURES VA HUMAN RIGHTS ISSUES VB HUMAN RIGHTS - SPECIFIC GROUPS ANNEX A: CHRONOLOGY ANNEX B: SOMALI CLAN STRUCTURE ANNEX C: POLITICAL ORGANISATIONS ANNEX D: PROMINENT PEOPLE REFERENCES TO SOURCE MATERIAL 1. SCOPE OF DOCUMENT 1.1 This assessment has been produced by the Country Information and Policy Unit, Immigration and Nationality Directorate, Home Office, from information obtained from a wide variety of recognised sources. The document does not contain any Home Office opinion or policy. 1.2 The assessment has been prepared for background purposes for those involved in the asylum/human rights determination process. The information it contains is not exhaustive. It concentrates on the issues most commonly raised in asylum/human rights claims made in the United Kingdom. 1.3 The assessment is sourced throughout. It is intended to be used by caseworkers as a signpost to the source material, which has been made available to them. The vast majority of the source material is readily available in the public domain. 1.4 It is intended to revise the assessment on a six-monthly basis while the country remains within the top 35 asylum-seeker producing countries in the United Kingdom. http://194.203.40.90/ppage.asp?section=193&title=Somalia%2C%20Country%20Informati...o 11/25/2002 Somalia, Country Information Page 2 of 47 2. GEOGRAPHY 2.1 Somalia (known officially from 1969 until the collapse of central government in 1991 as the Somali Democratic Republic) has an area of 637,657 sq km and borders Kenya, Ethiopia and Djibouti.
    [Show full text]
  • S.No Region Districts 1 Awdal Region Baki
    S.No Region Districts 1 Awdal Region Baki District 2 Awdal Region Borama District 3 Awdal Region Lughaya District 4 Awdal Region Zeila District 5 Bakool Region El Barde District 6 Bakool Region Hudur District 7 Bakool Region Rabdhure District 8 Bakool Region Tiyeglow District 9 Bakool Region Wajid District 10 Banaadir Region Abdiaziz District 11 Banaadir Region Bondhere District 12 Banaadir Region Daynile District 13 Banaadir Region Dharkenley District 14 Banaadir Region Hamar Jajab District 15 Banaadir Region Hamar Weyne District 16 Banaadir Region Hodan District 17 Banaadir Region Hawle Wadag District 18 Banaadir Region Huriwa District 19 Banaadir Region Karan District 20 Banaadir Region Shibis District 21 Banaadir Region Shangani District 22 Banaadir Region Waberi District 23 Banaadir Region Wadajir District 24 Banaadir Region Wardhigley District 25 Banaadir Region Yaqshid District 26 Bari Region Bayla District 27 Bari Region Bosaso District 28 Bari Region Alula District 29 Bari Region Iskushuban District 30 Bari Region Qandala District 31 Bari Region Ufayn District 32 Bari Region Qardho District 33 Bay Region Baidoa District 34 Bay Region Burhakaba District 35 Bay Region Dinsoor District 36 Bay Region Qasahdhere District 37 Galguduud Region Abudwaq District 38 Galguduud Region Adado District 39 Galguduud Region Dhusa Mareb District 40 Galguduud Region El Buur District 41 Galguduud Region El Dher District 42 Gedo Region Bardera District 43 Gedo Region Beled Hawo District www.downloadexcelfiles.com 44 Gedo Region El Wak District 45 Gedo
    [Show full text]
  • SO 000505 Declaration of National Commitment.Pdf
    PA-X, Peace Agreement Access Tool www.peaceagreements.org DECLARATION OF NATIONAL COMMITMENT (Arta Declaration), 5 May 2000 • The Somalia people are desirous oF reaFFirminG the sovereiGn state oF Somalia, and oF ForminG transitional mechanisms (transitional national assembly, transitional Government, an independent judiciary) which shall prepare the country For a peaceFul, permanent and democratic Future. • The Form oF Government shall be parliamentary democracy, with a bicameral national assembly ("Chamber of Elders" to provide leGitimacy, stability and assist in the reconciliation process; and a "Chamber of Representatives"). • The Transitional period shall last 24 months. • The Transitional mechanism shall be based on a "Decentralized" system oF Governance ""reGional autonomy " or Federal structure"), during the transitional period. • The decentralized system oF governance is one that brings diFFerent political communities under a common government For common purposes, and separates regional government For the particular needs of each region • Representation in the ConFerence and in the "Transitional National Assembly" shall be on the basis of local constituencies (regional /clan mix) The National Assembly THE TNA SHALL: • Symbolize power-sharing • be the sole authority with legislative Function during the period in question • elect an interim President (Head of State ) of the country • elect a "government" headed by a Prime Minister. TNA shall approve the Cabinet oF the Prime Minster. The Prime Minster shall be accountable to the TNA
    [Show full text]
  • Epidemiological Week 28 (Week Ending 15Th July, 2018)
    Epidemiological Week 28 (Week ending 15th July, 2018) Highlights Cumulative figures as of week 28 • 232 health facilities across Somalia submitted weekly • 1,576,745 consultations from week 1 reports of epidemic-prone diseases in the electronic to week 28. early warning disease surveillance (EWARN) system in • 5,880 cumulative cases of week 28. • Total number of consultations increased from 51,625 AWD/Cholera and 40 deaths since in week 27 to 54,605 in week 28. December 2017. • A total of 307 alerts were received. 35 of these alerts • 8,880 Accumulative alerts were were confirmed as true alerts in week 28. received, 499 of these, were • The highest numbers of diseases reported in week 28 confirmed as true alerts from week 1 were other acute diarrhoeas (2,306 cases), influenza to week 28, 2018. like illness (1,245 cases) and severe acute respiratory illness (1,559 cases). • 6,201 cumulative cases of suspected measles cases since the beginning of • A total of 146 new cases of suspected AWD/cholera with no death were reported in week 28 compared to 2018. Of the 6,201 measles cases, 151 AWD cases with no death in week 27. 4,112 (66%) are under 5 years while • A cumulative total of 5,880 AWD/cholera cases1, 2,089 (34%) are above 5 years. including 40 deaths have been reported since • 7,624 cumulative cases of Malaria December 2017. were reported since the beginning of • The number of reported measles cases decreased 2018, 3,302(43%) are under 5 years, from 61 in week 27 to 52 cases in week 28.
