June 18, 2014 the Honourable Mary Polak Minister of Environment PO
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Capital Regional District T: 250.360.3000 625 Fisgard Street, PO Box 1000 F: 250.360.3234 Making a difference ... together Victoria, BC, Canada V8W 256 www.crd.bc.ca June 18, 2014 File: 0400-20 The Honourable Mary Polak Minister of Environment PO Box 904 7 Stn Prov Govt Victoria BC V8W 9E2 Dear Minister Polak: RE: METRO VANCOUVER WASTE FLOW MANAGEMENT AND THE GREATER VANCOUVER SEWERAGE AND DRAINAGE DISTRICT RECYCLABLE MATERIAL REGULATORY BYLAW NO. 280 The Capital Regional District (CRD) received a request from Metro Vancouver to support its application for approval of the Greater Vancouver Sewerage and Drainage District Municipal Solid Waste and Recyclable Material Regulatory Bylaw No. 280, 2013. We are informed that flow management is included in Metro Vancouver's Solid Waste Management Plan and that their regional district has met the Ministry's public consultation requirements prior to submitting the bylaw for your approval. Our Board understands that waste flow management is an important regulatory tool to support the implementation of local governments' solid waste management plans and regulate the flow of municipal waste and recyclable materials as provided for in the Environmental Management Act. Waste flow management is becoming an important issue for many regional districts in British Columbia. The CRD may review waste flow management and regulatory approaches as part of the development of its new Integrated Solid Waste and Resource Management Plan. We support the principle that, where the authority has been granted through an approved Solid Waste Management Plan, a regional district may require that municipal solid waste, recyclable and organic materials generated within that jurisdiction be received at designated facilities. We appreciate Metro Vancouver's work on this emerging issue and support the authority of local government to decide upon this matter. We will follow this important solid waste issue and your decision with interest. Alastair Bryson Chair, Capital Regional District Board cc: Greg Moore, Chair, Metro Vancouver Board Malcolm Brodie, Chair, Zero Waste Committee Board Members, CRD Bob Lapham, Chief Administrative Officer, CRD Larisa Hutcheson, General Manager, Parks & Environmental Services, CRD 1548397 R£GI0~4l.o DISTRICT 101 Martin Street, Penticton, British Columbia V2A SJ9 Tel: 250.492.0237 Fax: 250.492.0063 Toll Free: 877.610.3737 Email:[email protected] OKANAGAN• SIMILKAMEEN March 25, 2014 RDOS FILE: 0400.60, 2014 Mr. Greg Moore, Chair Metro Vancouver Board 4330 Kingsway Burnaby, BC V5H 4G8 Dear Chair Moore and Board of Directors, Re: Support for Waste Flow Management Provisions in Solid Waste Management Plans Thank you for your letter dated February 12, 2014 entitled 'Metro Vancouver Waste Flow Management and the Greater Vancouver Sewerage and Drainage District Recyclable Material Regulatory Bylaw No. 280.' The RDOS Board has reviewed you letter and made the following resolution at our March 20th, 2014 meeting: B74/14PW IT WAS MOVED AND SECONDED THAT the Regional District of Okanagan-Similkameen provide a letter for Metro Vancouver supporting the principal that, where the power has been granted through an approved Solid Waste Management Plan, a Regional District may require that municipal solid waste, recycling and organic matter generated within that Regional District be received at a facility licensed by that Regional District. CARRIED A copy of the Staff Report brought forward with this resolution has been included. As requested by Metro Vancouver Staff, a copy of this letter has been sent to the Honourable Mary Polak, Minister of Environment. Please contact Cameron Baughen, RDOS Solid Waste Management Coordinator at 250-490-4203, by email at cbaughenC&.rdos.bc.ca or by mail at the RDOS address above if you have further questions. Sincerely, ~~r~ Bill Newell RDOSCAO CB cc Honourable Mary Polak. Minister of Environment M Pendergraft, RDOS Chair 0. French, RDOS Manager of Public Works C. Baughen, RDOS SW Management Coordinator .. " .. ' . .. .. ·-- . -- www.rdos. bc.ca RDOS Regular Board Meeting Agenda Item 6.1 ADMINISTRATIVE REPORT TO: Board of Directors t or' .... -• - -:n!.s•" ,4 FROM: B. Newell, Chief Administrative Officer DATE: March 20. 