TAG Parent Survey Results 2012 V2.Xlsx-Comments
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
www.ppstag.org TAG parent survey results 2012 v2.xlsx-comments www.ppstag.org A B C NOTE: These comments have been edited to remove personal information, replacing, for example, names of students, by "my son" or "our daughter". Please email [email protected] if you find any 1 remaining personal information that should be removed. 2 3 School_Name comment1 (positive aspects) comment2 (suggested improvements) Abernethy E.S. We love our school and teachers, but I have to say there has not been very clear communication from about exactly how and what TAG services are being provided, if any. My child's teachers have been very good about working with her particular strengths and weaknesses as a student, but it has not been clear whether her TAG status fits into their plan. More specific information about TAG services at our school would be helpful. 21 22 Abernethy E.S. Abernethy E.S. Don't think there are any at this point. Pull out! In my son's old school, he had a pull out one day a week. That was the ONLY day he was excited to go to school. He was able to be in a class of his PEERS, so that they understood where he was coming from. The other four days (even though he missed one day a week) he 23 was extremely bored, which led to bad behaviors. 25 Abernethy E.S. Abernethy E.S. She has attention from the teacher that guides her to appropriate individual challenges. Enhanced Group challenges with tag students on similar or equal level would help with 28 motivation and engagement. Abernethy E.S. We have had zero information sent to us regarding TAG. Inform, connect and communicate with families and the student. Tag families do not receive 30 adequate info. Abernethy E.S. There have honesty been zero positive aspects of my child's TAG services. I don't actually In my mind, TAG services mean smaller groups that have specialized learning, take home believe there have been any TAG services at all and the school openly admits to the fact that more challenging homework (not just more homework), more responsibility given to the 31 there are no extra services associated with TAG. student to learn at a higher rate but not singled out as a "TAG" child. / 38 Abernethy E.S. Abernethy E.S. I have seen no evidence of my child receiving ANYTHING from the TAG program other than a It could actually be a program as it is in Washington state and elsewhere. It could include different homework packet. I attend every school TAG meeting and express my concerns to some period of instruction with fellow TAG identified students. It could involve a classroom her teacher. I am told repeatedly by both the principal and the teachers that there are many component so my child is not always doing repetitive and mundane worksheets in class, TAG kids at this school and that the level of instruction is suitable for them and all other causing her to tune out, daydream and do sloppy work. students. The "challenge" homework is unrelated to what the class is doing, and often confusing and badly put together (missing pages, etc.). It does include more challenging work, and sometimes this is useful. However there often this homework focuses on areas where my daughter has had absolutely NO instruction (decimals in 2nd grade for example) so it falls on us to teach her the skills necessary to complete the homework. 39 Abernethy E.S. Only one of my chid's teachers made an effort to both recognize my child's abilities and find Actually have some sort of clear TAG program in operation that is NOT dependent on the ways to foster and challenge him. Otherwise, being identified as "TAG" just seems to be a individual teacher the child is assigned to. label that means nothing on the most part in terms of consistently more challenging 40 curriculum or activities. Abernethy E.S. My child frankly received 0 TAG services during his 6 years at elementary school. The How can they not be? Nothing was ever done for him in the five years after identification in teachers have so many children with so many needs at the school that he seemed forgotten. I regards to TAG. This population is being neglected. was told many times that the teachers could not advance him in math only enrich him. I never did figure out exactly what this meant. I volunteered many hours over the course of his elementary school tenure to help but finally in the end we have pulled him out of public school and he will now attend a private school in the fall. The TAG kids are being ignored. 44 Page 1 of 4 www.ppstag.org TAG parent survey results 2012 v2.xlsx-comments www.ppstag.org A B C Abernethy E.S. Other than parent volunteers coming in to pull groups of TAG kids once a week I can't really TAg services shouldnt mean extra busy work copied off for the student from a higher grade name any true TAG services that have been provided by qualified staff ?? What a shame. workbook for the child to independently chip away at while direct instruction is provided to the rest of the class. It should be small group instruction ( direct teaching) to the Tag students 47 using materials at their level. Abernethy E.S. Teachers are aware she is identified and mention it at conferences. They want to challenge Provide more opportunities for her to be challenged. Provide more training and time for 48 my child. teachers to develop differentiated curriculum for tag students. Abernethy E.S. There are NO TAG services offered at Abernethy. We've been told there are too many Individual plans should be included as a part of parent teacher conferences. I have had only students who test at that level to offer any TAG programs. It is all left up to individual teacher one teacher (out of five) mention that she was aware of TAG designation. 50 discretion/ability which means it doesn't happen. Abernethy E.S. My son gets extra homework which occasionally provides a good challenge. He likes the I know that there are important reasons why we do not sort kids into "tracks" any more, but I challenge homework much more than the rest of his work. Last year, the teachers wish we could do a better job of targeting classroom instruction to different abilities. I have standardized the challenge assignment for all classes in the grade, and this really lowered the spent a lot of time volunteering, and see very early how every teacher must focus on the bar. These standard assignments did not match my child's abilities. / Further, giving middle of the class. Kids suffer when they are not average. My son gets bored, and then additional homework fails to appreciate how excruciating hard the easy work seems to a TAG teachers think he has a hard time paying attention. student. Answering the same easy questions over and over feels like torture. TAG students need less easy work, not just more hard work. 52 Abernethy E.S. I would like to see more programs that allow tag children to work together on extended 55 learning projects. Abernethy E.S. I have not been able to discern any TAG specific services in the classroom. I am generally I am a skeptic about the value of TAG services and ambivalent about my child's TAG happy with the school and satisfied with the instruction my child receives, but I have not seen identification. It is important to me that any negative impacts from my child's TAG that TAG identification has made much if any difference. characteristics--i.e. behavior issues, wandering attention--be recognized and addressed in that context, but I am not generally in favor of separated or accelerated curriculum choices at 56 this age (3rd grade). Abernethy E.S. Testing and identification of both of them has given us as parents an understanding of their We need to understand specific strategies in place for challenging our kids with regard to abilities. / Knowing their abilities allows us to expect greater accomplishments and a higher baseline education. / We need to know what we can do at home to help them make the most level of learning from them. / of their early education. / We need support in understanding some of the personality triats that are related to TAG kids, and ideas how to guide some of their emotions and intensities. 57 Abernethy E.S. I don't really see any difference for my TAG child. He is usually just given extra worksheets. Something, anything, please. I would suggest math pull-out or something like that. 58 60 Abernethy E.S. Provides unique learning opportunities I would like to have meeting with teachers to discuss the overall plan 62 Abernethy E.S. 68 Abernethy E.S. I haven't seen any TAG-specific services. Special projects/assignments for my student and others at her level. Abernethy E.S. In theory I like the idea of TAG being incorporated into the regular classroom experience. I have a very hard time evaluating the effectiveness of PPS TAG services because of the way they are run. It mostly requires a lot of trust in the teacher's ability to dynamically adapt their teaching style per student. This kind of ability varies teacher to teacher, of course, but honestly, I would think these are skills a teacher would employ regardless of TAG classification.