    [Show full text]
  • S 2019 858 E.Pdf
    United Nations S/2019/858* Security Council Distr.: General 1 November 2019 Original: English Letter dated 1 November 2019 from the Chair of the Security Council Committee pursuant to resolution 751 (1992) concerning Somalia addressed to the President of the Security Council On behalf of the Security Council Committee pursuant to resolution 751 (1992) concerning Somalia, and in accordance with paragraph 54 of Security Council resolution 2444 (2018), I have the honour to transmit herewith the final report of the Panel of Experts on Somalia. In this connection, the Committee would appreciate it if the present letter and the report were brought to the attention of the members of the Security Council and issued as a document of the Council. (Signed) Marc Pecsteen de Buytswerve Chair Security Council Committee pursuant to resolution 751 (1992) concerning Somalia * Reissued for technical reasons on 14 November 2019. 19-16960* (E) 141119 *1916960* S/2019/858 Letter dated 27 September 2019 from the Panel of Experts on Somalia addressed to the Chair of the Security Council Committee pursuant to resolution 751 (1992) concerning Somalia In accordance with paragraph 54 of Security Council resolution 2444 (2018), we have the honour to transmit herewith the final report of the Panel of Experts on Somalia. (Signed) Jay Bahadur Coordinator Panel of Experts on Somalia (Signed) Mohamed Abdelsalam Babiker Humanitarian expert (Signed) Nazanine Moshiri Armed groups expert (Signed) Brian O’Sullivan Armed groups/natural resources expert (Signed) Matthew Rosbottom Finance expert (Signed) Richard Zabot Arms expert 2/161 19-16960 S/2019/858 Summary During the first reporting period of the Panel of Experts on Somalia, the use by Al-Shabaab of improvised explosive devices reached its greatest extent in Somali history, with a year-on-year increase of approximately one third.
    [Show full text]
  • Epidemiological Week 27 (Week Ending 8Th July, 2018)
    Epidemiological Week 27 (Week ending 8th July, 2018) Highlights Cumulative figures as of week 27 • A total of 224 health facilities submitted weekly • 1,522,140 consultations from week 1 reports of epidemic-prone diseases in week 27. to week 27. • Total number of consultations decreased from 55,343 • 5,733 cumulative cases of in week 26 to 51,625 in week 27. AWD/Cholera and 40 deaths since • A total of 257 alerts were received. 33 of these alerts were confirmed as true alerts in week 27. December 2017. • The highest numbers of diseases reported in week 27 • 8,573 total alerts were received, 464 were other acute diarrhoeas (2,486 cases), influenza of these, were confirmed as true like illness (1,342 cases) and severe acute respiratory alerts from week 1 to week 27, 2018. illness (1,173 cases). • 6,149 cumulative cases of suspected • A total of 151 new cases of suspected AWD/cholera measles cases since Jan 2018. Of the with no death were reported in week 27 compared to 344 AWD cases including 1 death in week 26. 4,068 (66%) are under 5 years while 2,081 (34%) are above 5 years. • A cumulative total of 5,733 AWD/cholera cases1, including 40 deaths have been reported since • 7,193 cumulative cases of Malaria December 2017. were reported since Jan 2018, 3,119 • The number of reported measles cases slightly (43%) are under 5 years, while increased from 58 in week 26 to 61 cases in week 27. 4,074(57%) are above 5 years.
    [Show full text]
  • Iom Somalia Updateupdate ## 77 Humanitarian Response September 2017 Highlights January - September 2017
    IOM SOMALIA UPDATEUPDATE ## 77 HUMANITARIAN RESPONSE SEPTEMBER 2017 HIGHLIGHTS JANUARY - SEPTEMBER 2017 ACCESS TO CLEAN WATER 212,719,940 litres of water provided to 568,749 people through water trucking in Banadir, Bay, Gedo, Lower Juba, Lower and Middle Shabelle regions PRIMARY HEALTH CARE 378,031 58,234 health children under 5 consultations vaccinated EMERGENCY SHELTER & NFIs IDP households received emergency IOM’s Migration Health Division (MHD) distributing long-lasting insecticidal 5,800 shelter materials and non-food items (NFIs) nets (LLIN) in internally displaced people (IDP) sites in Mogadishu, Banadir in Banadir and Gedo regions Region © IOM 2017 D DROUGHT RESPONSE D D H FUNDING TO DATE D D D H D H D D H D D D D D P D H D D D D D D USD 18.79 Million D D H D H D D D D D H W H KEY INTERVENTIONS H PER DISTRICT D D W Sectors of intervention D D D Displacement Tracking Matrix F Food Security / Livelihoods D W D H Health D D S H W D D D D D S W S Shelter / NFI D W D F C W D W W Water / Sanitation / Hygiene H W D W D P Protection S D D W H Camp Management D C D F C S H W D D Stressed D P H Crisis Emergency D S H W D H IOM SOMALIA / HUMANITARIAN RESPONSE UPDATE # 7 SITUATION OVERVIEW As severe drought conditions continue, the overall nutrition situation has continued to deteriorate, especially in northern and central parts of the country.
    [Show full text]