2014 OKANAGAN· SIHII.KAHEEN RE: Support for Flow Control Provisions in SoHd Waste Management Plans Administrative Recommendation: THAT the Regional District of Okanagan-Similkameen provide a letter for Metro Vancouver supporting the principal that, where the power has been granted through an approved Solid Waste Management Plan, a Regional District may require that municipal solid waste, recycling and organic matter generated within that Regional District be received at a facility licensed by that Regional District. Reference: Letter February 12, 2014 from Greg Moore, Metro Vancouver Chair, "Metro Vancouver Waste Flow Management and the Greater Vancouver Sewerage and Drainage District Recyclable Material Regulatory Bylaw No. 280" Metro Vancouver Website "Metro Vancouver Waste Flow Management• History: The Province of BC approved Metro Vancouver's Mlntegrated Solid Waste and Resource Management Plan" in 2011 . The Plan calls for the potential use of 'flow control' to ensure waste generated within the Metro Vancouver Regional District is disposed of at a facility licensed by Metro Vancouver. The Plan recognized the financial and environmental risk of waste being brought to unlicensed facilities. Licensed facilities, including private and local government owned, require enough tipping fees to ensure their financial viability. Flow control is also a tool to ensure that all waste is handled in a manner to increase recyclable and organic diversion as envisioned by the Plan. Due to certain haulers removing waste from Metro Vancouver to an unlicensed facility, Metro Vancouver has submitted to the Province the QGreater Vancouver Sewerage and Drainage Recyclable Material Regulatory Bylaw No. 280". The BC Minister of Environment has informed Metro Vancouver that she is concerned with effects of flow control on private businesses that may choose to take waste, recycling or organics to unlicensed facilities. Metro Vancouver is requesting that Regional Districts across the Province provide letters of support for the flow control restrictions in Metro Vancouver Bylaw No. 280. The Province requires that all Regional Districts develop a Solid Waste Management Plan. The development of these Plans are overseen and ultimately approved by the Province and require extensive public and commercial consultation. If approved by the Province, any power granted to the Regional District within the plan would not require the further assent of electors to establish bylaws. The RDOS went through a comprehensive multi-year revision of its Solid Waste Management Plan adopted in 2012. The creation of our Solid Waste Management Plan involved the creation of three parallel committees, extensive public and commercial consultation and a nearly yearlong review by the Province before being adopted. The issue of flow control was discussed but not included within the revised RDOS Solid Waste Management Plan. L:\Board Staff Reports\2014\2014·03-20\Boardreports\Approved\Metro_Vaneouver_Request_For_Support.Docx File No. Page 1 of 2 Analysis: Metro Vancouver is aspiring to divert 80% of waste by 2020 and develop expensive waste to energy facilities. Their current tipping fee for municipal solid waste varies around $108 per tonne at licensed facilities and may potentially increase with further diversion of waste or the development of waste to energy technologies. There is a financial incentive for companies to find other cheaper methods of disposing of waste. One method being employed now is transferring waste to Abbotsford and then shipping it to a massive landfill along the border of Washington and Oregon state. Waste transferred in this manner may not meet requirements for recycling and organic removal required for licensed facilities in Metro Vancouver. It also removes tipping fees from licensed facilities complying with Metro Vancouver bylaws. There are several reasons to support the principal that flow control powers granted by the Province to Regional Districts be respected: • The Province has overseen the public consultation process and approved the language of the Solid Waste Management Plan. Reversing the approval of a section of the Plan has the potential to undermine other related segments of the Plan. • The intent of the Solid Waste Management Planning process is to allow for thorough consultation. Private interests that feel their business may be impacted have opportunity to voice their concerns during this process. Before approving a Plan, Regional District Boards and the Province are required to assess these concerns as part of the planning process and assess them in terms of the greater good of the Regional District. Not allowing a power within the approved Plan to be utilized, due to special interests, has the potential to undermine the consultation component of the Solid Waste Management Planning process. • The implementation of flow control provides a level playing field for all waste haulers to compete on efficiency and service. Allowing for haulers to divert waste to avoid regulations on recycling and composting undermines the Solid Waste Management process and places licensed facilities and the haulers using these facilities at a financial disadvantage. • The RDOS has 7 different waste receiving facilities. There are several other waste receiving facilities in neighbouring